Smithtown Messenger Archive Oct. 9, 2025

Government Shutdown : A Conversation with Congressman LaLota

By Matt Meduri

For the first time since 2018, the federal government has shut down. On October 1, Congress failed to pass appropriations for the 2026 fiscal year. Primary causes of the consternation on Capitol Hill stem from healthcare subsidies, foreign aid recissions, and federal spending. The shutdown is the eleventh in U.S. history and the third under President Donald Trump (R-FL), with the first two during his first term. sat down with Congressman Nick LaLota (R-Amityville) to discuss the scene on the Hill.

Continued on page 8

DPW Completes

By Madison Warren

project to

Port Jefferson Summer Farmers Market at Harborfront Park

Every Saturday and Sunday, May 18-November 28

9:00 AM to 2:00 PM

Islip Farmers Market at Town Hall Every Sunday June 7 - November 22

7:00 AM to 12:00 PM

Goatman’s Haunted House

Riverhead County Fair

October 12, 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM

Pal-O-Mine Fall Festival

October 13, 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM 2025 Port Jefferson Harvest Festival

October 18, 11:00 AM to 5:00 PM Bats and Brews

PUBLISHER

Raheem Soto

EDITOR-IN-CHIEF

Matt Meduri

Sergio A. Fabbri CONTRIBUTORS

PJ Balzer

Ashley Pavlakis

Madison Warren

OFFICE MANAGER & ACCOUNTS

RECEIVABLE Kim Revere

PROOFREADER

Giavanna Rudilosso

SOCIAL MEDIA

Madison Warren

Library News

HAUPPAUGE:

WHERE TO FIND OUR PAPER

COMMACK

Bagel Chalet

Bagel Toasterie (Mayfair Shopping Center)

Candlelight Diner

HAUPPAUGE

Hauppauge Palace • Shop Rite (Smithtown Bypass)

KINGS PARK

3 Sons Deli • Bagel City Company Kings Park Card Shop

Kings Park Manor • Linda’s Pizza

LIRR Kings Park Train Station Park Bakery • Raleigh Poultry Farm

LAKE GROVE

Lake Grove Village Hall

RONKONKOMA

718 Slice Pizzeria (719 Hawkins Ave)

SMITHTOWN

American Legion

Hot Bagels • LIRR Smithtown Train Station

Maureen’s Kitchen • Millennium Diner

Smithtown Bagels

Smithtown Seniors Center

Smithtown Town Hall Stop & Shop • Sweetwaters

ST. JAMES

50% Cards Store (Lake Avenue)

7 Eleven (356 Lake Avenue) Lake Ave Deli

LIRR St. James Train Station

Little Movers Storytime- October 21, 10:00 AM to 10:30 AM

Farmer’s Market Pop Up- October 29, 10:00 AM to 1:00 PM

COMMACK:

Teen No-Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake - Grades 6-12 October 11, 2:30 PM

NESCONSET:

Sensory StorytimeOctober 21, 3:00 PM to 4:00 PM

KINGS PARK:

Nursery RhymesOctober 11, 10:30 AM to 11:00 AM

Trick or Treat TotesOctober 18, 10:30 AM to 11:00 AM

SACHEM:

Writers WorkshopOctober 14, 6:45 PM to 8:45 PM Zumba Kids - Grades K-5 October 20, 4:45 PM to 5:30 PM

AT THE SACHEM BUILDING

Crime

Tierney Nabs Two Criminal Organizations in Theft of Donated Clothing

By Matt Meduri

It’s one thing to commit burglary against homeowners, white-collar fraud against a company, or run a criminal organization proliferating contraband.

But it’s another to steal from a charity.

Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney (R) on Wednesday afternoon announced the end of an investigation that produced sixteen arrests relating to the theft of donated clothing worth nearly $200,000.

Alfredo Perez, 67, of Copiague, allegedly spearheaded one criminal operation, with Manuel Cabrera, 62, of Lindenhurst, allegedly heading the other. Investigators seized fourteen vehicles which were allegedly used to move the clothing. Investigators also recovered an estimated 25,000 pounds of stolen clothing.

Investigators allege that seventy incidents occurred across eight Suffolk donation sites, the first being one twenty-six burglaries starting November 25, 2024, at Our Lady of Perpetual Hope in Lindenhurst. The church continued to be ransacked until August 18, 2025.

Thirty-two burglaries are alleged at Saints Cyril and Methodius Church in Deer Park from November 30, 2024, until August 30 of this year. One burglary is alleged at St. Philip and St. James Church in St. James, occurring on June 30, 2025, six burglaries at St. Margaret’s of Scotland in Selden between June and September of this year, and two burglaries at St. Lawrence the Martyr church in Sayville on September 11 and 26.

One burglary is alleged to each of the following locations, St. John Nepomucene in Bohemia - September 27 - Mary Immaculate Roman Catholic Church in Bellport - September 11 - and St. Jude Church in Mastic BeachSeptember 11.

Investigators showed video evidence of the alleged defendants climbing into donation bins, removing the bagged clothing, and loading it into cars and vans before driving off.

Perez’s vans allegedly traveled to a used clothing export business in Nassau County. Investigators say that more than 285,000 pounds of stolen clothing were sold to that exporter and that Perez received payments exceeding $100,000. Cabrera is also alleged to have owned multiple Ford Econoline vans which transported another 280,000plus pounds of stolen clothing for payments in excess of $90,000.

In total, the defendants are alleged to have shipped and sold over half-a-million pounds of donated clothing in exchange for close to $200,000.

Perez is charged with one count of Grand Larceny in the Second Degree, a Class C felony, ten counts of Burglary in the Third Degree, Class D felonies, and one count of Conspiracy in the Fourth Degree, a Class E felony. District Court Judge John Zollo (R-Smithtown) held Perez on a $10,000 cash bond - $30,000 bond or $100,000 partially secured - and is due back in court on October 9.

Cabrera was charged with one count of Grand Larceny in the Second Degree, a Class C felony, three counts of Burglary in the Third Degree, Class D felonies, and one count of Conspiracy in the Fifth Degree, a Class E felony. Judge Zollo placed Cabrera on supervised release with GPS monitoring due to his charges being considered non-

bail-eligible under New York State law. Prosecutors cannot request bail and Judge Zollo cannot set bail in that case.

Fourteen co-conspirators, including two juveniles , - both 17, one of Wyandanch, the other of Brentwood - have also been charged. Tierney said that there is no evidence the juveniles were coerced into participating.

The targeted donation bins were operated by the Society of St. Vincent de Paul Long Island, a Catholic organization founded in 1845 that is one of the oldest charities still operating in the U.S.

“This is one of the charity’s largest sources of revenue for the poor, and this is hundreds of thousands of pounds of clothing representing hundreds of thousands of dollars that were unable to go those who needed it most,” said Tierney, (pictured photo left) joined by representatives of Sheriff Errol Toulon (D), Suffolk County Executive Ed Romaine (R-Center Moriches), Suffolk County Police Commissioner Kevin Catalina, St. Vincent de Paul Long Island Executive Director Tom Abbate, and a team of investigators and analysts. U.S. Secret Service also aided the investigation.

Tierney added that some thefts are alleged to have happened at night, but some during the day, even while church services were being held. A storage unit was also allegedly purchased as a holding site between drop-offs to the exporter. One of the vans was involved in a hit-and-run, while another was stopped in Huntington Station for a suspended registration. The latter van produced a loaded handgun and cocaine.

“You thought you’ve seen everything. Could you believe people would steal from a clothing bin?” said Executive Romaine (pictured left). “We are determined to keep Suffolk safe. With crimes like this, we will find them, prosecute them, and jail them. There should be consequences when you steal from the most needy.”

Commissioner Catalina (pictured third photo left) found the acts “truly unconscionable.”

“It’s up there with stealing from the elderly and children,” said Catalina. “It’s beyond comprehension.” He acknowledged patrol officers who made the stops and identified the individuals that helped the investigation take the suspects into custody.

Suffolk County Undersheriff John Becker (pictured fourth photo left) called the acts “not just theft”, but “exploitation.”

“They didn’t just steal bags of clothing. They stole the generosity of Suffolk County residents,” said Becker. “Turning kindness and charity into personal profit is absolutely shameful.” Becker said that the Suffolk Undersheriffs were an “integral” part of the investigation.

Tierney said that no gang affiliations have been established, and that the two rings appear to have acted independently from each other.

Though the juveniles are not assumed to have been coerced or manipulated, Tierney said it spawns a larger conversation on Raise the Age, a set of State laws that increased criminal liability for non-violent crimes from 16 to 18 years of age.

“It incentivizes a criminal organization using children or juveniles to commit crimes because the penalties faced are much less,” said Tierney, adding that while he thinks the Raise the Age law was “well-intentioned”, it warrants further scrutiny.

A seventeenth defendant is also in custody of Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Prosecutors have submitted a writ to have the defendant tried in Suffolk County.

Published by Messenger Papers, Inc.

Photo credit - Matt Meduri

Romaine Signs EO to Form County Alliance Against Domestic Violence

By Matt Meduri

On Tuesday afternoon, Suffolk County Executive Ed Romaine (R-Center Moriches) signed an executive order (EO) to better shape the County’s resources and offices to combat domestic violence.

The EO was signed at the H. Lee Dennison Building in Hauppauge.

Romaine said that there are a “great number of nonprofits” that seek to curb domestic violence and assist victims.

“We want to make sure that we continue to support them and make the public more aware of the programs available,” said Romaine. “There’s nothing more devastating than to see that type of violence in your household.”

The alliance will be a ten-member commission, including two chairs selected by the County Executive. Romaine said that the County designates domestic violence as a “grave threat”, but that further interoperability is needed.

“We need this alliance to look at the data, figure out what’s going wrong, and how we can help people and prevent domestic violence,” said Romaine. “It’s hard to believe that people are married, who at one point must have said the three magic words that we all want to hear in life - ‘I love you’ - but at some point, it turned violent.”

Romaine also called the 27,000 domestic violence incidents in Suffolk in 2024 “startling”, and that the hope is a decreased number in 2026.

Dr. Sylvia Diaz was appointed by Executive Romaine in 2024 to serve as Deputy County Executive for Health, Human Services, and Education. She called for resources and expertise to not be contained in “silos”, but bring them all together.

“We are going to work on this around the clock,” said Diaz.

Diaz introduced Bevin Llanes, whose daughter, Meghan Kiefer, was murdered by her then-boyfriend in 2021.

“She endured trauma that no young person should ever have. What makes her story even more heartbreaking is not only the abuse that she suffered every day of her adult life, but the lack of coordinated support from the various systems meant to help,” said Llanes, adding that she and her husband did “everything” they could, including counseling, hospital visits, medical care, and other services. Law enforcement was frequently contacted, but that “none of the systems ever worked together.”

“We were left without guidance, without navigation, and without true help,” said Llanes. “I often wonder if a coordinated community response had existed back then, would Megan still be here today? I truly believe she might.”

Suffolk County Police Department Chief William Doherty (pictured above left) said it’s important that “awareness turns into action.”

“While law enforcement, service agencies, and community organizations all do vital work on their own, we can achieve far more when we work together. I believe this collaboration will leave a lasting impact,” said Doherty, adding the initiative on the police end includes “providing enhanced training” to officers and “enforcing a pro-arrest policy in cases of domestic violence.”

“Additionally, it will enhance the effectiveness of victims’ advocates, our legal partners, and community -based organizations ensuring survivors are not left alone during these vulnerable times,” said Doherty. “The alliance will also increase efficiency, improve extreme risk protection orders or

red flag laws, strengthen officer safety, and prevent survivors from being re -victimized.” He added that all officers receive “robust” training on handling domestic violence calls.

Allen Bode, Chief Assistant District Attorney, said that the D.A.’s office is “committed to reducing and prosecuting domestic violence vigorously.”

Bode also hailed the County for applying for and securing a $2 million New York Statewide Targeted Reductions in Violence Initiative (STRIVE) Grant.

“At the District Attorney’s office, that means we have four victims’ advocates who are dedicated to domestic violence, including Spanishspeaking [victims],” said Bode. “We’ve added a second detective investigator to interview and locate witnesses. There’s now an interagency coordinator. That’s all on top of the thirty assistant D.A.’s, support staff, and investigators that the D.A.’s office already has working in domestic violence.” Bode also mentioned that the D.A.’s office is in the process of adding ten more victims’ advocates and will be applying for federal grants as well.

Anne Oh, Chief Counsel for the Department of Social Services and CoChair of the Alliance, was joined by Co-Chair Stacey Caggiano, the County Director of Women’s Services.

“If you had asked me ten years ago for prevention of domestic violence, I would say it was up to the police to catch them and for the prosecutors to convict them,” said Oh (pictured above left). “But having been in this area, I’ve learned that even though the conviction happens and the perpetrator is incarcerated, it’s not enough. The victims, the victims’ parents and children, neighbors, teachers, colleagues, and employers who are affected by domestic violence everyday, either directly or peripherally, that’s where the prevention is.”

Oh added that domestic violence “doesn’t happen overnight”, and often follows victims throughout their lives.

“It happens with a child who’s sex abused who has no value for his/ her body. It starts with a wife who says, ‘he’s just jealous. He just doesn’t like it when I talk to other men.’ It starts with people whose finances are controlled. It starts with the elder who says, ‘my nurse loves me. She would never take money from me.’”

Suffolk County Legislator Trish Bergin (R-East Islip) (pictured below left) has made domestic violence and human trafficking a key part of her legislative priorities. She serves as Chair of the Seniors and Human Services Committee.

“Three in every ten women and one in every ten men are victims of some form of domestic abuse,” said Bergin. She shared the story of a victim whose abuse started as financial control, which led to bills lapsing in payment and luxury cars in storage. It spiraled into emotional and eventually physical abuse. It only took intervention from the victim’s mother to leave her abusive husband.

“That was the permission that she finally got and the strength to leave. So, when you see friends, or maybe some of you are in this position right now, you don’t realize it’s not going to get better. It’s only going to get worse,” said Bergin.

Photo credit - Matt Meduri

The Zero-Sum Game of Government Shutdowns

It seems like it was just yesterday that the federal government was shut down. Fast-forward seven years and here we are again.

Our conversations with those on the Hill, namely Congressman Nick LaLota (R-Amityville), show that this shutdown, unlike some of its predecessors, is purely political. The GOP insisted on a clean funding bill devoid of riders, while Democratsnamely those in the Senate - have dug in their heels on healthcare subsidies.

This showdown, we believe, has cast a light on something once discussed more last decade: the provisions of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) - or Obamacare. The subsidies are argued to be needed to keep premiums low and care affordable. However, this is posing the bigger question of just how much the ACA can stand on its own merit. Without billions in subsidies, it turns out to be a broken attempt at fixing a broken healthcare system.

Moreover, the subsidies - nearly $200 billion - would be earmarked for illegal immigrants. It’s preposterous to think that Democrats, the minority party in both chambers, is willing to shut down the government - after decades of keeping the government running being part of their party’s creed - over benefits to non-citizens. We understand the gray areas and subjectivities that come into play when talking about immigration, but even if this wasn’t a brazen misuse of taxpayer dollars, it’s hard to see how they win the court of PR in that regard.

Now comes the blame game, in which party will the American public lay this shutdown at the feet of?

If Americans lay the blame at the feet of the Democrats, Republicans might be emboldened to keep a steady hand and wait out the Party of Jackson. President Donald Trump (R-FL) is already exploring permanent layoffs by assessing which agencies can run on minimalized staff - a form of “checkmate” that the President has achieved by the shutdown offering itself as a pilot program for some wider DOGE cuts. The Democrats can continue not to come to the table as the minority party while the GOP has offered continuing resolutions (CRs) that the Democrats have refused to sign until their demands are met.

The most surefire way to end it would be for the GOP to convince seven other Democratic Senators to break the filibuster, but Democrats could also double down if the American public lays the blame at the feet of the

FROM THE PUBLISHER’S DESK:

Republicans. It would force the GOP’s - and Trump’s - hand to capitulate. We don’t see a realistic scenario in which the GOP bends the knee on benefits for non-citizens, but it becomes a point of deciding whether dying on that hill is worse the political fallout that endangers their razor-thin House majority next year. Moreover, some holdout Senators hail from swing states set to have competitive Senate races on the map. The GOP could risk their ability to grow their Senate majority next year if this shutdown is viewed to be the GOP’s fault.

We do agree with Congressman LaLota’s assessment of Democratic leadership - or lack thereof. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) continues to find himself in a world he no longer recognizes, where blue dogs are diamonds in the rough and firebrand progressives are increasingly calling more shots. The progressives have already primaried institutions of Democratic leadership since 2018. Schumer continues to find himself in unusual territory by raking in the lowest approval ratings in his Senate career, according to the Siena College. It’s no stretch of the imagination that Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D, NY-14) could parlay an unsuccessful presidential run in 2028 to a primary against Schumer for Senate that year. Schumer, first elected in 1998, could conceivably call it quits ahead of 2028. With that in mind, Schumer might already see the writing on the wall - he won’t be in the Senate come 2029. At this point, he’s got nothing to lose and might be making a last-ditch effort to be the party’s de facto leader in opposing President Trump at every corner. The Independents and cautiously optimistic Democrats might not agree, but at least Schumer is playing to the party’s consistent base.

Of course, it could be a zero-sum game for both parties. If the shutdown continues for an extended period and the everyday life for Americans is affected, neither party will accrue favor. They only risk their own incumbency via primaries and the 2026 midterms, depending on where the shutdowns were felt the most. Not only is Schumer endangered, but Republicans might find themselves with primary opponents more ideologically aligned with fiscal stalwarts like Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) and Congressman Thomas Massie (R, KY-04).

It’s a hefty risk that’s been seen before in politics, with crucial dividends possibly to be paid in next year’s critical midterms. Either Democrats come to the table or Republicans make concessions. Neither seem imminently likely given the environment.

Suffolk Takes on Domestic Violence

On Monday, Suffolk County took an important step with the creation of the Alliance Against Domestic Violence. County Executive Ed Romaine (R-Center Moriches) signed the executive order forming this coalition, bringing together law enforcement, government agencies, and community organizations. The goal is simple but urgent: to give victims of domestic violence a clear path to safety and justice, without forcing them to navigate a maze of disconnected programs.

This alliance is not about adding another committee to the county directory. It is about closing the gaps that have too often left victims waiting for help while paperwork piled up. A phone call to the police should not lead to weeks of uncertainty, and a plea for shelter should not get lost between one agency and the next. By putting the Suffolk County Police Department directly at the table with service providers, the county is attempting to replace fragmentation with real coordination.

Suffolk County Police Department (SCPD) Deputy Commissioner Thomas Galati and Chief William Doherty stood alongside the County Executive to pledge their department’s support. That commitment matters. No single

agency can solve the problem of domestic violence alone. Police must act swiftly, but victims also need counselors, safe housing, legal advocates, and community groups that understand the human cost behind the statistics.

The test of this alliance will not be the press conference. It will be whether families in crisis see results. Are calls for help answered faster? Are shelters accessible when needed most? Do offenders face real consequences, or do cases stall once the cameras are gone? Taxpayers and families alike deserve answers measured in outcomes, not intentions.

If this new partnership delivers on its promise, Suffolk County will not only strengthen its safety net—it will send a clear message that protecting families is not a talking point, but a priority backed by action. If it fails, it will become one more example of good ideas lost in bureaucracy. The difference will be measured, as it always is, by whether real people are safer tomorrow than they were yesterday.

Raheem Soto

Publisher, Messenger Papers

Op-Ed

NYC Mayoral Race is a Concern for Every New Yorker

By Senator Alexis Weik

This summer I’ve heard upstaters and Long Islanders ask: “Why should I care who the mayor of New York City is? I don’t even live there.”

The answer is simple: one-third of our state budget goes to New York City every year. New York State’s total budget this year is $254 billion. Out of that, an enormous share is going straight into New York City. More than half of all statewide Medicaid spending, about 52%, goes to NYC, which amounts to roughly $19.5 billion. The city also takes in about 36% of all school aid, nearly $14.9 billion. On top of that, New York City receives about 52% of local aid revenue, another $13.9 billion. Combined, that means more than $32 billion in school and local aid alone is being poured into NYC. When you add other programs like homeless services, childcare, and transit, the total grows even larger. In other words, close to one-third of the state’s operating budget is flowing into one city that continues to struggle and fail. New York City has already had two failing mayors over the last eleven years, and taxpayers across the state have been forced to pay for the consequences.

The results speak for themselves. Despite the billions of dollars, New York City has become more dangerous and more expensive to get to, making it less of a destination, more expensive to live in, and new regulations and taxes have driven business to other states. Homelessness is at crisis levels. The city has committed billions to asylum-seeker shelters. Families and industry are leaving in large numbers. None of this has made life better for the rest of New York; it is no longer the economic engine that helped our state. Now, all taxpayers are paying the bill.

New York City is moving toward leadership that embraces extreme views. Weakening the police even more while pouring endless resources into programs that are already strained guarantees more insecurity and higher costs. The free bus program is a proposal with a $650 million annual price tag and no clarity on who will be responsible for paying for it, and it is just the start. The same mindset that calls for government-run transit

also extends to government-owned grocery stores, a vision that embraces a socialist mindset.

This matters everywhere; Wall Street, the New York Stock Exchange, and NASDAQ are located in New York City. If the city continues to grow even more unsafe or unmanageable, these institutions and the jobs and tax revenue they generate will move elsewhere. Financial industry giants are already expanding outside the state. This election could accelerate this trend moving the industries toward Texas and the Midwest. New York will lose its status as the nation’s financial capital; that would devastate State revenues. The same is true for tourism. More than 66 million people visited New York City in 2023, generating $74 billion in economic activity. If tourists stop coming because the city is unsafe, that revenue will disappear, taking jobs and tax dollars with it.

So, why is the New York City Mayoral election so important to the entire state of New York? Putting someone with even more extreme views in office will truly make things worse. We need stronger laws for more safety, less regulation and taxes for our businesses, no more sanctuary city status, more financial oversight for public transportation, ensuring that projects that receive state dollars are completed and run more efficiently, and no more congestion pricing. We need a mayor who will stand up to bad New York State proposed laws and fight back.

So yes, you should care who runs New York City. Because when the city fails, it will weigh heavily on our state, pulling our state further down the drain.

Preserving Suffolk’s Term Limits and the Will of Voters

By Presiding Officer Kevin McCaffrey

I recently led the Suffolk County Legislature in the historic passing of the Term Limit Preservation Act of 2025. I sponsored the Act proactively to protect local governance and taxpayer interests from Albany’s recently imposed election disruption -- the “Even-Year Elections” law signed by Governor Kathy Hochul in 2023.

My Term Limit Preservation Act passed without opposition, and Suffolk County Executive Ed Romaine (R-Center Moriches) has since signed the measure into law. It is now up to you – the residents of Suffolk County – to vote on the Act as a referendum during the November general election.

Due to Governor Hochul’s (D) “Even-Year Elections” law, all eighteen legislators elected or re-elected on this coming November’s ballot would face shortened terms, mid-term resignations, and potential special elections. At present, the County Charter outlines an election process in which all eighteen seats on the Suffolk County Legislature are at stake every odd year. Under the “Even-Year Elections” law signed by Governor Hochul, County Legislators elected in 2025 would be forced to run again in 2026 and again in 2028 –and in doing so be denied the second year of the term for which they were elected to serve in 2025. Moreover, that’s three costly elections in four years!

The potential disruption by the “Even-Year Elections” law is undeniable, particularly here in Suffolk County. The Term Limit Preservation Act of 2025 amends the County Charter to ensure that the County’s voter-approved 12year term limit remains intact and ensures that:

• Term limits remain enforceable and protected.

• Terms shift from two to four years, eliminating three elections in four years.

• Legislators may complete a full term, even if their 12th year of service occurs during that term.

Let me be clear, I am an advocate for term limits. When I was elected the Legislature’s Presiding Officer in 2022 by the new Republican Majority, one of our first actions was to close a loophole in the law and cap total service at 12 years. The resulting referendum was overwhelmingly approved by 85.9% of voters -- 449,605 votes.

Term limits are also favored by the national electorate, as evidenced generally by public opinion surveys, and by the Suffolk electorate

specifically as evidenced by voter approval in multiple referendums. Further, I firmly believe that term limits have proved successful, especially in Suffolk County.

Our Legislature boasts members who bring real-world experience from all walks of life to their public service, including lawyers, teachers, doctors, small business owners, first responders, farmers, civic leaders, and labor leaders.

Ultimately, term limits give voters more, not less, choices at the ballot box. Elections are not always dominated by incumbents.

Term Limits mitigate the advantages of incumbency and allow for new, emerging leaders to run for office.

The Term Limit Preservation Act of 2025, set for a ballot referendum this November, is a direct continuation of the Republican commitment to citizen-led government and strong term limits. The Act also ensures that Suffolk’s voter-approved term limits system remains in place and aligned with the new Democrat-imposed election schedule—without undermining its arguable intent to gain greater voter involvement based on increased turnout in even years.

I firmly believe that moving local elections from their historic oddyear November schedule to even years will overwhelm voters and bury important local issues under the static and noise of national elections.

Although 2025 represents my last year on the Legislature due to our 12year term limit system, I proudly introduced the Act and will wholeheartedly support efforts to prevent Albany-style dysfunction from taking root in Suffolk County.

With the approval of Suffolk voters in November, term limits will be preserved, and we will avoid forced mid-term resignations, costly special elections, and interrupted service and instability in local government leadership.

News from The Hill Government Shutdown: A Conversation with Congressman LaLota

A Lapse in Orthodoxy

LaLota says that the shutdown was a product of “Democrats violating their own religion of keeping the government open”, as well as “fear” within Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) to quell the shift within his party towards a more extreme platform.

“Democrats have historically been relied upon to keep the government open,” LaLota told The Messenger. “Thirteen times under the Biden Administration, the parties worked together to keep the funding going. Democrats have deviated from that path because, broadly, they haven’t been winning on any of their policies under the Trump Administration. They lost on the Big, Beautiful Bill, taxes, spending, and various policies. It’s clear to me that they’re using this round of funding to pick a fight with President Trump.”

Three Democratic Senators joined the Republicans to end debate and pass a stopgap - Senators Catherine Cortez Masto (DNV), John Fetterman (D-PA), and Angus King (I-ME), although reports have stated that their intentions were to avoid a shutdown, which would give Trump “more leverage.”

“In any other time in our nation’s history, Democrats have said that funding the government is essential,” said LaLota. “However, this time around, some Democrats are contorting their language and approach to satisfy their politics. In a shutdown, the president has much broader authority on what he spends the remaining dollars on and whether he fires or furloughs federal employees.”

A Battle Over Subsidies

A big contributor to the tensions on the Hill is that of healthcare subsidies, particularly for the Affordable Care Act (ACA) - or Obamacare. Pandemic-related subsidies were already slated to expire.

“It’s not like Republicans cut funding; they were naturally expiring. The Democrats are picking a fight over extending the subsidies that they themselves had slated to end in 2025,” said LaLota. “On September 19, House Republicans passed the stopgap as a funding mechanism while we’re having fights over broader tax-and-spend policies. But Democrats, thus far, have rejected that stopgap status quo funding, with no partisan riders, no gimmicks, no poison pills - merely a status quo funding of our gov that 99% of House Republicans voted for and 99% of Democrats voted against.”

However, LaLota says that Democrats have made pushing healthcare for illegal immigrants a priority in their fight this year.

shutdown goes, the more harmful it becomes. The more Americans will assign the blame to Democrats. Our Republicans are looking for a funding bill that keeps the status quo, something the parties have agreed on for decades,” said LaLota. “I voted for eight status quo funding bills under President Joe Biden (D-DE), despite my strong objections to his border policies. I voted for them because I understood the pain that would be caused to the general public for a legislative win. For years, every reasonable Republican and Democrat agreed to not shut down the government in order to achieve a policy win. It used to be a bipartisan understanding, but Democrats are rejecting their core philosophy.”

In the U.S. House, only one Democrat, Congressman Jared Golden (D, ME-02), sided with Republicans to keep the government funded. Congresswoman Marie Gluesenkamp Perez (D, WA-03) missed the vote by “seconds”, according to LaLota, but stated her intent to vote for the resolution.

LaLota adds that Schumer and his base fear a Senate primary from Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D, NY-14), colloquially referred to as AOC, as well as a takeover of their party that was once considered the party of the American working-class. AOC has been seen as a rising star in her party since her notable upset in the primary of Congressman Joe Crowley (D) in 2018. At the time, Crowley had been a high-ranking Democrat, defeated for his party’s nomination by AOC, then a political novice.

Schumer is up for re-election in 2028.

“On Page 57 of their $1.5 trillion wish list, Democrats included almost $200 billion to go to healthcare subsidies for illegal immigrants,” said LaLota. “Nobody has to take my word for it; it’s prominently displayed in that initiative.”

LaLota adds that the country’s healthcare system “needs reform”, but that the promises of Obamacare have not panned out.

In terms of services, 31,000 federal employees on Long Island will be affected.

“The longer this shutdown goes on, the worse it will get, especially for those who rely on federal services,” said LaLota, adding that some 3,000 scientists and engineers at Brookhaven National Lab (BNL) and air traffic controllers for Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) will be affected.

“The air traffic controllers, each and collectively, told me that it wouldn’t only become painful for their paychecks, but ordinary Americans who rely on air travel,” said LaLota. “With respect to BNL, the nation’s progress that we’re trying to keep on our economic and military adversary, China, is stalled.”

Schumer’s ‘Fear’

Regarding the political ramifications of this, LaLota believes that Democrats the longer the shutdown continues, the more blame Americans will lie at the feet of the Democrats.

“It’s all about Assemblyman Zoharan Mamdani (D-Astoria) and AOC. The old generation of Democrats, like the Schumers, are scared as hell of the AOCs and Mamdanis,” said LaLota of the current intraparty sparring over the Democrats’ political future. “They’re doing their best to get their socialist tendencies. If you look at NYC, Mamdani wasn’t ‘supposed’ to win that primary, but did, and is likely to win the mayorship. For forty-year politicians like Schumer, that’s scary, and Chuck is trying to become more like Mamdani.”

How Other Long Island Reps. Voted

Fellow Long Island Congressman Andrew Garbarino (R-Bayport) (pictured top) voted in favor of the continuing resolution, in a statement calling it a “clean, short-term funding extension to keep the federal government open and operational.”

“During this shutdown, my team will continue to assist constituents, and our phone lines will remain open. Certain services and response times from federal agencies may slow or cease. We will continue to seek guidance from federal agencies about what services remain available as the situation develops,” said Garbarino in the statement.

Congressman Tom Suozzi (D-Glen Cove) (pictured middle) voted against the resolution.

“‘My way or the highway’ is no way to run a government in a democracy,” said Suozzi in a statement. “Negotiating is how you keep a government open, not stonewalling the other side.”

“I think the politics are terrible for Democrats, because the longer this

Suozzi called on Republicans and Democrats to “sit down” and “hammer out a deal” to “reopen the government as soon as possible” and “extend expiring healthcare premium tax credits to stop doubledigit increases in health insurance premiums come November.”

Congresswoman Laura Gillen (D-Rockville Centre) (pictured bottom) branded the deadlock as a “GOP Shutdown” in a statement.

“First, Republicans threw our health care system into crisis with their Big Bad Bill that will make health care more expensive for millions of Americans,” said Gillen in a statement. “Next, they refused to even negotiate at all to craft a bipartisan spending bill and chose to let tax credits that allow thousands of Long Island families to afford health care expire. The health care cuts being currently pushed by the Majority will mean higher costs for Long Island families already struggling with groceries, rent and child care. This shutdown could have been prevented and Americans would have benefitted if House Republicans governed responsibly.”

The Messenger reached out to Senator Schumer’s office for comment, but received no response.

This Week Today

Thursday, October 9, 2025

National, State, and Local Temperature Checks

By Matt Meduri

National

Chicago is taking a stand against President Donald Trump (R-FL) and his administration’s immigration policies and the admin’s recent deployment of the National Guard to Illinois.

Mayor Brandon Johnson (D) signed an executive order on Monday that prohibits federal Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents from using cityowned property for their operations. Johnson has established “ICE-free zones” as part of his Protect Chicago Initiative.

“The order establishes ICE-free zones. That means that city property and unwilling private businesses will no longer serve as staging grounds for these raids,” Johnson said at a Monday press conference, according to FOX. Johnson went further by asserting that the “right wing in this country wants a rematch of the Civil War.”

Governor J.B. Pritzker (D-IL) filed a lawsuit on Monday which aims to block the Trump Administration from deploying National Guard troops to the Prairie State, calling the moves from Washington an “invasion.” Pritzker has long been floated as a 2028 presidential contender, or at least a significant financier of the Democrats’ candidate.

The Trump Administration has sent 400 Texas National Guard troops to both Illinois and Oregon, courtesy of Governor Greg Abbott (R-TX).

Illinois shifted dramatically to the right in the last election, owing to a substantial Democratic enthusiasm gap between 2020 and 2024. A state won by Joe Biden (D-DE) by seventeen points went to Kamala Harris (D-CA) by a little under eleven points. No Republican has won Illinois at the presidential level since 1988.

Meanwhile, Kansas Republicans are circulating a petition to call a special session of the state legislature to redraw their congressional maps ahead of the 2026 midterms - another development in the national redistricting “arms race” that has proliferated since July.

Kansas House Speaker Dan Hawkins (R) began circulating petitions for a special session at a Wichita event last weekend. Republicans currently have supermajorities in both chambers of the Kansas Legislature, meaning they could not only call a special session unilaterally, but override a likely veto of a gerrymandered map by Governor Laura Kelly (D-KS).

Republicans control three of the four congressional seats afforded to the Sunflower State. The only one not in their control is KS-03, a Kansas City-based district that was flipped by Congresswoman Sharice Davids (D, KS-03) in the 2018 blue wave and held by a significant ten-point margin in 2020. Even after the GOP drew her district to be more favorable to Republicans, Davids held the line by a comfortable margin.

As of now, Republicans can expect four or five seats from their Texas redraw and another from their recently-passed Missouri redraw.

Additionally, the Utah State Legislature is already meeting in special session to consider maps for a court-ordered redistricting process. The Redistricting Committee selected “Map C”, one of the several proposed. Utah is forced to redraw its map by court order, after a lawsuit found that the legislature violated a voter-approved referendum to concede to an independent redistricting commission. The map approved in 2021 made UT-04 a much redder district by spreading Salt Lake City, a blue stronghold, across all four of the state’s districts.

In the “Map C” proposal, Salt Lake City would remain whole within UT-03, while its Salt Lake County would be split only once between UT-03 and UT-02. (see map above)

On the international stage, Hamas delegates are headed to Egypt to discuss releasing the remaining Israeli hostages pursuant to a Gaza ceasefire plan pitched by President Trump. On Friday, Trump told Israel to cease bombing Gaza, but more than 100 people have been killed since those strikes. Qatar, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) are reportedly mediators who are at the table.

On the Hill, Congressman David Schweikert (R, AZ-01) is retiring from the House to run for governor of Arizona.

The Arizona gubernatorial race is likely to be one of the marquee races of the 2026 midterms. Once a Republican western stronghold, Arizona has developed into one of the most hotly contested swing states in the nation. In 2020, Democrats captured both U.S. Senate seats for the first time since 1953, while Joe Biden (D-DE) became the first Democratic presidential nominee to carry the Copper State since Bill Clinton (D-AR) did so in 1996 - and the second since Harry Truman (D-MO) in 1948.

At the state level, Republicans only narrowly control both chambers of the state legislature.

In 2022, Arizona Secretary State of State Katie Hobbs (D-AZ) won a razor-thin contest over firebrand conservative personality Kari Lake (R-AZ), marking the first time Democrats won a gubernatorial contest in Arizona since

2006. Hobbs now enters the 2026 cycle as one of the most vulnerable governors in a state won by Trump. Of the seven core swing states last year, all of which were swept by Trump, Arizona showed the strongest support for Trump - a 5.53% margin.

Schweikert has represented suburban Phoenix in the House since 2011. But Phoenix’s rapid leftward shift in recent years is what’s pulled Arizona into swing state territory. In 2022, Schweikert barely survived re-election, winning by a fraction of a percentage point. In 2024, however, he won just under four points - close but more comfortable than his previous margin.

Schweikert faces fellow Congressman Andy Biggs (R, AZ-05) and Karrin Taylor Robson (R-AZ), a former member of the Arizona Board of Regents and candidate for governor in 2022. He leaves behind a competitive suburban district that could very well have a hand in deciding which party controls the lower chamber in 2027. If the 2024 levels of Republican support in suburban Phoenix remain constant by next year, then it is plausible there’s enough of a floor of support in this red-tilting district.

Also on the Hill, Congressman Tom Tiffany (R, WI-07) is also retiring to run for governor of Wisconsin. Two-term Governor Tony Evers (D-WI) passed on a third term, leaving an open seat on the table in a state where Trump won by almost one percentage point last year. Like Arizona, Wisconsin has become one of the most hotly contested swing states over the last few cycles. It is the only state that was decided by a margin of less than one point in each of the last three presidential elections.

Tiffany starts as the frontrunner in a yet-to-be-developed Republican primary and is probably one of the strongest candidates who could have entered the race thus far. He leaves behind a solidred WI-07, a district that encompasses the northwestern-central part of the state and includes the city of Appleton. This part of Wisconsin used to be much more in the Democratic fold on the local level, but since 2010, it’s raced to the right. In 2024, Tiffany was re-elected by almost thirty points.

State

The Siena College released its final September poll, showing President Trump with a favorability rating of 34%-61% (-27) and job approval rating of 37%-62% (-25). The former figure is his lowest such rating since September 2023.

Moreover, Governor Kathy Hochul (D) has clinched more than 50% in a 2026 gubernatorial poll, the first time she’s ever crossed that important threshold, according to Siena’s ongoing research. She leads likely candidate Congresswoman Elise Stefanik (R, NY-21) 52%-27% (+25).

This is a stark difference from last month’s +14 margin for Hochul over the Plattsburgh Republican.

Hochul’s favorability rating also received

a slight bump from August, now resting at 45%-42% (+3), up from 42%-44% (-2) in the late summer. Her approval rating sits at 54%-40% (+14), compared to just 53%42% (+9) in August. 61% of Democrats view Hochul favorably and 72% approve of her job performance. However, 48% of Independents view her unfavorably and are evenly divided - 47%-46% (+1) - on her job performance.

Hochul still faces a harrowing statistic; only 37% of voters say they would re-elect her. 51% prefer “someone else.”

In terms of the gubernatorial landscape for next year, the College tracked Hochul at +41 in New York City, +23 in the downstate suburbs, and +9 Upstate. The College also finds that Hochul leads with white voters46%-35% (+11) black voters - 73%-6% (+67) - and Latino voters - 65%-19% (+46).

The Siena College found that 23% of voters say that crime in New York State has gotten better, while 38% say it’s stayed the same, and 35% say it’s gotten worse.

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) has a 42%-45% (-3) favorability rating, up substantially from his 38%-50% (-12) rating in August. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D, NY-08) has a 34%-31% (+3) favorability rating, down from a 38%-27% (+11) spread in August. Overall, the College finds that 42% of New Yorkers think the state is on the “right track”, compared to 41% who disagree. This figure is up slightly from the 41%-45% (-4) figure poll last month. This is the first time the College has found a net-positive on this question since October 2021, just two months after Hochul took office. The Siena College poll was conducted September 8-10 among 802 registered New York State voters. It has a margin of error of +/- 4.2%.

Local

The Suffolk County Police Department (SCPD) has a new deputy commissioner. On October 3, Tom Galati was promoted to Deputy Commissioner. Galati recently retired from the NYPD with thirty-nine years of experience. There, he served as Chief of Intelligence and Counterterrorism. He was also recently appointed as the First National Security Advisor for the Major Cities Chief Association.

(Let to right) County Clerk Puleo, SCPD Commissioner Catalina, Deputy Commissioner Galati, County Executive Romaine (Credit - Suffolk County Police Department)

Smithtown Matters

Celebrating Columbus Day and Italian-American Heritage

This coming Monday, our state and our nation will celebrate Columbus Day, a cherished tradition that honors the courage, determination, and lasting contributions of Italian-Americans throughout history. This day is not just a celebration of one explorer; it is a tribute to the generations of Italian-Americans whose hard work, faith, and family values helped shape our communities and our country.

The first Columbus Day celebration dates back to 1792, commemorating the 300th anniversary of Christopher Columbus’ landing in 1492. For centuries, the Italian and Catholic communities of our nation have taken great pride in this day, and in 1937, it became a federal holiday by President Franklin Delano Roosevelt (D-NY).

Here in Suffolk County, we continue that tradition with pride and unity. This Saturday, October 11, 2025, the Town of Babylon and Town of Huntington will host the Annual Long Island Columbus Day Parade, presented by the New York State Sons and Daughters of Italy. The parade will step off at 1:00p.m. from the Deer Park Fire Department, located at 94 Lake Avenue, Deer Park, and will feature floats, music, cultural performances, and community spirit for all to enjoy.

Following the parade, the celebration will continue at the Constantino Brumidi Lodge #2211 on Deer Park Avenue, where the Italian Food, Music & Cultural

Festival will take place from 1:30p.m. to 9:00p.m. Families will enjoy authentic Italian food, live entertainment, and activities that showcase the rich traditions of Italian heritage.

This year, I am deeply honored to serve as one of the Grand Marshals, alongside outstanding leaders who have each made a difference in their communities: Sal Mangano, Babylon Town Supervisor Rich Schaffer (D-North Babylon), former News 12 anchor Danielle Campbell, Assemblyman Steve Stern (D-Dix Hills), and Enzo Bifulco, a proud 52-year member of the Cellini Lodge. My heartfelt thanks also go out to Parade Chairman Keith Wilson, the Deer Park Fire Department, and all the members of the Brumidi Lodge who make this annual celebration possible.

At a time when some seek to erase or replace our shared history, it is important to remember that celebrating one culture does not diminish another. Columbus Day honors the story of perseverance, faith, and family that unites generations of Americans. We are all part of this great nation’s fabric, and by embracing our history, we ensure that its legacy continues to inspire.

Wishing everyone a Happy Columbus Day, a day to celebrate heritage, community, and the enduring spirit of America, and hope to see everyone at the parade!

Kennedy Hosts Girl Scouts in Mock Legislature Session

Suffolk County Legislator Leslie Kennedy (R-Nesconset) hosted over forty Girl Scouts from Hauppauge for a hands-on introduction to the workings of the lawmaking process.

Ranging from sixth graders to high school seniors, ages 11 to 17, the girls participated in a mock legislative session, taking seats at the “horseshoe” and acting in the roles of the Presiding Officer, Legislators, and interested citizens to question, debate, and ultimately take a roll call vote on model legislation.

Prior to her service in government, Legislator Kennedy worked in numerous hospitals and private service as a Registered Nurse (RN) for 30 years. She has also worked in the private sector managing a business, and at a rehabilitation facility working with individuals who have substance abuse issues.

She spoke to the students about elected office and outlined the responsibilities and activities of county lawmakers.

“Today was a marvelous day, working with probably the largest number of kids that I’ve ever had at one of these presentations, said Kennedy. “This is a huge Girl Scout group from my district. They brought the entire troop. They all worked together.”

“The girls got to see that government is not as frightening as what some people think…that we get along, that you get to speak. You get to express your opinion. And even the last young girl at the end came up with suggestions as to how to improve a bill -- which shows how smart they all are! It’s just a pleasure. I congratulated them all,” added Kennedy.

The participants debated and conducted votes on specific issues of relevance to young citizens, including animal cruelty and public safety.

Students were separated into two groups, one in favor of the proposed resolution and the other against. As in a real legislative session, students gained an opportunity to listen to other perspectives on the issues and obtain new insights.

“We’re pleased to be able to provide this opportunity to the Girl Scouts,” said Presiding Officer Kevin McCaffrey (R-Lindenhurst). “Having the chance to learn how

local government works is an invaluable opportunity to enhance civics among our young people– who may one day embark on their own careers in public service. These future leaders had a chance to see what it’s like to consider, debate, and vote on an issue as we do in the Legislature each session. I hope their experience was enjoyable and educational. We thank them for visiting the Legislature and wish them good luck with all their future endeavors.”

Some of the Scouts shared their personal perspectives

“I think it was very fun. I enjoyed getting to speak my mind and speak about how I felt about the bills. It was very interesting to learn how stuff works,” said Lily Clysh, age 11.

“I enjoyed today. I think it was a lot of fun that we got to argue about the issues and debate. I got to talk about the lifetime ban, that if you abuse animals, you’re no longer allowed to get another one,” said Ella Muilenburg, age 13.

“I thought this program was really informative and I think it was a great opportunity, especially for girls who aren’t as confident in public speaking. It was a great chance for them to have a comfortable space to speak their mind, and get a unique experience that could help them later down the line with speaking to authority and processing government,” said Nicole Florio, 17-year-old high school senior,

Adults were also delighted with the experience.

“This was a fantastic program and the girls got into some pretty intelligent debate. They had such good insights that I think were important for adults to see and to see it from a kid’s perspective because they had some really valid points. I think that more kids should participate in a program like this and see how the actual government works and get a good understanding for how our laws come into play,” said Jennifer Muilenberg, the Service Unit Coordinator for Hauppauge Girl Scouts.

With summer vacations over, this mock legislature was another in a series of events with students. In 2025, scouts, middle schoolers, and high school students from districts across Suffolk County participated in similar programs.

Theater & The Arts

Leapin’ Lizards!

By Cindi Sansone-Braff

Thanks to Jeffrey Sanzel and Sari Feldman, a dynamic directing duo, “Annie,” the world’s most beloved familyfriendly musical, kicked off Theatre Three’s 55th Mainstage season on a high note. This classic two-act musical, featuring music by Charles Strouse, lyrics by Martin Charnin, and a book by Thomas Meehan, has become a staple of professional and amateur theaters worldwide.

The endearing character known as Little Orphan Annie has captured the hearts of children of all ages for 140 years. James Whitcomb Riley, the beloved American poet, published a poem in 1885, originally entitled “The Elf-Child.” This cautionary tale warned children of the dire consequences of disobeying their parents and was based on the reallife story of an orphan who lived with the Riley family. That well-known poem inspired Harold Gray’s 1924 comic strip, “Little Orphan Annie,” which in turn became the inspiration for the 1977 Broadway musical, “Annie,” a seven-time Tony Award winner.

Theatre Three’s latest production, and Erin Risolo’s award-worthy performance in the lead role, Annie, is definitely one of them. Risolo, waif-like and wonderful, opened the show with a pitchperfect rendition of “Maybe,” a wistful ballad in which Annie expresses a melancholic longing for her parents. With heartfelt conviction, Risolo masterfully delivers the musical’s signature song, “Tomorrow,” conveying its life-affirming message of hope, faith, and the promise of a brighter future. Emmie Rockwell, a delightful Wheaton Terrier mix, made her stage debut as Annie’s dog and sidekick, Sandy. Patti Rockwell, Emmie’s mommy and trainer, also had brief onstage moments!

onstage moment!

The multitalented children in the cast are another reason this show is a must-see, including Nora Andersen as July, Adriana Como as Duffy, Ava Day Lugo as Kate, Kathleen Arabelle Han as Tessie, Sadie Mathers as Molly (I loved her backflips across the stage), and Olive Oakes as Pepper. One of the show’s

“Annie” tells the tale of a resilient, street-smart, eleven-year-old orphan living in a bleak Hudson Street Orphanage in New York City during the Great Depression. After being chosen to spend Christmas with the wealthy industrialist Oliver Warbucks, her life changes dramatically for the better, although there are a few bumps along the way.

This show is chock-full of timeless themes that offer healing and hope, such as the idea that goodness is rewarded, evil is punished, love is the true currency of life, tomorrow will be better, and the importance of paying it forward.

There are so many reasons to see

highlights was “It’s the Hard-Knock Life,” a high-energy ensemble piece with mesmerizing dance moves and strong vocals.

Every time Julianne Greaves stepped on stage as Miss Hannigan, the snarky, sadistic, sloshed headmistress of the orphanage, she stole the show with her sultry dance moves and sinister antics.

Although she is one of the musical’s villains, she provides much of the show’s comic relief. Greaves’ powerhouse vocals, emotive facial expressions, gestures, and body language made “Little Girls” a dark comedic show tune, an unforgettable

Chris Dufrenoy aced the role of Oliver “Daddy” Warbucks, the selfassured, self-made, sometimes stern billionaire, who turns out to have a heart of gold, especially when it comes to Annie. Dufrenoy’s expert delivery of his solo “Something Was Missing” was a high point in the production. The onstage chemistry between Warbucks and his loyal secretary, Grace Farrell, convincingly portrayed by Samantha Fierro, added some romantic sizzle to the show.

Tim Moriates was sensational as President Franklin D. Roosevelt, delivering a “New Deal” just in time for Christmas, and he commanded the stage as Lt. Ward, the police officer who returns Annie to the orphanage.

Will Logan, a natural-born physical comedian, delivered a standout performance as Rooster, Miss Hannigan’s swarthy, slimy, scheming brother, and Heidi Jaye convincingly portrayed Rooster’s money-hungry, ditzy girlfriend, Lily St. Regis.

According to Sanzel, Sari Feldman, the co-director and choreographer, “Is a veteran of the national tour and brought a wealth of knowledge and experience…” This show features many excellent dance numbers, but the jazzy “Easy Street,” performed by Miss Hannigan (Greaves), Rooster (Logan), and Lily (Jaye), was a showstopper.

The stellar ensemble includes Sophie Carpenter, Jaden Chimelis, Sophia Del Carmen, Emilia Guzzetta, Jacob Lesko, Wesley Oakes, Ben Russman, Haley Saunders, Paul Schiller, Andrew Timmins, and Ryan Van Nostrand.

The production’s creative team also deserves recognition for its outstanding behind-the-scenes work. Period costumes by Ronald Green III perfectly captured the 1930s era, while Randall Parsons’ inventive set designs transported audiences to Depression-era New York. The live orchestra, conducted by Jeffrey Hoffman, brought exuberant energy to the musical numbers.

Toward the end of Act II, when the entire company belted out a heartfelt version of “Tomorrow,” I tried to contain my tears as I looked over at my husband, wiping tears from his eyes. There is a certain theatrical magic about this show that penetrates through the layers of human hardness and strikes right to the heart. It is no wonder Saturday evening’s performance received a long, thunderous standing ovation.

If you’re feeling a little down and out, head to Theatre Three and receive a pure infusion of positive energy from this upbeat show. Trust me, it’s good for what ails you! This spectacular show runs through October 19, 2025. To purchase tickets, please call the box office at 631928-9100 or visit www.theatrethree.com.

Cindi Sansone-Braff is an awardwinning playwright. She holds a BFA in Theatre from the University of Connecticut and is a member of the Dramatists Guild. She is the author of “Grant Me a Higher Love,” “Why Good People Can’t Leave Bad Relationships,” and “Confessions of a Reluctant Long Island Psychic.” Her full-length Music Drama, “Beethoven, The Man, The Myth, The Music,” is published by Next Stage Press. www.Grantmeahigherlove.com

By Matt Meduri

Candidate: Supervisor Ed Wehrheim

Residence: Kings Park

Candidate Spotlight

Supervisor Ed Wehrheim

Party Lines: Smithtown Town Supervisor

First Elected: 2017, Re-Elected 2021

Prior Elected Office: Town Council (appointed in 2003), elected in 2003, re-elected 2007, 2011, 2015.

Party Endorsements: Republican, Conservative

Notable Endorsements: Law Enforcement

Coalition (Suffolk Police Conference, Suffolk Probation Officers Assn., SCPBA, Suffolk Superior Officers Assn., Suffolk Detective Assn., Suffolk Deputy Sheriff’s PBA, Suffolk Correction Officers Assn.), Local Labor Unions (Local 200, Local 138, Building and Construction Trades Council of Nassau and Suffolk Counties), Congresswoman Elise Stefanik (R, NY21), Congressman Nick LaLota (R-Amityville), Suffolk County Executive Ed Romaine (R-Center Moriches), County Clerk Vincent Puleo (R-Nesconset), Presiding Officer Kevin McCaffrey (R-Lindenhurst), Suffolk County Majority Leader Legislator Nick Caracappa (C-Selden), Senator Mario Mattera (R-St. James), Assemblyman Mike Fitzpatrick (R-St. James).

Supervisor Wehrheim is running for a third term. In June, he defeated Suffolk County Legislator Rob Trotta (R-Fort Salonga) in the Republican Primary. The Smithtown Democratic Committee has endorsed Trotta on a write-in campaign, although Trotta is not actively campaigning in that regard. Rosemary Griffin (D-Kings Park), the original Democratic nominee, dropped out of the race in July but remains on the ballot.

Supervisor Wehrheim sat down with The Messenger for this candidate spotlight interview.

Q: What are some of your accomplishments across Town these past four years?

A: We’ve revitalized 75% of our parks—adding fields, inclusive playgrounds, and trails, while preserving new open space and planting over 3,000 trees. We acquired key properties like the former Oasis site to keep Smithtown green. We modernized the Town’s Comprehensive Plan for the first time since 1957, aligning zoning, housing needs for seniors and young families, and we did it protecting neighborhoods from commercial development, without sacrificing suburban character.

We’ve secured over $83 million in grants to improve roads, parks, and downtowns—from the restored Callahan’s Beach to the revitalized St. James Business District and downtown Kings Park, which is currently underway. During the pandemic, we led from the frontline—distributing PPE, organizing food relief, and safeguarding our most vulnerable residents. I’m especially proud of the recognition we’ve earned for restoring historic landmarks, building accessible spaces, and championing veterans, seniors, and youth. I look forward to continuing that work in the next term.

Q: Looking ahead to the next four years, what’s starting now that you’d like to shepherd through?

A: In the next term, I’m focused on bridging the digital divide by launching a STARLINK initiative to expand reliable internet/Wi-Fi access in underserved parts of Smithtown. We’ll complete the final phases of our parks restoration, downtown revitalizations, continue preserving open space and historic sites, and push forward critical infrastructure upgrades—including sewers, roadways, streetscapes, and walkable downtown improvements in all hamlets. I also look forward to leading the Town in celebrating America’s 250th birthday with meaningful, community-wide events that honor our history and bring people together.

Q: You’ve received a lot of criticism over development and housing. Council candidates are calling for a first-time homebuyer downpayment assistance program for the Town. First, what’s your response to how development has been handled in Town, and second, what do you make of such a program? Does the Town already have something in place, or is the County’s existent program sufficient?

A: We’ve been very clear and consistent— development in Smithtown is focused on revitalizing long-vacant, blighted commercial sites that drain our tax base. Every project must follow strict zoning, engineering, and environmental standards. The Town Board doesn’t approve zone changes—we review site plans after professional determinations are made. We’ve rejected projects when they were out of character or posed public safety concerns. But State law does not allow us to deny a project simply because some residents don’t like it—there must be a valid legal basis.

As for a first-time homebuyer assistance program, the Town legally cannot offer tax breaks or downpayment aid. We collect taxes on behalf of all levels of government and only retain 11 cents on the dollar. Programs like this must come from the County or State. That said, I fully support efforts that make Smithtown, Long Island, and New York, for that matter, more affordable for young families—and I’d gladly advocate for such initiatives at the County and State levels.

Q: What is your favorite quote, motto, work ethic, or words to live by?

A: During the primary, I shared a favorite quote that still rings true for me: “Action is the foundational key to all success.” – Picasso. But another quote that’s guided me just as much comes from President Ronald Reagan: “I know in my heart that man is good. That what is right will always eventually triumph. And there’s purpose and worth to each and every life.”

Leadership, to me, is about more than holding a title—it’s about showing up, listening, inspiring the next generation, and delivering real results. I’ve spent my entire career in public service—starting in the military, working blue-collar jobs, and now managing the Town I’ve called home my whole life. I believe hard work and dedication to the community are non-negotiable.

At the end of the day, I try to lead with integrity, give people the benefit of the doubt, and always choose what’s right—even when it’s not the popular thing to do. Those values are my compass, and they continue to guide me every day.

Q: How do you like to connect with your community?

A: Smithtown isn’t just where I serve—it’s where I was born and raised, where I raised my family, and where I’ve built a lifetime of memories. Living in Kings Park my entire life has given me a deep love and appreciation for this community, and I stay connected by being present in the places that matter most.

Whether I’m chatting with residents at a local coffee shop, cheering on our youth at a ballgame, or walking the trails in our beautiful parks, I never take for granted the privilege of serving the people I live among. I’m still an active member in local civic groups, I regularly attend senior center programs for their always honest feedback, and I make it a point to be at the parades, festivals, and chamber events that bring us all together.

What inspires me most is the pride that lives in every corner of Smithtown. It’s a place where neighbors look out for each other, where families stay for generations, and where community isn’t just a word—it’s a way of life. That spirit is what drives me every day, and it’s what I’m committed to protecting and uplifting as your Town Supervisor.

The Messenger thanks Supervisor Wehrheim for his time for this interview.

By Matt Meduri

Candidate Spotlight

Highway Superintendent Bob Murphy

Candidate: Highway Superintendent Bob Murphy Residence: St. James

Party Lines: Republican, Conservative

First Elected: Succeeded 2015, elected 2017, reelected 2021

Highway Superintendent Bob Murphy ascended to the office in 2015, and ran unopposed for the office in 2017 and 2021. He remains unopposed this year.

Superintendent Murphy sat down with The Messenger for this candidate spotlight interview.

Q: What is your professional background and how has it equipped you for the office of Highway Superintendent?

A: I have over twenty-five years of engineering experience and currently manage a workforce of over 130 employees. Smithtown has extensive infrastructure: 470 miles of roads, curbs, driveway aprons, drainage systems, and recharge basins. It’s a multi-million-dollar operating budget.

Before I came to the Town, I worked as a capital project manager for the Suffolk County Building and Engineering Department. I oversaw big public works projects there.

I also have private sector experience with engineering firms Sidney B. Brown & Son, LLP, and Cashin Associates.

Q: Over the last four years, apart from the minutia of maintaining roads, what are some of the bigger infrastructure projects you’ve spearheaded? Likewise, what aspects of the department internally have you overhauled or advanced, if applicable?

A: Beyond the routine paving, we’ve taken on real, community-scale upgrades. On Lake Avenue in St. James and in Kings Park’s downtown, we didn’t just repave—we rebuilt curb to curb. We took the same approach on Brooksite Drive and on Edgewood Avenue—which is underway now— focusing on full reconstruction with better drainage and pedestrian safety. The goal with all our roadways is longevity and flood reduction, not a cosmetic overlay. When the August 18–19 storm hit and Harbor Road in Stony Brook collapsed and the Stump Pond area flooded, we were boots on the ground. In addition to those resilience efforts, we built a temporary access road for homeowners who were cut off by the Harbor Road collapse so they had safe ingress and egress while permanent fixes moved forward. We stabilized the assets, restored access quickly, and advanced long-term repairs.

Internally, we’ve modernized how we prevent problems before they start. Our Clean Stream Program proactively clears and rehabilitates basins, outfalls, and culverts—especially in high water-table areas—to cut flood risk. We also launched a Fiber-Optic Camera study, deploying pipe crawlers with fiber-optic sensors to inspect, map conditions, and prioritize repairs. Combining that technology with data-driven planning has protected residents, avoided costly emergency failures, and improved road safety and flood resilience across the township.

Q: With sewers coming online in the Smithtown hamlet, Kings Park, and St. James, what role do you have in implementing that infrastructure? How have those endeavors been going?

A: We work in lockstep with Suffolk County and NYS Department of Transportation (DOT) to coordinate the entire project from start to finish. We are with all government agencies and contractors every step of the way from start to finish.

Q: Congressman Nick LaLota (R-Amityville) helped appropriated about $1.4M in wastewater infrastructure funds. How is your office, either solo and/or in tandem with the Town at-large, utilizing these funds not only for environmental mitigations, but also in plotting out the downtowns as far as infrastructure goes?

A: Smithtown was deeply grateful to receive $1.38 million dedicated to flood-mitigation from Congressman LaLota. We’re using it on the NY-25 north side municipal lot on Main Street—installing 16 drainage pools and 5 catch basins, fully renovating and regrading the lot so stormwater is captured and treated instead of racing into a Nissequogue River tributary and, ultimately, the Long Island Sound. That protects the watershed and spares our Main Street storefronts from the flash-flooding that’s caused tens of thousands of dollars in damage, while keeping one of the only North Side customer lots usable during storms. The goal is simple: dig once—upgrade drainage and circulation now in ways that support walkable, resilient downtowns and avoid paying twice later.

Bottom line: this funding is both environmental mitigation and economic development—it protects the river and gives our small businesses a reliable, flood-resilient Main Street.

Q: What is your favorite quote, motto, or work ethic?

A: “There is enough light for those who want to believe, and enough shadows to blind those who don’t.” — Blaise Pascal.

For me, that’s a reminder to choose gratitude and perspective every day—our families, grandkids especially, our health, our friendships, and this community we’re lucky to serve. I’m blessed with a fantastic team at Town Hall and in the Highway Department.

When I counsel one of my guys, who’s maybe struggling through something difficult, I try to point out not to sweat the small stuff, what you can not control and to focus on all the good, great and miraculous things that we take advantage of daily. If you focus on the good… you can get through the tough days.

Q: How do you like to connect with your community? (Favorite parks, restaurants, hobbies, family, etc. As personal or as private as desired)

A: I’m a townie at heart. I shop local and stay present—at King Kullen, grabbing coffee at 7-11 or Sweatwaters on Main Street, or chatting with folks at Mass on Sundays—because that’s where I hear what matters most to my neighbors. I make a point to show up: Senior Center programs, hospital fundraisers, youth sports, civic and chamber events. I also host healthawareness drives and, with my family, I “adopt” local families during the holidays to make the season a little brighter.

I connect by listening first. I ask questions, take notes, and follow through—if someone needs help, my job is to find a path to yes or be honest about what it will take to get there. I won’t claim to get it right 100% of the time, but I never stop trying. Walking our parks, cheering on our kids, and supporting small businesses keeps me grounded—and reminds me why serving this community is the best part of the job.

The Messenger thanks Superintendent Murphy for his time for this interview.

Civics 101

The Necessary Standard for American Education

Government Shutdowns

By Matt Meduri

Since the federal government shutdown is in effect as of October 1, we find it appropriate to discuss the technicalities and history of government shutdowns for our column this week.

What is a Government Shutdown?

The federal government’s fiscal year ends on September 30 every year. The original fiscal year started in July, going back from the 1840s until 1974, with the passage of the Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act. The move gave lawmakers more time to deliberate on budget decisions after the summer recess, as well as giving legislation more time to be finalized without a massive rush.

A shutdown occurs when funding legislation that is required to finance the next year’s government is not enacted before the fiscal year ends. The U.S. House and U.S. Senate are required to deliberate appropriations, pursuant to the separation of powers outlined by the Constitution. Since Congress controls the pursestrings of the nation, much of the responsibility is on them. The president then signs the agreed upon bill into law.

The House requires just a simple majority of votes218 votes with a full quorum - to pass a budget. Should a president veto a spending bill, a two-thirds majority - 290 votes with full quorum - is required to override the veto.

In the Senate, a supermajority - 60 votes - is required to pass most spending bills and continuing resolutions (CRs) - extended funding that keeps the government running for a set period of time. This vote is a procedural one to end debate and invoke cloture. In other words, the filibuster allows Senators the right to unlimited debate, often used as a tactic to delay or block votes on a measure. Overcoming that right to debate requires a supermajority of the Senate to invoke cloture - the procedure of ending a debate and taking a vote. This is where much of the consternation in this year’s shutdown can be found.

Before the 1980s, many federal departments and agencies continued their operations during a shutdown while minimizing nonessential services. However, the Antideficiency Act Amendments of 1982 was passed to prevent the incurring of expenditures in excess of appropriations approved by Congress. In other words, agencies were no longer allowed to spend what wasn’t earmarked by Congress. While this wasn’t intended to prohibit services during a shutdown, it is the primary reason that shutdowns are so sweeping.

What is Affected During a Shutdown?

A full federal shutdown causes a large number of civilian federal employees to be furloughed - a temporary lay-off. The Office of Personnel Management (OPM) reported that as of March 2025, there are about 2.3 million civilian federal employees. During the 2013 shutdown, one of the longest on record, some 800,000 employees were furloughed, 1.3 million saw delayed payments, GDP growth slowed 0.1-0.2% - at that time, the GDP was a larger sum than that of the cost to keep the government running - and a decrease in the confidence of the overall job market.

The Department of Defense often loses half of its civilian workforce during a shutdown. Programs affected by large appropriation measures - such as Social Security - could also be affected by delays, not an outright cessation. According to USA Today, the federal departments most affected by the current shutdown are the Environmental Protection Agency (89% of workers furloughed), Education (87%), Commerce (81%), Labor (76%), Energy (63%), and State (62%).

This column will seek to address the long-forgotten concept of civics and how it relates to American government in general, from the federal level to the local level. This column will explore Constitutional rights, the inner workings of government, the electoral process, and the obligations and privileges of citizens.

CreditMatt Meduri

agencies except the legislative branch. 241,000 employees were furloughed with a cost of $80-$90 million. Democrats controlled both chambers of Congress.

1984: President Reagan oversaw a four-hour shutdown that affected only some agencies, furloughed $500,000 employees, and cost $65 million. Republicans controlled the Senate, while Democrats controlled the House.

1986: President Reagan again saw a four-hour shutdown that affected all agencies, saw 500,000 employees furlived, and cost $62.2 million. Republicans controlled the Senate, while Democrats controlled the House.

National Parks often bear the brunt of federal shutdowns. However, the parks are currently operating under a contingency plan. They remain open but with reduced staff and services. Trails, roads, and lookouts are accessible, but some buildings, shops, and facilities that require staff might be closed.

Additionally, Small Business Administration (SBA) loan approvals, Federal Housing Administration (FHA) mortgage issuances, nutrition programs, museums, and federal student grant and loan applications are just some of the sweeping effects of a federal shutdown.

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) is reported to furlough 25% of their staff. Roughly 33,000 employees will stay on the job since their work is deemed “necessary to protect life and property.”

What’s Still Running?

According to USA Today, the federal departments least affected are Agriculture (49% of workers furloughed), Defense (45%), Health and Human Services (41%), Transportation (23%), Social Security Administration (12%), Justice (11%), Homeland Security (5%), and Veterans Affairs (3%).

Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid payments will still be disbursed, although patients might experience delays in getting assistance.

Essential personnel, such as air traffic controls, Transportation Security Administration (TSA) agents, and Border Patrol officers will continue to work, but without pay. The FBI and DEA will also remain on the clock.

More than one million employees are keeping the Department of Defense running, although without pay. The Pentagon cannot start any new programs or award contracts. Overseas commissaries will remain open but on a limited basis. Elective medical procedures and surgeries within the military are postponed.

The Internal Revenue Services (IRS) will continue to operate, but since the shutdown has persisted for more than five days, the department is in unchartered waters. Democrats in 2022 enacted special funding to avoid furloughing most of the IRS’ 75,000 employees for the first business days after a shutdown.

How Many Shutdowns Has the U.S. Had?

The federal government has had eleven shutdowns since 1980.

1980: President Jimmy Carter (D-GA) presided over a shutdown that lasted one day, affected just the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), furloughed 1,600 employees, and cost $700,000 to the government. Democrats controlled both chambers of Congress.

1981: President Ronald Reagan (R-CA) presided over another one-day shutdown that ceased operations for all

1990: President George H. W. Bush (R-TX) presided over a three-day shutdown that affected all agencies, but only furloughed 2,800 employees and cost $2.57 million. Democrats controlled both chambers of Congress.

November 1995: President Bill Clinton (D-AR) oversaw a five-day shutdown that affected some agencies, furloughed 800,000 employees, and cost $400 million. Republicans controlled both chambers of Congress.

1995-1996: President Clinton saw a 21-day shutdownthen the longest in history and currently the secondlongest - that affected some agencies, furloughed 284,000 employees and cost $400 million. Republicans controlled both chambers of Congress.

2013: President Barack Obama (D-IL) presided over a 16-day shutdown that affected all agencies, furloughed 800,000 employees and cost $2.1 billion. Democrats controlled the Senate, while Republicans controlled the House.

January 2018: President Donald Trump (R-NY) oversaw a three-day shutdown that affected all agencies, furloughed 692,900 employees and cost an unknown amount. Republicans controlled both chambers of Congress.

2018-2019: The longest shutdown in history lasted 35 days, affected only some agencies, furloughed 380,000 and cost $5 billion - the most expensive in history. President Trump worked alongside a Republican House and Senate at the time.

2025: The current and ongoing shutdown is, as of press time at 17 days. All agencies are affected and some 803,300 employees are furloughed - the most ever for a federal shutdown. The cost is currently TBD. Republicans currently control both chambers of Congress.

Presidents Reagan and Trump are tied with the most shutdowns per term at three each. However, the shutdowns during the Reagan years lasted for brief periods.

How to Reopen the Government

Congress needs to pass an appropriations bill that funds the departments and agencies that have been shut down. The president must then sign the bill and does not have unilateral power to end the shutdown.

Currently, Democratic Senators are being courted to achieve the 60 votes needed to end the filibuster and invoke cloture. Three Democratic Senators sided with all 53 Republicans - Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV), John Fetterman (D-PA), and Angus King (I-ME) - to invoke cloture, but seven votes short of the needed supermajority. Not only are these political mavericks being courted yet again, but Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-SD) is looking to Senators Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), Dick Durbin (D-IL), Gary Peters (D-MI), and John Ossoff (D-GA) to possibly cross the aisle. All, except for Durbin, represent political swing states, with Ossoff being up for re-election next year. Peters is vacating his competitive Michigan seat, as is Shaheen in New Hampshire.

Around Town

DPW Completes CR-93 - the ‘Curve’ - Road Diet

The overhaul targets the hazardous curve between Woodlawn Avenue and Kirk Avenue, a section of road that for decades has plagued Ronkonkoma and Nesconset with high-speed accidents and poor visibility.

What’s Been Done

The project, developed from a 2023 redesign plan approved after extensive public input, includes several significant safety improvements:

• A road diet reducing CR-93 to one lane in each direction along the curve

• A realignment of the Ocean Avenue and Rosevale Avenue intersection to improve sight distance

• New pedestrian crossings with countdown timers at Woodlawn Avenue/Ontario Street, Kirk Avenue/ Town Park, Richmond Boulevard, and CR-67/Motor Parkway

• Milled-in rumble strips (SHARDs) along the shoulder to warn drivers who drift from their lane

• Fresh paving from Michigan Avenue to 400 feet south of CR-16

These changes follow road diet simulations conducted in summer 2023. Engineers recorded a nine-mph drop in average speeds and only minor increases in travel time, suggesting the approach could reduce crashes without creating significant delays.

Community Response

Public reaction to the redesign was initially mixed. Many residents welcomed the changes, calling them a long-overdue step toward safety. Others raised concerns about potential congestion, side-street access, and the possibility that speeding drivers will continue to ignore the road design without more vigorous enforcement.

At last year’s public forum, hosted by the Greater Ronkonkoma Civic Association and Suffolk County Legislators Trish Bergin (R-East Islip) and Leslie Kennedy (R-Nesconset), community members debated the plans. Some advocated for roundabouts or speed traps, while others questioned the removal of turn lanes and expressed concerns about rush-hour backups.

However, residents seem to be pleased with the results.

“The initial proposal was panned because the DPW wanted to road diet Ocean/Rosevale starting at Portion Road in the north and near the Long Island Expressway in the south,” Greater Ronkonkoma Civic Association President Sal Napolitano told The Messenger. “But many have been surprised at how well the road diet has worked out.”

Napolitano says that the community hasn’t seen congestion, even with school buses stopped, and that visibility and accessibility have been improved at the entrances and exits of the curve.

“This is a great example of government listening to the community and everyone working collaboratively to achieve a solution to a problem,” said Napolitano.

Monitoring and Flexibility

DPW officials emphasize that the project will not end with construction. The roadway will be closely monitored for crash data, speed reductions, and driver behavior, with metrics collected in partnership with law enforcement and other agencies.

“Any future roadway modifications, if any, would depend on the specific

details of the post-road diet crash history,” DPW Commissioner Charlie Bartha told The Messenger. If post-project data indicates that problems persist, DPW will consider remedial measures. While there is no rigid fallback plan, county engineers note that adjustments—such as striping modifications or lane reconfigurations—can be made quickly if benchmarks are not met.

Looking Ahead

With the main construction complete, sidewalk improvements are scheduled to begin later this year, adding another layer of safety and accessibility for pedestrians and cyclists.

For residents who have spent decades pressing for change, the CR-93 redesign represents a significant step forward. Whether the improvements will fully solve the dangers of the curve will depend on the months of monitoring ahead—but for now, Suffolk County has delivered on its promise to make one of its most notorious stretches of road safer.

Letter to the Editor: Concern Over Unprofessional Behavior by Town Leadership

I am writing to express my deep concern over the increasingly unprofessional behavior exhibited by our Town Supervisor and members of the Town Council during the Town Board meeting on October 2, 2025. As residents, we expect our elected officials to conduct themselves with integrity, respect, and a commitment to serving the best interests of our community. Unfortunately, what we witnessed on October 2 was behavior that undermines public trust and demeans the offices these individuals hold.

Shala Pascucci (D-Kings Park) attempted to speak at the board meeting on a specific agenda item that she and many residents believe highlights ongoing issues with the current Town administration. Yes, it is a fact Shala Pascucci is running for the Suffolk County Legislature’s Thirteenth District (LD-13), but she identified herself and was speaking only as a resident of Kings Park. Ms. Pascucci was speaking to agenda item 2944, and her comments were directly related to that agenda item. Mr. Wehrheim angrily shut her down

and had her escorted out of the room. Public service demands accountability and maturity, qualities that seem to be in short supply among some of our current officials. I implore all residents to go to the Town website www.smithtownny.gov and click on the Town Board meeting of October 2 and witness firsthand the treatment endured by a tax paying resident by Supervisor Wehrheim and Councilwoman Inzerillo.

Town meetings are meant to be spaces for respectful dialogue and responsible decision-making. It is disappointing and frankly unacceptable when residents who raise legitimate concerns are met with condescension or ignored entirely.

Our community deserves better. This includes listening with respect, debating with civility, and always acting with professionalism. It’s time for a change in Smithtown.

Sincerely,

Phyllis Hart Chair of the Smithtown Democrats

The start of the road diet at the curve, facing north (Credit - Matt Meduri)

Around Town

Thursday, October 9, 2025

Ronkonkoma Station Ice & Coal Company

By Ellyn Okvist B.Sc.

There were basic necessities needed in a home or business in the Village of Lake Ronkonkoma, and starting in the 1900s, two of them were ice and coal.

Coal was a vital energy source for the village’s homes and businesses, with the Long Island Rail Road serving as the primary method of delivery before the widespread use of natural gas and oil.

Artificial ice had largely replaced natural or harvested ice in New York City, and its transport by the Long Island Rail Road bought the product here for distribution for local use. Harvested ice were blocks of ice cut from a frozen pond or lake during the winter. The blocks were stored in large, insulated icehouses until they were loaded onto rail cars for delivery to ice distributors. The ice was delivered by the local iceman, who were a popular fixture in many neighborhoods. Households would often put a card in their window indicating they needed a new block of ice. The household ice delivery business would eventually become obsolete due to the widespread adoption of electric refrigerators.

“Artificial ice” or “clean ice”, as it was known, for household use was a block of ice manufactured in industrial ice plants using a refrigeration process, which was then delivered to homes for use in iceboxes. By 1940, however, mechanical home refrigerators were increasingly common, allowing people to make their own ice at home, making the ice delivery service less prevalent by the end of the decade.

To make artificial ice, large factories used complex machinery to freeze water in large, lidded cans submerged in a tank of ammonia-cooled brine. Water was poured into rectangular cans, and the tanks remained submerged in the brine for up to three days to freeze completely. After freezing, a crane would hoist the blocks of ice out of the cans, and the blocks would be cut and packed for delivery to homes. Residents placed blocks of this artificial ice in iceboxes, which were essentially wooden chests lined with zinc to keep them insulated and preserve food. Deliverymen would bring these blocks to homes, and homeowners and often used a card in their front window to indicate how much ice they needed for the day.

In the early years, before 1905, the majority of the entire yield of coal shipped from Pennsylvania was all destined for markets in New York. This was due in large measure to the fact that many influential members of the newly-created coal industry had significant interests in New York industries that required a good supply of coal.

One of the most important commodities handled by the LIRR was anthracite coal; bituminous coal was also transported. Up to the mid1950s, just about every town had at least one coal dealer with track-side facilities. The coal would be delivered and

stockpiled in the coal bins, with sides but no top, for easy access for local delivery.

The Ronkonkoma Station Ice & Coal Company was the local distributor of both ice and coal here in historic Lake Ronkonkoma. They were located on Hawkins Avenue just before the railroad tracks, and owned and operated by Sylvester Germano (1883-1975) born in Palombaio, Italy. Once he moved to the U.S., he married Antoinette Mitolo Germano (1886-1950) born in Bari, Italy. Their son, Nicholas Germano (1927–1996), was employed by his family, and he worked when not in school or during his deployment in World War II, U.S. Army, TEC 4. There were two daughters of Sylvester and Antoinette, Angelina “Lillie” Germano Anderson and Grayce Germano Dwyer. The well-respected family lived and operated the business for many years.

Their sales ticket, shown in the photograph (left), displays the other products sold - fuel oil, kerosene, and the installation of oil burners. Coal had been phased out in most of the United States, and the oil industry had moved in. They adapted to the times.

Thank you to our friends the Germano Family who continue to add happiness to our lives and in keeping our history real. Nicholas Germano and Gail Germano hold Military Tribute Banners for their military service to the USA and can be seen on Hawkins Avenue.

The old wooden water at the railroad station.

Published by Messenger Papers, Inc.

Thursday, October 9, 2025

SCHUMER SHUTDOWN: Trump, Republicans Expose Democrat Schemes to Give Taxpayer Benefits to Illegal Aliens

By Shane Harris | AMAC Newsline Editor-In-Chief

Desperate to shirk blame for the ongoing government shutdown, Democrats are now attempting to muddy the waters around their efforts to restore taxpayer-funded benefits for illegal aliens. But the facts are not on their side, and even liberals’ erstwhile allies in the corporate media have been unable to throw them a political lifeline.

As their price for providing the Senate votes to reopen the government, Democrats are demanding that Republicans reverse Medicaid reforms in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBB) that President Donald Trump signed into law this July. That legislation closed glaring loopholes in the program which allowed illegal aliens to enjoy taxpayer-funded healthcare and other benefits that should be reserved for American citizens.

Specifically, the Democrat continuing resolution that Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries are demanding the GOP pass repeals Sec. 71109 of the OBBB, titled “Alien Medicaid Eligibility.” That provision restricts Medicaid eligibility to U.S. citizens, lawful permanent residents, and a few other small groups.

Previously, Medicaid benefits were available to a shockingly broad set of “qualified aliens,” including parolees and asylum seekers. The Biden administration engaged in the most egregious abuse of the asylum system in American history, granting that status to millions of people who did not meet the requirements. As a result, this “qualified aliens” language meant that vast swaths of the 10-20 million people who crossed the border illegally during the Biden years could have applied for and received Medicaid –putting immense stress on the program and preventing American citizens from accessing the care they are entitled to.

Sections 71110, 71201, 71303, and 71302 of the OBBB make similar changes to ensure that taxpayer funds for emergency room visits, Medicare, and Affordable Care Act plans do not go to illegal aliens. Democrats are now demanding that Republicans repeal these provisions as well.

As the political pressure ramps up, Democrats are simply insisting that Republicans are lying. “Not a single federal dollar goes to providing health insurance for undocumented immigrants. NOT. ONE. PENNY,” Schumer posted on X on Monday, just before the shutdown commenced. “Republicans would rather lie and shut down the government than protect your health care.”

But as Center for Renewing America Senior Advisor Wade Miller succinctly explained in a post responding to Schumer, it is Democrats who are being dishonest about taxpayer benefits for illegal aliens.

“Here is how it works,” Miller wrote. “Federal dollars go to a Democrat state for healthcare, and since money is fungible, they then move state dollars over to fund illegals, which is made possible by federal dollars filling the gap where state dollars should be going.”

In a separate post, JD Vance continued to school Democrats on fungibility. “Consider, for instance, two state Medicaid programs – Ohio and New York. New York gives Medicaid to illegals and Ohio doesn’t. When the government gives billions of dollars to New York for Medicaid, that frees up state money in New York that can then be spent on illegals.”

“It’s like if you give a mobster $100 but he PROMISES you he won’t spend the money to buy a gun and commit a crime,” Vance continues. “Well, he takes the $100 you gave him and buys food, and then takes the money he would have spent on food and uses that money to buy the gun instead. This is what ‘money is fungible’ means.”

Democrats’ dishonesty on their burning desire to funnel taxpayer dollars to illegals is so outrageous that even the liberal media can’t cover for it.

During an interview with CNN’s Jake Tapper, Jeffries again stated that the notion that Democrats want to provide Medicaid to illegal aliens is a “lie.” But Tapper quickly shot back that “what you support does bring back funding for emergency Medicaid to hospitals, some of which does pay for undocumented immigrants and people who don’t have health insurance.”

“Why even include that in a bill, knowing that they’re going to seize right upon that and use that to message?” Tapper asked. “I understand that when you retake the House, you can get whatever you want passed, but at this point?” Jeffries had no coherent answer.

Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren was the next Democrat up to try to explain why her party is keeping the government shut to demand taxpayer-funded healthcare for illegal aliens. During an appearance on CBS with Tony Dokoupil, she went ballistic when presented with the exact language of Democrats’ bill, refusing to even allow Dokoupil to complete his question and calling it a “flat out lie.”

“Politically, putting that in there, exposes you to this talking point,” Dokoupil noted, echoing Tapper. “Why put it in there? Why is it worth it?” Like Jeffries, Warren deflected.

Democrats clearly recognize that what they are proposing is deeply unpopular with the American public, and even with most Democrat voters. But they are caught in a bind because handing out taxpayer dollars to illegal aliens remains a policy that elected Democrats and the progressive base are deeply committed to. Their position, as they have stated so many times, is that healthcare is a “human right.”

A resurfaced clip from 2020 now making the rounds on social media provides all the evidence Americans need for where Democrats

Overview - AMACThe Association of Mature American Citizens

The Association of Mature American Citizens represents Americans 50 plus. AMAC is centered on American values, freedom of the individual, free speech, and exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, rule of law, and love of family, with benefits at all levels.

AMAC plays a vital role in helping build the services that will enrich the lives of America’s seniors. AMAC Action, a 501 (C)(4) advocates for issues important to AMAC’s membership on Capitol Hill and locally through grassroots activism. To Learn more, visit amac.us

truly stand. During the first primary debate on NBC, every single participant on stage raised their hand to confirm that they support providing taxpayer-funded healthcare for “undocumented immigrants.”

For Democrats, every policy fight – including the current shutdown – has become about how much money they can smuggle to their favored groups, chief among them illegal aliens. That is why they have refused to vote for the exact same funding levels they voted for in March and voted for 13 times when Biden was in office.

Now Democrats want Republicans and President Trump to be their coconspirators in selling out and betraying the American people. That’s what this shutdown ultimately comes down to, and why Democrats are entirely to blame for whatever negative consequences result from it.

WORD OF THE Week

Etymology: mid 16th century: archaic past participle of stay.

STAID

adjective

Pronounced: /stayd/

Definition: sedate, respectable, and unadventurous.

Example: “Her staid demeanor on the debate stage won her immense public support.”

Synonyms: quiet, serious, steady

Antonyms: daring, frivolous, informal

Source: Oxford Languages

9, 2025

LEVEL: Hard

See how many words you can create. Must have center letter in word and can use letters more than once. 4 letter word minimum.

This Week in History

October 9, 1986: “The Phantom of the Opera” premieres in London, written by Andrew Lloyd Webber and starring Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman; runs for 13,629 performances.

October 14, 1933: Nazi Germany announces its withdrawal from the League of Nations.

October 12, 1999: The Day of Six Billion is proclaimed as the 6 billionth living human in the world is born.

October 10, 1899: African-American inventor Isaac R. Johnson patents the bicycle frame.

October 15, 1860: Abraham Lincoln (R-IL) receives a letter from eleven-year-old Grace Bedell asking him to grow “whiskers” ahead of the 1860 presidential election. Lincoln obliges.

Source: Onthisday.com.

October 11, 1945 First man-made object to escape the atmosphere (WAC Corporal) is fired from White Sands Missile Range, New Mexico, reaching 235,000 feet.

October 13, 1884: International Meridian Conference in Washington DC establishes Greenwich in London, England as the universal time meridian of longitude.

By PJ Balzer

The Hope I Found at the Bottom

This past week, someone I’m familiar with was found guilty of taking another person’s life.

In a few moments of anger, many split-second decisions were made. The end result was extremely sad, unfortunate, and changed life as we knew it for various people. After a long and contentious trial, the jury spoke, the gavel sounded, and many peoples’ lives are forever altered by those few moments of altercation that I’m sure everyone would want to re-do if that was possible.

When I went to visit this person in Riverhead Correctional Facility shortly after the incident took place, his mind was totally set on having a positive outlook and speaking positive outcomes into existence. He said he would be found innocent and be home sooner than later. He was able to hire a good lawyer and figured that this was the ticket to freedom. We finished the conversation by him telling me what he had planned to do once he arrived home and continued on with life as usual.

I believe I’m safe to say that the bottom of life dropped for him this week. On top of the jury handing the judge a guilty verdict, this man is well up in age.The truth is that he may never see the outside world again. He very well may take his final breath in a maximum security prison in Upstate New Yorkdefinitely not the utopian end to life that anyone has written up for themselves, but actions have consequences and a decision made in haste can change things forever.

I’m no stranger to the bottom of life suddenly falling out and having to navigate a life that I never wanted for myself. As many of you have probably read prior, I lost my younger brother to a heroin overdose in 2009. He was only twenty-two at the time, a young man just attempting to figure out his way in life. Within one phone call on a random weekday late afternoon, life changed forever. Yet, that very bottom is where I heard the message that changed my own life and altered my eternity.

I wasn’t willing to hear that same message while I was at, what I thought was, the top. Like the sentiment of many, “I’m young, good looking, have multiple streams of cash flowing in, and have plans for my future. What would I need God for? Maybe for a little feel-good inspiration on a Sunday morning, but not for a complete heart and life overhaul.”

Jesus tells His followers to go out and share the message of the Gospel - go to all people, but especially those who are at the bottom of life and society. Go to where people are completely crushed, depressed, trapped, desperate, and despairing of life; Tell them that He offers forgiveness, a clean slate, and a brand-new life. He offers hope, peace, and a reason to continue living life, even if you very well may finish living your life behind bars and barbed wire, He’ll still meet you there.

The Apostle Paul wrote many of his letters to other believers from behind prison walls. Those same letters make up much of our New Testament we have today. Specifically, the letter he penned to the Philippian church is known as a letter of hope and joy, a great encouragement to, not only the church in that city at that time, but also to us at this very moment. Paul was writing from a dark, dingy prison underground that would make our modern-day facilities look like

Disneyland. It’s from that cell that he writes to remind us that there’s a joy found in following Jesus, regardless of where that following may or may not lead us.

Paul had obviously found it and found something that this world alone doesn’t offer. Looking with earthly-focused eyes, the bottom had certainly fallen out for Paul and he would soon be put to death in Rome, but he was looking forward to a great reward waiting for him at the eternal gates for doing and finishing God’s will for his life on earth.

I spent this morning praying for this man that I began telling you about and praying for you as well - especially you, who has recently had life crumble down to merely rubble, a rubble that you hardly recognize and could never see any hope of rebuilding from. I’ve been praying that the message you haven’t been willing to hear while on “top” would reach into the depths of your heart while at what seems to be the bottom.

“Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, they are a new creation. The old passes away and all things become new.” - 2 Corinthians 5:17

On September 30, Hauppauge High School’s turf field was a sea of pink as students, staff and community members gathered to show their support at the 18th annual Kicks for Cancer event. This year, the event raised more than $44,000, bringing the cumulative total raised over the years to hit the one-million-dollar mark.

Kicks for Cancer was created to support and honor Courtney Tomkin, a Hauppauge student who was diagnosed with brain cancer at 17 years old. Following her diagnosis, Alexis Gonzalez, the girls’ varsity soccer team’s goalkeeper at the time, approached coach Jesseca Kulesa with the idea of helping Courtney and her family. That idea became the spark that started what is now a cherished community tradition.

Beneath the glow of the Robert Druckenmiller Field lights, the crowd erupted with cheers as the

boys’ and girls’ soccer teams took the field, sporting pink uniforms in honor of the cause. The boys team faced off against Eastport-South Manor Junior-Senior High School, earning a dominant 9-0 victory.

The girls team competed against Comsewogue High School, playing a hard-fought game that ended in a narrow 0-1 loss. Between games, the energy remained high thanks to performances by the Hauppauge kickline, color guard and pep band.

The night was more than just soccer; it was a community celebration. Food trucks and vendor tents offered everything from homemade gifts and sweet treats to Kicks for Cancer merchandise.

Attendees enjoyed a variety of activities, including bounce houses and raffles. All proceeds from the event will go towards cancer research and efforts to find a cure in memory of Courtney.

Hauppauge Teams Rally at 18th Annual Kicks for Cancer

Smithtown East Boys Football Wins on Homecoming

By Ashley Pavlakis

The Smithtown East Bulls turned on the lights for their homecoming game this past Saturday against the Commack Cougars. A thrilling end to homecoming was the icing on the cake to a perfect fall day of football. The East Bulls are members of the New York State Public High School Athletic Association (NYSPHSAA) and compete in DIV II. The boys are led by first-year head coach Greg Lauri. He comes to Smithtown East after spending the last seven seasons as an offensive coordinator for Sachem North. The squad is 2-2 to start the season.

To put it gently, the Bulls have not won very much over the last few years. With that, change is expected. Change came at the helm, and Greg Lauri took over, eager to develop a new culture at Smithtown East. His motto? S.W.I.N.G.

The acronym stands for Sacrifice, Wisdom, Integrity, Nerve, and Growth. This motto is displayed on the back of their team shirts, serving as a reminder for each day they step onto the field for practice or a game, representing the red and white Bulls.

On Saturday evening, the Bulls took to the turf under the lights for the first time in school history, according to the school district. Nighttime sporting events outdoors are always more fun; that’s a fact. The student section was absolutely packed, both past and present Smithtown East alumni and students filled the bleachers - a blackout in the stands and bright lights on the field. The Bulls student section was decked out in black, equipped with signs, eyeblack, and bandanas in support of their beloved Bulls

After a day filled with the homecoming parade and the crowning of the 2025 king & queen, football was to be played. Congratulations to Dyson Brown and Giulia Clark on being crowned Smithtown East’s king & queen! The Bulls started off slow in the first half, only scoring a touchdown in each quarter. The Cougars, on the other hand, took advantage of a slow start and headed into halftime leading 27-7. A comeback was on the horizon for the Bulls if they wanted any chance of ending homecoming on a positive note. In the third quarter, they started their comeback, recording a TD and an FG to bring the score to 34-24 Commack. Not too bad with one quarter left to go. One touchdown and two field goals while keeping the Cougars off the board in the fourth saw East emerge victorious.

Niko Stroveglia had himself a day on Saturday, accounting for 13 of his team’s 37 points. The kicker went four-for-four on his extra point attempts and kicked three field goals. Perhaps his most crucial moment was in the dying seconds of the game. With eight seconds on the clock, Stroveglia took the field at the 30-yard line with the game tied 34 apiece. As luck would have it, Stroveglia’s attempt was successful. Game over, 37-34 Bulls.

The student section stormed the field to celebrate the thrilling win with their team. The field invasion is typically seen at the collegiate level after a huge win, often reserved for special occasions. The Bulls’ win was certainly huge, and getting to celebrate together made it all the more special.

By PJ Balzer

No Shortage of Power on This Parkway

This past Saturday afternoon was the annual Parkway Power Bowl. It’s two high schools that are only 8.7 miles apart. Within those miles is William Floyd Parkway, a main strip of roadway that these two communities have in common. In some of the residential neighborhoods along this parkway, students on one side of the block attend William Floyd, while their friends on the opposite side of the street attend Longwood.

This is a rivalry that is now many decades old. The two communities both also have a passion for the sport of football. It’s not uncommon to drive through Ridge, Middle Island, or Coram and see a “Lions Country” banner. In the same way it’s also not uncommon to see kids walking down Mastic Road, Neighborhood Road, or Montauk Highway with shirts that scream “Floyd Strong.”

The Colonials and the Lions have strong fan bases and districts that rally around their student athletes. Both undoubtedly breed fearless kids that aren’t afraid to take a hit and give one out too. The Power Parkway Bowl is an in-league matchup that comes with bragging rights and much community pride. It even has its own trophy that the winner proudly displays in their trophy case until next year’s game. It’s been sitting in Floyd’s for nine consecutive years now; this year makes it ten.

On Saturday afternoon, the Suffolk County Police Department was on site to assist in the coin toss. The officers in attendance also handed the trophy to the winner at the game’s end. The Seventh Precinct takes part in this specific afternoon because they also serve and patrol most of the neighborhoods in both school districts.

Defense was the name of the game in the first half. Both teams held up their line and made sure their pads got the work that they were designed for, and then some. Floyd had a solid offense drive down the turf in the second quarter but picked up two consecutive penalties that cut the momentum short.

Midway through the second quarter, the contentious and back-

and-forth game was still a scoreless deadlock, until late in the second quarter when the Lions drove the ball upfield and secured a field goal with just a minute left in the first half.

Halftime seemed to ignite a fire inside the motor of one of the Island’s most revered running backs. Ja’Quan Thomas finished the game with 215 yards and 2 touchdowns for Floyd, and began the second half with an impressive series of pivots up field for a long carry into the end zone. This put Floyd up 7-3.

Longwood put the Colonials’ defense up to the test time and time again. Floyd came up with three major stops just feet from the goal line to end the third quarter, keeping the Lions away from celebrating in the paint.

But a Lion doesn’t just lay down in defeat with ease. Longwood opened the fourth quarter up with a short pass from quarterback Ryan Greene into the end zone making it 10-7. Aisays Wallace of Floyd answered back with a swift and shifty run upfield to complement Ja’Quan Thomas’ bulldozer-style run up the middle to make it 14-10 with 8:11 left in fourth.

Aidan Williams had a sack on Longwood’s quarterback coupled with a swatted-away pass attempt on third down to get Floyd the ball back with four minutes left in the game. After a tough drive upfield, Aisays Wallace runs in a dime-cutting touchdown from yards out to make it 21-10. Wallace contributed 102 yards on nine carries and one touchdown, with a sack on Longwood’s quarterback as well.

Longwood scored again on a long pass from Greene to wide receiver Kaden Reid with only 40 seconds left in the game, yet the Lions still fell short of taking home the Parkway Bowl trophy. The final score at the last whistle was 21-18 with the Colonials beating the Lions for the tenth consecutive year.

William Floyd increased its unbeaten season to 4-0, while Longwood fell to 2-2. Don’t be surprised if these cross-town rivals end up going back at it again in early November playoff action!