Vol. CXXXV, No. 7
The University of Toronto’s Student Newspaper Since 1880
20 October, 2014
Exploring the realities of homelessness in Toronto pg.14
Controversy at the CUSP Dispute between researchers may damage U of T involvement in international partnership Iris Robin
ASSOCIATE NEWS EDITOR
The University of Toronto’s involvement in a highly praised New York applied sciences research institute is off to a turbulent start. In April 2012, U of T announced that it would be expanding to New York in partnership with other international academic institutions. One of the highlights of the initiative was the Center for Urban Science and Progress (cusp), designed to foster collaborative research and technological development for the challenges facing the world’s cities. The cusp is part of the Applied Sciences nyc initiative and was intended to benefit students and faculty alike. As part of the initiative, three new campuses were slated to be opened in New York City. Carnegie Mellon University, the University of Warwick, Indian Institute of Technology Bom-
bay, and New York University (nyu) were also involved. U of T is the only Canadian post-secondary institution involved in this project. nyu planned to contribute around $50 million to the program, with New York City providing $15 million in benefits, according to The New York Times. A 2013–2014 U of T budget report allocated funding of $3.15 million, through the University Fund, to support salary and benefits for 21 faculty positions in the area of cities research and teaching. “Divisions in receipt of this funding will participate in the University of Toronto’s educational and research partnership in the Centre for Urban Science and Progress (cusp) located in New York City,” the report said. At the time of the project’s announcement, U of T hoped to send master’s and PhD students to study at the cusp and carry out their research. U of T also announced that some U of T faculty would take on the role of visiting professors
and teach at the cusp, allowing them to benefit from the research facilities, government, and industry in New York City, and then bring back transferrable expertise that could help tackle challenges in Toronto or other Canadian cities. Steve Easterbrook, professor of computer science at U of T, reported a recent research dispute between several U of T staff and Steven Koonin, the cusp’s director at nyu. “Incidentally, I’m no longer willing to have anything to do with the cusp since Steve Koonin, director of [the] cusp at nyu, started misrepresenting the work of many of my climate scientist colleagues by writing nonsense in the Wall Street Journal last month,” Easterbrook said. On September 19, Koonin published an article in the Wall Street Journal titled “Climate Science Is Not Settled,” which argued that we are very far from the knowledge needed to make good climate policy. Koonin posited that the uncertainties of cli-
mate science prevent it from being a solid base from which to enact policy decisions. “While the past two decades have seen progress in climate science, the field is not yet mature enough to usefully answer the difficult and important questions being asked of it,” Koonin wrote. “This decidedly unsettled state highlights what should be obvious: Understanding climate, at the level of detail relevant to human influences, is a very, very difficult problem,” he continued. These controversial claims drew a response from Raymond Pierrehumbert, a geophysical sciences professor at the University of Chicago. Pierrehumbert wrote an article in Slate titled “Climate Science Is Settled Enough.” “What [Koonin] fails to note is that this uncertainty provides an argument for more rather than less action on emissions control, since it
CONTINUED ON PG 9
INSIDE Comment When do you take a stand? Responses in light of solidarity protests in support of the Umbrella Revolution
Arts&Culture Discovering public art on campus
Science In conversation with Ari Cohen
Sports Strong starts for Blues hockey teams
A look at the art we see every day but may not notice
Canadian filmmaker talks about his award-winning documentary The Family Farm
A look at the key players in season previews