CPL - November 2024

Page 1


inspiration for our company name: turning thermoforming into an ar t that demands real craftsmanship ”

Aside from IPL, Plastique A r t’s other main customer in the early days was Prevost Car – now known simply as Prevost – a manufacturer of touring coaches and bus shells for high-end motorhomes and specialty conversions, and which is also located in Sainte-Claire “They asked us to make interior plastic par ts for their buses, and this eventually led us to leave the sign and toothbr ush businesses to focus exclusively on thermoforming,” Baillargeon said

Baillargeon himself joined the company in 1998, and the succession to the third generation was underway “When I was in high school, I worked on the shop f loor during summers, but throughout university I wasn’t sure that I wanted to make it my career,” he said. “But I’ve always been interested in business, and my degree is in business administration, so I joined to become involved on the business side, enjoyed it, and stayed.” In 1999, Baillargeon began buying shares in the company. “By 2010, I was the sole owner, and that was when my father retired,” he said “I’ve been the president and CEO since 2006 ”

Thermoforming is a process that involves heating a plastic sheet and forming it to specific shapes using a vacuum and a mold The shaped plastic then gets cooled down and CNCtrimmed to result in the finished par t. The process can produce a wide range of products, from intricate medical devices to large automotive par ts to tr uly huge plastic projects – unlike most other plastic molding processes, which are limited to smaller items. At the same time, it’s relatively cost-effective due to the minimal waste produced and the low labour and tooling costs i nvolved. “T he g reatest econom ies i n t her mofor m i ng a re achieved at low to moderate volumes, usually 100 to 10,000 units per year depending on the par t size,” Baillargeon said “And the lower par t costs allow thermoforming to compete directly with fibreglass, wood, and metal fabrication while achieving higher production rates ” And nearly all types of resin are suitable for thermoforming, he added, including post-consumer plastics

:S XNTP RDPUHBD

Plastique A r t offers a range of services, beginning with par t design. “We have a team of exper ts that can recommend the best materials, processes, and tools,” Baillargeon said. “From there, our factor y offers vacuum, pressure, and twin-sheet thermoforming capabilities We cur rently have 5 thermoforming machines that can mold par ts up to 80 by 120 inches; and 6 CNC digital machining centres for cutting and trimming Finally, we offer value-added services like gluing, welding, product assembly, paint, and other finishing and decoration processes.”

Plastique A r t’s ther mofor m ing machines come pr ima r ily from one vendor “We selected one brand ten years ago that offered customized machines that we were able to modify for our own needs,” Baillargeon said And while the basic thermoforming process remains the same, he continued, the technology has definitely improved over the years, as the field has seen an infusion of advanced software that brings a new level of precision. “The machines themselves also have more sensors for better

heating and cooling control – giving us more uniform stretching of the sheet – which allows for more complex shapes and more consistent par ts,” he said “Generally, the European machines are more energy-efficient and have more advanced features than the Nor th American brands, but the Nor th American OEMs are star ting to catch up ”

Moreover, automation has been a game changer, including at Plastique A r t. Industr y-wide, some exper ts say, top speeds of thermoformers are being restricted by the ability to handle par ts at those speeds Which is where making the process faster and more consistent by employing robotic arms and automated workf low systems comes in “Twenty-five years ago, all our par ts were trimmed by hand,” Baillargeon said “We were one of the first thermoformers to embrace using CNC – which crossed over from the woodworking industr y – for par t trimming, and now almost 100 per cent of what we trim is CNC-trimmed with automation. Customers are always concerned about the accuracy of the trimming and the placement of any par t holes, and our CNC technology provides this It’s a big boost to our productivity and par t consistency, and it also frees our workers from these repetitive manual tasks, which can be unsafe if not done properly.”

In theor y, automating par t handling creates a gap in the inspection process traditionally done by operators In practice, this is augmented at Plastique A r t by using 3D laser scanners to validate the dimensions of the par t

S gd bnloYmx r okYms hm R Yhmsd BkYhqd* vhsg sgd 3* 1 / / rptYqd enns dwoYmrhnm Ys sno qhfgs-

FDS SHMF RL: PS

Another advancement at Plastique A r t is the integration of smar t technologies. “Beginning 10 years ago, we star ted connecting all of our machines so that we can monitor them in real time,” Baillargeon said “We’ve been on the smar t factor y journey for a while, and it’s not finished yet. Before thermoforming machines came with these connected technologies, we added them ourselves in-house ”

A big force driving the automation and smar t technologies trends – not just at Plastique A r t, not just in thermoforming, but across the entire plastics manufacturing sector – is the lack of skilled labour that’s impacting the ability to meet production output and deliver customer orders. And Plastique A r t isn’t immune “Finding skilled labour is tough, and we have training programs to school our new workers in-house,” Baillargeon said. “At a minimum, our new operators need to be good with a bandsaw, and beyond that we’ll train them to become skilled CNC operators With the automation we’ve added, we’ve made the operator’s job easier – nowadays, the engineering knowledge on the operator’s par t comes more from knowing how to use the controls and to set the recipes ”

Other facts on the ground, however, are different for thermoforming companies than for processors of other types of plastic

molding. “Thermoformers make small-scale production r uns of big par ts, which makes the par ts prohibitively expensive to ship over long distances, so there’s not much overseas, or even international, competition,” Baillargeon said. “At Plastique A r t, we’re not competing against China, Europe or the U.S.; our competition is local, mainly in Eastern Canada ” But at least that pool of competitors is stable “There are few, if any, star tups, and because of mergers and acquisitions – especially in the U.S. – there are probably fewer thermoforming shops today, by company name, than 20 years ago,” Baillargeon said

SGD PN: C : GD: C

According to Baillargeon, Plastique A r t’s 3-phase, $3-million investment is par t of the firm’s standardization and modernization strategy. “We want to maintain a machine park that incor porates the latest molding and cutting technologies,” he said “Standardization of the machine park will make it easier to train new employees and optimize working methods.”

The purchase of new equipment, meanwhile, will enable the company to smooth production, reduce deliver y times, and double its production capacity for large par ts up to two metres by three metres And the plant expansion represents an oppor tunity to optimize production f low, improve efficiency, and save storage space. “We’ll receive the new machines in late 2024,” Baillargeon said

Plastique A r t has doubled its revenues since 2021, Baillargeon said, and is now reaching the highest production levels in its histor y, with growing demand for large par ts in par ticular. But the firm still isn’t satisfied “We’re going after new markets and, backed up by our new investment, we think we have a real chance to grow our business – for example, by replacing metal or fibreglass in products like electric vehicle par ts,” he said “In some ways, thermoforming and fibreglass are similar processes, but typical thermoformed par ts may be as much as 30 per cent cheaper, on average, than similar fibreglass par ts, while also being lighter and more recyclable We’re also thinking about expor ting more into the U.S. We’re a third-generation company, but in some ways it feels like we’re just star ting ” B O I

In 2021, during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, Plastique A r t worked with supply chain par tners to produce a notable ther mofor med application that wound up winning the “Vacuum For ming –Gold” award from the Ther mofor ming Division of the Society of Plastics Engineers

Developed for a customer with an urgent order to supply 10,0 0 0 mechanical ventilators for hospitals across the countr y, Plastique A r t created an enclosure assembly of 8 ther mofor med par ts to house the ventilator. Custom colour sheets made from medica l-g rade ac r yl ic/p oly vi nyl ch lor ide wit h t wo colours were used, and assembly of the enclosure

was designed to minimize the attachment points By ma king the tools in-house and with a staff fully dedicated to the project, Plastique A r t was able to meet the lead time of 10 days for 11 devices ready for cer tification by Health Canada.

After final approval of the device – and just 142 days since the star t of the project – mass production was under way, and Plastique A r t made the 10,0 0 0 devices in under 16 weeks, using multi-cavity, temperature controlled aluminum molds for all par ts (For perspective, the average time for a medical device to go from conception to production, under nor mal conditions, is at least 18 months )

P : OHC CD U DI NOLDM S NE : M :V: P C ,V HMMHMF U DM

process by using feedback a nd feedforwa rd mecha n isms, such as neu ra l networks, f uzzy logic, a nd rein forcement lea r n ing,” sa id Kaveh Ka kaei Nezhad, a n A I sof t wa re develop er wit h Rega l Pet rochem ica l “A I ca n a lso help optim ize the design a nd con f igu ration of the ext r uder, such as the screw geomet r y, ba r rel length, a nd die shape, to ach ieve the desi red product cha racter istics ” A nd by st rea m lin ing a nd ma inta in ing tight cont rol over the enti re production process, A I cont r ibutes to shor tened timeto -ma rket for new products, wh ich is pa r ticula rly cr ucia l in indust r ies where rapid in novation a nd quick responses to ma rket dema nds a re pa ra mount.

Second, A I-powered qua lit y cont rol systems offer a proactive approach to identif ying defects in rea l time by spott i ng t h e mom ent a p r o c e ss st r ays, expla i n i ng why, a nd of fer i ng si mple step -by-step inst r uctions for put ting it back. “A I ca n help adjust the process pa ra meters in rea l time according to the cha nges in the mater ia l proper ties, product sp e ci f icat ions, a nd envi ron ment a l c ond it ion s,” Nez ha d c ont i nue d. T h is mea ns t hat problems ca n be recti f ied b efore t hey esca lat e, m i n i m i z i ng t he ne e d for cost ly rework a nd ensu r i ng h igher qua lity out puts, wh ile a lso m in im izing mater ia l wastage A nd these savings a ren’t just theoretica l. “One of ou r customers has reduced its scrap by 23 per cent, down to less tha n 1 per cent, by using A I- d r iven insights,” sa id Da n Ba rlow, sen ior product ma nager, cont rols with M ilacron A nd K raussMa ffei’s new processSuppor t tech nology, pa r t of its socia l P roduction plat for m, uses A I to help identi f y deviations i n production p ro c esses a nd c om mu n icat e t hem to operators. K raussMa ffei off icia ls say the compa ny has developed its own complex a lgor it h m for ea rly detection of t hese deviat ions, wit h t he goa l of re duci ng scrap A nd reducing scrap a lso mea ns r e duc i ng u n ne c essa r y ene rg y usage, wh ich cont r ibutes to susta inabilit y goa ls a nd results in substa ntia l cost savings over the long ter m

T h i rd, a nd related, A I’s dat a collection capabilities – including dat a a na lysis f rom sensors embedded in mach in-

Ax kdudpIfhmf .B Im dwsptrhnm opnbdrrnp bIm ehmd,stmd opnctbshnm oIpIldsdpr khid sdlodpIstpd opdrrtpd roddc Imc eddc pIsd hm pdIk shld sn noshlhyd pdrntpbd IkknbIshnm Imc dmgImbd nudpIkk opnctbshuhs x-

er y, combi ne d wit h h istor ica l re cords – ca n be used for predictive ma intena nce by sp ot t i ng a nom a l ies t hat i nd icat e potentia l equipment fa ilu res before they happen, a llowing the ext r uder to schedu le m a i nt ena nc e p roa ct ively “ T hes e forecasting capabilities ca n keep ext r usion lines up a nd r un n ing, preventing exp ensive u npla n ne d downt i me,” Ba rlow sa id “For exa mple, there’s a n A I comp onent to M i lac ron’s M-Powere d, ou r I ndust r ia l I nter net of T h ings digita l plat for m for pre d ict ive a na ly t ics, t hat p r ov id e s p e r fo r m a n c e i m p r ove m e nt insights ” Even bet ter, the ext r uder ca n usua lly t roubleshoot with a n A I solution f rom a nywhere in the world.

As to how much of an extr uder’s operation the processor wants to hand off to AI, well, that’s up to each shop. “A lot depends on your organization’s comfor t level, but in general, AI is extremely valuable when decisions involve more data or variables than humans can manage,” Barlow continued “For example, it can be configured to war n an operator when an unsafe condition is detected or perfor m an emergency shutdown on its own Each organization sets its own parameters ”

Vi r t u a l ly a l l new ext r ud er s c ome with A I capabilities, a nd older mach ines ca n of ten be ret rof it ted with m in ima l in f rast r uct u res, a lthough it depends on severa l pa ra meters. “A I requi res a lot more computing power because it’s ha ndl i ng exponentia l ly la rger a mounts of data,” Ba rlow sa id. “T he mach ine’s processor speed, CPU, memor y, a nd other related factors will t ypica lly deter m ine its suitability for a n A I upg rade.”

: I I : ANT S C:S:

At the hea r t of A I lies dat a, wh ich is the f uel that powers a lgor ith ms, t ra ins models, a nd d r ives insights “Good data is

the foundation that a ll A I systems a re built on,” sa id Derek Moeller, the founder a nd president of Cogn itionWorks, a compa ny that designs nat u ra l la nguage A I systems for ma nufact u rers. “H igh- qua lit y, releva nt, a nd wel l- orga n i z e d d at a enables A I a lgor ith ms to lea r n pat ter ns, ma ke predictions, a nd generate va luable i nsights wit h accu racy a nd precision ” Without good data, A I systems ca n produce un reliable results, leading to f lawed de cisions a nd sub opt i ma l out comes –a nd if there’s a lim itation at present as to how much improvement A I ca n ma ke to a n ext r usion ap pl icat ion, it r evolves a round data ava ilability a nd qua lity “A I requi res a la rge a mount of data to lea r n a nd i mprove it s p er for ma nc e, but t he data may not be ava ilable or reliable due to the lack of sensors, com mun ication, a nd stor age syst em s i n t he ext r uder,” Kaveh Ka kaei Nezhad sa id “T he data may a lso be noisy, incomplete, or inconsistent due to the va r iability a nd uncerta inty of the ext r usion process ” T hese a reas a re works in prog ress, a nd it’s the reason why a n ext r uder ca n’t simply plug a ny indust r ia l A I model into its applications “T he A I solution has to be t ra ined by a tea m of h igh ly qua l i f ie d hu ma n exper ts who k now the process inside a nd out,” sa id Da n Ba rlow

A key to get ting th is good dat a – a nd a lso to understa nding how A I ca n benef it ext r usion in genera l – involves ta k ing a deeper dive into two specia lized classes of A I, both of wh ich represent the newest a nd most h igh ly dyna m ic doma ins with in t he A I f ield: la rge la ng u age mo d els ( LLMs) a nd generative A I. T he key difference between LLMs a nd generative A I lies in thei r scope LLMs constit ute a specif ic categor y of A I models with a specia lized focus on text-based data, by having been fed enough exa mples to be able to recogn ize a nd inter pret huma n la ng uage. Ma ny LLMs a re t ra i ned on data that’s been gathered f rom the I nternet huge sets of data consisting of t hou sa nd s or m i l l ion s of g iga by t es’ wor t h of t ext, henc e t he na m eword “la rge” – a nd they excel at predicting what comes next in a given sequence of word s or gener at i ng t ext ba se d on a p r om p t G e n e r a t ive A I, m e a nwh i le,

1. Narrow or Weak AI:

Nar row AI is designed to perfor m a specific task or a set of closely related tasks. It excels in its predefined domain but lacks the ability to generalize its intelligence beyond that scope Examples include vir tual personal assistants like Siri or Alexa, which are adept at understanding and responding to specific voice com mands.

2. General or Strong AI:

General AI represents a level of intelligence where machines possess the ability to understand, lear n, and apply knowledge across a wide range of tasks, a kin to human intelligence Achieving general AI remains a significant challenge, and cur rent AI systems are mostly categorized under nar row AI.

3. Machine Learning:

Machine lear ning is a subset of AI that focuses on enabling machines to lear n from data without explicit program ming. Machine lear ning algorithms use patter ns and statistical techniques to improve their perfor mance over time This is the technology behind recom mendation systems and natural language processing

4. Deep Learning:

Deep lear ning is a specialized for m of machine lear ning that involves neural networks with multiple layers (deep neural networks). Mimicking the str ucture of the human brain, deep lear ning excels in tasks like image and speech recognition. It has fueled advancements in facial recognition technology, autonomous vehicles, and more

5. Reinforcement Learning:

Reinforcement lear ning involves training machines to ma ke sequences of decisions by rewarding desired behaviours and penalizing undesirable ones This type of AI is often used in gaming, robotics, and optimization problems, allowing machines to lear n th rough trial and er ror

6. Natural Language Processing (NLP):

N LP enables machines to understand, inter pret, and generate human language Applications include language translation, sentiment analysis, and chatbots N LP is integral to ma king AI systems more accessible and interactive for users.

Source: RJG Inc S X ODR NE : H9 : ADFHMMDP&R FTHCD

i ntel lect ua l prop er t y t hef t, comprom isi ng t he comp et it ive edge of ma nu fact u ri ng busi nesses W h ich is why it’s i mport a nt to choose t he r ight A I model, wit h d at a secu r it y i n place, before goi ng down t he A I road To begi n, avoid usi ng ChatGP T – t he A I model t hat’s most fa m i l ia r to most p eople – i n a ma nu fact u r i ng sett i ng A nd not just be cause cybercr i m ina ls const a ntly se ek to exploit v ul nerab i l it ie s i n C h a t G P T a n d o t h e r A I chatbots i n order to ga i n u naut hor ized access to sensit ive i n for mat ion, but a lso because a ny t h i ng put i nto t he ChatGP T plat for m r u ns t he r isk of be com i ng publ ic a nd could be used to t ra i n its A I –wh ich is why ele ct ron ics gia nt Sa msu ng, for one, cla mp ed down on use of t he chatbot ea rl ier t h is yea r “ T he r isk is t hat, u n less t here’s a n A I a lter nat ive, a you ng work force wi l l use ChatGP T as a default because t hat’s what t hey’re used to,” D erek Mo el ler sa id “A bet ter opt ion, because it removes t h is tempt at ion, is for a n ext r usion compa ny to for mulate its own generat ive A I st rateg y a nd br i ng i n a tool where its i n for mat ion is se cu re a nd seg mente d, wit h no possibi l it y of i n for m a t ion b ei ng sh a r e d, or le a ke d, exter na l ly.” A nd t he good news is t hat d a t a s e cu r it y a nd p r iva cy a r e m o r e secu re now t ha n even a few shor t yea rs a go “ C u r r e n t d a t a p r o t e c t io n h a s become fa r more robust,” sa id Da n Ba rlow

T here’s a lso some concer n about a lack of t ra nspa rency, since some A I a lgor ith ms – pa r ticula rly deep lea r n ing models – a re opaque in thei r decision-ma k ing processes. T h is lack of t ra nspa rency ca n ma ke it diff icult to understa nd how A I systems a r r ive at thei r conclusions, some exper ts say, potentia lly leading to dist r ust a mong workers a nd sta keholders.

S GD MD V MNP L : I

T he A I mo dels for ma nu fact u r i ng a re developi ng fa st, a nd it’s ha rd to pre d ict where t he t e ch nolog y wi l l go But you ca n b et t hat so - ca l le d A I agent s wi l l have a role Autonomous i nt el l igent syst em s desig ne d to p er for m sp e ci f ic t a sk s wit hout hu ma n i nt er vent ion, A I agent s a re p owere d by mach i ne lea r n i ng a nd rea l-t i me d at a a na ly t ics to f u nct ion a s

vi r t ua l a ssist a nt s a nd – i n a ma nu fact u ri ng set t i ng – cou ld b e even more ef fe ct ive t ha n cu r rent A I t e ch nolog ies at such t a sk s a s opt i m i z i ng pro duct ion sche du l e s, e n h a n c i n g q u a l it y c o n t r ol by d e t e c t i ng d efe c t s e a rly, st r e a m l i n i ng pro c esses to re duc e op er at iona l cost s, a nd ident i f yi ng e qu ipment brea kdow ns b efo r e t h ey o c cu r “O n e of t h e c o r e st reng t hs of A I agent s is t hei r ad apt ive nat u re a nd cont i nuous i mprovement –by lever ag i ng L L Ms, A I agent s ref i ne t hei r capabi l it ies t h roug h ongoi ng i nt era c t i o n s, g r a d u a l ly b e c o m i n g m o r e s o p h i s t i c a t e d a n d ef fe c t ive,” D e r e k Mo el ler sa id “A I agent s wi l l b e much more comprehensive a nd complet e t ha n t h e A I m o d el s ava i l a ble t o d ay, a n d t hey’l l b e come pro duct i z e d i n 2 025 ”

But for ext r uders, t he t a keaway f rom LLMs, generat ive A I, A I agents – a nd ot her developments t hat no one ca n se e com i ng – is t hat t he A I gen ie is t r uly out of t he bot tle, a nd you ig nore it at you r compa ny’s p er i l “A I is a t ra nsfor mat ive, fou nd at iona l new te ch nolog y – just l i ke t he I nter net was 30 yea rs ago – a nd a lot of p eople a re st i l l g rappl i ng wit h it, a nd w it h t h e id e a t h a t we’ve c r e a t e d a mach i ne t hat ca n out p er for m hu ma ns on some cog n it ive levels, wh ich has never b e en ava i la ble b efor e,” Mo el le r sa id “But it’s not somet h i ng you buy just to che ck t he ‘A I’ box a nd t hen forget about; it’s a new way of r u n n i ng a busi ness, where you have hu ma n-level cog n it ion ava i lable at a ny t i me. Even t hough t he i ndust r y hasn’t had much t i me yet to f igu re out how to use it f ul ly, t he ext r usion compa n ies t hat a re A I-for wa rd have a good cha nce of pul l i ng a head, a nd t hose t hat wa it 10 yea rs for t he dust to set tle wi l l get lef t beh i nd ”

A I isn’t just com ing, it’s a l ready here, a nd it’s on ly going to become a bigger forc e i n ext r usion goi ng for wa rd O n offer is the ability of mach ines to automate t asks with no huma n inter vention wh en m a nu fa c t u r i ng la b ou r c a n b e exceedingly ha rd to f ind, t ra in, a nd keep; when mach ine uptime a nd optim ization is more c r ucia l t ha n ever; a nd where pro duct qua l it y a nd consist ency is a n absolute must. It a lso gives businesses the agilit y to quick ly revise production pla ns

or i m m e d iat ely a djust m at er ia l f low based on schedule or product cha nges

A nd t h is is on ly t h e b eg i n n i ng

W hereas the cu r rent tech nology sees A I being utilized on discrete pieces of ext r usion equipment, it’s not too fa r-fetched to envision A I- endowed ext r uders as pa r t of a n intercon nected pla nt that sequences a nd cont rols multiple mach ines

A ny ta kers?

B O I

Mdawaihmf lRaghmdr sdagmninfhdr Rmc chfhsRi rnitshnmr epnl AMAE. fhud oiRrsha R mdv ihed, :wbid Tesdq bwbid. Tmnsgdq ihed- Fgdw sqTmrenql yvTrsdfi hmsn T uTitTaid qdrntqbd- Cmdqfw rTuhmf de“bhdms Tmc rlTqs- Eqnl vTrsd sn uTitd- Eqnl sqTrg sn sqdTrtqd- Enq qdbwbidc odiidsr ne rsTaid Tmc qdihTaid ptTihsw- Enq T bhqbtiTq dbnmnlw sgTs hr rtrsThmTaid Tmc. oqn“sTaid enq wnt-

O C RLTO C I ER S

I q Zt r r,LZe e dh B nq o- ’ E knqdmbd+ Ix-(: v v v-j qYtrrlYe edh-bnl: 7 4 8 17 2 / 1 / /

LhkZbq nm K KB ’ A Ys YuhY+ Nghn(: v v v-lhkYbqnm-bnl: 402 4 2 5 1 /62

PdfZk Od s q nbgdlhbZk B n- ’ L YgrgYgq+ I gtydrs Ym+ HqYm(: v v v-qdfYkodsqn-bnl: )8 7 ’20( 2 5 2 / 4 7 40

dqdlT-bnl

IN YOUR OWN HANDS

Untq okYrshbr oqnbdrrhmf rgno gYr

sgd qhfgs rgqdccdqr Ymc.nq fqYmtkY snqr hm okYbd* bgdbjhmf Ykk sgd anwdr enq sgd Y ookhbY shnmr*

lY sdqhYkr* eddchmf ldsgncr* oqnctbsr* chldmrhnmr* bY oYbhshdr*

Ymc rbqddm rhydr- Ats tmenqbdc dqqnqr bYm rshkk jddo xnt eqnl qdbkYhlhmf xntq rbqY o Yr deehbhdmskx Yr onrrhakd-

Aw LZpi Rsdogdm dchsnp

Rhe ultimate sin of any tennis player is the un forced er ror – the lost point that’s entirely because of the player’s own blunder

And there’s a parallel when it comes to size reduction in the plastics indust r y. Unlike primar y machiner y like injection molding machines and extr uders, sh redders a nd g ra nulators don’t a lways get much attention from processors unless t here’s a problem A nd it’s probably caused by the fact that – unlike with recyclers, for whom size reduction is the prime directive – size reduction for processors can seem secondar y to the act of ma king par ts.

But it shouldn’t be treated as an afterthought Waste materials generated can be significant, as ever y f loor manager knows, and reclaimed star t-up waste and imperfect products have real value: For many molders, almost 80 per cent of the par t cost is represented by the material, a nd using clea n production waste that matches the new or virgin material being processed is a real benefit. And it beats the alter native of letting these valuable

byproducts go to waste in a landfill, outside the recycle loop.

T he fi rst step in the size reduction jour ney is working with an OEM or vendor to get the right size of equipment, ta king into account the application, material, fe ed i ng met hod, product, d i mensions, capacit y, a nd screen size Second, it’s impor tant to have the unit ar rive undamaged and then properly installed – if possible, i n a wel l-venti lated position to ensure heat dissipation. But even if all these boxes have been checked, the processor still isn’t home free There’s no shor tage of mista kes that operators and other shop f loor staff can ma ke on even the best-designed size reduction system Here’s a look at t he most com mon unforced er rors and how to avoid ma king them

FHU D XNTP AI : CDR : M DCFD

Here’s the big reveal, up front: Lack of preventive maintenance is the root cause of most of t hese problems. Neglected maintenance can result in a range of issues that not only affect the machine’s effi-

ciency, but also impact the quality of the g ra nulate produced. A nd vi r t ua lly a ll OEMs agree that dull blades are by far the most com mon problem in granulators –and probably the most avoidable “Blades are the highest wearing item on a granulator, and too many customers are letting them get too dull, which also causes the knife gap to open up too far,” said Joe Platek, director of sales with ACS Group “Or they’re not aware of knives that are nicked or chipped.” Regularly checking for blade damage and shar pening, cleaning, and changing the knives when necessar y prevents increased motor amperage, material jams, and excessive noise and vibrations; a nd cr ucially, it ensures an even, unifor m granulate size that matches the new or vi rgin mater ial being processed

Granulator knives should be inspected for damage and wear, and either shar pened or replaced when necessa r y; but exactly how often depends on different factors. “Some customers need to change the knives ever y five to seven days while others can go for up to six months to one

year, depending on how much the granulator is processing high volumes of mater ia ls, t he geomet r y of t he basic pa r t, screen size, temperature in the cutting chamber, and the material type – abrasive or glass-f illed mater ia ls a re obviously ver y hard on knives, for example,” said E J Stratman, national sales director with Zer ma America. “If you check knives as par t of a regular maintenance schedule, it will soon become clea r how often the blades need to be shar pened or replaced.” But it’s never been an exact science, which is why preventive ma i ntena nce is so impor tant “By the time you can see or hear the signs of degraded granulator perfor mance you’re usually past the point where knife maintenance was needed,” said Dave Miller, general manager, size reduction with Conair Group

T he da mage done is f u r t her compounded by the fact that the longer the processor waits, and the more the blades wea r down bet we en sha r p en i ngs, t he shor ter the blade’s lifespan. “Ever y blade has a f i xed number of resha r pen i ngs before it has to be th rown out,” said Mike

Cy r, president of Rotog ra n. “I f you shar pen them diligently, you can get more reshar pening cycles removing less material each time, which extends blade life a nd ulti mately gives a bet ter qua l it y regrind ” An aspect of knife replacement that often gets overlooked, Cyr continued, is adhering to proper torque specifications and using proper bolt torquing technique when tighten ing t he blades Fasten ing bolts according to “feel” without the correct tools is a ver y uncer tain way to do it, OEMs war n “The bolts have to be torqued properly so they can hold the knives on both the rotor and in the chamber,” Cyr said “Bolts that are too tight can fail, causing the head to pop off; and bolts that are too loose allow the blade to chatter and eventually fracture, causing damage to the granulator rotor, screen, and chamb er.” W h ich is why a n exp er ience d mechanic always uses a torque wrench as one of his indispensable tools

RG : PO OP :BSHBD

W hen it comes to blade shar pening, carefully follow the shar pening instr uctions in the operating manual. And it’s a mista ke to shar pen just the knife that’s the most wor n. “T he k n ives should a lways be shar pened all at the same time to maint a i n tight tolera nces,” Cyr conti nued “Knives that a re mismatched in height and weight will disturb the dynamic balance of the rotor, which can result in a bea r i ng fa i lu re ” A nd when replaci ng knives, keep the concept of tolerance – the decisive factor for new and sha r pened blade width – in mind as well “We recom mend that knives are replaced in sets to ensure that the k nife-to -k nife tolerances are accurate,” said Denis Metral, inter national granulators sales manager with Wittmann.

Also when replacing knives, beware of low- qu a l it y subst it ut es “L ow- qu a l it y replacement knives may brea k off, causi ng more issues,” sa id Jeremy Boggs, national sales manager with Weima The OEM will have provided original knives manufactured from high-quality steel –typically made from D2 steel at a minimum, and to dimensional tolerances that meet or exceed the needs of a customer’s application – so stick with the OEM as the

knife source. “It’s com mon for an OEM to supply a spare set of replacement knives with a new granulator, and they’ll supply the best-quality replacement knives going forward,” said Mike Cyr. So, have a spare set of rotor blades available on the shelf for each granulator to prevent extended downtime while waiting for blades to be reworked or replaced A nd a lthough it took a while, the value of knife maintenance is a message that seems finally to be getting th rough “Although hardly anyone changes out the knives often enough, more shops seem to be doing regular maintenance than in the past,” said Bob Har rison, product manager, size reduction with Piovan UnaDyn. “I thin k process engineers are realizing that processing is better with good quality regrind ”

With sh redders, blade wear is an issue, albeit a smaller one. “Sh redder blades are usually built ver y tough to withstand highi nt ensit y work i ng envi ron ment s, a nd t hey’re a lso i nexp ensive a nd easy to replace, so wear and damage aren’t as big a concer n,” said Greg Parent, the Canadia n sa les represent ative for Vecopla n. The big oversight being made with sh redder blades, Parent continued, is to rotate and change the cutters on a regular basis while forgetting about, or ignoring, the counter knives “This is a com mon er ror, resulting in low th roughput, dust, or thinwall material getting pulled th rough the counter knives and between the rotor and the screen,” he said And while it’s tr ue that counter knives last longer than cutters – usua lly up to one-a nd-a-ha lf to two times longer, Parent said – and therefore don’t have to be changed as often, the difference in th roughput between dull and sha r p counter k nives is night and day “W hen a processor that’s never changed the counter knives finally does so, they usually say the sh redder r uns like a new machine,” Parent said But they also must be replaced wit h some consideration. “Many companies sell cutters and counter knives, but they’re not always high-quality – even if the type of steel is the same, the hardness level may be significantly different, either too hard or too soft,” Parent said. “There’s a sweet spot with steel hardness, based on the application, that customers don’t always appreciate ”

L :HM SDM : MBD E:HIR

With granulators in pa r ticula r, another area of neglect is screens, which play a cr itical role in sepa rating the cor rectly sized granulate from larger pieces. Regularly inspecting, cleaning, and rotating the screen helps prevent build-up and clogging, which can reduce th roughput and damage the machine “The screen itself can also wear down; the small circular holes in the screen can eventually become la rger, a l lowi ng bigger, non-u n i for m pieces of plastic to fall th rough, and the quality of the regrind will be affected,” said Denis Metral. “Rotate the screen regularly to minimize wear and tear and look at the screen holes – if they’re beginning to look pear-shaped, it’s probably time to replace the screen ”

For sh redders, meanwhile, impor tant components that often get overlooked by maintenance staff include the guide rail, which keeps the ram moving in the right direction and prevents it from lifting; and the spring-loaded wipers, which seal the ram on all four sides “Both components should be checked at least annually, but they often get forgotten,” said Greg Parent “And the sh redder drive shaft, which is constantly in use, has to be monitored as well.” And don’t forget the gearbox, which is another impor tant sh redder component “We recom mend check ing and changing the oil in the gearbox of the sh redder as per our provided maintenance schedule, but customers don’t always do that,” said E. J. Stratman.

Issues wit h negl igent ma i ntena nce aren’t new, of course “In my 18 years of experience, most size reduction problems boil down to failing to perfor m regular scheduled preventive maintenance,” said Jeremy Boggs But it’s probably safe to say the problem has been aggravated by sta ff ing shor tages, a nd h igh t u r novers, car r ying over from the COVID-19 pandemic. With the result that the cream of the employee crop usually works in production, not maintenance “Due to today’s di ff icult y i n f i ndi ng qua l i f ied ser vice technicians, sometimes untrained people fill in when trouble suddenly arises, and they can ma ke unforeseen mista kes,” said Mike Cyr. Here’s one solution: Have the maintenance crew videotape the session

B ntmsdq j mhudr Ymc bts sdq r nm Y rgqdccdq-

when an OEM representative first trains the staff after an installation. “We suggest that our customers film us as we train the staff on a newly installed sh redder,” said E. J. Stratman. “We’ll wal k a round the machine and show them the grease points, where the gearboxes are, the process for changing knives, et cetera, and they can then show that video to any new workers.”

EDDCHMF SHLD

Other size reduction er rors have nothing to do with neglected maintenance, beginning with feeding Or more specifically when it comes to granulators, overfeeding and shock loading. First, many processors seemingly tr y to destroy their granulator not long after receiving it, in the name of “testing the limits” of what the capacity of the granulator really is This should be avoided Second, operators can simply get careless about the rate of feeding a granulator “Some operators dump too much mater ia l i nto t he g ra nu lator b e cause they’re in a hur r y or distracted,” said Jim Hoffman, president of Rapid Granulator This causes the granulator to approach or exceed the maximum amp load capacity of the drive motor and simply jam or stop working – and even if the granulator can keep up, OEMs say, the pneumatic evacuation system for the reg r ind may not, because it was sized for the application / th roughput required and not for the capacity of the machine. “Another problem with accumulating scrap in a box or a tote and then just dumping it in is that anything from around the area can be in there as contamination – including nippers, razor blades f rom pa r t t r im m ing, a nd loose hardware – that can damage the machine,” Hoffman continued. The solution is to automatically meter-feed the granulator,

either with a robot or a conveyor. A nd t h i rd, over feeding happens by accident – a granulator that works well in one appl icat ion of ten won’t work i n another, as when an existing granulator is wheeled across the shop f loor to perfor m its duties for a different par t or job where the materials and th roughput are different And in addition to overfeeding, this can cause other perfor mance issues “If you select a machine to grind PET [polyet hylene t erepht ha lat e] prefor m s, for example, and then move that granulator down the line, to where you’re generating PET bottle scrap, you may find the tangential chamber is too nar row,” said Dave M i l ler. “A nd because t he bot tle wa l l material is much lighter and less dense, it’s not going to fall as easily th rough the screen to the discharge bin and is also going to overf low that bin much more quickly ”

Moving a granulator also car ries other r isks: cables and connectors can come loose, or the unit can even be physically damaged “We’ve seen situations where forklift operators moving larger granulators have accidenta lly backed into the blower discharge system or hit the tips of the forks into the unit when tr ying to lift it,” said E. J. Stratman.

Finally, operators can also ma ke mista kes at the back end of the granulation process. “W hat I often see is the blower system filling up the gaylord or supersack and it’s not changed out and the material backs all the way up th rough the cyclone, piping, a nd event ua lly the g ra nulator,” said Bob Har rison “We advocate dual fill stations with automatic switchover using paddle-type level indicators in the ‘Y’ pipe feeding the collection bin An alar m can be triggered to aler t an operator to change the first bag or gaylord.” And a simple airf low switch located in the evacuation line can easily set off an alar m indicating an evacuation failure for an assor tment of reasons, Mike Cyr added W hen it comes to sh redders, meanwhile, operators tend to underfeed them. “It’s a com mon mista ke and is usually caused by meter-feeding, which is inefficient with a sh redder unless it’s kept at least half-full to maintain pressure on the ram,” said Greg Parent “The best way to

WASTE NOT, WANT NOT

; mdv qdrdYqbg oqnidbs hr stqmhmf ennc vYrsd hmsn ahncdfqYcYakd okYrshb-

Aw LZpi Rsdogdm dchsnp

Cx t r a o r d i n a r y a m o u nt s of e n e rg y, water, a nd capita l a re put into food systems th roughout the world – a nd fa r too much of that is wasted Globa lly, a n estimated one-th i rd of a ll the food that’s produced ends up in la ndf ills; a nd in Ca nada it’s even worse, with approximately 58 per cent of the food we produce ultimately going to la ndf ills

A ll of wh ich begs the question: W hat if there was a way to conver t th is wasted food into someth ing that people ca n use ever y day?

Resea rchers at Vi rgin ia Tech’s College of Ag r icult u re a nd Life Sciences, in Blacksbu rg, Va., a re at tempting to do just t hat by developi ng bio deg rad able bioplastics f rom food waste to give those mater ia ls a new a nd usef ul life.

Sp e ci f ica l ly, t he proje ct t ack les t he cha l lenge of o c ea n ic pla st ic p ol lut ion

t hat’s b e com i ng even more p reva lent with m icroplastics – def ined as plastic debr is that a re less tha n 5 m illimet res in length, that result f rom both com mercia l product development a nd the brea kdown of la rger plastics; a nd wh ich a re estimated by agencies such as t he World Wildlife Fund to effect more tha n 80 per cent of a ll ma r ine species, pr ima r ily by inadver tently swa llowing the tiny pa r ticles

Because they ca n quick ly biodeg rade in sea water, the Vi rgin ia Tech bioplastics have the potentia l to reduce the effect of pollution on ma r ine life across the globe. “By creating cost- effective biopla st ics t hat nat u ra l ly de comp ose, we ca n reduce plastic pollution on la nd a nd in ocea ns a nd add ress sign if ica nt issues such as g reen house gas em issions a nd e conom ic losses a sso ciat e d wit h fo o d

waste,” sa id lead resea rcher Z h iw u Wa ng, assista nt professor in the Depa r tment of Biolog ic a l Syst em s E ng i ne e r i ng a nd di rector of the Center for Applied Water Resea rch a nd I n novation

OPNU HMF H S NT S

Sa id to be the f i rst of its k ind, the pilot project will develop a nd demonst rate a n a ffordable modula r bioprocessing system t o p r o duc e bio d eg r a d able biopla st ics f rom food waste Resea rchers will ha rness m ic ro orga n ism s to c onver t fo o d waste into fats, wh ich a re then processed i nto bioplast ics T h is pro cess, a k i n to fer ment ation in m icrobrewer ies, ensu res that the produced bioplastics ca n be easi ly comp ost e d, m it igat i ng a ny ma r i ne pollution. T he project a ims to demonst rate t he feasibilit y a nd sca labilit y of t h i s bio p r o c e s si ng syst e m o n b o

UNIVERSIT Y OF WATERLOO VS. MICROPL ASTICS

QdrdYqbgdqr Y s sgd NmsYqhn tmhudqrhsx Yqd trhmf 2C hlY fhmf sdbgmnknf x sn fYhm mdv hmrhfgsr hmsn gn v lhbqnokYrshbr cdfqYcd* kdYchmf sn onsdmshYk YcuYmbdldmsr hm okYrshb vYrsd qdbxbkhmfAw LZpi Rsdogdm dchsnp

Oesea rchers at the Un iversit y of Waterloo ( U W ), in Waterloo, Ont , m ight be on the cusp of solving a ver y big waste problem that involves ver y sma ll pieces of plastic M icroplastics a nd na noplastics – pa r ticles t hat come f rom t he brea kdown of la rger plastic items – a re cha llenging to decompose sa fely I nstead, by in f ilt rating ter rest r ia l, aquatic, a nd even a t m o s p h e r ic e c o syst e m s, t h ey p o s e t h reat s to wi ld l i fe a nd p ot ent ia l ly to hu m a n he a lt h Obser v i ng a nd u nd ersta nding the specif ics of how m icroplastics f unction a nd how they brea k down a re key to erad icat i ng t hem f rom t he envi ron ment, but scient ist s t he world over have long st r uggled to understa nd the exact process of how these pa r ticles deg rade – pa r ticula rly on the m icro a nd na nosca le levels – a nd th is has ha mpered effor ts to m itigate t hei r envi ron ment a l impact Traditiona l 2D m icroscopy, sim ila r to medica l X-rays, has been used to st udy m ic ropla st ic deg r a d at ion, but it provides on ly lim ited in for mation due to

its lack of depth.

W h ich is where t he U W scient ists come i n I n a g rou ndbrea k i ng st udy, t he resea rchers have used 3D i magi ng te chnolog y to u nderst a nd t he f i ne det a i ls of m icroplast ics, pavi ng t he way for more ef fect ive met hods of plast ic waste re cycl i ng I n c ol lab or at ion w it h C a na d a’s N a t i o n a l R e s e a r c h C o u n c i l, U W resea rchers combi ned 3D i magi ng wit h a novel photocat a ly t ic process usi ng U V l ight a nd a t it a n iu m ox ide cat a lyst, a nd were able to obser ve t he deg rad at ion of m icroplast ics at a m icroscopic level wit h u npre cedented cla r it y, ga i n i ng i nsights t h a t we r e p r ev io u sly i m p o s sible t o obt a i n. “Most m icroscop e i mages provide a 2D view, wh ich gives us some i n for mat ion, but not enough,” sa id Wi ll ia m A nd e r son, a p r ofessor i n U W’s D epa r t ment of Chem ica l Engi ne er i ng “However, 3D i magi ng is l i ke a CT sca n, of fer i ng fa r more det a i led i nsights i nto t he st r uct u re a nd deg rad at ion of m icroplast ics T h is level of det a i l has be en

i ncred ibly cha l lengi ng to ach ieve, but it’s c r ucia l for u nder st a nd i ng what’s happ en i ng at t he su r face of m icro a nd na noplast ics a nd how deg rad at ion processes work ”

A nd i n a dd it ion to r evea l i ng how m icroplastics deg rade, the resea rch tea m is work i ng on i n novat ive met ho d s to recycle these pa r ticles.

S GD AHNBXBI HMF : MFI D

According to the resea rchers, the st udy a lso has broader implications for U W, wh ich is now for m ing a multidisciplina r y plastics biologica l recycling – or biocycl i ng – resea rch i n it iat ive to cont i nue explor ing these prom ising solutions for pla st ic wa st e r e cycl i ng Sp e c i f ic a l ly, A nderson a nd h is colleagues f rom the D epa r t ment of C hem ica l Eng i ne er i ng a nd the Depa r tment of Biology at U W a re developing biocycling methods where m icroplastics could be used as a ca rbon sou rce for bacter ia T hese bacter ia would ingest m icroplastics a nd then excrete a n e nv i r o n m e nt a l ly-f r i e n d ly b io p oly m e r that could be used to create new mater ia ls li ke plastic bags or packaging f ilms T he end goa l is to use biocycling to help create a ci rcula r economy where plastic wa st e is reg u la rly t r a nsfor me d i nto a r a nge of usef u l p ro duct s r at her t ha n b ei ng d i s c a r d e d “ T h e c ol la b o r a t ion underscores the impor ta nce of br inging together different f ields of exper tise to t a ck le c om plex env i r on m ent a l ch a llenges,” A nderson sa id “T h is resea rch offers va luable insights that could pave the way for more effective methods of plastic waste recycling ” B O

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.