IRJET- Response Spectrum Analysis of Irregular Shaped High Rise Buildings Under Combined Effect of P

International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)

e-ISSN: 2395-0056

Volume: 08 Issue: 01 | Jan 2021

p-ISSN: 2395-0072

www.irjet.net

RESPONSE SPECTRUM ANALYSIS OF IRREGULAR SHAPED HIGH RISE BUILDINGS UNDER COMBINED EFFECT OF PLAN AND VERTICAL IRREGULARITY: A CRITICAL REVIEW KRISHNA PRASAD CHAUDHARY1, Er. ANKIT MAHAJAN2 of M.Tech, Structural Engineering, Chandigarh University, Punjab, India Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Chandigarh University, Punjab, India --------------------------------------------------------------------------***---------------------------------------------------------------------------1Student

2Assistant

ABSTRACT: This paper surveys the earlier year's examinations dependent on the static and dynamic investigation of low ascent and tall structures to get required data with respect to the explorers performed over the concerned point. By and large, tall structure structures are planned as an outlined structure with shear dividers that can successfully oppose level powers. A large number of the skyscraper high rises as of late built in the Asian district utilize the container framework that comprises just of strengthened solid dividers and chunks as the underlying framework. In the majority of these structures, a shear divider may have at least one opening for utilitarian reasons. It is important to utilize a refined limited component model for an exact examination of a shear divider with openings. However, it would take a lot of computational time and memory if the whole structure were partitioned into a better lattice. Subsequently a proficient audit, which can be utilized for the examination of a tall structure with shear dividers paying little mind to the number, size and area of openings in the divider is evaluated in this investigation. The proposed audit utilizes super components, foundations and imaginary pillars. Static and dynamic examinations of model structures with different sorts of opening were performed to confirm the productivity and precision of the proposed survey. It was affirmed that the proposed survey can furnish results with exceptional precision requiring altogether diminished computational time and memory.

Key Words: Seismic Analysis, Response Spectrum Analysis, Time History Analysis, Vertical Irregularity, Plan Irregularity 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 GENERAL Constructing a new infrastructure is a complex work as it involves different stages at which different levels of work are being carried out. There are many agencies which are directly or indirectly involved in this process as shown in Fig.1.1. Client is the first agency which describes the guidelines and requirements of any project. Client then approaches architects (for architectural drawings) and structural designer (for structural drawings). After many discussions, approvals and rejections, the project enters the next phase i.e. construction phase. Different cost and time estimates are made along with the construction process to avoid any wastage and delay in this phase. Recalculation and discussion are made at every single phase.

1.2 STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS Structural analysis is the investigation of the behavior of a building/structure when it is subjected to some forces acting vertically or horizontally (external forces). These forces can be as weight because of individuals, furniture, day off, or some other excitation, for example, a quake, shaking of the ground because of an impact, and so forth. Structural analysis is also concerned with the safety and economy of the structure as they serve as a prime factor to any construction of a building. The structure should hold enough strength to fulfill the function for which it has been designed throughout its design time period.

Therefore, the structural members of a building should be designed carefully so that they can easily withstand both the forces, vertical and horizontal forces. Two major horizontal forces which may act on a building and has been proved to be a hazardous calamity in the past: Earthquake forces and wind forces. With the higher magnitude of these forces, they can be a real danger to the property and life. They can vanish the infrastructure within seconds when they come with its full strength. Therefore, proper resistance to the buildings shall be given while designing and special care shall be taken during construction phase.

Due to improper designing, conventional construction techniques and ignorance to earthquake and wind forces in the past, most of the existing infrastructure are unable to withstand the damage which will be caused if these disasters hit them.

Š 2021, IRJET

|

Impact Factor value: 7.529

|

ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal

|

Page 861

International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)

e-ISSN: 2395-0056

Volume: 08 Issue: 01 | Jan 2021

p-ISSN: 2395-0072

www.irjet.net

1.3 SEISMIC ANALYSIS After the Gujarat historical Earthquake ‘BHUJ’ 2001, we started taking earthquakes seriously and begin to design our buildings seismic resistant so that they will be non-vulnerable to the earthquakes as BHUJ created so much damage to structures and human life. Now, various experimental investigations are being carried out every day to invent new technologies relate to it so that our structures will not succumb at that moment. Earthquakes are created due to the movement of rocky surface within the earth’s surface which produces ground motion in various forms. These motions, when hit the building, shook the building and damages its structural members. Figure 1 shows the various types of faults which may be created in the rocky surface of the earth that leads to earthquake. Huge damages caused by earthquakes are being represented in the figure 2 and 4.

Figure 1. Types of Faults on Rock Boundaries during Earthquake http://www.geologypage.com/2017/10/three-main-types-faults.html

© 2021, IRJET

|

Impact Factor value: 7.529

|

ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal

|

Page 862

International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)

e-ISSN: 2395-0056

Volume: 08 Issue: 01 | Jan 2021

p-ISSN: 2395-0072

www.irjet.net

Figure 2. Damaged Infrastructure Due To Earthquake https://www.circleofblue.org/2015/world/nepal-earthquake-damages-at-least-14-hydropower-dams/

Figure 3. Damaged Highway Due To Earthquake. https://edition.cnn.com/2018/12/05/us/alaska-earthquake-road-repair-trnd/index.html

© 2021, IRJET

|

Impact Factor value: 7.529

|

ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal

|

Page 863

International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)

e-ISSN: 2395-0056

Volume: 08 Issue: 01 | Jan 2021

p-ISSN: 2395-0072

www.irjet.net

Then, in India, a special code was introduced for the seismic resistant design named as ‘Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structure IS-1893.’ At the beginning, country was divided into 5 seismic zones: zone I, II, III, IV & V but now there are only four left as zone I has been excluded from the list. This code is appropriate to structures; raised structures; modern and stack like structures; spans; solid brick work and earth dams; dikes and holding dividers and different structures. We all know that earthquakes are natural and random in nature, therefore, considering these forces while designing is must for any structure whether it is small or tall or big in order to make them seismic resistant. This is called seismic analysis of a building.

1.4 IRREGULAR STRUCTURES Today, most of the infrastructures are being widely constructed as irregular structures. A structure is a regular structure when its configurations (dimensional parameters) are almost symmetrical about all the axis. And when the structure is unsymmetrical and discontinuity in plan, elevation, mass or load bearing members, then the same shall be considered as irregular structure. This non symmetrical and discontinuity behavior of the structure causes large torsion forces which makes the structure imbalanced with respect to torsion force.

Regular buildings are those buildings which have same appearance either from plan or elevation. Yet, sporadic structures have unpredictable dissemination in their mass, strength, solidness, covered region and so on along the tallness of the structure.

Unpredictable structures comprise an enormous bit of the cutting edge metropolitan foundations. The structure design has been portrayed in BNBC-2006 as standard or sporadic regarding the size and state of the structure, game plan of primary the components and mass. The introduction of irregularity in the structure creates complex design problems. The response of such structure under seismic load depends on various factors and it is a dire need to understand the behavior of such irregular structure for the development of new design and construction technique through which the performance of the same shall be evaluated. Major failures (like shear failure) occurred due to irregularities like soft storey, mass irregularity etc. Moreover, more deflection can be seen in irregular buildings than regular buildings.

2. LITERATURE REVIEW Rahman & Deshmukh, (2013) Basic designer's most prominent test in the present situation is building seismic safe structure. Vulnerabilities included and conduct contemplates are fundamental for all polite building structures. The nearness of vertical unpredictable casing subject to destroying seismic tremor is matter of concern. The present paper endeavours to examine the relative conveyance of parallel powers advanced through seismic activity in every story level because of changes in firmness of casing on vertically sporadic edge. According to the Bureau of Indian Standard (BIS) 1893:2002(part1) arrangements, a G+10 vertically sporadic structure is displayed as a streamlined protuberance mass model for the examination with solidness anomaly at fourth floor.

To reaction parameters like story float, story diversion and story shear of structure under seismic power under the direct static and dynamic examination is considered. This investigation indicates centres around the base shear conveying limit of a structure and exhibition dimension of structure under severer zone of India. The outcome comments the decision that, a structure with firmness inconsistency gives shakiness and pulls in colossal story shear. A proportionate measure of firmness is profitable to authority over the story and base shear. The delicate processing device and business programming CSI-ETABS (variant 9.7) is utilized for displaying and investigation.

Mahesh & Rao, (2014) The conduct of G+11 multi-story working of normal and sporadic setup under earth shake is mind boggling and it differs of wind loads are expected to act all the while with earth tremor loads. In this paper a private of G+11 multi-story building is considered for earth shake and wind load utilizing ETABS (Extended Three-Dimensional Analysis of Building System) and STAAD PRO (Structural Analysis and Design Software) V8i. Accepting that material property is direct static and dynamic investigation are performed. These investigation are completed by thinking about various seismic zones and for each zone the conduct is surveyed by taking three unique sorts of soils to be specific Hard , Medium and Soft .Different reaction like story float, removals base shear are plotted for various zones and diverse kinds of soils.

© 2021, IRJET

|

Impact Factor value: 7.529

|

ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal

|

Page 864

International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)

e-ISSN: 2395-0056

Volume: 08 Issue: 01 | Jan 2021

p-ISSN: 2395-0072

www.irjet.net

Harsha & Vikranth, (2014) Multi-storeyed buildings have been examined for years on the postulation that entire of the load is functional on the comprehensive frame. Observing the mode of occurrence of the load, it is unmistakable that portion of the load is pragmatic in stages as the edifice of the frame continues, however the outstanding part of it is obligatory on accomplishment of the frame.

In contemporary paper the key element which they were bearing in mind is Cycle period for floor to floor building and forte of concrete. Due to architectural necessities some of the columns are premeditated as floating columns which respites on the transfer girder which intern rests on the shear walls in the multi-storeyed structure. Two cases have been well thought-out for the reading and judgement was made. However in Case A the erection was analysed as a whole for the subjected loading (DL, LL, WL, SL) by using ETABS software and in Case B the structure was analysed with orientation to the manufacture sequence or theatrical construction for the endangered loading by means of ETABS software.

Mohod, (2015) Structures with unpredictable geometry react contrastingly against seismic activity. Plan geometry is the parameter which chooses its execution against various stacking conditions. The impact of anomaly (plan and shape) on structure have been done by utilizing auxiliary examination programming STAAD Pro. V8i. There are a few variables which influence the conduct of structure from which story float and horizontal uprooting assume a significant job in understanding the conduct of structure. Results are communicated in type of diagrams and bar graphs. It has been seen from the exploration that straightforward arrangement and design must be embraced at the arranging stage to limit the impact of seismic tremor. Two fortified cement confined customary structures with various areas of shear dividers arranged in seismic zone V have been investigated in this examination. Ten-storeyed and Fifteen-storeyed structures were taken with four unique areas of sheardividers for example at focal edge, outer edge, interior edge, and joined outside and inside edges.

Himaja, et al. (2015) The strategy is connected to a 4 and 10 story edges framework with and without vertical anomaly, both planned according to the IS 456-2000 and IS 1893-2002 (Part I) with regards to Performance Based Seismic Design techniques. Present examination points towards doing Nonlinear Static Pushover Analysis of G+3 medium ascents and G+9 elevated structures RCC private structure outline which is to be planned by Conventional Design Methodology. A Non-direct Static Analysis (Pushover Analysis) had been utilized to acquire the inelastic disfigurement capacity of edge. It was discovered that Ferro concrete infilled sporadic model 4 (300%) tall structures building decline in distortion or relocation of the structure as it's stiffer than different structures.

Redd & Rao, (2016) Some elevated structures are planned with storm cellar. As a rule, we expect that a structure is fixed at the ground level. In this manner, the storm cellar of the structure is excluded in the investigation and just gravity loads are considered in planning the cellar. In any case, the storm cellar may acquaint adaptability with the structure bringing about bigger horizontal removals and longer vibration periods. The seismic burdens connected to a structure will influence the part powers in the storm cellar.

Along these lines, it is prescribed to incorporate the storm cellar in the examination of elevated structure structures. The impact of the storm cellar is examined dependent on the seismic reaction of elevated structures and a productive investigation technique to represent the impact of the cellar was proposed in this examination.

Kakpure & Mundhada, (2016) Reinforced Concrete (RC) building frames are most common types of constructions in urban India. These are endangered to numerous types of forces throughout their generation, such as stationary forces due to dead and live loads and lively forces due to earthquake. This paper presents a review of the previous work done on multistoried buildings vis-Ă -vis earthquake analysis. It focuses on static and dynamic analysis of buildings.

Malviya & Pahwa, (2017) This venture is worried about the investigation of seismic examination and plan of elevated structure. The primary investigation of skyscraper multistory story strengthened cement even and topsy-turvy outline building is finished with the

Š 2021, IRJET

|

Impact Factor value: 7.529

|

ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal

|

Page 865

International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)

e-ISSN: 2395-0056

Volume: 08 Issue: 01 | Jan 2021

p-ISSN: 2395-0072

www.irjet.net

assistance of SAP (System Applications and Products) programming. In the current examination, The Response range investigation (RSA) of customary RC building outlines is contrast and Response range investigation of ordinary structure and do the flexibility based plan according to IS 1893:2002 and IS 1893:2016.

Chandrika & Swamy, (2018) This exploration work centers around the investigation of conduct of plan sporadic (re-contestant corner) steel structure exposed to dynamic burdens utilizing limited component bundle SAP2000, to contemplate the impact of bracings with damper areas in arrangement unpredictable steel structure and to distinguish the reasonable area of dampers in arrangement sporadic steel structure for productively opposing the parallel burdens. This investigation incorporates the displaying of recontestant corner working of G+15 stories with plan territory of 36X40m and story stature of 3m. All the models are investigated for zone III and zone V by comparable static technique. Additionally powerful time history investigation is performed for Bhuj and El Centro tremor. Different seismic reactions like removals, base shear, story floats and time-frame are acquired. From the outcomes and conversations, it tends to be presumed that, the blend of bracings and damper has a critical commitment in opposing the sidelong loads both in the event of identical static and dynamic time history loads.

Salimath & Rajeeva, (2018) High-rise structures are for the most part influenced by horizontal burdens and helpless against seismic powers. One of the fundamental driver for disappointment of structures is their anomaly (either plan abnormality or vertical inconsistency). In this investigation, the reaction of sporadic structure with shape T arranged in seismic zone V are assessed. For the examination, 25 story structure is considered. The logical strategies utilized in this paper work are reaction range strategy and time history technique. The seismic parameters for quake loads and capacities are set according to IS1893-2002(1), IS18932016(1) and IS 16700-2017 and time history technique is completed utilizing BHUJ tremor information. The FEA programming ETABS v15 is utilized for examination. Additionally, the nearness of shear divider and the conduct of structure by its consideration is contemplated. For the examination, absolutely eight models are viewed as which are T-formed structures (with and without shear divider broke down utilizing direct and non-straight powerful technique for IS1893-2002 and IS1893-2016). In this work, different parameters like story float, story relocation, timeframe, base shear and modular mass support proportion are acquired for every one of the models and have been thought about. Likewise, the section powers at re-participant corner and inside segment is thought about.

CONCLUSIONS Based on the several literature studies based upon the seismic analysis of high rise buildings certain conclusions has been drawn which are a follows: 

When compared the both the regular and irregular configuration and the base shear value is more in the regular configuration. Because, the structures have more symmetrical dimensions.



When compared the both the regular and irregular configuration and the story drift value is more in the regular configuration. Because the structure has more dimensions.



It has found that the fundamental natural time period increases as the heavy mass shifted toward top, i.e. the time period of the frame with heavy mass at top floor will be more than the frame with heavy mass at 4th floor.



Results of max vertical reactions of a 12-storey regular building. It has been concluded that the max reaction produced is 4572.12kN in ETABS and 4624.92kN in STAAD Pro. Due to load 1.5 (Self +Dead +Live).



Max Deformation of members of regular and irregular building, it has been concluded that the maximum displacement is along x- direction and its value is 106.25mm (in STAAD Pro.) for irregular building and 53.47mm (in ETABS) along z direction for regular building. So, more precise results are generated by ETABS which leads to economical design of the building.

© 2021, IRJET

|

Impact Factor value: 7.529

|

ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal

|

Page 866

International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)

e-ISSN: 2395-0056

Volume: 08 Issue: 01 | Jan 2021

p-ISSN: 2395-0072

www.irjet.net

REFERRENCES                   

Salimath A., Rajeeva S. V., 2018, Comparative Analysis of T-shaped RC frame Structures with and without Shear Wall as per IS1893-2002 and IS1893-2016, International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, Volume: 05, Issue: 07, pp-1016-1025.

Malviya N., Pahwa S., 2017, Seismic Analysis Of High Rise Building With IS Code 1893-2002 And IS Code 1893-2016, International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, Volume: 04, Issue: 11, pp-2115-2119.

Kakpure G. G., Mundhada R. A., 2016, Comparative Study of Static and Dynamic Seismic Analysis of Multistoried RCC Building by ETAB: A Review, International Journal of Emerging Research in Management &Technology, Volume-5, Issue-12, pp-16-20.

Redd R. K., Rao M. V. S., 2016, Seismic Analysis of High Raised Building by Response Spectrum Method, International Journal of Advanced Technology and Innovative Research, Vol-08, Issue-21, pp-4111-4118.

Himaja S. V. G., Ashwini L. K., Jayaramappa N., 2015, Comparative Study on Non-Linear Analysis of Infilled Frames for Vertically Irregular Buildings, International Journal of Engineering Science Invention, Volume 4, Issue 6, pp-42-51.

Chandrika S. M., Swamy S. B., 2018, Effect Of Damper Locations On Behaviour Of Plan Irregular Steel Structure Subjected To Dynamic Loading, International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, Volume: 05, Issue: 06, pp-674-680.

Natarajan S., Veeraragavan S., 2016, A Review on Analysis and Design of Shear Walls in High Rise Irregular Building, International Journal of Scientific engineering and Technology Research, Vol-05, Issue-05, pp-808-815.

Padol R. S., Talikoti S. R., 2015, Review Paper On Seismic Responses Of Multistored Rcc Building With Mass Irregularity, International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology, Volume: 04 Issue: 03, pp-358-360.

Rahman A.S., Deshmukh G., 2013 “Seismic Response of vertically Irregular RC Frame with Stiffness Irregularity at Fourth Floor” International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering, Volume 3, Issue 8, pp-377385.

Reddy B. V. S., V. M., 2018, Comparative Study on Design Results of a Multi-storied Building using STAAD PRO and ETABS for Regular and Irregular Plan Configuration, International Journal of Applied Engineering Research, Volume 13, Number 15, pp-12194-12201.

Subash L., Chandran K. S., 2017, Influence Of P-Delta Effect On Reinforced Concrete Buildings With Vertical Irregularity - A Review, International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, Volume: 04, Issue: 02, pp-709713.

Narayan Malviya, Sumit Pahwa, “Seismic Analysis of High Rise Building With IS Code 1893-2002 And IS Code 18932016”, International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, Volume-04 Issue-11, pp-2115-2119 (2017).

Ravikant Singh, Vinay Kumar Singh, “Analysis of Seismic Loads acting on multistory Building as per IS: 1893-2002 and IS: 1893-2016 :- A comparative Study”, Journal of Civil Engineering and Environmental Technology, Volume 4, Issue 5, pp. 405-408 (2017).

B. S. Yashaswini, A. B. S. Dadapeer, “Comparative Study on Static and Dynamic Analysis of Multistoried Building Using ETABS”, IJSRST, Volume 3, Issue 6, pp-463-469 (2017).

Amit B. Anwade, Shubham B. Aher, Akshay D. Barate, Shivam Raghuvanshi, Mrs. Smita Kuralkar “Seismic Analysis, Design and Comparative Study of RC Structure Using Different Codes” International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, Volume: 05 Issue: 04, pp-4984-4990 (2018).

Miss.Aadishri D Kadam1 Dr. P.S.Pajgade, “Designing Of Soft Storey For Rc Structure Using IS-1893(Part I)-2016, And IS-13920-2016”, International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, Volume: 05, Issue: 05, pp-2855-2861 (2018).

Tejashree Kulkarni, Sachin Kulkarni, Anjum Algur, M. H. Kolhar, “Analysis And Design Of High Rise Building Frame Using Staad Pro”, International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology, Volume-05, Issue-04, pp-235-237 (2016).

K. Ramakrishna Reddy, Dr. S. Vijaya Mohan Rao, “Seismic Analysis of High Raised Building by Response Spectrum Method”, International Journal of Advanced Technology and Innovative Research, Volume-08, Issue-21, pp- 41114118 (2016).

Gauri G. Kakpure, Ashok R. Mundhada, “Comparative Study of Static and Dynamic Seismic Analysis of Multistoried RCC Building by ETAB: A Review”, International Journal of Emerging Research in Management &Technology, Volume-5, Issue-12, pp-16-20 (2016).

© 2021, IRJET

|

Impact Factor value: 7.529

|

ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal

|

Page 867