TRANSFORMING CONFLICT & COLLABORATION Laurie L. Mulvey, Sheffy Minnick and Michelle Frisby Illustrations by Simonida Nedeljković
TRANSFORMING CONFLICT & COLLABORATION Laurie L. Mulvey, Sheffy Minnick and Michelle Frisby Illustrations by Simonida Nedeljković
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercialNoDerivatives 4.0 International License. You are free to Share — copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format. The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms as long as you follow OUR LICENSE TERMS. Book design: michaelblack | BLACK SUNŽ
The following people have been integral to the creation and revision of this book: David Holloway, Lisa Dribin, Sam Richards, Danna Jayne Seballos, Brenton Joo Mitchell, Sarah Chelius, Eric Spielvogel, Serge DaDeppo, Tim Taylor, Takkeem Morgan, Carly Cubit, Rick Miller, Abeer Al-Yazji, Renata Rincon, Yuli Prieto, Amalia Shaltiel, Ray Mulvey, Sean Minnick, Greg Frisby, Lisa Thiry, A.J. Wagner, michael black, Mahdi Jafari and the many students we have worked with at Penn State University.
Introduction
xi
Part One: The Facilitator
15
Part Two: Facilitator Mindset
39
2.1: A Story 2.2: Conflict 2.3: Collaboration 2.4: Paradox Facilitation Mindset
41 63 123 193 249
Part Three: Communication Practices of a Facilitator 3.1: Socratic Inquiry 3.2: Taking All Sides 3.3: Open-Ended Questions 3.4: Active Reflective Listening 3.5: Disrupting Communication Patterns
Part Four: Transformation and What’s Possible
255 269 335 371 457 521
639
Introduction Dialogue facilitation is a lot more than moderating a conversation. Dialogue facilitation requires facing fear with understanding, building trust in relationships where there is no trust, and inviting authenticity and complexity where simplicity and certainty are often preferred. It also requires uniting real people with real issues, minds with hearts, and enemies with one another. A good facilitator, like a good traffic cop, takes the chaos of passions and perspectives and helps participants to create an underlying order together. All of this is an essential piece of the well-being of people and communities. We keep meeting people all around the globe who ask us how to become a facilitator. So we’ve spent several years writing and rewriting this book, testing out the material with students and colleagues, and developing illustrations, all so that the ideas can be translated and understood easily in different languages. And we are sharing it free of charge because our goal is for as many people to benefit from it as possible. We also know that what’s more important than reading this book is what you do with it.
Out beyond ideas of Wrongdoing and Rightdoing There is a field. I’ll meet you there. - Rumi
Part One The Facilitator
16
• The Facilitator
Have you ever met a doctor? Have you ever seen a doctor at work? Have you ever heard anyone say, “When I grow up I want to be a doctor”? ...most likely.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
17
Now imagine— that you didn’t know anything about doctors and you broke a bone in a bike accident.
18
• The Facilitator
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
19
You would probably think your only option was to take care of the injury on your own.
20
• The Facilitator
Sounds silly, right?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
21
Thankfully, we live in a world where we know doctors exist and we know how they can help.
22
• The Facilitator
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
23
But...
24
• The Facilitator
Have you ever met a dialogue facilitator? Have you ever seen a dialogue facilitator at work? Have you ever heard anyone say, “When I grow up I want to be a dialogue facilitator”? ...probably not.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
25
26
• The Facilitator
Unfortunately, when human communication breaks down, when we are in the middle of a conflict that we can’t resolve, and when our relationships become unhealthy,
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
27
28
• The Facilitator
most of us tend to think our only option is to “live with it”—
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
29
because we have no idea there are people who are trained to help in these situations.
30
• The Facilitator
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
31
There are so many times when we need dialogue facilitators...
32
• The Facilitator
just like we need medical doctors.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
33
That’s why we’re glad you decided to read this book—
34
• The Facilitator
to learn what dialogue facilitators do.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
35
Then perhaps we can add YOU to the growing list of dialogue facilitators on the planet.
36
• The Facilitator
So let’s get started!
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
37
Part Two The Facilitator
40
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
A Story
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
41
42
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
Let us bring you into a story.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
43
This is an ancient story.
44
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
It is a story of clashing and misunderstanding.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
45
This story begins with two forces—
46
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
two forces that have universal power and influence, two forces that profoundly impact our world, two forces that shape each of us.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
47
These forces are both invisible and well-known.
48
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
These forces are...
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
49
Conflict
50
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
and Collaboration
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
51
Conflict and Collaboration shape our past, present, and future. They shape nations, families and individuals.
52
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
And guess what? This is where YOU could enter the story...
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
53
54
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
because a facilitator works closely with these powerful forces. A facilitator helps to shift and direct these forces.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
55
In fact, if there is one thing a facilitator knows better than anything else, it is...
56
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
Conflict and Collaboration. (Okay, there are two things.)
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
57
Facilitators are willing to get close to Conflict and Collaboration because they know how essential these forces are—
58
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
to innovation and change, to health and well-being, and to Life itself.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
59
It’s okay if you don’t see all that yet. You will.
60
• Facilitator Mindset [A Story]
For now, let’s continue with the story.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
61
62
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Conflict
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
63
64
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
First, let’s get to know Conflict.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
65
66
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
What feelings arise when you encounter Conflict?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
67
Maybe you feel: Anger Pain Defensiveness Vulnerability Powerlessness Threat Fear Intimidation Isolation Division Competition
68
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
These feelings are common responses; however, they keep us in an uncomfortable relationship with Conflict.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
69
But there is good news—
70
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Conflict itself is not what actually leads to those feelings. “Then what does?” you must be asking.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
71
It is Combat,
72
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
the more extreme and less constructive “cousin” of Conflict.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
73
Anger Pain Defensiveness Vulnerability Powerlessness Threat Fear Intimidation Isolation
74
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
are actually responses to Combat— a force that attempts to repress or eliminate differences.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
75
Conflict is simply— an encounter between alternative ways or contrasting perspectives. Period.
76
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
77
Conflict itself contains no threat or demand. But somehow, Conflict has gotten a negative reputation.
78
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
79
80
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Thankfully, facilitators can help.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
81
Facilitators know: Conflict is an encounter with something dierent.
82
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Different views. Different suggestions. Different opinions. Different experiences. Simply different.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
83
Combat is the attempt to repress or eliminate those dierences.
84
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
85
Can you see the difference?
Conflict: an encounter with differences
86
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Combat: the struggle to eliminate those dierences
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
87
Now here’s the thing...
88
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Although Conflict and Combat are dierent, a facilitator needs to know something else about these forces:
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
89
Combat is often a result—of denying, ignoring or repressing Conflict.
90
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
91
In other words, when we turn away from Conflict (as so many of us do),
92
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
we are actually creating the conditions for Combat.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
93
94
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Of course, turning away from Conflict is usually based on our best intentions— to be non-judgemental, to keep peace, to accept other people.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
95
But these “good intentions” are not constructive because they are often based on Fear— which distorts what we see.
96
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
97
98
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
And so we usually mistake CONFLICT (an encounter between different perspectives)
for COMBAT (the struggle to eliminate those different perspectives).
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
99
We will say it again: Our underlying Fear often makes (non-threatening) Conflict appear to be Combat (which feels threatening).
100
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
And that innocent mistake is like the moment we fall and break a bone: We’re going to need help. We just don’t usually know that.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
101
Enter a facilitator who knows:
102
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Conflict itself is a benign force. Conflict is a simple indicator of dierence. Conflict is nothing to Fear.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
103
104
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Rather than seeing Conflict through the lens of Fear...
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
105
106
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
a facilitator sees Conflict with curiosity— through the lens of Discovery.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
107
This lens allows facilitators to see Conflict for what it is, and to trust that these dierences matter (in a good way).
108
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
109
And because facilitators learn to trust Conflict, they approach it as an ally.
110
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
111
112
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
And they relate to Conflict with the desire to listen to its important messages.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
113
Think of the last time you faced Conflict. What could you have tried to hear, to learn, to notice? What could you have Discovered if you didn’t turn away?
114
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
115
116
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
This is a lot to digest. So here’s what we’re saying so far:
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
117
Conflict is an encounter between differences.
Combat is the struggle to eliminate those differences.
118
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Fear actually pushes us away from Conflict, and toward Combat. Discovery invites us toward Conflict, and away from Combat.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
119
And, in the presence of Conflict, a facilitator operates with the fearless mindset of Discovery.
120
• Facilitator Mindset [Conflict]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
121
122
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Collaboration
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
123
124
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Now that you’ve had some time to get to know Conflict, let’s explore the other force in our story— Collaboration.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
125
126
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
First, let’s think about what’s essential to projects, relationships or moments that are “collaborative.”
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
127
Perhaps it’s: Teamwork Support Unity Creativity Sharing Partnership Harmony Agreement Belonging Friendship These qualities are probably a lot more appealing...
128
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
than the ones you may have associated with Conflict.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
129
BUT, here’s the thing:
130
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
This list is incomplete.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
131
132
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
What about? Objection Resistance Divergence Dissonance Disagreement Dissatisfaction Dissent Critique Hesitation Doubt Disapproval Questioning
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
133
134
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Without the presence of experiences like these, Collaboration is more of an illusion than a reality. (We’ll tell you why later. But follow us for a moment.)
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
135
And if you have lived or worked closely with other people without disagreement or dissatisfaction,
136
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
you have likely experienced this illusion of Collaboration.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
137
In this illusion of Collaboration, “togetherness” is more important than new or creative ideas.
138
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
139
140
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Think about these factors: Obligations Traditions Rules Laws Chains of command Standards Demands Needs for Acceptance even...Coercion
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
141
They can help us work together, but they also prevent us from acting on our gut instincts and inspirations—and from sharing our different opinion or unique vision.
142
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
143
They also contribute to an underlying sense that “you have to do it this way or you don’t belong with us.”
144
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
145
146
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
We’re not sure what you call this kind of forced togetherness, but we call it Conformity— the more restrictive and less accepting “cousin” of Collaboration.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
147
148
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Conformity can be really subtle, where it looks (and even feels) like “working together,” but it just doesn’t include our differences.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
149
And even though we may approach Collaboration with the desire for unity and teamwork,
150
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
we often fail when we encounter our basic dierences.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
151
So our groups usually end up in a place of Conformity, not Collaboration.
152
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
153
“Why?” you ask.
154
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Well, remember Fear?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
155
When we approach Collaboration with any Fear— which usually means not addressing basic differences— the outcome is Conformity.
156
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
But how does this happen?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
157
When working together, we often Fear being dierent or not belonging. So we silence our voice to fit in.
158
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
159
160
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
On the other hand, we may Fear losing control of our leadership, vision or independence. So we pressure others to follow us.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
161
Either way, we Fear disagreement. So we don’t address the disagreement.
162
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Sounds a lot like our Fear of Conflict, doesn’t it?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
163
But as you now know, facilitators don’t Fear disagreement.
164
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
165
166
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
They Trust disagreement— because they know the value of Conflict. And they believe in the power of true Collaboration just like they believe in the power of true Conflict.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
167
Facilitators know what to do when Fear leads to the illusion of Collaboration.
168
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Remember the mindset of Discovery?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
169
170
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
A facilitator helps people to Discover their divergent perspectives so they can work together, without losing their individuality.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
171
172
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
This becomes TRUE Collaboration– where we create something new based on our different ways.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
173
An important sidenote:
174
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
There are also members of groups who say, “I don’t care about this.” “I don’t have a position.” Where do they fit in all of this?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
175
176
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Well, “not caring” or not having a stance is actually a stance.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
177
“Not caring” is a position that adds extra weight to things being “as they are”, and to maintaining the status quo, whatever that may be at the time.
178
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Whatever
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
179
And while there is nothing essentially wrong with things being as they are, it is important for us to recognize that “not caring� maintains this.
180
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
In other words, “not caring” is a stance that has influence and weight in relationships and in groups.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
181
182
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
So let’s summarize this part of our story.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
183
Collaboration is working with others while maintaining our divergent views. Conformity is going along with others because we feel pressure to agree.
184
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Fear pushes us away from Collaboration, and toward Conformity. Discovery invites us toward Collaboration, and away from Conformity.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
185
In the presence of Collaboration, a facilitator operates with the mindset of Discovery—skeptical of unquestioned agreement.
186
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
187
REMEMBER: A facilitator’s work is to move individuals away from Combat and Conformity and towards Conflict and Collaboration—
188
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
to keep the forces of Conflict and Collaboration operating in a dynamic balance.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
189
190
• Facilitator Mindset [Collabortation]
And while a facilitator needs a mindset of Discovery to help do this, the whole process also requires Trust and the ability to embrace paradox. That’s where we’re headed next.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
191
192
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Paradox
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
193
Are you ready for an interesting, and seemingly contradictory, idea?
194
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
It is another key to this story— and to the mindset of a facilitator:
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
195
Combat and Conformity are actually very SIMILAR forces.
196
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
These forces appear to be opposites, appear to be at odds,
because they are at opposite ends of the fulcrum.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
197
But Combat and Conformity actually share very similar qualities.
198
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Can you name some?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
199
Here are a few:
200
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Both create clear enemies and clear borders between “us and them.” It’s all about “us, us, us.” Both seek converts to “our way.” Both have clear positions on moral/ethical/ philosophical issues. Their mottos could be,“You are with us, or you are against us.” Both have little latitude for alternate views. Following is important for both.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
201
Paradoxical? Yes.
202
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
But the ability to embrace paradox is actually the essence of the facilitator mindset.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
203
By embracing paradox, we can see that seemingly opposing activities like fighting a war (Combat) or following a movement (Conformity)
204
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
make little room for Discovery, can be driven by Fear,
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
205
and in both cases, need to silence dierences.
206
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Interesting, right?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
207
So what is unique about Combat and Conformity?
208
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Well… “our” voices are silenced in Conformity, while “their” voices are silenced in Combat.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
209
In other words— People don’t listen to themselves in Conformity and they don’t listen to others in Combat.
210
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
And yes, this is exactly where a facilitator can be helpful.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
211
Because this is exactly where a mindset of Discovery is essential.
212
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
A facilitator seeks to Discover unspoken and unheard perspectives. How exactly?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
213
Standing fearlessly in the presence of either Combat or Conformity, a facilitator invites individuals to voice their own perspectives
214
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
AND to listen to the perspectives of others.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
215
These acts of voicing and listening are imperative to restoring balance to unhealthy relationships.
216
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
217
And these acts of voicing and listening provide a foundation for building Trust between individuals—
218
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
and Trust in the forces of Conflict and Collaboration.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
219
So let’s return to the relationship between Conflict and Collaboration.
220
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
This is core to the work of a facilitator.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
221
222
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Collaboration is a force that creates a foundation for stability. Conflict is a force that creates a foundation for change.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
223
And we need both.
224
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Each plays a crucial role in ensuring that relationships are both stable and changing.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
225
So here’s another paradox for you: When people in Conflict listen to each other, Collaboration grows.
226
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
227
228
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
And, when people in Collaboration express divergent views, Conflict grows.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
229
And remember, we want and require both. This is the essence of paradox.
230
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Conflict and Collaboration actually “need” each other to create a healthy, dynamic balance.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
231
And as long as this movement between these essential forces flows back and forth, over and over and over again,
232
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
we should see more healthy and more balanced relationships, ones that build a foundation of trust and allow for dierences.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
233
234
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Believe it or not, you now have a picture of the mindset of a facilitator. Take a look‌
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
235
Conflict
Trust supports (and reinforces) Conflict and Collaboration.
236
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Collaboration
Combat
Conformity
Fear pushes us toward Combat and Conformity.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
237
To restore and maintain balance, a facilitator encourages listening when people are in Combat or Conflict and voicing when people are in Conformity or Collaboration.
238
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Combat
Listen Conformity
Voice
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
239
This mindset needs to be activated in every space where these powerful forces appear (and are regularly misunderstood).
240
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
We humans don’t do this naturally.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
241
That’s why we need facilitators. It’s not just our bodies that we need to keep healthy; it’s our relationships too.
242
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
243
And if all of this is beginning to feel exciting...
244
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
you are DEVELOPING the mindset of a facilitator.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
245
A mindset open to paradox. A mindset of Discovery.
246
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
A mindset to facilitate conversations that restore and maintain this necessary balance between Conflict and Collaboration. Here it is again‌
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
247
When Fear pushes us toward Combat, a facilitator encourages listening in order to move toward healthy Conflict.
This process creates a foundation of Trust which su
248
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
When Fear pushes us toward Conformity, a facilitator encourages voicing in order to move toward healthy Collaboration.
upports (and reinforces) Conflict and Collaboration.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
249
250
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
And with that, we leave our story...
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
251
252
• Facilitator Mindset [Paradox]
but not our book! Next we’re going to share with you some key communication practices to help you put all of these concepts to use.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
253
Part Three Communication Practices of a Facilitator
256
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
Facilitators need more than a mindset to navigate Conflict and Collaboration.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
257
Facilitators need specific communication practices to help redirect and balance the way these forces operate between people.
258
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
259
260
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
This section is about how a facilitator uses communication practices to apply their mindset to relationships that are out of balance.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
261
These practices will allow you to listen, to poke at people’s opinions, ideologies and positions, to push them to explore more nuanced views and to help enlarge their ability to think in grey areas.
262
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
Think Discovery.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
263
These practices will also help you to shift relationships away from the extremes of Combat and Conformity— and towards the more moderate forces of Conflict and Collaboration.
264
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
265
266
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
Ready for the first one?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
267
268
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
Socractic Inquiry
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
269
270
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Socratic Inquiry is the first step in moderating the forces of Combat and Conformity.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
271
272
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Remember, people stuck in these extreme positions think about things according to the side they’ve chosen and behave like they have answers.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
273
Having answers usually makes us feel “smart” and “informed” and superior to the side we have not chosen.
274
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
275
276
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
This also can make us feel like we belong with others who have similar answers.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
277
But most “answers” are more like knee-jerk reactions rather than thoughtful conclusions based on careful and ongoing examination. And—
278
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
answers tend to be absolute and inflexible, answers become positions, answers are diďŹƒcult to question.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
279
So a facilitator must find ways to help individuals in Combat and in Conformity to question their “answers.”
280
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
How do facilitators do this?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
281
You may have heard of the Socratic Method. It’s a philosophical practice of asking questions (and answering with questions) in a ongoing search for “truth.”
282
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
283
284
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
This practice is in direct opposition to maintaining one’s sense of “right-ness” by debating and defending one’s answers.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
285
286
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
When someone is asked good, constructive questions and at some point recognizes that their “answer” cannot stand up to these questions, their view can be reshaped or revised.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
287
By contrast, if an answer does stand up to good, constructive questions,
288
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
a person can feel more confident in their view.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
289
“Socratic Inquiry” is our “emotionally intelligent” version of the Socratic Method—
290
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
a practice we’ve developed that goes beyond the academic or philosophical discussions associated with the Socratic Method.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
291
Socratic Inquiry takes into account who is asking the questions and how the questions are being asked.
292
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
And facilitators practice it to address issues that are charged and relationships that are out of balance or inequitable.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
293
294
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
So facilitators ask questions from every perspective and every position in order to challenge every perspective and every position.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
295
This makes it more likely that individuals will receive the questions as an opportunity to explore rather than a moment to defend a position.
296
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
297
298
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
The practice of Socratic Inquiry helps people to question the answers that tend to dominate in groups who are standing in Combat and Conformity.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
299
300
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
With thoughtful questioning from ALL angles, facilitators help individuals to explore, discover or revise their views—which is good for them.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
301
302
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
And this process does a lot to modify the intensity of Combat and Conformity—which is good for everybody.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
303
304
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Remember: A facilitator is needed to apply this method in contentious (Combat) and uncompromising (Conformity) situations because people will not naturally question themselves—
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
305
especially when their answers are connected to their identity, belonging or beliefs.
306
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
We are all more likely to defend ourselves and our views (and solidify those same views), rather than to challenge ourselves. (And this keeps us stuck in Combat or Conformity.)
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
307
So HOW does a facilitator actually practice Socratic Inquiry?
308
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Overall, by responding to people’s “answers” with constructive questions (ones that activate a mindset of Discovery).
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
309
Let’s practice…
310
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Think of a belief that you hold that you know can be contentious. For example: The Western world is more progressive than other parts of the world.
Ask a question about that belief. For example: What are the progressive elements associated with the Western world?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
311
Keep generating more and more questions. What else could be included in this belief? What could be excluded from this belief? What are you curious about when you think of this belief? What else are you curious about? What do you think is absolutely true about this belief? What do you think is uncertain about this belief?
312
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Belief: The Western world is more progressive than other parts of the world. For example: What is the Western World? What does the rest of the world see that perhaps the progressive world does not? What is the other side of being progressive? What are the dangers of a progressive world?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
313
.
Examine it from all angles. What would someone from another group see? What would they think is true? What do they think you’re missing? How would you respond to them? Where does the other group have a good point? Etc., etc.
314
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Belief: The Western world is more progressive than other parts of the world For example: How is that actually dierent compared to the rest of the world? Whose rights are forgotten in the progressive world? Who is not being considered in either of these worlds?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
315
As you practice Socratic Inquiry—
316
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Question every answer. Explore the assumptions that are behind every answer. Elicit stories that illustrate how an individual arrived at their views. Seek more and more views on every topic than you can imagine.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
317
Here’s a very simple “formula” for Socratic Inquiry:
318
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Questions + Questions + Questions = More Questions
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
319
And “more questions” translates into:
320
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
less absolute clarity, less belief in a singular position (or answer), and more willingness to consider other views.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
321
More questions really means— more potential for Discovery.
322
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
323
We know this uncertainty often feels uncomfortable.
324
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
But, don’t worry! We’ve all done this before—
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
325
when we were children.
326
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Think of how children are not satisfied with “answers” because they are already on to the next question.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
327
And think about how much children Discover!
328
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Some call this a “Beginner’s Mind” (another key element of the mindset of a facilitator).
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
329
So now you know the first communication practice for facilitators— SOCRATIC INQUIRY.
330
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
Practicing this will keep you connected to a Beginner’s Mind, which is another way to say “a mindset of Discovery.”
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
331
332
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Socratic Inquiry]
But there are a few other basic practices a facilitator uses to be most effective in employing Socratic Inquiry. So, let’s keep going.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
333
334
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
Taking All Sides
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
335
336
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
As you now know, when people are in close proximity to Combat or Conformity, it is very tempting to take one side. Most of us do.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
337
338
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
BUT, the job of a facilitator is do something unusual. The job of a facilitator is to take all sides—temporarily.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
339
“Taking All Sides” is a temporary stance where a facilitator is not aligned with or in support of any one side or position in a controversy.
340
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
A facilitator is actually aligned with ALL sides and positions.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
341
This is like being a referee—you make the same calls for both teams.
342
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
343
344
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
It’s also like being a doctor in a war zone—you treat all people who are wounded.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
345
346
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
When a facilitator stands on all sides, it allows them to be curious from those different positions. And this turns into more thoughtful questions—which leads to more Discovery.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
347
Remember, your job as a facilitator is to help people from every side to move closer toward the fulcrum’s balance point.
348
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
349
We are not saying that facilitators should be “neutral” people—
350
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
just like we wouldn’t say doctors should be immune from disease.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
351
You are NOT a neutral person, we know that. You have opinions, answers, and positions as well.
352
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
353
BUT, when you are facilitating, your job is to seek and explore the truth in ALL sides. That act becomes a catalyst to the rebalancing of unhealthy relationships.
354
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
And this makes the work of a facilitator extremely diďŹƒcult and valuable and necessary to the world.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
355
Of course, facilitators are still people who can get “provoked” or “bothered” when they encounter certain views.
356
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
This will happen to you. It happens to all of us.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
357
“Getting provoked” will make you want to defend one side. It could even feel like a moral conflict. But in order to serve others, we put that tendency aside temporarily.
358
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
359
So let’s take a moment to think about you: What are some opinions, answers or positions you have?
360
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
What are some ideas you just cannot accept or that you refuse to believe? Or stated another way, what’s on YOUR sign(s)?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
361
362
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
Revisiting YOUR sign(s), and recognizing ideas that provoke or bother you is essential to your work as a facilitator. Why?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
363
Because you need to know when you can’t facilitate—because that happens.
364
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
You have limits. We all do. And it is good to know when you reach them. (We could write another book on that.)
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
365
Helpful hint: When it’s hard “Taking All Sides,” rely on the practice of Socratic Inquiry to keep you curious and to help you stay in Discovery mindset.
366
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
The practices of Socratic Inquiry and Taking All Sides work together.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
367
368
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Taking All Sides]
Ready for another practice?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
369
370
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
Open-Ended Questions
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
371
372
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Questions are not just questions.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
373
HOW
DID
YOU
DO
THAT
?
HY
W
For a facilitator, questions become a practice.
374
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
So they pay attention to how to design questions and how to ask them.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
375
Humans tend to ask questions that are familiar to them, ones that lead to comfortable or predictable answers.
376
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
The effect of these questions— intentional or not—is actually to close a conversation rather than to open one.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
377
But in order for new ideas and new perspectives to emerge,
378
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
we cannot keep asking the same questions in the same old ways.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
379
380
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
We have to ask new questions, open questions—so we can elicit creative and “new” responses (responses we have not heard before).
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
381
We especially need to do this when addressing seemingly intractable problems–
382
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
when we find ourselves in places of Combat or Conformity.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
383
“New” answers are ones that an individual has not previously considered or ones that have not been inherited from others.
384
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
385
New answers often take individuals beyond truths they have accepted and that have become obligatory.
386
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
This can be scary territory.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
387
388
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
But when individuals do uncover new answers, they are by definition in the territory of Discovery.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
389
And as you now know, Discovery is the antidote for Combat and Conformity.
390
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
391
As a facilitator, you need to be able to ask these new questions. Sounds daunting, right?
392
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Well, one place to start is to simply ask Open-Ended Questions.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
393
Open-Ended Questions are designed very specifically—
394
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
to elicit more than a one-word answer, more than a “yes” or “no.”
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
395
396
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
So facilitators don’t ask: Do you want that? Do you like that? Is that your view? Is this what bothers you?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
397
Can you see how those questions are closed-ended?
398
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
They effectively “close” a conversation because the person only can answer with “yes” or “no.”
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
399
Open-Ended Questions always begin with the words “what” or “how.”
400
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
What inspired you to go in that direction? How did you tell your sister that? What do you want? How do you feel when he forgets? (We’ll talk about “Why” questions later…)
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
401
402
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Open-Ended Questions are one of a facilitator’s practices because people respond to them with stories rather than “answers”.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
403
404
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
And stories humanize. Stories also express a wealth of information about a person’s assumptions, perspectives, feelings and experiences.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
405
Stories are richer, more complex and more nuanced than a person’s singular stance or opinion.
406
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
407
408
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Stories also begin to undermine: the divisiveness, the certainty, and the polarities that define how people think and talk when standing in Combat or Conformity.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
409
410
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Are you beginning to see how Open-Ended Questions have the power to alter the way people talk—and think—about something?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
411
In short, personal stories are harder to “tame,” harder to put into a box, and harder to dismiss because they are by nature complex.
412
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
413
414
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
And complexity is another route to Discovery!
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
415
But complexity can also lead to confusion and silence. That is okay.
416
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
417
418
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Remember, the new questions you ask require new responses— ones people have never thought about before. This is hard work—and takes time.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
419
Your questions may not be embraced immediately.
420
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
But with practice, you will acquire the patience and confidence to trust your questions and give people time to respond to them fully.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
421
Let’s talk about “Why” questions now.
422
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
You might have noticed that “Why” also creates an Open-Ended Question—and it definitely invites more than a one-word response. It even may lead to a story.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
423
However, it subtly asks for an explanation or a justification (which is perilously close to an “answer”).
424
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
And this often invites a more “scripted” response, a conclusion or an interpretation someone may have already determined.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
425
And “why” often just feels a bit pushy and demanding.
426
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
427
For example: Why do you feel this way? Why did you do that? Why are you not listening? Why do you prefer that? Why do you not understand them?
428
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Compared to: What makes you feel this way? What inspired you to do that? What makes it hard to listen? What made you prefer that? What is diďŹƒcult to understand about them?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
429
As you begin your work as a facilitator, it’s best to break the habit of using “Why” questions and to challenge yourself to ask “What” or “How” questions. Trust us, this makes a difference.
430
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
431
REMEMBER: People standing in Combat and Conformity already have “answers.” And they are really good at explaining and justifying those answers.
432
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
They need a facilitator to invite them to share stories and to explore their complex experiences.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
433
HOW
DID
YOU
DO
THAT
?
HY
W
And creating new, Open-Ended Questions will help with this.
434
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
By the way, we are not saying that “answers” are always bad.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
435
But we are saying that in the extremes of Combat and Conformity, answers do a great job of maintaining the extremes— rather than encouraging the moderating influence of nuance.
436
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
437
Ultimately, in practicing Open-Ended Questions here are some of your goals:
438
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Seek out the knowledge and lived experiences of individuals What motivated you to do‌? What inspired you? What took you there?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
439
Encourage personal reflection What feelings does this topic elicit? What does hearing this make you remember? How has this shown up in your life? What have you learned from this?
440
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Ask for stories that demonstrate how an individual arrived at a belief or understanding How did you learn about this? How did your understanding of this originate? How did you discover this belief? What personal stories support this idea?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
441
Invite diverse opinions and viewpoints What is a viewpoint that is missing from the current conversation? What is a dierent way to respond to that? What part of this dialogue is in disagreement with your beliefs? How might someone else think about this?
442
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Explore underlying assumptions What do you need to accept for this idea to be true? How is that idea incomplete? What assumptions come to mind as you listen to this idea?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
443
444
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
So let’s practice asking new, Open-Ended Questions Look at the image here with the ice cream cone and two characters. Spend a few minutes thinking of as many “How” or “What” questions you could ask to discover more of this story.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
445
Maybe some of your questions looked like this:
446
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Seek out the knowledge and lived experiences of individuals What is the motivation for not allowing ice cream? What might happen if either of you eat ice cream? What are other things that are not allowed? What are you really upset about in this moment?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
447
Encourage personal reflection You look sad that he is saying “no” to ice cream; what does this make you want to do? What angers you about seeing him with ice cream? What does not allowing ice cream mean to you? What made you bring ice cream if you knew it was not allowed?
448
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Ask for stories that demonstrate how an individual arrived at a belief or understanding What has happened in your experience that makes ice cream a bad idea? How did you come to be so strict about this rule? How did you decide to oer him ice cream?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
449
Invite diverse opinions and viewpoints How might he be feeling holding the ice cream? What would he say “yes” to? What can you do with the ice cream? What does ice cream taste like? What is hard to accept in this moment? What is another way to think about each of your actions? 450
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
Explore underlying assumptions How might each of you be right? How might each of you be wrong? How do you know he doesn’t like ice cream? How do you know he likes ice cream?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
451
The best practice will come in authentic situations.
452
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
So experiment with asking new, Open-Ended Questions the next time you are in a conversation— with anyone.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
453
The fourth facilitation practice will help you respond to what emerges when you ask these new, Open-Ended Questions—
454
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Open-Ended Questions]
because facilitation is about more than asking good questions. You’ll see what we mean.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
455
456
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
Active Reflective Listening
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
457
458
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
As you have probably already observed, humans are not the best listeners—even under ideal circumstances.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
459
We often “selectively listen”— which means paying attention to what we want to hear, or what we expect to hear.
460
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
461
462
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
We also “listen to win”— that is, we listen to prove we are right and others are wrong.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
463
We may listen for what is good or bad, right or wrong, yours or mine, or how we agree or disagree.
464
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
465
466
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
We may listen to maintain our answers. We may listen to keep our worldview in place. We may even pretend to listen.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
467
Overall, our listening is usually motivated by a subtle but potent desire NOT to hear something new.
468
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
469
Facilitators listen with a dierent purpose.
470
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
A facilitator’s job is to do the opposite of the rest of us.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
471
A facilitator’s job is to listen actively—with openness, with a mindset of Discovery, without attachment to specific answers.
472
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
473
474
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
A facilitator listens to discover more than what is currently accepted as true. That means they pay attention to what is not being said, what is hard to share, what is beneath the surface, what is shared between enemies and what is unshared between allies.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
475
476
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
A facilitator also listens to understand. So they pay attention to key details, examples, and experiences that help to explain a person’s views.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
477
478
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
A facilitator listens for unexpressed feelings.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
479
480
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
And a facilitator listens for the “pearls of truth” that exist in every perspective. (This can only happen if they are Taking All Sides, by the way.)
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
481
Overall, active listening is a commitment to listening fearlessly (as opposed to narrowly).
482
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
483
But… Facilitators don’t “just” listen actively. They actually “do something” with their listening.
484
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
They do something called reflective listening.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
485
486
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Facilitators summarize or rephrase or underline things that have been shared. Or even more simply, a facilitator just repeats the exact words that were just said. This is called “reflecting.” (You will be surprised by how often this simple tool matters.)
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
487
And this practice helps people in Combat and Conformity hear the things they otherwise cannot hear.
488
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
OU Y , Y NT A OKA W U O Y AID CT S E T P S ES JU R E MOR
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
489
490
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Because people in Combat and Conformity listen selectively, they cannot hear new things that would invite them to break out of the extremes.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
491
Reflective listening is essential because: It helps people to listen better to one another.
492
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
It slows down the pace. It helps an individual to listen to themselves.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
493
Facilitators can also move a dialogue forward by expressing in their own words thoughts, feelings or ideas that they have interpreted from what someone has said.
494
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
495
YOU MA KE ME SO M A WHEN Y D OU DO THA T.
496
YOU A FEE CTUAL L L THA HURT Y T PAY HE’S N O IN ATT G YOU T ENT ION.
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
In other words, facilitators can reflect the essence of what they heard.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
497
For this purpose, facilitators use phrases like this:
498
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
It sounds like you value… So what I’m hearing is… I believe what you’re saying is that… I’m noticing… It’s almost like you said… I’m getting the impression… I’m getting the sense that… When you say this… From your perspective… You seem to be feeling…
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
499
In practicing Active Reflective Listening, here are some of your goals:
500
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Affirm the value of an individual sharing his or her perspective. Thank you so much for sharing that story. Ensure every perspective is received and understood. I am wondering if someone else has another side to this story to share. Clarify an individual’s meaning and intent to better understand their viewpoint. What I am understanding is that…. Summarize information for the group. This is what I heard you say:
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
501
With that in mind, let’s practice.
502
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Read the story on the next page. And think of an Active Reflective Listening statement for each goal.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
503
The first time I met my parents, I was trembling, holding the hand of an air hostess. I had just flown from India all the way to New York City. (My parents lived in New York City. They moved there when I was one year old. They left me in India in the hands of my grandparents to raise me until they were ready to bring me overseas). It felt like seconds ago that I just left the arms of my grandmother who raised me with devotion. It also felt like eons ago when I said goodbye to my grandfather, promising him that I would continue to be a great math student. He was a math professor in a remote village in India you see. We lived at the border of Pakistan and India. I was born into a Sikh household, into a family that practices a religion that honors teachings from both Hinduism and Islam. Apart from our religion, mathematics was the only other
504
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
thing that mattered to my grandfather. I promised him I would continue to be good at math. That’s how I got through my flight alone, as an eight year old. I counted all the seats on the plane, multiplied them by 1’s, 5’s, 10’s, and did all sorts of math problems that my grandfather would do with me. We could be in line for getting milk and he would find a way to practice a math problem. As I waited in line now, I glanced down at the picture of my parents I was carrying. All I had was one little photo of them, smiling at each other holding me when I was one. As I looked up, I saw my parents ahead. And then I saw a third person, a little boy in the middle. The math didn’t add up. He wasn’t in my photo. No one had told me about the brother I was just about to meet. I was being adopted by my own family.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
505
Here’s a few examples: Affirm the value of an individual sharing his or her perspective. Thank you so much for taking the risk to share your experiences and memories of feeling like an outsider amidst your own family. It sounds so complicated. Ensure every perspective is received and understood. I am wondering what your brother feels about that story you shared about meeting your parents for the first time.
506
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Clarify an individual’s meaning and intent to better understand their viewpoint. So what I am understanding from your story is that it was difficult to leave your grandparents because they felt like your parents. From what I heard in your story, it sounds like you felt betrayed by your parents. Summarize information for the group. From your perspective, you grew up trusting your grandparents and feeling abandoned and misinformed by your parents.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
507
508
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
So... Active listening is a commitment to absorbing fearlessly what a person is communicating.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
509
510
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Active Reflective Listening is putting into words what you absorbed in order to share it with an individual.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
511
512
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
We hope you can see that listening actively and reflecting what you hear helps people to receive more fully what has been said—and thus, to create another route to Discovery.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
513
The next (and final) practice will tune your attention to basic principles of group communication.
514
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
We’ve been talking a lot about how facilitators work with individuals.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
515
But when you facilitate a dialogue, you will be working with a group— which can sometimes behave like a living, breathing organism.
516
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
517
518
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Active Reflective Listening]
This section will also help you to see how to integrate all of the practices we’ve discussed already.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
519
520
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator
Disrupting Communication Patterns
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
521
522
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
As you’ve learned, relationships can be seen as unhealthy or out of balance when the individuals involved cannot disagree meaningfully, and cannot maintain mutual trust and respect when they do.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
523
524
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
What we see is that people who are stuck in Combat or Conformity LIMIT both what they express and how they express themselves.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
525
maintain similar arguments
lead to similar conclusions
526
develop similar narratives
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
But these patterns 1. maintain similar arguments, 2. develop similar narratives, and 3. lead to similar conclusions which prevents the Discovery of new perspectives and new conclusions—
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
527
and which keeps people in Combat or Conformity.
528
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
maintain similar arguments
lead to similar conclusions
develop similar narratives
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
529
maintain similar arguments lead to similar conclusions
530
develop similar narratives
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
A facilitator’s work is to gently disrupt these patterns to help people to engage in less habitual or “scripted” ways. A facilitator can intervene on two different levels of a conversation:
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
531
The specific topics discussed... e.g., our homes, our families, our workplace, our thoughts about the latest election, our feelings about an incident of terrorism, our desires for the future, etc.
532
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
533
and how topics are discussed. e.g., suggesting, defending, intellectualizing, yelling, demanding, persuading, clarifying, etc.
534
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
535
536
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
This distinction matters because— the conversation can be stuck in a topic— or the way people are talking about the topic. Or both.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
537
And a facilitator has to identify where to disrupt the communication patterns.
538
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
539
Let’s start with how a facilitator can work with topics.
540
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
But get ready because we’re also going to explore a complex example here to show you how to use all of your practices at once.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
541
542
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
TOPICS = what people are talking about. For example, a group of men is talking about their roles in the family.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
543
Their comments revolve around a particular topic—that men must be the providers in their families.
544
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
They are saying things like: “What do we need to do to make sure young men in our community are ready to care for their family?” “I have two daughters, and I feel like I don’t have anyone to take care of my family in the future.” “Everything is ok in my family, I take care of making sure all needs are met.”
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
545
While these are all valuable ideas, they are only considering one perspective on the topic.
546
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
That perspective is: Men HAVE to be providers for the family.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
547
So what do you do as a facilitator when you observe this pattern— that people are locked in one particular perspective on a topic?
548
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
549
550
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
A facilitator uses their communication practices to disrupt this pattern in order to invite additional perspectives on the topic—to make their discussion more exploratory and constructive.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
551
A facilitator would use all of their practices here to explore the topic— That men must be the providers of a family
552
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
and to expand it to include additional perspectives. That providing for the family could include contributions from all members of the family That women need to be providers of the family That being a provider is not the most important role in a family
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
553
554
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
You can think of this as creating mini “thought experiments”—as a way to help people to think “outside the box.”
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
555
Questioning the limits of the topic and seeking additional perspectives helps the group to Discover new ways of thinking about the topic.
556
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
See how Discovery naturally emerges?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
557
And in Discovering new ways of thinking about a topic, a group may even be able to explore more topics.
558
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
For example: While the men started out talking about their role in the family, they move into talking about marriage or intimacy and what they need from their partners (which may, in turn, open up their view of their roles).
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
559
But... a conversation cannot move toward Discovery unless a facilitator interrupts a group’s most redundant topics.
560
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
561
562
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
So what are some practical ways to do this?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
563
564
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Hint: Use the communication practices you are learning to open the group to a new landscape of topics and perspectives.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
565
Ask Open-Ended Questions that will broaden the discussion: “What stories have yet to be shared about this?” “What other ideas are missing from our conversation?” “What’s another way to think about this topic that you would not consider?”
566
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
567
568
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Share what you are observing with Active Reflective Listening statements and questions: “It sounds like we are all expressing the same opinion.” “It seems like we are stuck between two topics. What’s another way to see this?” “We have been using similar positions to talk about this topic. Are there more?” “It seems that someone is trying to state a different perspective. Let’s explore it.”
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
569
Activate Socratic Inquiry and trust your facilitator mindset.
570
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
571
Now let’s examine the second level—how a group discusses things.
572
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Often, it’s hard for us to see how we are talking to each other. That’s why a facilitator is so important.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
573
There will be patterns that a facilitator will notice. These patterns are all impacting the conversation.
574
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
So, we’re going to examine six ways of communicating that allow a facilitator to understand relationships and possibilities in a dialogue:
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
575
576
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
1. Volume Example: yelling, being timid, mumbling, barely speaking
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
577
578
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
2. Tone Example: aggressive, angry, shy anxious, fearful, distracted
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
579
580
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
3. Body language Example: crossing legs, folding arms, edge of the seat, pulled into the group, smirking, smiling, crying
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
581
582
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
4. Pace Example: speaking fast, cutting people o, taking time to finish thoughts
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
583
584
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
5. Energy level Example: tired, emotional, lively, focused
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
585
586
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
6. Alliances Example: taking sides, speaking as “teams,” accepting certain ideas over others
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
587
588
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Let’s go back to our example of the men talking about providing for their families. You learned what to do as a facilitator when the conversation gets stuck on a topic.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
589
Now pay attention to how the group is communicating about a topic. As the men talk, their pace quickens, and people begin talking over one another— even making rapid arm motions in order to interrupt or stop what someone else is saying. At one point, two men turn to each other and start whispering.
590
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
591
The group’s current way of talking is exclusive, prevents everyone from being heard, and leaves little room for thinking about what is actually being said.
592
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
You have observed that there is a clear alliance between two men. You are noticing body language; a few other men have sat back in their seats. There is an aggressive tone and increased pace in people’s voices. The volume has died down, but the energy level seems really high and intense for a few participants while you notice that some participants are very reserved.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
593
As a facilitator you recognize that how they are talking is not the most eective means to Discover something new.
594
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
It is your job to disrupt these patterns. But how do you do that?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
595
596
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Return to your communication practices.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
597
You could start by simply asking Open-Ended Questions to the individuals about the ways they are communicating:
598
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
“What emotion is behind what you are saying?” “How can you say that so it can be understood by someone who disagrees?” “What is making you say this so timidly? (forcefully, quickly, loudly, etc.)” “What is making you want to speak over him?” “What are you feeling when you share that?”
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
599
You can also put two practices together—use your Active Reflective Listening to state an observation and follow it up with an Open-Ended Question.
600
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
“You both seem upset...what are you thinking?” “You have been quiet...what’s on your mind?” “I am aware that only three people are talking...what are we missing?” “We are talking really fast...what’s motivating that?” “I realized you just lowered your head… what are you feeling?”
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
601
602
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
As you begin noticing and disrupting communication patterns, you may begin to uncover a few common, unhelpful habits of communication.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
603
604
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
In fact, we call these “traps” rather than habits because humans tend to get stuck in these (usually invisible) patterns.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
605
Here are some communication traps you will likely need to disrupt in a group’s communication.
606
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
One overpowering voice setting the terms of the conversation Group members valuing thinking over feeling Group think: everyone agreeing with what is being said Non-mainstream perspectives being silenced
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
607
608
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Now, let’s break down a few traps that are a bit more complicated.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
609
Prioritizing rational argumentation over personal experience
610
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Think statistics, history, facts, researched articles, politics. When these dominate a conversation a facilitator needs to interrupt the speaker and ask for a story, “Can you share your facts through a story?” Why? These things tend to end true dialogue; they tend to lead us to positions and answers rather than the possibility of Discovery.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
611
Subtle judgments that systematically prevent expression of particular views
612
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
This may become apparent through body language (rolling of eyes, shaking of heads), or silence after someone has shared. Remember that a facilitator Takes All Sides. Momentarily take the side of a particular view so that it gets a fair chance to be examined. This often means simply talking to the person with the view that is being judged and inviting others to directly respond.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
613
Gender, race, culture norms
614
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
There are going to be dynamics at play that determine who tends to have power in situations (i.e. who is normally seen as “right�, who normally gets to talk, who is the victim, who is the oppressor, etc.). Being aware of these norms helps a facilitator to ensure that everyone has a fair chance to speak and to be heard in the dialogue. Work from a place of Socratic inquiry to discover rather than assume how these are at play in each dialogue.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
615
As you practice Disrupting Communication Patterns, you will see how crucial this is to creating a conversation that makes a difference to people’s lives.
616
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Remember—it can’t make a difference if it’s not different.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
617
As you do this, you will be asking people to engage with topics they may have never considered or topics they are afraid to examine.
618
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
And you will ask them to talk to each other in new ways.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
619
This often leads to Discomfort.
620
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
621
622
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Thankfully, Discomfort is another route toward Discovery (because individuals are more likely to seek new answers in this state).
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
623
But Discomfort can also lead to Fear.
624
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Of course, we don’t want people to retreat to Fear because Fear is a barrier to Discovery.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
625
626
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
But the presence of a trusted facilitator can help ease that Fear.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
627
That’s why part of a facilitator’s job is to earn trust and to build trust.
628
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Which requires you to trust Conflict and Discomfort (as you already do if you’ve developed the mindset of a facilitator).
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
629
But you will be challenged by participants many times. And if you don’t fundamentally trust these ideas, the individuals you are working with will not trust you.
630
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
Remember: If there’s not enough trust, there’s not enough room for Discovery.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
631
Wow
(Deep breath)
632
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
That was a lot to digest. And yes, we’re getting close to the end of this book.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
633
As you let the mindset and practices of a facilitator sink in, we hope you are feeling inspired to do this work in all of the places where it’s needed.
634
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
And as you prepare to step into this role, you are probably asking,
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
635
636
• Communication Practices of a Facilitator [Disrupting Communication Patterns]
“How can I tell if my facilitation is working?” Don’t worry—that’s where we’re headed next.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
637
Part Four Transformation and What’s Possible
640
• Transformation and What’s Possible
When we started this book, we invited you into a story focused on two powerful forces— the force of Conflict (that pushes for change) and the force of Collaboration (that pushes for stability).
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
641
We said that each force influences the shape of everything—from families to nationhood.
642
• Transformation and What’s Possible
What we didn’t say is that those forces also influence the shape of molecules, trees, solar systems... In other words—all living things.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
643
644
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Because every living thing needs both stability and change.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
645
646
• Transformation and What’s Possible
You probably noticed that the title of this book suggests that these two forces need to be transformed— presumably with the help of a trained facilitator.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
647
Did you notice that?
648
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Well, only someone (like you!) who has gotten this far into the book will learn our final—and hugely important—point:
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
649
650
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Our title is a misnomer. (It’s wrong or inaccurate.)
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
651
652
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Conflict and Collaboration
actually don’t need to be transformed.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
653
654
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Conflict and Collaboration simply need to exist. Just as they are. In dynamic balance.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
655
656
• Transformation and What’s Possible
We humans can’t prefer one over the other. And we can’t run away from either.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
657
We just need to Trust both forces, and to find ways to live in their continuous movement.
658
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Then these forces can work together as the partners that they are, rather than the opponents humans assume them to be. This provides the greatest balance and equity in our relationships.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
659
660
• Transformation and What’s Possible
When Conflict and Collaboration are living in partnership–neither force needs to change. Neither force needs to be transformed.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
661
When Conflict is doing its best work, it creates opportunities for Collaboration (because differences must be bridged).
662
• Transformation and What’s Possible
When Collaboration is doing its best work, it is open to Conflict (because incremental change is actually stabilizing).
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
663
664
• Transformation and What’s Possible
It is only when Conflict and Collaboration are free to exist together, in dynamic balance, that we see things like:
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
665
Thoughtful decisions
666
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
667
668
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Healthy disagreement
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
669
Creative negotiations
670
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
671
672
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Responsive solutions
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
673
Inclusive groups
674
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
675
676
• Transformation and What’s Possible
However, Combat and Conformity are another story.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
677
Combat and Conformity actually do need to be transformed— from their more extreme, unbending states into more moderate and responsive ones.
678
• Transformation and What’s Possible
And that is actually what you have been learning to do—to help people to shift away from Positions and Answers and to move towards Listening and Discovery.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
679
680
• Transformation and What’s Possible
You have been learning how to help humans to transform
Combat and Conformity.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
681
That was just too complicated to explain at the beginning of the book.
682
• Transformation and What’s Possible
So we saved it for you until now.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
683
684
• Transformation and What’s Possible
This is groundbreaking stuff. And, there’s one more question that we’re sure you have:
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
685
686
• Transformation and What’s Possible
How can a facilitator know transformation is happening?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
687
688
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Here are some ways:
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
689
TRUST grows (building confidence in a relationship)
EMPATHY arises (one can describe the world as someone else sees/experiences it)
RAPPORT expands (nurtures positive, cohesive interactions between people)
690
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
691
692
• Transformation and What’s Possible
PERSONAL STORIES are shared;
people are more candid and express their vulnerabilities
PARTICIPATION increases; inhibitions decrease
DISAGREEMENT is welcome and invited LISTENING improves (thus, creating more involvement and more views expressed)
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
693
CREATIVITY increases RISK TAKING occurs (there is enough trust to challenge ideas)
ENGAGEMENT increases INCLUSIVENESS increases
694
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
695
696
• Transformation and What’s Possible
In other words... Conformity is moving closer to Collaboration—Combat is moving closer to Conflict.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
697
698
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Overall, you will see less extreme positions, more aďŹƒrmation, and less hostility between divergent views, and...
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
699
700
• Transformation and What’s Possible
you will probably notice more... UNCERTAINTY.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
701
702
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Uncertainty means that new ideas and new thoughts are arising and gently destabilizing the previous certainty that was present in Combat or Conformity.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
703
704
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Uncertainty means that the “answers” that seemed so true, and so unquestionable, are actually being examined.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
705
It is in this uncertainty that people have the opportunity to Discover that certainty doesn’t hold up in the face of other competing certainties, and that certainty is limited.
706
• Transformation and What’s Possible
And it’s here that we get to encounter the more vital forces of Conflict and Collaboration—where certainty and uncertainty can exist together.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
707
708
• Transformation and What’s Possible
This opens the opportunity for all kinds of Discovery.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
709
710
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Can you see now how a trained facilitator knows they are transforming Combat into Conflict and Conformity into Collaboration?
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
711
Can you see why we need facilitators in the world as much as we need medical doctors?
712
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
713
714
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Like doctors, facilitators are essential to human health—to keeping the forces of Conflict and Collaboration alive, well, and in balance.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
715
716
• Transformation and What’s Possible
It’s a hard job. And great facilitators need lots of practice. A LIFETIME of practice. Really.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
717
718
• Transformation and What’s Possible
So this is the point where we end this book and where you take your part in this story through PRACTICE PRACTICE PRACTICE and
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
719
720
• Transformation and What’s Possible
DISCOVERY DISCOVERY DISCOVERY.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
721
722
• Transformation and What’s Possible
We invite you to join us in this important work. We are convinced that it’s worth it.
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
723
By now, we hope you are too.
724
• Transformation and What’s Possible
Transforming Conflict and Collaboration •
725
Essentials for Dialogue Facilitation
