SPD | Spring 2024

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

Studio Light Shading Device

Collaborative Design Class

Changing Studio Lighting Conditions

Self-Collab Design

Professor Ignacio Cardona

Spring 2024 Semester

2

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

STUDIO LIGHT SHADE DESIGN CHANGING THE LIGHTING CONDITIONS OF STUDIO FOR A BETTER QUALITY WORKING ENVIRONMENT

3

4

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

DESIGN TEAM Student Team: Gabe Blake Alex Chin Jared Cooney Ivan Kadurov Robbie Gaskins Alyssa Hill Timeus Mulinge Laura Pease Charlie Perechinsky Quincy Thomas Amber Vuong Mel Wilson Studio Professor: Ignacio Cardona 2024

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

5

BOOK CONTENTS List of Figures INTRODUCTION

P r e l i m i n a r y Vo t i n g Existing Conditions R e s e a rc h & An a ly s i s St u d e n t & Fa c u l t y S u r v e y s Consensus & Findings D e s i g n P roc e s s F o r m & D e s i g n Te s t i n g Fa b r i c a t i o n D e s i g n Te s t i n g D e s i g n I m p l e m e ntation Photos from Assembly K I T O F PA R T S MA N U AL

6

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: Class Rubric Created by Students Figure 2: Student Tactical Intervention #1 Figure 3: Student Tactical Intervention #2 Figure 4: Student Tactical Intervention #3 Figure 5: Student Tactical Intervention #4 Figure 6: Student Tactical Intervention #5 Figure 7: Student Tactical Intervention #6 Figure 8: Survey Question #2 What Grade Level Are You? Figure 9: Survey Question #3 What about Studio Would You Liked to See Changed?

Figure 10: Info-graphic Displaying Percentage of Students Who Believe Lighting is a Critical Issue Figure 11: Student Answers to Survey Regarding Taking Personal Action to Change the Lighting Condition Figure 12: Image Carousel of Fabrication Team Assembly Round #1 Figure 14: Image Carousel of Fabrication Team Assembly Round #3

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

7

STUDENT COMMENTS

8

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

1

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

9

INTRODUCTION

As a class, we came to the consensus to develop a light shade that mounts to the existing lighting fixtures to mitigate and disperse the harsh lighting. However, we had an extensive exploratory process where students creating a smorgasbord of ideas. Many included tactical interventions around Wentworth’s campus and expressing school identity, while others were steps into the community of Mission hill or other neighborhoods of Boston.

Once coming to the conclusion that we as a class would design and implement a shading device, also determined by the polls taken via Google Forum, more data for the existing conditions of studio were collected. We found that many different tactical solutions are present in studio, and we have created a catalog that identifies the most trending iterations.

Overview

The Prompt With the purpose and goal of this implementation in place, we needed to establish a baseline rubric for each of us team members to be graded upon.

Figure 1: Class Rubric Created by Students

10

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Changing Studio Lighting

Objective: In teams, students will design a modular lighting system that can be customized to meet the unique lighting challenges of different studio spaces.

The system, based on a kit-of-parts, should be scalable, replicated, sustainable and adaptable, incorporating feedback from the student body and insights from weekly lectures. The project emphasizes innovation, practicality, and community engagement, aiming to enhance the studio environment and promote a sense of ownership and creativity among students.

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

11

Overview JAN 26 - FEB 09: Preliminary Voting

12

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Changing Studio Lighting

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

13

Overview JAN 26 - FEB 09: Preliminary Voting

14

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Changing Studio Lighting

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

15

Overview

Figure 2: Student Tactical Intervention #1

Tactical Intervention #1 Current light fixture system implemented by students on the second floor of Annex North. Materials used are tape and trace paper. Weaknesses; severe gaps on the side. Strengths: Light is heavily filtered. A very simplistic design but accomplishes the desired goal

16

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Changing Studio Lighting

Figure 3: Student Tactical Intervention #2

Tactical Intervention #2 Student light fixture adaptation of Annex North on the second floor. Materials utilized are two pieces of trace paper and tape. Weaknesses: There are multiple gaps between the sheets of trace letting light through. Strengths: Light is filtered to a comfortable level. A unique take on trying to solve the issue, that again is effective but quite crude.

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

17

Overview

Figure 4: Student Tactical Intervention #3

Tactical Intervention #3 Another student intervention on a light fixture in Annex North on the second floor. The materials used were tape and a large piece of trace paper. Weaknesses: The trace paper system here is flawed, with a lack of a strong connection with the tape, it has allowed for the trace to fall off half of the fixture, letting a significant amount of direct light through. Strengths: light is still partially filtered. A rather unsuccessful attempt at solving the direct lighting problem; perhaps this can inform design, thinking about simplicity but effectiveness and beauty.

18

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Changing Studio Lighting

Figure 5: Student Tactical Intervention #4

Tactical Intervention #4 A student intervention on a lighting fixture on the second floor of Annex North.

The materials used are several pieces of tape and a circular sheet of paper.

Weaknesses: the tape strength and integrity failed, which caused the paper to fall out of place, allowing all the light to shine through. Strengths: The design is unique and if executed correctly could be potentially highly effective.

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

19

Overview

Figure 6: Student Tactical Intervention #5

Tactical Intervention #5 Another student intervention of a light fixture on the second floor of Annex North. The materials that are utilized in this design are two sheets of trace paper and a few pieces of tape. Weaknesses: The design looks sloppy and not well put together. Strengths: the lighting issue is solved here by solid light filtration.

20

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Changing Studio Lighting

Figure 7: Student Tactical Intervention #6

Tactical Intervention #6 A student design intervention of an overpowering light fixture on the second floor of Annex North. The materials used are one piece of trace paper and a few pieces of tape. Weaknesses: the design issues are the lack of coverage on the side of the light fixture where the trace is not attached. Strengths: Most of the light is filtered.

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

21

22

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

2 Research & Analysis

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

23

POLL RESEARCH

The following data was gathered by the outreach team in an effort to understand the current representation in opinion of the student body. A poll was sent out through google forums asking anyone - students, professors, and guests alike to take five minutes and evaluate the working conditions of Annex North’s top floor of studio. The questionnaire came back with an overwhelming number of responses, more dominantly by the Masters students.

Overview

Figure 8: Survey Question #2 What Grade Level Are You?

24

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Changing Studio Lighting

Figure 9: Survey Question #3 What about Studio Would You Liked to See Changed?

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

25

Overview

Figure 10: Info-graphic Displaying Percentage of Students Who Believe Lighting is a Critical Issue

26

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Changing Studio Lighting

Figure 11: Student Answers to Survey Regarding Taking Personal Action to Change the Lighting Condition

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

27

28

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

3 Fabrication Design Process

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

29

DESIGN PROCESS

It was importance to the Fabrication team that this design could be easily replicated and fabricated for any future student to produce and assemble. This required simplicity in the final design, and a kit of parts straight forward for anyone to pick up and duplicate. The following is a montage of the three trials endeavored b the Fabrication team to achieve the perfect culmination of function and fashion.

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

8.12”

2.25”

30

7.11”

2.25”

8.12”

SECTION | SCALE = 1 : 2

AXON

SECTION | SCALE = 1 : 2

8.12” 7.11”

5.25”

3.52” 3.52”

ELEVATION | SCALE = 1 : 2 ELEVATION | SCALE = 1 : 2

8.12” 7.11”

3.39”

3.39”

AXON

5.25”

11.01”

3.39”

11.01”

3.39”

7.11”

AXON

Design Development AXON

SECTION | SCALE = 1 : 2

SECTION | SCALE = 1 : 2

ELEVATION | SCALE = 1 : 2

ELEVATION | SCALE = 1 : 2

LIGHTING CHARETTE DESIGNS

3.52”

5.25”

11.01”

3.39”

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

SECTION | SCALE = 1 : 2

5.25”

11.01”

3.39”

7.11”

SECTION | SCALE = 1 : 2

ELEVATION | SCALE = 1 : 2

AXON

SECTION | SCALE = 1 : 2

ELEVATION | SCALE = 1 : 2

AXON

SECTION | SCALE = 1 : 2

ELEVATION | SCALE = 1 : 2

AXON

SECTION | SCALE = 1 : 2

ELEVATION | SCALE = 1 : 2

5.25”

11.01”

3.52”

2.25”

2.25”

AXON

5.25”

3.52”

2.25”

8.12”

11.01”

3.52”

5.25” 5.25”

ELEVATION | SCALE = 1 : 2

3.52”

AXON

11.01”

3.39”

3.39”

7.11”

11.01”

8.12”

3.52”

7.11”

2.25”

2.25”

8.12”

31

32

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Figure 12: Image Carousel of Fabrication Team Assembly Round #1

Design Development

ASSEMBLY #1

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

33

34

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Figure 13: Image Carousel of Fabrication Team Assembly Round #2

Design Development

ASSEMBLY #2

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

35

36

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

4 Design Implementation

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

37

IMPLEMENTATION

The final design was the manicured version of the provisions made during the iterative design process. The lamp shade design takes advantage of the most commonly used material in studio: chipboard. The material qualities of chip board serve its purpose as a structure for a diffusing shade device, but also permit it’s structure as a scaffolding for designs to be mounted as8 an ornament on top.

The dimension of the shading device was specifically chosen as 8.5” by 11” for a student to print out an image and slot the letter sheet onto the face of the shade.

5.25”

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

11.01”

38

ELEVATION | SCALE

WORMSEYE AXON

SECTION | SCALE = 1

3.39”

AXON

Final Design

DESIGN DIMENSIONS

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

2.25”

14.50”

3.52”

6.60”

=1:2

PLAN | SCALE = 1 : 2

8.12” .125”

.350”

7.11”

:2

DETAIL | SCALE = 1 : 20

39

40

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Figure 14: Image Carousel of Fabrication Team Assembly Round #3

Design Development

ASSEMBLY #3

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

41

42

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

5 Kit of Parts Assembly

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

43

ASSEMBLY MANUEL

The following chapter is meant to act as an Assembly Manual that prescribes the kit of parts required to assemble a singular lantern. The Manuel describes the materials and fabrication steps required to properly put a lantern together.

LANTERN ASSEMBLY

1

2x Structural Ring

Lantern Body 2

Structural Strips

5

1

Pin Fastener

2x Structural Ring

KIT OF PARTS 44

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

Diffuser

Inner Ring

6

3

4

1 2

4

rn Body

user

Ring

4 3

Laser Cut Chipboard 5

6

6

3

Laser Cut Wood

Hand Cut Dura-lar Wentworth Architecture School of Design

45

ASSEMBLY MANUAL MATERIALS LIST

(x3) 1/16” thick (24” x 36”) Chipboard (x1) Plank of 1/4” thick Basswood (x1) Matte Dura-Lar Film

46

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

LASER-CUTTING INSTRUCTIONS

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Download laser cut file(s) found in the same folder Use (x3) pieces of chipboard to laser cut: (x4) structural rings (x1) inner ring (x4) structural strips (x2) lantern body pieces Use plank of wood to laser cut (x4) pin fasteners Hand-cut the Dura-lar film with a diameter of 14 ¼” (or large enough for the film to lay flat on top of the inner ring)

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

47

ASSEMBLY INSTRUCTIONS

1 2

Take (x2) of the structural rings and glue them together.

Repeat with the remaining two structural rings Take (x2) of the lantern body pieces and gently bend them (with the scoring side facing outwards). Then glue the edges together

3

Align and glue each structural strip to the holes found on upper edge of the lantern body (ensure that the holes of located toward the top)

4 5 6 48

Glue the Dura-lar film on top of the inner ring Place the inner ring + Dura-lar film inside the lantern body and glue it toward the bottom section of the lantern Look for the horizontal lines found on the scoring side of the lantern (upper and lower)

Self-Collab Design | Cardona

7 8

Take one set of structural rings and align the bottom surface of the rings to the upper horizontal line. Then glue it in place Take the other set of structural rings and align the top surface of the rings to the bottom horizontal line. Then glue it in place

9

Add and glue any artwork or graphic onto the scoring side of the lantern (the artwork needs to be on an 8.5” x 11” sheet of paper)

10

Contact the Department of Facilities (physical_plant@wit. edu) to attach the assembled light diffuser onto the existing lamps (DO NOT attempt to attach the diffuser without supervision of anyone from the department of facilities)

Wentworth Architecture School of Design

49