The independent newspaper of Washington University in St. Louis since 1878 THURSDAY, OCTOBER 19, 2023
VOLUME 145, NO. 7
WWW.STUDLIFE.COM
FIRE IN U CITY
STILL UNDEFEATED
Burning apartment on Clemens forces students out of residence (News, pg 3)
#2 women’s soccer tops NYU, heads into high-stakes weekend. (Sports, pg 6)
Pro-Israel rally held on Mudd Field and pro-Palestine protest is postponed: Recapping student organizing on Oct. 13
ART MART
Armour and Sam Fox collab showcases student vendors (Scene, pg 4)
SU Senate discusses free speech after backlash from statement on Israel-Hamas conflict ALIANA MEDIRATTA JUNIOR NEWS EDITOR
JAMIE NICHOLSON | STUDENT LIFE
Students gather on the Mudd Field and wave Israeli flags at a rally on Friday morning.
NINA GIRALDO JAMES ELLINGHAUS SENIOR NEWS EDITORS
Two rallies on Washington University’s Mudd Field were scheduled for Friday morning in response to the latest IsraelHamas war: One to show support for Israel, and another to protest the Israeli government’s blockade of food, water, and electricity in Gaza. Hours before the scheduled times, the rally supporting Palestinian citizens was canceled due to organizers’ concerns for the safety of the protestors, leaving only the pro-Israel rally to gather on Mudd Field as planned.
Recap of the Pro-Israel Rally
Members of the University community gathered to show their support for Israel, pray for Israeli citizens and soldiers, and condemn antisemitism on Mudd Field at 9:45 a.m., Oct. 13. Roughly 100 students, professors, administrators, and staff members attended the rally, many of whom wore blue and white and carried Israeli flags. The event was organized by student leaders from the Jewish Student Association (JSA) and the WashU Israel Public Affairs Committee (WIPAC), but was
not affiliated with any particular student group due to the range of beliefs that exist within each organization, according to junior and JSA President Sonya Kest. The rally began with everyone singing the American and Israeli national anthems, followed by prayers for soldiers in the Israeli Defense Force (IDF) and Israeli hostages taken by Hamas. Kest said in a speech to the rally that Hamas exists to destroy the Jewish nation of Israel, and that support for Hamas is antisemitism masquerading as anti-Zionism. “There is zero moral equivalence between a Jewish nation, who dreams of peace with her neighbor, and Hamas, the evil terrorist regime hell-bent on destroying Israel, even at the price of its own citizens,” Kest said. Kest said she organized the rally to demonstrate support for Israel and provide a space for Jewish people to feel proud. “What’s going on with the Palestinians in Gaza who are under a terrorist regime is unfortunate, but it doesn’t mean that Israel doesn’t have the right to defend itself against terrorism,” Kest said. Junior Rayna Auerbach, Co-President of WIPAC, spoke to the pro-Israel crowd about the important role that Israel has
played in her life. She said that Israel is the only democracy in the Middle East and a defender of women’s and LGBTQ+ rights. She added that she feels not only safe, but also celebrated for her identities in Israel. After the speeches, the attendees broke out into song and dance to end the rally on an optimistic note. Following the event, a source, who chose to remain anonymous for safety concerns and will be referred to as X, said to Student Life that they decided to come to the rally because of their family’s history of experiencing and resisting antisemitism. “My grandma is a Holocaust survivor, so it’s always been embedded in my family to support the Jewish people and their history, like being here and making sure that something like that doesn’t happen again,” X said. Like others at the rally, junior Zev Kupferman has close family and friends in Israel. He said he feels helpless being so far away. “It’s really hard to walk around campus right now and see everyone going about their productive, normal day — and me not being able to work,” Kupferman said. “It’s just tearing at me to see everyone so normal, and my whole
world is on fire.” Kupferman said that he had originally not planned to come to the rally because he believed it was not productive to uniting the community. He offered a message of unity and support the night before at the vigil for Israelis killed by Hamas. “Why provoke?” Kupferman said. “Right now, we just need to spread love and unity. But I think [the pro-Israel rally] ended up doing that.” He said that he decided to come to the rally after hearing of a proPalestine event happening at the same time on Mudd Field.
Intentions behind the delayed Pro-Palestine Protest Until early Friday morning, a pro-Palestine protest was planned to take place on Mudd Field at 10 a.m., fifteen minutes after the proIsrael rally began. The idea for the protest began as an off-campus effort organized by Muslim student leaders at multiple St. Louis universities. First-year Hadia Khatri said that the event was going to peacefully protest the Israeli blockade on food, water, and electricity going to Gazan civilians, of which approximately half are children.
SEE RALLY, PAGE 2
Professor of Genomics claims he was fired over post about Israel-Hamas war
VIA POOLOS EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
A Washington University Professor of Genomics, Dr. Seth Crosby, claims to have lost his job over a post on X, formerly known as Twitter, calling the latest IsraelHamas war a “much needed cleansing.” On Friday, Crosby responded to a post by E. Michael Jones, a traditionalist Catholic writer and founder of Culture Wars, which is classified as a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center and Anti-Defamation League. In his post, Jones said “Israel is engaged in the ethnic cleansing of
Palestinians.” Crosby replied that it was “much-needed” and that “Israel is not targeting humans.” In a separate post, he said he believed that “rabid animals should be put down.” After people began to react to his statements online, Crosby said in a subsequent post on X that his initial post was in reference to Hamas, the terrorist militant group that initially launched attacks on Israel. “Israel is not targeting the Palestinian people. Israel is targeting HAMAS. Israel has just asked the Palestinian people to move out of the way,” he wrote. On Saturday, Crosby said he had lost his job over his posts, and by
Sunday, his X account was deleted. Julie Flory, Vice Chancellor for Marketing and Communications, said that “Professor Crosby is currently employed by Washington University,” but that “The opinions he has expressed as an individual do not represent the university’s position.” When asked if there were plans to terminate Crosby given his allegations of being fired, Flory said that she was not able to provide further information. “We are following up as appropriate, according to our policies and processes,” Flory said in a statement to Student Life. Crosby’s LinkedIn profile says he
has been the Director of Research Collaborations and professor of genetics at Washington University School of Medicine’s McDonnell Genome Institute (MGI) since November of 2017. At the time of publication, MGI’s website still had Crosby’s name and titles, but his picture and biographical information were gone. Student Life reached out to Crosby for comment, who responded with a screenshot of his posted apology: “I’m so very sorry for the anger I have caused by my clumsy words,” Crosby wrote. “I did not intend to imply that the deaths of the Palestinian people was in any way acceptable.”
CONTACT BY POST
CONTACT BY EMAIL
CONTACT BY PHONE
ONE BROOKINGS DRIVE #1039 #320 DANFORTH UNIVERSITY CENTER ST. LOUIS, MO 63130-4899
EDITOR@STUDLIFE.COM NEWS@STUDLIFE.COM CALENDAR@STUDLIFE.COM
NEWSROOM 314.935.5995 ADVERTISING 314.935.4240 FAX 314.935.5938
Washington University Student Union (SU) Senate talked about how to balance freedom of speech, student protection, and transparency in reference to the recent Israel-Hamas war and backlash towards an SU Executive Board statement on the subject, during their weekly meeting on Oct. 17. The conversation comes in the wake of a recent statement from the SU Executive Board about the Israel-Hamas conflict that led to anger from students before one of the slides of the post was deleted and comments were disabled. SU issued an apology for their words in an Instagram Story but did not externally acknowledge that part of the statement had been removed. The meeting began with an open discussion where senators talked about the ongoing conflict and ways in which their branch of SU could respond. They discussed promoting mental health resources and potentially releasing their own statement about the conflict, though many senators expressed reluctance to do so. Sophomore Ashton Lee said that since nobody in Senate is an expert on the Israel-Hamas war, he didn’t think releasing an additional statement would be beneficial. Instead, Lee suggested that it might be beneficial to instead talk with impacted students. “I think when you’re dealing with groups who are most impacted, [they] might feel left out by us making a broad statement on the post,” Lee said. “I feel like if we were meeting those groups, even if we can’t answer all their questions or give solutions, we could just know they’re hurt and they know that we see them.” The discussion then shifted towards talking about a resolution presented by Senate leadership that would prevent SU from deleting or archiving posts put on their social media, and would also ban the disabling of the comments on a post. The resolution was slated to be discussed during the meeting and voted on at a later date. Senate Diversity and Inclusion Chair and sophomore Sonal Churiwal said that there were transparency concerns from the Senate leadership that led to the creation of the resolution. “Because the initial exec post was only out for a day, not everyone had the chance to see it and that just brings up a concern of transparency,” Churiwal said. “That’s what the resolution outlines, that anything that’s put up on Instagram cannot be archived and any comments that are criticizing SU cannot be taken down.”
Read the rest online: