The independent newspaper of Washington University in St. Louis since 1878 THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 12, 2020
VOLUME 142, NO. 9
PANDEMIC GARDEN
WWW.STUDLIFE.COM
CITY DANCE
COMING TOGETHER
With Zoom and lots of outdoor space, the Burning Kumquat has kept the garden alive (Scene, pg 4)
How WU students are fighting for a better future through dance workshops (Cadenza, pg 9)
Black athletes build community to address isolation and lack of support (Sports, pg 6)
Among calls for abolition, experts weigh costs and As spring benefits of WUPD for the campus and community semester approaches, WU professors must decide class modality CLARA RICHARDS STAFF REPORTER
considered to be one of America’s most dysfunctional police forces. “WUPD is much more progressive than the St. Louis police department and they seem much more invested with community policing and building relationships with people in the immediate vicinity of the University and [with] students,” Gardner said. “They seem more sensitive to use of force issues than what you’ll find…in the St. Louis police department.” One mediating influence on University police forces can be parents, who would be upset if students were arrested by University employees for things such as lowlevel drug use, Gardner added. “Campus police often provide sanctuary in a sense for campus criminal behavior,” Gardner said. “Campuses are very protective of their students…and are disinclined to immediately arrest students for criminal conduct. I’d like to see your normal police department take a similar approach where they use a bit more discretion in deciding to arrest someone.” In recent years, Morton said that WUPD has been more vigilant about taking an active role in the areas around campus. “There was an incident where there was a dine and dash [at IHOP] and ten of our students… were not the ones who dined and dashed, but the police thought they were,” Morton said. “There were police officers involved— it was Richmond Heights and University City—and they did not call WUPD, and normally when students get in trouble they call WUPD so they can come and handle it.” Students have long pointed out racial biases in both WUPD and other St. Louis police departments, claiming that the presence of police officers around campus fails to protect students of color. The students stopped at IHOP were Black. Even if WUPD generally extends more courtesy to students, many proponents of WUPD abolition have highlighted the way that the force treats members of the local community who are not affiliated with the University as one of the problems surrounding it, arguing that it results in the overcriminalization of surrounding neighborhoods.
Professors across Washington University were required to declare by Nov. 6 whether they will conduct their classes online, hybrid or in-person for the spring 2021 semester. This fall, individual schools within the University have planned around their different needs. The College of Arts & Sciences, for example, has conducted around 30% of their classes in a hybrid format, Jen Smith, dean of the College of Arts & Sciences, said. The priority was given to classes that require a particular modality to conduct the course. One limitation is classroom availability: Smith said that there is room for 15% to 25% of normal class capacity in a socially distanced format. This semester, the College of Arts and Sciences did have slightly more classroom capacity than they used, but not by much— Smith said that any increase in in-person classes “won't be dramatic. It won't be more than half in-person.. Conversations between faculty and students have informed the decision-making process for the spring. Kathleen Finneran, a senior writer in residence at the University, for example, will be conducting all of her classes online in the spring because of personal health concerns, in addition to the risk of exposing family members to COVID-19. However, the level of discourse in her MFA nonfiction writing class “exceeds the level of discourse that often happened in person in the classroom,” she said. While her undergraduate class occasionally has more difficulty generating a fluid dialogue, Finneran has made use of resources like the Canvas discussion board. The spring 2020 semester, she said, was a trial-by-fire situation in terms of learning to use Canvas, but during the summer she had access to Canvas training opportunities. Thus, she said she’ll go into the spring 2021 semester with new tools to make her class more engaging, even with the online format. “I [feel] a greater ease on the Canvas website, it's different functions and potential that it presents for presenting material and organizing material,” Finneran said. “Also, having small group discussions and breakout rooms is really helpful, not just in terms of discussing material but also in terms of creating opportunities for the students in class to get to know each other better.”
SEE WUPD, PAGE 2
SEE SPRING, PAGE 3
GRAPHIC BY CHRISTINE WATRIDGE
GABBY HYMAN STAFF REPORTER After a summer of nationwide protests over systemic racism and police brutality, college students across the country have looked to implement calls for racial justice at a local level by demanding the abolition of university police departments. At Washington University, more than 100 students recently marched across campus demanding the abolition of the Washington University Police Department (WUPD). Emily Owens, a professor of Criminology, Law, and Society at the University of California, Irvine, noted that many universities are seriously considering abolishing their police forces, and said that she would not be surprised if Washington University ended up doing the same. “That would mean increased presence from the St. Louis police department,” Owens said. “Whatever the local…law enforcement agency would be, that would now be the agency that would respond to 911 calls.” WUPD is a police force of 66 officers, with a jurisdiction of the areas in and around Washington University’s campus as well as student housing on the Delmar Loop. “[WUPD has] jurisdiction… around campus and around The Loop area because students live over there,” Dr. Kimberly Morton,
director of TRIO Student Support Services, said. “They have partnerships with U[niversity] City police, Clayton police, and the city [St. Louis Metro] police because those are the jurisdictions surrounding the Wash. U. campus and University City is where students live off campus.” Washington University Associate Professor of Law Trevor Gardner said that there was overlap between the jurisdictions of WUPD and St. Louis police departments and there was “often a question of jurisdictional boundaries.” “Over time, [WUPD] has become sort of a real police department where you are protecting 30,000 people,” Morton said. “Wash. U. is a small city. You’ve got 14,000 students and 15,000 faculty and staff—it’s a lot of people they are protecting and serving.” A key difference between general and college police departments, Owens said, is “the relationship between the people who are policed and the person ultimately making the decisions about what the police do.” Most police departments work for an elected official with an interest in re-election, which Owens said added an aspect of accountability. “The mayor and the governor have an interest in getting re-elected, and that is the way
that many police departments change: There is pressure from that elected official who wants to ultimately satisfy the people who are policed,” Owens said. Although private departments such as WUPD are directly responsible to the University’s administration, the groups being policed by these departments, which include students as well as residents of neighborhoods with lots of student housing, have no direct influence over them. “In the case of private university police forces, the…police report to the president of the university,… [who] is not elected by the student body,” Owens added. “The [president’s incentives] are not the same as someone who is directly elected by the student body. So if you’re thinking about policies that a private university police choose to engage in, you need to think about what does the president want to happen, which is different than what a mayor or governor might want to happen because there isn’t an elected link.” Gardner was skeptical about the potential benefits of WUPD abolition, arguing that the alternative of inviting outside police departments from the city and surrounding municipalities could potentially have dangerous consequences. In recent years, the St. Louis Police Department has perpetrated racism, brutality and corruption, and is widely
HOLDEN HINDES | STUDENT LIFE
Students carry a sign reading “WUPD protects property, not people” during an Oct. 24 protest on the South 40.
CONTACT BY POST
CONTACT BY EMAIL
CONTACT BY PHONE
ONE BROOKINGS DRIVE #1039 #320 DANFORTH UNIVERSITY CENTER ST. LOUIS, MO 63130-4899
EDITOR@STUDLIFE.COM NEWS@STUDLIFE.COM CALENDAR@STUDLIFE.COM
NEWSROOM 314.935.5995 ADVERTISING 314.935.4240 FAX 314.935.5938