Consumer protection and artificial intelligence by UNCTAD

Page 1


ConsumerProtectionand ArtificialIntelligence

OECD Global Forum on Competition

Monday, 1 December 2025

Consumer Protection and AI

This technical notestems from the work of the UNCTAD informal working group on consumer protectionin ecommerce, establishedin 2017

Over the past two years, the group:

 Held several thematic webinars on consumer protection and AI

 Explored risks and opportunities for consumers

 Shared concrete examples of AI use by consumer protection agencies

 The findings informed this technical note and aim to support dialogue and cooperation at the multilateral level

 Checklist for consumer protection agencies staring to deploy AI

Consumer Protection and AI

The Technical note and its accompanying Checklist stems from the work of the UNCTADinformal working group on consumer protectionin e-commerce, establishedin 2017

Main Risks and Opportunities of AI for Consumer Protection

Risks

Opportunities

 Enable personalized consumer services

 Improve detection of unfair commercial practices

 Automate dispute resolution and complaint handling

 Enhanceefficiency and transparency in enforcement

 Opaque algorithmsand lack of explainability

 Manipulative practices (e.g., dark patterns, confirmshaming)

 Discriminationand biased AI outcomes

 Invasivedata collectionand privacy breaches

 Environmental impactsand rising use of resources

 Unequal access due to the digital divide

 Concentrationof influence in the hands of a few companies – AI oligopoly

Strengthening Consumer Protection through AI Regulation

RobustregulatoryframeworksareessentialtoensureAIisused responsiblyine-commerce,requiringnewlawsandguidancethat empoweragencies,protectconsumers,andalignnationaleffortswith internationalbestpractices.

Whyregulationmatters

 Lack of clear rules risks misuse of AI in e-commerce

 Urgent need for governance to ensure AI serves the public interest

 Consumer protection must be embedded in AI frameworks

What’sneeded

 Newregulatorytools: to address algorithmic harm, manipulation& redress

 Proceduralpowers: to investigate,modify or remove harmful AI systems

 Substantiverules: to set limitsfor high-risk AI applications

 Strongerguidance for consumer agencies, especially in developing countries

Use of AI - Consumer Protection Agencies

Technologyforsmarterenforcement

Agencies increasinglyuse AI to detect violations,manage complaintsand for consumer education. Tools support shift from reactiveto preventive enforcement

 Korea (KCA): AI-based knowledge platform improves dispute settlement

 Netherlands (ACM): AI-powered web scraper for unfair practices; scanning spoken words to detect wrongdoing

 Peru (INDECOPI): Monitors spam calls using AI

 Poland (UOKiK):ARBUZ scans contracts; new tool detects dark patterns

 Thailand (OCPB): Complaint triage; detect fraudulent digital advertising

 Zambia (CCPC): Chatbot-enabled case management system; developing a digital market surveillance

Benefits

Enhanced detection and evidence gathering

Faster response to consumer harm

Improved access to redress

Challenges

Data gaps and digital divides

Limited capacities

Legal and ethical concerns

Where to Start?

StrengtheningthefoundationsforAIinconsumerprotection:Ensuring dataqualityandbuildingtechnologicalcapacitiesinenforcementagencies

AI tools require clean,structured,and representativedata

Agencies should invest in:

 Data collection: complaints,market practices, business compliance, enforcement actions…

 Pre-processing data: handling missing information,converting data into usable formats, removing errors and irrelevant content…

 Ongoing quality assurance: reduce bias and error

Many agencies lackinfrastructure,staffing, andskills to deploy AI

Building technological capacities:

 Recruitment of technical specialists: integrate technical expertise into policy teams to support the design, deployment, and monitoring of AI tools

 Training for enforcement officer: strengthen staff digital skillsto ensure effective and responsible use of AI systems

 Investment in IT infrastructure: computers, high-connectivity,secure data storage systems

Why a Checklist?

Apractical,non-prescriptivetooltoguideinformed decision-making

The Checklistoffers guidance for consumer protection agencies to:

 Assess whether, when, and how AI could support their mandate

 Align decisions with consumer rights, legal safeguards, and operational realities

 Ensure approaches remain flexible, contextspecific, and risk-aware

 Share experiences and build on existing practices across jurisdictions

Checklist – 15 Questions

Practical & organizational considerations

 Understand the task or function AI will assist you with

 Ensure AI is the appropriate tool for the identifiedproblem

 Set clear and achievablegoals

 Build and trainthe right team

 Use a flexible development approach

 Secure the right funding

 Ensure seamless integration with existing systems

 Get your data in order

 Monitorandrefinethesystem

Legal,ethical&accountability considerations

 Be transparent about AI usage

 Guarantee the right side of ethics and law

 Safeguard data privacy

 Make AI systems secure

 Maintain decisional authority

 Consider environmental sustainability in AI deployment

 Monitorandrefinethesystem

TheChecklistsupportsinformedandcontextappropriatedecisionsonthepotentialroleofAIin consumerprotection.

International Cooperation

 Collaborationisessential:Joint tool development,knowledge exchange, and funding partnerships makeit possible for all countries—especially developing ones— to deploy AI responsibly.

 Globalinitiativesgainingmomentum: UNGA Resolutions (2024), the UN Secretary-General’sAI Advisory Body, and the Global Digital Compactall call for inclusive, rights-based, and sustainable AI governance.

 UNCTAD’sroleiskey: Enabling dialogue, collaboration, and capacity-building to strengthen consumer protection in the age of AI.

 Focusonfairnessandbestpractices: Agencies must approach AI use critically, guided by ethical principles and international standards to ensure safe, effective,and transparent enforcement.

Suggestions for Action

Forconsumerprotectionagencies

 Work collectively to adopt and promote best practices

 Boost consumer education on AI-driven risks

 Enhancetechnological capacities

 Engage in international cooperation

Forpolicymakers

 Support the development of inclusiveAI governance frameworks

 Ensure coherence with existing consumer protection laws

Thankyou

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.