Report: The 2023 Climate Ambition Gap

Page 1


1.0 THE 2035 CLIMATE AMBITION GAP

AN EMISSIONS AND ENERGY ANALYSIS OF G20 NDCS

Ten years after the Paris Agreement, taking stock of 2035 climate action plans on the road to achieving the 1.5°C limit.

SUMMARY

Countrieshavemadecollectivecommitmentstolimittheglobaltemperature riseto1.5°C,toreduceemissionsby60%by2035,totriplerenewableenergy anddoubleenergyefficiencyby2030,andtotransitionawayfromfossilfuels. Butcurrenttargets,policies,measures,andfinancialsupportarenot matchingupandwearefacingasubstantialambitionandimplementation gap Withallcountriesexpectedtobringinnew2035targetsbyCOP30,itwas hopedthatsubstantialprogresswouldbemade.BythemiddleofCOP30 howevermanycountrieshavenot(yet)submittednewtargets,andthosewho didhavepresentedplansthatcollectivelydonotmeetexpectations.In particular,G20countries-andespeciallythedevelopedcountriesamong them-whoareresponsibleforthevastmajorityofglobalgreenhousegas emissionsandthebulkoffossilfuelconsumption,arefailingtopresent adequatetargetsandmeasures.

TheimportanceoftheG20ʼscontributiontoglobalclimateactioncannotbe overstated.Thesemajoremittersaccountforalmost80%ofcurrentemissions andaround85%ofglobalGDP,givingtheirpoliciesoutsizedinfluenceon

globaltrade,investmentandtechnologyflows.Inshort,whatG20countries do-orfailtodo-willdeterminewhetherthe1.5°Ctemperaturelimitremains inreach.

Yettakentogetherasagroup,G20countriesʼsubmittedandannounced2035 targetswouldonlyleadtoareductionof23%to29%oftheiremissions comparedtotheiremissionsin2019.Thisrepresentsaseriousshortfall comparedtotheglobal60%reductionagreedintheGlobalStocktakeonlytwo yearsago.

WithintheG20,developedcountriesbearthegreatestresponsibility,given theirhistoricandcurrentcontributiontoglobalemissionsandtheirfar greatercapacitytoact.Theiremissionreductioncommitmentsshould thereforebewellinexcessof60%,accompaniedbytheprovisionofadequate climatefinancetosupportactionindevelopingcountries.Manyfallfarshort of60% andnonemeettheirfairshareoftheactionrequiredtomeetthis collectivetarget Takentogether,G20developedcountryNDCsamounttoonly a51%to57%reductioninemissionscomparedwith2019levels,representing aglaringfailuretoleadbythecountriesthatshouldbedrivingglobal ambition.

Beyondtheemissionsgap,allG20countryNDCsarefailingtoadequately contributetotheagreedenergytransition.Theylackboththenecessary commitmenttophaseoutfossilfuelsaswellasquantifiedtargetsforprogress relatedtorenewablesandenergyefficiencydevelopments.Overall,G20 countries-hometotheworldʼslargestproducersandconsumersoffossilfuelsofferNDCsthatconspicuouslylackcredible,actionableplanstophaseoutthe veryfuelsdrivingtheclimatecrisis.Developedcountriesinparticularstandout: thoughtheybearthegreatestresponsibilitytoleadandmovefirstandfastest, theirNDCscomenowhereclose.

AtCOP30,countrieswillneedtoadoptaGlobalResponsePlantotacklethe mitigationambitiongapandensuresubstantialandequitableprogressis madeinreducinggreenhousegasemissionsandphasingoutfossilfuels. Progressonclimatefinance,especiallytheprovisionofsignificantlyscaledup publicfinancebydevelopedcountries,willalsobecriticaltounlockgreater ambitionfromdevelopingcountriesthatneedsupport.

The challenge to prevent dangerous climate change

2024wasthewarmestyearsinceobservationsstarted175yearsago,withaverage temperaturesgoingbeyond15°C(comparedtothe1850-1900average)forthefirst time.1 Averagewarmingovera20-yearperiodreached1.25°C,whichsubstantially increasedextremeweatherevents,includingdestructivecyclones,floods,

1 Pleasenotethatthisreferstoanannualaverageabove15°Cwhichisdifferentfromthetargetunderthe ParisAgreementwhichreferstoa20yearaveragetemperaturerise

droughts,forestfiresandextremeheat,withdevastatingimpactonhumanlife.2 Andtheseimpactswillonlygrowasweareontracktofurthersubstantial increases,3 witheconomistswarningthattheglobaleconomycouldfacea50% lossinGDPafter2070,unlessimmediatepolicyactiononrisksposedbythe climatecrisisistaken.4

Temperatureswillcontinuerisingunlesswedrasticallyreduceemissions Emissionshaveincreasedby1.4%peryearbetween1990and2015,theyearofthe adoptionoftheParisAgreement,andby1.6%peryeareversince.5 Emissionsare highlyconcentratedinalimitednumberofcountries.The43membercountries oftheG20,includingtheEU27butexcludingtheAfricanUnion,madeupfor77% ofemissionsin2023 Whenaddingthe55membersoftheAfricanUnion,the sharewouldincreasebyonly5%,highlightingthelargediscrepancyinthe contributionofdifferentcountries(andcontinents).Thesedisparitiesincrease furtherwhentakingintoaccountthehistoricalresponsibilityofmostlydeveloped countriesforgreenhousegasconcentrationsintheatmosphere.

Ifwearetosubstantiallyreduceglobalgreenhousegasemissionstonearzero, thentheuseoffossilfuelswillneedtobecompletelyphasedout.Currentlyfossil fueluseisresponsibleforaround70%ofgreenhousegasemissions,and emissionsfromfossilfuelusehaveincreasedbymorethan60%since1990 6 Inits recentAdvisoryOpinionontheobligationsofstateswithrespecttoclimate change,7 theInternationalCourtofJustice(ICJ)underlinedtheimportanceof phasingoutfossilfueluseinordertoachievethegoalsoftheParisAgreement stating“thatastateʼsfossilfuelproduction,fossilfuelconsumption,grantingof fossilfuelexplorationlicenses,andtheprovisionoffossilfuelsubsidiesmay constituteaninternationallywrongfulactwhichisattributabletothatstate” (paragraph427).

International commitments to act

Alreadyin1992,whenadoptingtheUNFrameworkConventiononClimate Change,countriescommitted“toachievestabilizationofgreenhousegas concentrationsintheatmosphereatalevelthatwouldpreventdangerous

2 WMO(2025),“StateoftheGlobalClimate2024”.March2025: https://librarywmoint/viewer/69455/download?file=WMO-1368-2024 enpdf&type=pdf&navigator=1

3 IPCC,“ClimateChange2022:Impacts,AdaptationandVulnerability”. February2022: https://wwwipccch/report/sixth-assessment-report-working-group-ii

4Trust,Setal (2025),“PlanetarySolvency–findingourbalancewithnatureGlobalriskmanagementfor humanprosperity”,InstituteandFacultyofActuariesandUniversityofExeter January2025: https://actuariesorguk/document-library/thought-leadership/thought-leadership-campaigns/climate-paper s/planetary-solvency-finding-our-balance-with-nature

5EDGAR,“GHGEmissionsofallworldcountries” 2024:https://edgarjrceceuropaeu/report 2024

6UnitedNations,“Causesandeffectsofclimatechange”. https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/science/causes-effects-climate-change

7 InternationalCourtofJustice(ICJ)(2025),“ObligationsofStatesinrespectofClimateChange”,Advisory Opinion July2025:https://wwwicj-cijorg/sites/default/files/case-related/187/187-20250723-adv-01-00-enpdf

anthropogenicinterferencewiththeclimatesystem”.8 Inthe2015Paris Agreement,countriesfurthercommittedto“holdingtheincreaseintheglobal averagetemperaturetowellbelow2°Cabovepre-industriallevelsandpursuing effortstolimitthetemperatureincreaseto1.5°Cabovepre-industriallevels, recognizingthatthiswouldsignificantlyreducetherisksandimpactsofclimate change”.9 Subsequentagreementsconfirmedcountries'commitmenttolimit temperatureriseto1.5°Cbytheendofthecentury.10

TheParisAgreementobligescountriestosubmit,atleasteveryfiveyears, NationallyDeterminedContributions(NDCs)indicatingspecificnational objectivesforthenext10years.Throughthefirstandsecondround11 ofNDCs,195 countriessetspecificobjectivesfor2030 12 ThethirdroundofNDCswhichhaveto besubmittedthisyear13 shouldincludeobjectivesfor2035.

Asof15November2025,114countries,covering74%ofglobalemissionshave submittedan(economy-wideorsectoral)2035target 14 Someofthelargest emittingcountriesarestilltosubmittheirNDC.Asofnow,twelveG20member stateshavesubmittedanNDC.ThisincludestheUS,whoseNDCisnolonger supportedbythecurrentadministration,andisnotonlywithdrawingfromthe ParisAgreement,butalsorollingbackpoliciesandmeasuresthatwould implementtheNDC Asaresult,itisestimatedthattheUSwouldonlyachieve halforevenlessoftheemissionreductionsincludedinits2035NDC 15

TheParisAgreementalsoputsinplacea5-yearGlobalStocktakeprocesstotake stockoftheprogressofcountriesinreachingthecollectiveobjectivetolimitthe globalaveragetemperatureriseto1.5°C.Thisprocessshouldinformthe

8UnitedNations(1992),“UnitedNationsFrameworkConventiononClimateChange” May1992: https://unfccc.int/files/essential background/background publications htmlpdf/application/pdf/conveng.p df

9UnitedNations(2015),“ParisAgreement”.December2015: https://unfcccint/sites/default/files/english paris agreementpdf

10Suchasinparagraph21oftheGlasgowClimatePactofNovember2021: https://unfcccint/sites/default/files/resource/cma3 auv 2 cover%20decisionpdf

11ThefirstroundofNDCsweresubmittedpriortothe2015COP21inParis MostoftheseNDCstargeted 2030,thoughafewalsotargeted2025emissions Asecondroundmostlyconsistedofanupdateofthefirst NDCsintheperiod2021-2023,withpledgesfocusingon2030.

12TheUNreceived168NDCs,representing195countries Nolessthan180countriesprovidedmultiple (updated/improved)versionsoftheirfirstNDC.Source: https://unfcccint/process-and-meetings/the-paris-agreement/nationally-determined-contributions-ndcs/20 24-ndc-synthesis-report

13InfacttheParisAgreementcallsforthesesubmissionstohappenatthe latest9monthsbeforeCOP30, meaningthe'official'deadlinewasFebruary10 As90%ofcountriesfailedtosubmittheirNDCintime,a seconddeadlinewassetforendSeptembertoallowtheUNFCCCsecretariattoincludetheseNDCsintheir annualSynthesisReport Only64countriessubmittedanNDCintimefortheSynthesisReport

14 123countries(includingallEU27MemberStates)havesubmittedaneworrevisedNDCsince1stof November2024.Ofthese,100countriessubmittedanNDCwithaneconomy-wide2035target.14countries submittedanNDCcontainingasectoraltarget,while9countries(re-)submitteda2030target.Afull overviewcanbefoundontheUNFCCCNDCSubmissionpage:https://unfccc.int/NDCREG

15 TheRhodiumGroupestimatestheUSisontracktoreduceemissionsby26%to35%by2035,ascompared totheNDCwhichaimsatreducingemissionsby61%to66% B King(2025),“TakingStock2025:USEnergy andEmissionsOutlook“https://rhgcom/research/taking-stock-2025

developmentofNDCs.TheoutcomeofthefirstGlobalStocktake,whichendedin November2023,wasclear:moreactionisneededifwearetopreventdangerous climatechange UndertheGlobalStocktake,countriesendorsed:

● deep,rapidandsustainedreductionsinglobalgreenhousegasemissions of43percentby2030and60percentby2035relativetothe2019leveland reachingnetzerocarbondioxideemissionsby2050(para27);

● triplingrenewableenergycapacityby2030(para28a);

● doublingtheannualrateofenergyefficiencyimprovementsby2030(para 28a);

● transitioningawayfromfossilfuelsinenergysystems,inajust,orderly andequitablemanner,acceleratingactioninthiscriticaldecade(para 28d);

TheoutcomeoftheGlobalStocktake16 isamajorachievementasitclearlyputs theenergytransitionfrontandcentreofthedebateandcontainsspecific commitmentsrelatedtothepromotionofrenewablesandenergyefficiencyand thephaseoutoffossilfueluse.

16 UnitedNations(2023) Outcomesofthefirstglobalstocktake:https://unfcccint/documents/637073

COP21: Arc de Triomphe Sun Action in Paris. © Greenpeace

Failure to achieve the 1.5°C objective of the Paris Agreement

Havingcountriescommittothe15°CtemperaturetargetintheParisAgreement wasamajorachievement,butonethatneedstobefollowedbyambitious nationaltargetsaswellaspoliciesandmeasurestoensurethetargetsaremet. Severalreportsassessingcountries'currenttargets,policiesandmeasuresclearly indicatethattheworldfacesasubstantialgapbetweenwhatisneededtolimit temperatureriseto1.5°Candwhatisactuallybeingdone.

Current (2030) NDCs and policies

BothlastyearʼsUNEP2024EmissionsGapReport17 andtheUNFCCC's2024NDC SynthesisReport18 wereclear:afailuretoincreaseambitionin2030NDCs combinedwiththeirweakimplementationputstheworldontrackfora temperatureincreaseof26°Cto31°Coverthecourseofthiscentury Current NDCswouldleadtoemissionsof51.5GtCO2-ein2030,alevelonly2.6%lower thanin2019.Thisisfarfromthe43%cutby2030agreedintheGlobalStocktake. A2.6°Cincreaseinglobaltemperaturewouldleadtoasignificantescalationof climatechangeimpactscomparedto1.5°C,includingmorefrequentandintense heatwaves,droughts,andfloods,widespreadoceanimpactslikethelossof tropicalcoralreefs,andsevereconsequencesforwater,agriculture,andhuman health.Thislevelofwarming,whichcurrentclimatepledgesputusontrackto reach,wouldbemarkedbydangerous,compoundingrisks,andthelikelihoodof crossingmultipletippingpointsintheclimatesystem,triggeringsevere,abrupt andirreversiblechanges.19

New (2035) NDCs and the central role of the G20

TheimportanceoftheG20ʼscontributiontotheachievementofa60%greenhouse gasemissionreductionby2035cannotbeoverstated.Thesemajoremitters accountfor almost80%ofcurrentemissionsandaround85%ofglobalGDP, givingtheirpoliciesoutsizedinfluenceonglobaltrade,investmentand technologyflows Inshort,whatG20countriesdo-orfailtodo-willdetermine whetherthe1.5°Ctemperaturelimitremainsinreach.

OftheG20memberstates,Australia,Brazil,Canada,China,theEU,Indonesia, Japan,Russia,SouthAfrica,Turkiye,theUKandtheUShavesubmitteda2035 target.Twomorecountries(MexicoandSouthKorea)publiclyannouncedtheir 2035targetsbutdidnotofficiallysubmitthisyettotheUN.ThreeG20countries

17UNEnvironmentProgramme(2024),“Nomorehotair please!Withamassivegapbetweenrhetoricand reality,countriesdraftnewclimatecommitments” October2024: https://www.unep.org/resources/emissions-gap-report-2024

18UNFCCC(2024),“NationallydeterminedcontributionsundertheParisAgreement Synthesisreportby thesecretariat“.October2024:https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/resource/cma2024 10 adv.pdf

19ArmstrongMcKayetal (2022)“Exceeding15°Cglobalwarmingcouldtriggermultipleclimatetipping points” Science,9September2022: https://wwwscienceorg/doi/101126/scienceabn7950

(Argentina,IndiaandSaudiArabia)havenot(yet)submitted(norannounced) theirNDC.

AsTable1shows,basedonthesubmittedandannounced2035targets,G20 countrieswouldreducetheiremissionsby-23%to-29%by2035comparedto2019 -farshortofthetrajectoryrequiredtolimitwarmingto1.5°C.20

Table1:2035targetsforallG20memberscomparedwith2019emissions21

2-e(net) -29%-42%

SouthAfrica 320-380MtCO2-e(net) -21%-33% SouthKorea -53%-61%/2018(net) -50%-59%

Turkiye 643MtCO2-e(net) +42% UK -81%/1990(net) -66%

Combinedtotalfor G20countrieswith a2035target -23%-29%

1:CanadaistheonlyG20countrythathassubmittedagrossemissionstarget,whichonlydealswith emissionsandnotwithland-based(LULUCF)norindustrialremovals;2:tocalculateChinaʼstargetwe assumedemissionswouldpeakin2024andbasedpeakemissionsonanincreaseof670Mt(asreportedin theEDGARdatabase)abovethe2021emissionslevelsreportedinChinaʼsBiennialTransparencyReport (BTR);3:basedontheexistingNDCfromtheBidenadministration.

20 AllnumbersbasedondatacontainedincountriesʼNDC,furtheraddedbydatafromcountriesʼrespective InventoryReportstotheUNFCCCandwhereneededadditionaldatawereusedfromfromtheClimate Watchdatabase:www.climatewatchdata.org/ghg-emissions

21 Alltargetnumbersinthetablearebasedonofficialsubmissions Notallcountriesusethesame methodologytoaccountfortheiremissionsandactualemissionsmaydiffersubstantiallyfromthose reportedbygovernments

Notethatdevelopedcountries,owingtotheirhigherhistoricalemissionsandgreatereconomiccapacity, shouldaimforsignificantlydeeperemissionsreductionsthantherequiredglobalaverage

The G20 and beyond: Assessing global ambition of 2035 NDCs Asof15November2025,100countriessubmittedaneconomy-wide2035target. Furthermore,14countriessubmittedanNDCwithsectoraltargetsfor2035.A preliminaryassessmentofallcurrent2035economy-widetargets22 showsthatthe worldisfarofftrackfromreachingthe60%reductionby2035(comparedto2019) thatwasagreedintheGlobalStocktake.Currentsubmitted(andannounced) NDCs(G20countriesandbeyond)wouldleadtoagreenhousegasreduction between16%and25%23 comparedto2019emissions24 .

22 NotethatthisassessmentdoesnotincludeNDCswithsectoraltargets.

23 Thisassessmentincludesbothconditionalandunconditionaltargets Anumberofdevelopingcountries havesubmittedconditionaltargets(nexttounconditionalones)whoseimplementationdependsonthe provisionofadequateclimatefinanceandothersupportfromdevelopedcountries

24 NotethisassessmentincludesNDCssubmittedafterthecutoffdatefortheUNFCCCʼs(updated)Synthesis ReportaswellastheannouncedtargetsofMexicoandSouthKoreawhichwerenotincludedinthe SynthesisReport.Furthermore,theSynthesisReportsfocusesontargetsexcludingLULUCF(landuse,land usechangeandforestry)whileonlysevenofthe102countriesassessedhavetargetsexcludingLULUCF. ThisindicatesthatforalargemajorityofcountriestheSynthesisReportisbasedonassumptionsonthe divisionofcountriesʼeffortsbetweenemissionsandremovalsintheLULUCFsectorandemissionsinthe non-LULUCFsectors Ourreporthasnotengagedincalculatingsuchassumptionsandfocusesoncountriesʼ nettargetsasindicatedintheirNDCs.

Whilealreadyfarfromtheneeded60%reduction,thisnumbermightberather optimisticas(a)possiblythecountriesthathavenotyetsubmitteda2035target willhavebelowaveragetargets;(b)China'stargetiscalculatedbasedonits2024 emissions,assumingthiscouldbetheirpeakyear,whichmaynotbethecaseand inthatcaseChina'semissionsin2035willbehigherthaninthisexercise;and(c) theUSNDCwassubmittedbytheBidenadministrationandactionstakenbythe currentadministrationwillmakeachievingthistargetextremelychallenging.

Akeydriverofthislowambitionisweakcommitmentsfrommostdeveloped countries.AspartoftheequityprinciplesoftheUNFrameworkConventionon ClimateChange,developedcountries25 areexpectedtotaketheleadinreducing emissionsandshouldthusaimatemissionreductiontargetswellbeyondthe averageof-60%.UNSecretary-GeneralAntonioGuterrescalledupondeveloped countriestoreducegreenhousegasemissionstonetzeroby2040,whichwould needdevelopedcountriestoreducetheiremissionsbyatleast75%by2035.26 However, currentpledgesindicatedevelopedcountriesareontrackfor emissionsreductionsofonly-50%to-55%comparedto2019.

Althoughtheoverwhelmingresponsibilityfortheemissionsgaprestswith developedcountries,whosehistoricandcurrentemissionsremainfarabove equitablelevels,strongerambitionfromsomedevelopingcountrieswillalsobe essentialtolimitwarmingto1.5°C.Evenifdevelopedcountriesweretocommitto achievingnetzerogreenhousegasemissionsassoonas2035,toachievethe agreed-60%reduction,developingcountriesasawholewouldstillneedtoreduce their2019emissionsbyatleast35%by2035.Severalmajordeveloping-country emittershavesettargetsthatfallshortoftheirfairshareofwhatisrequired, furtherwideningtheglobalambitiongap.

Itshouldbenotedhoweverthatdevelopingcountriesarenotahomogenous groupintermsoftheiremissionsprofiles,economiccapacities,ordevelopment needs-andthisshapeswhatcanbeexpectedoftheir2035NDCtargets.For developingcountrieswithlowerincomesandsignificantdevelopmentneeds, substantialinternationalsupportwillalsobecriticaltoraisingambition

Aswellasleadingonmitigationefforts,theequityprinciplesoftheUN FrameworkConventionalsorequiredevelopedcountriestoprovidesubstantial climatefinancetosupportactionindevelopingcountriesthatneedit The inadequateNewCollectiveQuantifiedGoal(NCQG)agreedatCOP29lastyear highlightsthatthisisstillfarfrombeingachieved.27 Itisbothunjustand

25Developedcountriesinthisassessmentincludeallso-calledAnnex1countries,exceptforTurkiye,and all(non-annex1)Europeancountries

26 UnitedNations(2023) Secretary-GeneralCallsonStatestoTackleClimateChangeʻTimeBombʼthrough NewSolidarityPact,AccelerationAgenda,atLaunchofIntergovernmentalPanelReport.20March2023: https://press.un.org/en/2023/sgsm21730.doc.htm

27 SeeGreenpeaceInternationalresponsetoCOP29outcome https://wwwgreenpeaceorg/international/press-release/71474/cop29-ends-weak-climate-finance-goal-eyesturn-belem/

unrealistictoexpectdevelopingcountriesthatneedsupporttodramatically increasetheirambitionwithoutit.

Off track from the energy targets of the First Global Stocktake

2030 NDCs (and policies)

Doubling,nottriplingrenewableenergy:

ToimplementtherenewablesgoaloftheGlobalStocktakerenewableenergy capacityinthepowersectorneedstobeincreasedtoatleast11,000GWby2030, whichisatriplingascomparedto2022 28 TheIEA29 assessedcountries'renewables targetsandmeasuresinandoutsideofNDCsanditsanalysisindicatesthat triplingglobalrenewablepowercapacityby2030isanambitiousbutachievable goal.Countriesʼoverallambitionsonrenewablepowercapacitycorrespondto reachingalmost8,000GWgloballyin2030,whichis2.2timesthe2022leveland 30%shortoftriplingby2030 Solarandwindmakeupmostofthecapacity explicitlyidentifiedbygovernments.

28IEA,“NetZeroRoadmap:AGlobalPathwaytoKeepthe15°CGoalinReach 2023Update” September 2023:https://www.iea.org/reports/net-zero-roadmap-a-global-pathway-to-keep-the-15-0c-goal-in-reach

29IEA,“COP28TriplingRenewableCapacityPledge.Trackingcountriesʼambitionsandidentifyingpolicies tobridgethegap” June2024: https://ieablobcorewindowsnet/assets/ecb74736-41aa-4a55-aacc-d76bdfd7c70e/COP28TriplingRenewableC apacityPledgepdf

Wind Park in Feldheim, Germany. © Paul Langrock / Greenpeace

AsimilaranalysisbyEmber30 foundthatnearlytwoyearsaftertheagreementto triplerenewableenergycapacity,mostcountrieshaveyettoreflectthisambition intheirownnationalrenewableenergytargets AsofJuly2025,onlyeight countrieshaveupdatedtheirnationalrenewabletargets,withtheglobalsumof nationaltargetsjust2%higherthanatthetimetheGlobalStocktakeended.

Only1%,not2%energyefficiencyimprovements:

Globalenergyefficiencyprogress–measuredbytherateofchangeinprimary energyintensity–issettoseeonlyaweakimprovementofabout1%in2024.31 Thisisthesamerateasin2023,andaroundhalfoftheaveragerateoverthe 2010-19period.Whiletheenergycrisismarkedapossibleturningpointfor energyefficiencyinsomecountries,globalenergyintensityprogresshasbeen lacklustrein2023and2024.

Noorganisedtransitionawayfromfossilfuels:

Hardlyanycountryhassetatargetfortransitioningawayfromfossilfuelsintheir nationalpolicies,letaloneintheirNDC.Thisissupportedbyananalysis32 of2030 NDCsfromthetop20biggestfossil-fuel-producingcountries,33 whichtogether accountfor93%ofglobalcoalproduction,80%ofoil,and77%ofgas.Athirdof theseNDCsmakenomentionoffossilfuelproduction,whilesixstatedan intentiontocontinueorincreaseproduction.

New(2035)NDCs

Giventheabovefindingsthatcountriesarecurrentlynotontracktoachievethe collectiveenergytargetsofthefirstGlobalStocktake,itisimportanttoassess whetherthe2035NDCsprovideneweffortstobridgethegap.Ascountriesare askedtoexplicitlyindicatehowthefirstGlobalStocktakehasaffectedthe developmentofthenewNDCs,newcommitmentswouldbeexpected.However suchcommitmentsremainlimited,includingfromdevelopedcountrieswho shouldbeleadingtheway.

WhileallG20NDCs,withtheexceptionofJapanandRussia,givespecific attentionandsupporttoatleastoneofthemainthreecommitmentsofthefirst GlobalStocktake:triplingrenewables;doublingefficiency;andtransitioningaway

30Altieri,K.,“Whatʼsnewwithnationalrenewabletargets?Notmuch!”,Ember.July2025: https://ember-energyorg/app/uploads/2025/07/Ember-Whats-new-with-national-renewables-targets -Nothi ng-much-1pdf

31IEA(2024),“EnergyEfficiency2024” November2024:https://wwwieaorg/reports/energy-efficiency-2024

32IISD(2024):HowtheTransitionAwayFromFossilFuelProductionCanBeIncludedinNewClimate CommitmentsandPlans June2024: https://www.iisd.org/system/files/2024-06/fossil-fuel-transition-new-climate-commitments.pdf

33ThisincludesthefollowingG20countries:Australia,Brazil,Canada,China,Germany,India,Indonesia, Poland(aspartoftheEU),Russia,SaudiArabia,SouthAfrica,TürkiyeandtheUnitedStates.Additionally theresearchalsocovers:Algeria,Iran,Iraq,Kuwait,Norway,QatarandUnitedArabEmiratesanddoesnot coverthefollowingG20members:Argentina,mostoftheEU27,UnitedKingdom,Japan,SouthKoreaand Mexico

fromfossilfuels,fewincludespecificqualitativeandquantitativeindicationshow theywillcontributetothecollectivetargetsoftheGST.Withoutquantified economy-widerenewablesandefficiencytargetsandwithoutclearindicationsof pathwaystophaseoutfossilfueluse,itisimpossibletoassessthecontributionof G20countriestotheachievementofthecollectivegoalsoftheGST.

WhilemostG20NDCs(againwiththeexceptionofJapanandRussia)contain clearreferencestopolicies,measuresandsometimestargetstoincreasethe shareofrenewableenergy,theygenerallyprovidelimiteddetailonenergy efficiency(withtheEUasanotableexception).Andoverall,whileG20NDCs acknowledgethecommitmenttotransitionawayfromfossilfuels,theygenerally gonofurtherthansupportingtheglobaltransitionandinafewcasesthe domesticphaseoutofcoal.OnlytheNDCsofBrazilandtheUKcanbeseenas goingabitfurtherthantheothers.

Overall,G20countries-hometotheworldʼslargestproducersandconsumersof fossilfuels-offerNDCsthatconspicuouslylackcredible,actionableplansto phaseouttheveryfuelsdrivingtheclimatecrisis.Developedcountriesin particularstandout:thoughtheybearthegreatestresponsibilitytoleadand movefirstandfastest,theirNDCscomenowhereclose.

Table2providesanoverviewofenergycommitmentsinG20NDCs,andis followedbyacompilationofelementsfromG20NDCsonthethreekeyenergy commitmentsoftheGST.

Global Climate March during COP30 in Belém, Brazil © Filipe Bispo / Greenpeace

Table2:EnergycommitmentsinG20NDCs34

ThetablebelowindicateswhetherG20countriesreferencepolicies,measures,or targetsintheirNDCsthatsupportthecommitmentstotriplerenewables,double efficiency,ortransitionawayfromfossilfuels.ItdoesnotassesswhethertheNDC contentoracountryʼspoliciesaresufficienttoachievetheseobjectives. AsnoG20 countrymentionsatargetfortransitioningawayfromfossilfuels,thesubtarget columnreferstotargetsrelatedtoeithercoalpowerplantsand/orcombustionengine phaseouts. Tripling

Target(s) (oncoal and/or combust ion engines only)

34 ThisassessmentoftheenergycontentofNDCsdoesnotincludeMexiconorSouthKorea Whilethey publiclyannouncedtheir2035climatetargets,withouttheirNDCsubmissionitisimpossibletoassesstheir energycommitments GiventhecurrentUSadministrationistakingoppositemeasurestothose announcedintheNDC,theUSNDCisalsotakenoutofthisexerciseoflookingattheenergyelementsof the2035NDCs

Japan

Mexico

Russia

Saudi

Arabia

South Africa

South Korea

Turkiye

Triplingrenewablecapacity

Australia Wehavepoliciesinplacetosupportafurtherdoublingofourproportionof renewablesby2030,increasingrenewableelectricitygenerationtoatargetof 82%by2030.TheAustralianGovernmenthasintroducedtheRewiringthe Nationprogramtosupportthemodernisationoftheelectricitygrid, alongsidetheCapacityInvestmentScheme,anationalframeworktosupport greaterinvestmentinrenewables,todeliver40GWofrenewableenergy generationcapacityby2030.

Brazil Intheenergysector,wherethecountryalreadystandsoutforthehighshare ofrenewablesourcesinitsenergymatrix-89.2%electricitymixand49.1%in energymix-Brazilwillseektoexpandelectricitygenerationwithan increasedshareoftechnologyandcleansources

Canada Canadahasoneofthecleanestelectricitymixesintheworld–over80%of electricitygeneratedisnon-emitting However,Canadaisdrivingtowardsan evencleanerelectricitygridthroughtheCleanElectricityRegulations.

China Thecombinedinstalledcapacityofwindandsolarpowergenerationwillbe morethansixtimesthatof2020,strivingtoreach36billionkilowatts

EU

TheEUagreedtoatargettoensurethattheshareofenergyfromrenewable sourcesintheUnionʼsgrossfinalconsumptionofenergyin2030isatleast 42.5%,withanadditionalendeavourtoincreasetheshareofenergyfrom renewablesourcesintheUnionʼsgrossfinalconsumptionofenergyin2030to 45%

Indonesia GovernmentRegulationNo 40Year2025onNationalEnergyPolicy,setout theambitiontotransformby2030,2040and2060,theprimaryenergy supplymixwithsharesofnewandrenewableenergyasfollows:(i)19%-23% in2030,(ii)36%-40%in2040,and(iii)70%-72%in2060

South Africa

Ourelectricityplanenvisagesaddingsignificantgreenenergysourcestothe SouthAfricanpowersystem TheIRP2025indicatesthatatotalof44GWof newrenewableenergycapacitywillbeinstalledby2035,thuscontributingto greenindustrializationandhelpingtoachievethemitigationtargetsinthis secondNDC

Turkiye TheLongTermStrategy,whichisalignedwiththeoutcomesofthefirst GlobalStocktake(GST),outlineskeysectoralpoliciesfor2035and2053, includinganincreaseintheuseofrenewableenergysourcesand technologies,thedevelopmentofbatteryandhydrogeninfrastructure,the reductionofenergyintensity

UK TheUKisfullycommittedtotheoutcomesofParagraph28and33oftheGST, includingcontributingtowardtheseglobalgoals,commitmentsandefforts, andthisisreflectedintheactiontakentoachieveourNDC Thegovernment willworkwiththeprivatesectortoradicallyincreasethedeploymentof onshorewind,solarandoffshorewindsothatelectricitygeneratedby renewablesandnuclearpowerwillbethebackboneofacleanelectricity systemby2030.

Australia Whileincreasingrenewableenergysupply,theAustralianGovernmenthas introducedmeasurestoreduceenergydemandthroughtheNationalEnergy PerformanceStrategy,workingwithstateandterritorygovernmentsandlocal councils

Brazil Brazilwillalsoprioritizetheexpansionofenergyefficiencyactions ThePact forEcologicalTransformationincludescommitmentstoimplement managementmeasurestoincreaseenergyefficiency.

Canada TheCanadaGreenBuildingsStrategyincludesseveralaspectsimportantfor improvingenergyefficiency,suchasdeliveringtheCanadaGreenerHomes AffordabilityProgram(CGHAP),modernizingtheEnergyEfficiencyAct;and

developingasuiteofcommonlabellingstandards,tools,andguidelinesto supporthomelabellinginitiativesacrossCanada

China Strictlycontrolfossilfuelconsumption,prioritisingreductionsinnon-power coaluseanddispersed,inefficientcoalcombustion,whileenhancingthe cleanandefficientutilisationoffossilfuels.

EU TheEUagreedtoincreaseambitiononenergysavingsthroughanenhanced targettoreducefinalenergyconsumptionatEUlevelby11.7%in2030 comparedtotheprojectionsofthe2020EUReferenceScenario.

Indonesia GovernmentRegulationNo.33Year2023concerningEnergyConservation, representsaconcretesteptakenbythegovernmenttoregulatetheefficient andrationaluseofenergyresources,energysources,andenergyusage This regulationestablishesvariousprogrammesandmechanismstopromotethe implementationofenergy conservationacrossdifferentsectors(energy provider,industrial,transportation,building,andhousehold)

South Africa SouthAfricacontinuestoenhanceourmitigationefforts,withthe implementationofpolicies,programmesandplanswithsignificant mitigationoutcomes,includingourIntegratedResourcePlanforelectricity, GreenTransportStrategy,draftpost-2015NationalEnergyEfficiencyStrategy.

Turkiye

TheLongTermStrategy,whichisalignedwiththeoutcomesofthefirst GlobalStocktake(GST),outlineskeysectoralpoliciesfor2035and2053, includinganincreaseintheuseofrenewableenergysourcesand technologies,thedevelopmentofbatteryandhydrogeninfrastructure,the reductionofenergyintensity.

UK ThisgovernmenthasalsocommittedtotheWarmHomesPlantoimprove energyefficiencyandtosupporttheconversiontolowcarbon heatingin Britishbuildings

Australia Alongsidetheexitofcoalfromourenergysystem,theAustralianGovernment isacceleratingthedeploymentofrenewableresourcestodelivercleaner, morereliableenergyforAustralia.Australiaisrapidlyshiftingtoamodern, cost-effectiveelectricitysystembasedonrenewableenergy,withcoal-fired power-generationphasingout,andgasplayingafirmingrolealongsidehydro andbatteries.35

Brazil Brazilwouldwelcomethelaunchingofinternationalworkforthedefinition ofschedulesfortransitioningawayfromfossilfuelsinenergysystems,ina just,orderlyandequitablemanner,withdevelopedcountriestakingthelead, onthebasisofthebestavailablescience,reflectingequity Intheenergy

35 NotethatthiscommitmentcoversonlyAustraliaʼsdomesticuseoffossilfuels Thevastmajorityof Australianfossilfuelproductionisforexport

Transitionawayfromfossilfuels

sector TheNationalClimatePlanwillprovidedetailsabouttheexpansionof electricitygenerationand,inthemediumtolongterm,thegradual replacementoftheuseoffossilfuelswithelectrificationsolutionsand advancedbiofuels.

Canada In2016,Canadabecamethefirstcountryintheworldtointroduceregulations oncoal-firedpowerplantsandannouncedaphase-outofcoal-firedelectricity by2030

China China'sNDCadherestotheprinciplesandprovisionsoftheConventionand theParisAgreement,takingfullaccountofthefindingsofthefirstglobal stocktake.

EU TheEUanditsMemberStateshighlighttheimportanceofachievingthe globalphaseoutofunabatedfossilfuelsandapeakanddeclineintheir consumptionalreadyinthisdecadetodeliverthenecessarymitigationas indicatedbyIPCC TheEUanditsMemberStatesagreedthattheenergy sectorshouldbepredominantlyfreeoffossilfuelswellaheadof2050 underliningtheimportanceofaimingtoachieveafullyorpredominantly decarbonisedglobalpowersysteminthe2030s,leavingnoroomfornewcoal power.

South Africa Thisstructuraltransformationrequiresdiversifyingoureconomyawayfrom adependenceonfossilfuels,inajust,orderlyandequitablemanner,and informedbybestavailablescienceandsustainabledevelopmentpriorities.

Turkiye TürkiyeiscommittedtocontributingtheglobalgoalsoutlinedinthefirstGST.

UK InDecember2024,theUKpublishedtheCleanPower2030ActionPlansetting outapathwaytoacleanpowersystemby2030.Wewillconsultonour commitmenttonotissuenewoilandgaslicensestoexplorenewfields.The UKiscommittedtocleanpowerby2030andwehavealreadymadesignificant progressintransitioningawayfromfossilfuelsInSeptember2024,theUK wasthefirstG7economytoachievecoalpowerphaseout.

Recommendations for COP30

InordertoensurethecollectiveclimateandenergycommitmentsoftheParis AgreementandthefirstGlobalStocktakeareupheld,countriesmusturgently takeadditionalactiontoensurethe1.5°Ctargetremainsinreachandthe transitionawayfromfossilfuelsisaccelerated.

GreenpeaceiscallingonG20countriestoraisetheirambition-withdeveloped countriestakingthelead-andtoworktogethertocoordinateglobalaction groundedinequityandsharedresponsibilitytoachievemuchdeeperemissions reductions.TheworldcannotwaitforthenextGlobalStocktaketoagreeand advancethecollectiveactionneeded.COP30mustbeaturningpointwhere countriescommittoacredibleGlobalResponsePlantokeep1.5alive.

ThisGlobalResponsePlanmustinclude:

● Arecognitionofthecollectiveshortfallinemissionreduction commitmentsandanagreementtopeakglobalgreenhousegasemissions in2025anddeclinerapidlythereafteronapathto60%reductionby2035 (comparedto2019);

● Acommitmenttoreviseandstrengthen2035NDCsbyCOP31,whichmust includenationalplansandtimelinestotransitionawayfromfossil fuels,alignedwithequityandeachcountryʼsfairshare,andwhich contributetotheglobalgoalsonrenewableenergyandenergyefficiency;

● Anagreementona(existingornew)processwherecountriescandiscuss anddeliveracceleratedactiontotacklethemitigationambitiongapand theimplementationoftheGlobalStocktakeincludingsectoralaction;

● Theadoptionofadedicatedworkprogrammeonaroadmapforajust, orderlyandequitabletransitionawayfromfossilfuels;andtheadoption ofaForestActionPlanandmeasurestoaddresstheemissionscausedby theagricultureandland-usesectorby2030;

● AnagreementonexpandingthemandateoftheannualNDCSynthesis Reporttotrackandassesscollectiveprogresstowardsthemitigation relatedgoalsofthefirstGlobalStocktake.

IntegraltothesuccessofaGlobalResponsePlan,progressonclimatefinanceis vitaltoensureenhancedambitionindevelopingcountriesissupportedbythe necessarymeansofimplementation,includingcritically,theurgentscalingupof publicfinancebydevelopedcountries.Affirmingprogressiveenvironmental taxationinlinewiththepolluterpaysprincipleandCBDR-RC(Commonbut DifferentiatedResponsibilitiesandRespectiveCapabilities),andcommittingto taxcorporatepolluters-suchasprofittaxesonoilandgascorporations-willbe keytomobilisingtheadditionalresourcesneededformitigationaction,and protectingcommunitiesfromclimateimpacts

COP30mustalsodeliveraBelemActionMechanismonjusttransition-to coordinate,support,andscaleupjusttransitioneffortsworldwide,particularlyin developingcountries-ensuringthatactionstoreduceemissiondonotleave affectedcommunitiesbehindorworsenexistinginequalities

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.