A Headline Exploration: Air temperatures and accidental drowning

Page 1


A HEADLINE EXPLORATION of the relationship between air temperature and accidental drowning fatalities in the UK

RLSS UK

Red Hill House

227 London Road

Worcestershire

WR5 2JG

W. rlss.org.uk | E. info@rlss.org.uk | T. 0300 3230 096

Registered Charity (England and Wales 1046060, Scotland SC037912).

Private Limited by Guarantee Company (3033781). Fundraising Standards Board Member.

Last year, the National Drowning Report UK1 reported evidence of an increase in accidental drowning fatalities during periods of extreme air temperatures in 2022.

The fifth hottest August on record coincided with an increase in the proportion of accidental drowning fatalities, compared to the 5-year average.

As a leading water safety charity, the Royal Life Saving Society UK (RLSS UK) is interested in understanding more about the possible relationship between air temperature and accidental drowning fatalities.

Approach

We have used two data sources in our analysis.

Average UK maximum air temperatures, provided by the Met Office.

These cover all of the UK, including England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. As such, where maximum air temperatures are at their highest, these reflect extreme hotweather events.

- Daily data, which covers the period 2018 to 2022.

- Long-term average, which covers the period 1991 to 2020.

Accidental drowning fatalities, 2018 to 2022, from WAID2.

The headline findings from our analysis are outlined on the following pages.

19 people accidentally drowned across a consecutive 4-day period in July as the UK experienced an unprecedented heatwave, when air temperatures reached over 38°C.

1 Royal Life Saving Society UK (June 2023), National Drowning Report UK

2 Water Incident Database (WAID) | National Water Safety Forum

FINDING ONE:

Increases in the daily UK average maximum air temperatures in the summer coincide with increases in the number of daily UK accidental drowning fatalities

Figure 1 shows the daily UK average maximum temperature (°C) and the daily UK accidental drowning fatalities between 1st January 2018 and 31st December 2022.

Visually, we see increases in the daily UK average maximum air temperatures in the summer, which coincide with increases in the number of daily UK accidental drowning fatalities.

Fig 1. UK Average Maximum Air Temperatures ( °C) vs. UK Accidental Drowning Fatalities

Figure. 1: UK Average Maximum Air Temperature (°C) vs. UK Accidental Drowning Fatalities

Source: # of Accidental Drowning Fatalities, WAID (2018-2022), UK Average Maximum Air Temperatures, Met Office (2018-2022)

FINDING TWO:

The higher the daily UK average maximum air temperature, the higher the average number of daily UK accidental drowning fatalities

In Figure 2 we can see that the higher the daily UK average maximum air temperature, the higher the average number of daily UK accidental drowning fatalities.

Figure 2: Average no. of UK accidental drowning fatalities per day based on the average maximum air temperature ( °C)

Figure. 2: UK Average no. of UK Accidental Drowning Fatalities Per Day Based On The Average Maximum Air Temperature (°C)

Drowning

Source: # of Accidental Drowning Fatalities, WAID (2018-2022), UK Average Maximum Air Temperature, Met Office (July 2023)

By summarising this data into Table 1, it can be observed that when the daily UK average maximum air temperature reaches 25°C or above:

5x as many UK accidental drownings per day, on average, compared to when UK average maximum air temperatures are below 17°C.

Table 1: Summary Table - Average no. of UK accidental drowning fatalities per day based on the average maximum air temperature (°C)

Max Air Temperature (°C)

3x

There are more than 3x as many UK accidental drownings per day on average, compared to when temperatures are at or around the long-term UK average maximum summer air temperature of 18.9°C.

Base (days): Below 17°C (1,274), 17-18.9 °C (215), 19-20.9 °C (187), 21-22.9°C (80), 23-24.9°C (36), 25°C and over (34)

FINDING THREE:

Evidence of people actively entering the water when UK average maximum air temperatures rise to 25°C and over

When air temperatures rise, people may be tempted to head to nearby outdoor water spaces to enjoy the weather. In our analysis of UK accidental drownings that occur when UK average maximum air temperatures were 25°C, we found that 63% or above were inland, in places such as rivers and lakes.

We also found evidence of an increased propensity to enter the water during these periods of heat. Of those who accidentally drowned when UK average maximum air temperatures were 25°C or above, over half (57%) were swimming. This compares to just 20% of cases across all accidental drownings, where 1 in 3 of those who drowned were walking or running3, as shown in Figure 3.

Figure. 3: % UK Accidental Drowning Fatalities by Activity, Compared To The 5-Year Average

Base: UK Average Maximum Air Temperature 25°C or over (90), 5-Year Average, 2018-2022 (1,243)

3 Based on the WAID 5-year average 2018-2022

Accidental Drownings (5-year average)

FINDING FOUR:

Data shows an increase in the number of adolescents and young adults drowning when average maximum air temperatures are 25°C and over

We have also explored the ages of those who lost their lives to accidental drowning when UK average maximum air temperatures were 25°C and over.

In total, 40% of those that accidentally drowned were aged between 13 and 24 years of age.

- 20% were aged between 13 and 17 years old. This compares to 6% across all accidental drownings.

- 20% were aged between 18 and 24-years old, compared to 14% for all drownings.

Figure. 4: % UK Accidental Drowning Fatalities By Age (Where Known) Compared To The 5-Year Average

CONCLUSIONS

Conclusions

From our initial exploration between average maximum air temperature and the daily number of accidental drownings in the UK, there is evidence of a relationship between the two factors. When daily average UK maximum air temperatures rise, we also see a rise in the number of UK accidental drownings. This finding reinforces other work in academia

The relationship between the two factors is complex and more research is needed to fully understand other influences at play. Equally, UK average maximum air temperatures are likely to be just one of many factors that influence an individual’s likelihood to drown, and any learning should be considered in the broader context of all possible contributory factors.

The analysis indicates that when daily UK average air temperatures rise to 25°C or above we see:

• An increase in the number of individuals losing their lives to drowning when choosing to actively enter the water.

• That adolescents and young adults are proportionately more likely to lose their lives to accidental drowning.

RECOMMENDATIONS

Recommendations

Based on our initial exploration, and evidence outlined, we feel it is prudent that organisations focused on water safety and public health should seek to raise awareness of the risks associated with being in, on and around water during periods of extreme hot weather, when the number of daily drownings increases.

During these times, we recommend that water safety organisations, their partners and statutory bodies should work together to encourage members of the public to:

• Be aware of their surroundings and always choose a lifeguard venue, where available.

• Ensure their water safety knowledge is up to date to help minimise risk when actively entering the water.

Campaigns and messaging should be focused at those most at risk, notably adolescents and young adults.

In addition, the organisations and their partners should:

• Support opportunities to share water safety education with adolescents, ensuring they are aware of the dangers of outdoor water and equipping them with the knowledge of what to do in an emergency.

About RLSS UK

RLSS UK is passionate about ensuring that everyone has the opportunity to enjoy water safely. And there’s perhaps no more popular time to make use of our extensive coastline and waterways than when the sun is shining, and the weather is hot. Whilst having fun in, on or near water in hot weather, it is even more important that everyone ensures they know how to stay safe and how to respond in an emergency.

Remember the Water Safety Code and for more water safety advice, visit our website www.rlss.org.uk

For more information on drowning statistics, view the National Drowning Report UK.

Authored by the Royal Life Saving Society UK (RLSS UK).

RLSS UK is a registered charity which provides expert lifesaving education in the UK and Ireland, protecting families from the sudden and devastating impact of drowning.

www.rlss.org.uk

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.