International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
1,2,3 Asst. professor, Dept of Mech Engg, C.B.I.T, Gadipet hyd 4Asso.professor,Dept of Mech Engg, C.B.I.T,Gadipet, hyd ***
Abstract Planetary gearboxes are most commonly used in automatic transmission of automobiles and have significant advantage over spur gear transmissions due to their compactness andsignificantspeedreductionwithsametorque output. Present automobiles use 3 sets of planetary gear sets attached with a torque converter in their transmission. In general the gearbox and differential are present as separate units. In this a novel planetary transmission integrated with an open differential is designed. The gearbox contains two planetary gear sets to achieve 5 forwardand1reversestageof transmission with inputs given at sun and ring gears of planetary gear sets. The transmission will be tested for transmitting 75 BHP and 100 BHP at 2500 RPM, 5000 RPM, 7500 RPM and particular torque equivalent speeds. The 3D model is drafted using Solid Works and analysis is done using Ansys software
Key Words: Differential ,Planetary gear box
Transmissions are used in automobiles running using internal combustion (IC) engines as the engines produce optimal power delivery at particular torque range. High torqueisneededforquicklystartingfromrestandhighspeed is required for maximum power delivery, which can be achievedusingagearbox.Adifferentialsplitsasingleinputof powerdeliveryintotwoseparateoutputsgiventoeachwheel to have different speeds while turning. Combining both gearboxanddifferentialwillmakethespaceaccompaniedby thecomponentslow.Thegearsetsthatweareusinghereis planetary gear set which can be adjusted to multiple gear ratios per gear set with good load bearing capacity and mechanicalefficiencywhencomparedwithconventionalspur geartrains.Andthemainrootsofatransmissionaregears. Mr. G. Balbayev [1] has worked on design of two degree planetary gear box from aspects of mechanical design and kinematicmodeling.Andproposedadesignforthegearbox whichworkswithaproperspeedwithoutjamminggears Dr. A.Srinath[2]andhisteamhaveworkedonestimatingthe efficiencyofplanetarygeartrainsbasedonnumberofteeth ongearsandstructuralarrangement.Andconcludedthatif thegearsareplacedparalleltoeachotherthentheefficiency is more. Mr. Wen Miln Hwang [3] along with Mr. Yu Lien Huang proposed a configuration design of six speed
automatic transmissions using two degree planetary gear trainswiththreeplanetarygearsets.Mr.OliverK.Kelley[4] has worked on the design of planetary gear trains. And proposedthataminimumangleof88.57oandacorrectionof 1.43oshouldbepresentbetweentwoplanetgearsforsmooth powertransmission.Mr.A.Kahraman[5]andhisteamhas worked on kinematics and power flow methodology for automatic planetary gear transmissions and proposed all possible kinematic configurations satisfying design constraints.Mr.QingtaoLi[6]andhisteamhaveworkedon designofanewplanetarytransmissionwhichsplitsoneinput totwooutputsusingbothcontinuouslyvariabletransmission andplanetarygearswithsixconfigurations.Mr.NitinKapoor [7]andhisteamhaveusedglassfilledpolyamidecomposite material in a differential gearbox as an alternative for a gearboxwithmetallicgears.Withthehelpofcomputeraided engineeringandCATIAtheydevelopedvariousparametric modelsandanalyzedusingAnsysforequivalent(Von Mises) stressunderstaticconditions.Mr.C.Veeranjaneyulu[8]has conducted structural analysis on differential gears using aluminum alloy, alloy steel and cast steel for speeds 2400RPM,5000RPM,7500RPMandobservedthataluminum alloystressvalueswerewithinpermissiblestressvalues.
Themainaimistodesignanovelplanetarytransmission system integrated with a differential by using only 2 planetary gear sets and a differential. The transmission systeminputisgivenonlytogearset1andisconnectedto gearset2whichisconnectedtothedifferential.
2022, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
progressed with solid connections between the gears and thenfinallymodifiedusingbrakeclutches.
Fig 1:Gearssetswithdifferentialinisometricview
Themainelementsinworkingofthetransmissionsystem are the two brake clutches and the ring actuator clutch. Brakeclutch1isusedtoconnecttheringgearofgearset2 withringandplanetarycarrierofgearset1,similarlybrake clutch2isusedtoconnectsungearofgearset2withring gearofgearset1.
Brake Clutch 1 working: The clutch has three modes dependingonthegearselected Mode 1: In this mode the brake clutch won’t be in contact withtheringgearofgearset2andeitherofplanetarycarrier andringgearofgearset1.
Fig 2:Gearsetswithdifferentialinfrontview
Fig 3:Gearset2connectionwithdifferentialin isometricview
As in the above figures the final model transmission is designedusingonlytwoplanetarygearsetsandadifferential. Theinitialdesignismadeusingonlyoneplanetarygearset withdifferentialattachedtothesungearandinputsaregive toeitherringgearorplanetarycarrier.Inthenextdesigntwo planetarygearsetsareusedwithdifferentialandaspecific reverseassemblyisusedforachievingreverse.Thedesign
Fig 5 BrakeClutch1mode1
Mode2:Inthismodethebrakeclutchwillbeincontactwith theringgearofgearset2andplanetarycarrierofgearset1.
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
Mode2:Inthismodethebrakeclutchwillbeincontactwith thesungearofgearset2andringgearofgearset1.
Fig 6 BrakeClutch1mode2
Mode3:Inthismodethebrakeclutchwillbeincontactwith theringgearofgearset2andringgearofgearset1
Fig 8 BrakeClutch2mode2
Ring actuator clutch: Thisclutchisusedtohelpinlocking of planetary carrier on gear set 1. This is clutch has two modesdependingonthegear
Mode 1: In this mode the ring clutch will be ahead of planetarycarrierofgearset1,thishappenswhentheinputis giventosungearofgearset1.
Fig 7 BrakeClutch1mode3
Brake Clutch 2 working: Thisclutchhastwomodesbased onthegearselected
Mode1:Inthismodethebrakeclutchwillnotbeincontact withthesungearofgearset2andringgearofgearset1
Fig 9 Ringactuatorclutchmode1
Mode 2: In this mode the ring clutch will be behind the planetarycarrierofgearset1.
Fig 7 BrakeClutch2mode1
Fig 10 Ringactuatorclutchmode2
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
The analysis is done in static structural module of Ansys R16.0withappropriateboundaryconditionsappliedonthe geartoothprofiles
Theboundaryconditionsare Thebaseofthetoothisfixed
Thetangentialloadisactingonthetipofthetooth
Fig 11
Fig 12 Meshedmodelofgeartoothforsunandplanetgear ofgearset1
Fig 14 Meshedmodelofgeartoothforringgearofgear set2
Fig 13 Meshedmodelofgeartoothforringgearofgearset 2
Fig 15 Meshedmodelofgeartoothforbevelgearof differential
2.3.1. Stress distribution for 75 BHP at 2500 RPM
Fig 16 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset2
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
2.3.2. Stress distribution for 75 BHP at 5000 RPM
Fig 17 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planet gearofgearset1
Fig 20 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset2
Fig 18 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset2
Fig 21 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset1
Fig 19 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset2
Fig 22 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset2
Fig
Fig 27 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset1 2.3.4 Stress distribution for 75 BHP at 150N m Torque
Fig
Fig 25Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset1
Fig 28 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset2
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
2.3..5. Stress distribution for 100BHP at 2500RPM
Fig 29 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset1
Fig 32 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset2
Fig 30 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset2
Fig 33 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset1
Fig 31 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset1
Fig 34 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset2
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
2.3.8. Stress distribution for 100BHP at 180N m Torque
Fig 41 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset1
Fig 44 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset2
Fig 42 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset2
Fig 45 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofsunand planetgearofgearset1
Fig 43 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset1
Fig 46 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset2
International
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
Fig 47 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofringgearof gearset1
2.3.9. Stress distribution for bevel gears at 75BHP power transmission
Fig 50 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofbevelgearat 7500RPM
Fig 48 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofbevelgear at2500RPM
Fig 51 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofbevelgearat 150N mTorque
2.3.10. Stress distribution for bevel gears at 100BHP power transmission
Fig 49 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofbevelgearat 5000RPM
Fig 52 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofbevelgearat 2500RPM
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
Resultsaretabulatedbelow
Geardia(mm) Ft (N) σ(MPa) 80 5343.83 161.07 90 4749.57 136.81 240 1781.27 40.86 270 1583.19 34.52
Table 1 Stressdistributionfor75BHPat2500RPM
Fig 53 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofbevelgearat 5000RPM
Geardia(mm) Ft (N) σ(MPa) 80 2671.91 80.807 90 2374.98 49.025 240 890.49 26.957 270 791.53 21.314
Table 2 Stressdistributionfor75BHPat5000RPM
Geardia(mm) Ft (N) σ(MPa) 80 1780.99 55.863 90 1583.19 38.808 240 593.69 19.972 270 527.7 17.28
Table 3 Stressdistributionfor75BHPat7500RPM
Fig 54 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofbevelgearat 7500RPM
Geardia(mm) Ft (N) σ (MPa) 80 3752.51 127.94 90 3334.32 127.03 240 1250.55 34.745 270 1111.44 29.92
Table 4.Stressdistributionfor75BHPat150N mTorque
Geardia(mm) Ft (N) σ (MPa) 80 7125.11 213.80 90 6332.70 178.29 240 2375.03 54.486 270 2110.92 46.03
Fig 55 Stressdistributionforgeartoothofbevelgearat 80N mTorque
Table 5 Stressdistributionfor100BHPat2500RPM
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Geardia(mm) Ft (N) σ (MPa) 80 3562.55 108.81 90 3166.38 68.635 240 1187.33 35.943 270 1050.92 28.299
Table 6 Stressdistributionfor100BHPat5000RPM
Geardia(mm) Ft (N) σ (MPa) 80 2374.60 72.527 90 2110.92 51.744 240 791.59 23.96 270 703.64 21.127
Table 7 Stressdistributionfor100BHPat7500RPM
Geardia(mm) Ft (N) σ(Ansys)(MPa) 80 4502.11 173.65 90 4002.14 152.47 240 1500.4 41.687 270 1333.57 35.91
Table 8 Stressdistributionfor100BHPat180N mTorque
Speed(RPM) Ft (N) σ (MPa) 2500 3563.69 204.69 5000 1781.27 161.68 7500 1187.27 152.14 3561 2501.11 167.44
Table 9 Stressdistributionfordifferentialat75BHP Powerdelivery
Speed(RPM) Ft (N) σ (MPa) 2500 4751.59 272.92 5000 2375.039 215.57 7500 1583.191 202.85 3957 3000.8 200.89
Table 10 Stressdistributionfordifferentialat100BHP Powerdelivery
Completeoptimizeddesignofanovelplanetarytransmission integratedwithdifferentialforautomatictransmissionofthe vehicle. The gearbox should be easy to install, repair and maintain.Thegearboxwilloccupylessspaceandalsohave lessweightreducingtheoverallweightofthecar.Comparing withothergearboxeshelpedusoptimizingthedesignand generatingrequiredspeedratios.
1. G.Balbayevetal,DesignandCharacterizationofa New Planetary Gear Box, New Advances in Mechanisms, Transmissions and Applications, Mechanisms and Machine Science 17, DOI: 10.1007/978 94 007 7485 8_12, © Springer ScienceBusinessMediaDordrecht2014.
2. Dr. A. Srinath et al, Mechanical Efficiency of Planetary Gear Trains: An Estimate, Mechanical EngineeringResearch,1,No.1;December2011.
3. Mr.Wen MilnHwangetal,Configurationdesignof six speed automatic transmissions with two degree of freedom planetary gear trains, TransactionsoftheCSME/delaSCGM,Vol.29,No.1. 2005.
4. Mr. Oliver K. Kelley et al, The design of Planetary GearTrains,SAEAnnualMeeting,January1959.
5. Mr. A. Kahraman et al, A Kinematics and Power Flow Analysis Methodology for Automatic Transmission Planetary Gear Trains, Journal of MechanicalDesign,November2004.
6. Qingtao Li et al, Power split transmission with continuously variable planetary ratio, MechanismandMachineTheory140(2019)765 780.
7. NitinKapooretal,designandstressstrainanalysis of composite differential gear box, International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research(IJSETR),Volume3,Issue7,July2014.
8. C.Veeranjaneyulu et al, design and structural analysisofdifferentialgearboxatdifferentloads, International Journal of Advanced Engineering Research and Studies, IJAERS/Vol. I/ Issue II/January March,2012/65 69.
9. Mr. Surya Prabhakaran et al, Bending Stress Analysis of a Spur Gear for Material Steel 15NI2CR1MO28.
10. Mr.TawandaMushiri,Analysisofageartrainusing finiteelementmodeling.
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072 © 2022, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page2757