Ravenscroft School 7409 Falls of Neuse Road LowDown On Downton
MS Matches
Say Whhaatt?
Mean Girls
? ater W t o
March 2013
G
Page 5
You Just Got # RESPECT
Emi Myers
STAFF WRITER
J
ason Ramsden, Ravenscroftâs Chief Technology Officer, gave a passionate presentation to the Upper School on February 13th, concerning the treatment and condition of the Chromebooks issued last year. Ramsden compared damage reports between Ravenscroft and public schools also using Chromebooks, highlighting the huge percentage gap between damaged units , which suggested that Ravenscroft students are much harder on the units than their public school peers. His presentation served as a harsh awakening to the student population and perhaps even inspired better care for the Chromes but many students are questioning the validity of Ramsdenâs data and itâs portrayal of the Upper School community.
Chr med
Chrome1. Schools witsth uadent had book for each ges vlid overnight pri l students 2. Available gtoraaldes 4-12) (some cases 3. Used as a tool
Presentation
Gabrielle Rhoades, â13, Michael Wohlers, â13, and Nick LeFevre,â13, respectfully use their Chromebooks while in Rhondaâs Cafe. Photo by Emi Meyers
P
ublic schools were estimated to have a 1.4% damage rate whereas Ravenscroft is estimated to have a 26% damage rate. Further divided, the statistics showed that the 8th and 11th grades were responsible for the most damage throughout the school. At the end of his presentation, Ramsden threatened that if the damage levels continue at the same rate or increase, Ravenscroft might begin to charge for repairs. Ramsden reported that the data was collected through âGoogle+ chatâ with other public school districts.
T
he presentation, titled âRespect: Itâs a Community Thing,â accompanied by â#respect,â started by mentioning recent changes in North Carolina laws that outlaw the creation of fabricated profiles of both classmates and teachers. Midway through the presentation, the subject matter changed. Ramsden showed slide after slide containing facts about the amount of damaged Chromebooks at Ravenscroft and other public schools using the same units.
Page 10
Page 12
] s rohm pound k [ e m co om um Chr enoting hromi due C s n. D loys of rogres p l or a pause g or o v. T e closin of a to th wering k o unp meboo o Chr
The Facts
ol Public Scho k Usage : Chromeboo
Pages 8 & 9
Page 15
Grady Finch, â14, Rachel Ormand, â14, and Kayla Reali, â14, hard at work on their Chromebooks. Photo by Emi Meyers
r Rates Pe Damage Grade:
.1% Grade - 7 % * de - 46.4 **8th Gra - 5.9% de **9th Gra ade - 9.2% **10th Gr % ade - 28.1 **11th Gr ade - 3.3% **12th Gr *7th
The Student Response
F
ollowing the presentation, some students have questioned the viability of the data used by Ramsden. This is reinforced by the thought that such vastly different circumstances and upbringings might explain the difference in damage rates. Some students have also complained about the fragility of the Chromebooks, blaming the faulty design for the high damage rates, seeing as Chromebooks are encased with hard plastic, in comparison to the metal plating found on Macbooks and other PCs. Since then, one unintended consequence of the presentation is
that students have become tentative to turn their b r o k e n Chromes in for repair. I n Lila Welsh, â14, typing the long on the Chrome. run, this Photo by Emi Meyers could turn out to be even more detrimental and costly to the school. The IT Department has not yet been able to track a change in Chromebook damage considering the recent timing of the presentation, occurring right before break. Only time will tell if this presentation will have a lasting effect.
ft students âRavenscro iation for pprec have less a . Consideroks Chromebo ve students ha ing a lot of cy n fa ones, and iPads, iPh e m ,a iting at ho laptops wa ok seems Chromebo nt.â insignifica Wiehe, â15 - Stephanie
Laptops in Other Schools Cary Academy:
Students are provided with tablet PCs. First damage is $30 and second incident is $100.
Cardinal Gibbons:
Students are not given technology, but are allowed to bring their own computers in to use.
Durham Academy:
Grades 6-8 are provided with iPads. Personal computers are permitted in high school.
St. Maryâs:
Each student recieves a Lenovo Tablet PC. Damage repairs can cost from $100-$500.