INDEPENDENT SINCE 1880
The Corne¬ Daily Sun Vol. 133, No. 30
MONDAY, OCTOBER 31, 2016
!
ITHACA, NEW YORK
12 Pages – Free
News
Arts
Sports
Weather
President’s Podium
Draw Like Hell
Deflecting Defeat
Partly Cloudy HIGH: 48° LOW: 33º
Interim President Hunter Rawlings explained his vision for ‘One Cornell’ at the State of the University address. | Page 3
Nathan Chazan ’19 reflects on the legacy of firebrand cartoonist Jack T. Chick.
The football team dropped its fourth straight game on Saturday, 56-7.
| Page 6
| Page 12
Rawlings: Union Would ‘Weaken’Grad Education
Cornell Graduate Students United says president misrepresents group’s objectives, affiliates By SUN STAFF
Interim President Hunter Rawlings revealed his posture on graduate student unionization Thursday, saying he believes representation by a collective labor union could undermine shared governance and individualized learning, and so is “not in the best interests of graduate education at Cornell.” Rawling’s announcement on unionization comes months after the National Labor Relation Board’s August decision that graduate students are characterized as workers, in addition to students, opening the door for labor movements at private universities across the country. Cornell Graduate Students United is currently gathering signatures from graduate students to authorize an election, according to Michaela Brangan grad, an administrative liai-
son for CGSU. She said that, under the National Labor Relations Act, the organization needs approval from 30 percent of graduate students in order to vote on unionization.
“I believe we are better able to work through differences of opinion in a collegial atmosphere.” Hunter Rawlings In a statement emailed to students, Rawlings voiced concern that the Cornell Graduate Student Union would change the working relationship between faculty and graduate students by creating an artificial divide between workers
and “management.” The interim president said the nature of a union would interfere with the “flexibility, individuality and inventiveness” of graduate education, making students responsible to a larger collective labor group, rather than able to cater their educational experiences individually. Rawlings also expressed doubts about the ability of the American Federation of Teachers and New York State United Teachers — two unions affiliated with CGSU — to adequately represent students’ interests in dealing with the administration. In contrast, he cited the Graduate and Professional Student Assembly and the General Committee of the Graduate School as examples of bodies that endow graduate See CGSU page 3
TrusteesVote to Rename Plantations By NICHOLAS BOGEL-BURROUGHS Sun Staff Writer
OMAR ABDUL-RAHIM / SUN STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER
Let them eat cake | Cornell dining workers say their wages are significantly lower than those of comparable positions at all other Ivy Leagues.
Dining Staff:Wages Are Low, Strikes Forbidden By DEVON GILLIAMS Sun Staff Writer
Harvard dining hall workers went on strike almost a month ago, protesting problems of low pay, inconsistent employment during academic breaks and limited ability to better their working conditions. Cornell dining employees claim that they earn even less. Workers at Harvard staged a walkout following failed negotiations between the university and Unite Here Local 26, the union representing employees. The union’s demands included a salary increase to $35,000 a year and a freeze on out of pocket health expenses. Harvard acquiesced to both of these requests, ending the strike on Wednesday.
Cornell dining workers interviewed by The Sun — all of whom asked not to be named out of concern for their jobs — expressed similar grievances, saying their average wages fall well below the salary of comparable positions at all other Ivy League schools. But Cornell workers are loath to walk because they say they were warned that such a demonstration would lead to their dismissal. One worker detailed how Cornell employees were explicitly told not to stage a walkout during collective bargaining because it would be considered an unsanctioned union walkout. They were informed that they would face dismissal by the University if they disobeyed these instructions. See DINING page 4
The Cornell Board of Trustees voted unanimously to change the name of the Cornell Plantations to Cornell Botanic Gardens Friday, after 72 years under the former title. The name change follows a more than twoyears-long initiative by Christopher Dunn, the Elizabeth Newman Wilds director, to find a name that better describes the gardens and avoids the “negative and painful connotations” of the plantations name that has been in place since 1944. Cornell’s Black Students Union, in a November of 2015 delivered a letter to former president Elizabeth Garrett and Vice President Ryan Lombardi, demanding that Cornell “change the name of the Cornell Plantations as soon as possible.” Dunn said the concern of BSU and other campus groups added fuel to an initiative he had proposed in his first interview for the director job, when he was still at the University of Hawai’i. “I feel like the door has opened for the future,” Dunn said minutes after the trustees voted. “I think we were somewhat limited, in terms of our ability to really connect people with plants and gardens, by the name, and [the change] feels liberating. “We’ve been the Cornell Botanic Gardens for 12 minutes and it feels great,” he added. The gardens are one of the five largest gardens in North America, Cornell said in a statement, and are home to 50,000 plants as well as 3,400 acres of natural area preserves. Dunn said that during the job interview for his current director job, he asked Cornell leadership about the history of the name and the potential for changing it. “When I was hired, I was given the encouragement to pursue it,” Dunn said. “We wanted good justification and good support for a change, not just a knee-jerk reaction to one thing or another.” The two-year process included focus groups, surveys and internal polling of 2,700 stakeholders’ reaction to nine potential new names for the gardens. In August, the results came back from the sur-
veys and focus groups, with Cornell Botanic Gardens leading the pack. “That’s when things really took off,” Dunn said, and the University began preparing for the name change. Dunn said one problem with the former name, in addition to the slavery connotations of the word “plantation,” is that it was inaccurate term to describe the Cornell gardens. Plantations are large swaths of land, dominated by a single crop that is harvested and sold, Dunn INSET: LINDSAY MYRON / SUN FILE PHOTO
Botanic disputes | Plantations director Christopher Dunn said he first proposed the renaming two years ago. said. That name, Dunn said, was a poor description of the diversity that Cornell’s gardens include. Cornell has already acquired a website, cornellbotanicgardens.org, although it is not yet active, and the University says a new logo is being drafted. New signage will also be installed by spring 2017, according to a statement from Cornell. Nicholas Bogel-Burroughs can be reached at njb99@cornell.edu.