The
Davidsonian
Independent Student Journalism Since 1914
inside
davidsonian.com
Claire Kelly ‘25 reports on ongoing discussions of free speech on campus
Volume 122 Issue 18
April 3, 2024
3
Sola Omonije ‘24 is the focus of this week’s senior spotlight with Cameron Krakowiak ‘24
5
Josie Swain ‘27 speaks with student performers and bands at Walt Woodstock
6
The Yowl investigate the struggles white men face at Davidson, raises DEI concern
8
Sexual Assault Surivors Take Issue with College Response STELLA MACKLER ‘26 (SHE/HER) MADELINE RICHARD ‘26 (SHE/HER) CO-EDITORS IN CHIEF
O
ver half of women have experienced sexual violence involving physical contact in their lifetime, accoriding to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Davidson College is not immune to this statistic, and while the College has procedures in place to serve, protect and advocate for survivors, many find issues within the system. Maxine, whose name changed for privacy, is one such student. She sought help from the college soon after she was assaulted, but found administrative support unsatisfactory. Maxine experienced assault in the form of intimate partner violence during the spring 2023 semester. During the summer, she scheduled a meeting with Davidson’s Title IX Coordinator Carly Dix. “Ms. Dix and I started the meeting with an icebreaker that I suggested,” Maxine wrote in a statement to The Davidsonian. “I figured I was about to discuss one of the most traumatic experiences of my life to a total stranger, I might as well try to get to know her beforehand. Icebreakers completed, we dove right in. I provided as much detail as I could remember, date, time, and location on campus. I did not know what information was useful to my case, so I shared everything.” After recounting the story of her assault, Maxine found Dix’s response “jarring.” “After I was extremely vulnerable and emotional, she began to discuss different reports and resolutions,” Maxine wrote. “Imagine watching a super sad dog movie then having someone walk in and try to sell you insurance policies. She made no empathetic connection with me or acknowledged my pain. Instead, we were all logistics and business. I was hurt and confused while also frantically taking notes on what she was saying.” As Title IX Coordinator, Dix is legally responsible to meet the needs of students impacted by sexual violence. However, since her work serves all students, she is also legally prohibited from taking the side of one student over another. “What is different about my position as opposed to an advocate is I have to have that same empathy and legal boundaries for all the students I serve on this campus, meaning I cannot be biased in favor of one student over the other,” Dix wrote over email. Likewise, a Title IX Investigator Refresher Training from Georgia Institute of Technology stresses that investigators must remain unprejudiced throughout the Title IX process. According to the training manual, staying unbiased requires investigators to not make assumptions about a case based on sexual history, alcohol and drug use, gender stereotypes,
or other factors. Moreover, investigators should avoid conflicts of interest throughout the Title IX process, so developing a more personal relationship with either party might compromise their ability to do their job ethically. While impartiality is part of Dix’s job, it can make students like Maxine feel like they lack allies — particularly since students do not receive an official advocate unless they file a formal complaint. In a second meeting with Dix in July, Maxine searched for sources of support from the Davidson administration and was disappointed by what she learned. “My final follow up question was, ‘If you cannot be an advocate for me, who in Davidson’s administration can be my advocate?’ She told me unless I wanted to file a formal complaint then no one. Davidson partners with an off-campus
unheard, just as she had when she met with Dix that summer. “I was definitely really frustrated with the Dean of Students Office and the administration,” Maxine said. “I haven’t heard anything from her since. ” In response to a request for comment, Harris deferred to Dix. “She oversees this process and it is most appropriate that she answers your questions,” Harris wrote over email. For the rest of her fall semester, Maxine leaned on her friends for support and found a coincidental ally in Assistant Professor of Psychology Alesha Bond. Bond was leaving an evening event on campus when she saw Maxine upset outside of Chambers. “I saw her on the bench, just crying, you know,
April highlights Sexual Assault Awareness Month. Photo from National Sexual Violence Reource Center.
survivor group if students want to have more support and advocacy, but no one on Davidson could provide those services because it would be a violation of Title IX.” Maxine did not want to file a formal complaint and deeply internalized Dix’s lack of empathy, even though Dix is legally prohibited from sympathizing with one student over another. In addition to her statement, Maxine spoke to The Davidsonian about her experience of seeking out support from the college administration. In addition to meeting with Dix over the summer, when she returned to Davidson for the fall semester and a professor submitted a CARE referral for her. CARE (which stands for “Connection, Advocacy, Resources, Education”) referrals can be submitted by any Davidson community member about a student and connect them with the College’s CARE team. The team is headed by Assistant Dean of Students Angela Harris, who Maxine met with. During their meeting, Maxine mentioned that she had not felt supported during her interactions with Dix. “When I brought up my concerns about Title IX to the Dean of Students, she basically was like ‘Oh, I’m sorry, this happened to you, but this is not my jurisdiction or whatever. So I can’t do anything about it,’” Maxine said. Maxine left her meeting with Harris feeling
just very intense, loud crying,” Bond said. “I just kind of sat down, I was like, ‘You don’t have to say anything but I do want to make sure that you’re okay.’ I remember asking her what do you plan to do after you leave and she was like ‘I’m going to sit on that bench and cry.’” Bond and Maxine met again after this initial interaction. Bond said she wanted to ensure that Maxine felt a sense of validation. “I’m a human you know, a human with many experiences and I think a student in her position was very vulnerable, and just looking to feel heard,” Bond said. “That was something that she felt she was missing.” One obstacle Maxine faced in her search for validation was the fact that she did not want to file a formal complaint against her perpetrator. She was concerned about the impact the resulting procedure, which ranges from the student she accused accepting responsibility to a formal resolution involving an investigation and a hearing, would have on her life as a student at Davidson. “Davidson’s a small school,” Maxine said. “Filing a formal complaint against another student at Davidson, I mean, there’s no way to stay anonymous in that. I just want to be a student, and I love all the courses I’m in, the classes, extracurriculars, that sort of thing. I
percent of the votes. According to the New York Times, Stein is now in a tight race with his Republican opponent, Mark Robinson. Stein was raised in North Carolina, where he attended Chapel Hill High School. He graduated from Dartmouth College in 1988, and went on to teach English and economics
in Zimbabwe for two years. Following his stint in Zimbabwe, Stein returned to school and obtained a Master’s in Public Policy and Juris Doctorate from Harvard University. Before entering politics, Stein worked with the Self-Help Credit Union to transform abandoned drug houses in Durham into affordable family
don’t want to be known as the person who is going through this. I just don’t want my story to be so public at a very small school.” Filing a formal complaint with the Title IX Office would not make her case public knowledge, and Dix emphasized that in the majority of situation, she will only do what the student wants, “including taking no action or only engaging in actions that keep the identity of the student confidential.” Additionally, filing a formal complaint would result in Maxine being assigned an advisor, someone who could advocate on her behalf. “When students are considering filing a formal complaint I will get them assigned to an advisor if they do not already have one,” Dix wrote. “The advisor can act as their advocate, which means they only center one student’s perspective in their advising work. I think an advisor is absolutely needed as part of the holistic support the college provides. This is why we match students with an advisor early in the process as opposed to after a complainant has filed a formal complaint.” Dix also emphasized that many supportive measures are available to students, without them needing to file a formal complaint. “The Title IX Office has a robust supportive measures program that allows students to receive assistance with issues before they become policy violating behaviors,” Dix wrote. “In addition, students are able to receive many of the resolutions they are seeking via the supportive measures process.” However, because Maxine did not want to file a formal complaint, she did not receive that direct advisor support. Her desire to refrain from filing a complaint is not unique. Bond highlighted the many factors that can contribute to underreporting on college campuses and various barriers students may face. “Literature suggests that [...] people [may not report sexual assault] because of what they perceive the [Title IX] process is going to be,” Bond said. “These are the sorts of dynamics specifically related to campus that [...] drive things like underreporting,” Bond also discussed how, in her initial interaction with Maxine, some of Maxine’s first words to her were “please don’t report me.” As a professor, Bond is a mandated reporter, or “Responsible Employee” under Title IX, which means that she is required to report any violation of Title IX, including incidents of sex-based discrimination and sexual harassment. She noted that the concept of a mandated reporter can serve the opposite purpose of what it is intended to do. “One of the institutional factors that comes up just in research is what can feel like institutional betrayal,” Bond said. “[...] There are circumstances where a survivor may feel like they are more at risk, or that more harm will come to them because of this role.” Maxine’s experience epitomizes Bond’s
CONTINUED ON PAGE 2
Josh Stein Wins Democratic Party Governor Nomination
SAVANNAH SORAGHAN ‘27 (SHE/ HER) STAFF WRITER
C
urrent North Carolina Attorney General Josh Stein won the Democratic Party nomination for governor with 69.6
homes and the North Carolina Minority Support Center to raise money for small businesses across the state. Stein has occupied many roles in North Carolina’s government, each involving a commitment to public safety.
CONTINUED ON PAGE 2