reces s King Jut's re mains and riches take a Iran d tour of U.S. cities
towerview Provost Peter Lange prepares to shape Duke's strategic plan
IL4( f
sportswrap
•
After securing three recruits, Coach K is courting one more
The Chrroiiclei
WEDNESDAY, JULY 20, 2005
THE INDEPENDENT DAILY AT DUKE UNIVERSITY
ONE HUNDRED AND FIRST YEAR, SEND-HOME
Patient decries response to fluid mix-up Duke to launch aid by
Steve Veres
THE CHRONICLE
campaign
It has all the trappings of a modern-day David and Go-
Said i Chen THE CHRONICLE
by
TOM MENDEUTHE CHRONICLE
Raleigh resident Carol Svec is leading efforts to protest Duke University Medical Center's handling of the fluid mix-up. labeled as containing detergent. Svec had rotator cuff surgery Nov. 15 at Duke Health Raleigh, and she has spent the last seven months drawing attention to the mix-up—supporting and comforting patients who previously felt they had few places to turn. Patients have criticized Duke for not releasing information about the chemical composition of the liquid earlier; it took more than six months for Duke
and Exxon Mobil Corporation—which produces the fluid—to make the data public. In early July, Dr. Michael Cuffe, vice president for medical affairs at DUHS, said Duke should have responded more quickly and clearly when corresponding with patients about the specifics of the situation. “Duke did the right thing immediately,’" he said, citing Duke’s decision to correct the problem
and analyze the data gathered to assess the impact of the mix-up. “But I think Duke could have done better in communicating with the patients.” Cuffe also noted that Duke should have relayed the urgency of the situation to ExxonMobil when requesting information about the fluid. Since the discovery of the
v
■
liath tale. Carol Svec, a health writer from Raleigh, is almost singlehandedly taking on Duke University Health System. Acting as an advocate for patients affected by the widely publicized hydraulic fluid mishap of November and December 2004, Svec is pushing for patients’ rights and calling for more transparency from DUHS administrators. “We were put in this situation by no fault of our own. We were harmed while under Duke’s care,” Svec said, adding that she has spoken with more than three dozen affected patients the day before. “We would just like to be helped.” In late 2004, employees at Duke Health Raleigh and Durham Regional Hospital—both DUHS facilities—used tainted surgical tools in more than 3,800 surgeries. The instruments had been washed with elevator hydraulic fluid in one step of the standard cleaning process. An employee of a local elevator comhad pany inadvertently drained the fluid into drums
The University is gearing up for a new fundraising initiative targeted solely at financial aid. Administrators expect the initiative, which is slated to begin sometime this winter, to significantly boost Duke’s financial aid endowment and lessen the percentage of aid funded by the annual operating budget. Duke currently spends about $5O million each year to help students pay for tuition, room and board. Approximately 20 percent of the funds come from the financial aid endowment—money raised from investing and earning interest on the endowment. The rest comes from the operating budget, which is money that can be spent on a variety of other needs, including salaries, programming and renovation costs. With the new initiative, Executive Vice President Tallman Trask said the University hopes to increase the endowment enough so that only 50 percent ofannual
SEE FLUID ON PAGE 24 SEE AID ON PAGE 19
CAMPUS DEBATE | ACADEMIC FREEDOM
Students, profs question class climate by
Steve Veres
THE CHRONICLE
Michael Munger is hard to miss. With his wild curly hair, booming voice and wealth of political knowledge, Munger is one of Duke’s most recognized and
respected professors. But the chair of the political science department is also known by many as a conservative fixture in the classroom. He said students have come to him complaining about political bias, telling him they think they received an A- on a paper because they did not agree with his views. “That’s not blatant political discrimination,” Munger said. “You write a good paper and get a D, I may listen.” At the root of the students’ concerns—warranted or not—is an ideal intertwined with the TOM MENDEL/THE CHRONICLE
Students and professors agree that discussion is key to protecting academic freedom.
SEE ACADEMIC ON PAGE 26
Graduate student held in Armenia by
Tiffany Webber THE CHRONICLE
In the wee morning hours of
June 17, fourth-year Duke graduate student Yektan
Turkyilmaz ex-
changed farewells with friends at an airport in Yerevan, Armenia, and went to reunite with his family in Istanbul, Turkey. Four weeks later, Turkyilmaz still has not reached his final destination. “We were expecting his arrival at 2 p.m. We didn’t know where he was for 15 hours,” his sister Zeynep said. “We couldn’t figure out what was going on; it didn’t make sense at all.” Early in the morning he left for Istanbul, Turkyilmaz—who is studying cultural anthropology—was placed under arrest by Armenia’s National Security Service and escorted to the police headquarters in Yerevan,
the Armenian capital. Although no formal charges have
been filed against Turkyilmaz, officials allege he was in breach of an Armenian law that forbids the exportation of books more than 50 years old. Turkyilmaz was returning
Yektan Turkyilmaz
home after
spending
several weeks working in the Armenian national archives—the first Turk allowed to do so—as part of research for his dissertation. During his trip, Turkyilmaz SEE ARMENIA ON PAGE 17