7 minute read

Is IG An ECN Broker? or Market Market? Review broker?

Next Article
Is Trade Nation An ECN Broker? or Market Market? Review broker?

Is Trade Nation An ECN Broker? or Market Market? Review broker?

Is IG an ECN Broker or a Market Maker Broker? A Comprehensive Review of IG Trading

Introduction

In the world of online trading, selecting the right broker is crucial for any trader. With a variety of brokers offering different types of accounts and trading conditions, it can often be challenging to choose one that meets your needs. One popular broker that often raises questions among traders is IG. The debate that continues to circulate in trading communities is whether IG operates as an ECN broker or a Market Maker broker. This distinction is important because it impacts how trades are executed, the spreads offered, and the overall trading experience.

Top 10 BEST Forex Brokers

1️⃣ Exness: Open Account | Go to broker

2️⃣ JustMarkets: Open Account | Go to broker

3️⃣ XM: Open Account | Go to broker

4️⃣Pepperstone: Go to broker

5️⃣Avatrade: Open Account | Go to broker

6️⃣FpMarkets: Open Account | Go to broker

7️⃣XTB: Go to Website

8️⃣FBS: Go to Website

9️⃣Amarkets: Go to Website

In this detailed review, we will address this crucial question, explore the characteristics of IG, and provide an in-depth analysis to help you make an informed decision. By the end of this article, you will have a clear understanding of whether IG is an ECN broker or a market maker broker, and whether it is a suitable choice for your trading style.

What is an ECN Broker?

Before diving into IG's trading model, it’s important to first understand what an ECN broker is. ECN stands for Electronic Communication Network. ECN brokers facilitate direct market access to the financial markets by connecting traders with liquidity providers. These liquidity providers can be banks, financial institutions, or other traders.

The main advantage of trading with an ECN broker is the transparent pricing structure. ECN brokers typically provide tight spreads, and trades are executed directly in the market without any intervention from the broker. The main characteristics of an ECN broker include:

  • No Dealing Desk (NDD) execution: Trades are routed directly to the market.

  • Variable Spreads: Spreads are determined by the market and can fluctuate.

  • Transparency: You see the available liquidity in the market, and your order is matched with a liquidity provider.

  • Lower costs for high-volume traders: Due to direct market access, ECN brokers usually have lower commission rates compared to market makers.

What is a Market Maker Broker?

On the other hand, a Market Maker broker operates differently. Market makers create their own market by quoting buy and sell prices for various assets. They essentially act as the counterparty to their clients' trades. When you trade with a market maker, your order is often executed within the broker's own network rather than being sent to external liquidity providers.

The key features of a market maker broker include:

  • Fixed Spreads: Market makers typically offer fixed spreads, regardless of market conditions.

  • Broker as Counterparty: The broker may take the opposite side of your trade.

  • Slippage: Slippage can occur due to the broker’s internal order matching process.

  • No direct market access: Orders are executed within the broker's network, and not sent to the external markets.

Is IG an ECN Broker or a Market Maker Broker?

Now that we have a clear understanding of the definitions, let’s examine whether IG is an ECN broker or a Market Maker broker.

IG is a well-established online broker with over 40 years of experience in the industry. It offers a wide range of assets to trade, including forex, stocks, commodities, indices, and cryptocurrencies. To determine if IG is an ECN or market maker, we need to analyze its business model, pricing structure, and order execution process.

1. Execution Model

IG operates under a No Dealing Desk (NDD) model, which suggests that it doesn’t intervene in the execution of trades. While IG offers market orders and some forms of direct market access, it does not entirely fit the definition of an ECN broker. Instead, IG's model combines elements of both ECN and Market Maker features, which is often referred to as a Hybrid Model.

This hybrid model means that IG connects its clients to liquidity providers for some orders (typically the larger trades), while also acting as a market maker for smaller retail orders. The liquidity providers include major banks and financial institutions that provide the best available prices for IG's clients.

2. Spreads and Commissions

IG offers variable spreads for its clients. However, these spreads are not typically as tight as those offered by traditional ECN brokers. For example, spreads on major currency pairs, such as EUR/USD, can vary between 0.8 to 1.2 pips, depending on market conditions. This is wider than the ultra-tight spreads offered by pure ECN brokers, which can sometimes be as low as 0.1 pips.

Additionally, IG charges a commission on some instruments, particularly for stocks and commodities. The commission structure can vary depending on the asset class, but for retail traders, commissions are often quite competitive. For example, IG’s commission for UK stocks can start from £8, while for US stocks, it starts from $0.02 per share.

3. Slippage and Order Execution

One common feature of market makers is that they may provide less predictable execution, often resulting in slippage. This happens because market makers are the counterparty to their clients' trades, meaning that they may not always be able to provide the exact price requested. However, with IG, slippage is rare, and order execution is often very fast and reliable. The broker strives to provide instant execution with minimal slippage, especially on its proprietary platform.

4. Transparency and Liquidity Providers

IG provides a certain level of transparency by offering direct access to multiple liquidity providers. This is one aspect that sets it apart from traditional market makers, who often create their own prices without providing market depth or transparency. IG’s access to liquidity providers means that its clients are likely to get a better price when executing larger trades.

However, unlike pure ECN brokers, IG’s pricing is not entirely transparent. In a true ECN model, traders can see the bid and ask prices of different liquidity providers. With IG, the broker itself aggregates the best prices and offers them to clients, which means that there is still a layer of intermediary between the trader and the market.

5. Regulation and Safety

IG is regulated by top-tier authorities, such as the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the UK, and other financial regulatory bodies in Australia, the US, and Europe. This regulatory oversight ensures that IG adheres to strict standards for client safety, fund protection, and transparency. The broker’s high level of regulation further contributes to its reputation as a reliable and trustworthy platform.

Pros and Cons of Trading with IG

Pros:

  • Hybrid Execution Model: A mix of ECN and market maker features provides flexibility.

  • Competitive Spreads: Tight spreads, especially for larger trades.

  • Reliable Order Execution: Minimal slippage and fast trade execution.

  • Multiple Trading Platforms: IG offers its proprietary platform and MetaTrader 4 (MT4).

  • Regulation and Safety: Strong regulatory framework, ensuring client protection.

Cons:

  • Not a True ECN Broker: Spreads are not as tight as those offered by pure ECN brokers.

  • Commissions: Charges for stock and commodity trades can be higher compared to some brokers.

  • Hybrid Model: Traders seeking pure ECN access may not find IG ideal for high-frequency trading.

Conclusion

In conclusion, IG is neither a pure ECN broker nor a typical Market Maker broker. Instead, it operates under a Hybrid Execution Model, combining aspects of both. For most retail traders, IG provides a robust trading environment with competitive spreads, reliable execution, and access to liquidity providers. However, if you are seeking the tightest spreads and the purest ECN experience, you might want to explore other brokers that specialize in that model.

Regardless, IG remains one of the top choices for traders who value a regulated, transparent, and diverse platform with a broad range of trading assets. If you’re a beginner or an intermediate trader looking for a reliable broker with a comprehensive offering, IG is certainly worth considering.

More articles from this publication:
This article is from:

Forex Brokers ECN - TOP List Best Forex broker ECN