Aafia Alladin - Student Research and Creativity Forum

Page 1

Exploring the Effects of Acts of Kindness

University

Introduction

● ¹Neurodiversityinvolvesthebeliefthatone’sdifficultytofollowthesocialnorms orcontributetowards societyisduetoprocessinginformationdifferentlyrather thansymptomatology

● ²ThisstudyaimstostudythemajorroleofPositivePsychology,whichisto promotewell-beingthroughprosocialbehaviorsandlifestylechoices.Positive Psychologyexploreshowindividualsthriveandflourishbyutilizingresourcesor strateogiesinsteadoftreatingpathology

● ³Actsofkindnessareconsideredtobeprosocialbehaviororactionsthatcanuplift others.Prosocialbehaviorengagementwaspositivelyassociatedwithsubjective well-being

● Gratitudeinvolvesonedisplayingapositiveemotionalreactionwhenrecieving benefitsandponderingovertheirfavors.

● 4Selfesteemisone’svaluationoftheselfthatcomesfromtheperceptionofbeing goodorvaluabletoothers

● 5Positivethinkingderivesfromrememberingpositiveeventsorexperiencesand suppressingnegativethoughts

● 6Onewhofrequentlyexperiencespositiveemotionsismorelikelytodevelop variousresiliencefactorssuchasenvironmentalmasteryorsocialsupport

● 7Executivefunctioningdescribescomplexcognitiveabilitiesthatcanenhanceone’s performanceofgoal-orientedbehavior

Method

● Therewereatotalof34participants(12neurodiverse,22non-neurodiverse)

● Onepredictorvariableisthetypeofgroup,specificallytheneurodivergentgroupandthe non-neurodiversegroup.

● Thesecondpredictorvariableisthetypeofactivitywhetheraparticipantwatches/listenstoa portionofaPositivePsychologyorienteddocumentarycalled“Happy”byRokoBelicor wrote aletterforfamiliesattheRonaldMcDonaldHouse

● Thedependentvariableistheoutcomemeasuresassessinggratitude,positivethinking, positivemindset,executivecontrolfunctioning,andselfesteemlevelsbasedonthescales.

● Thedurationoftheactivityshouldtakeapproximately30minutes

Materials

● 8TheGratitude(GQ-6)Scalepredictsgratitudelevelsbasedona6itemLikertscale consistingof7pointsfrom1representingstronglydisagreeto5representingstronglyagree.

● 9ThePositiveThinkingScalefocusesontowhatextentone’sthinkingalignswithpositiveor negativeaspectsbasedonthesituations

● 10ThePositiveMindsetScaleassessespositivemindsetlevelsthrougha6itemBipolar five-pointLikertscalewith1asinthenegativeextremeto5asinthepositiveextremein responsetosixstatementsonfeelingsormindsetatthemomentsuchashappinessor confident

● ¹¹TheExecutiveControlFunctioningScalemeasuresgeneralexecutivefunctioningaspects througha4itemLikertscaleof4pointsrangingfrom1asinnoproblemsexperiencedto4as inagreatmanyproblemsexperiencedwithatotalof6statements

● ¹²TheRosenbergSelf-EsteemScaleincorporatesa10itemLikertscaletomeasurepositive andnegativeself-esteemlevelsfrom4pointsrepresenting0asinstronglydisagree,1asin disagree,2asinagreeand3asinstronglydisagree

Results

FirstANOVAanalysis

● Thisstudyusedanindependent2x2ANOVA

● Therewasnomaineffectingratitudelevelchangewhether participantswroteacard(M=.5294, SD=2.45)or watched/listenedtothedocumentary(M=-.9412, SD=2.33), F(1)=1.684, p=.204).

● Therewasnomaineffectingratitudelevelswhetherthe participantsidentifiedasneurodiverse(M=-.0833, SD=1.51) ornon-neurodiverse(M=-.2727, SD=2.90),(F(1)=.108, p=.744).Therewasnointeractioningratitudelevelsbetween thetypeofactivityandtheneurodiverseidentificationamong participants(error=5.629, F(1)=2.341, p=.136).

Discussion

● Overall,thefindingsindicatethatparticipantswritingafeelbetter cardorwatching/listeningtoaportionofapositivepsychology documentarydidn’treportanysignificantchangesingratitude, positivethinking,positivemindset,executivecontrolfunctioning, andselfesteemlevels.

● Theprimarymainpurposeofthisstudywastoexploretheroleof actsofkindnessamongneurodiverseandnon-neurodiversestudents.

● ²Thesecondarypurposeistoincreaseawarenessonvariousaspects ofPositivePsychologysincethisareaofPsychologyisconsideredto beevolvingandmorewellknowntoresearcherscomparedtobefore

● Onemainstrengthisthatparticipantswererandomlyassignedto eitherwritingacardorwatchingorlisteningtoaportionofa documentaryrelatedtoPositivePsychology.

● Anotherstrengthwasthatsomeparticipantsidentifiedas neurodiverse,whichincreasesinclusionandrepresentationof anotherspecialgroup.

● Onemajorlimitationwasthatparticipantswereselectedbasedon specificpools,whichalignswithconveniencesampling.

● Another limitationisthattherewasasmallnumberofparticipants

● Primarily,itwouldbeinterestingtoheartheperspectivesof individuals,includingthosewhoidentifyasneurodiversewhenit comestolearningabouthowtheyengageintheircommunities.

● Secondly,thisstudywasdirectedtowardscollegestudentsand perhapsitwouldbehelpfulthatwelookintohowotheragegroups performprosocialbehaviorsandvolunteerwithintheircommunities.

FifthANOVAanslysis

● Therewasnomaineffectinselfesteemlevel changewhetherparticipantswroteacard (M=.0000, SD=1.27)orwatched/listenedtothe documentary(M=-.3529, SD=2.12), (F(1)=.986, p=.329).

● Therewasnomaineffectinself-esteemlevels whethertheparticipantsidentifiedasneurodiverse (M=-.3333, SD=1.87)ornon-neurodiverse (M=-.0909, SD=1.67),(F(1)=.039, p=.844).

● Therewasnointeractioninself-esteemlevels betweenthetypeofactivityandtheneurodiverse identificationamongparticipants(error=3.717, F(1)=2.399, p=.132).

References

¹Griffin,E.,&Pollak,D.(2009).Studentexperiencesofneurodiversityinhighereducation:InsightsfromtheBRAINHE Project. Dyslexia: An International Journal of Research and Practice, 15(1),23–41. https://doi-org.ezproxy.hofstra.edu/10.1002/dys.383

²Lim,W.L.,&Tierney,S.(2022).Theeffectivenessofpositivepsychologyinterventionsforpromotingwell-beingofadults experiencingdepressioncomparedtootheractivepsychologicaltreatments:Asystematicreviewandmeta-analysis. Journal of Happiness Studies: An Interdisciplinary Forum on Subjective Well-Being

³Gherghel,C.,Nastas,D.,Hashimoto,T.,&Takai,J.(2021).Therelationshipbetweenfrequencyofperformingactsof kindnessandsubjectivewell-being:Amediationmodelinthreecultures. Current Psychology: A Journal for Diverse Perspectives on Diverse Psychological Issues 40(9),4446–4459.https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-019-00391-x

4Neff,K.D.(2011).Self-compassion,self-esteem,andwell-being. Social and Personality Psychology Compass 5(1),1–12. https://doi-org.ezproxy.hofstra.edu/10.1111/j.1751-9004.2010.00330.x

5Macleod,A.K.,&Moore,R.(2000).Positivethinkingrevisited:Positivecognitions,well-beingandmentalhealth. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy 7(1),1–10. https://doi-org.ezproxy.hofstra.edu/10.1002/(SICI)1099-0879(200002)7:1<1::AID-CPP228>3.0.CO;2-S

5Ruthig,J.C.,Holfeld,B.,&Hanson,B.L.(2012).Theroleofpositivethinkinginsocialperceptionsofcanceroutcomes. Psychology & Health 27(10),1244–1258.https://doi-org.ezproxy.hofstra.edu/10.1080/08870446.2012.666549

6Cabrita,M.,Lamers,S.M.A.,Trompetter,H.R.,Tabak,M.,&Vollenbroek-Hutten,M.M.R.(2017).Exploringthe relationbetweenpositiveemotionsandthefunctionalstatusofolderadultslivingindependently:Asystematicreview. Aging & Mental Health, 21(11),1121–1128.https://doi-org.ezproxy.hofstra.edu/10.1080/13607863.2016.1204982

7Stumper,A.,MacGiollabhui,N.,Abramson,L.Y.,&Alloy,L.B.(2020).Earlypubertaltimingmediatestheassociation betweenlowsocioeconomicstatusandpoorattentionandexecutivefunctioninginadiversecommunitysampleof adolescents. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 49(7),1420–1432. https://doi-org.ezproxy.hofstra.edu/10.1007/s10964-020-01198-x

8McCullough, M. E., Emmons, R. A., & Tsang, J. (2002). The grateful disposition: A conceptual and empirical topography. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 82, 112- 127.

9Diener,E.,Wirtz,D.,Tov,W.,Kim-Prieto,C.,Choi.D.,Oishi,S.,&Biswas-Diener,R.(2009).Newmeasuresof well-being: Flourishingandpositiveandnegativefeelings.SocialIndicatorsResearch,39,247-266. Onlineavailablehere.

10Barry,J.A.,Folkard,A.,&Ayliffe,W.(2014).Validationofabriefquestionnairemeasuringpositivemindsetinpatients withuveitis. Psychology, Community & Health, 3(1) 1-10

¹¹Buchanan,T.,Heffernan,T.M.,Parrott,A.C. et al. Ashortself-reportmeasureofproblemswithexecutivefunction suitableforadministrationviatheInternet. Behavior Research Methods 42,709–714(2010). https://doi.org/10.3758/BRM.42.3.709

¹²Rosenberg,M.(1965).Societyandtheadolescentself-image.Princeton,NJ:PrincetonUniversityPress.

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.