News from Maine’s Island and Coastal Communities volume 37, no. 6 n august 2023 n free circulation: 50,000
published by the island institute n workingwaterfront.com
Machias is on the move
LAURA B GOOD—
Cooperation, optimism accompany recent growth BY SARAH CRAIGHEAD DEDMON PHOTOS BY LESLIE BOWMAN
I
f you ask Bill Kitchen what’s going well in Machias, you’ll need to sit back because you’ll be listening for a while. Kitchen is a passionate booster for the shire town of Washington County. In fact, five years ago, during his campaign for a seat on board of selectmen, Kitchen penned an op-ed titled, “What’s Right with Machias.” He won in a landslide, and he hasn’t changed his position yet. “I knew it had become fashionable to say how downtrodden and poor we are in Machias, and once you slip into that, it’s very hard to get out of,” says Kitchen, who for two years has served as Machias town manager. “The point of that letter was to say, look, most of the pieces are already in place.” Those pieces include what Kitchen calls the town’s “signature assets,” like the Machias Dike, where vendors set up impromptu flea markets along Route 1, and Bad Little Falls Park, which wraps around twin waterfalls in the center of town, and the Machias Wild Blueberry Festival, now in its 46th year and set for Aug. 18-20.
The Laura B of Monhegan Boat Lines marks its 80th anniversary this year. For more photos of this storied vessel, still very much an active player in islander lives, see the photo essay on pages 14-15. PHOTO: JACK SULLIVAN
They also include key infrastructure, like the expanding Machias airport, where planning is underway to construct a longer runway, as well as Down East Community Hospital, and the University of Maine at Machias, standing high on College Hill since 1909.
Even with these assets, Kitchen acknowledges that by another measure, Machias is a poor town. In fact, according to the latest five-year data from American Community Survey, it’s the poorest town in Maine, with an average median income hovering just above continued on page 2
Battle over working waterfront on Orr’s Island Lawsuit pits privately owned parcel's owners against each other BY J. CRAIG ANDERSON
T
he numerous co-owners of a sliver of working waterfront on Orr’s Island, which has been treated as a public amenity for generations, may have to sell their shares soon if one of them prevails in court.
A lawsuit filed by part-owner John E. “Jack” Sylvester Jr. that seeks to force a sale of the property appears headed for trial later this year, following a failed attempt to resolve the dispute through mediation. Sylvester, of Orr’s Island, wants to become the site’s sole owner, according
NON-PROFIT ORG. U.S. POSTAGE PAID PORTLAND, ME 04101 PERMIT NO. 454
CAR-RT SORT POSTAL CUSTOMER
to court documents. Nearby residents The property, known as Barleyfield say they fear such a result would mean Point, is fractionally owned by at least 16 the end of public access for storage of people, including Sylvester, according fishing gear, as well as swimming, recre- to a lawsuit filed in spring 2022 in ational fishing, picnics Cumberland County on the beach, and other Superior Court and longtime community later transferred to Sylvester is asking uses for the property. the Maine Business the court to force “It’s been a place of and Consumer Court. solitude and joy, and The site is described in … co-owners to this stands to be taken Sylvester’s lawsuit as a sell their shares completely away,” said “narrow, rocky, mostly Orr’s Island resident tidal projection into to him, arguing Penny Wilson, who said Lowell’s Cove” that her family and several was conveyed by its the property is others have used the original owners to 12 “unmanaged, site for decades. “He local residents in the [Sylvester] will gate that late 1800s. unsecured, and off, and he will not allow The original owners, in deteriorating people on there.” Fidelia Prince and Sylvester declined Alice G. Robinson, condition.” to be interviewed, sold the property in citing the ongoing legal 1891 to members of dispute. All of the named defendants, four families living close to Barleyfield through their attorneys, also declined Point, the lawsuit says. interviews. continued on page 7