JCHS Journal — Summer 2015
11
Building the Faith and Preserving the Neighborhood:
The Conflict in the Truman Neighborhood This article was written in 1985 and is published as originally written. A coda has been added updating developments over the intervening three decades. By Brent Schondelmeyer
T
he New York Times journalist wrote to his frail father-inlaw in 1971 in a matter-of-fact fashion asking for a decision on a matter that first had been broached seven years earlier. He politely referred to his in-law as “Grandpa,” though to the world at large he was better known as Harry Truman – the Man from Independence. Son-in-law Clifton Daniel, at the urging of National Park Service officials, wrote to Truman at his Independence home seeking his personal approval for the creation of a National Historic Landmark District that would include the quiet residential neighborhood around the former president’s home at 219 N. Delaware. “The Park Service has the authority to register the Delaware Street area without approval of anyone,” Daniel wrote his father-in-law, “but it does not wish to do so without your approval. It is that approval that (the Park Service) now seeks.” Truman, in earlier years, had been less than enthusiastic about the idea. In 1965 the former president informed the then-Secretary of the Interior: “I must say to you, that in the past I have been reluctant to
An elderly Harry Truman walking south on Delaware St. towards his home at 219 N. Delaware in Independence. Date and photographer unknown.
contribute to any effort designed to commemorate my Presidency.” But Truman, who had been an occupant in his wife’s Delaware Street home for more than 50 years, responded to his son-inlaw’s urging by giving his personal consent to the creation of the federally-designated Harry S. Truman National Historic Landmark District. The 12-block area was formally established in November 1971. By 1984, in the midst of community and centennial celebration of Truman’s birth, the quiet character of the Independence neighborhood had been transformed into a pitched political fight that extended far beyond the district boundaries and the 115,000 residents of Truman’s hometown.
The dispute was a direct result of the plans of the First Baptist Church in Independence – located a half-block east of the presidential home – to add a $1.5 million 1,100 seat auditorium that would necessitate the demolition of church-owned structures in the Truman neighborhood.
A
s the result of neighborhood opposition, court suits, aggressive newspaper coverage, and editorial opposition, the church’s expansion plans become the source of continuing controversy and something of a cause célèbre to historic preservationists throughout the country. The dispute covered a range of democratic ideas and values that resulted in a sharp and strident conflict: religious freedom, prop-