6 minute read
Is FXCM An ECN Broker? or Market Market? Review broker?
Is FXCM an ECN Broker or a Market Maker? Full Broker Review
Introduction
Choosing the right broker is crucial for any trader, whether beginner or experienced. One of the most debated aspects of FXCM is whether it operates as an ECN broker or a market maker. Understanding the difference between these two types of brokers can significantly impact your trading strategy and overall profitability. In this in-depth FXCM review, we will analyze its brokerage model, trading conditions, fees, regulation, and customer service to determine whether FXCM is an ECN broker or a market maker.
Top 10 BEST Forex Brokers
1️⃣ Exness: Open Account | Go to broker
2️⃣ JustMarkets: Open Account | Go to broker
3️⃣ XM: Open Account | Go to broker
4️⃣Pepperstone: Go to broker
5️⃣Avatrade: Open Account | Go to broker
6️⃣FpMarkets: Open Account | Go to broker
7️⃣XTB: Go to Website
8️⃣FBS: Go to Website
9️⃣Amarkets: Go to Website
What is FXCM? Overview of the Broker
FXCM (Forex Capital Markets) is one of the most well-known online forex and CFD brokers. Established in 1999, FXCM has been in the trading industry for over two decades, providing services to traders globally. The company is headquartered in London and regulated by top-tier authorities such as the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), and CySEC.
FXCM offers a wide range of trading instruments, including:
Forex pairs
Indices
Commodities
Cryptocurrencies
Stocks
Key Features of FXCM
✔ Regulated by multiple financial authorities✔ Offers multiple trading platforms, including MetaTrader 4, Trading Station, and NinjaTrader✔ Competitive spreads and leverage✔ Supports algorithmic and automated trading✔ Provides educational resources for traders
What is an ECN Broker?
Before we determine whether FXCM is an ECN broker or a market maker, let’s define what an ECN broker is.
An ECN (Electronic Communication Network) broker connects traders directly to liquidity providers, such as banks and financial institutions, without intermediaries. This means that traders benefit from:✅ Tighter spreads due to real market pricing✅ No dealing desk (NDD) execution, reducing conflicts of interest✅ Faster order execution with minimal slippage✅ Access to deep liquidity, enhancing trade transparency
ECN brokers typically charge a commission per trade rather than widening the spreads, allowing traders to access raw market prices.
What is a Market Maker?
A market maker operates differently from an ECN broker. Instead of connecting traders to external liquidity providers, the broker itself creates a market for its clients. This means:❌ The broker acts as the counterparty to your trades❌ Trades are executed internally rather than in the interbank market❌ There may be a conflict of interest if the broker profits from client losses
Market makers offer fixed spreads and do not charge commissions, making them attractive for beginner traders. However, the potential for conflict of interest is a significant downside for experienced traders who prefer transparent market conditions.
Is FXCM an ECN Broker or a Market Maker?
FXCM’s Business Model
FXCM operates under a hybrid model, which means it provides both ECN (No Dealing Desk - NDD) and Market Maker execution depending on the account type.
1. No Dealing Desk (NDD) Execution
FXCM offers No Dealing Desk (NDD) trading for standard forex accounts. Under this model:✅ Orders are sent directly to liquidity providers✅ There is no conflict of interest✅ Spreads are variable, starting from 0.2 pips✅ A commission is charged per trade
This model is closest to an ECN structure, as traders interact with real market prices without dealer intervention.
2. Market Maker Execution
For smaller retail accounts or during times of low liquidity, FXCM may act as a market maker. In this case:❌ The broker executes orders internally❌ Spreads may be slightly wider❌ No commission is charged
This means FXCM operates under a hybrid model, providing both ECN and Market Maker services based on market conditions and account type.
Trading Conditions and Fees
Spreads and Commissions
FXCM offers competitive spreads, which vary depending on the account type and market conditions. Here’s a breakdown:
Trading ModelSpread TypeTypical EUR/USD SpreadCommissionECN (NDD)Variable0.2 – 1.5 pipsYes (from $3 per lot)Market MakerFixed1.2 – 2.5 pipsNo
Leverage
FXCM provides leverage up to 1:400, depending on the trader’s region and regulatory restrictions. European traders under FCA regulation can access up to 1:30 leverage due to ESMA restrictions.
Minimum Deposit
The minimum deposit at FXCM starts from $50, making it accessible for beginners.
Trading Platforms
FXCM supports a range of trading platforms, including:✔ MetaTrader 4 (MT4) – The most popular forex trading platform✔ Trading Station – FXCM’s proprietary platform✔ NinjaTrader – Ideal for futures and algorithmic trading✔ ZuluTrade – Supports social trading
Regulation and Security
FXCM is a well-regulated broker, ensuring high levels of security and transparency. It is licensed by:
FCA (UK) – License No. 217689
ASIC (Australia) – License No. 309763
CySEC (Cyprus) – License No. 392/20
Client funds are held in segregated accounts, ensuring that they remain protected even if FXCM faces financial difficulties.
Pros and Cons of Trading with FXCM
Pros
✔ Offers both ECN (No Dealing Desk) and Market Maker execution✔ Regulated by top-tier financial authorities (FCA, ASIC, CySEC)✔ Supports multiple trading platforms, including MT4 and NinjaTrader✔ Provides free educational resources and trading tools✔ Competitive spreads and commissions
Cons
❌ Hybrid model may confuse traders who prefer a fully ECN broker❌ Market Maker execution may lead to wider spreads during low liquidity periods❌ Limited cryptocurrency offerings
Final Verdict: Is FXCM an ECN Broker or a Market Maker?
FXCM operates under a hybrid model, offering both ECN (No Dealing Desk) and Market Maker execution. If you prefer direct market access with variable spreads, FXCM’s No Dealing Desk (NDD) execution is ideal. However, if you are a beginner looking for fixed spreads without commissions, FXCM’s Market Maker model may be suitable.
Who Should Trade with FXCM?
✅ Scalpers and day traders who need fast execution and low spreads should choose the NDD model✅ Beginners who prefer stability and no commissions may opt for the Market Maker model✅ Algorithmic traders benefit from FXCM’s support for multiple platforms
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is FXCM a true ECN broker?👉 FXCM offers No Dealing Desk (NDD) execution, similar to an ECN broker, but also provides market maker execution in some cases.
2. What is the minimum deposit for FXCM?👉 The minimum deposit is $50, making it accessible for all traders.
3. Does FXCM charge commissions?👉 Yes, commissions apply to ECN accounts, but Market Maker accounts do not have commission charges.
4. Is FXCM regulated?👉 Yes, FXCM is regulated by FCA (UK), ASIC (Australia), and CySEC (Cyprus).
Conclusion
FXCM is a reliable and well-regulated broker that operates under a hybrid model, offering both ECN and Market Maker execution. It is ideal for traders seeking low spreads, multiple platforms, and secure trading conditions. If you prefer direct access to liquidity providers, choose FXCM’s No Dealing Desk (NDD) account. However, if you want fixed spreads with no commissions, FXCM’s Market Maker model is also available.
