©1987
The Center for Wooden Boats—Volume 9, Number 2 - M a r . - A p r . 1987—25¢
Some Thoughts On Replicas and the Necessity of Saving the Real Thing After her stay at E x p o , the replica of Drake's Golden Hinde spent a month receiving visitors at the end of the H . C . Henry Pier next to Waterway 4. She received a lot of visitors, day and night. People called the C W B asking for information about the "tall ship," the "windjammer," even "the Spanish pirate galleon," a misnomer that must have had D r a k e spinning in his h a m m o c k at the bottom of N o m b r e Dios Bay. T h e landsmen and their families whose cars filled Benjamin's, Burger King's and the C W B ' s parking lots got a good idea of the life of an Elizabethan sailor: the cramped conditions, the appalling sanitation, the loathsome food. M a n y were surprised that a ship that circumnavigated the globe was so small. Everybody wondered how D r a k e ever did what he did, terrorizing the Spanish M a i n with such meager resources. A ship like the Hinde helps us realize that in Drake's day, the Spanish population was probably that of, say, Ballard, spread pretty thin. So a lot of folks got a "gee w h i z " look at history. F o r a maritime historian, there were some problems. T h e first question is why the Hinde? She was an historic ship certainly, possibly the first to establish England's dominion of the seas. But Drake's Revenge was a m u c h more developed example of the race-built ship, responsible for the defeat of the A r m a d a . A n d the defeat of the A r m a d a was what really made England the preeminent naval power. T h e r e were no plans for the Hinde, which was recreated from paintings and woodcuts of similar vessels. So what we have is not a replica of the specific ship but one generally like it. Frankly, if the current replica is as accurate as its creators claim, why does it need additional sponsons for stability? We may not know too m u c h about what the Hinde really looked like, but the best experts are sure Sir Francis didn't have sponsons. 'Tween
decks,
the
Hinde
smells
just
like
Balclutha, Cutty Sark a n d the Victory: a heady amalgam of bilge, paint, cordage, tar, and slightly mildewed canvas. Bulkheads, overhead, a n d the gundeck are painted the traditional dark m a r o o n red, selected to hide blood during a hot encounter. However, we're sure the Elizabethan shipwrights didn't use wood as green as the deckbeams obviously were when they were put into the replica. Huge checks ran their length a n d most of the stanchions had gapped away from them. Prowling around the stern reveals a very modern rudder and the concealed presence of an engine. We realize that keeping the Hinde afloat financially means meeting schedules: at E x p o , in Seattle, T a c o m a , and other Puget S o u n d ports. Still, every divergence from their attempts at authenticity weakens the case for replica ships. C o n t r a s t Hinde with Wawona. T h e Wawona may be in need of repair. She may sag in spots. S h e was never a crucial part of international relations, being a humble merchantman instead of a warship. S h e needs work. But, and this is a big but, she's undeniably real. H e r timbers are of a w o o d unmilled in these latter days. L o s e Wawona and where are we going to find timber for a
replica? T h e fox-tailed trunnels that fasten her are the way her planks were fastened, not a guess at the way she was fastened. Visit the ships at the National Maritime M u s e u m at Hyde Park Pier in San Francisco. T h e y may also be in shaky shape, but they too have the undeniable impact of reality. T h e r e is no supposition about them. If there are hooks for clothes a n d foul weather gear in the quarters, it's because they were there when the ships were in service. If there are pegs for clothes, it's because the sailors preferred pegs... or because the shipowners were cheap. If there's a jingus that nobody can figure out a use for, it means that we don't know as m u c h as we think
we do and we need more research. Replicas like Golden Hinde, the Mayflower, a n d the Pride of Baltimore are undeniably the only way we're going to see their like nowadays. But they can't answer our questions about how they were really constructed. T h e y have no enigmatic detail to wonder over, no puzzling fittings whose use has been lost, no spur to further research. T h e y seem a little smug about it.
You Can't Have One Without the Other
Vancouver's assessment of the geography and flora of this region. Puget Sound's first cash flow came because of the vast quantity of timber — high quality fir, cedar, and spruce — and because these trees grew on the edge of protected deep water. Puget S o u n d settlers first earned money with sawmill and sailing vessel. As each mill was established, the ships followed immediately. O l d photos show a forest of masts, yards, booms, gaffs, and rigging, surrounded by the nature-made forests, with a steam sawmill a n d pier in the center of it all.
In his 1792 voyage of exploration, Captain G e o r g e V a n c o u v e r viewed the steep hillsides and impenetrable forests of the Pacific Northwest's sounds and fiords, and declared it "useless" country. Puget Sound's first white settlers came to claim a homestead and establish a survival farm. In the process of finding even a postage stamp parcel of flat land and clearing the gargantuan trees, they came to agree with
It was fun to tour the Hinde. S h e had lessons for people who know little or nothing about ships or maritime history. But for the real information, in depth and in detail, we must save our historic ships. Because they're real.
Sailing vessels carried Northwest timber to all