SECTOR FOCUS:
BASE OILS
Environmental benefits from base oils in heavy duty engine oil Céline Thompson, Senior Customer Technical Service Specialist, Afton Chemical Reducing environmental impact is a clear target for governments, companies, and consumers worldwide and the heavy duty engine oil market is no exception. Afton explores how base oils can contribute to finished lubricant performance and additional environmental benefits in the growing top tier, premium and mainline heavy duty engine oil (HDEO) segments. The global legislative agenda has been pushing faster and harder to reduce carbon footprints, minimise emissions, improve resource conservation and create a truly circular economy. In heavy commercial vehicle applications, the pressure to reduce carbon dioxide emissions has driven widespread technological advances. With the latest hardware needing greater protection and performance than ever from lubricants, the spotlight is on how base oil selection can support this drive for sustainability. Why base oil matters By far the largest constituent by volume of finished lubricants is base oil - making up anywhere from 75-90% of a finished HDEO. The remainder is a blend of performance additives such as anti-wear additives, detergents, dispersants and antioxidants and viscosity modifiers. Mineral base oils that are refined from crude oil – Group I, II and III oils – can contain up to 500 different molecular types. As the proportions of each type influence the finished lubricant’s inherent properties, the choice of base oil is very important. Governments mandating minimum oil specifications have already rendered the lower tier HDEO industry specification obsolete in many countries. As the lower tier segment has diminished in importance, demand for Group I base stocks has dwindled, almost halving in the past decade.
32
LUBE MAGAZINE NO.169 JUNE 2022
Figure 1: Properties of chemical types.
Lower tier engine oils based on Group I base stocks are still widely used in Off Road vehicles in developing markets. However, the drive for sustainability means that Off Road emissions legislation is likely to keep following that for On Road commercial vehicles. Base oil trends In the meantime, demand is growing for the more highly refined base oils – Group II and even Group III. Being lower than Group I oils in aromatic content, and higher in naphthenic and paraffin molecules, Group II oils deliver a better all-round balance of performance, with sufficient solvency for blending performance additives, all typically at a lower cost than Group III base oils according to key market indices. This positions Group II perfectly for the mainline (API CH-4 / CI-4) and premium (API CK-4) HDEO segments. Not surprisingly, the Group II share of global base oil production is growing. Group III is also increasing in importance. The naturally high viscosity index and excellent oxidation resistance of Group III base oils make them well suited to the more nuanced requirements of top tier HDEO. As emissions legislation becomes increasingly stringent, Group III oils will likely see demand continuing to rise. In the United States, the American Petroleum Institute is expected to launch its PC-12 specification in 2027.
This could determine whether there is any greater divergence between On Road (lower HTHS – high temperature, high shear) and Off Road (standard HTHS) premium specifications. A move to low HTHS fluids will drive further demand for Group III in a market that is predominantly Group II today.
Afton has carried out in-house testing; this shows re-refined Group II based formulations can pass stringent industry and OEM requirements. Oxidation performance in both bench and engine testing was maintained when a suitable quality re-refined base oil was paired with a versatile additive technology designed to be robust regardless of base oil selection.
How base oil can add environmental benefits Top tier and premium HDEO provide additional environmental benefits compared to lower tier, thanks to innate base oil characteristics working in harmony with performance additives. Group III base oils have a naturally high viscosity index. When blended with the right additive package, this enables lower viscosity Group III fluids to be used without compromising antiwear performance. Today’s ultra low viscosity engine oils reduce emissions by minimising friction losses within the engine. This provides measurable gains in fuel economy, while still effectively protecting the very latest engine hardware.
Figure 2: Oxidation performance (Daimler oxidation test) of re-refined Group II in the mainline segment. Source: Afton Chemical in-house testing
Group III oils also demonstrate excellent oxidation stability, helping to extend the fluid’s required level of performance over the longest possible drain intervals. This longer lifespan saves resources and further enhances the environmental credentials of higher tier products. However, the physical characteristics of base oils are not the only factor influencing to what degree they might deliver on a market’s sustainability agenda. Re-refined base oil Although it currently accounts for less than 5% of global base oil production, there could be a growing role for re-refined base oils as oil marketers seek to improve the sustainability of their products. The vast majority of re-refined base oil is produced and used in Europe and the Americas.
Figure 3: Oxidation performance (Daimler oxidation test) of re-refined Group II in the premium segment. Source: Afton Chemical in-house testing
Made from collected waste oil from which any contaminants such as fuel, water, wear particles and spent additives have been removed, re-refined base oils are classified by API Group in the same way as their traditionally-refined counterparts. Unlocking the environmental benefits of re-refined base oil requires an enabling additive technology that is more robust across the full range of base oils. Given the potential for re-refined oils to play a bigger role,
Figure 4: Oxidation performance (Seq IIIF) of re-refined Group II in the mainline segment. Source: Afton Chemical in-house testing Continued on page 34
LUBE MAGAZINE NO.169 JUNE 2022
33
Continued from page 33
Base oil interchangeability Whether done for reasons of availability, sustainability, or both, just how complex is it to change the base oil used in an existing heavy duty engine oil product? Base Oil Interchange (BOI) rules can be found in the relevant Codes of Practice (API and ATIEL). Re-refined base oils follow the same rules as conventional base oils from the same API group. These rules facilitate interchange from one Group II to another Group II base oil without the need for the regeneration of all associated engine tests. As a result, it is in principle a straightforward approach to enable the extension of products in the HDEO mainline and premium market from conventional to re-refined Group II base oil should the need, or desire, arise. A balanced approach Only by understanding what different base oils
and additives can bring to each HDEO segment can sustainability and performance be optimised in finished lubricants. For futureproof HDEO solutions, objectives must be met in the context of future industry specifications and trends, not just the status quo. Base oil properties, availability, interchangeability, and price must all be considered when determining the right blend of performance, longevity, fuel economy and other environmental benefits.
LINK www.aftonchemical.com
Photo: FUCHS EUROPE SCHMIERSTOFFE GMBH
save the date!
30.–31. August 2022 in Stuttgart Informationen über: Kraft- und Biokraftstoffe Schmierstoffe Additive Grundöle + Get-together – Abendevent
Information about:
Apply now as a speaker, sponsor or exhibitor!
Fuels and Biofuels Lubricants Additives Base Oils + Get-together
Veranstalter / Organizer: UNITI-Kraftstoff GmbH · Jägerstraße 6 · 10117 Berlin T. (030) 755 414-400 · F. (030) 755 414-474 · umt@uniti.de · www.umtf.de
Bewerben Sie sich schon heute als Referent, Sponsor oder Aussteller!
Weitere Informationen More Information: www.umtf.de