Volume 55 - Issue 4

March 2023

The Magazine About Yale and New Haven

The Gender & Sexuality Issue Jabez Choi explores the histories inside New Haven gay bars. 16 Theia Chatelle and Iz Klemmer follow three trans kids seeking gender-affirming care in New Haven. 34 Abbey Kim finds how queer Christians enrich their spiritual lives. 42

Volume 55, Issue 4

Letter from the editors

Masthead

Dear readers,

Editors-in-Chief

The New Journal’s tagline has always been: “The Magazine about Yale and New Haven.” Our mission, as we understand it, is to represent these spaces through the stories of the people who occupy them. Recently, we’ve been thinking more about how best to do so.

We began our year as a managing board by discovering a trove of dusty archives—hundreds and hundreds of time capsules of the University and the city. We ended the year with TNJFest, where the past collided with the present as alums of the last fifty years descended on the Branford Common Room. These bookends on our term have affirmed to us that TNJ is a living history, and journalism can do essential record-keeping. More than that, we’ve been reminded that longform can follow the narratives behind the numbers, make human the abstractions of headlines, and in doing so disrupt assumptions; contradict generalizations; and reveal gaps in the common discourse.

Across the nation, queer people are facing renewed threats. Dozens of bills have been passed in state legislatures this year that restrict transgender people from accessing gender-affirming care, despite medical consensus that this care is sound and necessary. Anti-LGBTQ+ violence is on the rise, and the tired caricature of queer people as predatory “groomers” has reappeared in popular media. At what may be a regressive inflection point for LGBTQ+ rights in America, the future hangs uncertain.

In this issue, Abbey Kim explores queer Christians’ ongoing battles for acceptance in their churches. Jabez Choi chronicles the decline of gay bars, and asks the question: what is the meaning of a “safe” space? Sasha Carney traces the history of lesbian social life on campus, and Jools Fu navigates the complicated masculinity of the Singapore Armed Forces. Theia Chatelle and Iz Klemmer explore the obstacles trans kids face when seeking genderaffirming care, while Hannah Szabó remembers the spaces and people that supported her own journey during childhood.

Executive Editor Managing Editor Associate Editors

Amal Biskin Meg Buzbee Jabez Choi Lazo Gitchos Ella Goldblum Yonatan Greenberg

Nicole Dirks Dereen Shirnekhi Jesse Goodman J.D. Wright Abbey Kim Yosef Malka Cleo Maloney Paola Santos Kylie Volavongsa

Senior Editors

Beasie Goddu Madison Hahamy Alexandra Galloway Zachary Groz

Copy Editors

Marie Bong Adrian Elizalde Rafaela Kottou

Edie Lipsey Lukas Trelease Yingying Zhao

Creative Director

Kevin Chen

Design Editors

Meg Buzbee Camille Chang Etai Smotrich-Barr

Charlotte Rica Karela Palazio

Photography

Lukas Flippo

These stories aim to situate some of New Haven’s queer life in both history and experience. We hope to do in this issue the same thing we have sought to do since 1967, a purpose reiterated in our October 2001 issue’s letter from the editors: to put our moment in context.

TNJ love, The Managing Board

Thank you to our donors

Neela Banerjee* Anson M. Beard James Carney Andrew Court Romy Drucker Jeffrey Foster David Gerber David Greenberg*

Matthew Hamel Makiko Harunari James Lowe Chaitanya Mehra Ben Mueller Sarah Nutman Peter Phleger Jeffrey Pollock

Adriane Quinlan Elizabeth Sledge Gabriel Snyder Fred Strebeigh Arya Sundaram Stuart Weinzimer Steven Weisman Suzanne Wittebort

*Donated twice. Thank you!

2

thenewjournalatyale.com

Members & Directors: Emily Bazelon • Peter Cooper • Jonathan Dach • Kathrin Lassila • Elizabeth Sledge • Fred Strebeigh Advisors: Neela Banerjee • Richard Bradley • Susan Braudy • Lincoln Caplan • Jay Carney • Andy Court • Joshua Civin • Richard Conniff • Ruth Conniff • Elisha Cooper • Susan Dominus • David Greenberg • Daniel Kurtz-Phelan • Laura Pappano • Jennifer Pitts • Julia Preston • Lauren Rawbin • David Slifka • John Swansburg • Anya Kamenetz • Steven Weisman • Daniel Yergin

Friends: Nicole Allan • Margaret Bauer • Mark Badger and Laura Heymann • Anson M. Beard • Susan Braudy • Julia Calagiovanni • Elisha Cooper • Haley Cohen • Peter Cooper • Andy Court • The Elizabethan Club • Leslie Dach • David Freeman and Judith Gingold • Paul Haigney and Tracey Roberts • Bob Lamm • James Liberman • Alka Mansukhani • Benjamin Mueller • Sophia Nguyen • Valerie Nierenberg • Morris Panner • Jennifer Pitts • R. Anthony Reese • Eric Rutkow • Lainie Rutkow • Laura Saavedra and David Buckley • Anne-Marie Slaughter • Elizabeth Sledge • Caroline Smith • Gabriel Snyder • Elizabeth Steig • Aliyya Swaby • John Jeremiah Sullivan • Daphne and David Sydney • Kristian and Margarita Whiteleather • Blake Townsend Wilson • Daniel Yergin • William Yuen

TheNewJournal

Contents

Counter Memories

16

cover story

Is gay nightlife getting quieter? A writer explores the histories inside New Haven gay bars.

By Jabez Choi

Waiting for Care

34

At the Yale Pediatric Gender Program, trans kids say they receive great care—but it’s not easy to get.

By Theia Chatelle and Iz Klemmer

Coming Out, Coming Home

42

Queer Christians in New Haven and at Yale are finding ways to enrich their spiritual lives through their lgbtq + identities.

By Abbey Kim

point of departure

flash fiction

4 A Scene of Outsiders

At Space Ballroom, Danya Blokh is in for a night of “non-denominational, non-binary” hardcore. snapshots

10 Yalesbians, Sappho, and the Lesbian Life of the Party

A genealogy of lesbian social spaces at Yale.

By Sasha Carney

28 Drawing it Out

Local advocate Tony Ferraiolo guides trans youth—and their parents—through the complications of their gender journeys.

By Hannah Szabó personal essay

6 Where Boys Become Men

By Anaiis Rios-Kasoga asides

9 Jennifer’s Body

By Anaiis Rios-Kasoga

14 Grocery Store

By Amal Biskin

14 Dash of Fancy

By Amal Biskin poems

53 for Abel

By J.D. Wright

54 Berlin Poem for Owen

By Ella Goldblum

33 Kissing One of Your Queer Awakenings

By Adrian Elizalde

Violence and masculinity in the Singapore Armed Forces.

By Jools Fu

March 2023

40 We Will Live in a Corner House

crossword **REDACTED**, crossword , by Jesse Goodman, page 55.

image credits: Nour tantush; kevin chen; aaron miller

3

Points of Departure

A Scene of Outsiders At Space Ballroom, Danya Blokh is in for a night of “non-denominational, non-binary” hardcore.

n February 12, 2023, Hamden’s O Space Ballroom was a veritable convention of musical subgenres. Millennial

hardcore fans in gray hoodies with the hoods up, older bearded metalheads wearing band T-shirts, and young queer punks with piercings and tattoos milled about the small, dim venue. The crowd’s energy felt more like a school dance than a punk show, and even though small mosh pits formed for hard-hitting local hardcore bands Intercourse and Kidnapped, they fizzled out quickly once it became clear that most fans preferred watching to dancing. As a casual fan of hardcore who had always enjoyed the collective catharsis of a good mosh-pit, I came toward the front of the audience and hoped for some mayhem as the headliner, Space Camp, ascended to the stage.

I got mayhem, alright. June Aino and Daisy Josefa, the two vocalists and core members of Space Camp, led a plethora of supporting musicians up to the platform, packing the small stage with an upright bass, a cello, a sousaphone, a trombone, a synth and a drum set, with a second drummer set up in the middle of the audience. The musicians smiled broadly as they sound checked, their classical instruments contrasting starkly with their tattooed arms and all-black outfits. But nothing could have prepared me for the overwhelming cacophony of orchestral punk that followed. Somehow, with no guitar or bass, Space Camp’s music was more forceful than any punk band I’d heard.

With the drummer in the middle of the crowd, there wasn’t any room to 4

March 2023 TheNewJournal

start a mosh pit. But there was no need for one; the crowd’s attention was fixated on the hardcore symphony before us. The chaos I’d expected in the audience was happening on stage instead: June and Daisy screamed powerfully, the brass instruments boomed, and the second drummer wielded a drill during one song and a bugle horn during another.

One local reviewer noted in their article about the concert that the sheer force of Space Camp’s sound shattered a lightbulb in the bathroom, but no one around me blinked an eye. As one of the attendees, Connecticut resident Myles Vincent, phrased it afterwards, “it’s just an explosion. Rather than going to see a band go to play their songs, it’s like you’re going to see something go down.”

Brass instruments and power tools are rare at most live shows, but particularly in hardcore, an aggressive offshoot of punk music with a relatively strict sound and ethos. While the genre varies between bands and over time, there is nonetheless a defined set of expectations for hardcore songs: fast and brutal riffs, deeply screamed vocals, and climactic song sections called “breakdowns” intended to make listeners go wild in the mosh pit. Historically, hardcore’s aggressive attitude, as well as its lyrical preference for themes like hometown pride and the straight-edge lifestyle over the progressive politics of anarchist bands, attracted mostly male musicians and listeners to hardcore shows. Space Camp’s novel sound, which their bio calls “non-denominational, non-binary hardcore,” is unique in a genre as stylistically codified as hardcore. Consequently, whenever they’re booked on a show with a bunch of hardcore bands, “it’s a mixed bill, because we have single handedly mixed the bill,” says Daisy.

Yet this very love for instrumental play created Space Camp in the first place. June and Daisy became friends in fourth grade after finding themselves to be among the few fourth graders registered to learn trombone at their South Windsor Elementary School. “Our houses were so close together that we could walk through a neighborhood and some woods and be at each other’s houses,” says June when I speak with the band a few days after the show. Daisy started playing guitar and drums, while June kept learning trombone and picked up keys, and they briefly experimented with surf rock in high school before

officially forming Space Camp in March 2013. Their playful debut record consists of Daisy playing drums, June playing synth, and a friend reading passages aloud from books they found in their practice space. “At the time we were like, this is a cool concept,” says Daisy. “It’s since been wiped from the internet.”

In 2014, the band added a bassist, June introduced a full piano in addition to their microKORG synth, and Space Camp began booking more shows and seriously recording music. Their stylistic influences at the time were hardcore bands like Ceremony, Punch, and Code Orange Kids, whose influence is still evident in Space Camp’s roughly screamed vocals, ominously dissonant chords, and punchy song sections. “We’ve always been suckers for a lip-curling hardcore breakdown,” Daisy tells me. Yet instrumental diversity remained integral to their ethos; listening through their Bandcamp releases, you’ll hear just about everything—tuba, guitar, contrabass, oboe—all absorbed into their heavy punk sound. Their latest album Gold Star was released in January of this year and continues this tradition with twenty-nine minutes of magnificent auditory havoc.

Space Camp’s take on hardcore has thrived in Connecticut largely because of the state’s unique music scene. Whereas more densely populated states tend to stratify into separate subgenres with minimal overlap, Connecticut’s small size leads to a melding of styles perfect for Space Camp’ eclectic blend of genres.

As Daisy says, there’s a distinct charm to a place where only one show is happening on a given night: “If it’s a Friday night in Philadelphia in July, there’s six shows going on. You can get the best line-up at a sick venue, and everyone you know will still text you and say, sorry, we’re going to another show. But if we’re playing in Connecticut, everyone who’s interested is there, it is the thing to do.”

illustrations by meg buzbee

Points of Departure

Space Camp is only one example of Connecticut bands’ propensity for music experimentation. Tarek, the lead singer of Intercourse, says there’s an entire scene of local experimental punk—“I call it outsider hardcore”—dedicated to fostering a left-leaning, welcoming milieu opposed to the exclusivity of more regimented music scenes. “We’re not into that macho, gatekeepy shit,” he says proudly. Intercourse, which has been playing since 2014 and is soon releasing their new album Halo Castration Institute, is itself a genre-bending project too, with “one foot in hardcore and one foot in noise rock.”

The Connecticut scene’s inclusivity doesn’t just apply to the music, but also to the community itself. While hardcore is often perceived as a hypermasculine boy’s club, Connecticut’s outsider hardcore shows are “a place for a lot of people where they can go and be themselves,” says Tarek. “If you want to wear make-up and goth out, no one’s gonna bat an eye.”

Tarek, whose family is Egyptian, grew up as one of the only people of color in the small town of Naugatuck, Connecticut.

His upbringing was full of alienating and aggressive encounters with white Title illustration: Space Camp’s June Aino, left, and Daisy Josefa, right.

schoolmates. Connecticut’s music scene was also exclusionary, though in different ways. “People at shows used to tell me, don’t wear a Marilyn Manson shirt or you’ll get the shit beat out of you, make sure to wear a Cannibal Corpse shirt or something neutral,” Tarek remembers, laughing. Yet the young, left-leaning audience of Connecticut’s current outsider hardcore scene makes no space for such hostility, from musical elitism to racism and misogyny. “There’s lots of trans people, there’s lots of queer people, there’s lots of people of color. This is a really inclusive scene for everybody, and we’re really proud of that. We’ve had people come through and say, wow, this little niche of Connecticut is really special.”

This warm and welcoming attitude suffused the venue after Space Camp’s set concluded. Young newcomers to the scene and longtime outsider hardcore fans alike chatted eagerly with me about what we’d just experienced together and about other shows they’d recently attended. If the disparate contingents had struggled to gel at the start of the night, the singular intensity of Space Camp’s eclectic sound seemed to have bonded everyone at the Space Ballroom, dissolving any residual awkwardness in the space.

I shook hands with Daisy and Tarek, who both warmly thanked me

for coming and told me they’d be glad to interview. In the merch line, one fan told me he’d grown up in Connecticut, moved to Austin for nearly a decade, and only just returned. The scene in his time had been aggressive and intimidating, he told me, and the warmth of Space Ballroom’s crowd shocked him. Though this was his first time seeing Space Camp, his beaming smile while talking about his experience at the concert suggested he was bound to become an outsider hardcore regular.

I left with a newly purchased Space Camp T-shirt tucked under my arm.

Every time I’ve worn it since, at least one person has stopped me to ask if I caught them at Space Ballroom. Daisy was right about the perks of a small music scene; these people really had all been to the same show as me. The next time I find myself toppled over in a Connecticut hardcore mosh pit, I’m certain one of these familiar faces will be around to lift me up. ∎

Danya Blokh is a junior in Timothy Dwight College.

Fitness Center 285 Nicoll Street, New Haven CT 06511 203-936-9446 www.mactivity.com

Personal Essay

Where Boys Become Men Violence and masculinity in the Singapore Armed Forces.

By Jools Fu

Content warning: This piece contains a description of self-harm.

My nineteen-year-old recruit, Bing Jie, was hooked up to an IV and probably fast asleep. Two months ago at this time, he probably would’ve been at home, y combat boots were still awake maybe, playing video games, flecked with dirt and my for- watching TV. At the time when he first est-green fatigues were covered enlisted, he told me, he was a profesin mud and sweat. Somehow, my beret sional League of Legends player. He sustained its creases despite soaking up had come fourth in a national competithe bits of camouflage face paint that I tion the year before. In terms of national hadn’t managed to properly wash off. service, he really wanted to serve in The city was dead quiet. It was 3 a.m., the cyber security division. Instead, he my phone was out of battery, and I had was tossed into infantry, and he came to walk home from the hospital. under my charge. Rhabdomyolysis had

M 6

March 2023 TheNewJournal

broken down his major muscles. Now, he couldn’t walk without excruciating pain in both legs. The moment when he had collapsed into a messy heap of limbs and grass, he couldn’t even call out for help.

While we were in the waiting room, Bing Jie’s dad and older brother arrived. After a terse conversation with me, they sat with him on the other side of the room, away from me. They tried their best not to talk to me directly, and neither of them used my name.

I was “sergeant,” a tool of the state’s military apparatus. photos by jools fu

asic Military Training (BMT) more advanced forms of combat and alienated. I was barely sleeping, and B is a milestone in the lives of all familiarizing myself with a diverse array I hardly had time to eat. So, when I Singaporean men. It marks their man- of weapons, from machine guns to RPGs. caught a glimpse of a recruit running

datory enlistment into the Singapore Armed Forces (SAF). The training center isn’t even on the mainland; boys are packed onto ferries and shipped to Pulau Tekong, an island right off the coast of Singapore. It’s where their identification cards are exchanged, and suddenly they are no longer “citizens” but “NSF” (Fulltime National Servicemen). It’s where the SAF shaves the boys’ heads and the tropical sun burns their scalps. It’s where they fire their first rifle, where they dig their first trench, and where they start the endless cycle of physical and strategic combat training. After two months of grueling regimentation, recruits graduate and are then assigned to military vocations. The top 20 percent of recruits are sent to command school to undergo further combat training, Officer Cadet School (OCS) to become an officer, or Specialist Cadet School (SCS) to become a sergeant. But BMT is the start of any military career. Its motto: “Where boys become men.”

I entered BMT as an 18-year-old, having gone to high school in the United Kingdom and therefore largely unfamiliar with Singaporean society. National Service had always been something I dreaded. All throughout high school I had been bullied by other boys, who called me a “faggot” and kicked me when teachers weren’t looking. I was often reduced to tears, made to feel unfathomably small, and helplessly alone. If high school was like that, I couldn’t imagine what the army would be like. I considered myself a progressive, I thought militaries shouldn’t exist, and I knew my queerness was not accepted. I made the conscious choice to remain closeted. I enlisted with the bold assumption that the army was not going to change me or my beliefs. But to avoid being criticized or belittled, I tried my best to excel in this performance of masculinity.

I did well. My athleticism translated well to military training. I accepted the torrent of insults and verbal abuses my sergeants hurled at me. And when I was commended for my abilities, a part of me truly enjoyed it. For the first time in my life, I was considered tough and strong.

I completed BMT fifth in my platoon of sixty-four, and I earned a position in SCS. A week later, I started my training to become a sergeant and a commander.

In SCS, I spent six months learning layout design by Kevin Chen

I navigated miles of dense vegetation while carrying a seventy-pound field pack. I survived in the jungle for nine days without any contact with the outside world. With the completion of each exercise, the joy I found in the military became more real. I enjoyed infantry training in a way that would have been entirely alien less than a year before, intoxicated with my adaptation to an ideal masculinity. When I graduated, I was assigned to be a BMT trainer. Upon receiving my posting order, I promised myself I would be different, patient. “Be the change you want to see” was what I kept repeating to myself.

I remember the first time I made another person cry. He was part of the

It was an unending cycle of vicious masculinity: violence begetting more violence.

first batch of recruits I ever trained. In the first few weeks of their training, the recruits are given snacks to eat at night, as a part of their grace period: packaged buns, stuffed with artificially flavored cream the color and texture of playdough. The buns tasted like nothing but sugar, which was pure heaven compared to the nauseating food that we ate at the cookhouse. I’d had a rough day—contrary to my expectations, being a trainer was not simple and I was growing more and more frustrated with how ineffective I felt. My strategy of patience seemed completely inept compared to the fear other commanders were able to strike into their recruits. As much as I wanted to be morally strong, I felt myself becoming

out of his bunk to grab an extra bun from the parade square after lights out, I lost it. What came out was closer to barking than yelling, and it echoed so loudly that some heads peeked out from the fifth floor. “What the fuck do you think you’re doing?” He dropped the bun instantly, keeping his head down as I unleashed my wild wrath on him. As he walked away, I realized the blotches on his shirt were not sweat marks, but tears. When I reentered the company office, my friends and fellow commanders dapped me up. Later, my captain pulled me aside and commended me for enforcing discipline. As I went back to my bunk, I smiled for the first time in a while.

Bing Jie was in my third and final batch of recruits. By then, I had grown into a seasoned trainer. I had learned to harness my unbridled fury on my recruits, breaking them down physically and mentally into passive bodies, moldable soldiers. My rage was a defense mechanism, a way to throw others off my trail. If I could be “tough” and harsh on my recruits, no one, not even the boys from high school, could call me a “faggot” anymore. Before enlistment, a batch is given a grade based on their expected physical and mental competency. My first two batches had been A’s; Bing Jie’s was a C, and I felt the difference immediately. No matter how hard I pushed, they couldn’t meet my timings.

They were consistently late, none of them could perform any marching drills in sync, some couldn’t even hold up a rifle without shaking from the effort. It was a combination of physical inability and mental disinterest. But I had to be the one that got them there.

The Combat Circuit is BMT’s most difficult physical training. It requires recruits to dress in full battalion order, including field packs, suffocating armored vests, and heavy helmets. Then, they’re thrown into an outdoor training ground, made to climb steep hills, dash from tree to tree, and crawl through thick mud. The exercise is supposed to simulate the motions of jungle warfare. When I was a recruit, our sergeant shouted insults at us as we did the circuit, and I did the same to my recruits.

Nothing was off limits. I was telling them how worthless they were as they scrambled about, their rifles swinging TheNewJournal March 2023

7

Where Boys Become Men

wildly by their neck, knocking into their chins. Suddenly someone shouted out in alarm. Bing Jie had disintegrated into a crumpled heap underneath his field pack, which was larger than him.

I thought he was faking it. Three hours later, after the medical staff had evaluated he needed to be sent to a hospital, I volunteered to go.

of me, the driver was startled. I felt like a ghost from the jungle, a savage specter haunting the city. About a mile from my house, I passed by the twenty-four-hour McDonalds that I used to beg my mum to take me to when I was a kid. A group of drunk teenage boys was there, trying to scale the attached playground. I was reminded of combat obstacle courses. In a couple years at y commanding officer gave most, they too would be starting BMT, me the next few days off, and like I had, like Bing Jie did, like all of my house wasn’t far from the hospi- us would. It was an unending cycle of tal. Under moonlight, the quiet roads vicious masculinity: violence begetting felt like burgeoning gulfs. I reached more violence. Staring at them, I felt into my pocket to find a crushed pack a shuddering discomfort. I averted my of Marlboro Reds for a smoke, a habit eyes and walked home.

I had picked up in SCS, but I couldn’t In the next two months, I graduated find my lighter. Somewhere along the from the military and arrived at Yale. way, a car drove past me, its headlights On my first night out in New Haven, illuminating my dirty silhouette against my combat boots soaked up sticky an empty shopping mall. At the sight concoctions of beer, vodka, and fruit

M

8

March 2023 TheNewJournal

mixers instead of the squelching dirt, dead leaves, and rifle shells of the jungle floor. As I danced in the middle of the sloshing crowd, a group of men snaked their way in, bluntly pushing through me. A couple months prior, I would’ve shoved back, maybe more. But, something had shifted since that night walk.

To protect myself, I had adopted the violent tools of those before me, leaving Bing Jie in the hospital. Performing masculinity had not caused more harm. So I simply stared at them, not wanting to engage anymore.

I thought that I’d find solace in queer spaces, because it was the first time I could be so open about my own queerness. At an Office of LGBTQ Resources mixer, I was handed a nametag. “What do I write here?” I asked someone. “Your pronouns!” they answered. I tentatively put down “he/him,” unsure if it was

who I wanted to be anymore, but equally terrified of the alternative. The group shared their collective trauma: the ways in which they were shunned, bullied, and derided for their difference, largely by the men in their lives. I thought about every punishment I had ever subjected my recruits to. With each anecdote getting heavier and heavier, I left early, ashamed of myself. I hadn’t said a word to anyone.

I felt helplessly alone those first few months, but I refused to ask for help.

On Halloween night, while everyone around me prepared their costumes and left for parties, I laid paralyzed in my dorm. Without thinking, I grabbed a pair of scissors from my table and made around a half-dozen slashes on my forearm. Later that night, one of my suitemates called 911, and I was escorted to the psychiatric ward of Yale New Haven Hospital. While undergoing innumerable administrative, psychological, and medical procedures, what struck me the most was how easily my body fell into the monolithic category of “male.” I kept thinking about my position in the genealogy of manhood that I had known before: from the boys in school, the sergeants that trained me, and finally me to Bing Jie. I didn’t want to be a part of the lineage anymore. When I left the hospital, I walked back to my dormitory in the clear, cold New Haven morning air.

The sun was the brightest thing I could see and a part of me strangely felt stable.

Being a “man” was eating me alive, so I decided to stop.

In five months, I will have spent more time outside the military than in it. There is always an impulse to romanticize those times: the late night instant noodle parties, the raves we went to on our days off, the satisfying sense of exhaustion after finishing an exercise. I still miss catching crabs off the old bridge that we snuck out to when our recruits were asleep, and the genuine moments of tenderness in between smoke breaks and barking orders. That’s what I instinctively remember about all of it. But the SAF’s commands are all still there, in encrypted WhatsApp messages on my phone. When writing this piece, I spent hours sifting through them. The image of Bing Jie, unable to even crawl in that field, is still there. ∎

Aside

Jennifer’s Body The first time I watch Jennifer’s Body I am a budding adolescent huddled under my comforter during the first few months of the pandemic. Stale bedroom air presses into my lungs while crumbs brush against my unshaven legs. Over the next hour and forty minutes I am overcome by an unfamiliar zeal as I take in the bright outfits, hilarious dialogue, and mid-2000s emo soundtrack that plays while Jennifer Check and her best friend Needy unconvincingly pretend they aren’t in love with each other. The twentieth time I watch the movie is on 35mm at The Roxy in New York during my first summer on my own. I linger at the entrance and smile when I realize I can’t spot a single man.

In fact, I am surrounded by women who definitely had a crush on Megan Fox when they were 14. And in the velvet enclosure of the theater, we are teenagers again. The salt and butter of fresh popcorn mingles in the still air. We are suspended in a collective coming of age. We are filled to the brim with the kind of zeal you experience when you are finally seen.

Anaiis Rios-Kasoga

Jools Fu is a sophomore in Pierson College.

TheNewJournal

9

Snapshot

Yalesbians, Sappho, and the Lesbian Life of the Party A genealogy of lesbian social spaces at Yale.

By Sasha Carney

A

nna tender was “already very out” as bisexual when she came to Yale in 2018. Her first week on campus, she followed the stream of nervous first years to the fraternity houses on High Street, towards what seemed to be the archetypal college party: red Solo cups, a watered-down keg, and unremarkable music shaking the sticky walls. As she relaxed into the party, she began to dance with a girl next to her, letting her hands rest easily on her waist. Half-drunk, and thinking of very little except enjoying the night, Anna kissed her.

“Huge mistake,” she says of the public kiss now. A man leaned in and asked, leering, “Can I join?” They broke apart. Over the next few days, she found that the news of the kiss had spread through her residential college, without her knowledge or consent. People she barely knew “freaked out” at the fact that Anna, with her long hair and more femme style of dress, hadn’t been what they expected of her. A carefree moment turned into a public dissection of her sexuality. “After that,” she says about the party, “I was like, ‘Oh, okay. I get it. This is not a space for me.’”

She stopped going to frat parties, and started befriending more queer women: people she met in classes, her modern dance group, mutual friends, and hookups. Somebody added her to an email list for an organization called “Sappho,” an informal social group that hosted a semesterly party for queer women and nonbinary people. They promised a night out free from the 10

March 2023 TheNewJournal

anxiety that Anna felt at frats. Her sophomore year, she arrived at a “Euphoria”themed party in the basement of the women’s rugby team apartment on Elm Street. This was no Bud Light-ruled rager: attendees adorned themselves with glitter, sipping colorful, intricate cocktails made by student bartender Lauren Lee. She had already started to

Lesbians—growing doubly frustrated by the homophobia they experienced from straight women and the marginalization within gay spaces— felt they needed a space to breathe.

attend “smaller, more intimate” parties dominated by queer women, from wine nights hosted by girlfriends of friends to a set of lingerie parties hosted by an all-woman society. But Sappho was the largest gathering of queer women she’d seen in one space.

At “the Gay Ivy,” where, according to a Wall Street Journal article published

in 1987, at least “one in four” students are some kind of gay, lesbian social life is hardly an underground niche. But over the decades, Yale’s lesbians and queer women have wrestled with how to carve out a social life that is safe but still exciting.

1970s: Yalesbians begins

n September 1975, a record twelve IAlliance women attended a meeting of the Gay at Yale (GAY), a mostly male dis-

cussion and advocacy group. It was the height of the lesbian feminist movement, and some young lesbians were growing frustrated with what they saw as the patriarchal focus of gay activism across the United States. Four years before, the Yale Women’s Center was founded as a space for undergraduate women to gather.

In 1970, the activist Del Martin published an essay, “If That’s All There Is” in the lesbian review The Ladder, where she condemned gay rights organizations as sexist.

Lesbians—growing doubly frustrated by the homophobia they experienced from straight women and the marginalization within gay spaces—felt they needed a space to breathe.

Two lesbian undergraduates, the out-and-proud Tara Ayres and a partially anonymous woman identified only as “Sarah” by The Yale Daily News, formed a Yale-registered sister group to GAY known as “Yalesbians.” On a balmy September night, twenty lesbians and self-identified “straight woman” allies met for the first time at the GAY room

Photos courtesy of Maia Ettinger

in Hendrie Hall. They adopted the for- multiracial and cross-gender mat of “consciousness-raising circles,” than the “pretty white” nineseparatist open feminist discussions where women teen-seventies connected wider political issues to the world. She moved off-campus struggles of their everyday lives. The to 12 Whalley Avenue, where organization also co-ran multiple proj- she lived with fellow Yale ects with GAY, including a telephone gays Judith Rodenbeck, Lisa counseling service and a weekly radio Kennedy, and the late Donald Suggs, who later became known hour called “Come Out Tonight.”

Yale’s Weekly Bulletin and Calendar as a Black gay activist and jourinitially ignored requests to publicize nalist during his postgraduate Yalesbians’ weekly meetings. After a few life in New York City. While weeks, they finally responded and began Maia was a leader of on-campus to reluctantly spread the word. Through lesbian life at weekly Yalesbian word of mouth and print ads, member- meetings, the household threw ship grew to about one hundred people. after-hours parties that brought As co-founder, Tara noted Yalesbians’ campus gays together on more membership was a low estimate of the relaxed terms.

Rather than being exclutrue proportion of lesbians on campus, arguing in a 1977 report to the Yale sively lesbian, the household Corporation that the average gay woman “invited everyone cool, which at Yale “is probably not vocally a lesbian, was cool with us,” explains Maia. Though the parties and is afraid to be identified as such.”

On New Year’s Eve in 1976, a fire skewed gay, they allowed proud destroyed part of Hendrie Hall, burning lesbians and straight lefties out the room where Yalesbians and GAY alike to dance to Boy George, met, as well as the headquarters of the Annie Lennox, and Prince, who service frat Alpha Psi Omega. While the were bringing queer aesthetics frat was re-housed almost immediately, and sensibilities into poputhe administration dodged Ayres’ inqui- lar music for what felt like the ries about finding a space for Yalesbians first time.

Listening to Maia sketch for over a month. In late February, Tara Above: Maia Ettinger and her off-campus “household.” and GAY member Jack Winkler were out her gay world, I was Below: a Yalesbians party invitation. finally able to march up to the Associate enthralled by the vibrancy of Dean of Student Affairs’ office to secure her social and political life. I also started to wonder how my life would One athlete stood outside the door, trya new space in Bingham.

Off campus, meanwhile, many les- have unfolded on the gay campus of 1982. ing to intimidate her, and Maia “just bians could still find social and politi- I certainly wouldn’t have identified as hauled off and punched him in the eye.” cal community in the lesbian feminist nonbinary the way I do today—Maia She was proud to see him later that week scene in New Haven. “By the end of confirms that while “androgyny” was the with a black eye. The gays danced on.

Hostility continued to accumulate. the [1970s],” Yale alum and former word of the day, and something many Yale LGBTQ history professor George campus lesbians pursued, the language In February 1984, the senior class threw Chauncey wrote in The Yale Alumni just “wasn’t available” to identify outside a party at what is now Grace Hopper College, where the 17-year-old daughter Magazine, “New Haven was home to of womanhood.

Romantic and sexual relationships of a Yale faculty member was kicked in an extraordinarily vibrant and complex women’s culture and lesbian feminist flourished—most queer women that the stomach by male students. The men movement: the Feminist Union; femi- Maia knew had both casual encounters taunted the girl, and the female friends nist bookstores, women’s health centers, and long-term girlfriends. On nights out she was dancing with, with chants of self-defense classes.” While Yale lesbians at several gay off-campus apartments, “Lesbos!” Susan Arkun, a Yale College (and Yalesbians) found political homes open lesbians made out with the girls student who was verbally harassed at in New Haven’s more radical feminist who had attended weekday Yalesbians the event, explained to the News that scene, they often came cleaved closer to meetings as “straight allies.” The mood in social spaces she was often met with was both celebratory and anxious, and derision owing to her short dyed hair. “I campus to party. increased visibility came at a cost. In wish those lesbians would leave so we 1982, Yale’s LGBT Co-operative held the could tap the keg,” she overheard once.

1980s: Lesbians after hours first Gay and Lesbian Awareness Days Strangers shouted “Yalesbians!” at her y the late nineteen-seventies (GLAD), which culminated in an on-cam- on the street. and early nineteen-eighties, separat- pus dance for which the administration Maia freely accepts that in the face ism was no longer the word of the day. gave permission. Maia remembers a of these explosions of homophobia, some Maia Ettinger, a former official leader group of football players had overheard of her football player-punching bravado of Yalesbians, told me that by the nine- that a girl they knew, someone they cer- was bluster. She wishes the gay comteen-eighties, the gay “scene” was more tainly didn’t think was gay, was attending. munities on campus had the language

B

layout design by kevin chen

TheNewJournal March 2023

11

Yalesbians, Sappho, and the Lesbian Life of the Party sapphoyale.blogspot.com provided a way for queer women on campus to stay connected amid the emerging digital age.

at the time to articulate “how frightened we actually were.” At 18 or 19, she explains, “maybe you access anger more easily than you access your own vulnerability.” Parties are a good way to deflect from the fact that it is often difficult to be young and gay and alive.

Sappho comes out

faded, let down by a Ya alesbians quick student body turnover and lack of institutional memory. The

group’s archives were smaller and more informal than a lot of other, larger, official student orgs. Leadership changed hands, over and over again. By the time the third millennium rolled around, Yalesbians’ weekly, Wednesday meetings had stopped. I combed through campus newspaper archives to find some concrete reason for the organization’s dissolution, but came up with nothing. The last mention of the group I could find came in 1995, when the News advertised a regular Yalesbians meeting as part of “Sexuality Awareness Week.”

But lesbians, specifically, still wanted a space to come together. Sappho, named after the Greek poetess who gave us the word “lesbian,” was founded by an unknown group of queer women in 2004. Unlike Yalesbians, who were a registered student organization receiving Yale funding, Sappho began—and remained—an informal social collective.

Sticking true to Yalesbians’ 1979 declaration to “never again turn to the YDN” to publicize their work, Sappho in 2010 started to reach other on-campus queers in the most 2010 of ways: a blog.

On sapphoyale.blogspot.com, “queer, questioning, lesbian, bi, trans, and everything else in between women at Yale’’ could post, anonymously or not, about anything that came to mind.

In the style of full-on early 2010s hyper-enthusiasm, they gushed about their sexual awakenings (“I LOVE TOPPING . . . Eeeeee.”), brought gay political news to the blogosphere (“Yay, queer people can now visit thier [sic] partners in hospitals just like married people!”), and rejoiced over queer pop culture (“how awesome was glee in so many ways? way awesome.”) The blog encompassed the complexities of lesbian social life in the emerging digital age. On the one hand, queer women on campus could now stay connected to each other at all times, even in physical isolation. Dozens of posts popped 12

March 2023 TheNewJournal

up over summer and winter breaks, lamenting homophobic households and celebrating hometown pride parades.

But in some ways, with the arrival of the internet, lesbian spaces were also in the process of becoming more isolated, more dispersed. Websites like Tumblr, which flourished in the early 2010s, allowed younger queer people to “come out” under digital aliases, while remaining closeted in their day-to-day life, not taking the risk (and thrill) of venturing into physical queer spaces. Lesbians could raise their consciousness from the

comfort of their home, without looking another queer in the eye.

The blog only lasted a year before being replaced in September 2012 by a series of zines called “Hey Girl!” Perhaps Sappho’s new leadership, tiring of the dispersed nature of the digital, wanted to throw it back to the heyday of analog feminism. The DIY-style zines, frequently thrown together over the span of one night, were a deliberate aesthetic homage to the anarchist, punk, and Riot Grrrl subcultures of the nineteen-eighties and nineteen-nineties. They set out

Yalesbians, Sappho, and the Lesbian Life of the Party

Pages from the Sappho zine “Hey Girl!”

Sasha Carney / The New Journal

an ambitious agenda for what Sappho “make friends’’ and “make enemies.” would bring to the “queer ladies’’ of Yale, The zine folded after four issues. The including guerilla art, skillshares, protests, idea of “parties and pregaymes” stuck “parties and pregaymes,” and—suppos- around. Though it’s incredibly difficult edly—naked parties in the Yale Women’s to track down the “official” emergence of Center. The zine was earnest, funny, and Sappho parties, in 2014, a Silliman student pro-Beyonce. One full-page spread of named Zoe heard, through Facebook collages and hand-scrawled slogans groups and word of mouth, about a encouraged readers to “queer up Yale ‘’ in semesterly party for sapphic people only. any way they knew how. “GET OUT The series of Sappho parties, which was THERE! YOU DO YOU!” the caption funded entirely by the friend groups of blared over a drawing of a Venus symbol, juniors who put them on, was “passed a printed-out picture of the Hulk, and down” each year to a new friend group an invitation for lesbians everywhere to of queer women deemed sufficiently cool,

with enough off-campus space to host.

“Everyone seemed to know about it, but I can’t tell you how,” she recalls.

This sense of uncertainty and anonymity, which persisted throughout Sappho’s existence, is a kind of double-edged sword: these social spaces are at once unconstrained by official channels and institutional funding, and difficult to historicize or pin down. Of course, “everyone” can also never entirely encompass “everyone.”

Though Sappho invitations were entirely open, most knowledge of the parties, like in Maia’s day, boiled down to who already knew who.

As sophomores, Zoe and her roommates were selected to throw next year’s Sappho parties, but with few guidelines and no funding by the women who came before them. With money they had saved from campus jobs and donations from attendees, they put on a couple successful events where “people were definitely there to hook up.” Zoe recalled these parties as “more mixed-race and more genderfruity” than most other campus parties, and found herself encountering butchness as a possibility she could pursue for the first time. Attendees felt at ease picking up women in ways they didn’t elsewhere on campus—ways Anna didn’t at the frat party her first year. The next year, Zoe and her friends passed the baton to another Silliman friend group.

She confesses that she has no idea if they carried it on.

They did, although some people grew frustrated with the slowness of the parties’ semesterly format. “I think we need more parties to cruise at and have sex at,” recent Yale alumnus Mia Arias Tsang told me bluntly. She spent most of her time on campus surrounded by other queer women of color through her work at Broad Recognition, a campus feminist publication. Though she was already in those environments in her day-to-day life, she was looking for more explicitly sexual and romantic lesbian spaces afterhours. She remembers her disappointment at missing a Sappho party in 2017 where attendees reportedly did body shots. Anna both expressed to me that although she wasn’t seeking sex at the parties, being in multiple monogamous relationships through her time at Yale, she enjoyed their distinct atmosphere, at once both electric and celebratory.

When Mia did attend the fall 2019 Sappho party in the rugby basement, she felt a huge “pressure to fuck” owing to how infrequent and unpredictable the TheNewJournal March 2023

13

Asides

Dash of Fancy

Grocery Store

At seventeen, I devoted myself to the pursuit of eroticism. Evolutionary imperatives necessitated a baseline sexual appetite, but I was more concerned with Sontag. “In place of a hermeneutics we need an erotics of art,” Sontag contends in her 1966 essay “Against Interpretation.” In a miasma of theory, she believed that art had lost its fervor. Now, with heads cocked to analysis, audiences set out on interpretive undertakings at the first twitch of a curtain rising, at the edge of a frame, in the didactic aisles of a title page. We no longer laid ourselves bare and let art wash over us. We no longer felt the acerbic burn when its saline waves seeped into wounds we had forgotten.

I learned desire in the aisles of the grocery store.

It was a world of pleasure, of throbbing stimulation and tantalizing unknowns. So many things were off-limits: cheese puffs beckoning me with their curved fingers; cookies in perfect rows, glistening through plastic windows; bottles of soda, jewel-like in their translucent vibrancy (surely the liquid itself was not that bright green, I reasoned, and what did a mountain taste like?); rows and rows of cereal boxes like a city on the cutting edge of nightlife, fractal-like in their varieties—this one chocolate and that fruity, this with raisins and that oat clusters, this frosted and that with marshmallows and another frosted and with marshmallows! The hope that these delicacies could one day be mine helped me cope with the profound emptiness I felt knowing that there existed flavors and textures beyond my wildest dreams. With the barebone constituents of my existing culinary experience, I cobbled together succulent fantasies to tide me over until I could satiate myself for real. I imagined frosting so creamy it felt like the softest part of a child’s palm, chocolate so expertly balanced between sweet and bitter it could remain upright on a tightrope, gelatinous candies that my teeth would sink into like they were slipping into sleep.

I was no different. An erudite floozy, I had taken to reading the wall text before looking at the painting. No longer! With “Against Interpretation” in tow, I set out to let art stir me. Orgasm was the endgame. But like an addict whose senses were dulled by their fix, I could no longer get off on art alone. I craved a hit of theory, chased the electric jolt of recognizing classical allusion. I was Paolo and Francesca in Dante’s fifth Canto, tossed about by blustering waves of desire. Fuck, that was good.

Music was my first exception. If I sat very still in the dark and turned my headphones as loud as they would go, I could start to detect the buds of excitement. Alone in my room, I had no one to tell that Berlioz was quoting the dies irae in the fifth movement of “Symphonie Fantastique.”

Instead, I let the crashing gongs throb unanalyzed.

I trembled with emotion. I was redeemed.

Amal Biskin

14

Amal Biskin

Yalesbians, Sappho, and the Lesbian Life of the Party

parties were. She felt that these opportunities were somewhat scarce, and felt anxious about not taking full advantage of them. “I went with friends who all peeled off and found other people to have sex with,” she recalls. She adds that she was pleasantly surprised by the amount of lesbians of color there, but “at any Yale space,” she acknowledges, “as a queer [woman of color], if you’re trying to get laid, it’s going to be hard.” Still, she came away grateful for the experience, and excited for next semester. But before the next party, Covid hit.

possible. Last semester, I had top sur- is bioessentialist. “It’s drilled into our gery through Yale Health. Newly healed heads, for better or for worse, that lesbithis semester, I feel more comfortable at anism is associated with pussy.” parties and excited to dance, but more While campus “lesbian life” has anxious in things closer to “women’s become more trans, Sappho parties have spaces.” I jump back at the thought of arguably become less so. After the onset throwing someone off in a bathroom of Covid-19, what events have popped or changing room. I believe “lesbian up feel distinctly lackluster. Lily, a senior spaces’’ can, and should, include people who started attending Sappho events like me, but I don’t always feel at ease in 2022, describes the two parties they in those dominated by cisgender, gen- stopped by simply as “boring.” The music der-conforming women. The concept was soft, the drinks were sparse, and the of a “lesbian-only” or “woman-only” energy was conversational—more of an space can sometimes be code for “cis “affinity group” than a party space. After women-only,” something Maia worried recently beginning to present more masculine, they were acutely aware that the Today: Everyone is gay people they met at a fall 2022 Sappho s of 2023, “lesbian life” or “queer party were “almost all femmes, and pretty women’s life” spills out into much of white too.” They headed home early. everyday life at Yale. With outness not Attendance at these last two parties only encouraged at Yale, but essentially was small, something exemplified by the the default in vast swathes of the campus’ relative lack of undergraduate knowlacademic and social world, many lesbiedge about Sappho. When I asked her ans don’t have to look for “lesbian groups” about Sappho parties, Ava, who arrived or “gay issues” to find the comfort and at Yale in 2021, confessed “I don’t know community they seek. “It felt like my life what that is.” The same things that make was inherently a queer space in a way I Sappho exciting, flexible, and cool—the The definition never experienced before college,” Mia lack of Yale institutional ties or funding, of a “ lesbian explains. Many other queer students the informality of leadership, word of echoed this sentiment, feeling that while mouth—also make the whole operation social space” is they variously enjoyed Sappho parties, hard to maintain. By the time someone also increasingly they didn’t feel the need to attend them intending to throw a Sappho party has changing as to find sex, love, or friendship. the means to bring their idea to fruition, “I don’t think I hang out with anythey may have already graduated. Not to the idea of one who isn’t queer,” Ava Dadvand, mention, there’s no unified vision behind “ lesbianism” does. an Iranian trans lesbian, decided after what makes a Sappho party “good.” thinking for a moment. She finds most I, for one, don’t want the Sappho of her queer friends through Beyond party tradition to die out. Lesbian nightthe Binary, an official on-campus trans life on campus—the kinds experienced and nonbinary social group, as well as

by Ettinger in the nineteen-eighties, or through social media, friends of her what Anna reveled in as a first-year—is partner, and other mutual friends. A lot facing a number of challenges. The difof it is incidental. On an increasingly ficulties of resurrecting marginalized “out” campus, you can meet other lesbiparty spaces after Covid, the hesitancy ans and sapphic people with ease from a around where exactly to define “lesbiclass seminar to the line for lunch. Add anism” or “queer womanhood,” and the in the queer-centric social spaces of Yale uncertainty around whether exclusively Twitter, as well as the opportunities for about when I described Sappho parties gay social life even needs its own space casual sex and romance from dating apps, to her over the phone. “The parties aren’t on such a strongly queer campus, all and you’re giving Sappho-specific bulle- trans-exclusionary, right?” she asked seem to lead people to pause before they tins like Sappho.blog and Hey Girl! a run sharply. I assured her that they weren’t, send out an invitation to a naked party for their money. at least not in their advertising. But it’s in the Women’s Center. I say, there’s The definition of a “lesbian social certainly possible that some trans people value in taking the extra, deliberate space” is also increasingly changing as stay away. effort: to carve out a semesterly space, the idea of “lesbianism” does. While the Ava is perfectly happy finding a to reach queer women beyond your Sappho of the early 2010s nominally home in what she calls “dyke spaces,” social group, to confront the contradicincluded trans women in the labeling of but also notes that she’s found it a lot tions of a lesbian night out. Let the gays their organization (if not in the content easier since she had bottom surgery last dance on. ∎ of their blogs and zines), the language of summer. She concedes that this sounds the world of “lesbians” has become more “bioessentialist” of her, overly focused complex and gender-diverse as medical on genitalia as the site of sexuality.

Sasha Carney is a senior in and social transition become increasingly But, after all, she explains, our society Silliman College.

A

TheNewJournal March 2023

15

Counter Memories Is gay nightlife getting quieter?

A writer explores the histories inside New Haven gay bars.

By Jabez Choi 16

Layout design by Kevin Chen & photographs by nour tantush

17

I

t is a building that looks like it is hiding.

Some windows are blurred with frosted glass.

Others are boarded up. The walls are painted an aged white, peeling at some parts. On the side of the building, a small, orange sign names the building: Partners. Underneath a piercing streetlight, just next to the mural of a smiling Anne Frank, a man stands by himself, a lit cigarette in his mouth.

Nothing on the outside reveals that the building is one of the oldest gay bars in New Haven.

On Fridays and Saturdays, Partners opens its second floor to reveal a glittery night club. There, mirrors cover the walls and a spinning light shines on young, dancing bodies in the dark. Those are the endless nights—loud and hazy and crowded. On Sundays, the second floor closes, leaving the ground floor open for karaoke night. It draws in a smaller crowd. Now, it’s Monday night in February and the bar is barren—except for Paul, me, and two drunk men. The two men had waited outside the bar’s front door before he’d arrived. Now, they sit at the counter with me, babbling over each other. They interrupt Paul while he talks to me, asking for another drink.

Paul leaves to fill up their shot glasses.

“I was telling him how annoying it is when people showed up to the bar at seven fifty-nine, knocking on the door,” Paul says, nodding towards me.

They cackle in response.

“If your ass is open at eight, you better be open,” one of them shoots back.

Paul half-smiles. Then, he turns to me and rolls his eyes.

I like Paul for two reasons. The first is that he speaks to me like a friend. By nature, I am an anxious person. Despite this, we quickly chat like two old gossips. The second is that he is seasoned. He moved to New Haven from Massachusetts over a decade ago to work at Partners. This is his eleventh year behind the counter, and it shows—he is fluid, quick with his words. He’s seen more than me.

“So what was the gay bar scene like when you first started working here?” I ask.

“I want to say it was more gay men. Today, we have everything. Like, sometimes I’m working and I’m like, when did this become a straight bar?” he says, pouring another drink for one of the men. “There’s a lot of different types of people that come in and out of here all the time.”

As he talks, these broad terms—“everything,” “different types of people”—become clearer. Paul tells me that Partners defines itself as a gay bar, a gathering ground that has historically served queer people in New Haven. However, the events that the bar hosts—karaoke open-mics, bingo nights, goth dances, drag shows—now draw in straight people alongside the typically queer crowd. It isn’t abnormal to run into straight couples on a Friday night.

Partners’ clientele widened over the years; the bar became a space for a broader, open-minded community, rather than a specific queer one. Though these capacities still have queer communities in mind, the formerly rigid boundaries have blurred.

“So the culture of the clientele has changed?” I ask.

18

“Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it doesn’t ruin the vibes or anything. It’s just that times are changing. Gay bars, straight bars, you’re going anywhere you want,” Paul says. “No one’s really afraid to come here anymore. I mean, ten years ago, the straight men, they’d be like, ‘Oh, my God, I’m not going to a gay bar.’”

I understand. The culture change Paul talks about is something that has manifested in my generation, my lifetime. I was twelve when the Supreme Court recognized gay marriage as a legal right. I watched characters on television proclaim their gayness to accepting arms. I had openly queer friends who I fought and reconciled and grew up with. Whenever I hated myself, I could look at my queer friends and recognize that they were lovable. And through my love for them, I knew I was lovable too. In an odd way, I recognize that my ability to do this is evidence of an undeniable societal shift. Could this shift change landscapes of queer gathering? What happens to a space when the stigmatization that used to define it is dissolving? I think these questions as Paul talks.

“Then, does this mean gay bars are not needed anymore?” I ask. “As opposed to, say, any old bar?”

“Well, we still need them. I mean, Partners? It’s always going to be Partners. Everyone’s going to be coming here,” he says, assuredly. “It’s just now, it’s like a space for almost everybody.”

“So what does Partners mean to you?” I ask.

“A paycheck,” Paul jokes. The two drunk men next to me laugh. meet Bernard at Partners, two hours before Iquiet. opening. I have never seen the bar so empty and The main room is dark except for two spot-

lights that shine overhead. We sit in adjacent seats by the counter. I begin to fidget. When I look at Bernard’s hands, I notice that he, too, is fidgeting.

Bernard mentions growing up in a conservative family in a small town in Mexico. In 1993, Bernard immigrated to the United States. He was in his twenties and exploring New Haven gay bars. At Partners, he met Dave Klemens. Today, the two are married and run the bar together as co-owners. According to Bernard, not much has changed over the years in how they run their business. They have their cheap drinks, their drag shows, their busy weekends and softer weekends.

“The community has been evolving but we don’t exactly change with them, you know,” he says. “You can do everything on phones. But I mean, person-to-person is better. I don’t know how to explain it.” He pauses. Then—“That was the model the previous owners founded. And Dave kept doing the same thing. If it’s not broken, why fix it?”

Gay bars depend on the “person-to-person” model that Bernard emphasizes in a way that differs from any other bar. Usually, people go to bars to meet other people over a drink, to form a community, to relax and let loose. But the notion of a gay man letting loose is a radical act in this context. It means sexual identities could finally be actualized. It means camaraderie in a society that has condemned Counter Memories

The unassuming exterior of Partners and its accompanying mural of Anne Frank.

Could this shift change landscapes of queer gathering?

What happens to a space when the stigmatization that used to define it is dissolving?

March 2023

Counter Memories

19

20

n between interviews, I stop by the New ISoto, Haven Pride Center. Inside, I meet Juancarlos the interim director of the center. When I enter,

he has just gotten off the phone. After we talk, we find out both of our fathers are pastors. I laugh at this coincidence. We sit in a room covered with rainbow flags. On the wall beside us, there is a mural of men dancing. Queer history books line the bookshelf next to him. The room is warmly lit by a lamp, illuminating his face. We’re sitting in a chapel of queer paraphernalia.

“I think sometimes we can create harm when we call something a safe space, because the reality is violence still happens, even within our own community.

I still interact with queer spaces that don’t feel safe,” Juancarlos says. “Unfortunately, the same things we were fighting fifty years ago are still the same things we’re fighting today. In terms of how anti-trans folks are describing trans individuals and non-binary folks, it’s really the same playbook that we were using in the eighties. It’s just we swapped around terms.”

When Juancarlos describes “safe” queer spaces, such as the Pride Center or New Haven’s gay bars, he likes to call them “brave” spaces. It is an acknowledgement—though aspects of safety have arrived with acceptance, in Juancarlos’ eyes, acceptance has not fully arrived. And if safety cannot truly be guaranteed, why offer a false promise? Any queer space demands the bravery of queer people to exist.

It feels strange to assume acceptance has arrived.

Less than halfway through 2023, the United States has seen more anti-LGBTQ bills than the past five years combined. These bills have included a wide range of attacks, from bans on gender-affirming care and drag shows to the discontinuation of LGBTQ education in schools. Last year saw the murders of at least thirty-eight transgender people in the United States according to the Human Rights Campaign.

And memories of Colorado Springs, where a 2022 shooting at a gay club left five dead and seventeen wounded, are still fresh on the minds of many gay club-goers. Yet, though queer violence continues to persist, Juancarlos and I both agree that the queer community has changed dramatically.

“The ways the HIV epidemic and guilt have marked older generations compared to how its marked younger generations are very different, right?

Because of how much more we know around prevention and how fewer deaths we have now in comparison, when you talk to younger generations, the way you talk about the virus is almost flippant in younger generations compared to older adults,” Juancarlos says. “I think all of those things create differences in their experiences and the issues that they face. But I think if we pause and talk to each other, we may realize that they’re more like the same things that we were fighting.”

He’s right. Scrolling through TikTok, I come across influencers like Zach Willmore, who has been vlogging his life since his positive HIV test results. The videos are mundane. In some, he powders his face with makeup while talking about his medication treatment. In others, he shops for shoes.

Counter Memories

It feels strange to assume acceptance has arrived. Less than halfway through 2023,

queer lives. These often anonymous communities were essential to an entire generation of gay men; these bars were one of the few places they could gather. Outside the normative hours, into the nighttime, one could experience their first sexual encounters with other queer people in the liminality of the gay bar. With little barriers to self-expression, the gay bar becomes a place of genesis. Unique queer aesthetics were born: leather and kink sub-cultures, drag personas, cruising codes, creations a heteronormative society might find abnormal. Bernard puts it in a simpler way.

“For me, it was just liberating to come to a gay bar.

I knew I was gay, always. But it wasn’t talked about until I came here.” he says. “You see your gay friends.

It’s gay community so it’s fun, you know?”

Bernard tells me that Partners was founded in 1974 by Jack Garity and two friends, who ran the bar for fifteen years before handing it off to Dave.

Almost fifty years later, the bar is still open. It had survived the peak of the epidemic and the twenty-first century decline of gay bars nationwide. In March 2020, the bar closed due to the coronavirus pandemic. The face-to-face intimacy that the bar provided for the queer community momentarily disappeared. Nevertheless, once Bernard and Dave got state approval, they opened their doors again in May 2021. People flooded the bar and lined up out the door, clamoring to get inside and dance. In a time in which businesses were closing left and right, the community showed out for Partners.

Perhaps Partners is one of the lucky ones. The years between 2007 and 2019 saw a closure of 37 percent of gay bars across the United States and the pandemic ensured the closure of even more. More dire, around 200 lesbian bars have closed since the 1980s, leaving twenty-seven lesbian bars in the nation today according to the Lesbian Bar Project.

There have been numerous theories to explain this sudden uptick in closures. Some blame dating apps like Grindr or Scruff that have replaced the gay bar’s person-to-person model. Some blame an exhaustion among gay consumers, resulting from the extensive marketing of spaces and products as “gay” or “queer.” But others seem to hint toward a changing of attitudes within the LGBTQ+ community. Namely, that with a new generation marked by queer acceptance, the need for specific gay spaces as safe spaces is diminishing. In the context of the gay bar, acceptance almost seems like a contradictory phenomenon.

“There will always be the same need for gay people: love and acceptance,” Bernard tells me. “And we’ll provide that here. Because you can make a fool of yourself here. You can go to another place that accepts gay people but you need a safe space. You know that you are different and you always need a place to see your friends.”

He holds his hands up: “This is it.”

In my head, I repeat love and acceptance. I decide to take him for his word.

TheNewJournal

The end result, even on an interface like TikTok, is revolutionary—HIV is no longer seen as a death sentence. But with this cultural shift, a strange dilemma arises: is normalization synonymous with forgetting?

Juancarlos celebrates these generational changes. At the same time, he still seems concerned, unconvinced.

We are still fighting the same things.

“The movement sort of went dormant and silent.

We were like, ‘Oh, we have gay marriage. We have a president on TV talking about his evolution on same sex marriage. We don’t have to worry about high risk infections of HIV.’ Mind you. Black and brown, specifically, black trans women, were getting murdered at incredible rates,” he says. “Honestly, the LGBTQ community sort of got complacent. It feels like we are going backwards these days.”

streets away from the bar and wear reflective jackets to obscure their identities as they entered and left.

Anonymity was synonymous with nightlife.

“You had nicknames when you were going out, you know. People said ‘Call me Charlie, call me this, call me that,’ So everyone had names until you’re going back to the pub again and all of a sudden Charlie didn’t show up,” he says. “Then you found out that Charlie wasn’t his real name. And then you found out that if you didn’t see him in six months, you were sure he passed away.”

He quickly says goodbye to a departing friend.

Turning back, he takes a sip of his drink.

“People who were different came to a gay bar because there was no place else to go. Gay bars were shelters for them,” Joey says. “You wouldn’t see too many straight people in the gay bar back then. They were homophobic. We lived undergroundpurposely.” street over from Partners, another gay bar Joey sees more straight people entering 168 York called 168 York Street Cafe hides in the basement now. This isn’t anything that bothers him. In fact, he of a brick townhouse. Its windows are shy, peeking finds it humorous. He describes how a straight man just barely above ground level. From the outside, I will walk in, bypass the rainbow flags hanging above don’t notice too much. Maybe the movement of a the drinks, the trans pride colors on the refrigerator, dim shadow. And a faint Whitney Houston melody. the drag show advertisements on the walls, and sit When the night falls, loneliness calls . . . down for a drink. As more of the regulars walk in, When I enter, I hear the disco of the seven- the man will slowly realize where he is. Joey describes ties, the divas of the eighties—Whitney Houston, the man’s sudden nervousness when he asks the barCyndi Lauper, Donna Summer. It’s a far cry from tender if 168 York is a gay bar. the glitzy dance-pop that had reverberated from “I love it. It just entertains me the most. I’m sayPartners’ speakers. Nobody here dances. There is no ing to myself ‘God, I hope so-and-so doesn’t come need to. 168 York is a pub, not a nightclub. Instead of in. They’re going to give the whole thing away!’” Joey movement, there is the warm clamor of voices. The says, laughing. handful of patrons all seem familiar with one another, “Do you think the gay bar should in some way be sitting on the long counter, talking over each other, gate-kept?” I ask. “As in just for gay people?” laughing. Once in a while, a man walks in and the Joey shakes his head. “No. I always wanted to be noise crescendos. People look up, nod, hug, say hello, an educator. Being a bar owner, you have a responsithen goodbye. Amidst the noise, Joey Goodwin, the bility to say this is unacceptable, this is acceptable.” he owner of the bar, sits at the very end of the counter, a says. “I thought the only way that I would ever fulfill seat usually reserved for him. I sit next to him. that dream was to have people come in here and let “Look at this handsome gentleman interviewing them know that we’re not as bad as they think.” me,” Joey tells a leaving friend. “Oh, who am I kidHow Joey sees it, gay bars are used as a kind of ding. You look old enough to be my grandson.” guided discovery. By having straight people confront I laugh. It’s true. I am the youngest in the queerness in the gay bar, the fear regarding sexualroom by many years. As I sit next to Joey, I real- ity becomes obscured and ideally, leads to an obvious ize I have never in my life been surrounded by reckoning—that queer people, at their foundation, older gay men. Age, I realize, is a strange privilege. are human too. In the gay bar, the straight man For an older generation of gay men, lives seemed becomes othered by his straightness. Sexuality is not quickly lived. In a way, escaping youth was an odd defined by its relation to heterosexuality. It is defined, accomplishment. Here, all these men sit laughing, for once, in the context of queerness. in a future they have created for themselves. The “Are people trying to start new gay bars these wooden walls—a worn brown—testify to the bar’s days?” I ask. age. The floor’s faded planks creak at certain steps.

“I don’t see anyone waiting in line to open up a Joey used to sand the floors when he needed to gay bar, that I can tell you,” he says. “They don’t want deep clean. Now, after so many years, he can’t sand any more duplications of a gay bar anymore, because them down anymore without their nails breaking everything’s so diluted now. Most people don’t have loose. Between the previous owners and Joey, 168 to go to a gay bar anymore.”

York has existed in some form for about sixty years, “Do you think at one point . . .” I start to say. making it Partners’ senior. The bar, like Partners, He interrupts me, already knowing my question. has stood through the heights of the AIDS epidemic “Your question is, okay. There was a need for a gay bar and COVID-19, as well as a fire that burned down its but because of cultural changes, you’re thinking how old location in 1978. long I can stay in the game for.”

Joey talks about the levels of caution that used to I nod. He looks back at me knowingly. In the exist for gay bars. He tells me bar-goers would park background, there is an eruption of laughter. Someone,

the United States has seen more anti-LGBTQ bills than the past five years combined.

A

March 2023

Counter Memories

21

22

Counter Memories

TheNewJournal

Outside (left) and inside (above) 168 York Street.

In the gay bar, the straight man becomes othered by his straightness.

Sexuality is not defined by its relation to heterosexuality. It is defined, for once, in the context of queerness.

March 2023

Counter Memories

23

another friend of the bar, must have walked in.

“I question myself every day about that,” Joey says.

“More and more people keep accepting the fact that there are different people. And because of that, our customer base is dropping. Now people are accepted.

They can go anywhere they want right now, and have a really good time.”

As he says this, I look at his face. His voice does not change, nor does he look upset.

“Why do you think the bar has lasted as long as it has?” I ask. “Through so much?”

“We are resilient,” he says. His voice quiets. “But why? That’s the question.”

I pause when he says this. Joey had asked a question that I often think of: Why do we have to be resilient? Put another way, why does it cost so much strength to live?

“We started doing the magazine spreads of all the photos,” Seth says. “People would be very, very interested. They would go ‘Oh, I might be in it’ and they all started grabbing the magazine to look at it.”

As the years passed, though, Metroline began to falter. As more advertisers began using online mailing lists and other digital methods, Metroline, alongside other advertisement-reliant publications, took a hit. By the early 2010s, the magazine had become defunct.

“The internet started coming in. And that started killing the magazine,” Seth says. “The bar owners more and more started saying, ‘Why should I pay an ad in your magazine?’ It just became financially not feasible to keep the magazine in print because the bars weren’t paying.”

Over the years, the bars listed on Metroline’s backpages started cycling out, too. Seth says himself that the lifespan of a bar at the time was at most he next day, 168 York is empty. The noise that seven years. In New Haven, the gay bars—Choices, filled the bar the night before has slipped out the Maxie’s, Saloon—slowly became replaced with the window. Behind the counter, a bartender shuffles a Brownstone, the Krpyt, Beach Head Cafe. And after set of cards, then lines them facedown on the counter. a few years, those new names disappeared from the He plays by himself. I do not bother him. pages of Metroline. The addresses still exist today, but In the next room, I meet Seth Evans. He is just in their places, new businesses now stand. In some about to have his weekly dinner here at 168 York. cases, only empty, desolate buildings remain. At a He sits under a dim spotlight, sipping on a golden certain point, the only gay pubs that stood were drink. It glows in the light. Seth was the last editor- Partners and 168 York. in-chief of a Hartford-based LGBTQ+ publication “Will the bars continue to be a sanctuary?” I ask. called Metroline. The magazine intimately captured “It’s not as potent now as it was then. You’ll see queer New England life from the AIDS epidemic to straight couples come in and sit down and have just after Connecticut’s legalization of gay marriage drinks for a while. The acceptance, I don’t know if it’s in 2008. Between their coverage of the epidemic a good way or a bad way, kind of diluted the populaand interviews with activists, the magazine adver- tion.” he said. “You found different people coming in, tised the Connecticut bar scene. Seth knows many you know, it became like foreigners in our sanctuary.” of the bars closely, especially 168 York, where he “Acceptance,” to Seth, marked a departure from would write many of his own articles for Metroline a point that a previous generation lived through. at the counter.

But how do we make progress while remembering “What does the gay bar mean to you?” I ask. the past?

“The bar scene means to me what it means to the “Do you feel that your experiences pre-acceptance first person that walked into the oldest gay bar in are valued by my generation?” I ask bluntly.

Connecticut,” Seth says. “Sanctuary.”

“They don’t know that they appreciate it yet,” he “Sanctuary,” I repeat back to him. says. “Each of these generations contributed, you “The normal kid grows up in a home environ- know, little bits of acceptance, little bits of acceptance, ment where they’re seeing Mom and Dad, and all little bits of acceptance, it was a great wall built by the normal heterosexual way things are supposed to one stone at a time.” be. Where does that kid get guidance?” Seth said. “If In a Metroline article titled “Remembering you don’t come out to the clubs and allow yourself to Stonewall,” a contributor writes, “Our present combe yourself, you’ll never know who you are.” munity needs to remember the event with clarThis form of sanctuary is well-encapsulated in ity . . .The 25th anniversary of the Stonewall Riots is the pages of Metroline. Near the beginning of most a suitable reminder to do the right thing.” Later in issues, there are pictures of New Haven gay bars at the article, the writer honors the Black, transgender their prime. A camera’s flash reveals wide smiles, and gender non-conforming activists who had been sparkling drinks, bare skin. The dark rooms are leading the queer liberation movements since the filled to the brim with bodies. Queer joy is abun- nineteen-sixties. In a later issue, the fear of a collecdant. Underneath, captions read their locations: tive queer amnesia is spelled out in an op-ed titled: Chapel Pub Cafe, Choices, Maxie’s, Saloon—all older “WE MUST NEVER ACCEPT AIDS.” The conNew Haven bars. Large bar advertisements adorn tributing writer opines to the remaining gay commualmost every other page. The back of each Metroline nity that an acceptance of AIDS would be “forgetting” edition reveals a list of clubs for each Connecticut an entire generation of “brothers” lost to the disease. city, all of which have advertised in the issue numer- One advertisement pages after reads in large, bold ous times. The sentiment was clear—the clubs were lettering—“You can get HOSPITALIZED. You open and alive. can DIE.” The last word takes up most of the page.

24

Counter Memories

At a certain point, the only gay pubs that

T

TheNewJournal

stood were Partners and 168 York.

Three front covers and one back cover of the Metroline magazine.

Photos courtesy of Jabez Choi.

March 2023

Counter Memories

25

Partners Cafe.

We continue to talk—about the man’s partner, about our own partners, our own histories.

At that point, I stop taking notes. There is no need.

I remember the night clearly. We had shared secrets and now, I can only write so much.

26

Counter Memories

TheNewJournal

At the same time, Metroline writers envisioned started off as a protection measure, Bryan reclaims it brighter futures. An op-ed in a 1994 issue by Larry as a method of remembering queer culture.

Kirk titled “THE YEAR OF QUEER” reads: “It “Why do we do that? I’m using these pronouns is through such actions that our movement will ulti- in a different capacity because that’s what historically mately prevail, that the world will be made safer for a what we built on, from the raiding of bars,” he says. new generation of gay boys and girls. If this can hap- “Was I a part of that? No, I wasn’t a part of that. Do pen in 1994, it will indeed be the Year of the Queer, I know a little bit of that history? Do I want to keep no matter what else may, or may not occur.” The some of those things alive? Absolutely.” magazine attempted to immortalize turbulent and “This is your way of remembrance,” I say. frustrating moments. But, the pages are yellowed.

“Absolutely. How do we move forward from that, They carry a faint scent of dust. The advertisements while still acknowledging and respecting by mainand pictures look inexplicably off-kilter, an estrange- taining our culture?” he says. “Are you looking at ment only time can inflict.

America? Like, where are we going right now? We’ve Seth’s face changes, just slightly, after he sips already done all this stuff and now we’re going back his drink. because we’ve forgotten what we’ve already done.”

“What about the people that aren’t here?” He When he finishes, Bryan leaves me to tend to a says, his voice eases. “They have got no clue of under- regular, a man in a checkered shirt. As he pours a standing, all the sacrifice and all the commitment to drink for the man, he asks where the man’s partner equality that went down to create this, to bring it is. Before he can answer, Bryan asks if they had been to fruition.” fighting again. The two laugh. Bryan introduces me to the man. I also ask where this man’s partner is. We continue to talk—about the man’s partner, about our he next night, I talk with Bryan. He works own partners, our own histories. At that point, I stop behind the counter at 168 York some nights. He taking notes. There is no need. I remember the night doesn’t like the title “bartender,” though. Making clearly. We had shared secrets and now, I can only drinks is a gig he fell into by happenstance. A few write so much. years ago, Bryan walked into 168 York on a whim.

He sat by himself at a table by the windows. Across the room, Joey played setback with some friends. n a corner room at Partners, I play pool with Bryan watched, then eventually joined. They would a stranger who is old enough to be my father. I play together every week for two years. One day, a don’t call him my father, but I imagine that he is to bartender position opened, and Joey hired Bryan feign some intimacy. It is a close game, only because on the spot. we are both bad shots. In between turns, we talk. He “He looked to me like, you’re gonna be my new is an artist from New York, but whenever he is in bartender. I said ‘No, no. I’ve never done this before,’” town, he stops by Partners for a drink. In the end, he Bryan says. Then, jokingly: “It just kept happening. I beats me by just one ball. I’m lucky we haven’t bet can’t get out of it. I can’t make it stop!” on anything.

Bryan says he is at a strange age, describing “You’re supposed to be better than me,” he says, himself as being “right in the middle.” He didn’t laughing. “I’m all old now.” live through the AIDS epidemic like the generation He grabs his quarters and his bag. Before he before him. But he says he wasn’t exactly marked leaves, though, I ask if I could see his art. He spreads by the “acceptance” that seems to define the current his notepads across the pool table. They are worn. generation. He remembers growing up with stories One by one, he shows me his drawings, each a sketch of Matthew Shepard, a gay student at the University of a previous lover. Or a friend. Or a lover of a friend. of Wyoming who was killed in 1998 as a result of an They are all nude. He tells me how he fell in and out anti-gay hate crime. He still remembers when polit- of love with one of the naked men. And as he talks, I ical parties across the spectrum all opposed gay mar- realize the man misses him. Some of these men, he still visits back in New York. Others have since died. riage. Now, he notices the stark differences.

“I cannot just so unapologetically go to any bar I He doesn’t mention anything more. His eyes soften want to with a boy and feel comfortable kissing that on the pages.

It’s karaoke night. In the background, a man person,” he says. “You feel comfortable kissing everyone until you do that in the wrong place. You don’t sings “Bad Romance.” He’s impressively offkey. A understand the importance of having a safe place. group of people laugh. They all clink their glasses.

And why gay bars are so in need of being protected I stay for a few more minutes, humming along to the Lady Gaga song. The man reaches the final as safe spaces.”

As he talks, I notice that remembrance for chorus, and people begin clapping. I leave soon Bryan is significant. He takes pride in remember- after. Walking down Crown Street, I shiver. It has ing this past era. Certain traditions he still upholds suddenly become cold. ∎ with other bar-goers. Inside gay bars, Bryan calls his friends “Mary,” after a practice in the 80’s and 90’s of men calling their partners “Mary” to obscure the fact Jabez Choi is a sophomore in Trumbull College that they were seeing men. Inside the bar, Bryan only and an Asociate Editor of The New Journal. responds to feminine pronouns. Though this practice

T

I

March 2023

Counter Memories

27

Snapshot

Local advocate Tony Ferraiolo guides trans youth—and their parents— through the complications of their gender journeys.

Drawing it Out Local advocate Tony Ferraiolo guides trans youth—and their parents— through the complications of their gender journeys.

28

layout design by Etai Smotrich-bArr & Kevin Chen

TheNewJournal

Left: Hannah Szabó / The New Journal

By Hannah Szabó

Left: “Viotinah Szagah,” 2011, Hannah Szabó, age 8.

Made in Tony’s drawing group, labeled with an elaborate reimagining of my birth name.

gender-nonconforming youth and their parents.

A lack of conventional publicity has not prevented Tony’s group from expanding, however. Fifteen years after its founding, the program is thriving, with dozens of kids and families attending each week. When I started attending as a first-grader, I was one of the youngest, shyly watching the teenagers joke around in the room next door; now, there are facilitators and ‘junior facilitators’ (past members who have aged out of the program and want to remain involved) who help Tony manage the larger number of kids. He has split the group into three simultaneous sessions with different activities based on age: drawing time for those under nine, and discussion groups for pre-teens (ten to twelve) and teenagers (thirteen to eighteen). For the last hour of each session, everyone joins together to play board games and socialize.

This independence from a larger institution is part of what has allowed Tony’s classes to continue for so long; activities hosted by the New Haven Pride Center, for example, have been hampered since the nonprofit lost its 501(c)(3) status for a few months this year after failing to file tax returns.

Tony’s group, on the other hand, does not rely directly on institutional support; he offers the Saturday morning meetings pro bono, paying for the craft supplies out-of-pocket. Locations in and around New Haven allow him to use their spaces at no expense for him or the families who attend.

During the years when I was a member of Tony’s class, we bounced around between three locations. Since then, the group has settled down in one place. Tony keeps the meeting location private, he told me when we met in a Perhaps this casualness is part of cafe one February morning, to prowhy kids like me found so much com- tect the members of the group. “We fort in the group—it stands apart from have people who hate us.” well-intentioned but stiff LGBTQ+ info groups at medical centers and Gayhen I asked my mom Straight Alliances at high schools, spaces how we first learned about that make self-conscious attempts to Tony’s group, she described a tout institutional support but end up convoluted chain of contacts. stifling vulnerable discussion. But the Since my kindergarten days, fact that Tony’s group is separated from we had been part of a series larger support structures means that of informal groups focused the support it offers remains elusive on gender-nonconformto those not already within the sys- ing children: a mailing tem. No Google search will lead one to list for parents to share this group; it is a resource that travels resources (known by through the elaborate social network of its subscribers simply

March 2023

additional illustrations by charlotte rica

n carefully-labeled boxes in her study, my mother preserves my childhood drawings, schoolwork, and journals. Early attempts at academic writing sit inside the Hannah: 2015-2016 bin (“You may just think of Susan B. Anthony as the woman on the silver dollar coin, but she was much more than that”). Hannah: 2013 holds a hand-drawn comic book based on the Clue board game. The boxes before that, dating back to before my transition—all labeled with my birth name—include an evolving set of colorful self-portraits.

Each drawing was an attempt to communicate who I was to the world. Each was crafted in Tony Ferraiolo’s Saturday morning drawing group.

Every other weekend starting at age six, I would walk into the location of Tony’s drawing group in my school clothes. Solemnly, I’d change in the bathroom into whatever feminine outfit I had most recently bought from a secondhand store in Hamden. Sitting around a table covered with scraps of printer paper and loose magic markers, I’d make art with a group of other gendernonconforming kids from around the greater New Haven area. Tony would give us instructions: “How many of you have been sad about how you relate to your body? Draw it.”

As a kid, I just knew him as the bowler-hat wearing, tattoo-covered guy who ran my loosely-defined art class. But Tony wears many other hats: founder of the Jim Collins Foundation, which provides funding to trans people across America for gender-affirming surgeries; director of the youth and family program for Healthcare Advocate International, a Hartford-based educational and medical organization; guest speaker at countless corporations and groups across Connecticut—a self-described “professional trans person.”

When I began attending Tony’s classes, I never really wondered how or why the program started; I took it for granted that resources like these were available to me. But Tony founded the group in 2008, only a year before I joined. What he offers is a comprehensive but casual program that allows children to express themselves creatively, and, through a simultaneous parent

group, provide practical and emotional advice. Through this twofold structure, Tony helps families make sense of their role in their child’s gender journey.

The group evades bureaucratic categorization; it is not housed under any umbrella nonprofit, and there is no official name. He even avoids describing the group as his own: “I knew from the beginning that these are not ‘my’ groups, but the members’ groups,” Tony explained to me over email. “We don’t have an agenda or a certain subject that the members have to talk about.

The support groups are free flowing.”

Members can choose the creative activity that they do on a given day, and are free to direct the conversation in whichever direction they please.

29

Drawing it Out “My Self Portrait,” 2009, Hannah Szabó, age 6.

Made in Tony’s drawing group.

as ‘The Listserv’); a group in New York City that we attended a couple of times during my second grade year; an annual summer family gathering known as Camp I Am. One early liaison from these networks was Edgardo Menvielle, a Psychiatrist at the Children’s National Medical Center in Washington, D.C., who put us in touch with a local contact who in turn connected us with Tony.

Others seem to have found out about Tony’s group through similarly convoluted means. As I started working on this article, my mother forwarded me 30

March 2023 TheNewJournal

a few of the emails she had received over the last decade from parents of gender-nonconforming youth. Searching through the archives of her inbox, scrupulously sorted just like my childhood artwork, my mom had located dozens of email chains with parents from around Connecticut. Some had gotten her contact information from mutual friends; others knew to reach out to her because they had received an email sent to my whole elementary school when I transitioned; still others were referred to her by local clergy or physicians who

had worked with our family. The parents who reached out to her seemed unable to find these resources on their own; one 2016 email sent to my mom from a parent of a student at my elementary school read, “Do you know of any social support groups for preteens? I’ve reached out to a couple LGBT groups and haven’t heard back. We are trying to find anything near New Haven that would be welcoming.” A similar email came from a member of our synagogue; another was from a professor who had just moved to town. At the end of each

Drawing it Out

“Jonah,” 2008, Hannah Szabó, age 5. Made before I joined Tony’s drawing group, in kindergarten.

chain of correspondence, she would send the concerned parent Tony’s contact info.

“He is the connector who holds the community together,” she wrote in one email.

This elaborate network of referrals makes it difficult to trace the origins of Tony’s group—only Tony himself can explain how it began.

triangular point, arms covered in a sleeve campus. At Tony’s first class, only two of tattoos that featured, in black lettering kids showed up. “One of them, Angel, on his right arm, the phrase ‘CREATE did the same thing you always did,” YOURSELF.’ I, on the other hand, was Tony laughed, recalling my outfit swaps. ten inches taller and six years into hor- “She went to the bathroom and changed mone replacement therapy. He looked into what she wanted to wear. And up with a smile, exclaiming, “You’ve that’s when I knew that this could really gotten older!” be space to feel comfortable in your skin, When Tony started the group, he create, and be yourself.” hen I arrived five minutes early explained, it was easier to find. He Before 2011, when “gender idento scout out a table for my meeting announced the proposed meeting times tity or expression” was added to with Tony, I found him already there, sit- and distributed fliers at True Colors, the Connecticut’s list of legally protected ting by the window. He was the same as annual LGBTq+ youth conference hosted categories, there was no requirement I remembered him, beard combed into a on the University of Connecticut Storrs that schools respect the identities or TheNewJournal March 2023

31

Drawing it Out

needs of gender-nonconforming and daughter? Because there is a likelihood trans students. And it wasn’t until 2015 of you standing in front of that grave that Yale Health’s Gender Program, a saying, shit, I should have called you Chris centralized source for trans healthcare this whole time.” in New Haven, was established. Facing Tony has seen these stories, all-tooa lack of social and medical resources, common in the trans community, play many families with trans or gender out around him; he has witnessed firstnon-conforming children turned to hand the effects of children feeling alone.

Tony for his familiarity with these “A few years ago, I was visiting a psych issues, and ended up attending his sup- hospital to see a kid . . . When he saw me, port group. he smiled so big. To me, it felt like at Even nonprofits and medical ser- that moment in my life, I was responvices that were nominally offering sible for all these lives.” The burden support for queer youth began to refer of providing a child with the love and their patients to Tony, unsure of how to acceptance that their parents had withhelp them navigate other parts of the held left Tony physically incapacitated. bureaucracy. “Pretty soon organizations “My blood pressure went sky high. I had all around Connecticut were contact- to go to the emergency room.” Tony ing me,” Tony said. He would receive took a yearlong break from life coaching open-ended requests from overwhelmed after this incident. therapists and doctors, who knew him from his public speaking and nonprofit involvement: “We have a seven-year-old, we have a nine-year-old, we don’t know what to do,” Tony recalled them saying.

“Can you help?”

The group quickly grew from there.

Now, Tony finds publicizing the group unnecessary. He explained that people just know about him, as we had, through the natural social fabric of the LGBTQ+ community. “I always get emails that say stuff, like, ‘a friend of a friend knows a parent that goes to your group,’” described Tony. “Barely anyone knows my last name. People just say— oh, there’s this guy, you know Tony—oh yeah, I know Tony!” ony’s strength lies in his ability to simultaneously offer practical and emotional support. When families ask for advice about legal or medical services, he is already familiar with the specific laws and systems that govern Connecticut. When a child is unsure about how to express themselves in words, he sits with them and has them draw pictures. And when he needs to help a hesitant parent come around to accepting their child, he meets them where they are.

Tony described one recent interaction on the phone with the father of a child who had come out as trans: “He was dropping the F bomb, cursing his kid out. I said, well, is there any selfharm or any suicidal ideations going on with the kid? ‘Oh yeah. He tried to kill himself three times.’ So I said, let me ask you a quick question. Do you want to accept your son or mourn your 32

March 2023 TheNewJournal

Helping a child navigate their own gender identity thus requires a complex combination of buy-in and detachment from parents. “I don’t think people realize this enough with kids,” Tony posited, “but no one knows who they are better than they do. I tell parents all the time, allow your child to walk their journey. You just protect them. They know who they are.”

Tony described the types of language he frequently uses with hesitant parents. “I’m not trying to talk you into anything. The only thing I’m trying to do, because of the love you have for your child, is make sure you have a good relationship with them, support them.”

Beyond the myriad of concrete ways he contributes to Connecticut’s LGBTQ+

community, it is these relationships Tony crafts and facilitates that most powerfully transform the lives of those around him. “That’s what I’m here for,” he told me. “I’m here to talk it out.”

When I was around nine, I asked Tony to start having one-on-one meetings. I had started to become aware of an identity being forced upon me that felt deeply wrong. During music and gym time, we were now split into “boy” and “girl” groups; in Spanish class, my grammar started to be corrected when I resisted using the masculine ending -o to describe myself. Amidst these curricular shifts, I grappled with the fact that my body was soon going to change in ways I wasn’t sure I could deal with. But I lacked the words to describe exactly what it was I wanted to say.

Tony and I would meet every month or so, on weekday evenings in his Hamden apartment. The walls of his living room were decorated with his own art—abstract and tactile, loose brushwork and dripping colors. It was here in this private space, sketchpad in hand, that I first articulated through drawing that I was transgender. When I didn’t want to talk it out, Tony and I would draw it out. ∎ Hannah Szabó is a sophomore in Pauli Murray College.

On June 10th at 6:30, at North Branford High School, his alma mater, there will be a tenth-anniversary screening of the documentary A SelfMade Man, a film by Lori Petchers about Tony’s life and his work with transgender and nonbinary youth and their families The event will benefit Q+, a queer youth organization in Hartford, tv-365, a non-profit organization serving the transgender community, and North Branford High Schools Diversity Group.

Poem

Kissing One of Your Queer Awakenings 11/28/22 I had a dream about you last night.

In the dream, I was at a party that happened to be yours.

And in the dream, I wanted to avoid you but pick up something you had made before I left.

The night before you left, we sat in your old red pickup truck, or rather you sat on my lap in your old red pickup truck and you were strangely persistent about returning a small gift I had given you. Before kissing me.

The first time I wanted to say hello to you was in middle school when you were both what I wanted to be and who I wanted to be with. Maybe it was only one of those, maybe it was both.

I still don’t know. But I was happy to have you as something to think about.

High school came around and our first bad relationships had ended. And our mutual friend wingman’d us together until we became “definitely better than my first relationship” to each other.

Until we got sunburned from sitting in a muddy apple orchard. Until you were saying you’d show up to my high school on my birthday with a present and a lunch date. Until we drove back to our middle school where we walked, you close to me, in the pitch black you were afraid of, to look at racing meteors that we would never have been able to see. Until we got tired of sitting under our middle school tree. Until we walked back to your old red pickup truck where you sat on my lap and gave me back the thing that would’ve made you feel guilty to keep.

I don’t love you. I think I never did. And you knew that you never loved me, you just liked how I treated you. And that’s okay now. It has been for a long time.

We never said goodbye. You just said you were sorry to tell me like this over text. You returned my hoodie two days later. The one with my last name written on the back that you wore at school while we were together. We never said goodbye. You just watched the red pickuptruck hickey I left on your neck fade over the following days. And knowing that I’d left you with something that called for an explanation to my also fading friends at your school, That no one knew who you were at my school, was pettily satisfying to me.

We never said goodbye. We just pass each other in the street of our little town, pretending we never said hello to begin with Adrian Elizalde

TheNewJournal

33

Waiting for Care At the Yale Pediatric Gender Program, trans kids say they receive great care—but it’s not easy to get.

By Theia Chatelle and Iz Klemmer

34

TheNewJournal

LAYOUT DESIGN AND COVER ILLUSTRATION BY KEVIN CHEN INSIDE ILLUSTRATIONS BY CHARLOTTE RICA

March 2023

35

On the night of August 17th, 2022, Dr. Christy Olezeski received a Twitter notification. Then another, and another.

She was on vacation with her family, taking a break from New Haven and the pressures of her work as Director of the Yale Pediatric Gender Program (YPGP). She hadn’t even brought her work laptop with her—her goal was to unplug. But, as the Twitter notifications streamed in, she realized something was wrong. The world had found her.

Dr. Olezeski, affectionately known by her patients as just Dr. Christy, knew it was only a matter of time. Right-wing activists had launched threats targeting Boston Children’s Hospital earlier that same month, and the year’s legislative sessions had seen a slate of anti-trans bills passed in Texas, Alabama, and Idaho. Dr. Olezeski hadn’t been deterred— but when she saw that Libs of TikTok, a right-wing Twitter account with over a million followers, had reposted a video of her from the YPGP’s website, she knew the YPGP was in danger.

“I give it twenty-four hours before I get my first death threat,” she thought to herself.

The next morning, Dr. Olezeski woke up to four emails she described as “quite unpleasant.” Within two days, the story was picked up by international conservative media outlets including Fox News, the New York Post, and the Daily Mail. “Yale professor blasted for program working with 3-year-olds on their ‘gender journey,’” read Fox News’ headline. More emails streamed in, and phone calls and letDr. Christy Olezeski, Director and co-founder of the Yale Pediatric Gender Program (ypgp ). ters began arriving at the clinic. Some of Dr. Olezeski’s harassers even found her home address, sending letters directly to her house.

Dr. Olezeski was the face of the YPGP, and so far-right media Psychiatry at the Yale School of Medicine (YSM). After speakoutlets and influencers like Libs of TikTok descended on her ing with trans community leaders in New Haven about the as an emblem of “gender ideology,” a term used in transpho- needs of the trans kids they worked with, Dr. Olezeski emailed bic politics which presents the existence of trans people as a the Department of Endocrinology to ask who was providing threat to society. In total, she and the clinic received hundreds healthcare to trans youth. The response was concerning: Yale of threats. had no such program. Luckily, there were other interested As Dr. Olezeski sat in one of the clinic’s sterile conference doctors in the pediatric endocrinology department at YSM, rooms, recounting the harassment on a cloudy afternoon last including Dr. Patel.

February, she took a deep breath. Then she took another, and Prior to 2014, Dr. Patel had the occasional trans patient then another. And, finally, she began to cry. Dr. Anisha Patel, but lacked the infrastructure to do anything but refer them to one of the co-founders of the YPGP alongside Dr. Olezeski, hospitals in Boston and Hartford. One patient of hers lacked hugged her. “We’re huggers here at the clinic,” Dr. Patel the resources to make it to either city. “I don’t have anywhere affirmed. Dr. Patel sat back down, but Dr. Olezeski began to to go,” she remembers the patient telling her. “You’re my doctor, cry again, so Dr. Patel returned for another hug and continued and I want you to do this for me.” Dr. Patel looked him in the to sit by Christy’s side. The two took a moment to collect them- face and made a promise: “I will figure this out.” selves, and then Dr. Patel emphasized that, after the threats, With the addition of Dr. Susan Boulware and Dr. Stuart “the support came from the team. We were always pretty close, Weinzimer, both pediatric endocrinologists at Yale, the but now we’re like a little family.”

Pediatric Gender Program team officially numbered four. But The Yale Pediatric Gender Program started with an email. before they could open their doors, they had to research. The In 2014, Dr. Olezeski was working in the Department of team contacted academic pediatric gender centers across the 36

Waiting for Care

TheNewJournal

Photo courtesy of Christy Olezeski

BEGINNINGS

country, discussing policies and procedures. The four doctors year. “As someone who does a lot of singing, I started as a mezmet monthly for a year to assemble their team. They recruited zo-soprano and now I’m a bass baritone,” Rowan explained. endocrinologists, psychologists, psychiatrists, an OB­/­G YN, an “That’s super, super cool.” ethicist, and a lawyer. Every team member worked on a volRowan is fifteen years old, from South Windsor, CT. He unteer basis. loves Deftones, plays the guitar, and is excited about his “We knew it was going to take a long time to go through upcoming role as Pugsley in his school’s production of The the regular channels at Yale,” Dr. Olezeski said. But trans kids Addams Family. He’s also a patient at the YPGP. were in desperate need of care, and they had nowhere to go in When Rowan was thirteen, he told his parents he wanted New Haven. The team decided on a work-around: one half- to start testosterone. His voice dysphoria was so bad that he day a month, the three endocrinologists would take on gender struggled to talk and didn’t want to leave the house. He had patients instead of their general endocrine schedule. The clinic been questioning his gender since he was eleven, and he was officially started taking patients in October 2015. “There was finally sure that he wanted to pursue gender-affirming care. “I no ribbon cutting,” Dr. Christy laughed. “It was all word of felt very guilty that I was kind of breaking their expectations mouth in the beginning.” of me,” Rowan remembered. Despite his anxiety, his parents But word of mouth traveled fast: wait times had ballooned were accepting from the beginning, and they were eager to to eight months by 2017. Soon after, wait times were mea- meet his needs. They knew his quality of life was at risk. sured in years. The team petitioned Yale New Haven Hospital In late 2020, Rowan and his parents got to work finding (YNHH) for support, and, in 2018, they were able to begin a clinic. Rowan’s parents called the YPGP, and they were lucky: providing gender-affirming care for one full day per week. when they called, the waitlist for an appointment was only During the pandemic, they added clinics on the first and fifth three to five months. When the day of the appointment came, Thursdays each month, growing Rowan and his parents loaded up to their current total of nine to the car and drove for an hour to eleven clinics per month. As of get to New Haven. He remem2023, they provide services in bered being a little nervous but New Haven, Trumbull, and Old “very excited to see where it was Saybrook. To date, the YPGP has gonna lead me.”

For many trans kids provided care to 425 people. But The YPGP was an instantly in New Haven and as more states across the country comforting space for Rowan. “It have adopted hostile attitudes felt like they’re kind of a famacross Connecticut, toward trans teens, demand for ily,” he said. Even though it access to care the clinic’s services have grown, was a doctor’s appointment, it remains locked with patients streaming in from felt like a casual conversation places as far away as Florida. where he could express his needs. behind a waitlist 2020 was a difficult year for After Rowan explained what he and a multitude of LGBTQ+ youth. 2021 was worse, needed out of the clinic, they structural barriers. and 2022 was no better. As of explained the options they had March 10th, 2023, bills have available for him. Rowan left his been introduced in 22 different intake appointment with a prestate legislatures to criminalscription and a new outlook on ize gender-affirming healthcare. life. “My confidence skyrocketed.”

Recently, both Tennessee and Now, one year later, Rowan Mississippi passed bans on gender-affirming healthcare returns to the clinic every few months for follow-up appointfor minors, and several other states, including Texas, appear ments. First he meets with Dr. Boulware, then Dr. Olezeski poised to be next. While Connecticut has reaffirmed its com- and Dr. Patel. Rowan also meets with clinical psychology mitment to the legality of gender-affirming healthcare, Dr. Ph.D. student Wisteria Deng to have a one-on-one conversaOlezeski still worries. “While yes, Connecticut is lucky to be tion about his mental health and wellness. in a place where there aren’t attacks actively happening, but it In 2022, Rowan found out about a unique opportunity seems like the climate is still dangerous,” Dr. Olezeski said. from the clinic’s mailing list: a circus workshop for trans kids.

But the harassment Dr. Olezeski and the YPGP faced last Rowan participated for a few months that summer. “It was a summer has only strengthened their commitment to the trans really fun experience,” he said. The workshop was a space to community. “We’re not stopping and we’re just going to con- learn skills ranging from juggling to walking balance beams, tinue to grow,” Dr. Olezeski emphasized. “It’s made our team and doctors participated right alongside the kids. Even Dr. stronger, I think. And so we’re not backing down.”

Olezeski picked up a new favorite party trick: she can now balance a peacock feather on her hand.

At the Yale Pediatric Gender Clinic, Rowan has found more than just medical care: he’s found community. The YPGP changed Rowan’s life, and he knows it. “I’m very grateful that ROWAN I have this privilege,” he acknowledged. Rowan’s case, howOn the eleventh of every month, Rowan gets a calendar ever, is frustratingly rare. For many trans kids in New Haven notification: “record voice update video.” With his catalog of and across Connecticut, access to care remains locked behind monthly videos, he can look back and trace the changes in his a waitlist and a multitude of structural barriers. voice, an effect of the testosterone he’s been taking for the last March 2023

Waiting for Care

37

Illustrations of Rowan (left) and Jude (right).

JUDE Jude Arnott was referred to the YPGP in 2019 after he was hospitalized at the Yale New Haven Psychiatric Hospital.

Jude, fifteen years old at the time, struggled with overwhelming emotions and didn’t know how to cope. He struggled with outbursts, aggression, and suicidal ideation. He would later realize that many of his struggles were the result of gender dysphoria, which he had struggled with for years. When he found himself back at YNHH in 2019, the doctors on-call recommended he make an appointment with Dr. Olezeski at the YPGP. So he tried. And tried. And tried.

When Jude told his parents in 2015 that he wanted to start to socially transition, his parents didn’t bat an eye. “I am one of the luckiest people,” said Jude. “My parents have health insurance, they were supportive, and I was in a place where I could 38

get gender-affirming healthcare.” But as Dr. Olezeski stressed, for every person like Jude, there is at least one teen who wants to transition, but doesn’t have parental support or the financial resources to do so. “I worry about those kids,” said Dr. Olezeski.

Jude was placed on the YPGP waiting list. The YPGP told him and Kathleen, his mother, that it would be at least three years until he could be seen for an intake appointment. But Jude was in need of immediate attention: he was in and out of the hospital, and his relationship with his brother and parents was under strain, punctuated by fights despite their support.

He required treatment immediately, but the YPGP simply didn’t have the capacity. Jude and his parents had to look around for the next best option.

While Jude’s decision to leave the YPGP’s waiting list was quick, the process of finding other care was difficult. At first, Jude saw a gender therapist in the New Haven area. After six

Waiting for Care

TheNewJournal

months, he received a letter of written support from his thera- to be one or the other, “I choose girl,” she said. For Jessica, “the pist attesting to his need for treatment—these letters are a nec- pressures are still there to call certain behaviors girl behaviors essary first step toward beginning gender-affirming treatment and others boy behaviors.” Even though, as Jessica was quick to at many clinics. He also obtained a referral to the Connecticut point out, East Rock and New Haven are welcoming places to Children’s Medical Center’s Gender Identity Program (CCMC). be trans, there are still biases and uncomfortable situations that Letter in hand, he and his family called CCMC to schedule an Alex has encountered. For example, at school, there were only appointment. The process was quick: after his first visit at CCMC, boys or girls uniforms for her to pick from. This is something Jude was prescribed puberty-blocking medication. A doctor that Jessica admits Alex will have to live with, but “so far, she’s placed an implant in his arm, and shortly thereafter he began doing a great job.” hormone replacement therapy.

In late 2021, at the urging of their pediatrician, Alex’s parJude also attempted to get “top surgery,” a masculinizing ents decided to schedule an intake appointment with the YPGP. bilateral mastectomy, from a surgeon at YNHH. According to They were informed that the wait time was thirteen months.

Kathleen, the surgeon’s staff refused to update Jude’s legal name But Alex had time. She hadn’t started puberty, and while the in their system, which she says led to them deadnaming Jude— wait was long, it was something they were willing to put up referring to him by the name on his birth certificate that he with. The quality of care at the YPGP made the wait worth it, no longer identifies with—over twenty times. Kathleen strug- Jessica had heard. So as long as Alex was fine with the wait, gled with Anthem, her insurance provider, whose coverage of there was nothing to lose—until they received another call gender-affirming surgeries does not typically extend to minors. from the YPGP. Alex’s appointment had been canceled, and And then, after a year and a half of waiting, she received a call: they would have to reschedule for another thirteen months the surgeon had retired, and the surgery was canceled. The sur- later. That was enough for Jessica. “There’s this feeling that geon’s office didn’t return a request for comment. At the age of 15, maybe they’re providing great services, but if my kid can’t get and long after the ordeal at Yale, Jude was finally able to receive them, that makes me mad.” top surgery at CCMC. “It was tough for To meet the demand of their curhim, but if there’s one thing about Jude, rent waitlist, the YPGP needs to add if he wants to do something, he’s going more clinic time and hire more docto do it,” said Kathleen. tors. With appointments that average Families’ relationships with the ninety minutes, they need more time YPGP differ, and wait times can vary than most endocrinology providers. “...maybe they’re widely from year to year. While However, the YSM administration has Rowan was lucky enough to avoid been pushing back on their requests for providing great the YPGP’s growing waitlist, Jude was more resources. “When there’s limited services, but never able to schedule an appointspace, they’re gonna say, ‘No, we don’t if my kid can’t ment despite an inpatient psychiatric want you to open another gender clinic, referral. Oftentimes, a family’s experiwe want you to open up a general get them, that ence with the YPGP is driven by facendocrine clinic, because short kids makes me mad.” tors outside their control. Insurance need to be seen too,’” Dr. Boulware policies, distance between the clinic said, referring to cisgender kids who and a family’s home, and the support need support for atypical puberty. But (or lack of support) parents show for there are dozens of endocrinologists their child all influence a family’s abiltreating cisgender kids in the New ity to find treatment. But for trans Haven area, while the YPGP is the only teens, time is ticking. With every passing minute, they’re going program serving trans kids. through puberty—the wrong puberty—and undergoing the As a stopgap measure to help those on the waitlist, the unwanted, irreversible physical changes this puberty brings on. YPGP provides events and community to any trans kid in the area. Dr. Olezeski first started a parent support group and then expanded to a youth group. She offers the events to anyone on her mailing list as a way to provide outlets for trans kids to connect with other trans kids.“We’ll try to get them ALEX involved in these other things to sort of have that community Alex, an eleven-year-old in New Haven, could be and support,” she said. described as a free spirit. She refuses to conform to society’s But supplemental programming can only go so far when expectations of what a boy or girl should be. She likes to patients are waiting two years to be seen. “We’re just asking experiment: with her uniform at Elm City Montessori, her for more money. Continuously more money,” Dr. Olezeski name, her pronouns. She’s obsessed with Disney’s Frozen: explained. “More money to hire more people.” Without instiaccording to her mother, Jessica, the movie was a forma- tutional support, trans kids like Alex will continue to stare tive part of Alex’s gender journey. Jessica and her wife didn’t down extensive wait times at the expense of their physical and think much of it at the time. “We were like, Alex is a kid who mental wellbeing. ∎ loves long hair, loves princesses, and loves powers. That kind of thing.”

As Alex grew, she felt limited by her peers’ expectations of Theia Chatelle is a sophomore in Hopper College. Iz Klemmer her. She didn’t want to be a boy. She didn’t want to be a girl. is a sophomore in Saybrook College.

But after talking with her parents, she decided that, if she had March 2023

Waiting for Care

39

We will live in a corner house.

And when it pours in the springtime, the cherry blossoms will float down, blanketing the block in pink icing. They will create a new earth; water will clear away the old. I will sit in our bay window while you do the crossword in the kitchen. I will count the yellow taxis that roll by and the poor souls shrouded by large black umbrellas who fall victim to the not so shallow puddle at the base of our porch. This yellowed kitchen is a concert hall and we are the music, crowd, and singer. When I miss you, I just put on that Nina Simone record, the one you said was playing the night we met. I don’t remember, but you do—you always do. You follow behind while I scour the garage sale at the white picket fence house two streets over. My hands run over frayed garments, well-loved by someone else. I will lay in my favorite spot on the grass you’ve just mowed. You will admire the rays in between sneezes and red-rimmed eyes.

Our beloved, ancient couch will be the first thing we move in. It will find its place in the center of a room covered in dark hardwoods. My fingers will trace the outline of carefully embroidered flowers as I’ve done a hundred times before. Too exhausted to lift anything else, we will collapse into its well known, sun-faded grooves.

At the end of our days, when the sun has fallen, we settle into the weathered, flowered couch. Your grandmother gave it to us. It was her mother’s.

The cushions wear their age as she did. They cradle our bodies just right, morphed to our conjoined form over countless Sundays of use. I will lean into you and brush the hair from your shoulder.

I will kiss your cheek and you will turn to meet me halfway. You taste like you always have: warm.

Some nights we dance—off the couch, on our feet, around the peeling hardwoods. Nina’s voice rings

40

illustration by etai smotrich-barr

through the speakers. You throw your head back to match her croon. I laugh in between steps— not because it’s funny, but because I love you.

Large oak trees will line our street. They’d be ominous if they weren’t so saintly. Quiet but never barren, home to laughter and lost kitten signs.

Streets that swell with multi-colored leaves come autumn. You will point, placing bets on when they will fall. Just when we think they can’t hold anymore, we wake to find the asphalt submerged under a rust-colored sea. One that crunches under the running feet of eager vampires pushing their fangs back into place. The bloodsuckers are followed in single file by ghosts wearing tennis shoes and fire fighters with pigtails. You and I will wait for them to reach our front porch; the light is on. We pass out king-sized candy bars; our house will have quite the reputation. I make my best costume guess as the little ones arrive on our doorstep and reward them with sweets regardless of my blunders. When we’ve run out of currency, our jack-o’-lanterns still burn bright, so we sit on the rickety steps. When the winds reach our bones, we retreat to the television—back to that flowered couch. We sink into its cushions and I can feel all the other hallowed nights we’ve had together as if they’re happening all over again. We hear wolves howling over the screams of teenagers who need to be treated like adults. You slip out of costume still covered in makeup, half you, half make-believe.

Anaiis Rios-Kasoga

layout by kevin chen

41

TheNewJournal

Coming Out, Coming Home Queer Christians in New Haven and at Yale are finding ways to enrich their spiritual lives through their LGBTQ+ identities.

42

43

March 2023

By Abbey Kim Layout design by Kevin Chen

Coming Out, Coming Home

F

“Four days a week I was going to church,” Holly Nichols “It’s traumatizing to be told that you’re rejected by God,” told me in the nave of the United Church on the Green. “They Nichols said. “It was really hard to feel like it was safe to go back waited a year and a half to tell me I was going to Hell.” to church.”

Nichols has been religious since the age of six or seven, After a few months, Nichols began seeking a new worship when she first attended Lutheran services in Hamden with a community, but found it difficult to locate an affirming church. childhood friend. She described to me how being in church Her search, mainly directed by Google hits, led her to one dead continues to give her a peace she cannot find anywhere else. end after another, including uninspiring Zoom-only services Despite her love of God, she has struggled to find a church that and an empty parking lot where a church had once been. accepts and affirms her as a lesbian.

She started attending the United Church on the Green a About six months before we spoke, Nichols had been little over a month before we met. One of her Google searches attending a non-denominational church in North Haven. She’d for an “open and affirming” congregation had finally worked. been there for around a year—involved with Bible study, prayer “Open and affirming” is a designation created by the United group, and services—when she brought her wife to a Sunday Church of Christ (UCC)—the national Christian denominaservice. Shortly after, she told me, one of the five church alders tion to which the United Church on the Green belongs—to told her that being married to a woman was a sin and that she assert the full inclusion of LGBTQ+ congregants in church life. had to repent. Nichols brushed it off as just one person’s opinion The label means not only welcoming queer congregants into the rather than that of the church. But she did not bring her wife church, but also affirming that their lives are not in conflict with back again. the Bible’s teachings.

The next intervention came when Nichols attended In practice, “open and affirming” churches fall along a specmembership class, hoping to become an official member in trum; some churches incorporate it as a tenet of their comthe church after more than a year of devoted attendance and munity philosophy, while others—according to some queer financial support. But before she entered the church, a mem- churchgoers—appropriate the phrase as a means of drawing in ber at the door warned her that she couldn’t become a member new members. UCC is a congregational church, which means it’s if she was gay. much less centralized than other Christian denominations like “I think I was in denial that they were going to take it as far Episcopalian, Presbyterian, and Catholic churches. Because of as they did,” Nichols said. “I thought they were just trying to this decentralization, each local UCC congregation can determake a point, but I didn’t think it would stand in the way of my mine its own policies and practices, including whether to adhere becoming a member or eventually my being able to attend.” to suggested national guidelines. This includes approaches to In September 2022, a year and a half into Nichols’ time with queer affirmation. State by state, county by county, each congrethe church, the congregation staged a third, full-on interven- gation exercises their own discretion around inclusion. tion for her. Four alders—those with long-term experience and Standing by the light-filled pews at the back of the church, standing in the church—and two long-standing members sur- Nichols smiled as she told me about bringing her wife to United. rounded her in a room.

She hopes to reintegrate church into their lives together.

“They went around in a circle and told me why my marriage “It’s a fresh start without that negative nagging, enemy was wrong, why I was going to Hell,” Nichols said, growing qui- voice telling me this is what makes me not good enough or this eter. “And that did test me.” is what separates me from God that they were feeding me at After that final intervention, Nichols decided to leave that the other church,” she said, as she relaxed her fidgeting hands. church. She first took some time away from formal religious “Here I don’t have that. I have peace.” spaces, instead investing in her personal prayer life, journaling, Nichols’ experience with homophobia in the Church is making gratitude lists—even skydiving. not unique. Christian spaces and teachings have notoriously

44

45

TheNewJournal March 2023

Perhaps the most overt condemnation appears in Leviticus 18:22: “You shall not lie with a male as with a woman; it is an abomination.” created violent and traumatic experiences for members of the LGBTQ+ community—in Connecticut and beyond. But Nichols is also not alone in her persistent desire, as a queer person, to find a Christian community despite these hostile encounters. For the LGBTQ+ members of New Haven and Yale’s religious community with whom I spoke, creating queer spaces and forging new meaning in the church means adapting old traditions and reexamining conventional readings of the Bible. Many say their queerness and spirituality enrich each other.

blamed the misinterpretation of Christian teachings for the harm they faced, rather than the tenets of Christianity. Queer churchgoers generally hold the fundamental belief that God is good, loving, and just—even when church doctrines don’t reflect that.

“The greatest harm we have ever done in religion is to not say love yourself first, and you are lovable, and loved,” Rev. Aaron Miller, a transgender man and a pastor at the Metropolitan Community Church (MCC) in Hartford, tells me.

“That’s the thing I say over and over again because if you’ve heard it a million times, I want you to hear it a million from me.

Because you’ve been lied to.”

Miller was confirmed as a Lutheran and attended Catholic To exist as a queer person in a Christian space is to stand up Church for nearly a decade with a former partner. He left the against generations of canonized, homophobic dogma. Despite Catholic Church for a number of years before eventually returnnewer, affirming interpretations, many church leaders still wea- ing to religion and attending Yale Divinity School, graduating in ponize the Bible to condemn homosexuality. They often ground 2008 and working in pastoral care at Yale New Haven Hospital. these attacks in what have become known as the “clobber passages,” Then he started attending and later working at MCC, a denomithose most cited to condemn LGBTQ+ people as heretical. Perhaps nation founded in 1968 by a gay ex-Pentecostal minister explicthe most overt condemnation appears in Leviticus 18:22: “You itly for queer people to worship together. shall not lie with a male as with a woman; it is an abomination.”

At the beginning of our conversation, I told Miller—just as Congregants I spoke with had varying reactions to these I told everyone I spoke to—that I am a lesbian who was raised texts. Some cited other archaic rules in Leviticus—like prohi- Episcopalian, having grown up seeing sexuality and religion in bition of eating shellfish or mixing fabrics in one’s clothes, and fundamental tension with each other. Like the others, he was a decree ordering menstruating women to leave city limits—as quick to try to persuade me otherwise. proof that some homophobic Christians selectively punish queer “You have to really do gymnastics to ignore us in the Bible— people over those who commit other listed abominations. the queer folks in the Bible,” he told me, referencing specific Others see the process of interpretation as one that changes passages in the scripture that lend themselves to queer-affirmover time. There are a growing number of theologians who are ing interpretations, including what he interprets as same-sex reading the Bible—particularly these “clobber passages”—with romantic relationships and trans representation. a new lens that recasts them as condemnation of other sexual He told me about Jonathan and David, and Ruth and wrongs, like rape or incest, rather than being overtly homophobic. Naomi. He described them as the only romantic couples in the “I’m not going to look at it as this perfect document that has Bible, both of whom are same-sex. Ruth’s vow to Naomi, he been delivered to us today, as it exactly was when it was written,” said, is even commonly used at straight weddings. He went on Cal Swanson ’25, a co-chair of the Episcopal Church at Yale (ECY) to explain readings of transgender identity in the text, telling who is also queer, told me. “I’m going to look at it as an artifact the story of Genesis 1:27—“So God created humankind in his that has been through centuries of interpretations and changes.” image, in the image of God he created them; male and female In the face of the Bible’s weaponization, many of the queer he created them”—as connoting not separate beings but the people I spoke with explained how the text could be reclaimed fact that we contain the potential for both genders within us, as a powerful tool of love and affirmation. Most told me they embodying spectral identities.

Reclaiming the Bible

46

Coming Out, Coming Home

“It was the gay community wanting to worship with itself,” Theriault explained.

“It’s so strange to me that this is the same text that’s used against gay people,” said Rev. Ali Donohue, chaplain at the ECY and a lesbian. “It’s so clear to me how much of this message is helpful, and familiar, and home.”

Theriault and Lett’s requests to meet in their space, often for free.

“It was the gay community wanting to worship with itself,” Theriault explained. “Just the fact that there were three congregations that were willing to house us, and saw that as important as part of their mission—there was some acceptance there.”

The church advertised through word of mouth, as well as what Theriault called a “bar ministry,” in which members recruited patrons of local gay bars like Partners Cafe and passed As older churchgoers were quick to remind me, to out leaflets advertising the church. Later, the church accrued come out as queer even as little as fifty years ago could result more formal local coverage, including a 1979 profile of Theriault in anything from forced exile to social isolation in any given in the New Haven Register entitled “New Haven Church Offers church, depending on its denomination.

Sanctuary for Homosexuals.”

In 1975, Ken Theriault, then a 21-year-old junior at Yale “I would say most of us came with some negative experience, College, came out as gay. Theriault had been raised American and that’s why we’re looking for something else,” Theriault told Baptist, “singing in church choir since they had a robe small me, forty-four years later. “People still have their spirituality and enough for me.” He began studying at the Yale Divinity School, want to express it somehow.” hoping to be ordained in the American Baptist Church even Participation at MCC New Haven eventually dwindled. as it became clearer that he would not be able to serve in their Co-founder Lett left in 1979, and the church struggled to hold ministry because of his sexuality. down a permanent location or pastor. As more of New Haven’s Alongside Beverly Lett, a fellow student at the Yale Divinity churches became accepting of queer worshippers in the early School, Theriault founded a new branch of MCC in New Haven in 2000s, the need for a specifically queer church diminished, and 1977. The expansion filled a void, Theriault said, creating a space of social schisms proliferated within the MCC. Today, there are no formal LGBTQ+ religious acceptance in New Haven at a time where gatherings of MCC in New Haven—parishioners can join the no churches allowed or affirmed queer worshippers and leaders.

MCC Oasis Zoom group or travel forty-five minutes to Hartford.

At its first meeting, MCC New Haven met in the small MCC still exists—across the United States and twenty other upstairs parlor of a local Methodist church. There were about countries—but it faces struggles unique to being a queer church fifteen attendees, most of whom had heard about the church amid a broader landscape of declining church membership and through word of mouth or the MCC Hartford newsletter, aging parishioners. A lack of an endowment or the security of Metroline. MCC New Haven also joined with the New Haven a historically owned space makes stability nearly impossible, chapters of Integrity and Dignity—an Episcopalian and a explained Sharron Emmons, a member of the Board of the Catholic gay religious group, respectively—for monthly pot- Directors at MCC Hartford and a lesbian. She added that the lucks at members’ homes. historical lack of queer families—and thus the opportunity to From 1977 to 2015, MCC New Haven moved across several raise children in queer churches—hurts growth. churches and hosted anywhere between twenty and one hun“Early on, if you wanted to go to church, [MCC] was the dred congregants a week. church you went to, unless you wanted to be closeted. But as “It was a real church. Just the population was a little different,” different congregations opened up, now you didn’t really need Theriault told me. “A place to gather and sing and hear sermons, I an MCC,” said Cathy Vitelli, a lesbian and former member mean it was a regular church service. We weren’t playing church.” of MCC New Haven who moved to an Episcopalian church.

Theriault found that even though local churches weren’t “You’re more comfortable there. [But] you could find a commuopenly affirming of queer people yet, they accommodated nity someplace else.”

Creating Space

47

TheNewJournal March 2023

Courtesy of Ken Theriault

Rev. Aaron Miller is a transgender man and a pastor at mcc in Hartford.

Photo courtesy of Aaron Miller

Photo courtesy of Ken Theriault

Ken Theriault, second to left, receives his license to preach in 1978.

48

Coming Out, Coming Home

The first time he attended a service at United, he remembers, he was so overcome by emotion that he cried through the whole sermon.

Finding God, Again While most of the queer churchgoers I spoke with cited affirming interpretations of the Bible as helping them reconcile their faith and queerness, they stressed the greater importance of church as a site of that interpretation and burgeoning community, one that could transcend the text itself. The physical space and communal tenets of a church could provide shelter, refuge, and community in a way that the Bible alone couldn’t.

“I don’t know if it’s because we’ve been deprived of religion for so long, but there’s more of a yearning for it in the [LGBTQ+] community,” Alfred Forino, Moderator at United Church on the Green, tells me as we talk over coffee.

A skinny wooden cane, with a handle carved into an ornate crocodile head, leans against his chair—this is his lucky charm.

At sixty-five years old, Forino has been a member of United for twenty-three years. The first time he attended a service at United, he remembers, he was so overcome by emotion that he cried through the whole sermon.

Forino is gay. Like many queer people, he has navigated a complicated relationship with church.

“Growing up as a Catholic, I was very lucky that I had a good enough sense of my own self because what I heard from the pulpit was just homophobia,” Forino said. “There was a brief time where I prayed to change, [but] I realized very quickly that wasn’t going to happen. But I also had enough self worth to know that God made me this way.”

Forino ended up marrying his husband, Eric, at the United Church on the Green in 2005, three years before it was officially legal in Connecticut and ten before it was federal law. He was quick to point out to me the significance of having a church recognize the validity of their partnership before the government did.

Rather than leaving church altogether when they faced homophobia or belittlement, the queer Christian and religious people I talked to were determined to keep pushing for a church that would accept them—whether that meant encouraging their church to be more affirming or searching for a new one altogether.

“The church is a community where people can gather together and worship God and seek to be faithful to God. But

it’s also flawed and very human,” Rev. Jocelyn Cadwallader, a lesbian pastor at First Presbyterian Church of New Haven, told me. “I’ve always been very clear of separating those two things: that the church is not a God.” Cadwaller learned this distinction firsthand. She was raised Presbyterian and had been involved with her local church from a young age. Despite the fact that the national Presbyterian Church at the time did not allow openly queer people to be clergy, Cadwallader still felt compelled by God to serve in the ministry as a priest, and attended seminary school in 2004. She emphasized a commitment to staying within the Presbyterian denomination, despite its nationally hostile regulations, because her local church community had helped raise her and always supported her.

“I never felt interested in moving somewhere different for the sake of my own sexuality,” Cadwallader said. Instead, she hopes the denomination will grow into what she feels God calls the church to be—affirming of all its congregants.

Many queer congregants I spoke with emphasized Cadwallader’s idea of church as a pillar of community and an extension of their social, cultural, and familial history. This belief can be especially strong with queer Catholics.

“I see the Catholic Church as not just something you hop in and out of as you sort of church shop. I see it as a community to which I belong,” said Stephen McNulty, ’25, a gay Catholic at Yale and an active member of the LGBTQ+ Ministry at St. Thomas More (STM), Yale’s Catholic chapel.

McNulty echoed an idea shared by others: abandoning the churches he’d grown up in because he was queer could feel even more wrong than staying in a non-affirming denomination.

Jacquelyn Oesterblad YLS ’22, a Catholic and lesbian who helped found the St. Thomas More LGBTQ+ Ministry, believes that she is showing respect for the Church by thinking it has room for her. “There is definitely still defiance of like, I’m not going to let them have the Church,” she said, referring to homophobic Catholics. “They’re going to have to deal with my baptized ass as well.”

Oesterblad stressed the importance of queer representation even in non-affirming spaces, which she noted will inevitably host new generations of queer children looking for role models.

49

TheNewJournal March 2023

Photo courtesy of Alfred Forino

Al Forino, right, and his husband, Eric, following their marriage vows at the United Church on the Green.

Photo courtesy of Jacquelyn Osterblad.

Rev. Ali Donohue, chaplain of ecy, with her wife Rev. Kerith Harding and their two kids.

Photo courtesy of Jocelyn Cadwallader

Rev. Jocelyn Cadwallader is a pastor at the First Presbyterian Church of New Haven.

50

Coming Out, Coming Home

“There is definitely still defiance of like, I’m not going to let them have the Church,” she said, referring to homophobic Catholics.

“They’re going to have to deal with my baptized ass as well.”

“As long as queer kids are being raised in this church—and they will be—I think it’s better for them to see people like me in the pews than to not,” Oesterblad told me. She emphasized she does not try to recruit queer people into the Church. Instead, she works with others just like her: baptized Catholics trying to navigate hostile yet familiar spaces.

While McNulty and Oesterblad are not alone in their identities, many of the queer people with whom I spoke who were raised Catholic ultimately left the denomination for a variety of reasons. Some, like ECY’s Rev. Donohue, realized that, despite their love of the faith, it would not make room for their marriage or official ordination. Others, like Forino, were unwilling to endure homophobia and partial membership due to their sexualities.

In New Haven’s affirming churches, some queer churchgoers disregard the religious element of church altogether, staying for the welcoming community and its benefits for fostering queer connections and social justice.

“From a Christianity and believing-in-God point of view, there’s none of that there for me, it’s not what works for me,” says Emmons, who has spent decades at both MCC New Haven and MCC Hartford despite being an atheist.

“But I’ve seen the church save lives. People come to our church, broken—older people, especially because it was tougher in the past—where they were kicked out of their families, kicked out of their churches,” Emmons adds. “Our message is ‘come out, come home, and come back.’ Here’s a place where you can re-find your God.” And many queer people are intent on doing just that. I was shocked by the number of queer religious people I stumbled upon—young and old—in churches at Yale and New Haven.

At the United Church on the Green alone, I chatted with three queer churchgoers out of a crowd of around twenty people.

One of them was Darnel Ray, a middle-aged gay man who sat in the pew in front of me and hummed “mmhmm” in agreement throughout the service. Having been raised American Baptist, Ray continued to crave Christianity even after his coming out was a source of conflict between him and his parents.

Years later, in 2019, he saw the pride flag outside of United and decided to try it out. He’s since moved to West Haven but still

commutes about twenty-five minutes for services. He’s uunsure if the church closer to where he lives is accepting, and he’s nervous to find out.

From the Altar As more openly queer individuals join religious communities, queer leaders face a dilemma: do they spearhead progress towards greater acceptance or seek out already affirming spaces?

Some, like Donohue and Cadwallader, opt for churches that have made strides towards inclusion. Others, like Oesterblad and McNulty, find that the nature of non-affirming spaces thrusts them into leadership roles since their mere presence challenges the status quo. This tension between leading change and seeking acceptance animates church communities at New Haven and Yale.

Donohue noted that she and her wife, who is also an Episcopalian reverend, choose local churches that are already affirming. But this choice only came after Donohue left the Catholic Church, in which she’d been raised and educated for decades of her life.

“I experience [queerness and religion] as a source of strength, I observe it as a source of pain,” Donohue explained, noting the queer students she’s worked with at Yale are often the ones struggling the most. “My only hope is that I’m able to have people join me where I’m standing, because I see zero conflict.”

At Yale, there are only four explicitly affirming Christian groups out of twenty ministries, explains Rev. Jenny Peek, an Associate University Chaplain and lesbian. “Explicitly affirming” here means believing in the full inclusion and affirmation of LGBTQ+ people (including celebrating queer marriages and ordination) and advertising themselves as such. These groups are the Episcopal Church at Yale (ECY), the University Church at Yale (UCY), LuMin at Yale, and Yale Progressive Christians Students.

Peek added that the landscape can sometimes be difficult for incoming queer students to navigate.

St. Thomas More walks a thin line when dealing with queer students as a Catholic university chapel. The church can—and does—welcome queer students, but it cannot formally affirm

51

TheNewJournal March 2023

Photo courtesy of Jocelyn Cadwallader

Rev. Jocelyn Cadwallader holds her daughter while in the pulpit, and her son is crawling up in the foreground.

Photo courtesy of Aaron Miller

mcc Hartford aims to protect and support the local queer community.

52

Coming Out, Coming Home

Photo courtesy of Aaron Miller

The chapel at mcc Hartford.

them in their ability to live out their queerness, particularly in sex- he says he incurs “by virtue of existing”: being a gay Catholic. ual relationships. This would be a violation of Catholic teachings.

Ultimately, queer religious leaders across New Haven can Oesterblad recalls being thrust into a leadership role for the usher in a more accepting space, buttressed by the virtue of repLGBTQ+ Ministry at STM—a ministry affinity group founded resentation. Cadwallader says her queerness is a strength when during the pandemic—as one of the few openly queer people she preaches to all her congregants—even those who aren’t queer. in the church. Laughing, she remembers wishing she could join “I get to remind them again about who Jesus is in their lives an already existing space: “Can I just plug into something that and why Jesus is important,” Cadwallader said. “And they tend already exists and be ministered too, please?” Oesterblad ended to listen to me because I am the voice of the one that was told for up helping to create, design, and lead the ministry. so long that I shouldn’t be there.”

In the midst of this landscape, queer chaplains at Yale can offer a beacon of representation and affirmation. “Knowing that she’s queer and she has this amazing understanding of the Bible being about love and being about affirming your LGBTQ identities is so helpful for me,” Swanson said of Donohue, who “Do you have a church home?” Nichols asked me when leads his church. “I feel like I absorb some of my certainty we first met in the nave of United. She echoed the common about it from her. And so I think it’s been a big thing having a language of many that I spoke with—a church where I could belong, be affirmed, and return to, no matter where I was in life. queer chaplain.”

I told her how I had grown up in the Episcopalian Church, Outside of Yale’s walls, queer reverends often engage in the same kind of affirmative work, though for a much broader audi- but now I was more of a Christmas and Easter Christian. I worence—not just young adults. But the pastors I spoke with noted ried I’d stopped believing too soon, and I didn’t know if there that the churches that call these queer leaders are often already was a future path for me.

After we finish talking, I thank her for opening up about her accepting and progressive.

Rev. Cadwallader of the First Presbyterian Church story. She looks at me, holding eye contact as I close my noterecounted a time that a congregation offered her a job with the book. I have a strange feeling, like I’m about to cry.

“I hope this project opens your eyes to whatever it is you disclosure that about half of the congregation was not ready for a queer pastor. The hiring committee hoped she could change need to see,” Nichols says. “I hope you find whatever it is you’re their minds. She ultimately turned them down: “I’m not in the searching for.”

I think I’m starting to see. Perhaps more than queer peobusiness of splitting churches . . . That journey needs to be done ple seeking and finding religion, I’ve found them reclaiming it— by somebody else.”

But not every queer member of non-affirming spaces feel coming home. ∎ that they have a choice.

“I’ve often been the one who starts conversations,” McNulty Abbey Kim is a sophomore in Branford College and an said of his work at the STM’s LGBTQ+ Ministry. “And I’m okay Associate Editor of The New Journal. with that.” He starts these conversations with a contradiction

Coming Home

53

TheNewJournal March 2023

for Abel Genesis 4:10 Forgive me, my brother; or do not. I’m sorry for envying your hands, the way they never failed to be gentle when they ran through the wolf ’s fur, and the wolf fell to slumber; when they wrung the lamb’s neck who felt no need to bleat in pain for her mother, having understood the wringing. Do you Remember, in the garden, when we pressed our palms together?

Mine were calloused and caked in dirt, and the smoothness I felt in yours made me weep. In your arms I sank, the dirt stuck, my eyes bloodshot. When we returned home, our father asked what had happened, and I never explained it, and you never could.

Forgive me, my brother, for knowing you will.

I am walking toward nowhere, eating fruit from a gnarled branch, and if I ever may return, I will tell our Father to look for the bed of daisies rustling even in the iciest wind, and there you will rest forever, my brother, bloodless as you came J.D. Wright

illustration by charlotte rica

Berlin Poem for Owen i.

I laugh when I realize you’re also noticing lines perpendicular for a long second. the near-naked men in leather harnesses That’s how it is, I think, inarticulately, on elevated platforms, as you return with a gin and tonic, everyone feigning nonchalance in the line. the sort of Zen repose I only get You look so polished in your white button-down, when you’re moving your hips, so controlled and untouristy about to tell me a joke. we don’t struggle getting past the coat check.

Then bursting into the club with you, ii. We don’t get home until sunrise, the guttural thrum of techno the streets orange-tinted and industrial. and how you aren’t afraid to dance, haven’t been Too riled to sleep, since that boy called you a faggot in the tenth grade. we watch a free movie about a teenage drug addict.

When you’re turning around to get a drink, We are burrowed on the couch like immobilized cats, grotesque, I find myself randomly in awe not needing beauty. That is exactly what you do for me. of your sturdiness, wanting to tell you When I met you, we were chubby, suburban, we came this far poorly dressed, fourteen. or something equally trite We didn’t know the first thing about our bodies. but instead I let you disappear onto the balcony.

We grant each other our private fantasies, We ate together every lunchtime. knowing only a few can converge, Ella Goldblum

www.mactivity.com/free-pass

The healthy whole body cryotherapy that everyone is talking about!

COME AND TRY IT OUT @MACTIVITY

285 Nicoll Street, New Haven, CT 06511 (203) - 936 - 9446

54

March 2023 TheNewJournal

**REDACTED ** ACROSS

Puzzle by Jesse Goodman

Little piggy, in nursery rhyme 1 Elba of “The Suicide 37 Pass time in the Squad” shower, say 6 Precursor to lava 38 Ending with “pan-” or 11 Expensive Persian “di-” product 40 Contortionist’s feat 14 2016 animated film scored by Lin Manuel 41 There are 1.609 in a mi.

Miranda 42 Washington bills 15 Poet Vuong 16 Chemical suffix that’s 43 Actors taking solo bows also a direction 45 The best is ___ come 17 Like one often beaming 47 “Get what I mean?”, slangily 18 Sharp-tasting, as sour fruits 49 Featuring missing from a tube top 19 Hashtag below a nostalgic post 51 Group hunting Frankenstein’s 20 Color on the walls monster 21 -52 Classroom temp 22 Perform successfully, 55 Lose at a gambling as a finance bro table might say 56 Important info for an 23 Beginning of many Airbnb guest band names © The New Journal 59 -24 Crew implement 66 Sesame, Jump 60 Common Market 25 “And so on and so and Elm, in short letters forth” 67 “Sic, boy!”

61 Soldier getting 28 Click the paperclip walloped by Asterix 68 “The ___ true for me” icon or Obelix 31 What Old Testament sinners might incur 62 The “I” of I.P.A. DOWN from God 63 Snitch 1 “No more for me, 32 DVR devices with a thanks” 64 Literary character distinctive peanutwho said “Curioser 2 Moolah shaped remote and curioser!”

3 Place for archery 34 Literary orphan 65 Material for sharp practice Cabret keys?

4 Stopovers for travelers ANSWER TO PREVIOUS (JANUARY) PUZZLE 5 Give a wave 6 Insectoid enemy to Godzilla with a 250meter wingspan 7 Trendy berry 8 Chap 9 Irish-born Tony winner Patrick 10 Whichever 11 Fell back, as an army 12 Prepares to take off 36

March 2023

Ties the knot, so to 40 Boo speak 42 Alley-___ 21 Narrator of the 44 Homes away from Sherlock Holmes home for diplomats stories 46 Popeye’s anchor, e.g., 22 “Fortunate Son” for short band, for short 48 Slim Shady 24 -50 Like a gym rat, 26 He. on the periodic slangily table 52 Cty abandoned by 27 -Lot 28 Part of G.P.A.: Abbr.

53 Sample given to a 29 Climax of an action drug tester film 54 Twins usually share 30 What you might do if them, briefly you have an earworm 57 “You tagged me!”

32 “Come to dinner!”

58 Confront 33 Teaches 59 Brittney Griner’s org.

35 Faster than a trot 60 -or canter 61 New use for an old 37 Neck-straining NYC shirt attractions 62 -39 One forbidden from PLAY MORE TNJ sports betting, for CROSSWORDS ON short OUR WEBSITE! 13

E

IN

PL E

IS

E

TheNewJournal

TH

While this magazine is published by Yale College students, Yale University is not responsible for its contents. All contents Copyright ©2022 by The New Journal at Yale, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction either in whole or in part without written permission of the publisher and editors in chief is prohibited. Recycle Icon from Flaticon.com.

CL

The New Journal was founded in 1967, under the following mission statement: “This university has once again reached that stage in history when people are talking about the New Yale, presumably to be distinguished from the Old Yale, which in its own day was presumably considered new. Wishing to share in this modernity, we have chosen The New Journal as the name for our publication. Besides, things seemed slow around here.”

E RECY Today, The New Journal is published five times during the academic year by The New Journal at Yale, Inc. Two thousand five hundred AS copies of each issue are distributed free to members of the Yale and New Haven community. The New Journal is printed by TCI Press, Seekonk, Massachusetts; bookkeeping and billing services are provided by Colman Bookkeeping of New Haven. Office Address: P.O. Box 3311, New Haven, CT 06515.

M AGAZ

55

The Gender & Sexuality Issue Danya Blokh is in for a night of non-denominational, non-binary hardcore at Space Ballroom. 4 Jools Fu writes about violence and masculinity in the Singapore Armed Forces. 6 Sasha Carney tells a genealogy of lesbian social spaces at Yale. 10 Hannah Szabó draws it out with local trans advocate Tony Ferraiolo. 28 the new journal