9/19

Page 1

The

Davidsonian

Independent Student Journalism Since 1914

inside

davidsonian.com Langley Hoyt ‘19 reflects on summer as Stapleton Davidson intern

4

Volume 114, Issue 3

September 19, 2018 Davidson Football stuns nation with excessive scoring

5

Arts & Culture Double Feature: Humanities and Darts

6

Student engages class with suprising textbased argument

8

Students Debate the Ethics of Sabra Hummus

O

JAKE CARVER ‘21 STAFF WRITER

n September 5th, AJ Naddaff ‘18 posted a petition, now with 169 signatures, in the Davidson 2018-2019 Facebook group asking the college to replace Sabra food products in Union. The comments section of the post quickly became politically charged, in part because the grievances listed against Sabra were directly tied to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Sabra Dipping Company, LLC, a U.S. based company, is equally owned by PepsiCo and the Israeli Strauss Group. According to a page of its website that has since been removed, the Strauss Group provided food aid to the Golani Brigade, a division of the Israeli Defense Force (IDF) centered in the Golan Heights that is reputed for human rights abuses. Screenshots of this webpage can still be found on the Adalah website, a legal and human rights group supportive of Palestinians in Israel. Many of these claims originate from the Golani Brigade’s participation in Operation Cast Lead, in which well over 1,000 Palestinians perished in an attempt by the IDF to halt the illegal flow of weapons into the area. The ownership of the Golan Heights, located in the north of Israel, is a controversial subject in and of itself ever since Israel took over the area in 1967 after the Six Day War. Although the international community does not recognize the annexation, Israel controls most of the area in practice, with Syria owning the rest. What is designated as Palestine lies to the south, although many Palestinian communities can be found outside Palestinian boundaries. Layan Anabtawi ‘19, President of Davidson Students in Solidarity for Palestine, helped spread word of the petition early on and is currently discussing the issue with Davidson staff, primarily Union Station Manager Michael Wilson, to try to resolve the issue. A Palestinian herself,

CONTINUED ON PAGE 3

International Office Responds to Criticism

P

CATHY XU ‘21 STAFF WRITER

ost-graduate plans are a stressful matter for seniors, but international students face the added stress of obtaining permission to stay in the United States. Doing so requires either Curricular Practical Training (CPT) like work/study or internships granted by sponsoring employers who cooperate with schools, Optional Practical Training (OPT) which allows students to work for up to one year in their area of study, or a federally granted H-1B Visa for specialty occupations. Students also tackle hurdles like the ever-changing and tightening immigration laws, the lottery system, and employers who are unwilling to take chances by sponsoring them. Given all the above, it was not easy for Maria Antonia Bravo ’18, a student from Colombia, to acquire her post-graduate

position in Washington, D.C. However, she was ultimately unable to follow through due to legal issues and had to return to Colombia. Bravo worked three on-campus jobs and exceeded the twenty hour per week work limit that the U.S. Citizenship Immigration and Services (USCIS) imposes on international students. Bravo first learned about the restriction during her first-year orientation but forgot it by her senior year. She was reminded of the rule three weeks before her graduation after she had unknowingly violated it. Having failed to comply with the requirements necessary for her to maintain her visa status, Bravo became ineligible for her OPT and returned home. Bravo admitted, “I take every responsibility for not being more educated about the process...but on the other hand, I [had] been to [the former International Student Advisor’s] office many times before, encouraging her to do a mandatory meeting

for all international students. There are things that we should know that we are not doing.” In the past, international students have raised concerns about a lack of communication from the International Student Office’s administration. “There are a lot of legal procedures here if you’re not an American citizen, and it can get quite confusing,” says Ylin Wang ‘20. “Currently there’s no clear instruction... of legal procedures that international students can follow. ” The lack of communication between administration and students has resulted in many complications similar to Bravo’s situation. During his first year, Zouzou Debbs ’20 obtained a work-study job at the Ada Jenkins Center, only to find out that

CONTINUED ON PAGE 2

Just Admissions Rethinks College Policy

A

HOPE ANDERSON ‘22 STAFF WRITER

ccording to Princeton sociologist Thomas Espenshade, being a legacy applicant at an elite college or university is equivalent to adding 160 points to your SAT score. Some Davidson students want to change that reality. Legacy preference is the advantage an office of admissions gives applicants who have at least one alumnus parent. Emma Tayloe ‘19 thinks this edge is an “illogical adherence to tradition.”

Tayloe — a legacy student herself — is a leader in Just Admissions, a student movement advocating for a legacy blind admissions policy at Davidson. Just Admissions, as well as similar groups at schools across the country, sees legacy preference as an issue of both fairness and campus diversity. Since Davidson did not admit students of color until the 1960s, the vast majority of Davidson alumni are white. Thus, the advantages enjoyed by legacies do not apply equally to all groups of applicants. “By giving an advantage to a population that’s more likely to be white, more likely to be wealthy, and more likely to be otherwise

privileged, it seems like an intuitively and frankly kind of obviously unfair standard,” said Tayloe. According to Espenshade, top schools admit legacy students at around three times the rate of non-legacies. Christopher Gruber, Dean of Admissions, said in an email last year that for Davidson, that number is around two. Julia Bainum ‘21, another student involved in Just Admissions, agreed with Tayloe, and she added that prioritizing legacy students is superfluous, since students with college-educated parents already enjoy advantages throughout the college application process. “It makes me angry that I had all of these

things to make the college process easier, compared to somebody who doesn’t have parents who have gone through it before and was more worried about financial aid, and then on top of that I think it might be easier for me to get into a school that I want to go to,” said Bainum. One of the most common arguments in favor of legacy preference is that it increases alumni donations, which can then be used to fund things like scholarships for lower income students. However, the link between

CONTINUED ON PAGE 3


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.