Freight Shipping: Rail and Truck Freight's Modal Comparison

RSI Logistics presents this report to explore the discussion within the rail freight industry that revolves around recapturing and increasing its modal share from other modes of transportation.

Anyone involved in the rail freight industry, from shippers to operators and policymakers, will find this industry highlight informative.

Authored by our team of seasoned rail logistics experts, this publication delves into the historical outlook, the factors influencing modal shifts, and how rail carriers can recapture the shift to primarily road transportation.

Our motivation in producing this resource comes from a commitment to showcasing how the rail freight sector is adapting to current challenges and positioning itself as a crucial component of a greener, more efficient supply chain network.

We’ve produced this guide to share knowledge that can help anyone in the rail freight sector find new ways to move goods more effectively and sustainably.

The History and Evolution of North American Rail Freight Transp ortation

Rail versus Other Modes: A Comparative Analysis

The Current State and Lanscape of Rail Freight Transportation

The Modal Share Debate: A Freight Industry

The History and Evolution of North American Rail Freight Transportation

A Brief History of Rail

Freight Transportation

In the United States, rail freight transport has been integral to economic expansion since the early 19th century. Beginning in the 1820s, rail systems primarily transported agricultural products and raw materials, which were used to supply developments in other industries. The real transformative period began with the inauguration of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad in 1827, America’s first chartered rail transportation company.

The innovation of steam locomotives, popularized in the 1830s, markedly increased the efficiency and range of rail transport. As tracks spread across the country, they connected isolated communities, fostered the rise of new towns, and became a crucial artery for business and commerce.

The completion of the Transcontinental Railroad in 1869 marked a pivotal milestone, unifying the nation coast-to-coast and solidifying rail as the backbone of American freight movement.

The Golden Age of Rail Transportation and Its Decline

The 'Golden Age' of American rail transportation began in the late 19th century and continued well into the early 20th century. Rail was king of freight and passenger services, with an expansive network that was unrivaled by other modes of transport. Railroads spurred economic growth, shaped settlement patterns, and played crucial roles during wartime logistics.

However, post-World War II saw a steady decline in rail’s dominance. The rise of the Interstate Highway System, beginning in the 1950s, significantly boosted the trucking industry, particularly during the post-war economic boom when there was an increased demand for consumer goods more quickly Trucks also offered more flexible routes and more rapid, door-to-door shipments - appealing attributes as just-in-time practices began to become more common.

Additionally, regulatory burdens often placed more financial and operational constraints on rail companies compared to their road counterparts.

Rail Versus Other Modes: A Comparative Analysis

The historical shift from rail to truck in freight transportation is a quintessential example of industry evolution in response to changing times and needs.

Initially, railroads held the upper hand due to their ability to move large volumes over long distances efficiently. However, as the 20th century progressed, truck transportation began to overtake rail's modal share.

Understanding Modal Share in Freight Transportation

Modal share in the context of freight transportation refers to the percentage distribution of total freight volume that is transported by each type of transportation mode - namely rail, truck, air, and water.

This concept is crucial for several reasons.

First, it provides insights into the efficiency and popularity of different transportation modes within the macro supply chain of an economy.

Secondly, it can inform policy decisions, guiding investments in infrastructure and technology to support the most effective and sustainable modes.

Finally, understanding modal share helps businesses make informed decisions about how to move their goods in the most cost-effective, reliable, and environmentally friendly manner.

Reasons for the Modal Shift

Trucks became a popular choice for freight for several reasons:

Flexibility: Trucks offer route flexibility and direct shipment, not bound by fixed tracks or schedules like rail.

Economic Factors: Deregulation in the 1980s, especially the Motor Carrier Act, reduced trucking costs, stimulated competitive pricing, and inspired service innovation.

Technological Advancements: truck designs and technology have enhanced fuel efficiency and load capacities, further boosting trucks' cost-effectiveness and reducing their environmental impact.

Just-In-Time Logistics Shift: Rail deregulation in the early 1980s, despite intentions to boost competitiveness, couldn't fully meet the emerging just-in-time logistics demands for rapid, flexible delivery. This inability led to a loss of customers to trucking, which excelled in providing the quick, direct service that just-in-time operations required.

The Current State and Landscape of Rail Freight Transportation

Analysis of the Current Landscape

Rail freight transport in the United States continues to be a critical component of the national supply chain. It is responsible for moving significant volumes of bulk commodities such as coal, agricultural products, and manufactured goods across long distances. The major players in the industry are the Class I railroads (the BNSF, Canadian National, Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited, CSX, Union Pacific, and Norfolk Southern), and they dominate the market and operate the majority of rail freight tonnage and revenue.

In recent years, intermodal freight, which involves the transportation of shipping containers that can be moved interchangeably by rail, ship, and truck, has seen considerable growth. This method has become increasingly popular due to its efficiency and lower environmental impact compared to traditional truck deliveries.

Despite these advancements, the rail freight sector faces significant challenges. Recent years have unveiled a trend of a decline in rail freight volumes. According to the Surface Transportation Board (STB), there has been a noticeable downtick in carload volumes over the past decade, with an alarming 28% decline reported from May 2014 to May 2024.

With consumer demand stagnating, experts caution that rail volume growth may remain subdued in the short term, further exacerbating the industry's challenges.

Current Challenges Faced by the Rail Industry

Service Reliability and Operational Inefficiencies: Rail carriers struggle with reliability due to prioritizing cost-cutting over service flexibility. This is further exacerbated by fluctuating demand and labor managemen t practices.

Competition from Road Transport: Railroads face intense competition from the flexible, speedy, and door-to-door services that trucki ng provides.

Resistance to Change: A prevalent culture within railroads resists innovating service and growth due to institutional inertia, ris k aversion, and a focus on short-term financial targets.

Labor Relations: Labor relations are critical, and often strained by cost-cutting and operational changes. Disputes and labor shorta ges further impact service reliability.

Global Supply Chain Vulnerability: External events, like the COVID-19 pandemic, and internal workforce reductions have exposed rail l ogistics to volatility.

Regulatory and Policy Pressures: Railroads must navigate government policies and regulations that shape operations, posing challeng es in maintaining profitability against the backdrop of different trans portation modes.

Financial Pressures on Investment Decisions: Prioritization of short-term profitability influences investments towards cost-cutt ing and efficiency rather than enhancing service quality or investing in new technologies.

Infrastructure Limitations: Capacity and modernizations issues in rail networks restrict growth and reliability improvements, with nec essary upgrades requiring significant, long-term investment.

Environmental and Economic Impacts of Transportation Modes

Comparative Environmental Impact of Rail and Truck Freight Economic Implications

Rail freight is notably more fuel-efficient than trucks, moving a ton of freight about 500 miles on a single gallon of fuel— approximately four times more efficient than road transport. This efficiency translates to substantially lower greenhouse gas emissions and less roadway wear-and-tear.

In contrast, trucks, essential for their flexibility and door-to-door delivery, contribute significantly to carbon emissions and environmental degradation through increased road repairs and expansions.

The choice between rail and truck transport impacts not only direct shipping costs but also broader economic factors like road congestion and highway maintenance. Rail investments can reduce these costs by improving connectivity and efficiency, potentially offsetting the higher environmental and infrastructural burden of trucks.

For instance, U.S. highway congestion costs exceed $74 billion annually, much attributed to freight truck traffic, signifying both productivity losses and extensive road maintenance.

Leveraging a balanced transportation strategy that combines the strengths of both modes could enhance logistic efficiency and sustainability while mitigating economic and environmental impacts.

The Modal Share Debate: a Freight Industry Perspective

Overview of the Ongoing Discussion on Recapturing Modal Share

The freight industry faces a crucial challenge: shifting a larger share of freight from road to rail. This shift is motivated by urgent needs for environmental sustainability, reduced road congestion, and greater economic efficiency in goods transport.

As the push for greener supply chains and cost-effective transport intensifies, optimizing freight modal share, especially enhancing rail's role, is crucial.

Insights and Perspectives from Within the Industry

Rail freight's advantages are clear: it offers higher fuel efficiency, lower emissions, and the capacity to move significant volumes over long distances at competitive costs. However, its growth is hampered by inadequate rail infrastructure investment, delivery reliability issues, and last-mile connectivity challenges.

• Governments advocate for policy and investment shifts to bolster rail infrastructure and efficiency.

• Environmental groups support rail for its potential to decrease transport emissions and tackle climate change.

• Businesses demand more adaptable and reliable rail services to compete with the convenience of road transport.

Strategies for Growth and Recapturing the Modal Share

Deciding Factors

When businesses decide on whether to use rail or truck transport for their goods, there are several crucial factors at play:

Distance: Rail transport is generally more economical over long distances, benefiting from lower fuel costs per ton-mile. In contrast, truck transport is favored for shorter journeys and essential for last-mile delivery.

Nature of Goods: Rail is preferred for transporting bulky, heavy, or hazardous materials due to economic and safety considerations. Trucks, on the other hand, are highly adaptable, catering to a diverse range of goods including perishable and time-sensitive products.

Cost: Although trucks may present lower initial costs and simpler logistics, rail transport becomes more competitive for moving large volumes over extended distances, thanks to economies of scale.

Flexibility and Speed: Trucks excel in flexibility with their ability to navigate various routes and adhere to specific schedules, providing door-to-door service that ensures faster delivery, vital for urgent shipments.

Accessibility: The utility of rail is dependent on the coverage of the rail network. If the origin or destination lacks rail access, truck transport either complements or replaces rail, especially in intermodal shipments.

As global trade escalates, so does the demand for freight transport, ideally positioning rail for grabbing a larger market segment, primarily for long-haul deliveries.

The push for environmentally friendly transport solutions enhances rail's appeal, given its reduced emissions compared to trucks. Moreover, developing markets present opportunities for rail infrastructure investments to open new routes that bolster economic development.

Integrating rail with other transport modes can form cohesive multimodal logistics networks, delivering competitive benefits in cost, speed, and environmental footprint.

Infrastructure Investment

• Enhancing rail infrastructure to allow for more trains, higher speeds, and improved reliability is crucial. This includes investments in rail lines, terminals, and intermodal facilities that facilitate efficient transfers between rail and road.

Policy and Regulation

Technological

Advancements

• Implementing policies that encourage or incentivize the use of rail freight, such as lower tariffs for rail transportation, can help shift the balance. Additionally, regulations that limit emissions for freight transport could make rail a more attractive option.

• Leveraging technology to improve rail logistics, such as smart rail management solutions, real-time cargo tracking, and predictive maintenance of railroads, can increase the competitiveness of rail freight.

• Partnerships between rail operators, shippers, and government agencies can lead to more integrated logistics solutions that effectively combine the strengths of different modes of transport. This also includes working towards better last-mile connectivity options.

• By adopting more customer-centric approaches, offering flexible scheduling, and improving the reliability of services, rail freight can become a more appealing choice for shippers who prioritize speed and efficiency.

How Railroads Can Attract More Freight Shippers

To attract more shippers and secure a competitive edge, railroads must leverage innovation in several key areas:

Customer Service Enhancements

Offering more flexible, responsive, and tailor-made services that meet the unique needs of shippers. This could include customizable logistics solutions, dynamic pricing models, and improved communication channels for service support.

Sustainability Initiatives

Integration and Interoperability

Developing systems that ensure seamless integration with other transport modes, making rail a more convenient and efficient option within the larger logistics ecosystem. This also involves improving intermodal terminals and processes for smoother transitions between road, rail, and sea transport.

Promoting the environmental benefits of rail transport as a core advantage. Implementing and communicating sustainable practices and achievements can appeal to ecologically conscious shippers looking to reduce their carbon footprint.

Transparency and Reliability

Utilizing technology to provide customers with real-time tracking information and up to date records of their shipments. Improved transparency and the promise of reliability can significantly enhance the attractiveness of rail freight services.

Commitment to On-Time Deliveries

Increasing the reliability and punctuality of freight services by focusing on timely deliveries. This involves reducing delays and ensuring schedules are consistently met, which can significantly boost customer trust and satisfaction.

For shippers, the assurance that their goods will arrive on time is paramount, and railroads that can consistently deliver on this promise are likely to see increased loyalty and a larger share of customer freight.

Success Stories from Rail Freight Carriers

The Union Pacific (UP) has diversified its service offerings and integrated state-of-the-art technologies to bolster operational efficiencies. The UP’s commitment to safety and sustainability has positioned it as the railroad of choice for eco-conscious shippers, contributing to an uptick in its modal share.

The Canadian National (CN) distinguishes itself by ensuring exceptional connections to pivotal ports and facilitating seamless intermodal transfers across its network. Through strategic network investments and a commitment to leveraging technology, CN has bolstered its modal share by delivering efficient, reliable freight solutions that cater to the expansive North American market.

BNSF has significantly increased its modal share through a focused enhancement of its intermodal services. By investing heavily in network infrastructure and embracing cutting-edge technologies, BNSF has streamlined its operations, resulting in improved service reliability and a boost in its competitiveness across the continent.

Over the years, the Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CPKC) grown its rail freight modal share by prioritizing service consistency and expanding its network reach via strategic acquisitions. The railway's focus on reducing delivery times, enhancing customer service, and network improvements has accelerated freight volume growth.

Lessons Learned and Best Practices in Rail Logistics

• Prioritize Infrastructure Investment: Continuous investment in infrastructure is vital for accommodating growing freight volum es and maintaining high levels of safety and efficiency.

• Embrace Technological Innovations: Utilizing advanced technology for logistics management, tracking, and scheduling enhances operati onal productivity and customer experiences.

• Develop Efficient Intermodal Solutions: Offering competitive and efficient intermodal services is key to attracting shippers who a re considering a shift from road to more sustainable rail options.

• Adopt a Shipper-Centric Mindset: Success hinges on understanding and addressing the unique needs of shippers. Tailoring services to these needs fosters long-term partnerships and business growth.

• Champion Environmental Sustainability: The lesser environmental impact of rail freight, when compared to trucking, offers a subs tantial competitive edge. Companies that focus on improving their green credentials attract shippers prioritizing sustainability.

• Invest in Safety and Security: Strengthening safety and security measures not only meets regulatory demands but also reassures c lients about the safe handling of their cargo during transit.

• Engage in Policy Advocacy: Collaborating with policymakers to ensure supportive regulatory frameworks and securing infrastructure investments is crucial for the industry's expansion and efficienc y.

Conclusion

We hope this report has provided you with valuable insights into the innovative practices fueling the growth and efficiency of the rail freight industry. As the sector continues to evolve, staying informed about the latest trends, success stories, and strategies will be crucial for anyone involved in this dynamic field.

For ongoing updates, expert advice, and more, we invite you to sign up for the RSI Logistics blog. Our rail logistics experts, who brought you this publication, regularly contribute their knowledge and perspectives to help you navigate the complexities of rail freight and harness its full potential.

Don't miss out on the latest discussions—sign up for our blog today and keep yourself at the forefront of the industry!