Sites of the industrial revolution in the Meiji era 明治時代の産業革命の所 Example: Tomioka silk mill & associated facilities Tomioka seishijô 富岡製糸場, Gunma ken 群馬県 (UNESCO #1449) Seminar: Tourism in contemporary Japan WiSe 2022/23 Japanology, University of Cologne, Germany Thomas N. Schneider
Takayama-sha
Sericulture School Tajima Yahei Sericulture Farm Tomioka Silk Mill Arafune Cold Storage Tomioka Silk Mill & Sericulture Historical Timeline
Presentation content • What represents Japan’s industrial revolution? • Market timing & Trojan horse: silk supremacy • Location: Tomioka gov’t silk mill & associated sites • Genesis: industrial Japan & the European connection • Sericulture: spreading knowledge & innovation • Technological edge: research & development • Contested history: emancipation or subjugation? • Marketing success: brand & heritage preservation • Virtual tourism & crowdfunding Image: Hiroshige III (1843-1894) : Famous Views of Modern Tokyo: Opening celebration of Yaesu police dept. (1875)
st point of call: AI literature search (Yewno)
intersects
1
…no
2nd point of call: UNESCO world heritage convention
(pre-Meiji mining / proto-industrial)
(Meiji industrial heritage)
Note: The industrial revolution took place in Europe before Japan, so what was revolutionary to the Japanese, may not impress the European.
I.e.: since there is plenty authentic iron & coal heritage in Germany, why travel to Japan for it?
Well: it depends on who manages to preserve it.
UNESCO “world heritage” Inscription Criteria
(i) to represent a masterpiece of human creative genius;
(ii) to exhibit an important interchange of human values, over a span of time or within a cultural area of the world, on developments in architecture or technology, monumental arts, town-planning or landscape design;
(iii) to bear a unique or at least exceptional testimony to a cultural tradition or to a civilization which is living or which has disappeared;
(iv) to be an outstanding example of a type of building, architectural or technological ensemble or landscape which illustrates (a) significant stage(s) in human history;
(v) to be an outstanding example of a traditional human settlement, land-use, or sea-use which is representative of a culture (or cultures), or human interaction with the environment especially when it has become vulnerable under the impact of irreversible change;
(vi) to be directly or tangibly associated with events or living traditions, with ideas, or with beliefs, with artistic and literary works of outstanding universal significance. (this criterion should preferably be used in conjunction with other criteria);
(vii) to contain superlative natural phenomena or areas of exceptional natural beauty and aesthetic importance;
(viii) to be outstanding examples representing major stages of earth's history, including the record of life, significant on-going geological processes in the development of landforms, or significant geomorphic or physiographic features;
(ix) to be outstanding examples representing significant on-going ecological and biological processes in the evolution and development of terrestrial, fresh water, coastal and marine ecosystems and communities of plants and animals;
(x) to contain the most important and significant natural habitats for in-situ conservation of biological diversity, including those containing threatened species of outstanding universal value from the point of view of science or conservation
UNESCO Assessment #1449 (6 March 2014)
Mill
Associated Facilities
Tomioka Silk
&
• “Established in 1872 (Meiji 5) by the national government in the heart of Japan’s sericulture region, […] the mill is a prototypical example of the move to introduce advanced Western technology and factory systems during Japan’s early days of modernization.” • 1893: transfer to private ownership (initially Mitsui 三井) • 1909: Japan overtakes India to become the world’s largest silk producer • Post-WW2: production restart, increasing raw material imports • 1960’s: Japanese technology export of silk milling machinery • 1987: end of production in Tomioka “In 1862, raw silk and silkworm cocoons accounted for 86% of Japan's exports. However, soon after the Meiji restoration, overproduction, and the recovery of silk producing areas in Europe and China led to a drastic fall in raw silk prices.” Source: Wikipedia.
Fusatane 房種 (active 1854-1889) : Sericulture (1867)
Note: In contrast to Eri (Thai or “peace”) silkwhere silkworms are allowed to leave the cocoon - Mulberry silk worms are boiled prior to emerging from the cocoon (to prevent them breaking the continuous thread)
James Harrison Wilson Thompson (Mar 21, 1906 – Mar 26, 1967 disappeared) "almost singlehanded(ly) saved Thailand's vital silk industry from extinction" (Time Magazine)
>> video clip of a working silk mill <<
Disruptors: invention of new, synthetic fibres, e.g. Nylon-66 (DuPont, 1935), Nylon-6 (IG Farben/Toray, 1938)
道
project
製 糸
a national
~ 4 : 1 ~ 2.3 : 1
Cultural & economic exchange: From the West…. to Japan… to the world!
Tomioka Silk Mill Sites
Tomioka Silk Mill Sites
Tomioka Silk Mill:
115 years 1875 1908 1939 1986 size of site today: 55,391 ㎡
Tomioka’s “founding fathers” 田島弥平
Only traditional Japanese tools were used
First coal-fired steam (not water wheel) driven plant in Japan (1872)
otherwise: Q.E.D.! The flag must be in error (since it was the French)…
Clinic
Inspector’s house
Female dorm
Tajima Yahei’s “Sericulture Farm” 田島弥平旧宅
Note: the staggered roof allows for good ventilation
Tajima Yahei
“Sericulture Farm”
Innovation
Takayama Co. Sericulture School, Fujioka, Gunma Takayama-sha ato 高山社跡, 藤岡市, 群馬県 高山長五郎
清 温 育
seion iku
Disseminating Takayama’s teachings
Arafune-Azumaya 荒船・東谷 Cold Storage Facilities sanshu chozō sho ato 風穴蚕種貯蔵所跡 Increased yield two- to three-fold, rendered obsolete by mechanical refrigeration technology in mid 20th century
Arafune Cold Storage: “natural cooling effect”
years of
& Development)
100
R&D (Research
1960s - today: Technology export
Historical appraisal: A progressive mill…
Tomioka City's image character "Otomi-chan". Otomi-chan is a girl who was born in 2012 in the 140th anniversary of the founding of Tomioka Silk Mill, and has always been a 14-year-old girl.
The working environment at the Tomioka Silk Mill was progressive for its time. Brunat introduced eight-hour working days, Sunday holidays and ten-day holidays mid-year and at year-end. The workers were provided with uniforms, and as the prefectural governor, Katori Motohiko was enthusiastic on education, the women workers had access to an elementary school. However, worker turnover was high, as there was considerable social pressure against women working in a factory, and friction between women from different social classes forced to work side by side. Many workers left within three years of employment, and the need to keep training new worked added to the mill's expenses. Workers were graded according to their skill level, with a system of eight ranks introduced in 1873. Silk produced at the mill received a second place award at the 1873 Vienna World's Fair, and "Tomioka silk" became a brand name. Workers from Tomioka were also sent, or otherwise found employment at other privately owned silk mills which were subsequently built in Japan. (Source: Wikipedia)
(NHK 2017)
… leading to exploitation?
As the scale of production grew, demand for labour also increased. The number of women and male workers that came from wealthy families declined, [to be] replaced by [] young female workers from rural families. Most of the mill girls were the age of twelve to twenty, and they lived in dormitories in the nearby region. [15] [] The employers justified the low wages by providing training in silk production, which could be utilized even when they go back to their home prefectures to marry.
[] Working hours were repeatedly lengthened to increase production, [to] as much as eighteen hours per day during the peak period. Secondly, [the women] were not provided enough food to stay healthy, and [] not given enough meal breaks as they needed, to keep the machines working. Thirdly, the dormitory they lived in was very small and they had to sleep in a bed with many other workers []. Fourthly, they came to Tomioka mostly through recruiting agents, and only a small amount of the income went to the mill girls, employers or the agents would receive the majority of the income. Finally, the working conditions themselves were extremely unhealthy: [] the factory was always very humid and filled with dust. Hygiene facilities were inadequate []. Excessively long hours of work led to exhaustion, malnutrition, and illnesses such as tuberculosis. [17] To protest against [] sweat labour [], the first strike [in Japan] happened in Amemiya [Silk Mill, Kôfu City, Yamanashi ken] [18] in 1886 (Meiji 19) by [] female factory workers
[] In 1933, the Japanese government officially reported that the sanitary conditions of the Tomioka Silk Mill were particularly poor compared to other factories, and thus sicknesses and diseases among the workers were prevalent. In addition, Takase demonstrated that a large number of women even committed suicide due to the working conditions. [23] (Women in the Silk-reeling Industry at Tomioka Silk Mill – Digital Humanities and Japanese History (japanese-history.org)
[…]
Heritage preservation
Effect of UNESCO registration: A government/ public authority makes a commitment that it will work towards keeping up the maintenance. → Gift: The mill was gifted to the city of Tomioka by Katakura Co. in 2005. Restoration plans were drawn up and the works carried out with public funding, as well as private donations. → Benefit: Local businesses around the site (& the city tax office) benefit from an influx of visitors and work. The associated sites encourage (car) tourism and exploration of the surrounding area.
Marketing success?
“Since [the facility] was registered as a World Heritage Site in 2014, the number of visitors has increased rapidly. In most years, more than 1 million visitors visit annually, and it has become one of Gunma's leading tourist spots.” Source: https://www.asoview.com/note/1357/ (2014) (2021)(2005) Number of visitors: City Tourism Homepage
Going virtual?
Questions for debate
• Do you agree that the singular most representative example of Japan’s contribution to the industrial revolution of the world in the latter part of the 19th century (“Meiji period”) – hence worthy of UNESCO registration - was mass production and export of silk? Or can you think of other examples? • How do you explain – after initial success - the rapid and significant decline in visitor numbers to Tomiyoka silk mill after UNESCO registration? Should and can something be done to reverse this trend, and if so, what? • Is it more important to preserve and present a true record of (industrial) history than to maximize “story value” and “visitor experience” to generate revenues and employment opportunities in the present and for the future? Is there a conflict? Who is responsible and should pay for the maintenance?
UNESCO Inscription Criteria & #1449 Submission
UNESCO Assessment #1449 (6 March 2014)
Further links • UNESCO world heritage: https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1449 • Intro video (English): https://youtu.be/C8zFxUBv60I • Guided video (English/Japanese): https://youtu.be/2NumhK4iEMk • Homepage (Japanese): tomioka-silk.jp • NHK Movie "Red Collar - Tomioka Silk Mill Story": akaitasuki.com • Tomioka Silk Lovers on Facebook: 富岡製糸場を愛する会
Stätten der industriellen Revolution in der Meiji-Zeit 明治時代の産業革命の所 Beispiel: Tomioka Seidenspinnerei Tomioka seishijô 富岡製糸場, Gunma ken 群馬県 (UNESCO #1449) Seminar: Tourismus im gegenwärtigen Japan WiSe 2022/23 Japanologie, Uni Köln Thomas N. Schneider