Compliance Journal July 2022
Special Focus Overview of Latest Interagency Community Reinvestment Act Proposal On June 3, 2022, the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (FRB), Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), and Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) (collectively, the Agencies) issued a joint proposed rule (Proposal) to revise existing Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) regulations. The Proposal is meant to update how CRA activities qualify for consideration, where CRA activities are considered, and how CRA activities are evaluated. The Proposal comes after much advocacy by Wisconsin bankers and the WBA for a jointly-issued uniform rule between the Agencies. The Proposal is substantial and includes 180 specific questions for which the Agencies seek feedback in preparation for a final rule. The following is an overview of the Proposal broken down by section. The overview does not cover every nuance of the Proposal, so for more details regarding a particular section, please review the Proposal itself. A link to the proposed rule is included at the end of this article. Proposal Section III: Community Development Definitions. Under the current CRA regulations and the Proposal, a bank may, depending on its size, be evaluated for its community development lending, investments, and/or services under various tests. The activities must have community development as their primary purpose. Community development activities currently fall into four broad categories: affordable housing; community services; economic development; and revitalization and stabilization. The Agencies have proposed to review the community development definitions in order to clarify eligibility criteria for different community development activities by including eleven categories that establish specific eligibility standards for a broad range of community development activities. The new definitions incorporate some aspects of guidance that are currently provided in the Interagency CRA Questions and Answers. The proposed definitions reflect an emphasis on activities that are responsive to community needs, especially the needs of low- and moderate-income individuals and communities and small businesses and small farms. Section III discusses proposed definitions for community development activities, including: affordable housing; economic development that supports small businesses and small farms; community supportive services; revitalization activities; essential community facilities; essential community infrastructure; recovery activities in designated disaster areas; disaster preparedness and climate resiliency activities; activities with minority depository institutions (MDIs), women’s depository-institutions (WDIs), low-income credit unions (LICUs), and Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs) certified by the Department of the Treasury, referred to as Treasury Department-certified CDFIs; financial literacy; and qualifying activities in Native Land Areas. The Agencies propose using a primary purpose standard for determining eligibility of the above activities, with pro rata consideration for certain affordable housing activities. The Proposal provides background and current approach information for each of the above activities. Specific questions to each activity are embedded in the section to correspond to each activity for which the Agencies seek feedback thereon. Proposal Section IV: Qualifying Activities Confirmation and Illustrative List of Activities. Currently, as part of CRA examinations, banks submit community development activities that were undertaken without an assurance the activities are eligible. Knowing that an activity previously qualified can frequently provide banks with some confidence that the same types of activities are likely to receive consideration in the future. However, new, less common, more complex, or innovative activities might require examiner judgment and the use of performance context to determine whether an activity qualifies for CRA purposes. As a result, banks might know only at the end of an examination—and after a loan or investment has been made or a service provided—whether an activity will receive CRA credit. To provide additional certainty in determining what community development activities qualify, the Agencies have proposed maintaining a publicly available illustrative, non-exhaustive list of activities eligible for CRA consideration. The Agencies also propose including