02 03 14 entire issue lo res

INDEPENDENT SINCE 1880

The Corne¬ Daily Sun Vol. 131, No. 81

TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 3, 2015

!

ITHACA, NEW YORK

12 Pages – Free

News

Opinion

Sports

Weather

Eddy Street Eats

Deflategate

Iced Out

Partly Cloudy HIGH: 23º LOW: 16º

Green Castle Korean Market, a new Asian grocery store, opens on Eddy Street. | Page 3

David Fischer ’15 discusses the implications of the recent NFL scandal.

The women’s hockey team sweeps weekend games against Ivy League rivals.

| Page 9

| Page 12

$50M Verizon Gift To Fund Cornell Tech Education Center

By ANNIE BUI Sun News Editor

With a $50 million gift from Verizon, Cornell Tech will develop the Verizon Executive Education Center, where students, faculty and other members of the tech community will be able to collaborate and bring “cutting-edge” ideas to life.

The gift, announced Monday, will fund construction of the executive education building, according to Cornell Tech Dean and Vice Provost Dan Huttenlocher.

The center will be part of the campus’ first phase, which broke ground last month and is slated to open in the summer of 2017, according to a University press release. However, the executive education center will open

A ‘transformative’ gift | Pictured is a rendering of the Verizon Executive Education Center that will be built on the Cornell Tech campus.

at a later date than the rest of phase one.

Huttenlocher said the building will be used for activities that do not generally fit in the “normal full-time academic class schedule,” such as workshops, conferences and executive education classes.

“Many of these will attract people from companies, both large and small, both in New York City and beyond,” Huttenlocher said. “The benefit to students and faculty will be these additional kinds of academic functions and increased interaction with companies and practitioners.”

Programs and events at the center will also allow Verizon to “develop customized center-based programs for its executives and customers,” according to the University.

See VERIZON page 4 COURTESY OF KILOGRAPH

BRITTNEY CHEW / SUN STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER

Open for business | Gregar Brous, who purchased Rulloff’s Restaurant last year after it was closed down, said he plans to reopen the restaurant tomorrow.

Rulloff’s to Reopen Tomorrow Revamped restaurant returns under new owner

By SOFIA HU Sun Senior Writer

For an establishment that has stood on College Avenue since 1977, the silence and darkness at Rulloff’s Restaurant and Bar during the fall semester has been unusual.

However, all that may soon change when

the Collegetown staple reopens its doors on Wednesday with a revamped menu and spruced up restaurant.

Gregar Brous — the owner of the AGAVA Restaurant and Collegetown Bagels — purchased Rulloff’s after the restaurant’s previous See RULLOFF’S page 4

Horticulture Director Announced

By PAULINA GLASS Sun Staff Writer

Rhoda Maurer — a horticulturist from Geneva, N.Y. — will be the new director of horticulture for the Cornell Plantations, the University announced Monday.

As director, Maurer will be in charge of garden development, management of greenhouse and other Plantation staff and the continued cultivation of over 40,000 plants on the Plantations’ property, accord-

Most recently, Maurer was ing to a University press in Geneva leading the greenrelease. houses at Cornell’s Maurer directNew York State ed, curated and Agricultural worked at numerExperiment ous horticulture Station, according programs both to the release. domestically and Maurer said she abroad before looks forward to coming to bringing her Cornell, accord“affection for pubing to the release.

MAURER lic horticulture” to Notably, she worked at the gardens of the University and commuSwarthmore College in nity.

Pennsylvania and Wisley See PLANTATIONS page 4 Garden in England.

Rand Hall Renovation Will Expand Current Fine Arts Library

By OLIVIA LUTWAK Sun Staff Writer

A major renovation — funded by a $6 million donation from Mui Ho ’62 B.Arch ’66 — is planned for the Fine Arts Library in Rand Hall, according to the University.

The new library will be expanded to occupy the top

two floors of Rand Hall, ers the renovation to be a Arts Library as soon as pos- “We aim to provide a stateaccording to a press release “key academic priority” for sible since it is a critical of-the-art library that will teaching and learning offer direct access to the from the College of the college. fine arts collection as Architecture, Art and Planning.

“The Fine Arts Library ... is a critical teaching and well as public computand visual resource There is currently no learning source for many faculty and students.” ing support.” construction timeline or Kent Kleinman In an announcement design for the construclast July, the University tion, according to Kent “The University librari- resource for many faculty named alumnus Wolfgang Kleinman, dean of the architecture college. an and I are very commit- and students across the Tschapeller M.Arch ’87 as However, he said he consid- ted to rebuilding the Fine University,” Kleinman said. the main architect for the

Fine Arts Library.

Students had mixed opinions on the project, with current architecture students expressing both excitement and concern.

“Many architecture students share the sentiment that we are excited to have additional space for the See RENOVATION page 5

2 THE CORNELL DAILY SUN | Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Today

DAYBOOK

Tuesday, February 3, 2015

weather FORECAST

Daybook Today

Today

Tomorrow

Hi: 23° F Lo: 16º F Partly Cloudy

Hi: 37° F Lo: 14° F Snow Showers

International Opportunities Fair 11 a.m. - 2 p.m., Memorial Room, Willard Straight Hall Data Management Information Session Noon - 1 p.m., 701 Clark Hall The Political Economy of an Emerging Global Dream: In Search of the Brazil Dream 4:30 p.m., Management Library, Sage Hall Free Workshop with Nrityagram Dancers 5 - 6:30 p.m., SB10 Schwartz Center for Performing Arts

Tomorrow Dr. Akunzule, Versatile Veterinarian in Ghana 6 p.m., Lecture Hall 1, Veterinary College Slim by Design: Mindless Eating Solutions for Everyday Life 10:30 - 11:30 a.m., Auditorium, Boyce Thompson Institute

“Shake It Off” Temperature falls Student walking to class falls Yes, I did see that ~ I’m Next ’18

Dreer Award Seminar: Cool-Season Viticulture in New Zealand 12:15 p.m., 22 Plant Sciences Building Barry Pittendrigh, Responses of Insect Systems Seminar 12:15 - 1:15 p.m., 2123 Comstock Hall Ideas for a Better World: Sustainability Strategies Workshop 2 - 5 p.m., 401C Warren Hall LEPP Theory: Composite Higgs Models Seminar 2 - 3 p.m., 401 Physical Sciences Building

ReCYcLE. CD & RECORD FAIR Saturday, Feb. 7, 2015 10 A.M. – 5 P.M.

123 E. State St. • On The Commons DEALERS SELLING & BUYING ALL TYPES OF MUSIC:

100,000 CDs, DVDs, RECORDS, etc. FOR SALE Bargains & Rarities

nyrecordfairs.com

The Corne¬ Daily Sun INDEPENDENT SINCE 1880 Editor in Chief

Haley Velasco ’15

ALL DEPARTMENTS

Business Manager

Catherine Chen ’15

(607) 273-3606

Business: For questions regarding advertising, classifieds, subscriptions or delivery problems, please call from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., Monday-Friday.

News: To report breaking news or story ideas, please call after 5 p.m., SundayThursday.

SEND A FAX VISIT THE OFFICE THE SUN ONLINE E-MAIL

(607) 273-0746 139 W. State Street, Ithaca, N.Y. www.cornellsun.com sunmailbox@cornellsun.com

Postal Information: The Cornell Daily Sun (USPS 132680 ISSN 1095-8169) is published by THE CORNELL DAILY SUN, a New York corporation, 139 W. State St., Ithaca, N.Y. 14850.

The Sun is published Monday through Friday during the Cornell University academic year, with three special issues: one for seniors in May, one for alumni in June and one for incoming freshmen in July, for a total of 143 issues per year. Subscription rates are: $137.00 for fall term, $143.00 for spring term and $280.00 for both terms if paid in advance. First-class postage paid at Ithaca, New York.

Postmaster: Send address changes to The Cornell Daily Sun, 139 W. State St., Ithaca, N.Y. 14850.

PUPIL POETRY cornellians write verse Students may send poetry submissions to news-editor@cornellsun.com.

THE CORNELL DAILY SUN | Tuesday, February 3, 2015 3

NEWS

New Branch of Korean Grocery Store To Open on Collegetown’s Eddy Street

Local Structure Catches Fire In Dryden Monday

A small fire broke out in Dryden Monday afternoon, according to The Ithaca Voice.

Emergency responders arrived quickly and extinguished it, leaving no injuries. The dispatcher suspected that the structure was a wood shed in the backyard of a home, but was unable to say for certain.

State Cuomo Seeks ‘Ethics Reform’ In State Government

Following the arrest of assembly speaker Sheldon Silver, Governor Andrew Cuomo is encouraging the state senate and congress to pass legislation releasing budget and salary records, according to The New York Times.

Cuomo seeks to “have total disclosure” in the government.

National Obama Calls for $534 Million For Base Defense Spending

As part of the new budget proposed yesterday by President Barack Obama, $534 million was allocated for the base defense budget, according to The New York Times. This proposal, as well as the rest of the budget, will soon be voted on by the new Republican congress.

— Compiled by Paulina Glass

Green Castle Korean Market will offer foods ‘hard to come by’ in Collegetown

By GABRIELLA LEE

“I haven’t been there yet, but I’m glad lishments in Collegetown, among them Korean restaurants, Indian restaurants and there’s a place I can get Asian groceries,” Sara Cheong ’16 said. “I’ve been to the one Japanese restaurants.

Collegetown residents will see yet anothKim said she believes the increasing in Triphammer Mall, but it was always a er addition to the Asian food scene in amount of Asian cuisine in recent months is hassle to get to. This should make it a lot Collegetown with the due to changing tastes as more convenient.” official opening of Green Vicky Fam ’16, who lives on Eddy well as an increase in Asian “Students need Asian Castle Korean Market — Street, also said she was excited about the students at Cornell. a new Asian grocery store food. My customers, the “[Students] like [Asian] new Asian grocery store because it is close — Tuesday. food more than before,” to where she lives. students, asked, ‘Why Joining the neighbor- don’t you open a store in she said. “Also, [at] “A lot of the things [Green Castle hood with stores such as Cornell, I think there are Korean Market] sells are things that are Collegetown?’” bubble tea shop Kung Fu more and more Asian stu- hard to come by in Collegetown, so it’s Tea and Chinese restaugreat to be able to save time by shopping dents.”

Stella Kim rant De Tasty Hot Pot, Students currently liv- there,” Fam said.

Green Castle Korean ing in Collegetown said Market will be located at 325 Eddy St. they were pleased with the addition of an Gabriella Lee can be reached at The food market — which offers kim- Asian grocery store. glee@cornellsun.com. chi, ramen, sauces and homemade Korean side dishes — is a new branch of the original store in Triphammer Mall, according to owner Stella Kim. “Students need Asian food,” Kim said.

“My customers, the students, asked, ‘Why don’t you open a store in Collegetown? It’s too far away here [at Triphammer Mall].

They were so happy I decided to open in Collegetown.”

Kim said the store will be mostly stocked with Korean products, but that she would eventually expand to other types of Asian food and anything else students might request.

Kim, who is renting the space from landlord Steve Fontana ’79, said she decided to open a store at the Eddy Street location last summer and had been working on opening it for “about three to four months.”

Previously, the space had also been occupied by an Asian grocery store for 30 years before the owners retired last summer, HAEWON HWANG / SUN STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER according to Fontana.

Green Castle Korean Market joins the Eating on Eddy | Green Castle Korean Market will join the hub of already-existing restaurants ranks of numerous other Asian food estab- and stores on the busy street in Collegetown.

Sun Staff Writer

Students’ Stories John Lowry ’16 connects cafeteria food waste to hunger in Ithaca with the Food Recovery Network

By EVELYN NAM

After receiving the food, the was “shocked” to see the Courtney Dennee ’15 and amount of food that was wast- Erica Rausch ’15 — to kick- Friendship Donations Network start the Food Recovery redistributes the food to local ed at campus dining halls.

The Food Recovery shelters at its discretion.

“Seeing the amount of food Network at Cornell.

Network — a national organi- waste was such a culture Since its founding, the Food “Every Thursday we collect zation that focuses on provid- shock,” he said. “I’ve recoverable food ing food to those without realized that we have from the two dining “Seeing the amount of food means — arrived on campus become so desensitized to halls, cool it down waste was such a culture shock. to the appropriate two years ago when John [food waste]. That really Lowry ’16 saw the need to alle- stuck with me.” temperature and I’ve realized that we have viate two large issues in his pack it up and hand Lowry, who said he become so desensitized to community — eliminating “began to wonder” if he it to the volunteers food waste in campus dining could come up with a from [the] [food waste]. That really halls and providing food to the solution to the hunger Fr i e n d s h i p stuck with me.” hungry in Ithaca.

D o n a t i o n s issues in Ithaca and food Lowry said the idea of waste on Cornell’s camNetwork,” Dennee John Lowry ’16 bringing the Food Recovery pus, said. attended an Network to Cornell came dur- EcoReps conference at Rausch said extra ing his freshman year, when he Brown caution is taken to University took a course on sustainable through the sustainable Recovery Network has served ensure that distributed food living and volunteered at lifestyle class he was enrolled the local community with the taken from the dining halls is Loaves and Fishes, a food in. help of two campus dining safe to consume. pantry in downtown Ithaca. An Robert Purcell “Liabilities and food safety After attending the confer- halls, employee at Cornell Dining, ence, Lowry said he teamed up Marketplace Eatery and Becker are serious issues,” Rausch said.

Lowry said he with his former roommates — House Dining Room, as well as “When we get the food from the Friendship Donations the dining hall, we make sure Network of Ithaca, according that it is over 145 degrees and Know someone remarkable? Send your suggestion to Dennee. we cool it to below 40 degrees. to managing-editor@cornellsun.com.

Sun Contributor

Anything in-between is in a danger zone.”

Rausch added that she would like to see more involvement from other dining halls on campus.

“We would like to idealistically speaking have all 10 dining halls participate,” she said.

With training for new volunteers beginning next week, Lowry said he knows that the mission and purpose of the Food Recovery Network will continue for years to come.

“Food has this strange, fascinating element of drawing people together,” he said. “It’s not just about fighting food [and] it’s not just about fighting hunger — it’s about connecting Cornell and all its students and all of our busy lives to something larger than all of us.”

Evelyn Nam can be reached at yn95@cornellsun.com.

4 THE CORNELL DAILY SUN | Tuesday, February 3, 2015

NEWS

Rulloff’s Returns to Collegetown Tech Campus Receives $50 Million FromVerizon RULLOFF’S

Continued from page 1

owners abruptly shut down the restaurant on Sept. 1 in a decision that upset many former employees, alumni and students.

Brous said he and a team of approximately 40 newly hired employees have worked since November to return the restaurant to its “original luster.”

“There was a lot of tender love and care that went into preparing the restaurant,” Brous said.

“Every wall was repainted. Every piece of wood was polished and oiled. Every piece of metal was reshined.”

In addition to repairing and renovating parts of the restaurant, the team behind the new Rulloff’s has worked extensively to improve the menu.

“We’d like to have a stronger food presence for lunch, dinner and brunch,” Brous said. “It’s going to be a more bistro and upscale food bar.”

Not only will the menu feature more “serious” food, the restaurant will also begin offering a latenight menu from 10 p.m. to midnight and a brunch menu on weekends, according to Todd Nau, general manager of the restaurant.

Nau added that the bar menu will revisit the establishment’s historical roots by offering modern twists on cocktails previously served at Rulloff’s.

“We’re going to build off the strengths that Rulloff’s was known for in its original incarnation,” Nau said.

The service will also see an “upgrade,” according to Nick Alexander ’12, the front-of-house service manager.

“We want a relaxed atmosphere, but at the same time that doesn’t mean we want the service to be loose,” said Alexander, a graduate from the School of Hotel Administration.

Out of the over 40 employees hired, approximately four are former employees who worked at Rulloff’s before its closure on Labor Day last year, according to Brous.

Brous said he received positive comments from Ithaca residents following the December announcement that he planned to reopen Rulloff’s.

“There was a real void on College Avenue when Rulloff’s closed,” Brous said. “Locals who have been here for a very long time are very excited that we might bring Rulloff’s back to its original luster.”

Rulloff’s will open its doors on Wednesday at 3 p.m. Additionally, the restaurant will be serving food from an abbreviated menu from 5 to 9 p.m. until Sunday.

Starting Monday, the establishment will begin operating under normal hours from 11 a.m. until last call at 1 a.m., according to Brous.

Sofia Hu can be reached at shu@cornellsun.com.

VERIZON

Continued from page 1

The possibility of the Verizon gift had been under discussion for several months, according to Huttenlocher.

“The gift came about because of a shared interest in the future of education for the digital economy, and the fact that such education will not only be degree programs but also other forms of education that this facility will be designed for,” he said.

President David Skorton said in a press release that the “transformative” Verizon gift would allow Cornell to advance its mission of combining academia with industry.

“The campus will welcome everyone interested in using technology to advance the economy and to make the world a better place, and the Verizon Executive Education Center will be at the center of it,” Skorton said.

Verizon chairman and chief executive officer Lowell McAdam said the gift aligned “perfectly” with the company’s mission.

“The Verizon Executive Education Center will be a magnet for developers, entrepreneurs, educators and innovators across all industries, building on the great talent and creativity we already have in the tech sector here in New York City,” McAdam said in the release.

Huttenlocher said he believes the building will be a “major asset” for Cornell Tech. “[It will] provide facilities beyond those for research and for full-time degree programs that are in the other buildings,” he said.

Annie Bui can be reached at abui@cornellsun.com.

Plantations Selects New Director of Horticulture PLANTATIONS

Continued from page 1

“I’m excited to start an exploration of how Plantations might add value to people’s lives, inspiring collaborations to discover unforeseen possibilities for how we might connect our living collections with contemporary socio-economic-biological systems in our changing world,” Maurer said in the release.

Christopher Dunn, director of the Cornell Plantations, expressed his “delight” at the addition of Maurer to the programs.

“Her experience, matched with her enthusiasm will only serve to help keep Cornell Plantations growing forward in the years to come,” Dunn said in the release. “Everyone at Plantations is very excited for this new chapter in our 70-longyear history.”

Maurer will begin as director this week and will succeed Mary Hirschfield, who worked as the director of horticulture for 36 years, according to the University.

Paulina Glass can be reached at pglass@cornellsun.com.

THE CORNELL DAILY SUN | Tuesday, February 3, 2015 5

NEWS

Dean: Library Super Bowl Celebrations Delayed Due to Storm Renovation ‘Key’Priority Construction will be funded by $6 million gift from alumna RENOVATION

Continued from page 1

library,” Christopher Andras ’18 said. “The second floor of Rand had been home to first-year studio for a long time. Hopefully, the change will not drastically change the attitude and studio culture present during the first year of study.”

The Fine Arts Library is currently located on the top floor of the building, while studio space for undergraduates is located on the floor beneath it. Some students said they were worried that expanding the Fine Arts Library to occupy two floors would potentially displace their studio space.

Though Stephanie Cheung ’18 said she is looking forward to having “more study and reading spaces so conveniently located,” she was also concerned about the details of the renovation.

“As students, we are not really informed about the progress of the expansion and details of the project, so I don’t know to what extent it will affect our circulation from studio to the fabrication shops downstairs,” Cheung said.

Olivia Lutwak can be reached at olutwak@cornellsun.com.

BOSTON (AP) — The Super Bowl celebration for New Englanders and their beloved Patriots will have to wait another day as Boston continues to get battered by heavy snow.

Mayor Marty Walsh said the city will postpone a planned victory parade through downtown until Wednesday morning.

He said the city and team have both agreed to hold off on the parade due to Monday’s protracted snowstorm, which dumped more than a foot of fresh snow in the Boston area, making morning and evening commutes treacherous.

“We thank everyone for their flexibility and patience during the planning of this parade and we look forward to celebrating with Patriots fans during better weather on Wednesday,” he said in a joint statement with the team.

The city had announced earlier that the downtown parade would take place Tuesday. But with weather continuing to worsen, Boston public schools preemptively canceled Tuesday classes, the fifth snow day in the past week. A decision to cancel the parade followed shortly after.

Boston has seen a record 34.2 inches of snow over seven days, according to the National Weather Service. The previous seven-day record was 31.2 inches in January 1996.

Following their 28-24 victory over the defending champion Seattle Seahawks in Arizona, the Patriots flew back to Massachusetts as scores of flights in and out of Boston’s Logan airport were canceled or delayed Monday.

The latest snowstorm didn’t stop New Englanders from basking in the

glow of their team’s fourth Super Bowl victory.

Todd Penney, of Coventry, Connecticut, was still recovering from a heady night of celebrating as he prepared for work Monday morning as a town engineer.

“My voice is very hoarse from screaming at the TV. I was all in last night,” he said. “It will be a lot more fun for me to snowblow this morning after the Patriots' win, than if they would have lost, that's for sure.”

Other fans recounted tense moments from the rollercoaster victory.

“It was an exciting game, a nail-biter to the end. You don’t get to see games like that very often,” said George Vemis, as he cleared the sidewalk in front of his variety store in Whitman, south of Boston.

Punxsutawney Phil Predicts Six More Weeks of Winter PUNXSUTAWNEY, Pa. (AP) — The handlers of Pennsylvania’s most famous groundhog, Punxsutawney Phil, said Monday the furry rodent has forecast six more weeks of winter.

Members of the top hat-wearing Inner Circle announced the “prediction” Monday morning.

A German legend has it that if a furry rodent sees his shadow on Feb. 2, winter will last another six weeks. If not, spring comes early.

The forecast was also announced on Twitter, as was referenced in the official proclamation read by Jeff Lundy, the Fair Weatherman of the Inner Circle.

“Forecasts abound on the Internet, but, I, Punxsutawney Phil am still your

best bet. Yes, a shadow I see, you can start to Twitter, hash tag: Six more weeks of winter!”

The forecast was delivered after a steady pre-dawn rain turned to snow as temperatures dropped from the high 30s to around freezing. They were forecast to keep dropping over much of the state, prompting the state Department of Transportation to lower the speed limit to 45 mph for many interstate highways which were already wet and expected to freeze or be covered with snow as the day wore on.

The rain kept some revelers away, with state police estimating the crowd at around 11,000, slightly smaller than in recent years when upward of 15,000 attended.

Despite the German legend, Phil’s handlers don’t wait to see if he sees his shadow — as he likely would not have on such an overcast day. Instead, the Inner Circle decide on the forecast ahead of time and announce it on Gobbler’s Knob, a tiny hill in the town for which the groundhog is named, about 65 miles northeast of Pittsburgh.

Records going back to 1887 show Phil has now predicted more winter 102 times while forecasting an early spring just 17 times. There are no records for the remaining years.

Phil's counterpart in New York City, Staten Island Chuck, delivered a conflicting message in calling for an early spring after not seeing his shadow.

A&E

6 | The Corne¬ Daily Sun | Tuesday, February 3, 2015

ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT Napalm Death Apex Predator — Easy Meat Century Media

TE S T S P I N S new and notable O music in review OO O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O

O

Troy Sherman Musicians who once made (and got popular through making) music that is both good and accessible have been plagued — since (and maybe even before) Elvis first slathered himself with however much grease was necessary to slide his bloating decrepitude into that Vegasian white monstrosity of a performance suit post-Elvis in Memphis — with the disease of time. There are two paths a has-been can take once they’re past their proverbial prime: Either, A.) ceaselessly spew painfully dated facsimiles of the art that brought them into the limelight (which is bad) or B.) become deaf and/or senile to the point where adult pop or Frank Sinatra cover albums seem like a good idea (which is worse, and yes, I’m looking at you, Paul and Bob). However, there’s an almost surefire (albeit financially questionable) way for any musician to avoid this career-killing ineluctability: Just don’t get popular.

That’s right; obscurity is the artist’s fountain of youth.

Now, avoiding fame is easier said than done. Mr. Dylan, for example, was changing the world at a time when the youth culture desperately wanted (and, debatably, needed) the world to change. His path to stardom was almost inevitable; he followed his muse straight to the charts, and cut some of the greatest songs popular music has ever seen while doing it. But, after a while, Bobby started experiencing the classic couple’s dilemma. He and his muse wanted different things: The former, a paycheck; the latter, immortality. So alas, they began drifting (Nashville Skyline), finally split up (Self Portrait), tried to rekindle every once in a while over a cup of coffee (Desire, Blood on the Tracks), found their own ways to be happy (Saved), had a brief and questionably-fated fling (Love and Theft) and finally reached the point of culmination, one of utter mutual hatred marked by childishly

O

O

O

O

O

scornful attempts at offense (this current Sinatra debacle).

But, I digress … what I’m trying to say is that popularity tends to beget artistic idiocy.

Thankfully, there is a foil to this dishearteningly common chain of events: The saga of the independent (which word is roughly interchangeable with “unpopular” or “poor,” and by no means “indie”) artist. In this particular instance, I’m talking about Napalm Death, the Grindcore poster children/originators who just released album number 15, the deliciously rancid and bloodboilingly visceral Apex Predator — Easy Meat.

The trip kicks off titularly, with the funereal and almost terrifying “Apex Predator — Easy Meat.” It plays like a dirge, with Gregorian Greenway (our vocalist) groaning, barking and chanting quasi-indecipherable lyrics while the band pounds out the thrash metal equivalent to a haunted house soundtrack. It’s about as close as Napalm Death ever comes to Dark or Doom metal, and it’s just as crassly brilliant as anything else in their catalogue. It segues (with bizarre seamlessness) into the epitomically Thrash “Smash a Single Digit,” which, at 1:26, plays like a hardcore song in more ways than just its relentless guitar bombast. The succeeding track, “Metaphorically Screw You,” is no less cutting or punk, exciting with its flagrant command of “KILL KILL KILL KILL.” And so the record proceeds, through 14 wrenching, cagedanimal tracks (with such flagellating titles as “Timeless Flogging” and “Copulating Snakes”).

To be sure, Napalm Death have had better showings.

Scum and From Enslavement to Obliteration are two of the definitive recordings, in any genre, of the late 80s, and are likely not to be surpassed by their creators. That said, Apex

O

O

O

O

O

Predator is everything one could want in a metal record: It’s angry, vaguely political, spasmodic and comparatively experimental and its style fluctuates the perfect amount between a number of various metal and fringe-metal styles. Had this record come out in 1987, it would’ve been groundbreaking, and even though it did come out in 2015, it’s a fantastic listen (at least for anybody who is inclined towards aural masochism and paroxysmal musical experiences). But, Apex Predator isn’t great just because it sounds great; it’s great because it shows us a band who, 30 years ago, defined a genre, and now, in 2015, show no signs of wear or age.

Napalm Death is as relevant now as they were in 1987, which is proof of their staying power. No, they’re not going to make gobs of money; but, I’d bet that they’re going to continue making gobs of sonic satanic delight until they’re too old and grey to bang their heads any more, and that is the beauty of unpopular music like this. When Napalm Death lament on “How the Years Condemn,” that’s an example of them transferring their once-youthful angst and scorn into metaphysically contemplative (albeit ineloquent and bestial) metallic philosophy; That’s progression. The years condemn the members of Napalm Death to an imminent doom, after which their musical body will be their only lasting remnant, an echo of themselves in time capable of speaking an eternal, hateful truth too anyone down the road who’s willing or able to listen; the years condemn Bob Dylan to Frank Sinatra cover albums.

Troy Sherman is a sophomore in the College of Arts and Sciences.

He can be reached at jmg488@cornell.edu.

Fanclub’s First: Indie-Punk at the Bear Club

BY HADIYAH CHOWDHURY Sun Staff Writer

Fanclub’s first show of the semester did not have a very enthusiastic start. Modern Hut, a singer-songwriter from New York, opened the show with his dry, apathetic and slightly flat voice. Even though I thought I would not enjoy his set, some of his lyrics were surprisingly beautiful, especially when combined with his dry guitar picking. I felt that I would have adored Modern Hut if only he seemed a bit more interested in his music and what he was singing about. He sang about American apathy and some of my favorite lines of his were, “Sometimes I think I was born without a taste for life,” “When I’m not on drugs I’m just plain bored” and “I don’t wanna get adjusted to this world.” All of his lyrics defined his music; the dryness of his lyrics was perfectly expressed in his guitar playing. I certainly understand why some may enjoy listening to Modern Hut, but I did not feel that it was a very energetic way to open a show. I felt de-energized after his performance, but I also felt pensive. While Modern Hut’s croaky voice may not have been what I wanted to hear, I felt that it was something everyone should hear, if only to understand the apathy that is all too prevalent in American culture.

The Sea Life, an indie punk band from Washington, D.C., played their set after Modern Hut. I am not very familiar with the D.C. punk scene, but was told that The Sea Life very much embodied its feel. I could not make out a single lyric, but there was something in their sound that I very much enjoyed. While The Sea Life’s instrumentation was very unorganized and chaotic, I somehow felt safe in the knowledge that they knew what they were doing and how to energize their audience. There is something distinctly beautiful about listening to music that you normally would not and being able to

ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT

feel it in your soul. As my body moved to The Sea Life, I felt that their exquisite chaos was admirable, and I knew I would never be able to replicate it. So perhaps I did not understand any of the lyrics, but something about The Sea Life spoke to me. I think dissonance is perhaps more powerful than I had previously thought.

The next band, Pinegrove, was from northern New Jersey and was absolutely my favorite band of the night. They con-

COURTESY OF JULIA LEIBY

sisted of a lead singer, bassist and drummer. The lead singer’s voice was both sensitive and powerful. Pinegrove’s sound is extremely difficult to place; it lies somewhere between punk, rock and indie-alternative. They played a song they had only played once before for an audience, and while they did mess up a bit at the beginning, they held it together enough to finish it. A lot of Pinegrove’s soundscape consists of decaying guitar imagery, which was absolutely gorgeous. It may seem strange to describe a punk-rock band’s sound as gorgeous, but

I honestly cannot think of a better way to describe Pinegrove.

They just create really beautiful music, and if there’s anything you should check out from last night, it’s definitely Pinegrove.

They sing about life, love and loss while creating truly beautiful soundscapes. Really, what more could anyone ask for?

And finally, to end the show, a band from New York, What Moon Things played a set. At this point, the energy was quite high since Pinegrove had just finished playing. Unfortunately, I felt that What Moon Things deflated most of the rest of the energy in the room. They played in the dark, and while they did build a lot of tension into their songs, there was never really a release. In the end, I left the show feeling rather stressed and confused due to the unorganized nature of their content. The punk band just did not really have it together. They could not gauge their audience’s energy level or reactions and I felt that they did not know how to end each song. Either it ended abruptly and I was not completely aware of what had happened or it seemed to go on forever. Their last song was so long it was painful. I was quite disappointed with What Moon Things, though I do feel like they have a lot of potential. In order to become more cohesive, I just think they need to understand their audiences’ attention span and be able to better gauge their audiences’ energy level.

In the end, I really enjoyed the show, even though some bands were undoubtedly more put together than others.

I feel that if the show had been opened by someone more energizing, the entire ambiance would have felt different.

Ultimately, the show was a success, but it started and ended on a rather melancholy note. In any case, I am really looking forward to Fanclub’s future shows this semester!

Hadiyah Chowdhury is a freshman in the College of Arts and Sciences. She can be reached at hchowdhury@cornellsun.com.

A&E

Tuesday, February 3, 2015 | The Corne¬ Daily Sun | 7

Why Selma Is Important to the Movement T the face of the movement, with many scenes depicting his impassioned speeches and talks with President Lyndon B. Johnson, whereas Malcolm X — an equally important part of the black radical movement — is barely given a cameo. Additionally, female leaders in the Civil R i g h t s Movement are rarely mentioned, unless in relation to their male counterparts Sarah Paez (e.g. Coretta Scott King). ity on his face. We then flash to a But Selma stands as an important gaggle of girls and boys in their force in depicting the truth of the Sunday best, pink dresses bounc- movement — it wasn’t perfect, but ing, bowties crisp and straight. At it was filled with brutality, grit, this point, you might be able to determination, and most of all, an guess where we are — Bir- unwavering hope that we can still mingham, Alabama. A little girl see in the movement today. starts to say something, and, as if on cue, a horrendous burst of fire Sarah Paez is a sophomore in the engulfs her and the others, killing College of Arts and Sciences. She can be reached at spaez@cornell.edu. them immediately.

This is 1965, but it looks suspiciously like 2014, save for the clothing. An act of terror has seized the black community, and it’s only slightly more pronounced than today. The comparisons to Ferguson, Missouri are obvious, with the John Legend hit “Glory” playing during the end credits, and several brutal shots of unarmed black people getting beaten in broad daylight by armed white citizen militias and state troopers.

Does this call to mind the tear gas fired on unarmed protestors during the Ferguson protests this summer and fall? Does this call to mind the police brutality caught on tape by University of California at Berkeley students at an action protesting the deaths of Mike Brown, Eric Garner and Tamir Rice in December?

So, why is Selma important?

Because many people choose not to see this side of the story. It is much easier, as a white person enjoying the privileges of our racially hierarchical system, to think that the Civil Rights Movement solved all problems pertinent to black people.

It is much easier to assume that the deaths of Mike Brown and Eric Garner were brought on by their own contentious nature. It is much easier to assume there is no corruption in the law enforcement institutions we so value today. What Selma does is set up a clever parallel between actions of protesters then and protestors now, without even showing footage from our decade.

That’s why Selma’s snub at the Oscars hurts (Oyelowo did not even get nominated for his portrayal of Dr. King, nor did and director Ava DuVernay). It is a film that breaks barriers in the fact that it portrays black people as leaders, not slaves or subservient to white people. Oyelowo, in an outside interview by Mediaite, explains that this movie marks one of the first times a black story is not told through the eyes of a white person. Selma is also the only film featuring black actors in prominent roles that made it to the Oscars, a telling detail of an industry that devalues black narratives and actors.

That’s not to say there aren’t some things Selma could have done better — the film lauds Dr. King as he civil rights biopic Selma starts with a shot of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. (David Oyelowo) and his wife Coretta Scott King (Carmen Ejogo) in a lavish hotel room; she is attempting to straighten his tie, and he has a look of anxious sever-

Guest Room

COURTESY OF PARAMOUNT PICTURES

OPINION

Deon Thomas |

The Corne¬ Daily Sun Independent Since 1880 132ND EDITORIAL BOARD HALEY VELASCO ’15 Editor in Chief

CATHERINE CHEN ’15

TYLER ALICEA ’16

CAROLINE FLAX ’15

ZACH STEELE ’15

NICK DE TULLIO ’15

SCOTT CHIUSANO ’15

Business Manager

Managing Editor

Associate Editor

Advertising Manager

Web Editor

Sports Editor

RACHEL ELLICOTT ’15

ALEX REHBERG ’16

Blogs Editor

Multimedia Editor

ELIZABETH SOWERS ’15

KELLY YANG ’15

Design Editor

News Photography Editor

CONNOR ARCHARD ’15

NOAH RANKIN ’16

Sports Photography Editor

City Editor

ANNIE BUI ’16

ANUSHKA MEHROTRA ’16

News Editor

News Editor

KAITLYN TIFFANY ’15

SEAN DOOLITTLE ’16

Arts & Entertainment Editor

Arts & Entertainment Editor

KATHLEEN BITTER ’15

KAY XIAO ’16

Science Editor

Dining Editor

CHARDAE VARLACK ’15

SYDNEY ALTSCHULER ’16

Associate Multimedia Editor

Assistant Sports Editor

EMILY BERMAN ’16

ANNA FASMAN ’16

Assistant Sports Editor

Assistant Sports Editor

NICOLE HAMILTON ‘16

MANU RATHORE ‘15

EMMA LICHTENSTEIN ‘16

KATHLEEN SHIM ‘15

Graphic Design Editor

Outreach Coordinator

Marketing Manager

Social Media Manager

LUISE YANG ‘15

CHRISTOPHER UHLER ‘15

Human Resources Manager

The Spot Manager

ARIELLE CRUZ ‘15

ALEXA DAVIS ‘16

Senior Editor

Senior Editor

WORKING ON TODAY’S SUN DESIGN DESKERS PHOTO NIGHT EDITOR

Dennis Fedorko ’17 Melody Li ’17 Michelle Feldman ’15

EDITORS IN TRAINING EDITOR IN CHIEF MANAGING EDITOR ASSOCIATE EDITOR ONLINE MANAGING EDITOR ASSISTANT DESIGN EDITOR ARTS EDITOR NEWS DESKERS ASSISTANT SPORTS EDITOR

Alex Rehberg ’16 Annie Bui ’16 Anushka Mehrotra ’16 Cristina Dan ’17 Samantha Briggs ’16 Troy Sherman ’18 Gabriella Lee ’16 Paulina Glass ’18 Joon Lee ’17

Editorial

Expanding Cornell’s Shared Governance

AFTER ENACTING LEGISLATION STUDENT ASSEMBLY representatives assert as being “the most important resolution” this year, students will soon be able to submit referenda to the governing body to distribute during annual S.A. elections. Under the new system, which was outlined in the resolution passed by the S.A. Thursday, a referendum that receives the majority of supportive votes from students casting their votes in an S.A. election will be sent to the Office of the President. Though we believe this system will afford Cornellians new ways to communicate with Cornell’s president, we are still concerned the system may be underutilized by a student body that has previously shown itself to be dispassionate towards Cornell’s shared governance system.

Under the new system, students who petition and receive at least three percent of the registered undergraduate student body’s signatures can submit a referendum to the S.A. representatives, who can choose to put it on the ballot for students to vote for or reject it by a simple majority. However, denials of referenda can be overturned if 10 percent of the student body petitions for the referenda in question, according to the resolution. By giving vetoing power to the greater Cornell community, the S.A. will allow students to have the opportunity to speak out against the body when controversial matters arise, such as when conversations regarding last year’s Resolution 72 — which called for the University to divest from proIsraeli companies — were shut down by the Assembly prematurely. The referendum process will ultimately give Cornellians additional opportunities to participate in student government and a voice for those who are not able to interact with administrators on a regular basis.

Despite this stride forward for the Assembly and students looking to more easily communicate with those in Day Hall, a population of students within the last year have questioned the legitimacy of the S.A., including those outraged by the tabling of Resolution 72 in April. After the takeover, many commented on the role of the Assembly, including President David Skorton, who defended the University’s shared governance system in a November column in The Sun. While we stand by the structure of Cornell’s shared governance system and the constructive dialogue it enables, the S.A. must ensure students are aware of the referendum process and promote elections so the student body participates in what can be a transformative process for Cornellians. On a campus that prides itself for its governing structure, we should have more than 30 percent of the undergraduate body participate in S.A. elections.

We encourage Cornellians across campus to engage in the campus’ shared governance system and laud the S.A. for their referenda process, which we believe, if executed and promoted correctly, has the potential to change how students interact with the Office of the President.

“Y

It’s Not You, It’s Me

A Call To Empathize With My Pain

ou’re a nigger.” Despite find- enough, was merely to fit in. But, in as ing yourself at a prestigious many ways as I became a standout, all I university such as Cornell, and ever seemed to do was be on the outside regardless of the fact that you’ve been literally standing out. After spending my doing your absolute best to speak perfect entire adolescence combating these inner English. Despite resisting the allure of struggles it seemed as if it all paid off tattoos, and regardless of the fact that when I landed myself admission into an you’ve been pulling your pants up and Ivy League institution, but my fight keeping your hood down as much as the didn’t end there.

Life at Cornell, despite mirroring the weather allowed. Despite continuing to be courteous to those around you, and lack of diversity in the country, treats me regardless of the fact that you’ve followed pretty well on a day-to-day basis. I’m surthe law to the best of your abilities, they rounded by some of the brightest and refuse to see anything past your appear- most liberal young minds of today. I find it easy to navigate various social crowds, ance.

This seemingly random tirade is often glad to proclaim my diverse group of friends. I’m brought about treated with by a recent arguby prorespect ment in my life Despite my successes, fessors and feel that ended with achievements and work comfortable myself being walking into any called a “nigger.” towards assimilating, I can’t classroom or I wasn’t called the N-word, it help but be reminded that, in party. At last, I finally begin to didn’t end with the eyes of many, it feel myself an A and it sure falling into a as hell didn’t feel doesn’t matter. rhythm; no endearing. There longer actively is no way to explain how it feels to be called the word trying to fit in, but simply fitting in. I in its rawest and angriest form. When guess life isn’t that different from an telling my friends about what happened arcade game and, just when you feel like I found myself faced with extreme diffi- you can go on forever and never look culty in getting them to feel the same back, you’re forced to realize that the last complex and burning emotions that I felt few years have simply been a high score. every time I thought or spoke about the Except, instead of villains waiting behind incident. I didn’t want to sit them down corners to eat you or looming cliffs hidfor a diatribe on the subject as not to ing to swallow you up, it’s simply a peer ostracize myself for being that “angry dying to remind you that no matter how black man” stereotype that we’ve all seen far you’ve come — you’re still a nigger.

My head quickly falls from the clouds in movies and television shows, so I decided to shut down rather than to and the insecurities come rushing back. explain myself further. However, I found Despite my successes, achievements and myself with an aching passion to explain work towards assimilating, I can’t help myself to those who are not in the posi- but be reminded that, in the eyes of tion to fully understand me. I finally many, it doesn’t matter. I’ve been told came to terms with the fact that it is for before by those older and wiser than me these reasons that I decided to become a that the poor can become rich and the Daily Sun columnist, and it’s about time unknown can become famous, but you will never lose your racial identity. Some to go to work.

From day one, I knew that I was dif- people will never be able to look past ferent. Growing up in a predominately how you look and instead focus on “the white area, it was plain to see that I was content of your character.” If this incione of few. Every show I watched and dent can happen at a place like Cornell, every book I read served as evidence that then I am forced to accept the reality that it wasn’t just where I lived that I was in not only is it happening elsewhere but the minority. The next battle came when most likely at a higher frequency. This is I started realizing that your race also the first column where I have no lesson seems to come with its own stereotypes. I to teach and no admonishment to hand soon found my friends calling me out — I simply would like all of you to “white” when I refused to stop reading seek to understand my struggles and to books, speak broken English and dress a emphasize with my pain. I know many of certain way. This infuriated me because you will wonder the benefits of caring it seemed as if acting like an educated about this plight and even fewer will black male was frowned upon, as others attempt to understand it, but, in an appeared to insinuate that people like me effort to make this campus a better place were naturally dumber and less articu- for all of us, hear my story: this is me, late. I dedicated myself to fighting this asking you. idea by excelling in school, writing and Deon Thomas is a senior in the School of speaking as well as I could, and refusing Industrial and Labor Relations. He may be to dress as many refer to as “ghetto.” My reached at dthomas@cornellsun.com. It’s Not Me, undying goal at the end of the day, sadly It’s You appears alternate Tuesdays this semester.

CORRECTIONS A Feb. 2 news story, “Kroch Library to Display 13th Amendment,” misspelled Prof. Gerard Aching’s, Africana studies, name.

A Feb. 2 news story, “Campus Visitors Utilize New Itinerary Tool,” incorrectly stated that Adam Palcich worked for the Office of the Vice President for University Communications. In fact, he does not work for the Vice President’s office, but for University Communications.

THE CORNELL DAILY SUN | Tuesday, February 3, 2015 9

OPINION

Web

Hebani Duggal |

of the day Comment Unnoticed, Teach Me How to Duggal

But Not Unknown

E

verybody notices an accent. It is perhaps one of the first things we notice about a person. An accent doesn’t have to be from a different country to stand out — to us Northeasterners, the twang of a Southern accent is just as foreign as the clipped tone of a British accent. We base our first impressions of a person on the way they talk, the pronunciation with which they express their ideas to us.

We stereotype — sometimes subconsciously, sometimes not — assuming a person takes on the identity of the region from where his or her accent hails. An Australian accent conjures images of open deserts and kangaroos, while a Canadian accent paints a picture of maple syrup and snow.

We notice an accent and, most times, we go so far as to judge a person by their accent.

What goes unnoticed, however, is the story behind an accent. We assume the accent with which a person speaks is the accent with which they have always spoken. Rarely ever do we ask ourselves if the Brit speaking in clipped tones is actually British. We don’t wonder if the Brit was perhaps born in another country and moved to Britain. We don’t ask if he adapted quickly or if he had always been surrounded by those short syllables. Most times, the accent matches the background. There are times, however, when there is an exception. A person’s background is a blend of cultures and countries, and the accent with which he or she speaks does

It is surprising how much of a person’s personality can be read through the side comments, the little gestures and short laughs. not represent the journey through which the person has travelled to arrive at that accent. I am one such exception.

I speak with the typical Northeastern American accent. I talk too quickly, stringing words along and leaving out syllables. “I” is “I,” never “ah.” Pajamas are always P.J.s, and the first (and last) time I ever heard “y’all” was on the phone with someone who called the wrong number. In conversation, I can easily be mistaken for someone that has been born and brought up in the New England area. I sound like a Connecticut native, but assuming I am one is beyond misleading. I was born in Mumbai, India. When I was three, my family and I moved to Singapore for a year and then on to Japan for the next three years. I celebrated my seventh birthday in our new house in America, singing happy birthday in the accent of a very confused English speaker. I’ve come a long way since then. I’ve learned to adapt to the quirks of the New England accent, and I’ve learned to pass of as a native English speaker.

As proud as I am that my American accent reflects my ability to adapt and learn, it saddens me to think that my accent is all that others notice. Often times — at info sessions and interviews for clubs on campus, summer internships and jobs — we tend to focus only on the image of the person in front of us, rather than actively listen to their story. As we go from member to member, eager to network and meet as many people as we can, we forget to take the time to listen to genuinely listen to the experiences, the advice and the opportunities others have had as students in the same position as us a few years ago. Who a person is as a human being, what they value as a part of their life and why they choose to present themselves a certain way is hidden more in why a person brings up certain stories than what the story itself says. It is surprising how much of a person’s personality can be read through the side comments, the little gestures and the short laughs they make in conversation. Indeed, the quality of never letting exceptions go unnoticed is what makes people create, discover and invent. And, in the end, isn't that what we’re in college for?

Hebani Duggal is a freshman in the College of Arts and Sciences. She can be reached at hduggal@cornellsun.com. Teach Me How to Duggal appears alternate Tuesdays this semester.

“Visibility is not only immensely impaired for drivers, but also for pedestrians with snow flying into eyes, glasses becoming wet and blurry, and snow hoods cutting out any peripheral vision. These details, although minute, add up.”

Josh Shapiro Re: “LETTER TO THE EDITOR: A Bus Driver’s Perspective,” Opinion, published February 2, 2015

David Fischer |

Fischy Business

Just Here So I Won’t Get Fined

saying nothing at all to the media. case of a man, whose job is to ram his week, a 56-page Under these conditions, Lynch his head repeatedly into other men slideshow detailing findings reported to the league-mandated for the entertainment of thousands from a public opinion sur- Super Bowl media day (several days and the accumulation of billions of vey conducted by a health and before the Big Game) and sat for dollars, who simply doesn’t want to medical research advocacy group his mandatory, league-minimum be bound by a vulturous governing published in March 2011 caught five minutes of reporter question- body’s efforts to make him speak my eye. Research America, a group ing, responding to all queries: “I’m when he does not want to. that describes itself as “the nation's just here so I won’t get fined.”

Furthermore, the simple fact that largest not-for-profit public educaEnough has been said about the the PFWA even exists with the mistion and advocacy alliance commit- disingenuousness of a tax-exempt sion statement to be the “official ted to making research to improve steward of a multi-billion dollar voice of pro football writers” seems health a higher national priority,” industry forcing a man to speak to ridiculous to me. Anyone who has conducted the survey to focus reporters whilst it does a poor job ever seen the oft-criticized televimostly on public opinion sur- of protecting the long-term health sion program, First Take, with rounding publicly-funded scientific of its players’ heads and its players’ Stephen A. Smith and Skip Bayless research. However, buried in the family members, so I’ll steer clear. knows that established sports writslideshow, on the 51st page lies an The reactions of the reporters ers lack no avenue for expression by alarming finding that recently attempting to elicit a meaningful the First Amendment and require caught traction on the Internet. response from Lynch are what I no one to advocate for them.

This survey found that, out of the want to focus on. While some Another recent example of the 1,000 registered voters surveyed, reporters displayed amused indul- self-seriousness of sports journalism only 34 percent could name a living gence with their questions, others lies with the purported sports scanscientist. Out of the 1,000 U.S. questioned Lynch repeatedly. One dal of the century: Deflategate. adults surveyed, 15 percent rattled asked three questions in succession, After the Patriot’s walloping of the off Stephen Hawking’s name, while all variations on the theme of “why Colts by a margin of 45-7 in the fellow Cornellian and my child- won’t you talk to us?” and another recent AFC Championship, news hood scientific spiritual guide Bill frustratedly tried to pry Lynch with came out that 11 of the 12 footballs Nye ’77 surprisingly came in at one a question about his foundation for used by the Patriots in the first half percent along with other luminaries kids. The answer to all modes of were deflated under league limits, like Jane Goodall, James Watson questioning? “I’m just here so I something that would apparently and Neil Degrasse Tyson. Nice job won’t get fined.” give them a competitive advantage. burying the lede, Research In response to Lynch’s media Sports journalists had a field day America. day, the Pro Football Writers of with this scandal, affixing the allThese are some pretty shocking America issued a strongly worded too-common suffix “-gate” and statistics — at least they shocked statement saying, “several of our tying it to a 2007 Patriots taping of me. And then I started to think long-standing and high-profile New York Jets play signals. I’m realabout how many living scientists I members were appalled by Mr. ly not in the position to judge could name offhand. Nye and Lynch’s conduct” and “we find the whether or not the Patriots deflated Hawking came to mind, these footballs, but I wouldn’t be able to but I am here to tell you who won the It’s the case of a man ... who doesn’t want pass judgment Nobel Prize for physics to be bound by a vulturous governing on whether this last year (Isamu Akasaki, transgression Hiroshi Amano and Shuji body’s efforts to make him speak stands among a Nakamura split it), let when he does not want to. sitting President alone that it was for the lying about coninvention of a “blue lightspiracy, intimidation and abusemitting diode (LED)” that’s been statement that by the league — es of power. It doesn’t.

The fact that this non-story has heralded as a pragmatic, energy ‘Players are required to participate efficient way to bring electric light and he participated’ — to be an survived two weeks of the news to developing parts of the world. I affront to our membership.” To me, cycle when we really should be seem to remember a few brief sto- it seems like the PFWA is blowing talking about imminent Greek ries written about this prize and the this entire scenario way out of pro- rejection of austerity measures discovery’s implications after it was portion. The use of the words (ok, I agree, that one is too borawarded, but a discovery would “affront” and “appalled” imply that ing) is simply beyond me. I undernever seize hold of American cul- Lynch has personally and egre- stand the importance of the enterture like two narratives leading up giously offended these “long-stand- tainment industry, but when only to last Sunday’s nail-biting finish of ing and high-profile members” 34 percent of Americans can name Super Bowl XLIX. I’m speaking of who, counterintuitively for self- a living scientist, that’s a problem. course of “Deflategate” (aka “Ball- described journalists, seem to be Though the awarding of Nobel Prizes will never become the ghazi”) and Marshawn Lynch’s fairly thin-skinned. refusal to speak to sports media.

One could argue that Lynch’s biggest television event of the year, Lynch, Seattle’s running back, refusal to respond infringes on I believe that there needs to be a played a key part in Seattle’s these journalists’ ability to establish concerted effort into improving almost-victory against the Patriots, a complete narrative. But Lynch’s how we report on things and what but the storyline that has followed case has, quite frankly, much lower we report on. Until then, we’ll be him throughout the latter half of stakes than other notable NFL sto- worried about who deflated 11 this season was his refusal to answer rylines from this year. It’s not the footballs instead of how to make questions posed to him by case of a man who assaulted his the world a better place. reporters, commonly responding then-fiance (complete with ensuing with one-word answers or non- likely league coverup), or another David Fischer is a senior in the College of Arts sequiturs. In November, the NFL of a man who beat his 4-year-old and Sciences. He can be reached at dfischer@cornellsun.com. Fischy Business actually fined Lynch $100,000 for child with a tree branch. It’s the appears alternate Tuesdays this semester.

T

10 THE CORNELL DAILY SUN | Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Los Angeles Times Daily Crossword Puzzle

Sun Sudoku

Edited by Rich Norris and Joyce Nichols Lewis

ACROSS 1 Pharmacy purchase 5 Figure (out), slangily 9 Early Yucatán settlers 14 German “a” 15 Irish New Age singer 16 Bite-the-bullet type 17 400 athletes?

19 “Star Trek” lieutenant 20 Trophy prized by actors 21 Watermelon eater’s discard 23 Austin-to-Baton Rouge direction 24 Flat hat with a pompom 26 40 polos?

28 Football club based in Lombardy 32 Many a casino visitor 33 Bank offering 34 Kelly of morning TV 37 Moral code 39 Texter’s “Horrors!”

40 4 tire inserts?

42 Squeeze (out) 43 Local news hr.

45 Mix 46 ESPN analyst Hershiser 47 Wife of Abraham 49 Chatty gathering 51 600 stand-ups?

54 Plea at sea, briefly 55 “Sadly ...”

56 Pouty expression 58 Repetitive musical piece 62 ACC team with a turtle mascot 64 1,500 thermometer units?

66 Gobbled up 67 Letter carrier’s sackful 68 Starbucks order 69 Sound from an angry dog 70 Sugar bowl invaders 71 Battle of Normandy town

DOWN 1 Geometric art style 2 Frees (of) 3 Like the word “waitress,” briefly 4 Gummy bear ingredient 5 Susan of “L.A. Law” 6 Small bills 7 Oven-safe brand 8 Stand in a painting class 9 East Lansing sch.

10 Nonreligious sort 11 Mall directory words 12 Bombing missions 13 Sings like Ella 18 Shrunken Asian sea 22 Broadband initials 25 Harry and __, “Home Alone” bad guys 27 Ground breakers 28 Plenty 29 Fesses up 30 Document sealed

by King John in 1215

31 Petty peeves 35 Salt (away) 36 “Not __ deal” 38 Boston NBAer 40 Islamic prayer leader 41 Notable periods 44 Thrive 46 In some respects 48 That guy 50 Five-time Wimbledon champ Bjorn

51 Goes out with 52 Pause punctuation 53 Khartoum’s land 57 Cut a line from, say 59 Well-kept 60 Computer giant 61 Norway’s most populous city 63 NBC comedy staple 65 Some Bronx trains

ANSWER TO PREVIOUS PUZZLE:

xwordeditor@aol.com

02/03/15

COMICS AND PUZZLES

Puzzle #9

SPITFIRE Fill in the empty cells, one number in each, so that each column, row, and region contains the numbers 1-9 exactly once.

Each number in the solution therefore occurs only once in each of the three “directions,” hence the “single numbers” implied by the puzzle’s name.

(Rules from wikipedia.org/wiki /Sudoku)

3

4

5

CLASSIFIED AD RATES

7

Ads are accepted at The Sun’s office at 139 W. State Street downtown, by phone or e-mail.

Deadline: 2:30 p.m. at The Sun’s office on the day preceding publication. Monday’s deadline: Friday, 2:30 p.m. at The Sun’s office.

8

9

Standard Rate: $3.40 per day for first 15

2 1

2

9

3

8

2

Commercial Rate: $5.20 per day for first 15 words, 33 cents per day per word thereafter. Five or more consecutive insertions, $5.00 per day for first 15 words, 31 cents per day per word thereafter.

6

The Sun is responsible for only one day makegood on ads.

9 9

8

3 7

2

5 4

words, 32 cents per day per word thereafter.

Five or more consecutive insertions, $3.15 per day for first 15 words, 30 cents per day per word thereafter.

273-3606

6

classifieds@cornelldailysun.com

8

I Am Going to Be Small

7 C

by Jeffrey Brown

3 N OTICES ****************************

BIOLOGY & SOCIETY SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY STUDIES INFORMATIONAL MEETING Important meeting for students Interested in the Biology & Society or Science & Technology Studies majors!

Wednesday, FEBRUARY 4, 2015 12:30 p.m., 374 Rockefeller Hall Questions: Call 255-6047 or stop by 306 Rockefeller or email sms252@cornell.edu Website: http://www.sts.cornell.edu ****************************

17 H ELP WANTED Web Site Designer/Developer Wanted.

Must know forms or smart forms to Adobe Echosign or Docusign.

Ongoing projects. Please email to lcarilli@classactionsettlementhouse.com

By C.C. Burnikel ©2015 Tribune Content Agency, LLC

Classic Doonesbury (1981)

02/03/15

23 PARKING

by Garry Trudeau

Parking Collegetown College Ave., Dryden Rd., Linden Ave., Cook St. 607-330-2442, 607-273-9414

PARKING College Avenue Dryden Road

Available NOW

607-272-3000 www.ithacarenting.com

Mr. Gnu

Parking Collegetown Available Now 607-277-1234

by Travis Dandro ’15 Spring Parking Oak Ave Odd/Even got you? Great price up from CTB avail Spring Semester

607-256-3778 nick@lambrourealestate.com

26 A PARTMENT FOR R ENT

Mr. Gnu

by Travis Dandro

Now Renting for 2015-2016 1-6 Bedroom Apartments Collegetown and Near Vicinity Call Today Certified Properties 273-1669 certifiedpropertiesinc.com Campus Hill Apts.

709 Stewart Ave. We are not near the campus, We are ON THE CAMPUS, The only privately owned apartment complex literally on Cornell University's campus.We have three 1 bedrooms, two 2 bedrooms, one 3 bedroom, and three 4 bedrooms LEFT! 1. Walk to Campus in minutes 2. Most have wood burning fireplaces 3. Balconies 4. Two on site Laundry rooms 5. Free high-speed roadrunner internet 6. Free Standard Cable (70 channels) 7. On site parking 8. Furnished with TVs

www.kimballrentals.com 257-0313

THE CORNELL DAILY SUN | Tuesday, February 3, 2015 11

SPORTS

26 A PARTMENT FOR R ENT

26 A PARTMENT FOR R ENT RIGHT BY CORNELL 1, 2, 3 & 4 BR APTS. BEST PRICES 607-592-7694

PJ APARTMENTS COLLEGETOWN STUDIOS TO 18 BEDROOM MANSION 607-229-5116 WWW.PJAPTS.COM PJAPARTMENTS@GMAIL.COM MANY NEW BEAUTIFUL RENOVATIONS COMPLETED. TOURS AVAILABLE M-F, NOON-6PM OR BY APPOINTMENT. AVAILABLE FOR 2015-2016

Houses, Apts, Parking 1 to 3 Bedroom Collegetown - College Ave, Linden Ave, Dryden Rd, Bryant Ave, Cook St 607-330-2442 Office at 307 College Ave. info@urbanithaca.com www.urbanithaca.com

Collegetown Terrace Apartments 1 and 2 Bedroom / 2 Bath Apartments Available now and for Spring Semester!

2 bedroom apartments also available to share.

Heat, hot water and high speed wireless internet included.

Stackable washer and dryer in apartments.

Novarr-Mackesey Property Management www.collegetownterraceithaca.com office@ithacastudentapartments.com Free State of the Art Fitness Center Covered parking available for a fee.

607.277.1234

NOW renting.

Apartments without hassle.

Hudson Heights Apartments are located on South Hill, 8 minutes from Cornell.

Prices start at $680/month.

Rent includes: all utilities, parking, garbage and recycling. There are two laundry facilities on the premises and the bus route is on the block.

Contact ILS for an appointment: 607-280-7660 or email renting@ithacaLS.com.

110 Heights Court 3 bedroom furnished apts. in historic mansion on North Campus just 1 block from Thurston Ave. and walking distance to Suspension Bridge.

Spacious living areas with high ceilings and balconies. Gas heat, Standard Cable, High Speed Modem Internet, Water and Dumpster all included.

Coin-op washer/dryer on premises. $675/person. Some 3 bedrooms can accommodate 4 people @$550/person.

Call 257-0313 for showings.

North Campus Apartments Near your Sorority/Fraternity. Stay close! 3,4 and 5 bedrooms available with free roadrunner internet, cable, water, furniture and TV. Some apartments have 2 baths, dishwashers and fireplaces.

Call or email for a viewing. Checkout 110 Heights court and Westbourne Apts. at www.kimballrentals.com Kimball Real Estate 257-0313

Newly Renovated Apartments 1, 2 & 4 Bedroom 100 Ft. from main gates of Cornell Starting at $595 includes all utilities.

592-9482

2015-2016 WESTBOURNE APARTMENTS QUALITY, AFFORDABLE, CONVENIENT! 1–4 Bedroom Apartments & Houses In Collegetown PARKING, LAUNDRY, UTILITIES! (607) 273-7368 www.IthacaApartmentRental.com

Apartments, Houses, Parking Central Collegetown Superb Panoramic Views Modern Elevator Buildings Collegetown Plaza: Fitness Room, fantastic Cayuga Lake Views Studio, 1, 2, 5, 6 BRs Parking Collegetown Center: Concierge Service, quiet building, Fitness Room Studio, 1, 2 BRs Parking Collegetown Court: Super convenient, exceptional value Studio, 1 BRs Other Collegetown Locations: Dryden Road, Eddy Street, Buffalo Street: 3 BRs, Rooms with kitchen privileges Parking Rent Smart. Live Well.

607-272-3000 Visit our office at: 119 Dryden Road

Ithaca Renting Company www.ithacarenting.com

312 College Ave Collegetown’s Best Address Beautifully Furnished Studio, 1 Bedroom, 2 Bedroom & 3 Bedroom units.

Office Open M-F 9-9; Sat 10-5; Sun 11-4.

273-9777 or 312collegeave.com

We are located within a beautiful 10 minute walk to campus in the historical district of Cornell Heights and are managed by concerned Cornelians with 42 yrs. experience in caring for the residential needs of Ithacans. Our apts. have all the features you would expect in the very best area residences. Some of the units have fireplaces and two bathrooms. We provide free Roadrunner internet and standard cable service. Resident parking available.

RATES BEGIN AT $575-$700/person plus electric 257-0313 www.kimballrentals.com

227 LINDEN AVENUE 2&3 BR LUXURY APTS ********** COLLEGE AVENUE 1&2 BEDROOMS ********** 607-272-3389 BEFORE 7PM www.avramisrentals@aol.com

27 H OUSE FOR R ENT COLLEGETOWN OAK AVE. 3 BEDROOMS Oak kitchen.

Gas fireplaces.

New carpet.

Laundry & parking.

315-254-1717

RENT REDUCED!!

118 Cook St 12 BR House 607-277-1234 www.ithacastudentapartments.com

Carroll Throws Away Title SHATZMAN

idea of being ultra-conscious with the clock (basically, not wanting Tom Brady to have enough time to engineer a game-tying/winning drive).

I’m a St. Louis Rams fan and I don’t like the With Belichick deciding not to use a timeout, the Seahawks at all, but the decision to throw the ball on clock simply was not a factor. The Seahawks had second down from the one-yard line made me phys- plenty of time to run three plays and Belichick had ically sick. How do you throw the football over the given Seattle a gift by letting the clock run. If the middle to a guy with 25 career receptions in Ricardo Seahawks scored a touchdown, they would have won Lockett with Marshawn “Beast Mode” Lynch and the Super Bowl. The clock explanation is ludicrous. the chance to personally deny Tom Brady a Super Score a touchdown. If Tom Brady drives down the Bowl? Speechless. field in 25 seconds and ties the game, so be it. Trust Let’s look at the worst-case scenario — save for a your defense, you know, the defense ranked No. 1 in fumble — if Seattle runs the ball with Lynch. Maybe the NFL in like every category. That defense that has he gets stuffed for a loss of two yards and it’s third led you to two Super Bowls. Yes, that defense. down and goal from the 3Carroll also said that passing on secyard line with plenty of time ond down was essentially to “waste a left for two plays. That is It’s nice of Carroll to take play”. What?! Waste a play? Waste one worst-case. Lynch likely gets responsibility for the play of the three precious chances you have the one-yard, though, and call... but this was not to win the Super Bowl by calling a danthe Seahawks win the Super gerous play for an unproven receiver? just another game.

Bowl.

It’s as if the Seattle coaches placed no The most infuriating part value in second down at all. of the call was Seattle’s postMalcolm Butler deserves all of the game explanation. Head credit for making a tremendous play. If coach Pete Carroll said, rather confidently, that the he didn’t intercept the pass — say he just knocked it Seahawks did not have a good matchup to run down — the Seahawks would have had two more against on second down. The Patriots had their goal- chances to score and the idiotic play call may be forline package in versus Seattle’s three-wide receiver gotten. Butler made a legendary play. Russell set.

Wilson’s throw wasn’t perfect either.

Sure, but why did the Seahawks have three Carroll and Bevell are veteran coaches more than receivers in the game in the first place? Why didn’t twice the age of some of their players. A “mistake” of they too have their goal-line guys in? According to that magnitude by a coach, who needed just one yard the Harvard Sports Analysis Collective, the Patriots to win back-to-back titles and make history, is simwere last in the NFL at defending power rushing ply inexcusable. It’s nice of Carroll to take responsi(less than two yards), allowing the opponent to gain bility for the play call — to calmly take blame for the the necessary yardage 81 percent of the time. Keep in loss — but this was not just another game, Coach. mind that the Seahawks are a team built on power- This was the Super Bowl. And I don’t know how the rushing with the best power rusher in the league in players will be able to get over this “mistake.”

Lynch.

Other explanations from Carroll and Seahawks Ben Shatzman can be reached at offensive coordinator Darren Bevell included the bshatzman@cornellsun.com.

Continued from page 12

Saulnier’s Return Young Forwards Sparks Red Sweep Stand Out in Ivy W. HOCKEY

Continued from page 12

League Games

Although the Engineers chipped into Cornell’s lead early in the second period on a goal by forward Ali Svoboda, Cornell retaliated with three more goals in the second period to take the lead by a 6-1 tally.

Freshman wing Morgan McKim collected her first collegiate goal in the third period when she whipped a backhander into the net.

Despite the four-point weekend, Jenner said the team needs to continue to work hard for these last three weeks of regular season to gain a home-ice advantage during the playoffs.

“I think we definitely feel confident in our play this weekend, but we know it will get tougher from here on out,” Jenner said. “It’s going to be a tight race for both the Ivy [League] title and the ECAC regular season. We want to do all we can in this last stretch to secure home ice for the playoffs and put ourselves in a good position.”

As the Red prepares to face Colgate at home on Tuesday, Jenner expects the game to be physical and intense because there is a lot on the line.

“They play a tough, physical game and we need to be ready to compete for all 60 minutes,” Jenner said. “It’s a must-win [game] if we want to guarantee ourselves home ice [throughout the postseason].”

“We couldn’t really get in a consistent offensive rhythm which is a credit to their defense,” Aston said.

The teams went back and forth during the duration of the entire game. Both defenses challenged each other to rebound and convert on their possessions. With 1:26 left in the second half, senior forward Sarah Poland netted a layup under pressure cutting the Yale lead to 54-50.

Yale responded with a six-point streak.

Although, LeDuc hit a 3-pointer for the Red with less than a minute to play, the Bulldogs held on to the lead to finish off the Red. “It was a tough loss to swallow,” Aston said.

“Going into the next week of [Ivy League games], [women’s basketball head coach Dayna Smith] really challenged our mental toughness on executing the little things.”

Danielle Letourneau can be reached at dletourneau@cornellsun.com.

Olivia Mattyasovszky can be reached at omattyasovszky@cornellsun.com.

Sophomores Aston and Marshall post double-doubles on weekend BASKETBALL

Continued from page 12

www.cornellsun.com

The Corne¬ Daily Sun

Sports

TUESDAY FEBRUARY 3, 2015

12

WOMEN’S HOCKEY

Icers SweepWeekend Games Against Union,RPI

Fulton, Jenner, Saulnier combine for eight goals against Dutchmen, Engineers as Red’s ranking rises

By DANIELLE LETOURNEAU

Saulnier ripped a wrister top shelf with 6:39 left in the first period for Cornell’s first goal. Just four minutes later, Fulton doubled Lynah Rink felt electric when Cornell Cornell’s lead with a goal of her own. Union, (12-7-3, 10-3-2 ECAC) beat up on Union however, quickly retaliated 30 seconds later (4-19-4, 1-13-1 ECAC) and Rensselaer to make the score 2-1.

Polytechnic Institute (5-19-4, 3-12-1 Just a minute into the second period, ECAC) in two Jenner blasted the puck into the high-scoring net from the left circle for her first games this weekUNION @ CORNELL goal of the game. At the 15:53 end. The Red beat mark, the Red squashed the 2 8 the Dutchmen Dutchmen’s defense, scoring four 1ST 2ND 3RD FINAL goals in four minutes to take a 7and the Game: 0 1 2 1 Engineers, 8-2, Union 1 lead. Each team scored a goal in 5 1 8 and, 7-1, respec- Cornell 2 the final period for the 8-2 final tively. score.

Cornell and Fulton said she believes the Union played the matchups this weekend proved RPI @ CORNELL “Do It For more successful because the team Daron” game on was back to full strength. This, 1 7 Friday afternoon 1ST 2ND 3RD FINAL subsequently, improved the raising money for Game: team’s accuracy in all facets of the 1 0 1 RPI 0 mental health ini- Cornell 3 game, Jenner said.

3 1 7 The tiatives.

“We had a short bench in the matchup started past few games, some players with a touching ceremonial puck drop by were out with injury and our team caught a DIFD co-founder Stephanie Richardson. bit of the flu,” Fulton said. “I think focusing The Red rolled up its sleeves and got on the small things helped to regain focus. straight to business once the puck dropped. When you play some of the best teams in Senior forwards Brianne Jenner, Emily the league and NCAA, the smallest mistakes Fulton and Jillian Saulnier, who returned to during the game can cost you.” the Red after missing the previous weeks’ Jenner said she was pleased with the games, played a hand in six of Cornell’s eight team’s ability to create and take advantage of goals. offensive opportunities.

Sun Staff Writer

MICHELLE FELDMAN / SENIOR EDITOR

Canadian captain | Senior forward Jillian Saulnier, who returned to the Red after missing games against Brown, Dartmouth and Harvard, currently ranks third on the team in points.

“I thought we were great at possessing the puck this weekend, making the other teams play in their own zone a lot,” Jenner said. “We wore down their D and we were able to capitalize.

The Red dominated RPI Saturday afternoon en route to its 7-1 victory. This win tied Cornell with Clarkson and St. Lawrence for third-place in the ECAC with 22 points.

Cornell jump-started the game with two goals in the opening four minutes.

Saulnier picked up a rebound and poked the puck into the net to score her eighth goal of the season 2:21 into the period.

Jenner then scored an amazing shorthanded goal after faking out RPI’s sophomore defender Hannah Behounek.

Sophomore defenseman Sydney Smith tallied up a third goal for Cornell, cap the first period.

See W. HOCKEY page 11

Seattle Mistake Marshall Shines,Red SplitsWeekend Was Inexcusable O WOMEN’S BASKETBALL

By OLIVIA MATTYASOVSZKY

Sun Staff Writer

n Sunday night, the Seahawks’ found themselves in a position similar to that of the Packers just two week earlier: simple execution, in this case, gaining one yard over the course of three downs, would clinch the game. After Kearse’s Oscar-worthy performance as David Tyree in Heartbreak in New England, Marshawn Lynch rushed for four

Ben Shatzman Calling the Shatz yards before being stopped at the Patriots’ 1-yard line.

With the Seahawks facing second down, the clock was running, but Bill Belichick curiously decided not to call a timeout.

Unless Bill Belichick is an oracle, by failing to use his timeout, he seemingly handed the Seahawks the game. With 26 seconds left, the Seahawks snapped the ball in shotgun formation, and, for some godforsaken reason that will never make any fraction of sense, decided to throw the football.

Patriots cornerback Malcolm Butler intercepted said football. The Patriots win the Super Bowl.

See SHATZMAN page 11

This weekend wasn’t successful for every team from New England. The Cornell women’s basketball (12-6, 3-1 Ivy League) traveled to Providence, Rhode Island on Friday to play Brown University (7-11, 1-3 Ivy League) and handed them a beating, 65-52.

In the last 10 minutes of the first half, Brown and Cornell both turned on, trading baskets up until halftime. In the final seconds of the first half, junior Maddie Campbell had two layups, leaving the Red with a 31-26 lead.

In the second half, Cornell held on to a relatively comfortable cushion.

Although the Bears shrunk the Red lead to just six points with five minutes left to play, sophomore guard Taylor DePalma squashed Brown’s hope for a run when she sank a shot from beyond the 3-point arc. The Red held onto its lead for the rest of the game, closing the contest at 65-52.

“We came out a little slow, but we were able to really get our defense going which translated into solid offense,” said sophomore

guard Nicholle Aston. “We read traps well for the most part and were able to find the open man.”

Aston and Nia Marshall each posted double-doubles, scoring 18 and 14 points respectively, with each grabbing 10 rebounds apiece.

The Red’s strong presence in the paint helped them hold the Bears to just 27.9 percent from the field.

Senior captain Christine Kline and sophomore guards Megan LeDuc and Kerri Moran dominated up top. LeDuc and Moran both posted double digits, 11 and 10 points, respectively. Kline grabbed an impressive six rebounds from outside of the paint.

Her numbers contributed to the Red besting the Bears in rebounds, 47-35.

Going into the contest, the Red was focused on keeping the intensity high.

“We needed to work on playing a full 40 minutes and not letting up, even when we have a lead,” Marshall said.

The Red’s winning streak concluded when it traveled to Yale (10-8, 4-0 Ivy League) for its fourth Ivy League matchup Cornell dropped the Sunday

CONNOR ARCHARD / SUN SPORTS PHOTOGRAPHY EDITOR

Captain dimes | Senior guard and captain Christine Kline leads the Red in assists this season with 3.6 per game. matchup, 60-53.

Marshall led the squad with 20 points and 11 rebounds. Moran and Aston also added 10 and seven points apiece. Despite the

team’s 41.7 shooting percentage, the Red could not overtake the Bulldogs.

“We couldn’t really get in See BASKETBALL page 11