Monday March 24, 2014 year: 134 No. 41
www.thelantern.com @TheLantern weather high 39 low 27 mostly sunny
Students react to commencement speaker selection
Courtesy of OSU
thelantern the student voice of The Ohio State University
Tennis 184-0 at home
5A
Exclusive records to nab
8A
Proposed TV show ‘racist’
4A
OSU police staffing per student worst in B1G Caitlin essig Managing editor for content essig.21@osu.edu Ohio State has the lowest number of officers per student among Big Ten and Midwestern universities, leading some local law enforcement officials to question safety on campus. A May 2013 internal staffing analysis from the OSU Police Division states the need for hiring 10 to 13 full-time officers “to balance the amount of time required for response to calls from our community based on 2012 CAD call data.” CAD stands for computer-assisted dispatch, which is the system used by the University Police 911 dispatchers. University spokesman Gary Lewis said, however, “it is not accurate to report that we have a shortage of at least 10-13 officers.” “In looking at the last seven years of our staffing levels, at our highest staffing in 2008, we had 52 officers,” Lewis said in an email. “We currently have 46 sworn officers and are in the process of hiring one officer to replace someone who retired in January, which will bring us to 47, which is consistent with where our staffing levels have been.” Columbus Division of Police Sgt. Shaun Laird, who spoke on behalf of University Police as the secretary for a local chapter of the Fraternal Order of Police, said the change in staffing levels, though, should raise concerns. “In the last seven years, (University Police) had 52 officers at one point, and they’re basically saying that 52 to 46 is a wash,” he said. “And it’s really a 10 percent reduction. Ten percent when you have that few of people to start with is pretty dramatic. And as you can guess, if you had a 10 percent decrease in student enrollment or a 10 percent decrease in state funding, it would be front page news. “Ohio State says, ‘We want to be the best at everything,’ and they’re certainly not the best at safety. And they’re actually the worst.” Issues of under-staffing were highlighted recently when Capt. Eric Chin of Purdue University Police Department compiled data that showed OSU had the lowest rate of officers per student in the Big Ten and Midwest. The study notes that OSU has about .85 officers per 1,000 students, and the number has since been adjusted to about .80 officers per 1,000 students, as the number of officers is currently 46, not 48 as the data originally suggested. Laird said it’s important to note not all 46 officers are actively patrolling, nor do all 46 work at once.
The internal report states a typical shift is staffed by five officers, with one assigned to OSU East Hospital. Because of a shortage in officers, however, Laird said having an officer stationed at OSU East Hospital at all times could become a thing of the past. “As a measure because staffing numbers are so low, they’re proposing that they’re going to pull the officers out of OSU East,” Laird said. “So they have basically 24-hour coverage at the hospital, and they’re saying they’re going to pull those officers out.” Northwestern leads the list of Big Ten and Midwestern universities with 2.9 officers per 1,000 students, followed by the University of Notre Dame, with 2.3 officers per 1,000 students, according to Chin’s report. According to OSU’s 2013 annual campus security and fire safety report, there were 22 reports of burglary, four of aggravated assault, two of robbery and 21 of forcible sex offenses in 2012. Northwestern’s 2013 annual campus security and fire safety report noted 17 reports of burglary, one of aggravated assault, no robberies and two reports of forcible sex offenses on its main campus in that same period. There is, however, also a disparity in the population of the two schools, with OSU having about 40,000 more students than Northwestern, according to the police staffing data report. OSU’s Columbus campus has the third largest
population on the list (behind Michigan and Rutgers University, which have the third and second lowest officer-to-student ratio, respectively) and the largest amount of building space. The report said OSU needs more than 67 officers based on the overall Big Ten police officer to student ratio, and it should employ more than 84 officers to match up to the overall Midwest ratio. The University Police internal report said a possible alternative to hiring more officers is continuing to use overtime funding for current officers, although the report warns against that. “Use of overtime funding is not desirable based on the strain on existing staff, cost-per-hour for coverage, lack of flexibility when greater numbers of officers are needed and negative public perception based on high individual salaries,” the report states. Laird said mandating officers to work overtime could be dangerous for both the officers and constituents. “After a while, although the money sounds good at first, after a while you become stretched pretty thin,” Laird said. “And the university has so many things that they need covered, because it’s such a big university, that the officers are working all this mandated overtime start to have burn out, things like that. “The other concern is if you’re having to use all this overtime all the time, then that means probably
Buckeyes look to next year after loss to Dayton
OSU faculty, staff weigh in on search for missing plane
Chris Matthews, host of MSNBC political talk show ‘Hardball with Chris Matthews,’ is set to speak at OSU’s Spring 2014 Commencement.
Michele Theodore Copy chief theodore.13@osu.edu Some Ohio State students set to graduate in May said the commencement speaker is a somewhat surprising choice, especially after last year’s speech was given by President Barack Obama. Some, however, are hoping OSU’s selection will still give a memorable speech without playing hard ball. Chris Matthews, host of MSNBC political talk show “Hardball with Chris Matthews,” is set to speak at Ohio State’s Spring 2014 Commencement May 4 at Ohio Stadium. Caleb Inboden, a fourth-year in theatre and graduating senior, said he was expecting to see someone associated with OSU chosen. “I was a little confused at first,” Inboden said. “Last year, they got President Obama and even for the fall commencement, they got R.L. Stine who’s associated with the university, so I was wondering their reasoning behind it.” Matthews graduated from Holy Cross College in 1967 and has served as a visiting fellow at Harvard University’s Institute of Politics.
continued as Graduation on 3A
Eric Seger Sports editor seger.25@osu.edu The ball bounced off the front of the rim and fell to the floor at the First Niagara Center. Ohio State’s season was over. Dayton had a 60-59 advantage when the buzzer echoed throughout the rafters and signaled the end of the careers of two of the most accomplished players OSU has ever seen — senior guards Lenzelle Smith Jr. and Aaron Craft. But as their season ended Thursday in the NCAA Tournament’s second round, next season’s outlook is somewhat of a mixed bag with the unexpected departure of a bench player and an incoming Top 5 recruiting class. As it currently stands, OSU is set to have just 11 players on scholarship when practice for the 2014-15 season opens this fall. Losing Craft and Smith Jr. will likely hurt from a leadership standpoint, but coach Thad Matta has five returning players who are on scholarship and will be seniors, provided forward LaQuinton Ross doesn’t bounce to the NBA. “Both guys, you look at how many games they’ve won here, championships they’ve been a part of, it’s really an amazing four years,” Matta said of Craft and Smith Jr. March 7. “With that said, both guys have had a major impact on this program in terms of making it better. And that’s what we ask guys to do.” Craft said in the locker room after his final game as a Buckeye that junior guard Shannon Scott needs to step up as a leader next season, but filling that void can’t just fall on him. “Obviously he has some big games under his belt and he’s experienced this, but it’s not just going to fall on one guy’s shoulders. Guy like (junior forward) Sam (Thompson) can help, too,” Craft said. The number of players on scholarships is one less than it would have been even with the departure of Craft and Smith Jr., because sophomore guard Amedeo Della Valle told Matta and his staff Saturday that he intends to head back home to Italy and pursue a professional career in Europe. Della Valle posted a message to his personal Twitter account, @Ame_ DV_33, Saturday afternoon announcing his farewell. “I wouldn’t trade this experience with anything else, B1G Champions, the run to the Elite 8, the 12-0 year, man was that special,” the message read. “It is now time for me to begin new experiences as I decided to head back to Europe to continue to play PRO basketball.” So with three men gone and the potential to lose another in Ross — who said his decision would come
continued as Police on 3A
Chahinaz Seghiri Lantern reporter seghiri.1@osu.edu
ritika shah / Asst. photo editor
Junior guard Shannon Scott (3) guards Dayton freshman guard Scoochie Smith (11). OSU lost to Dayton, 60-59, at First Niagara Center March 20. “in the next couple of weeks” — Matta and company have some rebuilding to do. Matta signed yet another top 5 recruiting class for next season, bringing in guard D’Angelo Russell, forwards Keita Bates-Diop and Jae’Sean Tate and center David Bell. It’s a class Matta said he’s excited to coach. “The biggest thing with this particular class is we got what we wanted,” Matta said Nov. 14. Russell, 21st in the ESPN top 150 rankings, is likely to figure largely in the rotation next year to help replace Craft and Smith Jr.’s production. Tate is recovering from surgery for a torn labrum in his right shoulder and is out for the rest of his senior season so it remains to be seen when he will be 100 percent, and Bates-Diop and Bell likely have their work cut out for them to get minutes unless Ross leaves. Another player who will figure into the equation is current freshman guard Kam Williams, who sat out all year after battling through mono and missing the bulk of training camp. All season long, something appeared off with the team, whether it be a lack of instinct, absence of ability to consistently put points on the board or an undependable post presence.
“(Fans) deserve an answer. They deserved an answer all year. They’ve seen us play well, and they’ve seen us play like this,” Craft said after the loss to the Flyers Thursday. “Nothing is guaranteed and that’s one of the tougher things to get across from people. My time’s done now, so it’s on these guys to learn from what this season’s been. How hard it’s been. How difficult we’ve made it on ourselves at times. That’s what they gotta do.” Returning to try and fill in the blanks are juniors in Thompson, Scott and center Amir Williams, who all averaged at least 7.5 points per game in OSU’s 25-win campaign. Junior center Trey McDonald is also set to return, but he only averaged 2.0 points per game and 1.7 rebounds off the bench this season. Scoring points will be a premium for the Buckeyes next year, as aside from Ross, no one really stepped up to be that second scorer the team so desperately needed. “It’s one of those things where everybody wants to be that guy. But the guys got to be willing to do the things in terms of work ethic and in terms of the system and knowing that,” Matta said. “You see guys have great off-seasons, and hopefully we have that.”
After a flight disappeared more than two weeks ago halfway around the world, some faculty and staff at Ohio State said the search is like looking for a needle in a yet-to-be discovered haystack. Malaysian Airlines Flight MH370 from Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, to Beijing took off at 12:41 a.m. March 8 and then vanished from radars shortly after 1 a.m. It was scheduled to land at 6:30 a.m. and was carrying 227 passengers from 14 countries and 12 crew members. Some radars picked up signals from what was likely MH370 later in the night that showed it had flown away from its scheduled path, but as of Sunday evening, there was no complete theory as to where the plane had gone. OSU’s Center for Aviation Studies director Seth Young put the size of the search into perspective. “The area that the investigators are targeting on right now is an area about the size of the United States, and they started to focus on an area maybe the size of the Great Lakes region,” Young said. “We are looking for an aircraft when whole is only 200 feet long by 200 feet wide, and when broken up into pieces during a crash, these pieces could be as small as a piece of an upholstery seat.” The United States’ area is about 3.72 million square feet, according to the United States Department of the Interior’s National Atlas, and the Great Lakes region covers 94,250 square miles of water area, according to the United States Environmental Protection Agency website. Young said he doesn’t think there is evidence to support a terrorist-related theory. “As an aviation safety person, what I try to do is gather evidence that would lead towards a certain determination, and at this point, I haven’t seen any evidence that points towards any malicious act,” Young said. Young said an emergency or problem on the plane could have prompted the pilot to try to find a safe place to land. “Because the plane was only about 35 minutes into its flight, sometimes the instinct of the pilot is to turn back home,” Young said. Young said he believes there are airfields
continued as Plane on 2A 1A