Egypt Insight Report 2017

Page 1

World Business Times INSIGHT: Egypt

2

The perception problem Egypt reboots its economy with FDI up $3.3bn.

4

World Business Times is a leading provider of global business intelligence

6

Healthcare sector needs a booster shot Soaring costs create turmoil whilst the government addresses concerns by bolstering medical tourism.

Inside Egypt

The Six by Six plan Egypt’s Minister of Tourism, Yehia Rashed, explains his plan to revive the country’s battered tourism sector.

www.world-businesstimes.com

22 August 2017

WORLD BUSINESS TIMES INSIGHT REPORT DISTRIBUTED BY THE DAILY TELEGRAPH

President Sisi gambles on economic overhaul By floating the pound, agreeing to the IMF’s terms, and imposing VAT, Egypt goes all in, leveraging substantial risks to gain huge rewards and get the economy back on track. Last year, Egypt faced stark economic realities, including the Central Bank’s dwindling foreign currency reserves, a sizable budget deficit, and low growth rates. In November, President Abdul Fattah El-Sisi implemented stringent reforms to address long-standing economic issues. “It is crucial to recall that Egypt has passed through an acute crisis since January 2011 [i.e. the Egyptian Revolution],” said Mr Sisi, in an exclusive interview with World Business Times. He continued, “The economic challenges that I confronted as the elected president in June 2014 were enormous and I had to come up with an effective and credible plan with a package of programs and projects to put the economy back on course and alleviate the suffering of the Egyptians”. Mr Sisi sees a clear path forward under his leadership: “I was elected President with a clear mandate to usher Egypt into a new era of stability and development, and to lay the political and economic foundation

of a modern, democratic, and prosperous state that can fulfil the aspirations of the Egyptian people and the next generation for a better tomorrow.” The floating of the Egyptian pound has been the most significant move so far. The pound has lost more than half its value since liberalisation, which caused increased production costs and reduced buying power. The cessation of fuel subsidies and the introduction of value-added taxes (VAT) added to the woes of Egyptian producers and consumers alike. Industries like real estate and the construction sector have been the most impacted. The rising cost of building materials, especially cement and steel products, collectively threaten the viability of specific projects as well as entire firms. The IMF directed Egypt’s economic reforms after approving a $12 billion loan to revive Egypt’s economy. Experts confirm that while the reforms may aggrieve consumers and producers in

the short term, they will have long-term benefits including foreign investment. Mr Sisi expressed hope that the long-term benefits of these reforms will outweigh the short-term burdens: “In recounting the achievements of the past two years, it is equally important to emphasize that our plan cannot bear fruit overnight.” He added that, “economic transition is never easy, and creating a new model of economic growth takes time”. Mr Sisi’s economic scheme has also been complicated by ongoing development for New Cairo Capital City, a key mega-project in Egypt’s bid to woo foreign investment. The China State Construction Engineering Corporation (CSCEC) signed a Memorandum of Understanding worth $3 billion for the development of government buildings in the new city. However, CSCEC withdrew its support from the project in early 2017 following disagreements over pricing,

throwing Egypt’s emerging partnership with China into doubt. Local contractors will now build the governmental facilities, but most analysts still believe China Fortune Land Development Company (CFLD) will bring $20 billion of support to the project, though no agreement has been signed. Despite these challenges, Egypt is faring relatively well in the region. It ranked highest in Moody’s economic strength assessment for the Middle East and north Africa. But as Egypt finds its economic footing, it must also address its recent past, and current sectarian divisions. Former President Mohamed Hosni Mubarak was recently released from prison after Egypt’s top appeals court cleared him of any responsibility for the scores of protestor deaths during the 2011 uprising. The move is seen by some as the final resolution of the Arab Spring, and the return of the military’s dominance in Egyptian politics. However, with the 2018 presidential election approaching, what matters most is delivering tangible benefits to the Egyptian people.

Abdul Fattah El-Sisi, President of Egypt

The three Rs: reform, return, revive El Sisi’s government going all out to return Egypt’s shine to foreign investors’ eyes. Investors have been keeping their distance from Egypt for over six years. The government recently issued a new investment law and other business-friendly regulations to restart stable economic growth. Meanwhile, significant difficulties due to economic reforms bordering on austerity and widespread security concerns still remain.Though FDI to Egypt is slowly regaining traction, significant risks remain in spite of recent reforms. According to Dr Sahar Nasr, Minister of Investment and International Cooperation, FDI from new investments have steadily increased in the last half of 2016 and the first half of 2017. As a result, Egypt surged to fifth place from fifteenth in the Financial Times’ fDi Markets report on global FDI inflows for green field investments. These figures suggest that the new government initiatives are working. Egypt’s currency float has been a major factor by itself in reviving investors’ interest. Speaking exclusively to World Business Times, Ahmed Ezz, founder and majority shareholder of Ezz Steel, noted the economic difficulties Egypt suffered pre-currency liberalisation: “An overvalued Egyptian pound has led to increased imports at the expense of local production sectors, including manufacturing and agriculture.” Though the pound rapidly lost half its value and inflation increased, the fallout has not been calamitous. Mr Ezz believes that the pound’s devaluation is helping the economy. He said: “The recent successful free floating of the Egyptian pound, with its concurrent devaluation, will rebalance our trade deficit. Imports are already decreasing. Exports are on the rise.” He also sees

the economy reaping significant growth over the next fiscal year due to the government’s economic reforms. He noted: “Short and medium term, the Egyptian economy will go through a strong phase, expanding at 7 per cent and above post-2017. This is against a backdrop of a currency devaluation that will positively affect all of Egypt’s productive sectors.” Mr Ezz’s optimism seems well placed. Egypt has traditionally been import-dependent, which has fuelled its hard currency shortage. However, according to a February 2017 statement from Egypt’s Central Bank, imports dropped by $800 million in Q1 for FY 2016/2017. With exports increasing by 25 per cent in January, Mr Ezz’s predictions appear to be coming true. Other sectors are also catching the eye of would-be foreign investors. Real estate development remains a popular choice, but the industrial and manufacturing sectors are receiving increased attention. “I see such opportunities primarily in the industrial sector,” said Mr Ezz. “Egypt could be a manufacturing hub for North Africa and the Middle East,” he continued. When interviewed by World Business Times, Tareq Kabil, Egypt’s Minister of Trade and Industry, echoed Mr Ezz’s sentiments. He said: “My vision is to make Egypt into the manufacturing facility for Africa. We opened five commercial offices on the continent, and it is one of our major focuses.” Both private and public sectors have plans to bolster Egypt’s manufacturing industry, which foreign investors should find attractive. Though optimism is in the air, Egypt’s current ranking is 122 out of

190 in the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business report. One long-standing hurdle that has repeatedly frustrated foreign investors is the complicated and lengthy licensing process. The government is restructuring its regulatory environment to shake off its reputation as a difficult country for business. “We’re working very hard to have a complete economic reform,” said Mr Kabil. “The new investment law will remake Egypt’s business environment, paving the way for foreign investors to harness the country’s abundant resources,” he continued. Mr Ezz believes that the government must ‘rise up to the challenge,’ whilst acknowledging that the new investment law is a step forward. Among the new provisions in the investment law is a change to the key performance indicators for government authorities, which will be tied to business development to curb corruption, and improve performance in a system many view as overly complicated. Even more interesting will be the creation of the General Authority for Investments and Free Zones, which will serve as a ‘one-stop shop’ for incorporation. There are also some encouraging fiscal amendments, such as the reduction of customs rates from 5 per cent to 2 per cent for tools, equipment, and machinery. These fundamental reforms are an encouraging first step; however, to tempt FDI to return, the government will need to follow through with timely and consistent modifications that embrace change. Otherwise, wary investors could decide that promises of reform are simply not worth the risk.

With change in the air also comes a renewed interest in public-private partnerships to create an investment channel for foreign investors. As Mr Ezz noted: “The Egyptian private sector has already accumulated capacity and expertise.” Mr Ezz believes the public sector must now work with the private sector to generate overall economic growth. An Ezz Group subsidiary, EZ-

The recent successful free floating of the Egyptian pound, with its concurrent devaluation, will rebalance our trade deficit DK, serves as a case in point where a strong public-private partnership has maintained both growth and resilience for over 17 years. With Ezz Steel as Egypt’s leading steel producer, the creation of EZ-DK and the government’s minority stake helped generate awareness regarding what these partnerships can do for the economy. Though there has been substantial progress in revamping Egypt’s business climate, there is still considerable concern about fully embracing Egypt-based opportunities. Following multiple attacks against Egypt’s Coptic

Christian community, President Abdel Fatah El-Sisi ordered a three-month state of emergency. The order gives the government extensive powers, including the ability to close businesses and seize property. As Egypt combats terrorism at home, its efforts could negatively affect its drive to attract FDI. Along with Mr Sisi’s order, Egypt’s political landscape is still working toward stability. Those connected with former President Hosni Mubarak’s regime remain targets. After Mr Mubarak was removed from office, Mr Ezz faced prosecution due to his government connections. He served four years in prison before being granted bail after Egypt’s Court of Cassation overturned the lower courts’ ruling and ordered a retrial. Mr Ezz understood the political motivation at work. He said: “In 2011, a revolutionary fervour gripped Egypt. There was a price to pay by almost all of the previous regime frontline politicians. I understand the motivation and consequences behind the allegations of wrongdoing. I have always insisted on my innocence of all such allegations.” The fervour appears to be rising again. Mr. Ezz now faces nearly identical charges and was re-arrested shortly after speaking to WBT. He was released on bail after being imprisoned for nearly six months. At a time when the government is pushing for new investment, arrests of industry leaders could create a chilling effect that would be difficult to fix. As the current regime tries to sort its friends from its enemies, foreign investors are watching, wondering if a new Egypt is ready for business or if this is simply the calm before the storm.

A WORLD BUSINESS TIMES REPORT PRODUCED BY: Vesna Obradovic, Managing Director & Editor; Tim Hydari, Editorial Director; Kerry Luck, Editorial Manager; Gavin Parsons, Senior Editor; Dhruv Bahri, Creative Director; Elizabeth Campero, Country Manager This report is produced and published by World Business Times, which takes full responsibility for the content

The modern Cairo skyline

A canal built on hope Expansion of the critical Suez Canal could invigorate Egypt’s economy but concerns linger over the returns and cost.

Expansion of the Suez Canal

Forming the foundation of the main trade route linking Europe and Southern Asia, the Suez Canal sees 7 to 10 per cent of all yearly global seaborne trade, and is recognised by Egypt’s business community as the backbone of the country’s economic future. The Suez Canal Economic Zone (SCZone) was unveiled in 2015 alongside the Egyptian Army’s ambitious expansion of the original canal at a cost of $8.4 billion. The expanded canal is expected to generate an additional $13 billion in revenue by 2023 from the current $5 billion. The goal is to increase the Suez Canal’s share of Egypt’s economy from 30 per cent to 35 per cent, though no deadline has been given to achieve this target. There’s room for optimism in 2017 as March and April saw a 4 per cent increase in revenue over the same period last year. Traffic through the canal has stablised after falling steadily last year. The number of vessels transiting through increased by 28 per cent in March and 22 per cent in April, with a year-over-year growth of 4 per cent. There is some concern that these figures do not represent organic growth. They could be in response

Continued on page 2


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.