7 minute read
Is IC Markets An ECN Broker? or Market Market? Review broker?
Is IC Markets An ECN Broker or Market Maker? Broker Review
When it comes to choosing a reliable forex broker, one of the most common questions traders ask is: "Is IC Markets an ECN broker or a Market Maker?" The distinction between these two types of brokers can significantly affect your trading experience. In this comprehensive review, we’ll dive deep into the characteristics of IC Markets, its trading environment, and how it compares to other brokers in the industry.
Top 10 BEST Forex Brokers
1️⃣ Exness: Open Account | Go to broker
2️⃣ JustMarkets: Open Account | Go to broker
3️⃣ XM: Open Account | Go to broker
4️⃣Pepperstone: Go to broker
5️⃣Avatrade: Open Account | Go to broker
6️⃣FpMarkets: Open Account | Go to broker
7️⃣XTB: Go to Website
8️⃣FBS: Go to Website
9️⃣Amarkets: Go to Website
IC Markets is known as one of the most prominent brokers in the forex and CFD trading space. Since its establishment in 2007, it has gained recognition for offering competitive spreads, fast execution, and a robust trading platform. But the big question remains: Does IC Markets operate as an ECN broker or a Market Maker? Let’s explore this in detail.
What Is an ECN Broker?
To understand IC Markets' model, we need to first understand the key features of an ECN (Electronic Communication Network) broker. An ECN broker connects traders directly with liquidity providers (like banks and other financial institutions) through an electronic network. This allows traders to access the real market prices, and the broker typically does not interfere in the pricing process.
Key Features of ECN Brokers:
Direct Market Access: With an ECN broker, orders are routed directly to liquidity providers without any intervention or manipulation.
Low Spreads: ECN brokers typically offer tighter spreads because they aggregate liquidity from multiple sources.
No Dealing Desk (NDD): Unlike market makers, ECN brokers don’t take the other side of your trades, meaning there is no conflict of interest.
Faster Execution: As trades are directly processed through the liquidity providers, execution speeds tend to be faster.
Transparency: ECN brokers provide transparency in pricing, allowing traders to see the best bid and ask prices from various liquidity sources.
What Is a Market Maker?
In contrast, a market maker is a type of broker who creates a market for traders by offering buy and sell prices. These brokers often have a dealing desk and can control the spread and liquidity. Market makers may take the opposite side of your trade, which creates a potential conflict of interest because they profit when you lose.
Key Features of Market Makers:
Wide Spreads: Market makers tend to have wider spreads because they control the pricing.
Dealing Desk: Market makers usually have a dealing desk, where they can manage orders and sometimes even take the other side of the trade.
Slower Execution: Since trades are routed through the dealing desk, execution speeds may be slower compared to ECN brokers.
Potential for Conflict of Interest: Since the broker may take the other side of a trade, there could be a conflict of interest between the broker and the trader.
IC Markets: ECN or Market Maker?
Now that we’ve covered the basics of ECN and Market Maker models, let’s explore IC Markets' business structure. IC Markets is widely known for operating as an ECN broker, but does it truly meet the criteria for this classification? Let’s break it down.
1. ECN Account Types
IC Markets offers two primary types of trading accounts: Standard and Raw Spread. The Raw Spread accounts are specifically designed to offer direct access to liquidity providers, making them an ideal choice for traders who want to take advantage of tight spreads. These accounts are characterized by their ECN-like features.
2. Direct Market Access
IC Markets provides direct market access (DMA) for traders, which is a hallmark of an ECN broker. With DMA, your orders are directly routed to the liquidity providers, and there is no interference from the broker in the pricing process.
3. No Dealing Desk
IC Markets operates with a No Dealing Desk (NDD) model, which is a key feature of ECN brokers. In this setup, the broker does not take the opposite side of a trader's position, reducing the risk of conflicts of interest. Instead, traders’ orders are matched with liquidity providers in the market.
4. Spreads and Liquidity
IC Markets is known for offering some of the tightest spreads in the industry, particularly on its Raw Spread accounts. The broker aggregates liquidity from multiple sources, which allows it to offer traders the best possible prices. This is consistent with the behavior of ECN brokers, who typically offer lower spreads due to their access to interbank liquidity.
5. Execution Speed
IC Markets offers ultra-fast execution speeds, with typical latency under 40 milliseconds. This low latency is a common trait of ECN brokers, who connect traders directly to liquidity providers and avoid intermediaries that could slow down order processing.
6. Transparency
One of the most significant advantages of trading with IC Markets is the transparency in pricing. As an ECN broker, IC Markets provides its clients with full visibility of the bid and ask prices from multiple liquidity providers, enabling traders to make informed decisions.
IC Markets vs Market Maker Brokers
While IC Markets operates primarily as an ECN broker, it is useful to compare it to market maker brokers to highlight the differences clearly.
Spreads
Market makers often have wider spreads because they control the price they offer to traders. On the other hand, ECN brokers like IC Markets typically offer much tighter spreads. This can make a significant difference in trading costs, especially for high-frequency traders.
Execution
ECN brokers like IC Markets usually offer faster execution speeds compared to market makers. This is because orders are directly processed through liquidity providers, eliminating the need for any manual intervention from the broker.
Order Routing
Market makers route orders through their dealing desk, where they can adjust prices and even take the other side of trades. In contrast, IC Markets routes orders through an ECN system, where the orders are matched with liquidity providers automatically.
Conflicts of Interest
The main disadvantage of market makers is the potential for conflicts of interest. Since they may take the opposite side of a trade, they could profit when their clients lose. This conflict is largely avoided with ECN brokers like IC Markets, who do not take the other side of the trade and have no incentive to see their clients lose.
Pros and Cons of IC Markets
As an ECN broker, IC Markets offers numerous advantages to traders, but there are also a few potential drawbacks to consider.
Pros of IC Markets
Tight Spreads: IC Markets offers some of the tightest spreads in the industry, especially on Raw Spread accounts.
Fast Execution: With low latency and no dealing desk, IC Markets provides fast order execution, which is crucial for high-frequency traders.
Transparency: The broker offers full visibility of market prices, helping traders make informed decisions.
Variety of Platforms: IC Markets supports popular trading platforms like MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, and cTrader, offering flexibility for traders.
Low Commissions: IC Markets charges competitive commissions, especially on its Raw Spread accounts, making it a cost-effective option for active traders.
Cons of IC Markets
High Minimum Deposit for Raw Spread Accounts: To access Raw Spread accounts, traders need to deposit a minimum of $200, which may be a barrier for some beginners.
Limited Educational Resources: While IC Markets offers a range of trading tools and resources, its educational content may not be as extensive as some other brokers.
Conclusion
So, is IC Markets an ECN broker or a market maker? The answer is clear: IC Markets operates primarily as an ECN broker. The broker provides direct market access, tight spreads, and fast execution speeds, all of which are characteristics of ECN brokers. IC Markets does not take the opposite side of your trades and offers full transparency in pricing, making it a reliable choice for traders who seek an ECN-style trading experience.
While IC Markets has a few drawbacks, such as a higher minimum deposit for Raw Spread accounts, it offers numerous advantages for active traders, particularly those who prioritize low spreads, fast execution, and transparency. For those looking for a genuine ECN trading experience, IC Markets stands out as one of the best options in the industry.
In summary, IC Markets offers all the hallmarks of an ECN broker, and for most traders, it is an excellent choice for forex and CFD trading.
