OH Today Issue 2 - 2023

Biophillia in the Workplace

Partners of OH Today

2

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

CONTENTS From the President

4

The Role of Biophilia in Workplace Health and Wellbeing

6

The Importance of Objective Testing in Occupational Asthma

12

Asbestos: the UK’s number one occupational killer

18

Risk Assessment : a case study

26

A vocational rehabilitation approach to Occupational Health: the OT-way

31

Concussion and Return to Work

36

Empowering Occupational Health professionals through digital technology

42

Artificial Intelligence (AI) and the digitisation of clinical decision-making: What’s in it for the OH professional?

46

50

ioh.org.uk

Data driven Occupational Health: Why is it important?

54

email: admin@ioh.org.uk

The skill of a Work Coach within an EAP service A Mental health case study; an employee’s perspective with a positive outcome.

57

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

Editor LYNN PRATT Assistant Editor JANET O’NEILL Production Editor IAN GARNER

Copyright © iOH 2023

Published by iOH, The Association of Occupational Health and Wellbeing Professionals

Views expressed in OH Today are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of iOH.

Nor does iOH necessarily endorse any of the products or services mentioned or advertised in the publication.

3

From the President Lynn Pratt

W

ith long-term sickness at a

professionals coming into our

record high, the

professions. The value of our

Department of Work and

membership was rated 4.5/5 which is

Pensions (DWP) has pledged to tackle

very pleasing. Your Board will be

economic inactivity as a priority. As OH

meeting shortly to discuss our longer-

professionals you can help shape the UK

term strategy and consider the survey

government's consultation

results which will help to shape our

“Occupational Health: Working Better”

future.

a proposal aimed at increasing employer use of Occupational Health (OH) Services. In addition “Tax Incentives for Occupational Health”, a joint HMTHMRC consultation on the role of tax incentives in boosting occupational health provision by employers is under consultation. Watch out on the iOH Facebook and iOH Blog area for details

of iOH sessions to gather your views for submission, led by Libby Morley.

Alternatively, you can provide your input directly by completing the response form by 12 Oct 2023.

The last few months have continued to be busy for the iOH Board. We are delighted to welcome our 1000th member last month. A huge thank you to all our members who completed the iOH Feedback Survey. It was interesting

to see the breadth of organisations where our members work. 10% work for the NHS, 24% work for OH providers, 30% in-house, 18% are contracting or self-employed and 6% are business owners. A hefty 70% have been working

Once again, iOH are proud to partner with Health and Wellbeing at Work for the annual conference on 12th & 13th March 2024 at the NEC, Birmingham. An iOH discount code is coming soon.

Meanwhile you can register interest. We are also planning the annual iOH Ruth Alston Memorial Lecture and Dinner on the evening of 12th March at the Hilton Metropole which will be open to all iOH members as a priority. iOH grants designed to support iOH members, including trainees, with CPD and career progression have been relaunched. To find out more and apply view the link in the members area of the website. The closing date is 31 Oct 2023.

Finally, a warm welcome to Mandy Kelly, who has joined the iOH Board as

Director of Occupational Therapy (OT).

Mandy comes with a wealth of experience having worked as an OT in OH for over 25 years. Mandy’s role will bring additional diversity to our multidisciplinary team.

in OH for over 10 years which could demonstrate how much we love OH, but also the necessity to encourage new blood to keep the pipeline of OH

4

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

Lynn Pratt President iOH

The Role of Biophilia in Workplace Health and Wellbeing

By Tracie McKelvie, TJM Occupational Health and Wellbeing

6

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

A

Mental Health Foundation

body is positioned. Even though we may

report highlighted our

not always be as aware of these other

relationship with nature, and

senses as we are of the five main senses,

noticing, thinking about, and

they can still have a significant impact

appreciating our natural surroundings is

on us 4.

critical in supporting good mental health, and preventing distress. If allowed, nature permits us to momentarily lose ourselves in an innocent but reflective “fantasy” of speculative fiction involving magical elements that occasionally interrupts our thoughts.

Our “sense” reactions can be from the anticipation of what we may expect, as well as from our reactive responses to the natural elements that are around us.

Our senses can influence our health and wellbeing and can have a positive knock effect on how we function and respond.

In today’s fast-paced climate, when it

Nature (or elements thereof) is an

comes to our work this can be crucial

appealing environment to enhance and

especially if others are reliant upon us

improve our mental wellbeing. When we

for our expert input, or if we need to

are exposed to, or when we think about

make important business decisions.

nature, our five senses are stimulated and tentatively teased in such a way that when “activated”, helps us to perceive and interact with our environment. This encourages creative thinking and allows us an objective perception of reality. – which in turn allows us to absorb, understand, and process information from our surroundings.

In the right surroundings, this can exude positive reactions and emotions that are difficult to ignore - regardless of how we are feeling at that moment in time. Our five senses are intricately connected to our emotions and memories 4. They can considerably influence how we feel and respond to certain situations.

The Mental Health Foundation share a consensus view that nature can generate positive emotions, such as calmness, joy, and creativity. Exposure to calming and natural environments can help to facilitate concentration and nature

connectedness and is also associated with lower levels of poor mental health, particularly lower depression and anxiety 1.

This became more apparent in very recent years when accessibility, and the ability to freely engage with nature was interrupted during the COVID-19 pandemic. This lack of exposure to nature and the outdoors led to increased stress levels amongst those who were

forced to stay indoors during several

The process of converting stimuli can be

lockdowns. For some, the lockdowns

experienced from the body’s senses, such

meant that they had little, or no access

as touch, sight, sound, and/or from

to environmental greenery, water, and

chemical senses, such as taste and smell.

open spaces.

Beyond the five senses, we can also sense a lot more within our environments. For example, we can (intuitively) tell how hot or cold it is, we can feel pain, and we can sense how our

The Mental Health Foundation share a consensus view that nature can generate positive emotions, such as calmness, joy, and creativity.

Despite moving on, today’s reality in achieving a positive and balanced exposure to the natural elements during our typical working day/s, or nights can be difficult. Our relationship with other

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

7

less appealing and less natural

Common biophilic design elements

surroundings such as a windowless

include skylights, green walls, or living

office, darkened/small/noisy/enclosed

walls covered with living greenery; and

working spaces, or shift work can have

the presence and sound of water, such

the opposite effect when it comes to

as fountains or ponds.

supporting good mental health. Whilst accessibility to high-quality nature

How can we bring nature indoors?

spaces are not equally available to

This is especially important since the

nature can mostly be found anywhere,

everyone in the UK.

So, what is biophilia?

rocketed over the past few years. But

While the Oxford Languages Dictionary

from the office, or hot-desking, making

defines biophilia as “an innate and genetically determined affinity of human beings with the natural world” the word biophilia originates from the Greek with “philia” meaning “love of.” As humans, we have a deeply ingrained and inherent love of nature which is an intuitive and natural drive imprinted into our DNA. Biophilic design is a concept used within the building industry to increase

it is argued that in addition to health benefits, there are also environmental, and economic benefits

occupant connectivity to the natural environment using direct nature, indirect nature, and space and place conditions. Used at both the building and city scale, it is argued that in addition to health benefits, there are also environmental, and economic benefits.

Although its name was coined in recent history, indicators of biophilic design have been seen in architecture from as far back as the Hanging Gardens of Babylon 2.

In terms of health and wellbeing, biophilic design has been found to support cognitive function, physical health, and psychological well-being 3, and the idea of incorporating “biophilic design” into indoor workspace is hoped to encourage the connection between humans and nature, as well as promote staff wellness and productivity.

8

OH TODAY

increase in home or hybrid working has

Summer 2023

whether we are working from home, small changes to enhance our surroundings can have a significantly positive impact on our mood, and on our general health and wellbeing.

Simply opening blinds or curtains and having access to an open window will complement our “downtime” by allowing us to immerse ourselves in natural light, and the gentle fresh breeze that circulates around us. This

open access will also allow us to absorb the natural aromas and sounds of birds chirping, or agricultural processing (such as bailing and ploughing), or even the sound and smell of falling rainwater – although for some, feeling able to take some time out may be more of a challenge.

Other ideas to promote biophilia into our home and/or office working environments could include:

✓ Mimicking, and bringing indoors some of the visuals and aromas that natural elements from the outdoors offer - such as plants, plant and wood smells, earth smells, the smell of freshly cut grass, wild garlic, and freshly growing herbs. It may be that a balcony or deck area could be transformed into a mini “indoor garden.” Or a simpler

transformation could involve

known to regulate temperatures and

growing herbs on your kitchen

remove pollutants from indoor air.

windowsill. Along with the vision of,

So why not see whether you can slot

and smell of freshly growing indoor

one or two into a sneaky nook or

herbs, there is nothing as lovely as

cranny? Alongside smaller potted

cooking with fresh, fragrant herbs

plants, leafy tropical palms in large

right from your very own indoor

pots are also statement pieces that

“garden patch.” Herbs such as mint,

will invigorate and add movement to

coriander, thyme, basil, and oregano

tired indoor spaces. You could even

are very easy to grow in little pots on

add in a lovely fragrant Jasmine

your kitchen windowsill. All you

hanging plant!

need is a little fresh air, a bit of sunlight, and some water. Oh, and if you are anything like me, put a label

For ideas on suitable indoor plants,

you can visit:

on each to remind you which is

12 DIY Indoor Plant Pot Ideas

which!

The Best Indoor Plants For Every

✓ Creating a green wall – by simply entwining greenery of choice through a trellis on one wall, or even on a wooden static structure near your workspace, this can create a tranquil and mesmerising statement. ✓ Creating a living wall – with similar

Home And Skill Level Gardeners World Best House Plants ✓ Decorating or adding to your home/office environment with sustainable, organic materials.

Some examples could include items like jute rugs (made with a soft

effects, this will require a little more

natural fibre derived from tropical

planning, and some great tips can be

plants), rubberwood furniture,

found at Gardeners World or Age UK

bamboo blinds, driftwood artifacts,

✓ You can incorporate botanical prints – regardless of whether your space is big or small, a statement wall with leafy prints or wallpaper

natural material throws, wickerwork lamps, a decorative bowl of organic dried locus pods, or a display of seashell beach décor.

with delicate floral prints can help

✓ The sound of water. Welcoming the

mimic nature within your indoor

water element into our space and

environment. Wallcoverings that

listening to the sound of gently

have textures and colours from

flowing water soothes and refreshes

outdoors go a long way towards

the senses, reduces stress levels, and

lightening and refreshing a room, but

infuses space with positivity. Just by

if you are unable to, or you don’t

adding a small tabletop water feature

want to go bold with an entire

closer to where your working space is

“botanical wall”, photographs or posters will also do the trick! ✓ You can also fill your home, (or where appropriate, your office space) with potted plants. Did you know that besides adding muchneeded oxygen, many plants are also ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

9

can make a world of difference to the

In summary, creating a workplace that

energy around you, and it can act as a

facilitates optimal performance and

great enchanting visual too.

better productivity makes good business

✓ Lighting is also an important factor - in addition to promoting well -being, biophilic lighting has been shown to have positive impacts on mood, productivity, and cognitive function 5, 6. As such, the aim would be to achieve varying intensities of light and shadow that change over

as an employer, getting the best out of people is key for performance and productivity; as an employee, feeling good when at work is also key for health and wellbeing, job satisfaction, and personal performance and productivity.

While the notion of biophilia and how

conditions and imagery that we might

this may be introduced may vary from

experience out in nature i.e.,

individual to individual, (depending on

following the circadian lighting cycle

personal choice and preferences), the

(the natural sleep/wake cycles of the

advantages that biophilia can bring to

human body). This is referred to as

an indoor space appear to be very

“dynamic” and “diffuse” lighting.

beneficial in promoting positivity, and in enhancing physical and psychological wellbeing. This in turn impacts favourably on our cognitive functioning.

Sunlight that filters through clouds or

As individuals, we do have an element of

trees

control in terms of considering our

Skylights that allow for natural light Lamps that adjust their brightness and colour temperature throughout the day Light fixtures that create patterns or shadows on the walls or ceiling Ways in which to achieve biophilic lighting in line with the circadian lighting cycle include: Dynamic control of light intensity, colour temperature, and distribution to imitate natural daylight White LED lights can adjust colour temperature throughout the day Designing lighting schemes that highlight patterns, textures, and shapes found in nature

OH TODAY

researched, and talked about topic, and

time in order to mimic the lighting

Examples of dynamic and diffuse lighting are:

10

sense. This notion is a heavily

Summer 2023

working environments, and in making changes – i.e., bringing a little bit of nature indoors. Remember, the smallest of changes can make a significant difference.

References: 1.Ref: Mental Health Foundation (MHF) 2021, Nature; how connecting with nature benefits our mental health, https://www.mentalhealth.org.uk/our-work/research/nature-how-connecting-nature-benefits-our-mental-health 2.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biophilic_design 3.https://www.nrdc.org/bio/maria-mccain/bringing-outdoors-benefits-biophilia 4.https://www.harleystreetent.com/blog/the-five-senses-and-why-they-are-important/ 5.https://workinmind.org/2020/02/17/the-benefits-of-biophilia 6.https://www.ies.org/research/fires/double-dynamic-lighting-bringing-qualities-of-natural-light-into-the-office/

Tracie McKelvie is an Independent Specialist Nurse Practitioner in Occupational Health, Queens Nurse and Founder of TJM Occupational Health and Wellbeing.

Follow on Linkedin.

Contact Tracie - tracie@tjm-ohw.co.uk

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

11

The Importance of Objective Testing in Occupational Asthma

By Charlene Mhangami Senior Clinical Application Specialist, Vitalograph What is occupational asthma?

Working is important for an individual’s health and

well-being, as well as providing the employee with income, social interaction, purpose, and identity.

Workplaces are required to be safe and free from risks to health and there is a legal duty for employers to maintain this. However, there are some instances where workers may develop a

disease called occupational asthma (OA) in the workplace where they may become allergic to certain substances and chemicals which cause

airflow obstruction, i.e. some healthcare workers may develop a latex allergy by breathing in the powder from the inner lining of the gloves or some workers may be exposed to substances like ammonia and develop asthma as the result of an irritant effect, not an allergic reaction.

Before delving deeper into occupational asthma (OA) it is important to discuss what is asthma, according to GINA (2022), “Asthma is characterized by chronic airway inflammation, there are two key defining features of asthma, which include variable respiratory symptoms such as wheezing, shortness of breath, chest tightness, and cough. Also, variable expiratory flow and airflow limitation”.

Approximately 360 million people have asthma around the world, for those workers with asthma, their asthma control may be affected by factors in

12

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

the workplace, especially if the asthma is related to

the workplace. This leads to the development of the term ‘work-related asthma’ (WRA). It is suggested that 25% of adult-onset asthma is WRA. WRA can be subdivided into phenotypes which include work-aggravated asthma (WAA), which affects people with pre-existing asthma or report symptoms worsened by non-specific factors in the

or humidity extremes, exertion from manual work

tasks, workplace stress, or anxiety. In contrast, occupational asthma (OA) is caused by airborne exposures in the working environment and accounts for 1 in 6 cases of adult asthma. OA can be subdivided into two categories Allergic OA due to sensitization and Irritant induced asthma as shown in Figure 1.

workplace. Causes include workplace temperature

Figure 1 BTS Clarification of Occupational Asthma1 There are over 400 known causes of OA, and most cases in the UK are mainly related to exposure to a small number of allergens, commonly flour dust, and isocyanates. Allergic OA sensitization requires

a period of repeated allergen exposure and the duration of time between first exposure and symptom onset is referred to as the ‘latent period’.

The asthmagens that cause Allergic OA can be divided into two categories: high molecular weight (HMW) agents, and low molecular weight (LMW) asthmagens.

HMW includes animal proteins, cereal grains, and natural rubber latex. Some examples of workers at risk of this are bakers, laboratory workers, and

detergent manufacturers, to name a few.

LMW includes di-isocyanates, metals, and acrylic monomers. Workers who may be at risk of this are adhesive workers, welders, spray painters, and many others.

OA caused by exposure to HMW asthmagens is an IgE-associated response involving T-helper cells and this is a common allergic response to asthma.

The immune response is also relevant to a small number of LMW, such as anhydrides and platinum salts. It is suggested the highest risk of OA is within the first year of exposure, and reported latency is variable ranging from a week to many years. ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

13

A main risk factor for the development

and reasons for a late diagnosis varied. These include lack of

of OA is the level of exposure to the

awareness or patient engagement and in some cases, diagnostic

cause. Individual susceptibility is also

delays resulting from missed opportunities to ask simple

important, as only a proportion of

screening questions during health surveillance.

similarly exposed workers become sensitized, and only some of these will ever develop OA.

Investigations into OA should be carried out as early as possible, prior to the commencement of any medical interventions and while patients are still working in the job considered to be the

Investigations in the workplace

cause of their OA. Health surveillance programs are a way of

The diagnosis of OA involves first

disease. However, few workers are identified via health

confirming the presence of asthma and

surveillance programs as only 30% of workers have access to

evidence that asthma is caused by

health surveillance.

preventing occupational health diseases and can help to identify those with OA early on, reducing the severity and impact of the

workplace conditions with various investigations involved. The best diagnostic approach for OA is having a good combination of clinical history and objective diagnostic tests. The diagnostic process aims to confirm or exclude OA; no single diagnostic test exists for OA, and the exact approach used will vary based on the individual patient's circumstances, the level of practice and expertise of healthcare professionals, and the testing facilities available. Clinical and occupational history plays a key role in making diagnosis in OA, this includes an overview of full occupational history, a fully detailed discussion of respiratory symptoms and their relationship to

“According to the BTS, annual health surveillance is generally carried out by an occupational health provider and usually consists of a respiratory symptom questionnaire and spirometry.

In some special circumstances, such as the detergent and precious metal refining industries, immunological surveillance is also used”

work. NICE recommends checking for possible OA by asking organisations to regularly monitor their employees with

Serial PEF

new adult-onset symptoms. It is

There are a variety of objective tests available for investigating

important to note a diagnosis of OA

OA. Serial PEF offers a cheap and simple first-line approach to

cannot be made based on history alone,

assessing the physiological responses to inhaled agents in the

as some of the symptoms may improve

workplace. However, it is important to note serial PEFs are only

away from work. Sensitized workers are

helpful if the patient is still exposed to the potential agents.

also at risk of other related forms of

Serial work-related PEF measurements do not usually confirm a

occupational allergies such as rhinitis.

specific cause for OA and may be seen in other conditions such

Therefore, cautious precautions should

as WAA and occupational hypersensitivity pneumonitis.

be taken in the investigation.

Depending on the local protocol, occupational health

A UK study has shown the duration of symptoms prior to diagnosis is 4 years, 14

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

professionals can initiate serial PEF recording or upon referral to secondary care. In serial PEF recording, this involves the patient

learning how to use the PEF monitor and understanding the charts outputted from the data collected. There is software available for healthcare professionals that analyzes the data such as the Oasys software, which looks for pattern recognition and produces an Oasys score to show positive or negative work effects. The serial PEF data should be collected over a long period of time, and the worker should make recordings before and during work, as well as on periods of annual leave.

Immunological testing: specific IgE and SPT A positive SPT or high level of IgE antibodies related to the workplace allergen confirm sensitization but not the presence of OA. The diagnostic usefulness of immunological testing for OA is greater for HMW allergens with a clear immunological mechanism (enzymes, laboratory animals, latex and wheat flour). Specific IgE tests are also available for a limited number of LMW agents and when present, have high specificity for diagnosis.

Spirometry All workers suspected of having OA should have their PEF, FEV1 and FVC measured and interpreted according to international spirometry guidelines. Some measured values are commonly

within normal limits, but in some cases, a bronchodilator responsiveness test may need to be performed to confirm reversible airflow obstruction. In addition to its diagnostic value, spirometry is important in providing a baseline measurement for monitoring throughout employment.

Monitoring FEV1 has proven beneficial in OA however, if available, the pattern of previous spirometry results (often from health surveillance) can be informative. For example, if a drop in FEV1 is followed by a marked improvement, that can clearly be linked to a reduction in exposure.

“Workers found to have new symptoms of asthma, airflow obstruction, accelerated forced expiratory volume (FEV1) decline (≥15% from baseline, in addition to expected age-related loss) or sensitization to a workplace allergen, may be referred to an occupational physician, their General Practitioner (GP) or directly to a specialist centre”. ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

15

Fractional exhaled nitric oxide with sputum and eosinophils A common way of measuring airway inflammation is by fractional exhaled nitric oxide (FeNO), or by induced sputum eosinophil counts. This has an established role in the assessment of patients with suspected asthma, but normal levels may be found in a proportion of patients with OA. Although limited data is available in their assessment of inflammatory response, these types of tests are more useful with OA due to HMW chemicals, as LMW chemicals are less likely to cause eosinophilic disease. Elevated FeNO levels were found in OA induced by HMW agents where an IgE-mediated mechanism was involved (e.g. baker’s asthma), as well as in OA induced by some LMW agents such as diisocyanates. It is suggested that FeNO levels were more consistently increased in patients with

OA to HMW agents than in those with LMW agents.

Non-specific bronchial hyper-responsiveness testing An option for measuring airway reactivity is by using mannitol or histamine as a specific test, although this has low sensitivity for OA diagnosis, and in some early cases of the disease the airway reactivity resolves with a few days away from work. The test is very useful in those who are symptomatic with recent exposure, where the absence of non-specific bronchial hyper-responsiveness makes OA unlikely. Nevertheless, this type of testing is performed within a secondary care setting.

Management of occupational asthma A common consensus across this article is that correct diagnosis is essential for a favorable outcome in the management of occupational asthma. NICE lists occupational exposures as a risk factor for poor asthma outcomes. The diagnostic process should involve a combination of diagnostic tests and questionnaires. Having an objective test involved in the diagnostic process increases the confidence of the healthcare professional in their diagnosis, and the confidence of the worker who may be diagnosed with OA. Management of occupational asthma involves asthma education, control of exposure to environmental triggers, and initiation of appropriate pharmacotherapy. If OA is not diagnosed correctly, and the worker is not protected or able to avoid exposure to the triggers, permanent changes can present themselves in the lung.

References: Barber, C.M. et al. (2022) ‘British Thoracic Society Clinical Statement on occupational asthma’, Thorax, 77(5), pp.

433–442. doi:10.1136/thoraxjnl-2021-218597.

Global strategy for asthma management and prevention (2016 update) - gina. Available at: https://ginasthma.org/wp -content/uploads/2016/04/GINA-2016-main-report_tracked.pdf Asthma: Diagnosis, monitoring and Chronic Asthma Management. Available at: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ ng80/resources/asthma-diagnosis-monitoring-and-chronic-asthma-management-pdf-1837687975621 Tiotiu, A.I. et al. (2020) ‘Progress in occupational asthma’, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(12), p. 4553. doi:10.3390/ijerph17124553.

Occupational asthma (2022) Mayo Clinic. Available at: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/ occupational-asthma/symptoms-causes/syc-20375772 16

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

Asbestos: the UK’s number one occupational killer

By Mesothelioma UK

W

hile the import, supply and use of asbestos was banned from 1999, it is still present in most buildings built before the year 2000. According to the Health and Safety Executive (HSE), asbestos is still in around 300,000 non-domestic buildings including hospitals, schools, prisons, council offices and more.

cancer deaths linked to past exposures to asbestos.

Before its ban, asbestos was used in a wide range of industries because of its resistance to chemicals, heat, water and electricity. In particular it was used as an insulator in the shipbuilding industry and as a cheap construction material for post-war buildings.

• The chest wall, where it is known as the pleura

The deadly dust

Mesothelioma is more common in men than in

The first documented death from asbestos was as far back as 1906, however it wasn’t until the 1950s that the first report linking asbestos and lung cancer was produced.

From the 1950s onwards there was an understanding in the medical community of the link between asbestos and cancer, although the first report linking asbestos to mesothelioma specifically wasn’t until 1960.

In 1985 the first mandatory ban on asbestos was introduced, but this only covered blue and brown asbestos. White asbestos is far more common in the UK, and was not banned until 1999. Whilst there has been some debate previously about whether white asbestos was harmful, it is now widely accepted that all types of asbestos are carcinogenic.

HSE statistics on asbestosis, mesothelioma and lung cancer in Britain, show that asbestosrelated deaths have now climbed to over 5,000 each year. In 2020, there were 2,544 mesothelioma deaths in total (Health and Safety Executive ‘Mesothelioma statistics for Great Britain, 2022’), with a similar number of lung 18

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

Mesothelioma Mesothelioma is a cancer caused by exposure to asbestos in up to 90 per cent of all cases. It affects the mesothelium which is a thin membrane that lines the inner surface of:

• The abdomen where it is known as the peritoneum • The heart where it is known as the pericardium • The testes women and nearly half of the people diagnosed with the disease are over 75 years old (Royal College of Physicians 2020 ‘National Mesothelioma Audit report 2020’) and there is usually a long delay (between 15 and 45 years) from exposure to the onset of the disease.

Mesothelioma used to be thought of as ‘an old man’s disease’ but there is increasing evidence demonstrating how the demographic and occupation of those dying is changing. Teachers, healthcare workers, and younger people who have never worked with asbestos are all at risk of contracting an asbestos-related disease. This is something that has also been identified by Mesothelioma UK nurses, who are seeing patients from occupational backgrounds previously not considered at high risk of exposure to asbestos.

Research by Howie concluded that teachers and nurses experienced about four and two times higher mesothelioma deaths. (Howie R. 2017 ‘Mesothelioma Deaths in Teachers and Nurses in Great Britain’. Environmental Health Scotland 2017;29(4):35-37)

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

19

Mesothelioma can sometimes be treated with

immunotherapy, chemotherapy or, less commonly, surgery. However, whilst some progress is being made to find new treatments there is no cure and sadly, it can progress quite quickly after diagnosis with only 10 per cent of people living three years beyond diagnosis (Royal College of Physicians 2020 ‘National Mesothelioma Audit report 2020’).

Mesothelioma has a high burden of symptoms

Where might asbestos be?

Asbestos was commonly used in building materials that were used in workplace and industrial buildings in the 1950s – 1990s.

Therefore, it is possible that asbestos containing materials may be found in any workplace premises built or refurbished before the year 2000, including many schools and hospitals. It is thought that up to 81 per cent

Before and after Mesothelioma which includes breathlessness, pain, weight

of schools (Department of Education 2019

loss and fatigue. It is a devastating diagnosis

‘Asbestos Management Assurance Process

for patients and families and the fact that this

report’) and 94 per cent of hospitals in London

disease is preventable can make it even harder

contain asbestos (BBC News, London 2017).

to come to terms with.

A detailed list of typical locations where asbestos materials can be found in industrial and workplace properties can be found on the HSE website.

It can be difficult to identify asbestos, as it is

20

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

often mixed with other materials. The HSE

asbestos image gallery shows a number of common materials that contain asbestos.

Challenging the asbestos regulations

These include ceiling tiles, floor tiles, roof

In 2021, Mesothelioma UK Chief Executive, Liz

panelling, pipe lagging and many more.

Darlison, gave evidence at a Work & Pensions

Raising awareness of the dangers Mesothelioma UK is dedicated to providing specialist mesothelioma information, support and education, and to improving care and treatment for all UK mesothelioma patients

and their carers. It aims to prevent mesothelioma happening to future generations.

In addition to supporting patients and families through a network of clinical nurse specialists, Mesothelioma UK funds research, produces a National Mesothelioma Audit, promotes clinical trials and collaborates with organisations and campaigns seeking to promote better management or removal of asbestos.

In July 2023, the Sunday Times launched a campaign, Act Now on Asbestos, highlighting the dangers of asbestos in public buildings and calling for a national plan for the removal of all asbestos over the next four decades.

Select Committee inquiry into the Health and Safety Executive’s asbestos policy. The resulting report referred to asbestos-related illness as ‘one of the great workplace tragedies of modern times’, with the HSE estimating that the total annual cost of death from mesothelioma is £3.4 billion. The report recommended a cross-government strategy for the removal of asbestos from public buildings within 40 years and a central register to record the location and condition of asbestos in public buildings.

These recommendations were robustly supported by Mesothelioma UK. Unfortunately, the Government/HSE response to the W&P Select Committee report showed little movement on any of the recommendations. On the phased, prioritised removal of asbestos from at-risk buildings – something Mesothelioma UK strongly advocates – the Government says: ‘The Government could only advocate a proactive course of action in this area if there is compelling evidence that the, undoubted,

“Former pupils and teachers are dying after

increase in exposure to asbestos workers that

exposure to asbestos in classrooms, decades

will result from active removal, possibly

ago, while children continue to be taught in

prematurely, is justified in terms of reducing

schools full of the material…The Sunday

risk of exposure to building users. At present

Times believes there should be a national

this evidence is not there.’

register of buildings with asbestos.”

With the continued danger of asbestos

Sunday Times front page, 2 July 2023.

exposure, particularly to public sector workers,

Mesothelioma UK fully supports the Sunday Times’ efforts to raise awareness of the dangers of asbestos and as part of it’s Don’t Let The Dust Settle campaign, encourages people to sign a parliamentary petition calling for a register and a phased removal plan.

Mesothelioma UK will press the Government to empower the Health and Safety Executive to deliver better research, measurement and monitoring of asbestos risk, to ensure enforcement of and compliance with Control of Asbestos Regulations.

https://petition.parliament.uk/ petitions/635817

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

21

Staying safe at work

Find asbestos professionals

Until progress is made in terms of asbestos

ATAC - the Asbestos Testing and Consultancy

removal on a national scale, it’s vital that

Association represents specialists in asbestos

employers take the issue of asbestos seriously.

surveying and testing

The UK has strict regulations to prevent

NORAC – the National Organisation of

people’s exposure to asbestos fibres. These

Asbestos Consultants represents asbestos

regulations are the Control of Asbestos

consultants

Regulations 2012. The regulations detail what actions need to be taken to identify and manage asbestos in the workplace, who can carry out work on asbestos, what training they need, what controls they need to use and what records they need to keep.

ARCA - the Asbestos Removal Contractors Association represents specialist licensed asbestos removal contractors UKATA - the UK Asbestos Training Association

represents asbestos training providers

Duty to manage Regulation 4 of the Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012 requires the risk from asbestos in all workplace premises to be managed. This means that the location and condition of all asbestos within the premises needs to be identified, and the risk presented by any asbestos present has to be managed to prevent harm to anyone who works on the

building, or to the building occupants. More details on the duty to manage asbestos – who, where, what, how etc is here on the HSE website and this useful guide will tell duty holders what steps to take to meet their responsibilities and keep their workplace safe for employees.

Until asbestos is removed from all buildings, people are still at risk of contracting asbestosrelated diseases. Mesothelioma UK will continue to campaign for change and

encourages all employers to do all they can to raise awareness of the dangers of asbestos and take all possible steps to keep employees safe.

22

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

For more information on mesothelioma, or if you would like to know more about our work and how to get involved please contact Mesothelioma UK at info@mesothelioma.uk.com or visit www.mesothelioma.uk.com

26

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

Risk Assessment : a case study

By Phina Amahoro One of the primary goals of public health is to establish conditions that allow people to live healthy lives for as long as feasible. People are believed to spend around one-third of their lives at work. As a result, protecting the health of the working population through occupational health services has been recognised as an important component of public health strategy (WHO, 2001).

Occupational Health Nurses (OHN’s) deploy a variety of evidence-based clinical and risk management interventions to ensure that an employee's work tasks do not have a negative impact on their health (WHO, 2001).

This case study will outline the health and safety recommendations provided to a local authority in accordance with evidence-based clinical and risk management guidance.

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

27

Introduction

T

he author was contracted by a maintenance team manager regarding occupational health

advice. Management provided information about the employees’ occupational health history which included stress (work-related) and epilepsy.

all workers have the right to work in environments where risks to their health and safety are effectively managed

comes to finding and obtaining employment (De Boer, 2005). There are a variety of external factors that contribute to the disadvantages that individuals with epilepsy encounter when it comes to finding and retaining work. Researchers observed that employers were often unfamiliar with the different types of epilepsy, the

advises employers on how to keep their

varying ways in which epilepsy can

employees physically and

affect different people, and the fact that

psychologically safe at work. According

anti-epileptic drugs can control the

to the HSE, all workers have the right to

condition in some people (Francis,

work in environments where risks to

Byford and Wilson, 2019). The

their health and safety are effectively

aforementioned factors were considered

managed (Health and Safety and

when developing a robust OH

Executive, 2009).

intervention plan for the employee in

Work Stress

question.

has identified six fundamental features

Occupational Health interventions

that can contribute to work-related

The management team informed the

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE)

stress in the workplace (Health and Safety Executive, 2019). These features will be addressed in the section below and linked to the employee-reported (2022), the estimated number of workers in the United Kingdom suffering from a work-related illness is 1.8 million, with stress, depression, and anxiety accounting for over half of all instances.

Epilepsy and work It is estimated that 50 million worldwide suffer from epilepsy, Epilepsy is defined as recurrent, unpredictable, and usually unprovoked seizure activity. Individuals with epilepsy are among the most vulnerable members of society because

OH TODAY

epilepsy face several challenges when it

The Health and Safety Executive (2009)

workplace issues. According to HSE

28

Evidence suggests that individuals with

author that the employee had recently had frequent sickness absences, all of which were attributed to work stress.

The maintenance worker was initially hired as a Slater. However, in the last 18 months, the individual has been redeployed to another position working in a canteen. The employee is currently absent from his workplace due to reported work-related stress.

An initial fitness for work assessment was conducted as soon as operationally feasible as evidence suggests that intervention-based case management in OH can result in people returning to work sooner, which is cost-effective for the organization (Parsons et al., 2021).

epilepsy is a hidden disability that

Following a recent absence, the author

remains a highly stigmatized condition

assessed the employee's fitness for work

to this day (Mula and Kaufman, 2020).

and discovered that the source of the

Summer 2023

perceived work stress was twofold. The

set and where he felt that his

author discovered that the employee

specialist skills were not being

had a known epilepsy diagnosis and had

utilized.

a single seizure 18 months ago. This appeared to be the first seizure in a decade. The employee stated that he experienced multiple absences due to work-related stress during the 18-month period of redeployment. The employee felt unsupported by the management team and desired to return to his substantive work as a slater. The author wished to gain clarity on the employees’ health history. To do so, further medical evidence was sought from the employees’ GP and neurologist. The employee’s treating specialists provided

2. Control - The employee stated that he felt that he had little control over his current work environment and whether he would be able to return to his substantive post.

3. Support - The employee stated that he had not had much interaction with management since changes in management structure, and his

health/work situation had not been reviewed as previously recommended.

4. Relationships at work - The

evidence about the employee’s medical

employee reported that he was

diagnosis, how his condition presents,

having difficulty blending in with the

and what treatment pathways have been

catering staff because they had been

recommended.

working together for many years and

HRA findings

had a fixed ‘culture’. He added that

The first level of risk management in the

substantive role, with whom he had

workplace is risk assessment. It is the

worked for many years.

process of considering all of the aspects in a given circumstance, including recognising the dangers, the potential degree and nature of any risk, and those who may be affected (Williams, Dotson and Maier, 2012).

Risk assessment's findings serve as the foundation for ongoing planned management. Risk management is a plan, strategy, or programme that tries

to manage an incident, event, or danger by removing or lowering factors that may cause harm and allowing any chance for beneficial outcomes to be taken as safely as possible (Aven, 2016).

he missed his colleagues in his

5. Role - The employee was unclear as to why, after several months in his redeployed function and with his condition having stabilized, he had not yet been reviewed or spoken with management about the possibility of returning to his previous role.

6. Change - The employee felt that the combination of changes in

management structure, his job role, and the changes to his typically good attendance record were all too much and that he was unable to envision staying in the workplace if things remained the same.

Stress risk Assessment 1. Demands – The employee reported working in a deployed role where tasks allocated did not match his skill

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

29

Epilepsy Risk Assessment

they have any physical or psychological

The author was able to provide

entail the employees’ work tasks, work

management with advice on health,

means / equipment, and the working

safety, and risk management for this

environment. Collaboration between

individual employee after reviewing and

management and employees is required

observing the employee's medical

for occupational health to provide

history and specialist reports. According

effective health and safety advice.

to the employee's specialist, the

Employers must follow good safety

individual had focal (partial) seizures

practices established by legal

without loss of consciousness. It was

frameworks from apt governing

established that the diagnosis was given

authorities and legislation. (Jardine et

to him as a child, and he had been

al., 2003). Occupational Health Services

seizure free for ten years. It was noted

(OHS) play an essential role in

that the disease was adequately

protecting all workers' health and

managed with prescription anti-

wellbeing. Our primary engagement

epileptic drugs, and that the seizure 18

with employers as OH practitioners is

months prior was caused by

through management referrals.

unforeseeable circumstances. It was

Ensuring that all Bio-Psycho-social

noted that the employee had gone on

components and workplace contributors

holiday without taking his prescribed

are addressed in a consultation allows

medication for ten days.

OHN's to provide fitness-for-work

Regarding risk management and the

(Nicholson, 2017) advice as well

employee’s role, the author’s OH opinion was that the employee was fit

issues that may interfere with their performance. The other three pillars

as education and support for those managing the employees.

for his substantive role which includes working from heights with a few recommendations. The employee should always be harnessed and wear protective headgear when working at heights, he should never be the first ascender and these recommendations should be kept in place for a minimum of 2 years. The author carried out an individual risk

assessment with guidance from the specialist report and Epilepsy Action.

The risk assessment was to be reviewed and updated every 6 months.

Conclusion Risk management in the workplace is determined by four pillars. These include the employees' current capacity to perform their work tasks and whether

30

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

Phina is a Specialised Occupational Health Nurse (SCHPN) currently working for PAM Group. She is particularly passionate about community health and is a trustee of a charity focusing on tackling mental ill-health within the African / Caribbean communities Baba Yangu foundation.

A vocational rehabilitation approach to occupational health: the OT-way

By Jo Vallom-Smith

Introduction

T

he occupational therapy (OT) and occupational health (OH)

professions emerged in the

same periods for similar, work-focussed reasons. Over the centuries, we went in different directions and have remained relatively separate for far too long.

Happily, however, we are now coming together to benefit employees and employers alike.

The following quotes are taken from Occupational Health: The Value Proposition (2022, Dr Paul J Nicholson OBE):

"Occupational health disability case management interventions that include early contact with workers on sick leave and specific agreements around work modifications result in faster returns to work and are cost saving" "It is suggested that active occupational health care aimed at prevention and rehabilitation is more profitable than a focus on treatment"

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

31

A large meta-analysis of what works in

the interventions continue as long as there is a

occupational health found that interventions

need and cease when this has been resolved.

that were proactive and followed a

This creates the possibility for a more person-

rehabilitation model were effective and

centred and targeted approach.

provide a good return on investment.

Whenever appropriate, VR practitioners will

In Mark Howard's wonderful 2023 article, he

liaise with other stakeholders, such as HR

explains the potential downsides of traditional

representatives or the line manager, to gain a

OH services, which, in my experience, make up

fuller perspective on the workplace situation

the majority of OH provision in the UK. He

to plan interventions appropriately.

quotes Peckham, et al., (2017) who says "researchers and practitioners entering the field are largely being trained to assess and

control exposures using approaches developed under old models of work and risks." and goes on to argue that "we need to better align with the current realities of work and health and to prepare practitioners for the changing array of workplace health challenges."

What is VR?

Another element that often forms a part of VR interventions by OTs is "functional restoration" or "work hardening" programmes

(the former being the preferred term). These can be delivered as an outpatient or in-house service. Functional restoration programmes (FRPs) may include time in the gym or the workplace, specifically working on factors that are preventing a return to work. These are widely used in the US, Canada and Australia

The Vocational Rehabilitation Association defines vocational rehabilitation as "a multidisciplinary intervention offered to those with physical, psychological and/or social difficulties enabling a return to work or preventing loss of work". Vocational rehabilitation interventions use a

and have a good evidence base for efficacy.

In this article, I often refer to the "OT" as this is my field of experience (and bias!). However, in many cases, these services are expertly

delivered by a "VR practitioner" who may come from a vast range of backgrounds, including but not limited to nurses, psychologists, social

rehabilitation approach, which usually means

workers and "non-qualified" workers.

working with the same person over a period of

How does VR fit into OH?

time to support them to work towards certain work-focussed goals. This kind of intervention has a strong evidence base for return on investment, especially for chronic and fluctuating conditions such as ME/CFS and fibromyalgia.

Following a referral, VR practitioners undertake an initial assessment, which is usually much more in-depth than a standard management referral. The VR practitioner may then make some initial recommendations, and the service may be complete at this stage.

More often, however, the practitioner will book a follow-up appointment to review the interventions and make further recommendations accordingly. In this model, 32

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

VR provision within OH is not standard, and there is a wide diversity in how VR is delivered.

In some OH companies, OTs are providing a hybrid VR-OH approach which has been received incredibly well with employers, who

come back time and again for this service.

Using this hybrid approach, all management referrals are undertaken by OTs, who will make a clinical judgement for each case as to whether they will follow up with this person to deliver VR interventions or if the one-off management referral was sufficient.

In other OH companies, OHAs or OHNs screen employees, who will then signpost, as needed, to an OT for VR interventions. In my

experience, many employers want VR for their

employees but cannot access vocational rehabilitation through their existing OH

Who is best placed to deliver VR?

provider. Therefore, a growing number of

I want to caveat this section by acknowledging

employers, particularly SMEs, are seeking

my obvious bias towards OTs! However, I will

these interventions through external specialist

try to back up my bias with evidence. OTs were

VR companies, most often from the insurance

created in response to a huge societal need for

and medicolegal sector, where VR

VR in the moral treatment movement and post

interventions are more commonplace.

-WW1. Our degree focuses on understanding

Case study example: One of the cases that, I feel, best demonstrates the unique contribution of OTs delivering a VR approach to OH, is that of Mr X, who had worked as an operations manager for a public service organisation for many years. He sustained a road traffic injury which resulted in an amputation of his non-dominant upper limb below the elbow. Before returning to work, HR referred him to an occupational therapist. It was felt that their in-house OH team might not have the skills required for this complex and high-profile case. In the referral, practical concerns were raised regarding Mr X's ability to use DSE and operate a vehicle, but HR also identified some significant anxiety and low mood symptoms, which they felt may present an additional barrier to returning to work.

The occupational therapist met with the employee, completed an initial assessment and wrote an initial report. The occupational therapist then met with Mr X on several occasions over the following months and supported the implementation of various recommendations: Voice recognition software to reduce the typing demand of his job Arrangement of vehicle control adaptation Engagement with the employer's EAP (employee assistance programme) for cognitive behavioural therapy Signposting to peer support groups for amputees A phased return to work. Not only the hours of work but gradually increasing the particular demands of Mr X's job that he found most challenging.

The occupational therapist liaised with the employee, HR, H&S and line manager throughout this process to ensure a smooth and sustained return to work.

In other settings, this gentleman may have been seen by an OHA or OHN, a physiotherapist and perhaps a physician. Mr X may have needed to repeatedly share his traumatic story and disclose the needs that made him feel incredibly vulnerable to people he may only see once. In this case, however, Mr X was seen by one health professional throughout, who was able to build a therapeutic relationship and coordinate all relevant services to meet all of his occupational needs. As well as seeing one professional, the VR approach was key in reviewing recommendations to ensure they met the identified needs.

I honestly believe that, without a VR approach, this case may have ended very differently. With a VR approach, everyone is a winner. The employee feels valued and listened to, the business retains important talent, and the occupational therapist has the satisfaction of going on a journey with a person and following a case to its conclusion.

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

33

the person, the task they’re required to do, and the

same quantity and quality of work as their nurse

environment in which they do it. We are

colleagues. However, they also work as "specialist

rehabilitation experts and work in many

OTs", delivering a vast range of assessments and

rehabilitation fields. Our training covers not only

interventions. This may include cognitive

mental health and physical health but also

assessments, functional capacity evaluations

cognitive, neurodivergent, neurological, ME/CFS,

(FCEs), ergonomics and specialist mental health

chronic pain conditions and most other types of

assessments.

conditions that humans experience.

A recent work-related development in the OT world

OTs consistently focus on function over pathology.

is that we now work widely in GP surgeries, offering

Whilst we understand and consider diagnoses,

VR interventions and writing fit notes. OTs are well

medication and treatment, these are rarely our

placed to offer this service due to their

focus. We are hyper-focused on how any condition

understanding of VR, breadth of training and focus

(or conditions) impact the functional ability of any

on function.

individual worker. From day one of our degree, we learn to break down any task into the minutiae of

Conclusion

its physical, social, cognitive and myriad other

In this article, I hope to have convinced you that

components using "activity analysis". Throughout

occupational therapists have a key role in

our degree, we are taught about the

occupational health provision. Whether through

biopsychosocial model and how to incorporate this

specialist assessments, working as OHAs or

into all areas of our practice.

delivering vocational rehabilitation interventions.

OTs can and do work as occupational health advisors (OHAs), delivering traditional one-off management referral services and achieving the

There is a river of untapped potential here, and employees and employers will be the beneficiaries if we can make this shift together.

I'd like to leave you musing with a question.

What would a working population look like if all employers used a VR approach to OH instead of the traditional OH provision?

Jo Vallom-Smith is an occupational therapist who has specialised in the field of occupational health. Jo is the director of OTforOH, a specialist recruitment agency placing OTs in OH roles. Jo runs an informal networking group for OTs who work in occupational health. Jo is also on the national executive committee for the Royal College of Occupational Therapists, Specialist Section Work and is the Occupational Health co-lead.

Follow Jo www.OTforOH.com. w.linkedin.com/in/jo-otforoh/ (2) Facebook

34

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH IN POLICING “Driving the governance of clinical interventions” OHNAPS Conference to be held on 12 – 13 October 2023 at the College of Policing The Occupational Health Nurse Advisers to the Police Services is a professional association of occupational health clinicians. Our members work in the OH departments of the police forces throughout the UK and support the National Police Chief Council and College of Policing governance and project boards. The patron is Chief Constable and College of Policing CEO Andy Marsh, QPM. There is an active membership, steered by an executive committee who work closely with the Oscar Kilo – National Police Wellbeing Service.

OHNAPS provides subject matter expertise and peer support to professionals working in OH departments and for strategic leaders of these departments. It promotes best professional practice by sharing policies and procedures.

In conjunction with Oscar Kilo a course for those in this speciality is currently being developed.

The 2023 conference: “Sharing Best Practice” will be on 12-13 October. There are two free places per force, if your OH Service looks after two forces then there are four free places. If you have more delegates attending, then the cost is £120 per-delegate. Places include delegate attendance on both days, overnight accommodation, and formal dinner at the College of Policing. This is possible due to the generosity of the Oscar Kilo NPWS and our exhibitors. Certificates of attendance for CPD will be issued. The conference is open to all clinicians: OH Nurse Advisors, Technicians, OHP’s, RMN’s and other health professionals and managers & Heads of OH Services. The main speaker on Day 1 is Dr John Harrison the National Police Chief Medical Officer - Oscar Kilo - NPWS. He will be speaking on: “The police covenant and OH: potential and pitfalls”. One of our guest speakers on Day 2 is Janet O’Neill – Deputy Head of the National School of OH. She will be taking us through the remit of the NSOH, projects they are working on and blue sky thinking for future workforce development. Other topics on the

programme include “CBRN - What is the OH role?”: “Overview of psychological health surveillance.”: “Should you ask for OH records when an officer is transferred between Police Services?” and more.

To register as a delegate please email: College Events events@college.police.uk College of Policing, Leamington Road. Coventry. CV8 3EN

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

35

Concussion and Return to Work

By Claire Odd Introduction

I

was a high achieving professional, working as Group Health and Safety Manager for a large PLC. Also, an

academic achiever, having recently

completed an Executive MBA and was on course to commence a PhD. However, in 2017 I sustained a concussion in a mountain bike accident and within a

make a full recovery within 3 months; however, there are people (19%) whose

symptoms still affected their work after this time; the most common symptoms in this group were workplace fatigue and an inability to maintain previous

Initially, I thought it was just a bump on

Rehabilitation

included, it is a life-changing experience, and not always a positive

There are 160,000 people who experience traumatic brain injuries each year in the UK (Radford, 2018).

one.

Concussion recovery is different for

What is a concussion?

same. (Karmali, 2022).

everyone, no two recoveries will be the

There is an ongoing debate about

Much is still unknown about the whole-

whether concussion should be renamed

body impact of a concussion, and

as a mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI).

research is primarily undertaken with

Literature uses the terms

male elite athletes. Translating this to

interchangeably (Clark and Guskiewicz,

the general population, taking account

2015, Graff, 2020).

of hormonal changes and physiological

Concussion is frequently described as a

differences between genders is not easy.

traumatic brain injury or functional injury, caused by a direct or indirect

blow to the head, neck, or body (McCrory et al., 2017, Boshra et Al, 2020 and Patricious et al, 2023). An impulsive force is transmitted to the brain. It does not involve damage or change to the structure of the brain and is not visible on most readily available imaging in the emergency care setting (Lunkova et al., 2021, Pinky et al, 2022). Imaging is, however, important to rule out more

OH TODAY

Typically, people with concussion will

workload/standards (Cooksley, 2018).

than that. For many people, me

36

al., 2022, Patricious et al, 2023).

split second my life turned upside down. the head, but it became so much more

For many people, me included, it is a life-changing experience, and not always a positive one.

serious traumatic brain injury (Pinky et

Summer 2023

However, Patricious et al 2023, reports longer recovery times for females, due

to the cyclical nature of female hormones and metabolic effects.

Ongoing symptoms of concussion (or post-concussion syndrome (PCS)) may be non-specific and may be due to other exacerbating factors such as mental health issues, sleep disturbance, learning and attention difficulties, vestibular problems and even menopause (Patricious et al, 2023).

Figure 1 below, demonstrates the number of functions of the brain and therefore the

challenges in recovering from concussion. Understanding the points of impact that led to the concussion can be helpful to understand where there are likely to be challenges with areas of executive function (Dooley, 2022). Previously, it was thought that the only recovery from concussion was protection and rest, sitting in a dark room and avoiding any kind of activity that would stimulate the brain, however, given the interconnectedness of the human body, rehabilitation should have a whole-person approach, especially with the metabolic effects reported by Patricious et al, 2023.

Figure 1. Brain anatomy and function A holistic and targeted rehabilitation

Concussion has a complex

programme can be helpful. I personally

pathophysiology that disrupts the

found immense success working with a

normal neuro metabolic activities within

practitioner who used a combination of

the brain, causing an inflammation

Neuro Kinetic Therapy, Proprioceptive

response. It may take up to 30 days to

Deep Tendon Reflexes, and Cranio-

rebuild energy stores (Sun et al., 2008,

Sacral Therapy.

Concussion Alliance)

Recovery and return to work (RTW)

The Consensus Statement in Concussion

There are still questions about how to

of daily living during the initial 24–48

optimise a return to work given the

hours following a concussion, then

variation in mechanisms of injury,

proposes a framework for returning to

personal experience, and symptoms

work/learn then progressing in more

(Patricious et al 2023).

vigorous activities/sport (Schneider,

in Sport advocates a brief period of rest, which includes a reduction in activities

2023).

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

37

Table 1 - Return to work plan (Adapted from Return to Learn, Consensus statement in Concussion in Sport, 2022) Mental activity Daily activities that do not result in more than a mild exacerbation of symptoms related to the current concussion

Dedicated cognitive activities

Activity at each step Typical activities during the day (e.g., reading) while minimising screen time.

Start with 5–15 min at a time and increase gradually.

Setting aside time to perform cognitive activities such as reading or completing puzzles, logic games, crosswords, or similar outside of the workplace place

A gradual introduction of work.

Return to work part-time

Return to work full time

May need to start with a reduced day or with greater access to rest breaks during the day.

Gradually progress into full work activities until a full day can be tolerated without more than mild symptom exacerbation.

Goal

Gradual return to typical life management activities

Increase tolerance to cognitive in readiness for work

Increase cognitive load activities & reintroduction to workplace

To return to full workload capacity

Individuals can then return to light-intensity physical activity, which does not more than mildly exacerbate symptoms, such as walking. Gentle exercise (without any risk of falls) is also great for regulating the nervous system and mobilising the lymphatic system to reduce inflammation. When I think about my own journey, it took some time to start normal daily living activities. Swimming was my saviour during most of my recovery, primarily as I did not have to worry about balance and coordinating my body.

Where there are cognitive difficulties, sleep disturbances, dizziness, headaches, and neck pain that persist for more than ten days, then further support should be gained from an appropriately trained and experienced physical therapist.

38

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

Typical challenges in returning to work (RTW).

Persistent PCS can have long-term consequences for return to work (Cancelliere et al., 2014) and influence selfesteem and quality of life (Mani et al.,2017). This is something that was very much part of my own journey.

The one thing from my own journey that has really stood out, was that my recovery was anything but linear. This made it both frustrating and difficult to plan incremental milestones for both me and my employer. This is something that is repeated frequently by my clients and recalled anecdotally by my colleagues. A typical example would be completing routine work tasks successfully for several consecutive days, but then producing lower quality work whilst not displaying an overt return of symptoms. Working through this requires patience from both sides. Table 2 details the challenges involved for both employers and employees in successfully navigating returning to work.

Table 2 - Concussion RTW challenges Employee

Employer

• Understanding of concussion

• Understanding of concussion

• Understanding their own capability

• Referral pathways and signposting

• Dealing with non-linear recovery

• Understanding the employee capabilities

• Sensitivity to light and noise

• Dealing with non-linear recovery

• Visual and vestibular processing issues

• Adjusted working hours.

• Reading comprehension

• Changes to shift pattern (such as not working nights)

• Trouble finding words/word amnesia.

• Taking part in conversations with multiple people

• Flexible working

• Insomnia

• Headaches

• Physical changes to the working environment (quiet room, reduced lighting, blinds, moving closer to entrance/ exits, working on the ground floor, different lenses in safety specs)

• Attention span

• Temporary secondment

• Anxiety & loss of confidence

• Working from home

• Emotional regulation

• Decreased workload

• Nausea

• Re-allocation of tasks

• Digestive issues and food sensitivities

• Less complex work allocated.

• Balance and co-ordination issues

• Non-computer-based work

• Cognitive capacity and processing • Personal Organisation

• Using additional technology (dictation & transcript)

• Memory and recall

• Buddy system

• Support from family and friends

• Support of employer & colleagues

• Fatigue • Tinnitus

• Increased breaks

• Support from an appropriately qualified and experienced rehabilitation team.

• Travelling for work – particularly at dawn/ dusk or in rush hour ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

39

I know that from my own experiences,

my ability to self-organise and be in the

About the Author

right place at the right time was deeply affected – as someone who was always unflustered no matter what and never late, this was hard to comprehend and accept. Other areas that I struggled with were memory recall, being able to keep up with the flow of conversation in meetings and being able to multi-task (e.g., listening and note-taking). I still struggle with memory recall now and being able to call things the right name spontaneously. Through a mindset shift and reframing, I no longer see this as a weakness, stressful or embarrassing. It is about creativity and finding new ways to use language.

Learning more about concussion Coming from a background in exercise rehabilitation, learning more about effective rehabilitation for concussion was key for me and my journey to where I am today. Even more so as the support and onward referral for specialist support from my GP was lacking. It consisted of you just need to rest, and that is as good as it’s going to get for you, so you need to accept it. I feel lucky to have learnt about concussion with some of the world’s leading educators.

• Dr Kathy Dooley - Immaculate

Claire is a Health Coach, Rehabilitation Therapist, Sports Scientist and Chartered Health & Safety Practitioner. Before moving to independent practice and consultancy she worked in senior leadership positions in highprofile safety-critical organisations leading their health, safety, and wellbeing programmes.

In her independent practice, she practices a whole-person approach, working with all aspects of women’s health, particularly perimenopause & post-operative recovery, and concussion rehabilitation, alongside supporting organisations with their workplace health and wellbeing programmes. www.restoring-balance.co.uk

Dissection • Dr Ryan Foley and Dr Kyle Paxton Integrated Kinetic Neurology • Dr Cameron Marshall – Complete Concussion • Dr Molly Parker – Concussion Compass • Carrick Institute • University of Calgary

40

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

PS I didn’t get to start my PhD, but I have accepted that my brain just does not work that way anymore and that I have gone a different but more fulfilling path.

Upcoming iOH webinars

Visit the iOH website for more Webinars

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

41

Empowering Occupational Health professionals through digital technology

By Rachel Rowe SiSU

I

n late July, the Department

technologies can be rolled out at scale

for Work and Pensions (DWP)

and can transform the healthcare

and Department of Health

system in the UK.

and Social Care (DHSC)

announced they are looking at plans to widen access to health support in the workplace.

Employers will be encouraged to take up Occupational Health offers to help employees access

SiSU Health Stations have empowered the Health and Wellbeing Teams

vital mental and physical health support at work. But how do we scale quickly and provide occupational health services that

When will this technology be available to utilise in the workforce? Technology that gives you detailed real-time data and insights on the health of your workforce, facilitating early intervention of those who might become unfit for work is already available today.

Leading companies such as Aldi and Currys have been early adopters of selfservice health check technology in their

are affordable, particularly for the

smaller and medium organisations? Traditional occupational health services often face challenges in reaching a large number of employees due to logistical constraints and costs.

It was announced in June that Digital NHS Health Checks (free for those eligible over 40 years old), will be rolled out from next Spring to alleviate the pressure on

GP surgeries. The initiative will deliver one million checks in the first four years, according to the DHSC. Tens of thousands of cases of hypertension are expected to be identified and hundreds of strokes and heart attacks prevented with patients accessing the health check via digital means. A great example of how innovative

42

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

SiSU Health Station

workplaces. SiSU Health Stations have

limits, employers are needing to re-consider their

empowered the Health and Wellbeing

role in supporting the health of their employees. But

Teams with detailed insight into their

to truly scale and be fully inclusive, these solutions

workforce health, well-being and the

also need to flex to the different needs of individuals

productivity impacts over time.

and to the new hybrid ways of working and therefore

This technology offers cost effectiveness and increased efficiency when compared to traditional people-embedded service.

By digitising various aspects of health

cannot only be available in the physical workplace or just via apps. Solutions need to exist in places where people live their daily lives – supermarkets, pharmacies, leisure centres, libraries.

monitoring and data collection,

Local authorities such as Luton Borough Council and

Occupational Health Teams can

Buckinghamshire Council are already being proactive

optimise resource allocation, and offer

in adopting digital health check technology for their

more personalised services to a larger

communities. Working together with workplaces, the

employee base. The data collected can

promotion of self-service health checks in the

be used to target and tailor wellness

community, can not only positively impact the health

programs enhancing the effectiveness of

of workforces but also the wider community in

these initiatives with ongoing, accurate

improving longer term health and addressing health

measurement of impact.

inequalities.

The increased accessibility, real-time monitoring, data driven insights and personalised user experiences, can empower occupational health practitioners to transform employee

health and wellbeing propositions at scale. Embracing such digital solutions not only benefits the individual employees but enables employers to monitor health at scale whilst reducing costs and enhancing productivity and wider society benefits in the long run.

The data produced by these digital solutions is both accurate (measured by a medical device and not self-reported) and incredibly powerful. For example,

Christina Gleeson, Public Health Manager at Luton Borough Council and says “Working with SiSU Health has enabled localised, tailored opportunistic health screening aiming to tackle modifiable health risk among some of our poorest and marginalised communities in the town. The high proportion of the calls to action identified has enabled greater support to be provided by our local integrated wellbeing service already tackling health inequalities faced by such communities.”

did you know that employees in Transportation have the highest number of health risks (and the highest levels of smoking). Transportation also has the highest proportion of employees living in deprived areas. However, we also see the greatest improvement in BMI risk in Transportation when platforms such as SiSU health are implemented. (Source).

With NHS services stretched to their

Health inequalities arising from poor access and poor engagement with healthcare services result in low health literacy and preventable health risks. This results in a cost to business and to the NHS. It costs the NHS c.£4.8 billion each year for the greater use of hospitals by people in deprived areas (source).

This is because those living in more socio-economically disadvantaged neighbourhoods and minority ethnic groups have higher rates of hypertension, diabetes, asthma, COPD heart disease, liver disease, renal disease, cancer, cardiovascular disease, obesity and smoking. ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

43

SiSU analysed millions of data points from their UK

health checks to better understand the issues around health inequalities.

The results highlighted that 74% of people who completed a health check, had not had their blood pressure measured in the last 12 months, but in males who recognised as being of mixed ethnicity, it was over 80%. Put another way and more concerning, 62% of people who measured a blood pressure risk, had not recently measured it and so were likely unaware. Users identifying as Black, reported the highest levels of BMI and blood pressure

risk with the prevalence of people with BMI obesity (BMI 30+) strongly aligned to their deprivation.

Regarding the potential impact on health literacy and motivation to improve health, 35% of people reported not being aware of the health risks identified by the health check and that rose to over 50% for Asian people. Over 70% of people who completed a health check reported they were motivated to make positive changes to improve their health because of the check and that rose to over 90% in those identifying as black. Demonstrating the

real power and impact of these highly accessible,

scalable solutions for everyone.

Testimonials from that cohort are formidable:

“Now l am more aware that if I do not keep my weight and BP in check, I might suffer stroke and heart diseases.”

However, these platforms not only come with the ability to identify and support health risks, but also to integrate and signpost people to the most appropriate health service for them, according to their level of risk and the services available. For

example, by directing people with high blood pressure, high perceived stress, high BMI, smoking, alcohol risk etc. to an onward service, whether that be an occupational health service, pharmacy, partner or an NHS service.

In the rapidly evolving landscape of healthcare, the integration of technology has proven a powerful force for change. The realm of occupational health services is no exception as digital health checks emerge as transformative tools to drive costeffective scaling, promoting employee wellbeing

and addressing health inequalities .

SiSU Health provides highly accessible, self-service health checks, utilising a medical device (class 11a) health check machine, the SiSU Health Station. A typical health check takes about 5 minutes and includes Height, Weight, BMI, Blood Pressure (BP), BP medication and recency of check, Heart Rate, Body Fat, Smoking, CVD risk, Alcohol, Physical Activity and Perceived Stress. No supervision is needed. SiSU Health’s Mission is simple: “to help people live a healthy life”. Read the UK Health Equalities Report in full: https:// www.sisuhealth.co.uk/uk-health-report

44

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

Artificial Intelligence (AI) and the digitisation of clinical decisionmaking: What’s in it for the OH professional?

By Lucy Kenyon

T

echnology that might move our

resulting in the need for a follow-up call

industry forward is subject to

from a health professional to clarify

the mathematical modelling

whether there is an impact on work and/

behind policies. In this article, I am exploring the factors that influence Insurance Risk Assessment. Selfinsuring organisations such as the NHS,

primary care, prevention and treatment services are already using the latest wearable technology, the use of which is subject to consent to share data with AI. OH services are required to hold insurance policies and their records are ‘Special data’ with additional safeguards over and above patient records.

Clinical decision-making pathways have

or adjustments required.

A McKinsey study reported the lowest automation potential for professionals managing people (9%) of work time and those applying expertise (18%). Other factors were costs to automate, availability and cost of skilled workers, quality gains), and regulatory and social -acceptance considerations. Professions applying medical expertise were rated low-risk overall.

AI and OH

been featured in NICE guidelines since

We cannot discuss the digitisation of

2002 when the first clinical guideline

OH and the use of AI without

was published on schizophrenia. They

considering policy underwriters for OH

are designed to improve consistency of

businesses. My own experience is that

treatment across the UK and this makes

most underwriters still have little

the model ideal to address the public

understanding of the scope and purpose

concerns around variability in OH

of OH beyond listed chargeable activity

advice. Pre-placement

titles with no requirement to clarify the

recommendations are probably the most

decision-making processes involved.

automated OH process at present.

Actuaries and underwriters working

Applicants and new starters answer yes

with experienced OH brokers such as

or no to a series of questions, often

BHIB report being wary of services using

46

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

AI has the p prevent inci becoming tr tragedies t being re

potential to idents from ragedies and themselves epeated.

triage and automated decision-making.

OH needs technology that facilitates efficiencies, learning and growth at a similar rate to other areas of healthcare.

Would training help the financial and insurance sectors to safely remove or reduce the barriers to technological advancement whilst maintaining data protection?

The recent conviction of a health professional is a powerful example of the consequences of not understanding

or learning from incidents. It also generated earnest discussions amongst fellow OH professionals regarding the consequences of and liability for ‘fitness for work’ recommendations, as we contemplate the outcome and impact of a new Clothier style enquiry into how fitness to practice might best be assessed. AI has the potential to prevent incidents from becoming tragedies and tragedies themselves being repeated.

Custom and practice continue to see the term ‘Fitness Certificate’ issued by OH services. Most of us have experienced the frustrations of our service users when a relatively new starter experiences difficulties before the end of their probationary period despite having been issued with a Fit certificate at the time of the job offer. It is clear from the number of employers expressing at best disappointment or referring individuals

within the first 6 months of employment that their expectations and interpretation of these certificates are a guarantee of fitness.

One positive legacy of COVID is how it changed managers’ perceptions of OH advice. Our reports were suddenly welcomed enthusiastically as sources of evidence for protective arrangements or reassurance that the available evidence

suggested that they were unlikely to

experience severe illness. Although R Kelly v Royal Mail (UKEAT/0262/18/RN) is not a landmark judgement, Justice Choudhury was eloquently clear in his recommendations about OH advice; “That assistance and guidance may be to the effect that the employee is a disabled person: and, unless the employer has good reason to disagree with the basis of such advice, he will ordinarily respect it in his dealings with the employee. In other cases, the guidance may be that the opinion of the adviser is that the employee is not a disabled person. In such cases the employer must not forget that it is still he, the employer, who has to make the factual judgement as to whether the employee is or is not disabled: he cannot simply rubber-stamp the (OH) adviser’s opinion that he is not.”

This raises fundamental questions about the nature, reach and outcomes of OH advice in a digital age. As soon as AI apps and systems appeared, my business partner asked me whether it was safe to use one of the familiar AI systems to generate an OH report.

Pioneering data-driven technologies in OH In 1948 the first radiology images were sent 24 miles over a telephone line.

Since then technological developments have paved the way for the transmission of psychiatric consultations via closedcircuit TV and in-flight monitoring and self-reporting of heart rate, temperature and respiration via microphone in the ‘60s. 1982 saw the first digital health assessment using a wearable biometric sports watch.

In 1983 the American Industrial Hygiene

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

47

Association reported that “The use of the microcomputer offers

time away from the workplace for the

a simple, inexpensive solution to the numerous problems

individual and time lost by clinicians

associated with data management in an OH program”. I first

and service users in case of late arrival

used an OH records management system when helping Peter

and unplanned or complex

Mattison set up health surveillance for Body Shop

documentation.

manufacturing in 1995. In the last 30 years, implementation on a large scale has remained challenging on technical, logistical, and financial levels. Comparative studies of digital diagnostics have published reassuring data on safety and feasibility, but the implementation challenges referred to above highlight the need for training and the knowledge of pitfalls.

Faxed or scanned images of forms and letters within OH workflows have propelled us into digital medicine (DM).

Digital images and video streams can now be shared in real-time (telemedicine), bridging the physical

The DHSC code of conduct lists the following behaviours

distance between clinicians and service

expected from those developing, deploying and using data-

users. For me, this has led to real-time

driven technologies:

case conferences at the end of consultations to ensure that the

Respect for persons Respect for human rights

manager has immediate recommendations to consider pending

Participation

the final report.

Accounting for decision

Digital health surveillance images can

Many clinicians remain reluctant to sign off reports on selfassessment questionnaires alone and are concerned about reporting without the clinical consultation that has historically represented their profession.

now be evaluated by OH physicians for early signs of occupational disease with digital record keeping developing the capability for new trend recognition and

analysis that outstrips the traditional

Cost-efficiency analyses and OH issues need to be addressed

assessment of symptoms and links

comprehensively. Health risk assessment is being blended into

images to clinical data. For me, the most

the traditional OH workflow, and the approval of AI for routine

exciting aspect is the opportunity to

assessments is beginning to challenge human evaluation as the

record and monitor decision-making

gold standard.

using AI and make occupational disease

Past digital assessment implementations and future possibilities

truly preventable and ultimately a thing

The addition of artificial intelligence coupled with technical

challenges to increase availability and efficiency in OH is already driving changes to the profession, and we must retain ownership if we are to maintain the protection of the ‘special data’.

of the past.

Quality Digital OH provides enables in-house

validation of representative cases and techniques. Should OH work to the Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM), standard to ensure

Historically, completed questionnaires were digitized for

that diagnostically used data storage is

detailed evaluation and record keeping, audit and teaching. The

adequate?

introduction of “tele-assessment”, pioneered in OH in the early 2000s, saw consultations carried out by telephone rather than in person, challenging the idea that visual assessment of the individual would provide greater diagnostic accuracy than competent clinical assessment. The intention was to reduce

48

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

In conclusion, the digitisation of routine diagnostics is complex and requires expertise, human resources, and a continuous focus on technical advances.

Clinicians may also need external

eyestrain, burning eyes, diplopia, and blurred vision when using

professionals to define specifications for

(computer) screens (M Rosenfield, 2011). Musculoskeletal injury

major hardware procurements and

from computer use has been estimated to account for at least

compare vendors’ offers in-depth

half of work-related injuries (PC Bohr, 2000).

meaningfully.

A quick search for AI clinical workflow produced several applications providing analysis of reports before actual signout, configured to analyse the assessment report as well as images of screening to automatically alert the clinician to potential diagnostic

Keywords: digital occupational health; machine learning; artificial intelligence; occupational health; computer vision syndrome; automation; clinical guidelines, clinical protocols, underwriting, medical malpractice, medical negligence, public liability

Biography

discrepancies before final sign-out. I understand that AI that collects and analyses human input has been proposed to triage cancer pre-screening cases for reporting and to balance workload distribution. This has huge potential for mesothelioma and other occupational cancers.

AI applications have been shown to benefit from human input for increased classification performance and reduced

training. This concept is called “Humanin-the-loop”.

With the majority of OH professionals operating independently, costeffectiveness can only realistically be achieved with a digital assessment workflow that does not cost more than the human processing time and also enables human audit on request.

Digital DSE risk evaluation We cannot talk about the use of technology within OH without

Lucy Kenyon is a Specialist Independent OH Nurse Consultant who has been teaching and mentoring Occupational Health since 1996 for the RCN, Universities of Birmingham, Coventry, Derby and West of Scotland. She delivers professional development courses for the National Performance Advisory Group, Cordell Health and employers. Lucy was President of iOH from 2017 until 2020. She has been a NonExecutive Director since 2021. She has a Master of Medical Science and International Certificate in Occupational Hygiene from Birmingham, where she has taught and worked on research projects. Follow Lucy on LinkedIn.

considering the foreseeable risks associated with continuous DSE use.

Time-efficient hardware and software must consider digital eye and upper limb strain. Between 64% and 90% of computer users experience visual symptoms such as dry eyes, headaches,

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

49

Data driven Occupational Health: Why is it important?

By Nikki Cordell

In this article, Dr Nikki Cordell, CEO of Cordell Health, and a keen proponent of technology in the occupational health sector shares how we can use data to improve the quality and evidence base of occupational health practice. She will also explore how the profession can harness the power of technology to support their clinical practice and improve outcomes.

50

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

H

ow should clinicians use data

data helps us move beyond mere assumptions

in decision-making? Whilst

and subjective judgments avoiding our

clinical experience is a key

unconscious biases. Stepping back to

factor, as clinicians we need to be

objectively assess the facts, and where useful,

careful that unconscious bias doesn’t

undertake trend analysis of data for target

influence the specialist advice we

populations, provides us with a powerful tool

provide to both employee and employer.

to advise employers in order that their

Within the sector, we promote

decision-making can become more evidence

occupational health as being

based and grounded in the facts.

independent and evidence based, but how much of our decision-making meets these criteria. Therefore, it is essential

we consider what data we use to help inform our decisions and opinion, its quality and how it’s both accessed and interpreted.

“

How might this positively impact employee health and wellbeing?

A practical example of this would be in providing advice for shift workers. We understand that rotating shift patterns can have adverse impacts on employees. We can

You can’t manage what you can’t

use this information with data provided on a

measure” is a well-known quote by

night worker questionnaire to advise at

management guru Peter Drucker.

employee level and organisational level on

This does have relevance to occupational health practice. The more

sophisticated we are in how we measure, what we measure and how we manage data, the more robust and evidencebased our specialist advice becomes.

Data collection and analysis of health metrics, combined with harnessing targeted information published in evidence based publications relevant to the case in hand, can provide a tailored

interventions which might improve health.

How much more tailored would the advice be if

we add data on cognitive performance over the working shift pattern, heart rate monitoring and sleep patterns? This would allow us to provide bespoke advice to the employee on measures to optimise their health whilst working shifts.

How does data support proactive risk management?

approach to the advice and

As occupational health practitioners, we want

recommendations we provide as

to be able to identify potential hazards and

clinicians.

advise organisations on potential mitigation of

Why is data quality so important to occupational health?

Primarily because the better the quality of the data available to practitioners, the more confident we can be in the advice we provide to inform decision making within our day to day work. Good quality

occupational risks before they escalate into significant health issues. In the example above, an analysis of trends on cognitive performance and sleep would help identify for the employer if there are elements of the shift pattern which may present potential health and safety risk in order that they can manage this more effectively or, provide reassurance that no change to shift design is required from a health perspective. ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

51

How can real-time data and monitoring identify any warning signs?

Much of the data used by occupational health practitioners has been a measurement of a particular point in time. Assessments and medicals were done periodically which, while helpful, also carried the risk that any subsequent changes wouldn’t be detected until the next assessment. With real-time data

and analytics currently being developed in the health and safety field to support employers meeting their health and safety responsibilities to reduce risk, we now have an incredible opportunity to apply this also to workplace health. The

Data can only bring benefits if both occupational health practitioners and employers are able to access what they need

use of wearable devices, sensors and monitoring equipment can all

What is needed to support clinicians harness data to their advantage?

In most occupational health practice, we often have data in multiple places, in different formats (electronic and paper) and with key data points in scanned or pdf files which make any aggregated

analysis challenging. The development of technology, particularly in Artificial Intelligence holds great potential in data-driven delivery of healthcare, but the current software platforms available to the occupational health sector do not have this capability.

Our new Information System for Health

health as well as manage risk better.

and Work, ISHAW, and its occupational

By integrating health data with data on

workplace injuries, illnesses, and nearmiss incidents, organisations can identify high-risk areas or job roles that present potential risk to health and implement targeted interventions to where they are most needed.

As with all new advances in the technological world, real-time

monitoring does present potential risk in how data is used. There is nervousness as a result which needs to be addressed. In particular addressing ethical and governance issues transparently and putting in place measures to ensure that data is used appropriately in accordance with data protection law will be key to successful

OH TODAY

wellbeing world.

contribute to providing data to optimise

What are the potential risks?

52

transformation in the health, safety and

Summer 2023

health application, MediWork will be a game changer. The unique combination of human clinical expertise and leadingedge technology will radically transform occupational health delivery with the aim of doing so much more with less investment. The first phased of development is complete for launch on 01 September 2023 including modules for post-offer screening including healthcare worker/student screening, health surveillance, and case management. An exciting road map of

development of tools is planned over the next decade with the aim of optimising health and wellbeing at work.

Conclusion Transformational change of occupational health, safety and wellbeing services are at a place is incredibly exciting, with the potential for significant benefit to both employees and organisations. By having robust, ethical and reliable systems to support data driven decisions, organisations can be supported in identifying and mitigating risks. However, data can only bring benefits if both occupational health practitioners and employers are able to access what they need. Data systems designed to empower rather than hinder are an absolute requirement to support this transformation and play its part in creating healthier employees and more productive organisations as a result.

About ISHAW and MediWork MediWork is a secure, cloud-based comprehensive occupational healthcare management application for delivery of occupational health services. It is part of the ISHAW suite of tools that aim to transform work health for the

future. It is designed for efficiency whilst capturing key data. The aim is to build a robust database of information to provide trend analysis and data analytics with a key focus on outcome data which will help inform occupational health practice. The system will empower clinicians with data to support their service delivery whilst minimising the administrative burden of day to day clinical practice.

Find out more about ISHAW and MediWork If you would like further information, please contact us at MWenquiry@cordellhealth.co.uk.

Nikki Cordell | Linkedin Dr Nikki Cordell is co-founder and CEO of Cordell Health. An experienced specialist occupational physician, she passionately believes in improving the health of workers, pursuing excellence and bringing innovation to the way that health and wellbeing is delivered in the workplace.

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

53

The skill of a Work Coach within an EAP service Michael Whitlow, Case Manager, PAM Wellbeing.

D

emonstrating the case for the

are customer-focused, dedicated

skill of work coaching in

individuals, able to deliver exceptional

supporting those back to work

service with empathy and compassion to

and in work. A personal reflection.

Dr Shriti Pattani, past SOM president, promoted employment support for the

a lot of what I did was to help those in need with their confidence towards work and their ability within

over 50s who may have chronic health

tailored coaching to help people’s ability to find, stay in, and progress in a job.

This is an insight from a Work Coach

primary care services to capture this

perspective:

group and piloted a scheme of Work

Having worked as a Work Coach and

Coaches within GP practices (SOM Jan 23). The Government, recently published a consultation – Occupational Health Working Better (Chapter 3:66 August 23), where they say they will consider the “emergence of innovative new health” including the “SOM-led initiative which also involves a pilot ‘join up’ between OH, primary care, and DWP Work Coaches to reduce worklessness

OH TODAY

Coaches use sound judgement and

conditions. She and SOM advocate

approaches to low-intensity work and

54

people who need their support”. Work

experienced many situations, I discovered a lot of what I did was to help those in need with their confidence in

work and their ability within it. It always seemed to come down to a few things: what they have to offer, their skills and recognizing competency.

Competency questions are always the biggest obstacle, no one enjoys answering competency questions:

due to ill-health”

“Give me an example of when….”

According to the DWP, “Work Coaches

This is difficult for most as it asks them

Summer 2023

to think of a time when they have

I discovered very quickly that mental

succeeded or made a mistake. Two

and physical health impacts an

things rise from this:

individual significantly harder than we

Difficult to think of success, as at the end of the day it is their job! People can’t perceive something as successful if it’s just a part of their day-to-day tasks.

think. As someone who experienced mental health problems that impacted work, I am not only passionate but knowledgeable about this.

Getting them to understand this can be

Moving from Work Coach to Case

enlightening for them.

Manager within Occupational Health

No one wants to acknowledge that they

Psychological Services

have made a mistake as they feel it will

A Case Manager role within EAP

go against them. However, I discovered

(Employee Assistance Program)

that encouraging them to rephrase it in

provides short-term interventions for

their own mind and instead of

employees (DeGenarro 2008).

“mistake”, look at it as a lesson, rephrase the question from “when have you made a mistake” to “tell me a time when you have learned from a negative experience”. I found that people can engage far more when rephrasing a mistake.

Transferable skills, moving from a Work Coach to a Case Manager within EAP (Employee Assistance Program) were a lot more obvious than I had anticipated.

Working with the public, helping them to realise their potential and supporting them back into work, gave me the skills

Key skills are also a huge part of

and understanding to support those

someone’s confidence. I found that most

already in work but struggling. I have

people don’t know what skills they have.

found that people need someone to

They know what their job role was and

speak to when they’re feeling low or

what their day-to-day was, but they’re

unmotivated. An ear can be enough in

unsure how to bullet points this. Asking

some circumstances.

them to describe an average day would usually give me an idea as to what key skills they have.

I quickly discovered that the positions are very similar in the respect that anyone I speak to is going to need me to

Transferable skills: Like key skills, it’s

be patient and able to listen. Most

useful to know what these are, but

people are unsure what to do, they’re

people find it difficult to put into words

confused, upset, and can sometimes be

what skills they have to offer.

annoyed. So, it’s very important to

Confidence: As I stated at the beginning, confidence is such a huge part of why people find it difficult to get back into work or into a different career because they’re unsure as to what they can bring to the table. Going over my previous two points can help them to realise their potential, thus increasing their confidence.

recognise the intentions of the individual, i.e., what exactly is motivating them to get in touch. Having gone through it myself in the past, I find that I’m able to empathise and put myself in their position. Although listening tends to be one of the best things you can do for someone, being able to effectively understand what it is they’re going through can help just as

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

55

much if not more so. It is my job to accommodate

Wanting to help people is a huge part of either role.

everything being said, let them know they’re being

Knowing that you’re making even the slightest

listened to and give tailored advice specific to that

difference makes either role easier. Admittedly, it

individual.

can be emotionally demanding but wanting to help

The first thing I tend to do is note that they have acknowledged that there is something wrong. That this is courageous. Some people can’t see past their pride so keep struggling each day. It is important to respect that it’s difficult to even ask for help.

The second thing is to make notes and be able to repeat back any important thing they have shared.

There is nothing worse than trying to explain

something and having to repeat it, especially when you’re not in the best mental state.

The third thing is patience, some people may talk slowly or take a little bit of time to say what they mean, so just allowing them to get to that point organically can help them to open up.

can make any day better with the knowledge that someone will benefit. Applying a different perspective can make all the difference, especially when it comes to mental health. Not only can it help the caller, but it can also help you to apply a more positive phrase to things that may appear tedious and unhelpful.

To conclude, most of the skills I learnt while

working as a Work Coach, I have easily applied to the case manager role. The day-to-day within both positions is very similar in the respect that every call and every email is from someone looking for support at work. We all understand the importance of needing to work so anyone willing to reach out to overcome their battles is already making huge steps.

I have always tried not to act like I know what

Although each call is different they all share the

they’re going through, it can be frustrating for some

same goal. Thanks to my experience as a work

people if someone keeps saying they understand or

coach, I have started to understand what it takes to

they get it because usually, you feel like you’re the

actually support somebody who, without us there to

only person going through it so no one can

help, would otherwise get worse in the long term.

understand, which is why it’s best to listen. This

There are many uncertainties so being consistent for

aside, sometimes solidarity can be a very useful tool

those reaching out is very positive.

in certain cases but again, it comes down to the individual and it’s up to the skill of the Case Manager to determine this and then tailor the experience to them.

Michael is a Case Manager for PAM Wellbeing part of PAM Group. Originally studying to be an English teacher, then working in customer services, he went on to become a Work Coach and Training Facilitator before moving into case management. PAM Wellbeing case managers ensure that all counselling cases are matched to the most appropriate counsellor for the individual's needs and monitor the ongoing activity of the case.

He is a keen musician and has been a guitar teacher as well as a mental health advocate. He has always been fairly goaldriven & ambitious and always looking for his next challenge.

56

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

A Mental health case study; an employee’s perspective with a positive outcome.

By Libby Morley-Hassanali

I

managed this case between

rarely shower.

September and December 2021,

Concentration/focus: Watching TV for

during the Covid 19 Pandemic. I

spoke with Debbie on three occasions, supporting her and guiding her employer. What started as upset and tears ended up with laughter and tears… for both of us! Below is an extract from

my book “Mental Health in the Workplace: A Practical Guide for Occupational health Practitioners on

long is not possible. When scrolling Facebook, she is not taking anything in.

Nods off to sleep watching YouTube videos.

Motivation for hobbies/interests:

Usually likes to read about quite distressing things but now she is unable as it is upsetting her. Photography, but

Consultations and Report Writing.”

feels less interested lately. Says she has

Debbie is a 55-year-old female, working

no motivation.

fulltime as a community nurse. She has been working throughout the Covid pandemic and has been off work for four weeks but feeling mentally unwell for nine months. Her GP has diagnosed

the thought to do things but then feels Sleep: Wears a tracker and it shows sleep is poor. Bad dreams about work.

Says she feels tired and is going to bed early but wakes a lot during the night. Is

PTSD. She was also diagnosed with

not sleeping during the day.

ADHD at the age of 40.

Suicide risk: Says no thoughts of self-

Symptoms/Impact of condition:

harm or suicide currently but did

Self-care: Showering less often and

another 20 years of this sh*t”. No

attempt when younger. Says, “occasionally I think oh god I could have

wearing pyjamas all day. Having

current risk apparent.

encouragement to self-care from her

As well as providing her lived experience

husband and friend gives her a nudge to

of PTSD or burnout symptoms, her

do so, but if she lived alone, she feels

words also provide valuable insight into

she would stay in pyjamas all day and

her experience of living with ADHD. ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

57

She is now back at work. Her

OK I was tired, emotionally distant, and

contribution to my book is further

constantly angry. I am sure anyone close

evidence that people can and do recover

to me was worried about my constant

from an episode of mental illness. You

obsession with the covid stats and my

might need a tissue!

inability to focus on anything positive. I

In Debbie’s’ words: When I first spoke with Libby, I was dreading the call. As someone who has come up against many well-meaning health care professionals in the past, I was dreading another list of things I was supposed to do.

I have ADHD and it means I am a super over achiever that cannot keep simple things together. I can take care of the seriously ill and manage their care but

I remember you said, “Debbie, you are very sick.”

I felt like a weight was lifted at that moment.

seem unable to focus on my own needs or those of my family. I often tie my self -esteem to my job and so when I started to struggle with my work, I became fearful and nervous.

The pandemic started slowly changing

how I felt about people. I have always thought that I was an endless supplier of tea and sympathy, always trying to fix people. I went further than others because I thought it was my responsibility to care for them when they had lost their way physically. I rarely held people responsible for their behaviours or actions and often felt that, given the right kind of care, I could make a difference. I arrive early and stay late out of my desire to always give 100% I caught covid, and later I was diagnosed with long covid. During the time of investigations, I was working full time and studying for my master’s degree. My husband also contracted covid and suffered ill health for the next 18 months.

By the time I had to admit that I was not

58

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

wanted to shout at patients who continued to come with their seemingly ridiculous issues. I had constantly tried to understand that they were going through this too, but eventually I just wanted to tell them that they had no idea what we were going through.

Just before I went off work there were some incidents that left me traumatised.

Patients were becoming aggressive, there were patients self-harming in the department and staff were all feeling the same burnout. I had reacted out of character to a patient, and this had left me feeling ashamed to the point where I have put my head in my hands just thinking about it.

I went to my GP and sobbed to her about

how I was feeling. I was not sleeping, was scared of everything, I jumped at loud voices or noises, and most upsettingly I had lost my empathy for others and spent my time either at work or at home thinking about work. Mostly instead of the accepting and helpful person I sought to be I was angry...really angry. I was scared by the depth of my feelings and totally overwhelmed.

So, as I sat in my car, parked near my

church so that my husband didn’t hear the depths to which I had sunk, I got my first call with you. I remember little of what was said, I know I sobbed through most of it...I felt beyond sad, I felt broken.

I remember you said, “Debbie, you are very sick.” I felt like a weight was lifted at that moment. Finally, someone who wasn’t trying to negate my feelings or

give me some well-meaning advice. We

my past was part of my journey but not

did talk about some things that would

part of this journey. I have always felt

hopefully help such as podcasts and

that GPs looked at me as my issues and

mindfulness, and these were things I felt

not as a person. I found myself worrying

I could achieve. We finished with you

that they would judge me by my past

telling me to rest and take care of myself

diagnoses. I now also understand that

and not to worry about letting co-

not advocating for myself gives them

workers down as I needed to be well to

little else to base their judgement on.

be able to help others. I remember thinking that for once I had not been blamed for feeling the way I did, I felt that someone had given me permission to feel it without having to justify my feelings. I felt legitimised.

Libby helped me to allow myself to be kind to myself, and to stop blaming myself for not being more resilient.

Instead, I looked for ways to build

resilience again. To allow me the time to think without worrying. I truly believe

My discussions with Libby were always

that without Libby to support and guide

about how I was feeling rather than

me that I would have floundered further

what I was doing. In reality, of course

into a life disability.

there were always discussions about what I was doing but they never felt like that was the only point of the talk. Libby encouraged me to think about what I could do for me, rather than what I had to do for me. That might not seem like much of a difference, but it really was.

Having someone who knew how to push me and when to push me while being there if I failed was amazing. I have rebuilt my structure and reconnected with myself. I am sleeping well, eating better, I do Pilates, which is fantastic, I

listen more and worry less. I have

Obviously, the older we get, the more

stopped stressing about the small stuff,

emotional baggage we have. As a woman

and I find myself stopping to question

with ADHD, I had challenges that

my assumptions or actions and changing

impacted my life. I was diagnosed late in

course appropriately. Self-education and

life, and it made a huge difference in my

opening to new things are powerful

ability to understand some of my issues.

when we are encouraged and supported.

I never leaned on my diagnosis. I hadn’t really given myself permission to be different and not feel like others would find me odd. Wearing a mask of normalcy can be exhausting day after day. I had suffered abuse as a child and had an eating disorder for many years.

This had all been dealt with by me having a better understanding of why I had been vulnerable to such things. Low self-esteem and feeling like an imposter are two of the many challenges that have been there throughout my life.

Libby believed me when I told her that

If you asked me how Libby did this, I would say by being supportive, constructive, and honest. Of course, I know she used all her professionalism

and training to do what she does very well, but the best bit is that I never felt managed. I felt treated.

I have learnt to say no, I have learnt that I do not have to be extra just because I’m not neurotypical...that has been fantastic for me. I am embracing my differences and learning to use my newfound strengths.

ioh.org.uk

OH TODAY

59

Libby has become part of my journey, one which I will always remember with a grateful heart. I am not religious, but I do believe as I sat there next to the church, baring my soul, I found the best person to help me, and I cannot thank her enough.

Libby is an Independent Occupational Health Nurse Practitioner and trainer in Stress & Mental Health. She is the Author of the book “Mental Health in the Workplace: A Practical Guide for Occupational Health Practitioners on Consultation and Report Writing”, published in March 2022.

60

OH TODAY

Summer 2023

Ioh.org.uk OH TODAY 62