Executive Committee Report 2010-'11

Executive Committee Chair's Report, 2010–2011 The Yale College Executive Committee has 10 regular voting members: three tenured and three untenured faculty members; three undergraduate students; and the Dean of Yale College or her designee. In addition there are three officers. For the 2010-2011 year these were: the chair, Margaret Clark, Professor of Psychology; the fact-finder, Eric Sargis, Professor of Anthropology; and the secretary, Dean Pamela George, Assistant Dean of Academic Affairs in Yale College.

The Committee hears complaints regarding alleged violations of the undergraduate regulations. (Up to and including the 2010-2011 academic year these included charges of sexual misconduct and harassment. However, the new University Wide Committee on Sexual Misconduct began operation on July 1, 2011 and, going forward, violations of the Undergraduate Regulations involving sexual misconduct or harassment will be heard by that committee.)

The committee saw a total of 146 students in the 2010-2011 academic year.

The committee found eleven not to have violated the undergraduate regulations. 135 were deemed to have violated the regulations with the majority of these students acknowledging that that had done so following charges having been made. Most students found to have violated the regulations received reprimands (82). Thirty-two students were placed on probation and twenty-one students were suspended from Yale College. In the 2010-2011 year no student was expelled. Three students, facing charges that arose late in their senior years, had their degrees briefly withheld until after their cases were adjudicated.

Whereas in past years the executive committee met only during the academic year, with charges brought during the final days of the spring semester being held over to the fall, a new policy was introduced during the 2010-2011 year. Following the conclusion of the spring 2011 semester, the committee continued to meet through mid-June of 2011 to hear serious cases that might result in decision to suspend or expel students. The new extended term policy provides for resolution of serious cases in a timely fashion reducing, we hope, student anxiety and uncertainty. In the 2010-2011 year it also eliminated the problem of having some charged students return to school in the fall and having to leave due to suspensions soon thereafter.

FULL HEARINGS A “full hearing” of the Committee occurs when a student disputes the validity of a charge made against him or her. These cases involve fact-finding and the convening of the full committee. The student appears before the committee with an advisor of his or her choice. The student and committee receive copies of the charges and of the fact-finding report. Prior to the hearing the student also provides a written statement that is given to the committee. At the start of the hearing, the student is advised of the committee’s procedures, makes an opening statement, and is asked questions by committee members.

The student may choose to have his or her advisor speak and most students do make this 1

choice. The student makes a closing statement if he or she wishes to do so and most do.

Witnesses may appear, make statements and be asked questions. The student is excused after making concluding comments and the committee deliberates. The committee may either dismiss the charge or impose one of the following penalties on the student: reprimand, probation, suspension (for one or more terms), or expulsion. A suspended student may be required to go through the readmission process before returning to enrollment in Yale College. A degree may be withheld. The group can also place restrictions on students or ask the student to pay for repairs to property that he or she has damaged.

There were four formal hearings during the 2010-2011 year.

Three involved individual students. One student was charged with of cheating on a final exam, another was charged acts of violence, defiance and violating a “no contact” order and a third student was charged with sexual misconduct and harassment and intimidation or coercion.

A final hearing involved charges of harassment, intimidation or coercion of any member of the Yale Community and imperiling the integrity of the University. This charge was brought in connection with the actions of a group of students. A number of students students who held formal positions within the group appeared before the committee but the actions of the entire group were considered and both their responsibility for the group’s actions and that of the group as a whole was considered.

DISPOSITIONS Almost all our meetings are “dispositions without a formal hearing.” A student who admits the validity of a charge made against him or her may petition for a disposition without a full hearing and, in 2010-2011, we granted all such petitions. Once the petition is granted, the chair, the fact-finder, the secretary, and one of our three students (who alternate in this role) meet with the charged student or students. This group is called the “coordinating group.”

The coordinating group met nearly every week in 2010-2011 year to adjudicate 80 cases involving 111 students. Prior to the meetings, all students submitted statements to the coordinating group regarding their actions, all consulted with their chosen advisors (most often their residential college deans but sometimes a master, a coach or a professor) in preparation for this meeting, and often consultations included discussions with Secretary of the Executive Committee.

Later, the students appeared before the coordinating group and the Chair went over basic information regarding confidentiality, confirmed that the student wished to admit the validity of the charge or charges in question, and made sure there are no conflicts of interest. (Conflicts sometimes did exist and there were times members of the coordinating group recused themselves from deliberations and were replaced by others.)

2

In 2010-2011 there were 79 dispositions without a formal hearing, involving 135 students.

PENALTY HEARING. If, following a hearing or disposition, a student believes an imposed penalty is too harsh, that student may appeal the decision and request a penalty hearing.

In such a case the chair of the committee is excused, an acting chair is appointed (often someone who has previously served as chair of the committee) and a full hearing takes place. The new hearing can result in upholding a penalty, a decrease in its severity or increase its severity.

One such request was made following a disposition in 2010-2011. The original penalty was upheld.

REFERRED CASES In addition to the cases mentioned above, another 100 cases involving 120 students were referred to the residential college deans and masters. These cases almost always involved issues involving alcohol and, more rarely, marijuana use. Students generally received reprimands.

COMMON TYPES OF CASES AND OUTCOMES The following section of this report is provided to give the reader a good sense of the types of violations that were seen and adjudicated in the 2010-2011 academic year.

We do not identify students nor make public outcomes of individual cases in ways that would identify the students with one exception. FERPA (The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act) requires the disclosure of decisions to victims of certain crimes/violations of our rules. In cases covered by this act we do disclose the outcome of our hearings and dispositions to the victim(s). In one case in the 2010-2011 year all victims of a group’s actions could not be identified and sanctions relating to the group were publicly announced. This is an unusual circumstance.

CHEATING AND PLAGIARISM BY INDIVIDUALS OR PAIRS OF STUDENTS Fifty-three students were charged with cheating which resulted in 13 suspensions, 17 probations, 13 reprimands, 6 instances of the charges being withdrawn and three cases which were carried over to the fall term. (Cases may be carried over to the fall term if they occur late in the spring semester (for instance during final exams). An additional case is pending and will be adjudicated if and when the involved student returns to Yale.

Twenty-seven of these cases involved plagiarism. The nature of plagiarism varied widely.

3

In some cases a paper or lab report written by someone else was turned in as the student’s own work. In many cases students “cut and pasted” material found via the internet in a paper. Many students failed to provide proper citations for material used or to place quotation marks around direct quotations. Students also turned in papers done for prior classes as “new” work done for current courses.

It is noteworthy that many students claimed not to have understood what constitutes plagiarism. Claims of not knowing what constitutes plagiarism do not mitigate charges of plagiarism. The committee urges all students to read the undergraduate regulations regarding plagiarism carefully and to consult the faculty and writing tutors if they have any questions whatsoever regarding plagiarism. It is especially important to take note of rules regarding quotations, citations, and properly crediting others for their ideas. So too are students advised that it is not permissible to take others’ ideas and to paraphrase them without giving the source of the idea credit through direct acknowledgement of the source in the text of the paper and, always, proper citations to the original source.

Some students were charged and found guilty of plagiarism in early drafts of assignments turned in for comments to teaching fellows or professors and some of these students expressed surprise regarding the charges. Students are responsible for academic integrity at all stages of their academic work.

Cheating took the form of submissions of the same work (and, in one case, work done in high school) as new work, collaboration on take-home exams, copying answers from other students, referring to notes or electronic devices during exams and claiming to have taken an exam that had not been taken. Collaborating on problem sets that faculty members had stated should be completed independently was a particularly common form of cheating.

VIOLATIONS OF UNDERGRADUATE REGULATIONS INVOLVING ORGANIZED GROUPS: RECRUITING, INITIATING AND “CELEBRATING” NEW GROUP MEMBERS In 2010-2011, as in prior years, a large number of students appeared before the committee as a result of individual actions taken in the context groups selecting, initiating or “bonding” with new or potential members of organized groups. Often these actions occurred in conjunction with the consumption of alcohol. Very often members of the groups informed the committee that their actions were the result of their following “traditions” that clearly violated undergraduate regulations, sometimes caused harm to others and to property belonging to Yale and often disruptions of others’ lives. The violations included trespassing, destruction of property, theft, breaking and entering, serving alcohol to minors, requiring alcohol consumption by others, minors procuring alcohol, harassment (including sexual harassment), coercion and intimidation of others, and hazing. The consequences of these actions ranged from relatively minor to very serious psychological harm to others and, in several cases, threats to others’ lives.

4

The committee took these actions very seriously. Students initiating new students into a groups as well as students being initiated into groups are advised that they are personally responsible for their individual behaviors and that they are required to follow laws as well as the Yale College regulations. Leaders and members of groups (including singing groups, fraternities and sororities, senior societies and other societies alike) and aspiring members of groups are advised to consider carefully the legality and morality of their actions well before undertaking initiations, to make conscious, deliberate decisions as to whether they wish to be involved in such activities and to consider the power that social groups can exert over members and aspiring members of groups. Just because something is labeled as a tradition does not mean it should be followed. Many groups would be well advised to change traditions; all groups would be well advised to consider the perspective of potential initiates, others at Yale, and the welfare of Yale College as a whole before taking unwise and, often, illegal actions.

In the 2010-2011 academic year forty-four individual students appeared before the committee for such actions. (The numbers are likely slightly higher as the committee does not always know the social context in which violations of undergraduate regulations have taken place.)

In four cases charges were withdrawn. Twenty-two cases resulted in reprimands, six cases resulted in students being placed on probation and four cases resulted in suspensions from Yale College.

OTHER TYPES OF CASES A variety of other types of violations, mostly involving individuals occurred with sufficient frequency to be worthy of note.

Falsification of documents and emails: A number of students falsified documents such as forms used to request the use of Yale facilities and dean’s excuses. Others engaged in identity theft by sending out mass emails to panlists or to all students in the college under the name of a professor, administrator or staff member at Yale.

Use of drugs and alcohol: Many students violated drug and alcohol laws/the undergraduate regulations primarily though the illegal use of substances and, in one case, by distributing drugs. All students are expected to obey the law as well as undergraduate regulations in this regard.

Unruly and destructive behavior when intoxicated: When under the influence of alcohol students engaged in a number of unruly and harmful behaviors including getting into physical fights, destroying property, trespassing and defying authorities such as the Yale police, the New Haven police and members of the administration. It is important for students to note that not only do such behaviors violate the undergraduate regulations but also those regulations specifically state that being under the influence of alcohol or other drugs is never considered a mitigating circumstance and may be considered an exacerbating circumstance by the committee.

5

A NOTE OF CAUTION IN INTERPRETING SPECIFIC CHARGES AND SANCTIONS A list of charges and associated sanctions appears along with this report. It is important to note that charges that may appear similar when briefly described, in fact, may be quite different. For instance, plagiarizing may involve copying a single sentence from a source or turning in a complete paper written by another person. Harassment takes many forms.

Moreover, in determining sanctions the committee takes into account the student’s past disciplinary record and a second offense for an action is likely to elicit larger sanction than a first offense. Differences in the magnitude of offenses and in disciplinary histories do influence the nature of the sanctions.

THANKS The chair of the committee expresses thanks to all members of the 2010-2011 Executive Committee. Their service in the 2010-2011 year included hearings demanding many hours of their time and ones that typically extended late into the evening. In one case committee members convened for a lengthy hearing after the spring term had ended.

Some members made lengthy (and unexpected) trips back to campus to participate.

Special thanks are extended to Dean Joseph Gordon, Yale College Dean Mary Miller, Susan Sawyer, Esq., and Dr. Lorraine Siggins. Each provided extensive counsel and assistance to the committee while simultaneously being careful to respect the committee’s independence.

I thank Dean Pamela Schirmeister who stepped in as Fact Finder for a difficult case in which the regular fact finder had declared a conflict of interest.

I thank the residential college deans, the masters, coaches, professors and members of the professional staff who accompanied students to dispositions, advised students before, during and after hearings and waited with students during the committee deliberations in order to be with those students when they heard the decisions.

Most especially I thank the Secretary of the committee, Dean Pamela George, and the Fact Finder of the committee, Professor Eric Sargis, who worked harder and longer than anyone else, taking great care to team with others and to make the best decisions possible in cases that, in 2010-2011, were often very difficult and complex.

Margaret S. Clark Chair, Yale College Executive Committee, 2010-2011

6

SUMMARIES for annual report Formal Hearings Sophomore, charged with cheating on a final exam, had charges withdrawn.

Two Seniors charged with Harassment, Intimidation, or Coercion of Any Member of the Community and imperiling the integrity of the university for conduct on-campus were reprimanded.

Senior, charged with Acts of Violence and Defiance for pushing another undergraduate at an off campus house and violating a no-contact agreement afterwards, was suspended for three semesters Two Seniors, charged with Harassment, Intimidation, or Coercion of Any Member of the Community and imperiling the integrity of the university for conduct on-campus had the charges withdrawn.

Three Juniors, charged with Harassment, Intimidation, or Coercion of Any Member of the Community and imperiling the integrity of the university for conduct on-campus were reprimanded.

Junior, charged with Harassment, Intimidation, or Coercion of Any Member of the Community and imperiling the integrity of the university for conduct on-campus had charge withdrawn.

Senior, charged with Sexual Misconduct and Harassment, Intimidation or Coercion for conduct involving another Senior on Old Campus, had charge withdrawn.

Charges of “sexual harassment” and “imperiling the integrity and values of the University community,” involving members of an organization. After a full hearing, the Committee found the organization in violation of sexual harassment and imperiling the integrity and values of the University community. The organization was sanctioned prohibiting the group from conducting any activities on campus for a period of five years, (including recruiting.) No communicating with Yale students by means of Yale bulletin boards or Yale email. Severely limit its use of the Yale name in connection with the organization.

If after five years, the organization has observed all restrictions and agrees to register as an undergraduate organization, the committee recommends that the Yale College Dean’s Office reconsider these sanctions.

The Committee requested that the national chapter formally suspend the Yale chapter for five years.

Penalty Hearing In a penalty hearing, Sophomore, charged with imperiling the integrity of the university, trespassing and intimidation for entering the bedrooms of other students without consent, had penalty upheld: suspension for 1 term and probation for the remainder of his time at Yale.

Dispositions without Formal Hearings Junior, charged with Harassment, Intimidation or Coercion of any member of the university community for trying to make contact with another undergraduate, had charge withdrawn.

7

Two freshmen, charged with cheating for submitting the same answer to a question on an online examination, were put on probation for the remainder of their time at Yale.

Junior, charged with Willful Property Damage for breaking an exit gate in a parking lot and publicly urinating in the stairwell of a university building was reprimanded.

Junior, charged with Willful Property Damage and violating Alcohol regulations for damaging a car while intoxicated, was reprimanded.

Junior, charged with cheating for copying another student's paper and submitting it as the student’s own, was put on probation for the remainder of the student’s time at Yale.

Junior, 21 years old was found intoxicated in the courtyard of Old Campus and was charged with violating alcohol regulations, was reprimanded.

Junior, charged with cheating for submitting a paper used for a previous class as the final paper for another class, was reprimanded.

Three juniors, charged with theft and trespassing for entering and stealing items from a senior society’s building were reprimanded.

Freshman, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a final paper, was put on probation for 2 years.

Sophomore, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a final paper, was suspended for 2 terms.

Freshman, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a final paper, was given 2 terms probation.

Freshman, charged with cheating for submitting 4 essays that had identical sections to essays submitted by another undergraduate in the preceding term, was put on probation for the remainder of his time at Yale.

Junior, charged with imperiling the integrity of the university for behavior while studying abroad was put on probation for the remainder of his time at Yale.

Junior, charged with Falsification of Documents for lying about an event to be held in a residential college on a document was reprimanded.

Junior, charged with Falsification of Documents for forging the signature of the Master's assistant on a Theatrical Production Application to a residential college, had charge withdrawn.

Sophomore, charged with Falsification of Documents for forging the signature of the Master's assistant on a Theatrical Production Application to a residential college, was reprimanded and restricted.

12 Seniors, charged with trespassing and violating social functions regulations for entering a college building, ignoring posted signs and hosting an unauthorized gathering where food & alcoholic drinks were served, the digital projector and DVD player were used without permission and the room was left in disarray were reprimanded.

Senior, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a final paper, was suspended for 2 terms.

Sophomore, charged with cheating for looking at notes during a bathroom break during an exam, was put on probation for the remainder of his time at Yale.

Senior, charged with Acts of Violence or Physical Force for attacking a non-university affiliated male in the area of Tower Parkway and York Street, was reprimanded.

Senior, charged with Acts of Violence or Physical Force for attacking a non-university affiliated male in the area of Tower Parkway and York Street, had the charge dismissed.

Junior, charged with Willful Property Damage for kicking the side of a car, had charges dismissed.

Senior, charged with Defiance of Authority for being uncooperative with police as they were shutting down a party at an off campus house, was reprimanded.

Sophomore, charged with cheating for plagiarizing two written assignments, was reprimanded.

8

Junior, charged with violating alcohol regulations for serving underage students at an offcampus fraternity was reprimanded.

Senior, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a lab report using a lab report from a previous year given to her from another student, was suspended for 1 term.

Sophomore, charged with violating Drug regulations for possession of marijuana and intent to sell in a residential college was suspended for 3 terms.

Senior, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a midterm essay, was suspended for 4 terms.

Freshman, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a final paper, was suspended for 1 term.

Freshman, charged with Falsification of Documents for forging Dean's Excuses, was suspended for one term.

Two juniors charged with cheating for submitting like papers were reprimanded.

Four Sophomores, charged with violating Drug and Smoking regulations for an odor of marijuana coming from a suite in a residential college were reprimanded.

Senior, charged with Falsification of Documents, Misuse of Computer Facilities and Sexual Misconduct for sending an obscene email under the name of a professor, was put on probation for the remainder of his time at Yale.

Freshman, charged with violating alcohol regulations and defiance for drinking from a can of beer on Wall Street and being uncooperative with police, was reprimanded.

Two Juniors, charged with Acts of Violence for fighting in the Yale Bowl parking lot, were reprimanded.

Senior, charged with Acts of Violence for fighting in the Yale Bowl parking lot and defiance for interfering with a police officer, was reprimanded.

Sophomore, charged with violating drug and smoking regulations for smoking marijuana in a residential college, was reprimanded.

Senior, charged with violating drug and smoking regulations for smoking marijuana in a residential college, was reprimanded.

Three Sophomores, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a final paper, were reprimanded.

Senior, charged with Acts of Violence for a fight with a male outside Toad's Place at 300 York Street, had charge withdrawn.

Senior, charged with Acts of Violence for a fight with a male outside Toad's Place at 300 York Street, was reprimanded.

Junior, charged with cheating for referring to notes during an exam, was suspended for 1 term.

Senior, charged with Willful Property Damage for painting graffiti on a metal building panel of Hendrie Hall, was put on probation for the remainder of his time at Yale and required to pay for the cost of the cleaning and repair.

Junior, charged with cheating for copying exam answers from another student, was put on probation for the remainder of his time at Yale.

Junior, charged with cheating for collaborating on a take-home final exam, was suspended for 1 term.

Junior, charged with Defiance and violating alcohol regulations for throwing liquid at a police officer and running away when asked to remain, was reprimanded.

Junior, charged with cheating for collaborating on a take-home final exam, was suspended for 4 terms.

Senior, charged with cheating for submitting a final paper that was identical to a paper submitted in another course, was given probation for the remainder of her time at Yale.

Junior, charged with cheating for referring to his iPod Touch during an exam, was suspended 9

for 4 terms.

Junior, charged with Offenses Compromising Course Materials for tweeting information about the course and the lecture without the permission of the lecturer, was reprimanded.

Two Seniors, charged with Falsification of Documents and Misuse of Computer Services for sending an email to undergraduates under the name of Dr. James Perlotto, Chief of Student Health, were given probation for the remainder of their time at Yale.

2 seniors, charged with violating alcohol regulations for serving alcohol to minors in a residential college, were reprimanded.

Senior, charged with violating drug regulations for smoking marijuana in a residential college, was reprimanded.

Junior and two sophomores, charged with Trespassing and Hazing for an initiation incident in the basement of Battell Chapel, were reprimanded.

Freshman, charged with Trespassing and Hazing for an initiation incident in the basement of Battell Chapel, had charge withdrawn.

Junior, charged with Falsification of Documents for applying for a CPA Award using another undergraduate's name, was reprimanded.

Sophomore charged with Falsification of Documents for applying for a CPA Award using another undergraduate's name, was reprimanded.

Freshman, charged with cheating for plagiarizing an essay, was reprimanded.

Sophomore, charged with Alcohol, Imperil, Assault, Intimidation and Willful Property Damage for behavior at an off-campus gathering at an off campus location, was given probation for the remainder of his time at Yale. Restitution was required for a broken window.

The willful property damage charge was dismissed.

Sophomore, charged with Alcohol, Imperiling and Intimidation for behavior at an off-campus gathering at an off campus location, was put on probation for 3 terms and required to pay for damages caused to the apartment.

Freshman, 18 y.o., charged with violating alcohol regulations when found intoxicated on Chapel Street and then running into Old Campus followed by an AMR transport, was reprimanded.

Sophomore, charged with violating alcohol regulations and willful property damage for entering another undergraduate's apartment, causing damage to the apartment; he was eventually transported via AMR to YNHH for intoxication, was put on probation for the remainder of his time at Yale.

Junior, charged with Unlawful Use of Computer Services for illegally downloading a movie to his Yale account, was reprimanded.

Four seniors, charged with violating alcohol regulations causing multiple transports for medical attention, imperiling the integrity of the university and hazing were suspended for one week.

Five seniors and one junior, charged with violating alcohol regulations causing multiple transports for medical attention, imperiling the integrity of the university and hazing were placed on probation for the remainder of their time at Yale Four seniors and one junior, charged with violating alcohol regulations causing multiple transports for medical attention, imperiling the integrity of the university and hazing were reprimanded.

Sophomore, charged with cheating for submitting a paper that he had submitted in another course, was reprimanded.

10

Freshman, charged with cheating for submitting near identical paper to another freshman, and Misconduct during a Formal Hearing for lying to the Fact Finder, was suspended for 2 terms.

Freshman, charged with cheating for submitting a near identical paper to another student, was put on probation for 3 terms.

Senior, charged with violating alcohol regulations, imperiling the integrity of the university and hazing for hosting a party at 174 Park Street and serving grain alcohol to minors, 4 of whom had to be transported to YNHH for medical assistance, was reprimanded.

Freshman, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a final paper, was suspended 2 terms.

Freshman, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a response paper, was put on probation for 3 terms.

Junior, charged with violating alcohol regulations and willful property damage for kicking out stairway windows in Davenport College while intoxicated, was reprimanded.

3 freshmen, charged with Trespassing for attempting to enter a door to the steeple of Battell Chapel and with violating Drug regulations, were reprimanded.

Freshman, charged with violating Fire Safety regulations for pulling a fire alarm without cause and leaving the scene was put on probation for 4 terms.

Junior, charged with Defiance of Authority and violating alcohol regulations for refusing to empty a cup of beer outside Lot 78W, was reprimanded.

Freshman, 18 y.o., charged with violating alcohol regulations after found in possession of a case of beer at Phelps Gate, was reprimanded. Student has two prior transports.

Senior, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a final paper rough draft, was reprimanded.

Junior, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a paper, was given probation for the remainder of his time at Yale.

Three seniors, charged with Trespassing for breaking a lock and having a gathering on the roof of university building, were reprimanded and required to pay for damage to Yale property.

Senior, charged with cheating for plagiarizing 2 class papers, was put on probation for the remainder of her time at Yale.

Junior, charged with cheating for claiming to take an exam when he did not, was put on probation for the remainder of his time at Yale.

Two Sophomores, charged with cheating for submitting very similar problem sets were reprimanded.

Senior, charged with Acts of Violence and Trespassing for a physical altercation with another senior in a residential college, was reprimanded.

Freshman, charged with cheating for turning in a make-up take home midterm exam that was identical in many areas to another student's, was suspended for 1 term.

Senior, charged with Defiance for arguing with a residential college dean and refusing to identify himself to 2 residential college deans on Cross Campus, was reprimanded.

Senior, charged with violating drug regulations for possession of marijuana in a residential college, was reprimanded.

Senior, charged with cheating for plagiarizing a final paper, was reprimanded.

Junior, charged with cheating for referring to notes during a final exam, was suspended for 2 terms.

Sophomore, charged with academic dishonesty for collaborating on a take-home final exam, was put on probation for 2 terms.

Freshman charged with academic dishonesty for collaborating on a take-home final exam was reprimanded.

11

Senior, charged with Academic Dishonesty for plagiarizing a final paper, was given probation.

Referrals Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Vanderbilt Hall. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 19 y.o., found intoxicated at the High Street gate. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at the intersection of Lock St. and Ashmun St. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Bingham Hall. AMR evaluated student but did not transport.

Senior, 21 y.o., found with a laceration on his head at Trumbull College. He had been drinking before the incident. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Welch Hall. AMR evaluated student but did not transport.

Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at Phelps Gate on College Street. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated walking on York Street. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at 350 Elm Street. AMR transport to YNHH. Senior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated in Jonathan Edwards College. AMR transport to YNHH. Junior, 20 y.o., found intoxicated in Timothy Dwight College. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated near the High Street gate. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Lawrence Hall. AMR transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Branford College. AMR transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in on Broadway. AMR transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated at the High Street gate. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Vanderbilt Hall. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Saybrook College. AMR transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Davenport College. AMR transport to YNHH. Two juniors and a senior referred and reprimanded for smoking marijuana on the front stoop of 305 Crown Street.

Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at Phelps Gate. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at Phelps Gate. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at Phelps Gate. AMR transport to UHS. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Bingham Hall. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Bingham Hall. Not transported.

Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in the courtyard behind 35 Broadway. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Phelps Hall. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at the Safety Dance at Yale Commons. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at the Safety Dance at Yale Commons. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at Timothy Dwight College. AMR Transport to DUH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at Lawrence Hall. AMR Transport to DUH. this is the 2nd transport for this student.

Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated at Davenport College. AMR Transport to DUH. Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated at Vanderbilt Hall. AMR Transport to YNNH. 12

Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at Welch Hall. AMR Transport to YNNH. Senior, 21 y.o., referred to residential college dean for drinking at the Tailgate Party at the Yale Bowl and being intoxicated at 1 Temple Street.

Senior, 21 y.o., referred to residential college dean for drinking at the Tailgate Party at the Yale Bowl and being intoxicated at 1 Temple Street.

Junior, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in the Pierson Courtyard. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Davenport College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Farnum Hall. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 17 y.o., found intoxicated in Calhoun College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 20 y.o., found intoxicated in Saybrook College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Senior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated on Prospect Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Sophomore reprimanded and referred to his residential college dean for possessing alcohol on High Street. The student was also underage.

3 Freshman referred and reprimanded for possessing alcohol while underage. One fake id was confiscated.

2 Freshman referred and reprimanded for possessing alcohol while underage. One fake id was confiscated.

Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in the courtyard of Morse College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Silliman College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated in the back of a Yale shuttle vehicle at 320 York Street.

AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior, 20 y.o., found intoxicated on York Street, near Chapel Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior, 20 y.o., found intoxicated on Elm Street in front of Saybrook College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Senior, 22 y.o., found intoxicated in Calhoun College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Lanman-Wright Hall. AMR Transport to YNHH. Senior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated on Elm Street next to Berkeley College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in the parking lot of 78 Ashmun Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman found intoxicated in the courtyard of Lanman Wright Hall. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Durfee Hall. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated near the Morse/Stiles walkway. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Bingham Hall. Medical assistance not needed.

Freshman, 19 y.o., found intoxicated at the corner of York St. and Wall St. AMR Transport to YNHH. Sophomore referred to residential college dean for possessing alcohol as a minor in Branford College.

Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Saybrook College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Bingham Hall. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at Toad's Place, 300 York Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. 13

Freshman, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Welch Hall. AMR Transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Swing Dorm. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 19 y.o., found intoxicated at Phelps Gate on High Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior, 20 y.o., found intoxicated in Trumbull College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Senior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated in Morse College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in front of Davenport College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Senior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated in Ezra Stiles. Evaluated by AMR who felt she did not require medical attention.

Sophomore, 21 y.o., found intoxicated in the Omni Hotel, 155 Temple Street, at a Yale party.

AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated at 174 Park Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated at 174 Park Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior found intoxicated in Vanderbilt Hall. AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior, 20 y.o., found intoxicated and unconscious on the sidewalk in front of 1184 Chapel Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated at 174 Park Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated and unconscious at 366 Elm Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated and unconscious at the Yale Bookstore. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated at the corner of College Street and Wall Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 20 y.o., found intoxicated in Swing Dorm. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Lawrence Hall. AMR Transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 20 y.o., found intoxicated in Jonathan Edwards College. Evaluated by AMR but not transported.

4 Freshman reprimanded and referred to their residential college deans for possession of alcohol by minors outside Payne Whitney Gymnasium.

Junior reprimanded and referred to his residential college dean for possession of alcohol by a minor outside a liquor store at 375 Elm Street.

Freshman, 18 y.o., found intoxicated in Durfee Hall. AMR transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated at Swing Dorm. AMR Transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 20 y.o., found intoxicated in the driveway of the Silliman Master's House. AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior, 22 y.o., found intoxicated in the basement of Berkeley College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman, 19 y.o., found in possession of a case of beer at Phelps Gate, was reprimanded and referred to his residential college dean.

Junior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated in the Vanderbilt College courtyard. AMR Transport to YNHH. Freshman found intoxicated near the corner of Crown Street and Howe Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Junior, 21y.o., found intoxicated at Elm Street and High Street. AMR Transport to YNHH. Senior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated at Temple Street and Trumbull Street. AMR Transport to 14

YNHH. Sophomore, 19 y.o., found in possession of alcohol at 1 Whitney Avenue, was referred to his residential college dean and reprimanded.

Junior, 20 y.o., found in possession of alcohol on Tower Parkway, was reprimanded and referred to her residential college dean and reprimanded.

Freshman, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Davenport College. AMR Transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 20 y.o., found intoxicated in Davenport College. AMR summoned but transport not needed.

Sophomore, 19 y.o., found in possession of alcohol on Tower Parkway.

Junior, 19 y.o., found in possession of alcohol on Tower Parkway, was referred to his residential college dean and reprimanded.

Sophomore, 20 y.o., found in possession of alcohol at 1 Whitney Avenue, was referred to his residential college dean and reprimanded.

Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Calhoun College. AMR transport to YNHH. Junior, 20 y.o., found intoxicated on Elm Street. AMR transport to YNHH. Junior, 20 y.o., found intoxicated on Elm Street. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Lanman-Wright Hall. AMR transport to YNHH. Junior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated at Spring Fling on High Street. AMR transport to YNHH. Junior, 22 y.o., found intoxicated at Spring Fling on Old Campus. AMR transport to YNHH. Senior, 21 y.o., found intoxicated on Elm Street. AMR summoned but no transport needed.

Sophomore, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Silliman College. AMR summoned but no transport needed.

Sophomore, 20 y.o., found intoxicated in Linsly-Chittenden Hall. AMR transport to YNHH. Freshman, 19 y.o., found intoxicated in Welch Hall. AMR transport to YNHH. Sophomore, 20 y.o., found intoxicated in Trumbull College. AMR transport to YNHH.

15