October 3, 2002

Page 1

Thursday, October 3, 2002

Mostly Sunny High 88, Low 64 www.chronicle.duke.edu Vol. 98, No. 31

The Chronicle

Boys will be Girls Think being a drag queen is all about big hair and outlandish dresses? Think again. See RECESS

THE INDEPENDENT DAILY AT DUKE UNIVERSITY

A crisis of law and medicine?

Community Increasing litigation plagues health care reacts to new football plan

This is the second story in a threepart series examining rising malpractice costs and the health-care industry.

By DANIEL KENNEDY and MIKE MILLER

� The University’s release of a

The Chronicle

A recent boom in medical malpractice insurance that many fear is creating a national health-care crisis has forced experts to look for solutions, even at the Duke University Health System and other institutions that remain relatively unaffected and do not plan on shutting down any services. The consensus among doctors is that soaring jury awards in malpractice cases are driving the sudden increases in insurance costs, as the median award

new mission statement for the football team has met with mixed

opinions. By ALEX GARINGER The Chronicle

doubled to about $1 mil-

lion over a three-year period from 1997 to 2OOO, according to Jury HflM Verdict Research. “There’s no question that rising jury awards are the root cause of the problem,” said Phil Israel, a general surgeon at Kennestone Hospital in Marietta, Ga., and a board member at the MAG Mutual insurance company. “The basic mindset today is, ‘Let’s try to sue. I might hit the lottery.’” Peter Kussin, an associate clinical professor of pulmonary medicine at the Medical Center, is approached to testify in malpractice suits about once a week. He agrees that excessive awards are creating an atmosphere of

HSUi

*

profiteering by lawyers and patients. “Judging by the number of cases [I get], there has been an explosion in litigation over the past year,” he said. “Lawyers push their case even ifit’s totally groundless.... I testify in absolutely meritless cases where I defend the doctors.” Ofthe cases Kussin takes, only one in 10 go to trial. “The plaintiff and prosecutors will push a case until the hospital or physician will settle,” he said. “It’s very rare for a case to actually go to trial.” Rising malpractice costs are also a function of subtle changes in medicine and a public that pays greater attention to medical errors.

Julies rule in favor of the plaintiff in only a third of all cases that go to trial, but successful suits can cost millions of dollars, amounts that are “over and above what is necessary,” said Robert Seligson, chief executive officer of the North Carolina Medical Society, the state branch of the American Medical Association. Physicians and health care experts are now demanding limits on the potential awards in malpractice cases, and the American Medical Association is vigorously campaigning for national legislation capping pain and suffering damSee MALPRACTICE on page 6

Faculty and students are expressing mixed reactions to a new mission statement for the football team that seeks to help rebuild the program. The statement, released last week by President Nan Keohane’s office, calls for accepting more football players at the lower end ofthe SAT and grade point average range typically allowed for players, while also hiking coaches’ salaries

based on demonstrated success. “I was flabbergasted by the statement. If it had been part of a Doonesbury cartoon it would have seemed reasonable,” said Research Professor of Biology Peter Klopfer. He added that despite University officials’ assertions otherwise, the admissions move translates into a lowering of academic standards. Further, he said linking the team’s winloss record to the coaches’ salaries is detrimental to the program. “It’s a matter of what is more imporSee FOOTBALL on page 6

Friends remember DSG passes tenting, ICC changes dedicated teacher By MOLLY NICHOLSON The Chronicle

By DAVE INGRAM The Chronicle

Tamsen Webb, director of Duke’s Elementary Teacher Preparation Program and praised as a tireless advocate for children and the teaching profession, died from colon cancer last Thursday in her Chapel Hill home. She was 52. Often called a “hell on wheels,” a “fireball,” a “book fairy” a “wonderful storyteller” and “our Duke mom” by Mends and former students, Webb came to Duke three years ago to train elementary-level teachers—a mission that captivated every aspect ofWebb’s life, said David Malone, director of the Program in Education. “She was a gifted teacher herself, and she was an especially gifted teacher of young adults who were preparing to become teachers themselves,” Tamsen Webb Malone said. “She was a caring and inspirational professional who always took the interests of her students into mind.” Webb spent much of her career as a teacher in the See WEBB on page 8

Inslfflp

HEAD LINE MONITOR Jeremy Morgan presents his amendments to the basketball tenting policy to DSG Wednesday night.

Mayor Bill Bell announced a new initiative Wednesday targeted at helping Latinos and increasing cultural aware ness in the Durham community. See page 3 -

Duke Student Government voted to accept both the undergraduate basketball admissions policy and the Inter-Community Council bylaw amendments at its meeting Wednesday night. Junior Pushpa Raja, Student Organization Finance Committee chair, also read amendments to the SOFC bylaw, which DSG will vote on next week. In his basketball policy, Head Line Monitor Jeremy Morgan, a senior, added a clause to include his right to cap the number of tents registered for Blue, or early, registration during the University ofNorth Carolina at Chapel Hill game tenting period. Morgan said he was concerned too many tenters from the UNC game would continue tenting for the University of Maryland game. He added that he had purposely kept the grace period policy vague to allow leniency in assigning grace periods. “My general policy is probably going to be one-hour grace periods,” Morgan said. Thaniyyah Ahmad, DSG vice president for community interaction, changed her proposed amendments to the ICC bylaw, reinstating The Chronicle editor to the committee and adding an at-large position to the group. “I had a meeting with The Chronicle editor [Dave

Statistics for 2001 campus crimes were released this week. Drug related infractions and burglaries increased but the number of alcohol violations fell. See page 3 -

See DSG on page 8 North Carolina Sen. John Edwards held a retreat in Pinehurst last week, raising speculation that he is seeking a nomination tor the 2004 presidential election. See page 4


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
October 3, 2002 by Duke Chronicle Print Archives - Issuu