Page 1
Volume CXIX, No. 15
Blasts from the past
♦
Thursday, May 4, 2017
Thursday, May 4, 2017
FREE
Students hear Spencer, rally in solidarity Hundreds attend lecture, hundreds attend rally
This week in 1912, a letter to the editor ran in The Gettysburgian expressing vehement opposition to a proposed merger between it and Mercury, another student publication on campus. The writer, a graduate from the class of 1906, argued that the art and literary submissions to Mercury should be separate from the news function of The Gettysburgian. Ultimately, that view held out, and both publications exist to this day.
This week in 1978, prominent consumer advocate and eventual presidential candidate Ralph Nader spoke at Gettysburg College. He asserted that, in addition to the government, corporations hold immense power over individuals in America, and he blamed such corporations for deteriorating environmental conditions across the country, urging students to take action to fight these trends. This week in 1986, The Gettysburgian led with a story that profiled student and faculty reactions to news that the United States had conducted an air raid in Tripoli, Libya, against President Muammar Gadhafi in response to acts of terrorism allegedly perpetrated by the regime. Many professors noted how complicated fighting terrorism can be and the possibility of civilian casualties happening in raids designed to kill terrorists. This week in 2010, the college announced that it had completed implementation of its plan to reduce the teaching course load for tenured and tenure-track faculty from six courses per year to five, which James White, Acting Provost, said would allow for greater opportunities for faculty to collaborate with students on research and creative projects and engage in additional scholarly activity. The plan was accomplished through the hiring of additional faculty members rather than a reduction in course offerings to avoid increasing class sizes. These archived “blasts from the past” were compiled by news editor Benjamin Pontz thanks to the digitized Special Collections in Musselman Library.
Nearly 400 students packed CUB Ballroom to hear Robert Spencer’s presentation on “The Political Ramifications of Islamic Fundamentalism.” Photo courtesy of Jamie Welch
Students, faculty, and community members engaged in a night of solidarity with Muslim students. Photo courtesy of San Khai Luc.
Students engage in civil Hundreds rally, discourse at Spencer lecture dance, and celebrate
B y B enjamin P ontz N ews E ditor As Robert Spencer took the stage of the CUB Ballroom Wednesday night, the audience seemed unsure of what would happen next. On the heels of students at the University of Buffalo shouting down Spencer last evening, Jack Ryan, Vice Provost of Gettysburg College, had warned the audience to engage in civil discourse in listening to Spencer’s speech, which was sponsored by the Gettysburg chapter of the Young Americans for Freedom (YAF).
S p e n c e r opened his speech by commending students who attended for standing up to pressure levied on them by other members of the campus community, many of whom attended a simultaneous Muslim Solidarity Rally in front of Penn Hall. “There is one kind of diversity that is not valued generally in an academic setting,” he said, “and that is intellectual diversity. I commend you for having the courage to brave the stigma and to come here tonight despite the tremendous pressure that was placed on you not
to come.” He continued by deconstructing arguments made by Dr. Todd Green, an associate professor of religion at Luther College, in a speech Sunday on “Professional Islamophobia,” something Green accused Spencer of perpetrating. S p e n c e r suggested that Green had committed “slander” and is part of a wellfunded movement that aims to delegitimize any suggestion that jihad is an intrinsic component of Islam. “Islamophobia - Continued on next page -
B y J oshua W agner S taff W riter Dr. Todd Green, Associate Professor of Religion at Luther College, presented on professional Islamophobia Sunday evening to a packed Mara Auditorium. Green is a regular contributor for The Huffington Post and has appeared in various media outlets including NPR, CNN, Al Jazeera, France 24 and Reuters to speak on Islamophobia. The lecture, sponsored by the Religious Studies Department and the Peace and Justice Studies program, was arranged to develop the idea of Professional Islamophobia before the presentation on “The Political Ramifications of Islamic Fundamentalism” by Robert Spencer on Wednesday. In opening the lecture, Green posed two moral questions: “What are our commitments to our Muslim neighbors?” and “How do we tell truths about our Muslim neighbors?” Green went on to define Islamophobia as “the irrational fear, hostility and hatred of
Muslims and of Islam. It is also the exclusionary and discriminatory practices that arise from that fear and hatred.” Green defined professional Islamophobia as “a cadre of extremist bloggers, authors, some politicians, [and] pundits, who make a living and a career off of dehumanizing and demonizing Muslims.” He highlighted three full-time practitioners of professional Islamophobia: Pamela Geller, Robert Spencer and Frank Gaffney. Geller and Spencer, cofounders of the American Freedom Defense Initiative and noted for their “Defeat Jihad” poster campaign, were both banned from the United Kingdom by then Home Secretary Theresa May in 2013. Green noted that Theresa May, now Prime Minister and leader of the Conservative party, is not a “flaming liberal.” Green identified four common themes in professional Islamophobia: violent jihad, civilizational jihad, creeping sharia, and taquiyaa. (For detailed explanations of these doctrines, see the online
version of this article.) Green also showed that Professional Islamophobia is a lucrative business. $56,900,440 in revenue was brought in by 10 anti-Islam organizations between 2001-2012, and over $200 million was raised by 33 anti-Islam organizations between 2008-2013 according to research by Fear, Inc, CAIR, and U.C. Berkeley Center for Race and Gender. Spencer received $186,237 from the David Horowitz Freedom Center and an additional $29,461 from the American Freedom Defense Initiative for his work according to IRS 990 forms. Green then detailed ways in which Muslims were being discriminated against in the United States. Hate crimes soared in the year after 911, and have normalized to levels five times higher than before 2001. Mosques experienced a 345 percent increase in conflicts in 20102012 compared to 2008-2010 according to the ACLU. Ten states have enacted anti-Islam legislation mostly referring to Sharia law. Green then suggested three ideas to avoid
B y D aniella S nyder E ditor - in -C hief
Over 300 students, faculty members, and community members joined together on the steps on Penn Hall in solidarity with Muslim members of campus and the town in response to Robert Spencer’s lecture in the CUB ballroom Wednesday evening. Green ribbons were distributed for people to wear to show their support, along with green fabric donning the phrase, “Hate has no home here”, and “No Islamophobia”. Jerome Clarke, ’17, welcomed everyone to
the event. “When there are those that are suffering, we stand. We are out here to celebrate and love each other,” Clarke said. Clarke introduced the Nawaz Brothers, a Qawwali band, to perform. Qawwali is a type of Sufi devotional music that originated over 700 years ago in South Asia. One of the band members addressed the crowd. “We are family. We must rise. We must stick together,” he said. After a few songs, Chaplain Donnella spoke to the group on the importance of interfaith
- Continued on next page -
Todd Green discusses “Professional Islamophobia” in speech to campus community
Inside This Issue
This week in 1957, the faculty of Gettysburg College ratified a student proposal to institute an honor commission despite some objections that “the system is not broad enough.” Nevertheless, a committee was established to review student petitions to s erve on w hat w ould be the inaugural Honor Commission.
Climate study, pg. 2
“Buzz” Jones retires, pg. 3
New skill for Amazon Echo, pg. 5
The audience for Green’s lecture nearly filled Mara Auditorium Sunday evening; Photo courtesy of Jamie Welch
Islamophobia. First, develop “Holy Envy.” This means that one should admire someone else’s piety, not judge them for it. Second, “Learn from practitioners, not enemies” or as Green also stated, “Learn from practitioners, not from Robert Spencer.” To this point, Green cited that two-thirds of Americans believe they don’t even know a Muslim person. Lastly, “Don’t compare their worst to our best.”After the lecture, questions were taken from the audience. The first member of the audience to ask a question was a Quran-carrying 84-year old member of the Gettysburg community who repeatedly said “I’m nobody.” He questioned the ethos of the lecturer by asking specific questions about Islam, and claimed
Music review, pg. 6
that Green mischaracterized and trivialized the danger of Islam. Although the event was largely restricted to attendees with college IDs, Bill Lafferty, Director of the Department of Public Safety, said that certain non-members of the campus community were permitted to attend with prior approval. After the lecture, Green commented that there is usually one person, usually carrying a Quran, who makes such an appearance. Later, Brittany Russell, a sophomore, asked whether it is better to go to the Robert Spencer lecture and engage him in debate or to protest outside and attend the Muslim Solidarity Rally. Green noted that no matter what decision students made, - Continued on next page -
Strong “A Warning showing for for Track & Democrats” Field pg. 7 pg. 8