OFFERING MEMORANDUM
Wingate at Belle Meadows 240 Units | 100% LIHTC | Dayton, OH
CONFIDENTIALITY & DISCLAIMER
The information contained in the following Marketing Brochure is proprietary and strictly confidential. It is intended to be reviewed only by the party receiving it from Marcus & Millichap and should not be made available to any other person or entity without the written consent of Marcus & Millichap. This Marketing Brochure has been prepared to provide summary, unverified information to prospective purchasers, and to establish only a preliminary level of interest in the subject property. The information contained herein is not a substitute for a thorough due diligence investigation. Marcus & Millichap has not made any investigation, and makes no warranty or representation, with respect to the income or expenses for the subject property, the future projected financial performance of the property, the size and square footage of the property and improvements, the presence or absence of contaminating substances, PCB’s or asbestos, the compliance with State and Federal regulations, the physical condition of the improvements thereon, or the financial condition or business prospects of any tenant, or any tenant’s plans or intentions to continue its occupancy of the subject property. The information contained in this Marketing Brochure has been obtained from sources we believe to be reliable; however, Marcus & Millichap has not verified, and will not verify, any of the information contained herein, nor has Marcus & Millichap conducted any investigation regarding these matters and makes no warranty or representation whatsoever regarding the accuracy or completeness of the information provided. All potential buyers must take appropriate measures to verify all of the information set forth herein. Marcus & Millichap is a service mark of Marcus & Millichap Real Estate Investment Services, Inc. © 2021 Marcus & Millichap. All rights reserved. Broker makes reasonable efforts to locate the most current property information available. Any person or entity who relies upon this information does so at their own risk. Broker makes no warranties, concerning the accuracy, completeness, reliability of this information.
NON-ENDORSEMENT NOTICE
Marcus & Millichap is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by any commercial tenant or lessee identified in this marketing package. The presence of any corporation’s logo or name is not intended to indicate or imply affiliation with, or sponsorship or endorsement by, said corporation of Marcus & Millichap, its affiliates or subsidiaries, or any agent, product, service, or commercial listing of Marcus & Millichap, and is solely included for the purpose of providing tenant lessee information about this listing to prospective customers.
ALL PROPERTY SHOWINGS ARE BY APPOINTMENT ONLY. PLEASE CONSULT YOUR AGENT FOR MORE DETAILS. RENT DISCLAIMER
Any rent or income information in this offering memorandum, with the exception of actual, historical rent collections, represent good faith projections of potential future rent only, and Marcus & Millichap makes no representations as to whether such rent may actually be attainable. Local, state, and federal laws regarding restrictions on rent increases may make these projections impossible, and Buyer and its advisors should conduct their own investigation to determine whether such rent increases are legally permitted and reasonably attainable.
SPECIAL COVID-19 NOTICE
All potential buyers are strongly advised to take advantage of their opportunities and obligations to conduct thorough due diligence and seek expert opinions as they may deem necessary, especially given the unpredictable changes resulting from the continuing COVID-19 pandemic. Marcus & Millichap has not been retained to perform, and cannot conduct, due diligence on behalf of any prospective purchaser. Marcus & Millichap’s principal expertise is in marketing investment properties and acting as intermediaries between buyers and sellers. Marcus & Millichap and its investment professionals cannot and will not act as lawyers, accountants, contractors, or engineers. All potential buyers are admonished and advised to engage other professionals on legal issues, tax, regulatory, financial, and accounting matters, and for questions involving the property’s physical condition or financial outlook. Projections and pro forma financial statements are not guarantees and, given the potential volatility created by COVID-19, all potential buyers should be comfortable with and rely solely on their own projections, analyses, and decision-making.
2 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
EXCLUSIVELY LISTED BY
AHA S42 Jeremiah K. Jarmin | Senior National Director LIHTC 602.687.6690 jeremiah@mmaha.com License #: AZ SA694592000; GA 355022
AHA S8 Paul D. Davis | Founder 248.415.2630 paul@mmaha.com License #: MI 6506008394
Andrew S. Daitch | Executive Managing Director 248.415.2537 andy@mmaha.com License #: MI 6501302475
Steven A. Miscavish | Chief Financial Officer 248.415.2647 steve@mmaha.com License #: MI 6506046449
Seth I. Barnett | Senior National Director 248.415.2653 seth@mmaha.com License #: MI 6501346607
Matthew I. Kurzmann | Senior National Director 248.415.3036 matt@mmaha.com License #: MI 6501369303
Tyler J. Martin | National Director 949.419.3287 tyler@mmaha.com License #: CA 01457016
Gerson H. Askenazy | National Director Nonprofit 248.415.3013 gerson@mmaha.com License #: MI 6506047074
Alyssa Van Hyfte | National Director 248.415.2654 alyssa@mmaha.com License #: MI 6501421796
Neil B. Rosenthal | National Director 248.415.2657 neil@mmaha.com License #: MI 6501423232
LISTED IN CONJUNCTION WITH Nicholas Andrews | First Vice President Investments 513.878.7741 nicholas.andrews@marcusmillichap.com
Jordan Dickman | First Vice President Investments 513.878.7735 jordan.dickman@marcusmillichap.com
BROKER OF RECORD Michael Glass | Senior Vice President / Division Manager 216.264.2050 michael.glass@marcusmillichap.com
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 3
PROCESS & TERMS EXCLUSIVE LISTING: This portfolio is exclusively listed by the Affordable Housing Advisors and Marcus & Millichap. CONFIDENTIALITY & COMMUNICATION: This agreement prohibits any contact with the site staff and/or ownership. The highest level of confidentiality is expected, any perceived breach of confidentiality can result in disqualification from the process. PROPERTY TOURS: The owner has specifically requested that all site visits be scheduled through AHA. Unaccompanied site visits are prohibited. Please do not contact the management company or site staff during this process. CALL FOR OFFERS: AHA will announce a Call for Offers date at a later time. INFORMATION ACCESS: Additional information is accessible by registration on the AHA website, which can be found at www. AffordableHousingAdvisors.com. Upon registering, you will receive e-mail updates during the marketing process along with information regarding Property Tours and a Call for Offers Date.
4 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
TABLE OF CONTENTS Section
1
Page
The Offering
08
Investment Overview & Highlights Property Description & Amenities Property Photos
2
Financial Analysis
18
Unit Mix Area Median Income Annual Operating Cash Flow Financial Footnotes
3
Rent Comparables
24
Rent Comps Summary Rent Comps Map Rent Comps Details
4
Market Overview
30
Location Highlights Demographics Local Points of Interest
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 5
Wingate at Belle Meadows | DAYTON, OHIO
THE OFFERING
01
THE OFFERING
Wingate at Belle Meadows INVESTMENT OVERVIEW Affordable Housing Advisors, listed in conjunction with Marcus & Millichap, are pleased to present the opportunity to acquire Wingate at Belle Meadows Apartments, a 240-unit affordable housing property located in Dayton, Ohio. This opportunity is being offered without an asking price. The property received an allocation of Low Income Housing Tax Credits pursuant to Internal Revenue Code §42 and is subject to rent and income restrictions for a minimum of 30 years. The Placed-in-Service year was 2004, the End of Initial Compliance Period is December 31, 2019 and the End of Extended Use Period is 2034. The property is located in a Qualified Census Tract (130% basis) for Low Income Housing Tax Credit rehabilitation.
INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS Proven out value-add opportunity on recently renovated 3 Bed / 2.5 Bath units achieving $100 rental premium over standard units.
8 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
Located in a Qualified Census Tract (130% basis) for LIHTC rehabilitation.
Excellent unit mix: 76% of the units are 2BR & 3BR apartments or townhomes.
Recently installed sub-metering will provide a new owner with significant net positive increase to NOI via RUBS program.
Over $500,000 of recent property improvements including but not limited to roof replacement and new parking overly.
AERIAL IMAGE
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 9
THE OFFERING OFFERING SUMMARY ADDRESS Property Name
Wingate at Belle Meadows Apartments 5 Belle Meadows Drive
Street Address City, State, Zip Code
Dayton, OH 45426 Montgomery County
County REGULATORY Development Type
4%
% Units Affordable
100%
State Agency
OHFA
Year Placed in Service
2004
End of Initial Compliance
2019
End of Extended Use
2034
Qualified Contract Eligible
No Voucher (58 units or 17%)
Section 8 Located in QCT/DDA
QCT
10-Year Chain of Title
Yes
BUILDING INFORMATION Brick Exterior
Construction
Gable / Asphalt Shingle
Roof Type Year Built / LIHTC Rehab
1972 / 2004
Total Buildings
28 Buildings 2 Stories
Stories
22.26 Acres
Lot Size UTILITIES
None
Landlord-Paid
Gas (Heat), Electric & Water*
Tenant-Paid Air Conditioning
Central
*Note: submetering of water/sewer with direct billing to tenants being implemented
ASSESSMENT Parcel Identificiation #
H33006050001, H33006050002, H3001190001
2020 Market Value
$4,176,990
2020 Assessed Value (35%)
$1,461,960
10 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
Cleveland, OH
Canton, OH
Wingate At Belle Meadows Apartments Dayton, OH
OHIO Columbus, OH
Cincinnati, OH
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 11
THE PROPERTY COMMUNITY AMENITIES
Clubhouse
Business Center
Tennis Court
Laundry Facilities
Playground
Picnic Area
24-Hour Maintenance
On-Site Management
Dog Park
Close To The Moss Creek Golf Club
Nearby Shopping & Entertainment
Nearby Restaurants
Balcony/Patio
Washer/Dryer Connections
Security System
Walk-In Closets
Central Air & Heating
Oven & Range
Dishwasher
Refrigerator
Disposal
Additional Storage Available
Cable/Satellite Available
High Speed Internet Access
UNIT AMENITIES
12 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 13
FLOORPLANS
1 BEDROOM | 1 BATH
2 BEDROOM | 1.75 BATH
3 BEDROOM | 2 BATH
560 SF APARTMENT
950 SF APARTMENT
1,200 SF APARTMENT
14 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
FLOORPLANS
2 BEDROOM | 1.5 BATH
2 BEDROOM | 2.5 BATH
3 BEDROOM | 2.5 BATH
1,100 SF TOWNHOME
1,200 SF TOWNHOME
1,250 SF TOWNHOME
2ND FLOOR
2ND FLOOR
2ND FLOOR
1ST FLOOR
1ST FLOOR
1ST FLOOR
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 15
Wingate at Belle Meadows | DAYTON, OHIO
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
02
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS UNIT MIX UNIT COUNT
AMI
AVERAGE SF
CURRENT RENT
CURRENT RENT/SF
PRO FORMA RENTS
PRO FORMA RENT/SF
1X1 60%
56
60%
650
$586
$0.90
$650
$1.00
11%
$64
$852
$98
$754
22%
2X1.75 60%
93
60%
959
$683
$0.71
$700
$0.73
2%
$17
$1,023
$131
$892
23%
2X1.5 60% (TOWNHOME)
28
60%
1,100
$724
$0.66
$725
$0.66
0%
$1
$1,023
$131
$892
19%
2X2.5 60% (DELUXE)
11
60%
1,200
$716
$0.60
$750
$0.63
5%
$34
$1,023
$131
$892
20%
3X2 60%
16
60%
1,250
$784
$0.63
$800
$0.64
2%
$16
$1,181
$156
$1,025
23%
3X2.5 60% (TOWNHOME)
28
60%
1,250
$838
$0.67
$850
$0.68
1%
$12
$1,181
$156
$1,025
18%
3X2.5 60% (UPGRADED)
8
60%
1,250
$923
$0.74
$925
$0.74
0%
$2
$1,181
$156
$1,025
10%
234,600
$2,014,538
$2,929,920
$370,704
$2,559,216
21%
978
$699
TYPE
TOTALS
240
AVERAGES
$2,088,600 $0.72
BY BEDROOM
$725
% / $ DIFF. BETWEEN CURRENT RENT AND PRO FORMA
4% $0.74
$26
2021 MAX 2021 MAX DISCOUNT UTILITY LIHTC RENT LIHTC TO NET ALLOWANCE (GROSS) RENT (NET) MAX
$1,017
$889
SET ASIDE
1 Bedroom
2 Bedroom
60% AMI
3 Bedroom 1 BR 2 BR
#
%
1 Bedroom
56
23%
2 Bedroom
132
55%
3 Bedroom
52
22%
240
100%
TYPE
3 BR
TOTALS
18 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
60%
#
%
60% AMI
240
100%
TOTALS
240
100%
TYPE
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS AREA MEDIAN INCOME MONTGOMERY COUNTY | OHIO 4-Person AMGI Source: Novogradac
$ 80,000 $ 75,000 $ 70,000 $ 65,000 $ 60,000 $ 55,000 $ 50,000 1999
2001
2003
2005
2007
2009
2011
2013
2015
2017
2019
2021
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 19
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS HISTORICAL & PRO FORMA CASH FLOW TRAILING 12 MONTHS ANNUALIZED CASH FLOW OPERATING REVENUE
PROJECTED CASH FLOW T12 ACTUAL
Aug-21
Per Unit
T3 ANNUALIZED %
Aug-21
PRO FORMA YEAR 1
Per Unit
%
Dec-22
Per Unit
%
Notes
Potential Market Rent
$ 2,417,949
$ 10,075
100.00%
$ 2,383,146
$ 9,930
100.00%
$ 2,088,600
$ 8,703
100.00%
(1)
(Loss to Lease) / Gain to Lease
($ 507,149)
($ 2,113)
(20.97%)
($ 428,972)
($ 1,787)
(18.00%)
($ 62,658)
($ 261)
(3.00%)
(2)
$ 1,910,800
$ 7,962
79.03%
$ 1,954,174
$ 8,142
82.00%
$ 2,025,942
$ 8,441
97.00%
Vacancy
($ 92,466)
($ 385)
(3.82%)
($ 136,543)
($ 569)
(5.73%)
($ 104,430)
($ 435)
(5.00%)
(3)
Concessions
($ 2,685)
($ 11)
(0.11%)
($ 2,317)
($ 10)
(0.10%)
($ 2,837)
($ 12)
(0.14%)
(4)
($ 145,103)
($ 605)
(6.00%)
($ 150,069)
($ 625)
(6.30%)
($ 57,560)
($ 240)
(2.76%)
(5)
$ 1,670,546
$ 6,961
69.09%
$ 1,665,245
$ 6,939
69.88%
$ 1,861,115
$ 7,755
89.11%
Gross Potential Revenue
Collection Loss / Bad Debt Base Rental Revenue Expense Reimbursements
-
-
-
-
-
-
$ 214,942
$ 896
10.29%
(6)
Other Residential Income
$ 91,524
$ 381
3.79%
$ 91,524
$ 381
3.84%
$ 94,269
$ 393
4.51%
(7)
Other Income EFFECTIVE GROSS REVENUE
$ 91,524
$ 381
3.79%
$ 91,524
$ 381
3.84%
$ 309,212
$ 1,288
14.80%
$ 1,762,070
$ 7,342
72.87%
$ 1,756,768
$ 7,320
73.72%
$ 2,170,326
$ 9,043
103.91%
OPERATING EXPENSES
T12 ACTUAL
BUYER ADJUSTED EXPENSES
YEAR 1 PRO FORMA
Repair & Maintenance
$ 240,052
$ 1,000
13.62%
$ 180,000
$ 750
10.25%
$ 185,400
$ 773
8.54%
Contract Services
$ 76,088
$ 317
4.32%
$ 76,088
$ 317
4.33%
$ 78,371
$ 327
3.61%
(8) (9)
Landscaping / Grounds
$ 56,893
$ 237
3.23%
$ 56,893
$ 237
3.24%
$ 58,600
$ 244
2.70%
(10)
Personnel
$ 401,545
$ 1,673
22.79%
$ 312,000
$ 1,300
17.76%
$ 312,000
$ 1,300
14.38%
(11)
Marketing / Advertising
$ 5,269
$ 22
0.30%
$ 5,269
$ 22
0.30%
$ 5,427
$ 23
0.25%
(12)
Administrative Expenses
$ 59,348
$ 247
3.37%
$ 59,348
$ 247
3.38%
$ 61,129
$ 255
2.82%
(13)
Electricity
$ 15,771
$ 66
0.90%
$ 15,771
$ 66
0.90%
$ 16,245
$ 68
0.75%
(14)
Fuel (Gas & Oil)
$ 1,944
$8
0.11%
$ 1,944
$8
0.11%
$ 2,003
$8
0.09%
(15)
Water & Sewer
$ 231,869
$ 966
13.16%
$ 231,869
$ 966
13.20%
$ 238,825
$ 995
11.00%
(16)
$ 2,500
$ 10
0.14%
$ 2,500
$ 10
0.14%
$ 2,575
$ 11
0.12%
(17)
Insurance
$ 116,528
$ 486
6.61%
$ 84,000
$ 350
4.78%
$ 84,000
$ 350
3.87%
(18)
Real Estate Taxes
$ 169,640
$ 707
9.63%
$ 169,640
$ 707
9.66%
$ 174,729
$ 728
8.05%
(19) (20)
Other Utilities
Property Management Fee
$ 51,390
$ 214
2.92%
$ 51,390
$ 214
2.93%
$ 65,110
$ 271
3.00%
TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSES
$ 1,428,839
$ 5,953
81.09%
$ 1,246,714
$ 5,195
70.97%
$ 1,284,414
$ 5,352
59.18%
$ 333,231
$ 1,388
18.91%
$ 510,054
$ 2,125
29.03%
$ 885,913
$ 3,691
40.82%
NET OPERATING INCOME Net Operating Income (Bef. Reserves) Replacement Reserves
$ 72,000
$ 300
4.09%
$ 72,000
$ 300
4.10%
$ 72,000
$ 300
3.32%
NET OPERATING INCOME (Aft. Reserves)
$ 261,231
$ 1,088
14.83%
$ 438,054
$ 1,825
24.94%
$ 813,913
$ 3,391
37.50%
20 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
(21)
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS PRO FORMA FOOTNOTES (1)
PMR: Pro forma rents increased 3% on average over in-place
(2)
Loss to Lease / Gain to Lease: 3% of PMR
(3)
Vacancy: 5% of PMR
(4)
Concessions: 0.15% of in-place revenue
(5)
Collection Loss/Bad Debt: 3% of Base Rental Revenue
(6)
RUBS: Water Bill Reimbursed at 90% of Property Usage Per New Sub-Metering Plan
(7)
Other Income: T12 average inflated 3%
(8)
R&M: Underwritten at $750/unit
(9)
Contract Services: T12 average inflated 3%
(10)
Landscaping / Grounds: T12 average inflated 3%
(11)
Personnel: Underwritten at $1300/unit; grown 3%
(12)
Marketing / Advertising: T12 average inflated 3%
(13)
Administrative Expenses: T12 average inflated 3%
(14)
Electricity: T12 average inflated 3%
(15)
Fuel (Gas & Oil): T12 average inflated 3%
(16)
Water & Sewer: T12 average inflated 3%
(17)
Other Utilities: T12 average inflated 3%
(18)
Insurance: Underwritten at $350/unit
(19)
Real Estate Taxes: Inflated 2% over actual. Please consult commercial property tax professional.
(20)
Property Management: 3% of EGR
(21)
Replacement Reserves: $300/unit
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 21
Wingate at Belle Meadows | DAYTON, OHIO
RENT COMPARABLES
03
RENT COMPARABLES SUMMARY
1 BEDROOM
PROPERTIES SORTED BY UNIT RENT MILES TO SUBJECT
AFFORDABILITY PROGRAM
AMI RESTRICTIONS
YEAR BUILT
YEAR RENOV.
AVG. SF
AVG. RENT
AVG. RENT/SF
VACANCY
3001 Shiloh Springs Road
0.1
MKT
-
1987
-
720
$685
$0.95
0.0%
Meadowlark
1550 Shiloh Springs Road
1.8
Rent Restricted
-
-
-
600
$662
$1.10
1.8%
Willowood Apartments
3303-B Shiloh Springs Road
0.1
MKT
-
1983
-
575
$636
$1.11
8.4%
4
Broadmoor Apartments
400 Burman Avenue
1.4
MKT/Affordable
-
1973
2005
681
$593
$0.87
0.0%
5
Kensington Square
700 Keswick Circle
0.2
MKT
-
1972
2015
751
$589
$0.78
38.5%
Wingate at Belle Meadows
5 Belle Meadows Drive
-
LIHTC
60%
PROPERTY NAME
ADDRESS
1
Belle Meadows
2 3
2 BEDROOM
AVERAGES:
0.7
2004
650
$586
$0.90
8.3%
2010
665
$633
$0.96
9.7%
MILES TO SUBJECT
AFFORDABILITY PROGRAM
AMI RESTRICTIONS
YEAR BUILT
YEAR RENOV.
AVG. SF
AVG. RENT
AVG. RENT/SF
VACANCY
3001 Shiloh Springs Road
0.1
MKT
-
1987
-
970
$823
$0.85
0.0%
Kensington Square
700 Keswick Circle
0.2
MKT
-
1972
2015
1,049
$776
$0.74
38.5%
4
Broadmoor Apartments
400 Burman Avenue
1.4
MKT/Affordable
-
1973
2005
1,005
$747
$0.74
0.0%
3
Willowood Apartments
3303-B Shiloh Springs Road
0.1
MKT
-
1983
-
875
$731
$0.84
8.4%
6
Shiloh Villas
4000 Willow Drive
1.9
Rent Restricted
-
1997
-
1,041
$725
$0.70
0.0%
2
Meadowlark
1550 Shiloh Springs Road
1.8
Rent Restricted
-
-
-
1,000
$696
$0.70
1.8%
Wingate at Belle Meadows
5 Belle Meadows Drive
-
LIHTC
60%
1972
2004
1,009
$694
$0.69
8.3%
1982
2010
990
$750
$0.76
8.1%
AMI RESTRICTIONS
YEAR BUILT
YEAR RENOV.
AVG. SF
AVG. RENT
AVG. RENT/SF
VACANCY
PROPERTY NAME
ADDRESS
1
Belle Meadows
5
AVERAGES:
3 BEDROOM
1972 1979
5
2
0.9
PROPERTY NAME
ADDRESS
Kensington Square
700 Keswick Circle
Wingate at Belle Meadows
5 Belle Meadows Drive
Meadowlark
1550 Shiloh Springs Road
AVERAGES:
24 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
MILES TO SUBJECT
AFFORDABILITY PROGRAM
0.2
MKT
-
1972
2015
1,592
$876
$0.55
38.5%
-
LIHTC
60%
1972
2004
1,250
$835
$0.67
8.3%
1.8
Rent Restricted
-
-
-
1,200
$820
$0.68
1.8%
1972
2015
1,396
$848
$0.62
20.2%
1.0
1
3
2
6
5
4
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 25
RENT COMPARABLES BELLE MEADOWS
1
MEADOWLARK
2
PROPERTY DETAILS Property Street Address City, State Zip Miles from Subject Units Rentable SF Vacancy Concessions Year Built Building Type Affordability Program Management Ownership
PROPERTY DETAILS
3001 Shiloh Springs Road Trotwood, OH 45426 0.1 160 144,000 0.0% 0.2% 1987 Garden Market Harvest Properties Harvest Investments LLC
Property Street Address City, State Zip Miles from Subject Units Rentable SF Vacancy Concessions Year Built Building Type Affordability Program Management Ownership
230 Surface; 32 Covered $35 $250 $35 -
Garage/Parking Pet Rent Pet Deposit/Fee Application Fee Admin. Fee
FEES
UNIT MIX 1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom
SF
720 970
ASKING RENT $685 $823
RENT/SF $0.95 $0.85
UNIT TYPE 1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom 3 Bedroom
FEES -
Basketball Court, Clubhouse, Fitness Center, Laundry Facilities, Laundry Service, Maintenance On Site, Pool, Sundeck, Tennis Court
UNIT: A/C, Cable Ready, Dishwasher, Disposal, Fireplace, Heating, Tile Floors, Walk-In Closets, Washer/Dryer Hookup, Window Coverings
26 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
SF
600 1,000 1,200
None listed
UNIT: A/C, Heating, Oven, Range
$40 -
Garage/Parking Pet Rent Pet Deposit/Fee Application Fee Admin. Fee
UNIT MIX
ASKING RENT $662 $696 $820
RENT/SF $1.10 $0.70 $0.68
UNIT TYPE 1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom
AMENITIES SITE:
3303-B Shiloh Springs Road Trotwood, OH 45426 0.1 131 82,521 8.4% 0.9% 1983 Garden Market Nrex Syndication Nrex Syndication
Property Street Address City, State Zip Miles from Subject Units Rentable SF Vacancy Concessions Year Built Building Type Affordability Program Management Ownership
UNIT MIX
AMENITIES SITE:
PROPERTY DETAILS
1550 Shiloh Springs Road Dayton, OH 45426 1.8 112 160,808 1.8% 0.3% Garden Affordable The Church of LDS
FEES
Garage/Parking Pet Rent Pet Deposit/Fee Application Fee Admin. Fee
UNIT TYPE
WILLOWOOD APARTMENTS
3
SF
575 875
ASKING RENT $636 $731
RENT/SF $1.11 $0.84
AMENITIES SITE:
24 Hour Access, Maintenance On Site, Property Manager On Site, Public Transportation Nearby
UNIT: A/C, Balcony, Heating, Oven, Patio, Refrigerator, Washer/Dryer Hookup
RENT COMPARABLES BROADMOOR APARTMENTS
4
KENSINGTON SQUARE
5
PROPERTY DETAILS
PROPERTY DETAILS
400 Burman Avenue Trotwood, OH 45426 1.4 111 97,596 0.0% 0.3% 1973 / 2005 Garden Market/Affordable Broadmoor Apartments Ernest Tschannen
Property Street Address City, State Zip Miles from Subject Units Rentable SF Vacancy Concessions Year Built Building Type Affordability Program Management Ownership
SF
681 1,005
$593 $747
RENT/SF $0.87 $0.74
UNIT TYPE 1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom 3 Bedroom
AMENITIES SITE:
FEES 470 Surface $45 -
Garage/Parking Pet Rent Pet Deposit/Fee Application Fee Admin. Fee
Laundry Facilities, Laundry Service, Property Manager On Site
UNIT: A/C, Cable Ready, Disposal, Heating, Oven,
Refrigerator, Walk-In Closets, Washer/Dryer Hookup, Wheelchair Accessible Rooms
SF
751 1,049 1,592
UNIT MIX
ASKING RENT $589 $776 $876
RENT/SF $0.78 $0.74 $0.55
UNIT TYPE 2 Bedroom
AMENITIES SITE:
$200/$25 $11 -
Garage/Parking Pet Rent Pet Deposit/Fee Application Fee Admin. Fee
UNIT MIX
ASKING RENT
4000 Willow Drive Dayton, OH 45426 1.9 120 147,525 0.0% 0.2% 1997 Garden Affordable Towne Properties Victor Kaufman
Property Street Address City, State Zip Miles from Subject Units Rentable SF Vacancy Concessions Year Built Building Type Affordability Program Management Ownership
FEES 225 Surface $25 $150 $35 $50
UNIT MIX 1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom
PROPERTY DETAILS
700 Keswick Circle Trotwood, OH 45426 0.2 224 302,032 38.5% 1.0% 1972 / 2015 Garden Market Friedman Real Estate The Chetrit Group
Property Street Address City, State Zip Miles from Subject Units Rentable SF Vacancy Concessions Year Built Building Type Affordability Program Management Ownership
FEES Garage/Parking Pet Rent Pet Deposit/Fee Application Fee Admin. Fee
UNIT TYPE
SHILOH VILLAS
6
Clubhouse, Package Service, Playground, Property Manager On Site, Storage Space
UNIT: A/C, Dishwasher, Disposal, Heating, High Speed
Internet Access, Range, Security System, Vinyl Flooring, Walk-In Closets, Washer/Dryer Hookup
SF
1,041
ASKING RENT $725
RENT/SF $0.70
AMENITIES SITE:
24 Hour Controlled Access, Bicycle Storage, Clubhouse, Fitness Center, Gated, Laundry Facilities, Multi Use Room, Picnic Area, Storage Space
UNIT: A/C, Dishwasher, Disposal, Heating, Storage Space, Tile Floors, Trash Compactor, Vinyl Flooring, Walk-In Closets, Washer/Dryer Hookup
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 27
Wingate at Belle Meadows | DAYTON, OHIO
MARKET OVERVIEW
04
MARKET OVERVIEW
DAYTON, OHIO The Dayton metro area is often referred to as the birthplace of aviation as it was the home of the Wright brothers and where they researched and experimented with flight. Composed of Greene, Montgomery and Miami counties, it is the fourth largest metropolitan area in Ohio. Defense and aerospace industries comprise a large section of the region’s economy. Additionally, healthcare accounts for a sizable portion of the area’s employment; several key institutes and centers are located here.
METRO HIGHLIGHTS TECHNOLOGY HUB
HEALTHCARE SERVICES
HIGHER EDUCATION
Dayton is known for its high concentration of aerospace and aviation technology. In 2009, it was designated as Ohio’s aerospace innovation hub.
Metro hospitals consistently earn top national rankings and recognition as well as many of HealthGrades’ top ratings.
The University of Dayton and Wright State University are two major higher-education institutions providing a skilled labor pool.
30 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
MARKET OVERVIEW ECONOMY • Hospitals in the Greater Dayton area including Miami Valley
Hospital, Kettering Medical Center and Dayton Children’s Hospital are a major employment sector with nearly 32,000 workers.
DAYTON METRO DEMOGRAPHIC HIGHLIGHTS Approximate Population
Median Household Income
Number of Households
808K
$55,300
330K
• Wright-Patterson U.S. Air Force Base is just east of Dayton. The base employs 27,500 military, civilian and contract employees and has a $4.3 billion annual economic impact.
• The logistics sector is growing buoyed by interstate access, a
dedicated freight runway and on-site warehouse at the Dayton International Airport, CSX Rail and a Foreign Trade Zone designation.
• Tech Town, a 40-acre district developed in downtown Dayton, was
created as a tool to support the attraction and growth of hightechnology business and promote technology commercialization.
PROPERTY DEMOGRAPHICS (1-5 MILE RADIUS) FROM WINGATE AT BELLE MEADOWS
1-MILE
3-MILE
5-MILE
2025 Projection - Total Population
4,141
40,530
92,522
2020 Estimate - Total Population
4,221
41,310
94,696
2020 Estimate - Daytime Population
5,159
34,987
76,811
2025 Projection - Total Households
1,873
17,075
39,008
2020 Estimate - Total Households
1,900
17,282
39,698
2020 Estimate - Average Household Size
2,071
17,841
43,278
2025 Projection
2,440
19,375
46,432
2020 Estimate
POPULATION
HOUSEHOLDS
HOUSING UNITS 2,438
19,493
46,906
Owner Occupied
654
10,752
23,361
Renter Occupied
1,247
6,531
16,337
537
2,211
7,209
$51,262
$64,839
$60,645
Vacant HOUSEHOLDS BY INCOME (2020 ESTIMATE) Average Household Income Median Household Income
$39,464
$49,373
$43,130
Per Capita Income
$23,404
$27,450
$25,668
$110,042
$107,538
$97,948
PROPERTY VALUES 2010 Median Owner Occupied Property Value INCOME CENSUS TRACT INFORMATION 39113070101
Qualified
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 31
LOCAL POINTS OF INTEREST
9
DAYTON, OHIO
18
EDUCATION:
HARDWARE STORES:
1
Trotwood Madison High School
15
Ace Hardware
2
Trotwood Middle School
16
Home Depot
3
Westbrook Village Elementary School
17
Lowe’s
18
Tractor Supply
GROCERY SHOPPING: HOSPITAL:
4
ALDI
5
Dayton Nutra Foods
6
Gordon Food Service
7
Kroger
8
Meijer
20
Art Van Atta Park
9
Walmart
21
Meadowbrook at Clayton Golf Course
22
Miami Valley Golf Club
23
Sycamore State Park
24
Wegerzyn Gardens MetroPark
GENERAL SHOPPING: 10
Big Lots
11
CVS
12
Dollar General
13
Family Dollar
14
Northwest Outlet
32 | Wingate at Belle Meadows
19
Miami Valley Hospital North
PARKS & REC:
Wingate at Belle Meadows Apartments 2-Mile Radius Per Ring
23
4 8 19
20 21
3 6
13
5 17
16 10 12
1 24
2 15
11
14
7
22
Wingate at Belle Meadows | 33
Wingate at Belle Meadows EXCLUSIVELY LISTED BY
AHA S42 Jeremiah K. Jarmin | Senior National Director LIHTC 602.687.6690 jeremiah@mmaha.com License #: AZ SA694592000; GA 355022
AHA S8 Paul D. Davis | Founder 248.415.2630 paul@mmaha.com License #: MI 6506008394
Andrew S. Daitch | Executive Managing Director 248.415.2537 andy@mmaha.com License #: MI 6501302475
Steven A. Miscavish | Chief Financial Officer 248.415.2647 steve@mmaha.com License #: MI 6506046449
Seth I. Barnett | Senior National Director 248.415.2653 seth@mmaha.com License #: MI 6501346607
Matthew I. Kurzmann | Senior National Director 248.415.3036 matt@mmaha.com License #: MI 6501369303
Tyler J. Martin | National Director 949.419.3287 tyler@mmaha.com License #: CA 01457016
Gerson H. Askenazy | National Director Nonprofit 248.415.3013 gerson@mmaha.com License #: MI 6506047074
Alyssa Van Hyfte | National Director 248.415.2654 alyssa@mmaha.com License #: MI 6501421796
Neil B. Rosenthal | National Director 248.415.2657 neil@mmaha.com License #: MI 6501423232
LISTED IN CONJUNCTION WITH Nicholas Andrews | First Vice President Investments 513.878.7741 nicholas.andrews@marcusmillichap.com
Jordan Dickman | First Vice President Investments 513.878.7735 jordan.dickman@marcusmillichap.com
BROKER OF RECORD Michael Glass | Senior Vice President / Division Manager 216.264.2050 michael.glass@marcusmillichap.com