World Business Times INSIGHT: United Arab Emirates
2
Markets resist urge to merge UAE bourses weather perfect storm but still face liquidity challenge
World Business Times is a leading global provider of business intelligence and insight
4
5
Bankruptcy law in the UAE New legislation aims to avoid past pitfalls and reassure investors
United Arab Emirates
UAE unfazed by economic challenges ahead
Sheikh Mohammed Bin Zayed Al Nahyan Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi
With the second largest economy in the Arab world, the UAE has pursued a conscious strategy to develop away from an oil-dependent economy since the country’s founding in 1971. Lower oil prices have made the UAE’s economic diversification practically prescient, and helped to place it ahead in the region with a GDP growth rate of 2.6% in 2017. That doesn’t mean the UAE is unscathed by the oil slump. The IMF has downgraded its forecast for the country’s economic growth twice in 2016, from 2.6% to 2.4%. The IMF praised the UAE’s consistent diversification efforts, but warned that
government anticipates generating over $3.3 billion in revenue, or roughly 1% of the UAE’s current GDP. The UAE also recently established the Federal Tax Authority, which has led to speculation that the country will follow the IMF’s recommendations to implement additional taxes. Taxation, even VAT, will have serious consequences for the UAE’s private sector. Additionally, how VAT revenue will be divided between each emirate and whether emirates may establish individual policies remains to be seen. Any move toward emiratespecific tax policies could undermine the UAE’s economic unity. SMEs are the heart of the UAE’s post-oil economic vision and each emirate hosts its own free zones with regulations set according to their own economic objectives. However, SMEs across the UAE have felt the pressure of the strong US dollar and slow global economy. SMEs make up 86% of the UAE’s total workforce and 60% of its GDP, according to Sultan bin Saeed Al Mansouri, the UAE’s Minister of Economy. Though they account for 94% of the UAE’s
operating companies, SMEs have felt the brunt of delayed payments, increased governmental fees, stagnant employment, and lower liquidity. Considered central to the UAE’s diversification policy, SMEs have struggled since oil prices hit their lowest point in 2014 and have yet to bounce back. New incorporations were up 18% in Q1 of 2016, but no data exist regarding how many have closed. Instead, the Emirates NBD sponsored Purchasing Managers Index (PMI) gives some insight. Lower oil prices slowed private sector growth as governments across the GCC tightened belts with cautious overtures toward austerity. The PMI showed the UAE’s non-oil private business sector activity falling from 54.1% in September 2016 to 53.3% in October 2016, the lowest level in six months. Though the PMI showed promising signs for a stronger Q4, employment stagnated and new work was subdued. The reduction in cash deposits with banks also had a negative impact on the private sector’s liquidity whilst governments sought relief from low oil prices through sovereign bonds
Geopolitical uncertainty How will political upheaval in the UK and US affect the UAE? Though Brexit may prove enriching for overseas investors, expatriates with UK-based real property and other investments, including pension plans, will see a significant reduction in value with no rebound in sight. The only certainty is change, especially following the UK’s decision to part ways with the EU and the surprise election of Donald Trump as President of the United States of America. The UAE now faces an uncertain era with two key allies embracing isolationist nationalism over international cooperation, whilst three on-going conflicts threaten stability throughout the MENA region. Though the long-term effects of these unprecedented events will take years to establish, the UAE, and the Middle East, can expect to see its relationships with the US and UK change on a fundamental level. In June, the world was shocked when the UK voted to leave the EU. Though it will be years before analysts and pundits can gauge Brexit’s full effect, in the short term, the move has proved a boon for UAE investors who have long favoured the UK property market. The British pound fell steeply following Brexit’s announcement and has failed to stage a meaningful comeback against a strong US dollar. According to multiple analysts and economists, the British pound is likely to experience fluctuations in value against the US dollar and the Euro as the British government
battles a court case about how Brexit can be triggered. “However, there is a huge amount of uncertainty around [the court case], and from that point of view I think sterling is at the very least likely to see a lot of volatility and still remains pretty vulnerable,” said Rabobank currency specialist Jane Foley. The UAE dirham’s increased purchasing power has already benefitted the portfolios of UAE-based investment funds. Abu Dhabi Financial Group LLC netted significant savings when it closed its purchase of New Scotland Yard due to the pound’s 22.7% fall against the UAE dirham, almost exclusively as a result of Brexit. Charles Pinchbeck, head of West End development at JLL, said the sale shows “continuing international confidence in the London market.” Though Brexit may prove enriching for overseas investors, expatriates with UK-based real property and other investments, including pension plans, will see a significant reduction in value with no rebound in sight. As the UK government continues to wrestle with how and when to invoke Article 7 of the Lisbon Treaty, uncertainty looms over whether London will retain its
A WORLD BUSINESS TIMES SUPPLEMENT PRODUCED BY: Vesna Obradovic, Managing Director & Editor; Tim Hydari, Editorial Director; Kerry Luck, Editorial Manager; Gavin Parsons, Senior Editor; Frank Kane, Contributing Editor; Dhruv Bahri, Creative Director
status as a global financial hub, and whether the EU can survive Britain’s exit as France enters an election cycle where a “Frexit” is a serious possibility and Italy has voted against a constitutional referendum, forcing Prime Minister Matteo Renzi to resign. Though Austria has managed to avoid the same fate by electing the Green Party’s Alexander Van der Bellen as president over far-right, anti-EU candidate Norbert Hofer, the EU’s future is looking increasingly bleak. Whether the EU will manage to survive or not, the UAE should focus on its relationships with member countries, positioning itself for trade negotiations if and when another exit occurs. GCC leaders have already signalled their readiness to continue relations with a post-Brexit UK by hosting UK Prime Minister Theresa May at the GCC Summit. There, Ms. May discussed the UK’s commitment to helping the region counter “Iran’s destablising activities” and working together to achieve joint safety initiatives and bilateral trade ties. Though the country has always held its own policy in the MENA region, as it exits the EU, direct economic and security interests are likely to take precedence. Of working directly with GCC countries after Brexit, Ms. May said in a recent statement, ‘There is so much we can do together – whether it is helping one another to prevent terrorist attacks, Gulf investment regenerating cities
British Prime Minister Theresa May meets with GCC leaders
across the UK, or British businesses helping Gulf countries to achieve their long term vision of reform.” What will be more of a struggle is how the political uncertainty introduced by Brexit will affect the UAE and the region. As Scotland and Northern Ireland discuss breaking from the UK, the UAE could see its former ally fracture into three separate countries with competing interests. In another surprising move, Donald J. Trump was elected as US President following a deeply contentious, and at times openly antagonistic, campaign. Whether Mr. Trump is committed to implementing any of his campaign promises remains to be seen; however, his vow to “Make America Great Again!” underscores one unchanging theme - an inward-looking, increasingly isolationist America. For the MENA region, American policy has often been a delicate, but largely predictable, tightrope act balancing competing interests and open conflict. American administrations change regularly but its Middle East
w w w. w o r l d - b u s i n e s s t i m e s . c o m
and drawing down on savings, which further stressed the money market. The construction, hospitality, and tourism sectors supported the economy, but SMEs absorbed most of the pressure. The new federal bankruptcy law may provide relief, allowing ailing SMEs to restructure and removing some criminal liability for company debts. However, an increased focus on relieving day-today economic issues would better serve the UAE’s overall economic vision, such as increasing incubator funding for national and expatriate SMEs, adjusting regulatory frameworks to boost e-commerce, and working with banks to ease borrowing and loan restructuring. China remains a bright spot in the UAE’s economic landscape. The countries maintain strong bilateral trade ties, and Chinese companies continue to establish regional offices in the UAE to access the MENA market for a diverse range of goods. The UAE is clearing the way for Chinese investors with a commercial representative office in Shanghai as well as holding several joint
conferences and exploratory meetings. Chinese construction and engineering companies are now moving into the UAE’s lucrative property development sector. China State Construction Engineering Corporation (Middle East) LLC is a regular joint venture partner with major UAE developers. Tourism from China has increased significantly, particularly for Dubai and Ras Al Khaimah, but China has suffered its own economic setbacks. Real growth is at the slowest level in 25 years while debt is high. Though a Chinese economic meltdown is unlikely, there is cause for concern and caution going forward to gauge whether actual growth develops. The UAE hasn’t discounted longstanding trade partners, including the UK. Prime Minister Theresa May has made overtures to the GCC to set the stage for a new future following Brexit. She noted that, “As the UK leaves the EU, we should seize the opportunity to forge a new trade arrangement between the UK and the Gulf.” Ms. May recently attended the GCC Summit, becoming the first UK prime minister to attend and the first female leader to meet with GCC leaders collectively. At the Summit, GCC and UK leaders issued a joint statement, declaring that, “We will make it a priority, when the UK leaves the European Union, to build the closest possible commercial and economic relationship, and [work] even more closely with business to promote actively GCC-UK economic engagement beyond current levels.” Ms. May also emphasised that, “I want these talks to pave the way for an ambitious trade arrangement.” Through hard work, the country is better positioned to transition to a less oil-dependent economy, but continued collaboration between emirates and cautious reflection coupled with careful action going forward will ensure the UAE’s vision becomes a reality.
foreign policy remained more or less consistent. Mr. Trump’s election as the new American President casts doubt on a previously steady policy direction. No one yet knows how a Trump presidency will affect the Middle East. As the transition begins to take shape, few elements have materialised into substantive policies. One possible point of clarity has emerged with the appointment of Mr. Trump’s foreign policy team. Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn, Mr. Trump’s selection for national security adviser, has shown a singleminded focus on combating “radical Islam,” and has repeatedly claimed Iran supports terrorist groups around the world. Both Lt. Gen. Flynn and Mr. Trump strongly disagree with the Iran nuclear deal, with Mr. Trump threatening to withdraw US backing to the dismay of European partners. Such a move could also anger Russia who has been thawing its own relationship with Iran recently. Though pulling out of the deal is easier said than done, Mr. Trump’s recent announcement that the US will not ratify the TransPacific Partnership indicates he could follow through with his threat, leaving European allies in the difficult position of deciding whether to press on or abandon the deal entirely. These developments suggest an increased commitment to isolationism with a more transactional relationship set to emerge with regional power players like Saudi Arabia and the UAE. As Lina Khatib, head of the Middle East and North Africa division at Chatham House stated, “It’s an approach based on turning a blind eye to many international issues with the idea of building a
metaphorical wall around the United States and diverting attention to national security in a way that defines national security from a rather narrow perspective.” It’s doubtful Mr. Trump’s administration will expend significant energy tackling difficult international diplomacy when there is business to be done. His son, Donald Trump Jr., met with members of a pro-Russian French think tank in October to discuss resolving the Syrian conflict. Such a meeting suggests that Mr. Trump will support Russia’s plans to lay the groundwork for resolution, in keeping with previous statements to work closely with Mr. Putin. Mr. Trump’s own personal real estate investments in the UAE suggest he believes the nation continues to offer a financial safe haven in a troubled region. It remains to be seen whether business ties will prove stronger than Mr. Trump’s inflammatory campaign rhetoric. His statements advocating the torture of terror subjects, registering American Muslims, and possibly banning Muslim visitors could decrease GCC investors’ appetite for US-based investments. Still, with both the UAE dirham and the Saudi riyal pegged to the US dollar, any real break with the US is unlikely, leaving the UAE to navigate uncertain terrain for the time being. For the UAE, the US and the UK have introduced a new element to long-standing relationships – uncertainty. Coupled with depressed oil prices and regional instability, the UAE should prepare itself for a time of global and local transition where anything is possible but nothing is certain.
Lower oil prices are a harsh reality and the UAE’s vision of a diversified economy must now face the true test of implementation. Unity is key to transition in GCC region.
curbing government spending and cutting remaining energy subsidies were essential to future growth and development. As 2017 dawns, the key to ensuring the UAE’s vision will continue to rest on its ability to maintain a strong, unified presence throughout the region and the world. His Highness Sheikh Mohammed Bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi and Supreme Commander of the UAE Armed Forces, supports the country’s unified economic vision as critical to the success and stability of the nation and its citizens. “Do not be concerned as long as our nation is united.” Though each emirate has pursued individual economic objectives, the country has adopted a collaborative economic plan for a diversified economy. This unified effort means the UAE is introducing the previously unthinkable – taxation. VAT is considered a game-changer for the country’s own development plans and for the GCC. The UAE will introduce VAT in 2018 for businesses with $1 million of revenue or more. The rate is expected to be 5% with some industries exempted. The
Travel, trade and tourism still the dynamo of UAE growth
December 14, 2016
WORLD BUSINESS TIMES INSIGHT REPORT DISTRIBUTED BY THE DAILY TELEGRAPH
Al Maryah Island, Abu Dhabi’s business and lifestyle destination
Crossing the three T’s
This report is produced and published by World Business Times, which takes full responsibility for the content