Celebrating 41 Years! Issue 31 Volume 42
Seattle Gay News
FRIDAY August 1, 2014 FREE!
25¢ in bookstores & newsstands
SEATTLE’S LGBT NEWS & ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY
Musab Masmari -10 years for Neighbours’ arson
low him to only get five years prison time for what he attempted to do, I was sickened by that. I am still sickened by “When I heard that Masmari was that. Please don’t allow that to happen.” able to negotiate a plea that would alThat is what I asked U.S. District by Shaun Knittel SGN Associate Editor
Judge Ricardo Martinez to consider at the sentencing of Musab Masmari, the man who set fire to Neighbours on December 31, this past New Year’s Eve. The U.S. District Court Judge
then sentenced Masmari to 10 years in prison on a federal arson charge, shocking victims and Masmari’s supporters alike. In a statement of responsibility submitted before the sentencing, Masmari admitted to setting the fire at Neighbours nightclub, but said he had no recollection of it. He declined to speak during his sentencing, referring to his statement. The sentence Masmari received was double that recommended by both the U.S. Attorney’s Office and the defense. U.S. District Judge Ricardo Martinez disregarded Masmari’s statement that he committed the crime during a drunken blackout, and, instead, invoked his discretion to impose the exceptional sentence. In fact, Martinez said he didn’t believe Masmari’s blackout story because the crime was too well planned and Masmari tried to leave the country on a flight to Turkey. The Seattle Times reports that the judge took particular note of comments made by me, a club employee and longtime Gay community advocate, who told the court that I was “disgusted” with the five-year plea deal and considered the arson
a “blatant attack on our lives.” Here’s why I had a problem with the plea bargain: • Masmari pleaded guilty to arson, which carries a mandatory minimum sentence of five years and a maximum of 20 years. • Because prosecutors could not prove in court that the arson was a hate crime, both the U.S. Attorney’s Office and Masmari’s attorneys agreed to the five-year sentence. While the burden of proof rested on the shoulders of the prosecution, and I understand why they felt they had to go for just arson charges, the community wanted more. This was a hate crime. Even the judge said he thought it was. Judge Martinez, however, was not bound by the plea deal and concluded “common sense tells us exactly what was on Mr. Masmari’s mind when he set that fire.” ”The community does need to be protected from the defendant in the future,” Martinez said. Defense attorney Charles Swift said he may appeal the sentence, saying “because of the political nature of this case, one always suspected this could happen.”
Sixth Circuit mega-hearing on Transgender public Aug. 6: Six cases from four states employees to get equal More than 18,000 children impacted
A three-judge panel of the Sixth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals will hold a six-case mega-hearing on August 6. Appellate Judges Martha Craig Daughtrey, Jeffrey S. Sutton, and Deborah L. Cook will hear challenges to laws banning same-sex marriage in two Kentucky cases, two Ohio cases, and one case each from Michigan and Tennessee. Daughtrey was appointed by President Clinton, and Sutton and Cook by George W. Bush. According to the Williams Institute, “approximately 18,300 children of same-sex couples, and nearly 52,400 same-sex couples, could be impacted by the outcome of the August 6 oral arguments in the five marriage cases before the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals.” Several national LGBT rights organization are involved in the cases. The National Center for Appellate Judge Martha Craig Daughtrey
cheshirepensionfund.org
umt.edu
by Mike Andrew SGN Staff Writer
healthcare coverage
by Mike Andrew SGN Staff Writer
The Washington Public Employee Benefits Board (PEBB) voted unanimously on July 31 to offer Transgender-inclusive healthcare coverage to all public employees in the state. Beginning on January 1, 2015, hormones, mental health, and other non-surgical healthcare services will be provided for the treatment of gender dysphoria. Surgery will also be covered beginning on July 1, 2015. see 6th Circuit page 13 The PEBB is a state agency that
“purchases and coordinates health insurance benefits for eligible public employees and retirees,” according to its web page. Gender dysphoria is a well-documented medical condition in which an individual’s gender does not conform to the gender they were assigned at birth. Treatment of gender dysphoria is considered medically necessary by the American Medical Association. “We applaud the PEBB for their leadership on this critical issue,” see TRANSGENDER page 7