The
Davidsonian
Independent Student Journalism Since 1914
inside
davidsonian.com
Bella Andjelkovic ‘26 sheds light on upcoming library renovations
Volume 122 Issue 20
April 17, 2024
3
Vicki Burch ‘26 reflects on her experience with the Health Center, criticizes inaccessibility
4
Henry Rendle ‘27 considers effect of sports betting on Davidson community
5
The Yowl offers guidelines for students bands, gives song recommendations
8
Students Probe Financial Priorities Amidst Fundraising Campaign ABBY SMETANA ‘27 (SHE/HER) STAFF WRITER
E
ach spring, Davidson College calls on students, faculty, staff, and alumni for their annual financial day of giving called “All in For Davidson.” This day is full of social media content featuring community members and activities on campus for students to partake in, including pie-ing faculty members and entering raffles. Wednesday, April 10th marked the college’s 11th annual All in For Davidson event. According to Director of Annual Giving Morgan Bell Kee, Davidson was one of the first colleges to host a giving day, and the practice has now become a cornerstone of higher educational fundraising efforts for schools across the country. In addition to the money raised last Wednesday, All in For Davidson has raised over $11 million dollars over its 11-year runtime. “Our annual giving program consistently ranks in the top five nationally in terms of alumni giving participation, and All in For Davidson is one more opportunity for our broader community to share why they go all-in for Davidson, each and every day,” said Morgan Bell Kee. According to Bell Kee, the money raised from All in For Davidson is allocated to many different causes, but “the top three designations for the 2024 campaign were: The Fund for DavidsonUnrestricted, Davidson Trust/Scholarships, and Diversity and Inclusion Initiatives.” As part of All in For Davidson and other fundraising initiatives, the college emphasizes that it practices a “no-loan” policy, meaning that it meets financial needs without including any loans in its financial aid packages. “Davidson is proud to be one of about two dozen schools that practice both need-blind admissions while meeting 100 percent of calculated need through grants and campus employment. Our financial aid office also works with students to address financial crises in their families,” Director of Media Relations Jay Pfeifer said. Pfeifer elaborated on the financial support systems in place to support students once they are on campus. “The college has programs in place to meet unexpected hardships like the SAFE Program and the team at Lula Bell’s offers support and
programming for all students. We will continue to focus resources on meeting the needs of all of our students,” Pfeifer said. He also recommends perusing the list of resources available on Davidson’s Financial Wellness page. Though Davidson presents itself as financially supportive, some students feel otherwise and believe that the college is not “all-in” for their wellbeing. They find themselves taking out loans and enduring financial hardship to fund their study at Davidson and experience financial hardship. Meghan Lagoutine ’24 recently went public with her financial aid story in response to an
However, Marsicano emphasized that some students might take out loans due to an imperfect estimate of their expected family contribution. “When we have students who complain very much sincerely that their loan debt has gotten too high, it often has to deal with the fact that [...] what the expected family contribution is and what that student’s actual amount that they think they can pay are two different numbers,” Marsicano said. For Lagoutine, taking out loans was not a strategic choice — rather, it was a necessity for her to remain at Davidson. In a LinkedIn response to Marsicano’s original post, Lagoutine explained
This year’s “All in for Davidson” occcured on April 10th, while nearly 70% of students at Davidson are on some type of financial aid. Photo by Davidson College. email from college president Doug Hicks lauding the school’s aid program. “I saw that paragraph where Doug Hicks was sharing how we still proudly represent as one of the only colleges in the nation that admits students free of financial need, meet 100% of their demonstrated need, and do so without loans,” Lagoutine said. “That just triggered something in me because I was coming into Davidson expecting to graduate loan free.” Assistant Professor of Educational Studies Dr. Chris Marsicano explained in a LinkedIn post that about a quarter of Davidson students take out loans even though the school is technically loan-free. According to him, this discrepancy has multiple causes. Marsicano suggested that taking out loans can be a smart financial strategy for certain students. “If you qualify for subsidized loans, it’s a really good deal to take them out, even if you don’t need them [...] it doesn’t charge interest over time while you’re in school, and you don’t have to pay it back until six months after school,” Marsicano told the Davidsonian.
that she has taken out over a total of $39,000 in private and federal loans. According to her post, she did not take out loans her freshman year, but decided to do so her during her sophomore year, when her “financial aid package unexpectedly decreased by over $14,000.” Though Lagoutine appealed the financial aid package, her needs were still not met — she had to take out private and federal loans to pay her Davidson tuition and still lacks financial security. “I work at Union, and I’ll see student groups come and give tours, and they’ll talk about the no-loan policy. Every time I want to [say], ‘it’s not that simple,’” Lagoutine said. To make ends meet, she works four jobs and is on food stamps. Lauren Collver ’25 echoed Lagoutine’s sentiments and pointed out that the no-loan program does not work for all students. “I have a ton of loans; I work three jobs on campus. And then there’s also just another aspect that I think a lot of people don’t talk about, which is technically, right now, I couldn’t tell you if I’m coming back next year, because I don’t have my financial aid information.” The college will
release aid information over the summer, but until then, Collver and many other students will be uncertain of their financial aid packages. These students’ financial obstacles are hardly the exception. “I’ve had so many alumni and students reach out and say, ‘This is something I’ve struggled with too, and nobody talks about it. Thank you for sharing,’” Lagoutine said. Both Lagoutine and Collver have a complicated relationship with college fundraising initiatives, a bond marred by financial insecurity. They feel that the nature of giving at Davidson is performative and often isolates low income students. “The money [from fundraisers] goes to things that will give the college a good name, so they’ll be able to use my pictures from abroad and be like, here’s a way we supported a student,” Lagoutine, who is a recipient of a Dean Rusk grant, said. “All in For Davidson is all in for Davidson’s image.” Collver, too, has hesitations with the way the school advertises their generosity. “The one thing I find annoying is that they ask students to donate,” Collver said. “It does feel alienating to be in Union when [...] all of these students are being asked to give money and you realize that, you, as a low income student, are not who Davidson looks to.” Though Collver and Lagoutine expressed some frustration with the school’s fundraising campaigns and financial support, they appreciate the resources Davidson and its donors provide. “I’m obviously very grateful for everyone who has donated to the Davidson Trust. There would be no way I would be here if not for that,” Collver said. Lagoutine emphasized that, while she loves the college, she wants to hold it accountable. “The whole reason that I want to talk about this is because I don’t want to bring Davidson down. I love Davidson as a college and how it’s helped me grow,” Lagoutine said. “I do not know how to fix financial systems. My goal is to just be like, ‘this is something that needs to be addressed and shouldn’t just be shoved under the rug’ [...]I would say the people who have helped me most is the Davidson community, but it’s not the Davidson administration.”
Party Cancellation Prompts Backlash, Questions Campus Accessability
T
STELLA MACKLER ‘26 (SHE/HER) CO-EDITOR IN CHIEF
he open party scene is a defining characteristic of social life at Davidson. Parties hosted by Patterson Court Council, Walt, and any other organization are open to all students. However, when those parties are held in spaces that are physically inaccessible to students with disabilities, i.e. stairs are required to enter or they can only be accessed through grass which is difficult for students with mobility aids, Davidson’s inclusive nature is called into question. At the beginning of the spring semester Turner House moved into PC House 2, the former Sigma Phi Epsilon space on Patterson Court Circle. To celebrate their move, Turner planned a housewarming party to be held in their new basement in collaboration with Walt 1610, Davidson’s student radio station for Saturday, April 13. However, the party was canceled due to accessibility concerns communicated from the Davidson Disability Alliance (DDA)
and from within Turner members. The cancellation prompted an explosion of hateful messaging and misinformation. In planning the party, Turner’s social chair Georgina Haspel ‘26, was aware of the accessibility challenges presented by the basement, as it can only be accessed using stairs. “With the event on our minds for many weeks, I did know that the basement was inaccessible,” Haspel said. “And there wasn’t really any feasible safe option to make it accessible within our budget, and the time period, so that’s on me. The DDA had the social chairs in last semester to talk about accessibility.” In November of 2023, the DDA hosted an event with members of Patterson Court Council (PCC) organization and other groups on campus to discuss accessibility within hosting events. “One thing that was discussed at this event was basement parties, and how many of the basements of PCC houses are not accessible because they have stairs and no ramp, or they’re only accessible through grass, which would not be accessible for people with mobility aids or who have trouble walking,” said DDA Founder and President ST Hammer ‘24. “So we encourage organizations
to host their events in spaces that are accessible via a ramp if there are stairs and so this has been an ongoing conversation since that meeting.” At the same time, basement events are not uncommon at Davidson. There have been at least four basement parties in PCC houses this school year, including Boiler Room at the Kappa Sigma House in November and Pice’s performance at Rusk House in February. “We were kind of using the campus norm of we just gained a house with a basement,” said Turner President Evie Mulhern ‘25. “We’ve never had that before so we were really looking out at like, what other houses do;, almost every house in the court has hosted in their basement, many this semester. So it seems like this is a thing. So we will participate as well.” In an April 9 email to Turner and Walt social chairs and presidents, DDA Outreach Coordinator Zoe Moseley ‘26 and Vice President Rui Rui Bleifuss ‘26 expressed their concerns regarding the site of the party in the basement of Turner’s house. “By hosting the party in an inaccessible location, a portion of
CONTINUED ON PAGE 2