7 minute read
Is Deriv An ECN Broker? or Market Market? Review broker?
Is Deriv An ECN Broker or Market Maker? A Comprehensive Broker Review
In the world of online trading, choosing the right broker is crucial for any trader's success. With numerous platforms available, traders often seek brokers that offer competitive spreads, fast execution, and a transparent trading environment. One of the most popular brokers in the industry today is Deriv, but is it an ECN broker or a market maker? This article delves deep into Deriv's operations to answer that question, providing a comprehensive review of its features, benefits, and drawbacks.
Top 10 BEST Forex Brokers
1️⃣ Exness: Open Account | Go to broker
2️⃣ JustMarkets: Open Account | Go to broker
3️⃣ XM: Open Account | Go to broker
4️⃣Pepperstone: Go to broker
5️⃣Avatrade: Open Account | Go to broker
6️⃣FpMarkets: Open Account | Go to broker
7️⃣XTB: Go to Website
8️⃣FBS: Go to Website
9️⃣Amarkets: Go to Website
What is an ECN Broker?
Before analyzing whether Deriv is an ECN broker, it is essential to understand what an ECN (Electronic Communication Network) broker is. ECN brokers operate by directly connecting their clients to the liquidity providers and the market. This means that all orders, whether buy or sell, are matched with other market participants' orders. ECN brokers do not interfere with trade execution, and they do not act as a counterparty to their clients’ trades.
Key Characteristics of an ECN Broker:
Direct Market Access: ECN brokers provide direct access to the interbank market, allowing traders to interact with multiple liquidity providers.
Tighter Spreads: Because ECN brokers connect clients to the market, they typically offer tighter spreads.
No Dealing Desk (NDD): Trades are executed automatically without manual intervention.
Transparency: ECN brokers often provide full transparency regarding pricing and execution.
ECN brokers are favored by many professional traders due to their transparency, lower latency, and absence of conflicts of interest. However, they might charge commissions on trades and require higher minimum deposits.
What is a Market Maker Broker?
A market maker broker, on the other hand, is a type of broker that creates a market for traders by acting as the counterparty to the trades. This means that when you place a trade with a market maker broker, the broker may take the other side of your trade, effectively "making" the market. Market makers typically offer wider spreads compared to ECN brokers but might not charge commissions on trades.
Key Characteristics of a Market Maker Broker:
Wider Spreads: Due to acting as the counterparty, market makers tend to offer wider spreads.
Dealing Desk (DD): Market makers often employ a dealing desk to facilitate trade execution.
No Direct Market Access: Unlike ECN brokers, market makers do not connect clients to the interbank market.
Profit from Client Losses: Since they take the other side of trades, market makers may profit if their clients lose.
While market makers are often suitable for beginner traders due to their user-friendly platforms and lack of commissions, they can present a conflict of interest, as their profits may depend on clients losing trades.
Is Deriv an ECN Broker?
Now that we understand the fundamental differences between ECN brokers and market makers, the question remains: Is Deriv an ECN broker or a market maker? To determine this, let's explore how Deriv operates.
Deriv's Trading Model: Hybrid Approach
Deriv employs a hybrid trading model that combines elements of both ECN and market maker models. While it does not strictly follow the ECN model, it does offer certain ECN-like features that aim to enhance the trader's experience.
Multiple Asset Classes: Deriv provides a wide variety of financial instruments for trading, including Forex, stocks, commodities, and synthetic indices. This wide range of assets suggests that Deriv has access to liquidity providers, similar to an ECN broker.
No Dealing Desk Execution: Deriv claims to offer No Dealing Desk (NDD) execution, meaning that orders are processed automatically without manual intervention. This feature is typical of ECN brokers, as it avoids the potential for the broker to take the opposite side of a trade.
Tight Spreads on Some Accounts: Deriv offers tighter spreads on certain accounts, which is a characteristic of ECN brokers. However, these spreads are still wider than what would be expected from a pure ECN broker, suggesting that the broker may rely on market-making aspects.
Does Deriv Use Liquidity Providers?
Yes, Deriv sources liquidity from a range of providers, including large banks, financial institutions, and other major liquidity sources. This is a key feature of the ECN model, as liquidity providers help ensure that the broker can offer competitive pricing to its clients.
However, Deriv also operates a market maker model for certain assets and under certain conditions. For example, the broker might provide liquidity for synthetic indices, where it can act as the counterparty to client trades. This is typical of market maker brokers, who can create their own markets for less liquid instruments.
Execution Speed and Slippage
One of the hallmark features of ECN brokers is fast execution and minimal slippage. Deriv offers fast execution speeds on some accounts, but clients may experience slippage on highly volatile assets. The execution speed and potential slippage depend on the liquidity of the asset being traded, the type of account, and market conditions at the time of execution.
Is Deriv a Market Maker Broker?
Yes, Deriv also operates as a market maker for certain financial instruments, particularly its synthetic indices. As a market maker, Deriv can take the opposite side of a client's trade, which may present a potential conflict of interest. However, the broker is transparent about this aspect of its operations and aims to provide a fair trading environment.
Market Maker Features of Deriv:
Synthetic Indices Trading: Deriv offers synthetic indices like the Volatility Index (VIX), which are created and maintained by the broker itself. These indices are typically not traded in the interbank market, meaning that Deriv acts as the counterparty for trades.
Wider Spreads: When trading synthetic indices, traders may encounter wider spreads, typical of market maker brokers.
Potential for Conflict of Interest: Since Deriv acts as the counterparty for synthetic index trades, it could profit from a trader’s loss.
However, this model is suitable for traders looking for unique instruments like synthetic indices, as these markets are not available on traditional exchanges.
Pros and Cons of Trading with Deriv
To help you make an informed decision, let’s summarize the advantages and disadvantages of trading with Deriv.
Pros:
Wide Range of Instruments: Deriv offers a variety of assets, including Forex, stocks, commodities, and synthetic indices, making it a versatile broker.
Multiple Trading Platforms: Traders can use several platforms, including MetaTrader 5 (MT5) and Deriv’s proprietary web platform, for a customized experience.
No Dealing Desk Execution: For certain account types, Deriv offers NDD execution, which is favorable for traders who prefer a direct market approach.
Low Minimum Deposit: Deriv offers relatively low minimum deposit requirements, making it accessible for new traders.
Flexible Leverage Options: Deriv offers a range of leverage options, catering to both conservative and more aggressive traders.
Cons:
Wider Spreads on Market Maker Accounts: Traders who choose accounts where Deriv acts as a market maker may face wider spreads, which can reduce profitability.
Conflict of Interest: As a market maker for synthetic indices, Deriv may profit from its clients' losses, which may raise concerns for some traders.
Limited Access to Major Liquidity Pools: While Deriv provides liquidity for various assets, it does not offer direct access to all major liquidity providers for all markets, especially for more niche instruments.
Conclusion: Is Deriv an ECN Broker or Market Maker?
Deriv operates a hybrid model, combining elements of both ECN and market maker brokers. While it does not fully align with the traditional ECN model, it does offer No Dealing Desk execution and connects traders to liquidity providers for certain assets. However, for other products like synthetic indices, Deriv operates as a market maker, which can create a potential conflict of interest.
Ultimately, whether Deriv is the right broker for you depends on your trading preferences and the instruments you wish to trade. If you’re a trader looking for direct market access and tighter spreads, you may prefer ECN brokers. On the other hand, if you’re interested in synthetic indices or other unique products, Deriv’s market maker model might be appealing.
In conclusion, Deriv is a versatile broker that caters to various trader needs, and its hybrid model offers a balance between the benefits of both ECN and market maker approaches.
