B1
SUNDAY, JUNE 25, 2017 Adelle Chua, Editor
Opinion
Joyce Pangco Pañares, Issue Editor
mst.daydesk@gmail.com
SAUDI ARABIA’S NEW HEIR CAN’T GO SOFT ON TERROR
EDITORIAL
By Bloomberg Editorial THE new heir to the throne in Saudi Arabia has great ambitions to modernize its economy. The West can and should help—so long as he keeps his kingdom committed to the fight against terrorism. The timing of the promotion of Prince Mohammed bin Salman from his role as deputy crown prince was perhaps a surprise, but the fact of it was not. Prince Mohammed, favorite son of King Salman, was already dictating the country’s foreign and military policies, in addition to its oil strategy. The man in charge of the Saudi counterterrorism effort, Prince Muhammad bin Nayef, was stripped of power in Wednesday’s shakeup. The Saudis’ contributions to the fight in the region were inconsistent, to be sure. Yet Nayef was sufficiently competent to merit both an assassination attempt by al-Qaeda and a medal from the CIA. The new crown prince, with his focus on the economy, has paid little attention to the threat Sunni extremism poses to the kingdom. He is also unlikely to cut off government support for domestic Wahhabi clerics who preach violence, as he may need their support to calm any public opposition to his reform plans, which will require cutting subsidies and payouts Saudis have long enjoyed. Prince Mohammed was also the driving force behind the flailing efforts to wipe out Iranian-backed Houthi rebels in Yemen and to lead several other Gulf states, including the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain, to cut off diplomatic and trade relations with Qatar, needlessly destabilizing the Gulf Cooperation Council at a time of war and of increasing Iranian influence across the Middle East. Prince Mohammed and President Donald Trump seem to have hit it off, first when the prince got a one-onone in the White House in March and then when Trump visited the kingdom last month. Trump needs to make something clear to the young prince: If his economic changes and plan for a Saudi Aramco IPO are to have any chance of success, he will need lots of foreign investment and cooperation. Any lessening of his nation’s efforts against Islamic State and alQaeda, or to crack down on “charity” money going to fund terrorists and hate-preachers abroad, will make Saudi Arabia a vastly less appealing business partner for the West. Ditto failure to resolve the Qatar imbroglio and find an exit from the Yemen war. Vision 2030, the 31-year-old prince’s ambitious plan to diversify the monarchy’s economy, is both popular and necessary. Non-oil revenue has risen by nearly half in the last two years, but still comprises just 12 percent of gross domestic product. Budget deficits have been rising, shocking for a nation with that ran a surplus of nearly 30 percent of GDP a decade ago. To be successful, the prince’s reforms will probably require both higher oil prices and lower public spending – and a receptive market for what is expected to be the largest IPO ever. The rest of the world needs a modernized Saudi Arabia. But for that to happen, Saudi Arabia needs the rest of the world.
LEGISLATING CIRCUMSPECTION
T
HERE are many ways to fight fake news.
One can go the German way. In early April, the cabinet of Chancellor Angela Merkel backed a bill that would threaten social media platforms with fines if they did not give their users the option to complain about fake news or hate speech, or if they did not remove illegal content. The objective is to provide better options for its voters ahead of the elections in September. Apparently, German officials do not want to experience what happened in the United States leading to last November’s polls. Critics, however, say this is dangerous territory because it might trample on freedom of speech, especially now that other European leaders have said they wanted to make social media companies like Facebook and Twitter accountable for hate speeches or statements inciting to terrorism. Another option is to target individuals fabricating or spreading fake news. This was what Senator Joel Villanueva, through a bill filed this week, said he wanted to do. Senate Bill No. 1492, An Act Penalizing the Malicious Distribution of False News and Other Related Violations, penalizes “any person or entity creating and circulating false news in print, broadcast or social media.” Public officials doing the same would be meted stiffer penalties. Fake news is described as “an information causing or tending to cause panic, division, chaos, violence, hate” and “those exhibiting, or tending to exhibit propaganda to blacken or discredit one’s reputation.” Those found guilty will be fined anywhere between P100,000 and P5 million and will be locked up between one year and five years. Mass media enterprises or social media platforms that do not remove such news will also be penalized by fine and imprisonment. Public officials found guilty have to pay twice the fine and spend twice
the time in jail. They will also be disqualified from public service. But it is not difficult to imagine how Villanueva conceived of this bill in reaction to recent blunders by members of the Duterte administration. An assistant secretary of the Presidential Communication Coordination Office, a woman who said it was her mandate to fight fake news, was exposed to have used photos of Honduran soldiers while talking about our own soldiers in her social media account. No less than the Philippine News Agency published a story that said many countries did not believe there were extrajudicial killings here—patently false. Most recently, the Secretary of Justice alleged some members of the opposition were in Marawi City days before the still-ongoing siege began. A University of the Philippines professor said such a bill would be too dangerous because even ordinary, well-meaning people could fall under the conditions stated in the proposed law. A third way, obvious and commonsensical but all-too-often ignored, is for people to educate themselves and refuse to fall prey to false information. Fake news should die a natural death when it fails to have takers. The key is to resist being a taker. The problem is, it is often difficult to be circumspect in this age when information flows so freely. All political groups should be wary of creating and spreading false information. They just make people ignorant and undiscerning. More importantly, people should be more critical of the information that is fed them. There are steps to ensure that what we read about is true. There are ways to be angry—indignant—about how some people believe they can get away with misleading us, or lying to us outright. Circumspection need not be legislated at all. We just need to be armed with a healthy dose of skepticism, and this starts at home, in school, in the workplace, and the people with whom we constantly interact.
Scan this icon to view the PDF
AVENUE OF MYSTERIES: A RAMBLING, MESSY, TRUTHFUL READ POP GOES THE WORLD JENNY ORTUOSTE
THERE are many instances of the Philippines being mentioned in novels by non-Filipinos, sometimes positively, more often not. Remember that time Dan Brown called Manila “the gates of hell” in his
book “Inferno” because of the city’s “six-hour traffic jams [and] suffocating pollution,” prompting an out-of-tune defense from then-MMDA chairman Francis Tolentino? Then there’s “My Hollywood” by
Mona Simpson, which tells the story of Lola, a Filipino nanny, juxtaposed against that of her wealthy white employer Claire, and the disparities between them. Now comes John Irving’s “Avenue
of the Mysteries.” I saw it on display last April at Fully Booked Power Plant, and, flipping through it, was surprised to find it was partly set in Manila. Published in November 2015, it seems to have gone under the radar, perhaps Turn to B2
Rolando G. Estabillo Publisher ManilaStandard
Published Monday to Sunday by Philippine Manila Standard Publishing Inc. at 6/F Universal Re Building, 106 Paseo de Roxas, corner Perea St., Legaspi Village, Makati City. Telephone numbers 832-5554, 832-5556, 832-5558 (connecting all departments), (Editorial) 832-5554, (Advertising) 832-5550. P.O. Box 2933, Manila Central Post Office, Manila. Website: www.thestandard. com.ph; e-mail: contact@thestandard.com.ph
ONLINE
can be accessed at: manilstandard.net
MEMBER
PPI
Philippine Press Institute The National Association of Philippine Newspapers
Benjamin Philip G. Romualdez Former Chief Justice Reynato S. Puno Anita F. Grefal Baldwin R. Felipe Edgar M. Valmorida
Chairman Board Member & Chief Legal Adviser Treasury Manager OIC-Ad Solutions Circulation Manager
Ramonchito L. Tomeldan Chin Wong/Ray S. Eñano Joyce Pangco Pañares Adelle Chua
Managing Editor Associate Editors City Editor Opinion Editor
Emil P. Jurado
Honor Blanco Cabie Night Editor Romel J. Mendez Art Director Roberto Cabrera Chief Photographer
Chairman Emeritus, Editorial Board