2024 Annual Report
Photo by: Tim Johnson, the Vineyard Gazette
What We Do
Since 1975, Vineyard Preservation Trust has been dedicated to restoring, managing, and caring for Martha’s Vineyard’s most important iconic landmarks, providing public access to 20 historic places across four island towns.
Stately, classic, quirky, and beloved, the Trust’s landmarks include its flagship Heritage Center in the heart of Edgartown, a farm, two of New England’s most distinctive churches, green spaces, formal gardens, eight event venues, spaces for stores, island nonprofit workplaces, and a fanciful, 19th-century carousel.
The Trust’s nonprofit work ensures that the Island’s unique character, culture, and heritage remain integral to the daily lives of the local community and the experiences of our visitors—both today and for future generations. Visit us at vineyardtrust.org.
Photo by: Michael Blanchard
From the Executive Director From the Chairman of the Board
As I reflect on this past year, I want to personally thank you for your generosity in ensuring that these cherished places remain part of our authentic island experience and continue to bring our community together—today and tomorrow.
Thanks to supporters like you, 2024 was a remarkable year of preservation and engagement. From dedicated Carnegie educators Sissy Biggers and Laura Pla, who welcomed thousands of visitors, to Friends of Events hosts Mike and Lisa MacKenty, who introduced a new generation of Islanders to their family’s heritage at the Vincent House, and Lisa and Gareth Brown, whose KIN Fashion Show has become a spectacular annual fundraiser on the Village Green, our team and partners made incredible contributions. Meanwhile, in its second year, our ongoing collaboration with the Edgartown Board of Trade has strengthened the Edgartown Village Market, creating a vibrant platform for Island makers. And a heartfelt thanks to 93-year-old contra dance contra dance enthusiast Mal Jones, who funded a five-year series of dances to inspire young people to “get moving.” Each effort strengthens our sense of community and connection.
This summer, I had such fun with special guests Bob Vila, Jim Athearn, and Allen Whiting, who brought the Grange’s history to life through their personal stories at our summer breakfast series. And finally, I am deeply grateful to the unflappable Debi Crews, who did an outstanding job chairing our Patrons Party, elevating and expanding our most cherished event of the season. Recalling these joyful moments, I am reminded of why our work matters—the Trust’s spaces are where our community gathers, connects, creates, and builds lasting memories.
No matter how you support the Trust, I am grateful. Because of you, we can continue preserving and activating these historic spaces. I look forward to seeing you at one of the 50 events celebrating our 50th anniversary this year!
Thank you for all that you do.
Vineyard Preservation Trust’s mission is to preserve and steward the historic properties that define Martha’s Vineyard’s culture and narrative. Thanks to your support and the dedication of our staff, Board, and partners, these landmarks are not just preserved—they are thriving.
The year 2024 was one of momentum and progress. Our signature events—Taste of the Vineyard, Patrons’ Dinner, and Generations Picnic—drew record attendance, reinforcing their role in bringing our community together. The Carnegie continues to grow as a hub for education, conversation, and artistic expression. Participation in our Annual Fund increased, strengthening our ability to sustain this work.
Key investments advanced our mission: we welcomed a full-time Facilities Director to ensure expert care for our properties, launched the large-scale restoration of Grange Hall, and hired a Marketing Manager to bolster our event team. Meanwhile, committed and pledged endowment funds are nearing our ambitious $10 million goal, securing our future.
“The Carnegie continues to grow as a hub for education, conversation, and artistic expression.
Participation in our Annual Fund increased, strengthening our ability to sustain this work.
Serving as the Trust’s Board Chair in 2024 is an honor. Collaborating with our dedicated team and Trustees—whether strategizing for the future or assessing the bones of Grange Hall’s 166-year-old frame before a much-needed roof replacement—is incredibly rewarding. But my greatest joy remains sharing these places with my grandchildren—watching their delight as they ride the Flying Horses, a simple yet profound reminder of why we do this work.
I invite you to explore our 2024 Annual Report for a closer look at our accomplishments. And as we prepare for our 50th Anniversary, I hope you’ll mark your calendars and join us for this milestone celebration.
Your support keeps these treasured landmarks vibrant, relevant, and accessible for future generations.
Thank you for being part of this journey.
JOSH MCCALL, Chairman of the Board
NEVETTE PREVID, Executive Director
Nevette with Bob Vila
Year in Review Preservation in Action! 2024 Highlights.
In 2024, Vineyard Preservation Trust remained steadfast in its mission, undertaking critical repairs, maintenance, and capital projects to ensure the vitality and accessibility of its historic landmarks.
In Edgartown, the Daniel Fisher House received a new HVAC system and fresh interior and exterior paint. A special thanks to John Murphy and Kalani Gonzales of Tracker Home Decor for their exceptional design and generous donation of new curtains, lighting, and wallpaper in the grand front hall at the Daniel Fisher House, helping us continue elevating our historic spaces. The Vincent House saw a transformation with the creation of a Colonial Medicinal Garden, guided by Jody Erdman and Delena Previd, while additional curated plantings by Donaroma further enhanced the property. A comprehensive tree audit led to strategic pruning and removal of trees at the Daniel Fisher House and Village Green, with new plantings planned for spring.
In Oak Bluffs, the Flying Horses Carousel underwent essential repairs, including clutch arm restoration and reinforcement of basement walls. New educational
Photo by: Jeanna Shepard
signage, branding, and merchandise invite the next generation to experience its charm. The Union Chapel accessibility plan, including new walkways, ramps, railings, and the restoration of like-original wood stairs at the five entrances of the Chapel, has begun its approval process with historic districts and the state, with completion set for Spring 2026.
In West Tisbury, phase one of the Grange Hall restoration is well underway, with red cedar roof replacement, repair and painting of the gingerbread trim and windows, restoration of white cedar sidewalls, and installation of dry wells for improved drainage. Phase two, starting in January 2026, will focus on load-bearing
“structural improvements to the foundation and existing framing. The Old West Tisbury Library and Nathan Mayhew Schoolhouse in Vineyard Haven now feature modern HVAC systems, enhancing comfort for the nonprofits that call these landmarks home.
Gallons of paint, piles of leaves, new locks, endless scrubbing, and over 500 work orders completed—our maintenance team had an incredibly busy year.
Through these efforts, we continue to honor our commitment to preserving Martha’s Vineyard’s historic treasures for public use and future generations to enjoy.
I think people need to look beyond their houses and focus on their community — understanding what they have down the street, whether it’s a 1920s movie palace or a church that no longer has a congregation. I think it would be great if people spent more time and energy understanding their immediate communities and figuring out how to preserve the more important buildings that are in danger.
—
BOB VILA, Home Renovation Expert and Architectural Preservationist (via National Trust for Historic Preservation)
Financial Summary 2024
Zollo, Vice Chair of Finance (2024), Vice Chair of the Endowment (2025)
Lisa MacKenty, Treasurer and Vice-chair of Finance (2025)
Diversification of income sources played a key role in these achievements. Event venue rentals and property rents generated $1.4 million, while the signature fundraising event, “A Taste of the Vineyard,” grossed $1.2 million, which includes the paddle raise that is earmarked for the Union Chapel. The Annual Fund exceeded expectations by raising $446,437** , surpassing its initial goal of $295,000. In addition, grants provided critical support: a $232,000 Save America’s Treasures grant from the National Park Service is funding essential structural and mechanical repairs to the Flying Horses Carousel,
Vineyard Preservation Trust strengthened its financial foundation in 2024 while advancing its mission to preserve Martha’s Vineyard’s historic landmarks. Through strategic diversification, data-driven decision-making, and enhanced property management, the Trust maximized resource allocation for long-term sustainability while reaffirming its commitment to protecting the island’s cultural heritage.
The Trust experienced increased income and contributions, and expenses were tightly controlled; this positive trend allowed us to set aside an operating reserve, ensuring that the organization remains agile in addressing unforeseen challenges.
The Trust’s endowment also reflected this positive momentum. Excluding pledges, the balance reached $7,160,819, marking a 144% growth from 2023. Significant contributions came from a $195,000 legacy gift from the late David Thompson and Joan Norton estates, further strengthening the Trust’s financial base.
including the restoration of 18 hand-carved wooden horses and four chariots, and a $145,000 grant from the Mass Cultural Council is earmarked for accessibility upgrades and park beautification at Union Chapel for the 2025/2026 period. A combined $95,000 grant from Community Preservations Funds of the Towns of West Tisbury, Chilmark, and Aquinnah will support the structural upgrades of the Grange Hall, to be completed in the winter of 2026.
Central to these accomplishments was the strategic oversight and diligent financial management of Executive Director Nevette Previd and Comptroller Tammy Degregario. Their leadership ensured effective expense management, transparent tracking of capital projects, and the successful execution of fundraising initiatives.
This strengthened position secures current operations and positions Vineyard Preservation Trust for continued success in preserving Martha’s Vineyard’s treasured historic landmarks for future generations.
Victor
Strengthening Leadership & Honoring Legacy
At Vineyard Preservation Trust’s Annual Board Meeting on August 29, 2024, the organization welcomed new leadership and honored key contributors, reaffirming its commitment to preserving the island’s historic landmarks.
The Trust is pleased to announce the appointment of Vaughn R. Butler, Founder of Scholar Painting LLC, as Vice Chair of Properties. A leader in historic restoration, Butler brings expertise in preservation, project management, and workforce development, further strengthening the Trust’s efforts to maintain and enhance its historic sites.
The Board also confirmed its 2024 Executive Committee appointments and granted Emeritus status to two esteemed Trustees. Nancy Caraboolad, former Vice Chair of Properties, played a key role in restoring and reopening Alley’s General Store and overseeing the Trust’s properties. Joseph Sollitto provided invaluable legal and municipal expertise, shaping the Trust’s preservation advocacy. The organization also thanks longtime Trustee Gina Mortara for her dedicated service.
The Trust remembers those we lost in 2024, including longtime Trustee Audrey McCargo and Life Trustee Joan Norton. Additionally, we honor the memory of Robert Ribeiro, who served as VPT’s Maintenance Manager for 25 years. His deep commitment to the Trust’s properties—especially his beloved Flying Horses Carousel—leaves a lasting impact. In his honor, a memorial tree now stands at the Daniel Fisher House, symbolizing his enduring legacy. We also remember Floyd Norton, a true Vineyarder, who generously donated the Norton Boathouse to the Trust along with his late brother, Bailey Norton, and sister, Drusilla Park.
CHAIR
J.B. McCall IV
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
J.B. McCall IV, Chair
Elizabeth D. MacKenty, Vice-chair Finance
Vaughn R. Butler, Vice-chair, Properties
Vineyard Preservation Trust Board of Trustees and Staff
Deborah Crews, Vice-Chair, Trustees & Governance
William H. Weeks, Vice-Chair, Development
Victor A. Zollo, Vice-Chair, Endowment
John E. Klein, Ex Officio, Emeritus
Sarah B. Rorer, Ex Officio, Emerita (In Memoriam)
CLERK
Alvin R. Johnson
TREASURER
Elizabeth D. MacKenty
TRUSTEES
Lynn Allegaert
Deborah Barnes
R. Kelsey Biggers
Brooke R. Brown
Nancy T. Caraboolad
Gerret Conover
G. Drew Conway
Tana Gibson
Melissa M. Hedley
Alice B. Indelicato
Gail Kittenplan
John P. Murphy
Ian Murray
Shep Murray
Kevin A. Myatt
Deborah A. Nugent
Amanda T. Phillips
Richard N. Purington
Rosalie R. Shane
Mary B. Stanton
Margaret C. Tattersall
Twanette Tharp
Pamela Zilly
EMERITI
Patrick J. Ahearn
Carole M. Berger
Alison M. Convery
Robert G. Cox
Robert C. Graham, Jr.
Michele M. Hedley
John E. Klein
Sarah B. Rorer (In Memoriam)
Joseph E. Sollitto, Jr.
STAFF
Sissy Biggers, The Carnegie: Community Engagement and Program Director
Sandy Burt, Venue & Event Director
Tammy DeGregorio, Finance Director & HR Coordinator
Julie Hatt, Events & Cultivation Director
Jaime Hiltz, Flying Horses
Carousel Manager
Steve Kelly, Facilities Director
Bruno Leoncio, Maintenance Manager
Laura Pla, The Carnegie: Lead Educator
Nevette Previd, Executive Director
Molly Pogue, Marketing Manager
This year, we pay special tribute to longtime Trustee Sally (Sarah) Rorer, whose leadership, passion, and commitment shaped Vineyard Preservation Trust for over four decades. From her early days as a donor in 1982 to joining the Board in 1992, serving as Chair (2011–2014), and stepping in as interim Executive Director in 2021, Sally was the ultimate volunteer and guided the Trust through pivotal moments with confidence and care.
Sally was class. She was a force. She cared—a lot. As her friend and former Trustee Richard Canty said, “Everything she touched, she made better. Her tireless dedication left an indelible mark, and her spirit will continue to inspire us for generations to come. “ - In Memoriam, Sally Rorer, February 23, 2025.
Nancy Caraboolad
Vaughn Butler
Debi Crews & Star Jones
Joe & Kathy Sollitto
John Murphy & Kalanie Gonzales
The Carnegie’s Continued Success Walking Through History:
Now in our seventh year, we are grateful for our team of walking tour educators—Laura Pla, Lynn Murray, and Patty Topping—whose energy and expertise are vital to our success. The beauty of our reading rooms and exhibit spaces continues to open doors for exciting new partnerships.
Coffee & Conversations remained a winter favorite, and in the spring, we launched Edgartown Books at The Carnegie, both bringing together Island talent— from performer Louise DuArt-Rushnell on a January afternoon to illustrator Kate Feiffer, who debuted her
first novel in early June. Our historic walking tours, now departing from the Old Whaling Church, offered a richer experience and a new synergy with the Martha’s Vineyard Museum through the addition of the Cooke House.
Changing exhibits brought fresh perspectives, including the impactful YWCA installation, Equal. Powerful. Unstoppable: 165 Years of Eliminating Racism and Empowering Women, culminating in a thoughtprovoking forum in August. The Martha’s Vineyard Garden Club’s centennial exhibition and Garden Tour homebase included the famed dahlias still blooming
at the Emily Post House on Fuller Street, which scores of visitors especially enjoyed, along with our special Emily Post exhibit in our Reading Room cases.
The revitalized Carnegie Gallery showcased Island artists Libby Ellis and Elizabeth Whelan, providing a new artistic destination and source of revenue. Our partnership with Bass in the Grass continues to enhance the Edgartown Board of Trade’s annual Fishing Derby auction, boosting the Derby scholarship fund and visits in waders.
Our third annual Dickens Christmas Village, now a cherished holiday tradition in Edgartown for hundreds of families, closed out our year. Our popular holiday party, set amid the festively decorated galleries thanks to Sandy Burt, Julie Hatt and volunteers, remains a highlight of Christmas in Edgartown celebrations.
A magical slice of Christmas history came to the Vincent House this year, and thanks to Cristina Jubin’s support and inspiration, it will now be an annual event. Always a highlight of our walking tours, visitors can now experience the revitalization of the historic kitchen garden. A special visit from artists William Pettit and Candice ColbySmith launched the production of Golden Hours, an exciting art installation for our 50th anniversary that reimagines three centuries of American living in the family home.
Courtesy: YWCA
“Maybe it was the idea of playing hooky from work, or maybe it was the feeling of being on a field trip, or maybe it was just a thrill to play tourist for a morning – a warm sunny morning, no less – that endeared me to the tour. But I think, ultimately, the reason I enjoyed it so much was the same reason anyone, Islanders included (or maybe especially), would: It’s a rare and fascinating opportunity to see how Islanders lived across three centuries – to imagine their family life, their daily chores, their worship, their fortunes – through the lens of structures built 350, 250 and 180 years ago.
— SUSIE MIDDLETON,
The Vine, Cook the Vineyard, Vineyard Gazette
