__MAIN_TEXT__
feature-image

Page 1

Neighbourhood 10 OCTOBER 2020

PROPERTY & LIFESTYLE

East coast upswing Properties across all price bands are selling in Port Elizabeth and East London, page 4

2 60+ LIFESTYLE OPTIONS yourneighbourhood.co.za

4 RIVAL BUYERS INCREASE PRICES

4 CAPE TOWN’S TRENDING HUB

Connecting homeowners with great communities


2

PROPERTY

10 OCTOBER 2020

The perfect lifestyle for 60-plussers When comfort, aesthetics, technology, design and health precautions all come together smartly in a retirement estate, you’re all set WORDS: KIM MAXWELL • IMAGES: SUPPLIED risk groups of retirees interact in communal spaces and facilities, and explored aspects such as physical security, financial peace of mind, hospitality and continuous care.  ACCESS CONTROL Evergreen Lifestyle Villages MD Garry Reed says they learned from being forced to shift to virtual interactions. “During the toughest lock-down period, Evergreen had to relook onsite logistical procedures such as residents’ health monitoring and moving nurses to live inside its villages. We had to rethink how we operate daily, with clear definitions of shifts, roles and responsibilities on site. The way we approach design and layout now takes safety into account even more.”  Touchless access control was also implemented in villages. “Evergreen is continuously looking to improve the lifestyle and welfare of its residents through a combination of design development, innovation, technology and operations,” says Evergreen Lifestyle’s head of developments Julie Morelle. 

Evergreen, Bergvliet

E

ase into the retirement process gradually, by finding a home that provides for your current and future lifestyle needs. The rest will then fall into place. This is the advice future retirees are given. Yet deciding on a place to settle for your retirement years can be stressful, with concerns about hidden costs or feeling isolated from friends and family. Affordability, quality of life and safety concerns are often top of mind. Some downsize to a smaller home or townhouse, then find they have to move again as their mobility or health needs change. Residential estates are a onesize-fits-all option for retirees looking for community living in a secure environment. Some cater for multiple family and retirement phases. According to Devmark Property Group’s national sales manager Bruwer de Jager, the success of their

PUBLISHED BY TIMES MEDIA PROPERTY PUBLISHING

Retirement Collection villages lies in offering everything. “Location is of paramount importance. Our developments including The Plettenberg Manor, Helderberg Manor and Langebaan Manor are situated close to beaches, shops and restaurants. Furthermore, amenities usually include a clubhouse, hair and beauty salon, coffee shop, gym, assisted living suites and 24hour care — all in beautifully landscaped gardens,” he says. De Jager adds that garden and house-cleaning services make leading a lock-up-and-go lifestyle achievable. Retirement villages limiting visitor access and insisting on only gate deliveries for groceries during the pandemic, highlighted the importance of top-notch health security too. It’s why Evergreen has undergone a redesign of safe spaces for its seniors. The developer looked at how higher-

River Dale

EDITORIAL TEAM

ADVERTISING SALES

Editor: debbie.loots@thecreativegroup.info Subeditor: Marana Brand Designers: Peter Batistich & Samantha Durand Visit yourneighbourhood.co.za

Call us for advertising opportunities on 087 828 0423 Production (Editorial & Property Advertising): Lucea Goosen jhb@yourneighbourhood.co.za Online coordinator: Chantelle Balsdon chantelle@augmentcreative.com


10 OCTOBER 2020

PROPERTY

3

For instance, they made the design of units more compact, yet still offering comfort and quality. All homes have a private outdoor balcony or garden too — on top of communal recreational areas. “At Evergreen we embrace flexibility — designing more, yet smaller — amenities for socialising and coming together. Post-Covid we are fast-tracking the integration of technology: access control and communication with the outside world,” says Morelle. “We have since incorporated ‘hotelification’ as a diversified standard, as well as ondemand services, adapted to our residents’ needs and requirements.” GAUTENG VOLUMES A Lightstone survey investigated trends within the retirement property industry. Its findings were that, for the total volume of retirement properties transacted across South Africa over the past decade (2009 to 2020), the majority of transfers were conducted in 2013 in Gauteng (2,883), with the Western Cape showing a slight peak by 2017. This might help explain why Evergreen’s Broadacres Lifestyle Village in Johannesburg is described as “a firm favourite” by sales director Phil Wilson. The village consists of 144 – sold out – houses. Another 48 one and two-bedroom apartments were recently launched. Lightstone Property’s head of real estate Esteani Marx says the trend of Gauteng enjoying the most collective transfers in volume terms is not surprising. But she notes that when Lightstone “investigates the value bands in the retirement category, the view is rather different over the last decade”. Marx says Gauteng started enjoying higher

Oasis Life Burgundy Estate will be ready mid-2021 value transfers from 2010, and remained the front runner for those years. But from 2015, transactions in higher value bands started to climb in the Western Cape, and continued to do so until late 2019. Lightstone reports that, during 2018, the variance in value between the Western Cape and its closest competitor, Gauteng, was more than R1m. HIGHER CAPE VALUES Rabie Property Group has seen high demand for its upmarket Cape Town retirement estate homes, situated near family homes within Clara Anna Fontein Lifestyle Estate in Durbanville. Launched in 2018, Phase 1 of the

Oasis Life development is nearing completion, with 18 residents having moved in since June. The first phase includes 58 houses, plus a R25m clubhouse scheduled to open in December. Designed as the “heart and soul of the Oasis Life village”, a restaurant, healthcare suites, library and event space “will complete the well-rounded offering of Clara Anna Fontein” and set into motion “its hospitality-based lifestyle” according to Rabie director Miguel Rodrigues. For Devmark’s De Jager, geographic appeal is a no-brainer. “The Western Cape offers some of the most beautiful scenery in the

world and property in the province has become incredibly popular,” he says. HOTEL-STYLE LUXURY Bev Bloch, manager of Pam Golding Properties Specialised Southern Suburbs Retirement sales team, says she has seen “considerable interest” in Quadrant Gardens, a flagship lifestyle retirement development in Cape Town’s Claremont. She describes it as “hotel-style luxury with all the comforts of home”. A few of the 74 apartments are still available, priced from R3m to R6,4m for one to three-bedroom units, including penthouses. Managed by Cape Peninsula Organisation for the Aged (CPOA),

Evergreen is continuously looking to improve the lifestyle and welfare of its residents through a combination of design development, innovation, technology and operations JULIE MORELLE, HEAD OF DEVELOPMENTS, EVERGREEN LIFESTYLE

Quadrant Gardens is a joint venture with private developer Corevest. “In keeping with the latest retirement trends, all apartments are sold on a life right basis, through CPOA, who is responsible for rates, security, maintenance and building insurance,” says Bloch.    This year, Lightstone singled out Burgundy Estate near the Durbanville Winelands as one of SA’s top-10 most popular retirement estate choices for 60-plussers. Oasis Life Burgundy Estate is in its first phase of construction, with 24 houses and 33 apartments set for completion in mid-2021.  EAST COAST’S GROWING SHARE In Port Elizabeth, health, a community lifestyle and financial benefits are all part of the deal at the Amdec Group’s multigenerational Westbrook Lifestyle Estate. The development provides secure living in affordable designer homes with footpaths, running and cycling tracks. Their first development, The Ridge, is sold out and they have just launched their new village, River Dale. “Our vision of a walkable environment with homes and communal areas has come to fruition,” says managing director of Westbrook residential developments Clifford Oosthuizen. “The Ridge is already home to a happy and thriving community. We anticipate the same success for River Dale”.

Quadrant Gardens' herb garden, Claremont

An Evergreen Lifestyle retirement village is also planned and as there is a Curro school on the premises, offering grandparents a carefree retirement lifestyle while living in close proximity to their children and grandchildren. Westbrook residents’ safety is ensured through electrified perimeter fencing, guarded gatehouses, access control, CCTV and 24-hour foot, bike and vehicular patrols. All homes are also fitted with alarms and security systems.


4

NEWS

10 OCTOBER 2020

East London and PE see sales uptick

This smallholding is priced at R11.995m in Sardinia Bay, Port Elizabeth Pam Golding Properties in the Eastern Cape hubs of Port Elizabeth and East London reports escalating residential property sales across all price ranges, since June this year.

property as they perceive a better return on their investment in this asset class. Top-end sales are seen in the Nahoon Mouth, Glen Gariff and Beacon Bay areas where a home recently sold for R6,35m.

Stands are also selling in both cities, suggesting a demand for new homes.

Properties up to the R2m mark are also in high demand with popular areas such as Vincent and Beacon Bay fetching prices between R1,6m to R2,2m.

While the housing market here underperformed relative to the national market during much of the past decade, it has enjoyed stronger growth since late 2017, says Pam Golding Properties senior research analyst Sandra Gordon. According to Pam Golding Properties area principal in East London Sean Coetzee, people are spending more time at home since the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic, which sees them selling or upscaling to larger properties or moving to more expensive areas closer to schools, beaches and other amenities. He says investors are also buying

People buying in East London are mostly from the Eastern Cape areas such as King William’s Town and Mthatha, motivated by work transfers or seeking better schooling, says Coetzee. “Many first-time buyers who were renting are now buying because the low interest rate makes it more affordable.” Secure, lock-up-and-go properties remain in demand with sectional title sales increasing at prices ranging between R1,1m and R1,3m for a two-bedroom townhouse in a cluster development.

Justin Kreusch, an area principal for Pam Golding Properties in PE says family homes are in demand here with mostly locals either trading up or scaling down, and a small percentage of professionals relocating from other major centres. “We’ve seen unprecedented activity in areas such as Richmond Hill, Walmer, Summerstrand, Lorraine, Glendinningvale and Mount Croix,” he says. “Sales at the top end of the market include a 520m2, four-bedroom home in Little Walmer Golf Estate for just under R7m.”

Competing buyers push up asking prices Buyers competing for soughtafter homes priced below R2,5m are in some instances pushing up asking prices, according to fixedfee agency Eazi Real Estate.

“Our offer and administration processes have always been online, and going forward, more and more buyers and sellers are benefitting from this capability.”

“Not only are asking prices in this price band readily being achieved, they’re also sometimes exceeded, with these high-demand properties selling in one or two days,” says Eazi Real Estate's CEO Richard Day. “This happens when buyers submit competitive offers, resulting in properties being sold for above the asking price.”

With interest rates at record lows and no transfer duty payable on properties up to R1m, many of Eazi’s purchasers are first-time buyers and young couples or families, including those upsizing or downsizing.

According to Day, Eazi has seen sales increase by 166%, 366% and 200% respectively for June, July and August this year. He says although they sell most homes in less than 30 days, some properties are now being snapped up in just a few days. “Given our business model and technological capabilities, we were well-positioned and ready for lockdown. Our online systems were already in place, so we could adjust quickly and easily to the new regulations,” he says.

This trend is underlined by mortgage originator ooba, whose first-time buyers comprised 53.4% of total mortgages in August. Says Day, “The interest rate drop has had a marked impact on the number of buyers who have decided to buy rather than rent. "In addition, we’ve concluded a few linked sales where owners are upscaling and therefore not only selling their property but also buying bigger properties. And in the sectional title market, we are defintely seeing an increased appetite for homes with gardens.”

Port Elizabeth hasn’t experienced the expected countrywide buyers’ market post-Covid-19, instead, he says, well-priced properties aren’t staying on the market for more than a few weeks. “A property we thought would fetch about R2,1m eight weeks ago, was priced at R2,4m and sold at full asking price, a month later,” he says.

This Fish Hoek home sold for R2.75m

Cape Town’s East City on the rise Just nine months after launching to market, 63% of The Harri, a new 48-unit apartment block and mixed-use property development going up at 75 Harrington Street in Cape Town’s East City Precinct, has sold off plan. Only 16 of 42 studio apartments remain unsold, while just two of the six loft apartments are still on the market. Construction has already begun, with the completion date set for April next year. The Harri’s units are priced between R1,3m and R2m for a studio apartment and R2,5m for a two-storey loft apartment. The development, in the heart of Cape Town’s design district, offers a blend of apartment living with open-plan, tastefully furnished, co-living and co-working spaces, and includes fireplace lounges, a TV room with a large smart TV and access to Netflix, three dedicated Zoom (video chat)

rooms, a rooftop terrace with a gas braai and mini-bar area, and hotel-grade amenities like Wi-Fi, a concierge, a housekeeping service, and 24-hour security. “We sold right through lockdown,” says Jeff Kleu, co-developer with Steven Lampert, both of propertydevelopment company Sepia and Silk. “We sold to investors wanting to buy to rent, parents buying an apartment for their student kids or a holiday flat, and to locals as well as Zimbabwean, German and American nationals.” Harrington Street has been at the heart of the recent revival of the East City, which was previously a gritty industrial-commercial area. Major developments here include the upgrading of the Cape Town City Hall at a cost of R27m, The Old Granary at R31m, the purchase of the Nicro head office on Harrington Street by a European company, Groupe SOS, for R30m,

and the opening last year of a R75m five-star boutique hotel on Church Square. Sandra Gordon, research economist for Cape Town’s Central City Improvement District,

says, “Numerous applications submitted to the City suggest that a variety of new retail and food outlets are set to open their doors here, which will really cement the East City’s reputation as a trendy precinct that sees people flock to

the area at the weekend.” The Harri is close to the Gardens Shopping Centre, Virgin Active Wembley Square, and MyCiti bus stops. It's also an easy drive to major beaches from the CBD.


Neighbourhood

yourneighbourhood.co.za | 10 OCTOBER 2020

Neighbourhood

  5

What's ON SHOW this weekend?

MARKETPLACE

Get the full list at www.yourneighbourhood.co.za

There's no place quite like your neighbourhood www.yourneighbourhood.co.za

SEARCH BY SUBURB SUMMERSTRAND – R795 000

To advertise here contact 087 828 0423

ON SHOW SUN 3-5PM

Spacious Studio Apartment. Fully furnished catering for two occupants

All sorts of entertainment on your doorstep. Enjoy sitting at the pool with magnificent views on offer. Cross the road, walk, jog, bike on the promenade next to the sea. This must be the best position in Port Elizabeth and is a corporate disposal, therefore in the event of a vat vendor acquiring this valuable apartment, the vat portion can be claimed. Perfect for student accommodation. The purchase price at 7% interest over 20-years translates to a monthly payment of approx. R6 200.00 / month. On the bus route, central to everywhere. Secure. After the completion of studies, dispose of the unit and recover most of the university accommodation costs. Markers: Follow the marker from the corner Marine Drive and Brookes Road. At Dolphinarium. Call Sally 083 232 4162 or Alan 076 645 1708 to view.

BE A BETTER AGENT AND SELL MORE HOUSES

with Property Professional

Sign up for the newsletter and get involved on Facebook Sign up via propertyprofessional.co.za

Get balanced analyses of market and industry trends

Read and watch practical advice and useful how-tos

Be part of an industry community and increase your network

PROPERTY

PROFESSIONAL THE SOUTH AFRICAN PROPERTY INDUSTRY PORTAL


6 

Neighbourhood

yourneighbourhood.co.za | 10 OCTOBER 2020



Neighbourhood PROPERTY & LIFESTYLE

AGENT INDEX Keyhousing Development..............................6 Legal Eagle....................................................6 Sally Watkins Properties............................... 5

UITENHAGE / DESPATCH Talietha Holloway Properties........................ 7

Talietha Holloway Properties........................ 7

FOR BOOKINGS & ALL PROPERTY ADVERTISING ENQUIRIES CONTACT LUCEA ON TEL: 087 828 0423 Email: pe@yourneighbourhood.co.za

ON SHOW

Neighbourhood

Show house guide

Get it all at stneighbourhood.co.za

AS SHOW HOUSE TIMES VARY WITH EACH AGENCY, PLEASE CONFIRM THE TIMES BEFORE VISITING A SHOW HOUSE

SUBURB PRICE DIRECTIONS

AGENCY

Summerstrand R795 000

Sally Watkins Properties

Pointers: Follow the marker from the corner Marine Drive and Brookes Road. At Dolphinarium.

Whilst every effort is made to ensure correctness of the information, the Publisher does not accept liability for any errors or omissions.

KEY HOUSING PROPERTY DEVELOPERS

Claire Crescent, Ben Kamma, Port Elizabeth.

Built by one of PE’s leading developers

Selling Price R1 550 000 – R2 000 000

VIEW BY APPOINTMENT

Stunning Upmarket handcrafted face brick units available in this Sectional Title Townhouse Development. Several options available at present – choice of Plots and ďŹ nishes. Stylish 3 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom homes all have Granite Tops ďŹ tted to Kitchen and Scullery. All have large Open Plan living areas and Double Garages. Notting Hill boasts High-speed Fibre connectivity.

View Website: www.keyhousing.co.za

Claire Keogh -083 655 4699 / Larry Keogh - 082 448 9386

PROP 24 – 106175977 - 103656751 Articles appearing in the legal Eagle Column are sponsored by writer Kaplan Blumberg & the following Legal firms:

Tel: 041 363 6044

DEFAULTING ON MAINTENANCE OBLIGATIONS

maintenance does not pay, the primary caregiver of the child can bring an application for the enforcement of the Maintenance Order in terms of which a writ of execution or an emolument attachment order can be issued.

Having trouble with recovering maintenance that is due to you in terms of a Court Order?

The writ of execution allows the sheriff to attach the defaulter’s movable property, which can include a pension fund or provident fund, while the emolument attachment order will direct the defaulter’s employer to make deductions from the defaulter’s salary.

Failure to pay maintenance in terms of a Court Order is both a civil and criminal offence. If a parent who is obligated to pay

For assistance, contact our Family Law Department on 041 363 6044 or info@kaplans.co.za.


Neighbourhood

yourneighbourhood.co.za | 10 OCTOBER 2020

  7

ALGOA PARK

D BY SOL HEN STEP STEPHEN & TALIETHA 082 400 9510 082 442 6931

Tel/Fax 041 583 4583 e-mail: th@thprop.co.za ALGOA PARK

ALGOA PARK FREESTANDING FAMILY HOME

ALGOA PARK

ALGOA PARK GREAT STARTER.

D

This home offers 3 bedrooms, lounge,

D

CE

U ED

R

kitchen, bathroom all

This home offers

This home offers

2 bedrooms, lounge,

3 bedrooms, living area,

kitchen, bathroom, lock-up

3 bedrooms (bic), lounge, beautiful fitted kitchen, bathroom and toilet. R299 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

NORTH END

NORTH END FAMILY HOME / This home offers 3 bedrooms, lounge, kitchen, bathroom, secure parking for 2 vehicles R549 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

SIDWELL COVER YOUR BOND This property offers 2 houses on one erf with a flatlet and single garage. Both houses have 2 bedrooms, lounge, kitchen and bathroom and enclosed stoep. Secure parking for 6 vehicles. R949 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

CENTRAL IDEAL FOR BUSINESSES. This property consist of large warehouse with office, kitchen, toilet, single garage with outside storeroom on enclosed erf. R699 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

KWADWESI This home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms (1 mes), lounge, dining room, kitchen, double garage. R650 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

NEW BRIGHTON

SYDENHAM

BY SOLDHEN STEP

SECURE FAMILY HOME This home offers 3 bedrooms, open plan lounge to dining room, kitchen, bathroom, carport, flatlet with toilet and a storage. Enclosed boundary wall. Close to amenities. R420 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

BLUEWATER BAY IDEAL FAMILY HOME Come and view this neat home, it offers 3 bedrooms with built in cupboards, lounge, kitchen, bathroom and laundry. Beautiful private garden to enjoy, secure parking with carport. Close to schools and public transport. R699 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

YOUNG PARK This home offers 3 bedrooms with build in cupboards, 2 bathrooms with one main en suite, lounge, dining room. All open plan with spacious fitted kitchen, double tandem garage of which the front is converted into an indoor entertainment area with a build in braai. House has wooden floors. Front door leads onto swimming pool area and garden. R999 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

FOR THE INVESTOR / STUDENTS This beautiful home offers 2 bedrooms, lounge with fireplace, kitchen, bathroom and secure parking all in the heart of Central. R620 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

FOR THE YOUNG FAMILY This neat freestanding home offers 3 bedrooms with build in cupboards, bathroom with separate toilet, lounge and fitted kitchen, caport all on enclosed erf. R569 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

FAMILY HOME.

IDEAL FOR A FAMILY

OWN YOUR OWN BLOCK OF FLATS / STUDENTS. 1 x 7 Bedroom flat with kitchen, lounge, bathroom and courtyard. 1 x 3 Bedroom flat with lounge, kitchen, bathroom and courtyard. 1 x 2 Bedrooms flat with lounge, kitchen and bathroom and yard with secure parking. R1 299 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

STUDENTS.

STEPHEN 082 400 9510

DESPATCH

FOR THE YOUNG FAMILY. This spacious unit offers 2 large bedrooms (bic), beautiful bathroom, lounge, dining room, fitted kitchen, guest toilet and garage. R499 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

This unit offers

CALLING ALL INVESTORS. This property offers lounge, kitchen, 1.5 bathrooms, 6 bedrooms, storeroom, secure parking for 2 – 3 vehicles. The house can easily be converted back into 2 x 2 bedroom houses with a one bedroom flatlet for excellent rental income. R699 000

BEAUTIFUL FAMILY HOME. 3 Bedroom home, lounge open plan to dining room, beautiful kitchen with bic. 1 bathroom, no garage. It has a spacious yard that can accommodate 5 cars and its close to amenities. R380 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

R369 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

AANDBLOM.

This neat home offers 3 bedrooms with build in cupboards, lounge, beautiful fitted kitchen, bathroom with separate toilet and shower, garage with enclosed tandem carport, servant quarters plus neat one bedroom flatlet with lounge, kitchen and bathroom. All this on large enclosed erf. R980 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

MOTHERWELL

enclosed erf.

SWARTKOPS

ALGOA PARK SPACIOUS FAMILY HOME

KWADWESI

garage all on neat

STEPHEN 082 400 9510

STEPHEN 082 400 9510

SIDWELL

GREAT STARTER.

STARTER

R220 000 CASH ONLY

R350 000

BY SOLDHEN STEP

ALGOA PARK

kitchen and bathroom.

sliding gate.

NORTH END

STEPHEN 082 400 9510

CASH ONLY / GREAT

on enclosed yard with

ALGOA PARK

FOR THE YOUNG FAMILY This facebrick home offers 2 bedrooms with build in cupboards, lounge, kitchen and bathroom, carport all on spacious enclosed erf. R630 000

This home offers 2 spacious bedrooms with build in cupboards, neat tiled floors,modern bathroom, living area with open plan fitted kitchen opening onto spacious courtyard all in secure complex with secure parking. R550 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

STEPHEN 082 400 9510

CE

ALGOA PARK ALGOA HOF

This neat home offers 3 spacious bedrooms with build in cupboards, lounge, dining room, family room, 1.5 bathrooms, fitted kitchen, laundry, double garage and carport all on enclosed erf. R899 000

DU RE

FREESTANDING FAMILY HOME. This home offers 3 bedrooms, 3 living areas, bathroom, fitted kitchen, laundry, garage PLUS one bedroom flatlet all on corner erf. R839 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

TWO HOUSES ONE ERF. 2 Houses and flatlet. 2 Houses each offer 3 beds, 2 bath (1mes), lounge, dining room, kitchen, D/garage. Flatlet offers 2 beds, lounge, kitchen, bathroom and D/carport. R1 999 999 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

SUMMERSTRAND IDEAL FAMILY HOME This freestanding home offers 3 bedrooms with build in cupboards, lounge, dining room and family room, large kitchen, bathroom and carport all on spacious erf. R699 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

SPACIOUS AND STUNNING This home in the heart of old Summerstrand offers 4 bedrooms (bic), 2 bathrooms (1mes), formal lounge, family room flowing into diningroom and farm size modern fitted kitchen, study, pool with entertainment area with build-in braai, laundry, servant quarters with bathroom, double garage, PLUS spacious flatlet with kitchenette and bathroom. R2 699 000 STEPHEN 082 400 9510

Profile for Your Neighbourhood

Neighbourhood PE - 10 October 2020  

Neighbourhood PE - 10 October 2020  

Advertisement

Recommendations could not be loaded

Recommendations could not be loaded

Recommendations could not be loaded

Recommendations could not be loaded