business@tribunemedia.net
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 21, 2023
$6.05
$6.11
$6.01
$6.07
No Bahamas taxes on Shell’s $1.55bn profits t &OFSHZ HJBOU MFHBMMZ QBZT OPU B DFOU PO MPDBM FBSOJOHT t 'JHVSFT TBJE UP TUSFOHUIFO DPSQPSBUF JODPNF UBY DBTF t -PXFS SBUF DPNQFUJUJWF BEWBOUBHF UP CFBU OECD/G-20
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE CASE for imposing a corporate income tax was yesterday said to be have been strengthened by revelations that a Shell subsidiary paid not a cent in tax on $1.55bn of profits generated in The Bahamas. The multinational energy giant, unveiling its 2022 global “tax contribution” report, revealed that Bahamas-based Shell Western Supply and Trading earned pre-tax profits equal to 12.4 percent of the country’s $12.556bn total public sector but none of this reached the Public Treasury in the absence of a corporate income tax.
Shell Western, which specialises in the buying and selling (trading) of crude oil sourced from Africa and Latin America, generated total revenues worth $28.29bn from these activities last year - a sum that is more than double, or twice as large, as The Bahamas’ total public sector debt. Combined revenues produced by Shell’s Bahamian subsidiary increased by almost $7bn or 31 percent year-over-year, while profits nearly tripled from the $571.441m achieved in 2021. Yet the energy giant’s report made clear that none of its millions/billions were taxed in The Bahamas and, as an International Business Company (IBC), it only paid a very modest amount of taxes and fees locally.
GOWON BOWE
PAUL MOSS
“Shell has been present in The Bahamas since 2002. As of 2018, Shell’s principal business in the Bahamas is Shell Western Supply and Trading (SWST). SWST sources crude oil from West Africa and Latin America, and trades globally,” the Shell report said.
“The Bahamas does not impose corporate income tax on international business companies (IBCs) operating in the country. However, international business companies pay indirect taxes and fees in The Bahamas. The increase in profit before tax is the result of higher crude oil prices.” When these revelations were brought to their attention, financial services executives again urged The Bahamas to “get on the front foot” and beat the OECD/G-20 push for a ‘minimum’ 15 percent global corporate income tax by implementing a lower rate version to suit its needs and maintain economic competitiveness.
SEE PAGE B4
‘Incredibly difficult’ Public sector debt drops $93m during first quarter for middle class to ever purchase home By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
t 0XOFSTIJQ AIVSEMFT SBJTFE B MJUUMF CJU IJHIFS t PG IPNF TBMFT GBJM PO NPSUHBHF XPFT t 4JS 'SBOLMZO DJUFT QSFTTVSFT PG HBNCMJOH By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net MIDDLE class Bahamians will find it “incredibly difficult to ever get a home”, developers and realtors warned yesterday, with financing and other hurdles constantly being raised that “little bit higher”. Matt Sweeting, real estate broker with 1 OAK Bahamas, told Tribune Business that three out of every 10 potential property deals he handles fail due to the buyer’s inability to secure mortgage financing and this number has increased in recent years post-COVID. Speaking after the Central Bank’s lending conditions survey for the 2023 first half revealed the mortgage loan approval ratio had fallen to its lowest level in four-and-a-half years, with less than on in three applications approved by commercial banks, he added that the industry’s standard time for processing such credit has in many
TOTAL public sector debt fell by $93m during the first quarter of the 2023-2024 fiscal year, it was disclosed yesterday, cutting it slightly from its June peak as the foreign currency share fell by 1.5 percentage points. The Ministry of Finance’s quarterly public debt statistical bulletin, covering the three months to end-September 2023, suggested that further growth in the Government’s debt burden had been contained over the period with the economy’s continuing postCOVID rebound helping to lower the debt-to-GDP
ratio to 80.4 percent over the period. The central government’s direct debt also declined by $45m during the 2023-2024 fiscal year’s first quarter, lowering slightly to $11.215bn, although some $3.257bn in maturing debt has to be refinanced in the nine months between October 2023 and June 2024. Included in that sum is a $300m foreign currency bond issue held by external investors. “Outstanding debt of the public sector was estimated at $12.556bn at end-September 2023, a decline of $92.9m (0.7 percent) from end-June 2023 and a $453.8m (3.8 percent) increase since end-September 2022,” the report said.
THE Attorney General yesterday admitted The Bahamas has been “negligent” in protecting the innovations of its entrepreneurs by failing to keep pace with intellectual property (IP) safeguards. Ryan Pinder KC, addressing an IP consultation with representatives from the cultural and agribusiness industries, said it
Despite the modest reduction in the Government’s outstanding debt, the interest burden associated with it continues to suck large sums of money away from the provision of public services such as health, education, social services, the police, Defence Force and other national security agencies. “Debt service costs totaled an estimated $830.7m for the first quarter of fiscal year 2023-2024, a reduction of 7.4 percent from the June 2023 quarter but nearly 58 percent above the outlays in the corresponding period of the prior year,” the Government’s debt bulletin said.
SEE PAGE B4
Bahamians using renewables ‘without understanding’ them MATT SWEETING cases near-tripled from 21 days to 60 days. Affirming that “99 percent” of the transactions he brokers require the buyers to come up with mortgage financing, Mr Sweeting told this newspaper that applying and gaining the necessary bank approvals is “the longest process in the transaction right now”. “Traditionally we were writing the industry standard language for financing at 21 days some years ago,” he explained. “We’ve been forced to adjust that to a minimum industry standard
SEE PAGE B4
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net BAHAMIANS are using key components of renewable energy technology “without understanding where or when or how” it impacts their lives, regulators are asserting. The Utilities Regulation and Competition Authority (URCA), in unveiling the results of a 400-strong survey on battery energy storage systems (BESS), referred to “disturbing” findings when it came to both renewable energy uptake and the level of confidence several
residential consumers have in the regulator. More than three out of every four residential respondents, who totalled 300, said they have no plans to install a renewable system at their homes, which could have consequences for The Bahamas’ ambitions to achieve its target of generating 30 percent of total energy needs from sustainable sources by 2030. And 19 percent of respondents, or almost one in five, said they either did not know what role URCA should play in this process and the roll-out of BESS systems or lacked confidence and trust in the energy sector regulator.
Bahamas ‘negligent’ in protecting innovators By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
“Foreign currency debt was lower by $182.6m relative to the previous quarter and constituted 44.6 percent of the total portfolio—an almost uninterrupted quarterly reduction from the 46 percent posted at end-September 2022. Since end-June 2023, the Bahamian dollar component grew by $89.7m (1.3 percent), and the share in total debt firmed by 1.4 percentage points since end-September 2022 to 55.4 percent. Movements in the public debt stock vis-à-vis end-June 2023 were due to almost equal net repayment positions for both government and agencies and GBEs (government business enterprises).”
was “the plain truth” that successive administrations have failed to ensure creative money-making ideas were given the necessary protections to prevent them from being pirated, stolen or copied. Describing the present system for intellectual property rights protection as “clunky, slow and inefficient”, and with The Bahamas also lacking membership in the necessary international conventions, he pledged to
transform processes from ones that are manual-based via the launch of an online electronic portal. Mr Pinder said a dedicated IP Office will be created as a standalone entity, spun out from its present home in the Registrar General’s Department. Confirming that the Government plans to implement IP legal reforms that will bring The Bahamas into line with international best
SEE PAGE B2
RYAN PINDER KC
BESS systems, at their most basic, allow energy generated from traditional sources or renewables, such as solar and wind, to be stored and then released when that power is needed. With solar, they typically store any excess energy produced during the day for
use at night when no sun is shining. “Knowledge of the concept of energy storage and use of batteries is widespread in residential consumers. This may be due to familiarisation with consumer electronics and
SEE PAGE B2