BusinessMirror December 18, 2014

Page 1

BusinessMirror

three-time rotary club of manila journalism awardee 2006, 2010, 2012

U.N. Media Award 2008

www.businessmirror.com.ph

A broader look at today’s business

n

Tuesday, Thursday,November December18, 18,2014 2014Vol. Vol.1010No. No.4070

P25.00 nationwide | 6 sections 3o pages | 7 days a week

BASED ON INDICATIVE NUMBERS, Q4 GROWTH FASTER THAN Q3’s 5.3%––BALISACAN

PAPAL VISIT 2015

ADB cuts PHL growth forecast

T

he slower pace of economic expansion in the first three quarters of the year forced the Asian Development Bank (ADB) to revise downward its growth estimate for the Philippines in 2014.

27 DAYS INSIDE

a countryside tour of georgia D

Spirit of unity

EAR Lord, may the spirit of unity reign in our midst. As human beings we are called to “interpersonal communion” with others. We are zealous in taking the initiative to infuse the Christian spirit of unity into the mentality, customs, laws and structures of the communities of which we are part, mindful that Jesus desires is to be one with one another, just as He and the Father are one. We, therefore, make the necessary effort to establish relationships of love, joy and peace with others as one big Family in Christ. Amen. CHILDREN’S ROSARY FOUNDATION, JO A. SALDANA AND LOUIE M. LACSON Word&Life Publications • teacherlouie1965@yahoo.com

Editor: Gerard S. Ramos • lifestylebusinessmirror@gmail.com

Life

In the Asian Development Outlook Supplement, the ADB said the Philippine economy is now projected to post a growth of 6 percent from the September estimate of 6.2 percent. “After GDP [gross domestic product] in the Philippines rose by 6.1 percent in the first half, the growth pace fell back to 5.3 percent in the third quarter. Robust private consumption, and higher private investment and net exports were insufficient to balance unexpectedly weak public spending,” the ADB said. “As growth in the first nine months of the year reached only 5.8 percent, the 2014 GDP growth forecast is downgraded by 0.2 percentage points to 6 percent,” it added.

FAITH AND MAGIC GET A MAG ‘REVIVAL’... »D4

BusinessMirror

Thursday, December 18, 2014

D1

THE San Fernando Pampanga giant lantern at the CCP. ORLY DAQUIPIL

SAN FERNANDO GIANT PAMPANGA LANTERN LIGHTING AT THE CCP

A 20-FOOT-HIGH colorful lantern from San Fernando, Pampanga, was lit at the Main Ramp of the Cultural Center of the Philippines (CCP) recently. The event was held in cooperation with the City of San Fernando, Pampanga. CCP Performance and Exhibition Department Manager Ariel Yonzon and Ching Pangilinan of the City Tourism and Investment Promotions of San Fernando City spoke at the event. The San Fernando lantern display is the fourth to be held at the CCP under a partnership between the CCP and the City of San Fernando, Pampanga. San Fernando, Pampanga, is known as the Christmas capital of the Philippines. The San Fernando parol is renowned for its large size, brilliant colors and flashing kaleidoscopic patterns made possible by the intricate electrical circuitry fashioned by the craftsmen of San Fernando. The Ligligan Parul, or the Giant Lantern Festival, is the top tourist attraction of the city. The San Fernando parol is on display at the CCP until January 4, 2015.

❶ ❷

❶ ANANURI

Fortress

❷ BORJOMI ❸ GERGETI Trinity

Church

JVARI Monastery

❺ DAVID Gareja

AUSTIN, Texas

Top travel destinations for 2015 B N R The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

A countryside tour of Georgia B B L

O

NE of the highlights of our 10-day, Qatar Airways-sponsored working visit to the Republic of Georgia was our three-day tour of the Georgian countryside sponsored by the Georgia National Tourism Administration (GNTA). For this purpose, the GNTA provided us with a coach, a driver and a guide—the affable Sopho Makashvili. Our party consisted of Thelmo O. Cunanan Jr. (honorary consul of Georgia in the Philippines), Pancho Piano (the first Filipino artist to officially present his work in Georgia and the entire Caucasus Region), Riva M. Galveztan (health food advocate), Prof. Melissa DizonDulalia and yours truly. Day One saw us traveling along eastern Georgia at Mtskheta, one of the country’s oldest cities and the former capital of the Georgian Kingdom of Kartli—Iberia. Here, we visited the hilltop Jvari Monastery, known for the exceptional relief sculptures decorating its façade, and Svetitskhoveli (the Living Pillar Cathedral), known as the burial site of Christ’s mantle and the site for the coronation and burial of Georgian kings. In the afternoon, after lunch at Gori, we dropped by the Joseph Stalin Museum which contains a memorial house (where native son Stalin was born),

exposition building with tower and Stalin’s personal railway coach by which he had traveled to Tehran, Yalta and Potsdam. From here, we also made a 10-kilometer drive to visit Uplistsikhe, an ancient, abandoned rock-hewn town identified as one of the oldest urban settlements in Georgia. We started Day Two by traveling 157 kms to the northeastern Georgian town of Stepantsminda (formerly Kazbegi) with a short stopover at the scenic Ananuri Fortress which stands spectacularly above a reservoir on the Aragvi River. While waiting for our transfer at snowy Gudauri, I had fun experiencing my first snowball fight with my companions. Upon arrival at Stepantsminda, we had lunch at the beautiful Rooms Hotel prior to our 30-minute drive up a rough mountain trail, to the 14th-century Gergeti Trinity Church, the only cross-cupola church in Khevi province and a symbol of Georgia. Day Three again brought us back to the east, this time to the postcard-pretty town of Sighnaghi, with stopovers at the Badiauri Village in Sagarejo, where we observed the baking of the delicious, canoe-shaped Georgian shoti (bread) in a tone (deep, circular clay oven); and the Bodbe Monastery, the burial place of the revered Saint Nino, a fourth-century female evangelist who preached Christianity in Georgia.

Upon arrival at Sighnaghi town proper, Sopho took us on a walking of the town’s defensive wall where we climbed one of the towers for a panoramic view of the town. We were also enthralled by its two- to three-story tiled-roof houses with their wooden, lacy balconies and bow-backed windows. A delightful lunch of Georgian cuisine awaited us at Pheasant’s Tears, a winery that produces artisanal natural wines according to ancient Georgian traditions. After lunch, we moved on to the village of Tsinandali in the Kakheti region. Here, we visited the estate and the historic winery which once belonged to the 19thcentury aristocratic poet Alexander Chavchavadze (1786-1846). The house-museum, which often hosts various exhibitions of prominent Georgian and foreign artists, is surrounded by a beautiful park with a unique and interesting layout. The next day, Riva and I, together with our guide Sopho and driver Giorgi, drove to David Gareja, near the border with Azerbaijan, unique for its wild nature, mural masterpieces and rock-hewn monasteries. Prior to our GNTA-sponsored tour, Riva and I also joined Filipino expat, Ruby Bebita, on a visit to the south-central resort town of Borjomi, famous for its mineral water industry. The next day, we continued on to explore Vardzia, another cave monastery site in Southern Georgia. ■

WHILE some of us are still making our holiday travel plans, Travelzoo is looking to the future. The travel web site recently released its list of the top five destinations to travel for 2015. These are places around the world where you are likely to see impressive deals based current trends and travel industry projections. Here’s the list (in alphabetical order) and a few reasons why it’s a hot destination for 2015: ■ Asia: New ships and itineraries mean more deals on Asia cruises. You can take in several countries in one trip or do a deep dive into areas like Thailand’s Phang Nga Bay. The deals will range from large ocean liners to small, luxury ships and more. ■ Brazil: Last year was the Fifa World Cup. In 2016 it’s the Summer Olympics. That makes 2015 the perfect time to visit the country and take advantage of the savings. Plans to open 400 new hotels by 2016 means there will be lots of price competition for lodging. ■ Dubai: Dubai has been on top destination lists for a while. Now it is a major player in the world of tourism. Two airports attract 71 million passengers annually who come to see sights including Burj Khalifa, the world’s tallest skyscraper. In 2020 the country welcomes the World Expo; take it in now while travel discounts are plentiful. ■ Puerto Rico: This is always an affordable vacation option as it is easy to fly in and you don’t need a passport. JetBlue Airways, Southwest Airlines and United Airlines have increased air routes to get you to more than 200 beaches on the island. ■ Texas (Austin, San Antonio): The big state will have big deals next year. Here’s Texas by the travel numbers: two airports, 11 airlines servicing the state and several hotels opening in 2015. Spring offers the best weather and events such as SXSW and Fiesta San Antonio. TNS

life

World Companies BusinessMirror

Editor: Dionisio L. Pelayo• corp@businessmirror.com.ph

O

AKLAND, California—A federal jury decided on Tuesday that Apple did not compete unfairly when it sold music players and songs with copy-protection software that was incompatible with rival devices and music from competing online stores. The eight-member jury in the US District Court handed Apple a victory by rejecting a claim from consumers’ and iPod resellers’ lawyers, who were seeking as much as $1 billion in a class-action lawsuit. The plaintiffs argued that Apple was able to overcharge consumers for iPods by making it difficult to switch to a rival music player, as music bought from Apple’s iTunes store would not work on other players, nor would music from other stores work on iPods. After just three hours of deliberation, the jury accepted Apple’s argument that the software provided necessary security protection and was part of a larger package of improvements that made iPods and iTunes popular with consumers. Apple applauded the verdict: “We created iPod and iTunes to give our customers the world’s best way to

listen to music. Every time we’ve updated those products — and every Apple product over the years — we’ve done it to make the user experience even better.” Apple no longer uses the copyprotection software in question, so the ruling has no effect on the company’s current practices. The case, originally filed in 2005, covers an estimated 8 million consumers who purchased iPods from 2006 to 2009, when the software was still in place. The plaintiffs argued that the software locked people into using iPods and allowed Apple to overcharge for the devices. Plaintiffs were seeking $350 million in damages, which could have been tripled if the jury found Apple violated antitrust laws. Lawyers for the plaintiffs said they plan to appeal. “We’re glad we

got this to the jury,” lawyer Bonny Sweeney said. But she said that a ruling by US District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers kept the jury from considering the impact of encryption code used in an iTunes software update that was the focus of the trial. During a two-week trial, the plaintiffs’ attorneys played a video of testimony by the late Apple CEO Steve Jobs, who died in 2011. They also showed e-mails between Apple executives that indicated they were concerned about some early efforts by rival companies to sell digital music files that might be played on iPods. But Apple executives testified they were focused on preventing unauthorized copying—which was a big concern of recording labels— and said Apple was worried that digital files from outside sources might compromise the security of its iTunes software. In what turned out to be the key issue of the trial, Apple argued that its iTunes software updates were legitimate product improvements, which combined security

Former employees sue Sony over hacked personal details

N

EW YORK—Two former employees of Sony Pictures Entertainment are suing the company for not preventing hackers from stealing nearly 50,000 social security numbers, salary details and other personal information from current and former workers. The lawsuit claims that Sony Pictures failed to secure its computer systems despite “weaknesses that it has known about for years,” and made a business decision to accept the risk. It states that the latest data breaches are especially “surprising and egregious” because Sony Pictures has been repeatedly attacked over the years, including a 2011 hack that revealed millions of user accounts on Sony’s PlayStation video-game network. The case filed in a federal court in Los Angeles on Monday seeks class-action status for other current and former employees whose personal information was stolen posted online. Sony did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Tuesday morning. Highly sensitive material from the entertainment unit of Tokyobased Sony Corp. has been leaked almost daily since hackers broke into its computer networks last month. New threats and data leaks from the shadowy group calling itself Guardians of Peace, or GOP, were issued Tuesday. The case has two named plaintiffs: Michael Corona, a former Sony Entertainment employee who left the company in 2007 and now lives in Virginia, and Christina Mathis, who left the company in 2002 and lives in California. They allege their Social Security numbers and other sensitive personal information have been leaked, exposing them to identify theft for years to come. Their lawyers allege that e-mails and other information leaked by the hackers show that Sony’s informationtechnology department and its top lawyer believed its security system was vulnerable to attack, but that company did not act on those warnings. Corona and Mathis do not spell out how much they are seeking the case, but want

actual damages and an order requiring Sony to pay for services to monitor credit and banking services and repair damage from identify theft for at least five years. Sony has offered employees one year of credit monitoring, the lawsuit states. The plaintiffs claim that protection is inadequate because it can take years for thieves to exploit the personal information included in the data breach. Corona so far has spent $700 on identity theft protection for him and his family, and Mathis has spent $300, according to the suit. Legal experts said the case is likely the first of many that will be filed over the data breach. Sony potentially faces tens of millions of dollars in damages from a class-action lawsuit, said Jonathan Handel, an entertainment law professor at the University of Southern California Gould School of Law. “This is not a ‘bet your company’ lawsuit but it is a serious matter for Sony both in terms of dollar exposure and public perception of the brand,” Handel said. “This doesn’t look good for Sony, which after all is a technology company.” In addition to lawsuits from its ex-employees, Sony is likely to face fines from government regulators and lawsuits from actors, producers and directors who may not want to work with the studio anymore, said Steven S. Rubin, a New York cybersecurity lawyer with the firm Moritt Hock & Hamroff. Among the materials that have been leaked are sensitive emails and studio materials that criticize actors and producers. Those with ongoing contracts with Sony could argue the company has breached their agreement and move their work elsewhere, Rubin said. “It’s devastating. This is killing their reputation,” Rubin said. He noted that Sony may be able to get out of this, by investing in a “gold star cybersecurity approach.” However, “it’s a clear reminder for companies that are smaller than Sony, you don’t want this to happen.” AP

protections with other new features that allowed consumers to watch videos, view album covers and synch their music collections on different computers. Federal antitrust law permits companies to make legitimate product improvements, regardless of their effect on competitors. Rogers told jurors that if they agreed with Apple on that point, they did not need to examine other arguments in the case. The jury began deliberating on Monday afternoon. Although the case focused on an iTunes software update that blocked music sold by competitor Real Networks, Real and other rival music sellers were not parties in the case. While the case took almost 10 years to get to trial, it nearly collapsed last week when the named plaintiffs were disqualified from the case. Apple lawyer William Isaacson told the judge that records showed that neither of the two lead plaintiffs, who are supposed to represent the other consumers affected by the case, had purchased iPod models covered by the lawsuit. A third plaintiff had withdrawn earlier. After a last-minute scramble, Rogers agreed to add Massachusetts business consultant Barbara Bennett as the lead plaintiff. Jurors did not hear any testimony from Bennett, who told lawyers she listened to her iPod while figure skating. AP

Thursday, December 18, 2014

B2-3

Fiat’s Chrysler Group changes its name to FCA United States

A

UBURN HILLS, Michigan— Chrysler Group Llc. has changed its name to FCA US Llc. The change will be largely unnoticed by consumers, affecting mostly corporate and financial communications. Chrysler-branded cars will continue to bear the Chrysler badge, as those branded Fiat will bear the Fiat badge. The move was part of Fiat Chrysler Automobiles’ renaming of its mass-market brands. Fiat Chrysler Automobiles becomes FCA Italy SpA. The automaker said on Tuesday that the name change follows the naming convention of its parent company, Fiat Chrysler Automobiles N.V., which adopted its name in October when it listed on the New York Stock Exchange. Chrysler and its Italian owner Fiat

SpA merged earlier this year. Fiat was granted management control and a 20-percent stake in Chrysler after it emerged from bankruptcy protection in 2009. Fiat gradually raised its stake and eventually became majority owner. The name change doesn’t impact its headquarters in Auburn Hills, Michigan, its holdings, management team, board or brands. FCA US has more than 77,000 employees worldwide and runs 36 manufacturing plants, including 23 in the US. In Europe, Fiat Chrysler employs 89,000 people, 40 percent of the worldwide workforce, producing annual revenues about €20 billion, 23 percent of the total global revenues of €87 billion. Fiat Chrysler has 78 plants in Europe. AP

RadioShack hires advisory firm

N

EW YORK—RadioShack is bringing in FTI Consulting as an adviser in the midst of another round of cost-cutting as the troubled electronics retailer warned again last week that it may have to seek bankruptcy protection. The company said in a regulatory filing on Tuesday that Carlin Adrianopoli, a senior managing director with FTI’s corporate finance and restructuring service, will take over as interim CFO at RadioShack. Holly Etlin, who became interim CFO in September, will no longer serve in that position. The company hired former Treasury Department Adviser Harry Wilson to help with its turnaround efforts in late October. Last week RadioShack Corp. posted bigger third-quarter losses

‘Nut rage’ gives Hawaii macadamia nuts a boost

and said it would boost earnings by changing store hours and staffing, altering overtime practices and cutting its field manager staff. A trade group also ruled that RadioShack has not failed to make debt payments, despite a lender accusing the chain of violating terms on a $250-million loan. RadioShack warned in September that it may have to seek Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, and last week CEO Joseph Magnacca reiterated that stance, saying that there is no assurance the Fort Worth, Texas-based company can put into place a long-term solution to stay afloat. Shares of RadioShack fell by a penny, or more than 3 percent, to 38 cents in Tuesday morning trading. AP

American Apparel fires founder, names new CEO

L

In this photo taken on Friday, Cho Hyun-ah, who was head of cabin service at Korean Air and the oldest child of Korean Air Lines Co. Chairman Cho Yang-ho, speaks to the media upon her arrival for questioning at the Aviation and Railway Accident Investigation Board office of Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport in Seoul, South Korea. The chairman of Korean Air Lines Co. apologized on Friday for the behavior of his adult daughter who delayed a flight in an incident now dubbed “nut rage.” AP

H

ONOLULU—A Korean Air Lines executive’s tantrum over bagged nuts in a first-class cabin is drawing enough attention to give Hawaii’s macadamia nut industry a boost. Cho Hyun-ah, an airline vice president of cabin service and daughter of the company’s chairman, ordered a flight attendant off a December 5 flight from New York City after she was served macadamia nuts in a bag instead of on a plate. The incident dubbed “nut rage” imploded her career, embarrassed her family and led to an unexpected boom in sales of macadamias in South Korea. Some producers told the Honolulu

Star-Advertiser that is also helping Hawaii’s $38-million macadamia nut industry, which accounts for more than 700 farms and eight processing plants. “Any type of publicity is good for the industry,” Hawaii Macadamia Nut Association President John Cross said. “Macadamia nuts are not well-known outside of Hawaii and the West Coast. If they were as well-known in the Central and Eastern US, there wouldn’t be enough nuts to supply demand.” Almost all of Hawaii’s macadamia nuts come from its Big Island. They are also grown in Australia, Central America and South Africa. “If anything should be served on a silver tray, it should be maca-

damia nuts,” Richard Schnitzler, president of Hamakua Macadamia Nut Co., said with a laugh, referring to the inflight outburst. “It’s a high-quality nut. It’s understandable how that can happen.” He said it would be difficult to track a recent surge in sales because sales are always up during the holiday season. Macadamias are now a household name in South Korea, and with curiosity about their taste piqued, sales are booming. South Korea’s largest online shopping retailer, Gmarket, owned by eBay, said macadamia nut sales jumped 20 times from one week to the next earlier this month. AP

OS ANGELES—American Apparel has fired founder Dov Charney and named longtime fashion executive Paula Schneider to be its next CEO. The Los Angeles-basedcompany’s board voted to oust Charney as CEO in June, citing allegations of misconduct. He was put under suspension, but still served as a consultant to the company. American Apparel said Tuesday that it has terminated his position “for cause” after an internal investigation. Messages left with a lawyer who has represented Charney this year were not immediately returned. American Apparel Inc., which Charney founded in 1998, manufactures clothes and sells them in 245 of its own retail stores in 20 countries and has about 10,000 employees. It is famous for selling American-made goods and for its risque advertising. Charney has been the subject of lawsuits that allege he had inappropriate sexual conduct with female employees. He has said he had consensual sexual relationships with workers. American Apparel said on Tuesday that a special committee of its board decided, based on the results of an internal investigation conducted by FTI Consulting, that “it would not be appropriate for Mr. Charney to be reinstated as CEO or an officer or employee.” The company has suffered financially. It has recorded annual losses since 2010 and reported three quarterly losses this year. Its stock has dropped 53 percent in 2014. Schneider, who officially starts as CEO on January 5, has been a senior executive at retail and clothing companies, including Warnaco, Gores Group and BCBG Max Azria. American Apparel has operated under two interim CEOs since Charney’s ouster, most recently Scott Brubaker, who will continue in that role through the end of the year. Shares rose 5 cents, or 8.6 percent, to 63 cents in after-hours trading. The stock closed up 3 cents at 58 cents on Tuesday. AP

world companies

Continued on A2

d1

apple wins class-action lawsuit over ipod prices Apple wins class-action lawsuit over iPod prices

By Cai U. Ordinario

b2-3

OIL NEARING 5-YEAR LOW AS RUSSIA ECHOES OPEC

O

il in New York traded near a five-year low as Russia reiterated that it will keep crude production steady next year, echoing the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries’ (Opec) strategy to refrain from curbing supply to tackle a global surplus. Futures fell as much as 2.4 percent, after sliding below $54 a barrel on Tuesday for the first time since May 2009. Output from Russia, the world’s largest crude producer, will be similar to this year’s 10.6 million barrels a day, according to Energy Minister Alexander Novak. Iran is said to be offering shipments to Asia at the deepest discount in at least 14 years, taking a cue from Saudi Arabia in cutting price differentials. Oil has slumped 43 percent this year, as a surge in shale drilling lifted US output to the fastest pace in three decades amid slowing world demand growth. Leading members of the Opec, such as Saudi Arabia, have resisted calls from smaller producers, including

PESO exchange rates n US 44.8020

See “Oil,” A2

PAPAL planning The various sectors under the Pope Francis Sa Pilipinas, Media ng Bayan banner meet at the Manila Hotel on Wednesday to craft plans and programs related to the state and apostolic journey of the charismatic Pope Francis beginning January 17 next year. Key entities include the Presidential Communications Operations Office, PTV-4, IBC 13, the Philippine Information Agency, Radyo ng Bayan, RPN Ronda Radyo nationwide, DWIZ nationwide, Home Radio FM nationwide, the BusinessMirror, Philippines Graphic, Manila Bulletin Group and the Pilipino Mirror. From left, Art Samaniego, Manila Bulletin Tech editor; Manila Bulletin AVP and Marketing Head JV Dimayuga; Manila Hotel AVP for PR and Corporate Communications Nian Rigor; BusinessMirror VP for Corporate Affairs Frederick M. Alegre; BusinessMirror President Benjamin V. Ramos; Communications Secretary Herminio B. Coloma Jr.; Manila Bulletin Chairman Basilio Yap; PCOO Undersecretary Jesus Yu; Manila Hotel President Joey Lina; BusinessMirror Publisher T. Anthony Cabangon; Manila Bulletin Vice Chairman Emilio C. Yap III; Deedee Siytangco; Sandy Siytangco; and PTV-4 General Manager Cleo Dongga-as.

S&P: Oil savings should be spent to fuel economy

T

By Bianca Cuaresma

he lower oil prices globally can speed up the Philippines’s gross domestic product (GDP) expansion rate, if the country would opt to spend the unexpected “windfall” from the savings generated from the considerable cut in fuel cost, an international credit watcher said. In a recent statement, Standard and Poor’s (S&P) Ratings Services said the lower oil prices can give a “welcome boost” to Asia-Pacific countries—with the largest effect to be felt in the Philippines, Hong

Kong, China and Thailand. However, the ratings agency highlighted that the country must be able to spend these additional windfall—or the sudden, unexpected piece of financial gain—from lower oil prices to fuel further the economy rather than set it aside. “Spending the windfall can raise GDP in key economies, while saving it will provide little or no stimulus to growth,” S&P’s Asia Pacific chief economist Paul Gruenwald said. “If the oil-price windfall is largely spent, the effects on GDP are highest in the Philippines, Hong Kong, China and Thailand,”

S&P said. The ratings agency further said in this group of economies, a one-year drop in Brent Crude to $86 per barrel could raise output by a third of a percentage point. Other countries, such as India and South Korea, will benefit from the lower oil prices but, at a lower rate, contributing about a fifth of a percentage point to their GDP. The ratings agency said the countries in the region must take advantage of the potential benefit of the lower prices of oil to boost their output expansion for the year See “S&P,” A2

n japan 0.3851 n UK 70.5452 n HK 5.7780 n CHINA 7.2374 n singapore 34.3943 n australia 36.8104 n EU 56.0787 n SAUDI arabia 11.9377 Source: BSP (17 December 2014)


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.