Riding Herd Saying things that need to be said. March 15, 2023 • www.aaalivestock.com
Volume 65 • No. 3
Going To The Dogs LEE PITTS
Although the quote is often attributed to Thomas Jefferson, it was actually Thoreau who said, “That government is best which governs least.” A sterling example of that wisdom was on full display when Congress passed the Food Safety Modernization Act and made changes to the Veterinary Feed Directive which require rural veterinarians to take a more active role in the beef production process. As a result, beginning in June, cattlemen won’t be able to buy over-the-counter antibiotics like penicillin and tetracycline without a prescription from a veterinarian. And in order to get that prescription you must now be able to prove that you have what the legislators called “a healthy veterinary-client-patient relationship.” But what happens if there is no veterinarian to have a close personal relationship with?
Yoohoo, Is Anyone There?
NEWSPAPER PRIORITY HANDLING
As usual, the legislators got the cart before the horse. Maybe they should have done something about the shortage of vets in cattle country before playing like eHarmony by forcing you to hook up with a veterinarian for a “relationship.” And it’s going to be fascinating to watch an internet vet tell a rancher how to perform a caesarean or preg check a cow on a Zoom call. Dr. Randy Wheeler, executive director of the Iowa Veterinary Medical Association says that, “According to 2019 statistics, 44 states are seeing veterinarian shortages and the deficit is only worsening. Many of the shortages are in rural areas, and this issue may be increasing.” Dr. Clinton Neill, PhD wrote the definitive work on the subject in his paper, Addressing the
Persistent Shortage of Food Animal Vets and its Impact on Rural Communities. He wrote, “The USDA has identified over 200 shortage areas (unfilled veterinarian positions) in 2021 that cover over 500 counties, many of which are rural. Food animal veterinarian positions in
Much of the decline in large animal vets stems from three key changes. Says Dr. Neill, “A significant increase in education debt obtained by veterinary students, which has outpaced their potential earnings. A flat, if not slightly declining, trend in the number of veterinary students
Never joke with mules or cooks as they have no sense of humor. two-thirds of these shortage areas have remained vacant in the past 5 years.” Dr. Neill says that this vet shortage is nothing new but, “It has now reached such a critically low point that urgent action is required. Only 3-4 percent of new veterinary graduates have entered food animal-related practice over the past 20 years. This does not bode well for the future, as food animal veterinarians currently make up about 5 percent of all veterinarians in the U.S.”
who pursue food animal veterinary practice after graduation. And a rapidly growing companion animal sector that is outpacing the earning potential of other fields of veterinary medicine.” “Further,” says Dr. Neill, “the increase in consolidation among concentrated animal feeding operations has led to larger herd sizes, but fewer operations, which may contribute to a lack of sufficient demand in some rural areas where smaller-scale and lower-income livestock pro-
Legislation to Suspend Brazilian Beef Imports to the U.S. SOURCE: NORTHERNAG.NET
B
ducers often operate.” Many of the larger ranches now hire their own vet which skews the figures making the shortage of large animal vets available to work on smaller clients’ livestock even worse than the numbers indicate.
Follow The Money We hate to bore you with numbers but to understand the problem fully it’s necessary. So let’s get this over with as fast and as efficient as we can. Here are 25 reasons gleaned from several sources that explain why large animal vets in cattle country are as rare as a cowboy with a 401K. 1. According to Dr. Rosslyn Biggs, the director of continuing education for the College of Veterinary Medicine at Oklahoma State University, “Veterinarians spend four years in vet school after completing a four-year undergraduate degree. On average, they leave school with nearly $190,000 in debt. When you’ve got six figures of debt and then you’re looking at trying to buy a practice or buy into a practice, and then the continued on page 2
Despite What You Might Have Heard, Wildlife Populations Are Thriving
razil, the world’s largest exporter of beef halted exports to China, their top customer, after a case of BSE was discovered in late February. The investigation of the case was announced earlier this week with Brazil’s agriculture ministry confirming the case shortly thereafter. Brazil’s beef shipments to China were halted as part of the trade protocol between the two countries. The suspension is expected to be temporary although it’s unknown how long it will be. China accounted for 60 percent of Brazil’s beef exports in January so the suspension will start to be felt across the global beef market quickly. Samples of the infected animal were sent to the World Organization for Animal Health (OIE) lab in Alberta, Canada, to confirm whether it was the classic form of the disease or its “atypical” version. An atypical case also generally means the animal contracted the disease spontaneously, not through contaminated meat-and-bone meal. Preliminary testing in Brazil indicated that the case was the atypical form of the disease.
With the incessant warnings of vanishing wildlife, it just might surprise you to learn that many animals in the U.S. are doing quite well. The population and range of most dramatically shrank by the beginning of the 20th century. We had converted forests to fields and fueled our economy and built our homes, buildings, fences, train trestles, and transportation (wagons, boats, ships, boxcars, and even early cars) from wood. It was a time before basic laws prohibiting things like dumping raw sewage and cruder agricultural practices generated the Dust Bowl. Some of these animals were an important food source, while there was little if any management of hunting, trapping, and fishing. Perhaps most importantly, many were considered serious threats to crops, livestock, desired wildlife, and people, and were purposefully eradicated. However, the past century has seen a dramatic turnaround on human pressure on American wildlife. Huge improvements in ag-
continued on page 4
continued on page 4
BY ROB GORDON / DAILY SIGNAL
by LEE PITTS
The Vegan Solution
A
popular idea floating around the vegan community is that we could solve the whole climate change dilemma (hoax) overnight if all the world’s vegan billionaires would donate a billion dollars each to buy up all the cows on earth and destroy them. I am far from being a mathematician but I did a bit of number crunching on the back of a napkin to see if the vegan’s idea would work. According to the Food and Agriculture Organization there are one and a half BILLION head of cattle on earth and let’s say each one of them was worth $1,000. According to my calculations it would cost one and a half TRILLION dollars to buy all the world’s cattle. There are an estimated 2,668 billionaires on earth but we don’t know how many of them are vegans. So far I could only find two who will admit to it. So the two vegans would have to come up with 750 BILLION dollars EACH to make cattle extinct. Not even Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos or Bill Gates has that kind of cash laying around. The problem with the vegan “solution” is that it assumes every cattle owner would be willing to sell their bovines. Take India, for example. It’s the country with the most cattle with an estimated 305 million head. The problem for the vegan mathematicians is that cattle are revered and protected in India and the thought of killing them all would be inconceivable to them. The United States owns the third most cattle and its billionaires are quite fond of their cattle too. Take John Malone, for example, who just so happens to be the largest landowner in the country. He owns Silver Spur Ranches, a top-notch ranching and beef company that runs on 2.2 million acres and includes the Silver Spur Ranch in Encampment, Wyoming, and the Bell Ranch and the TO Ranch, both in New Mexico. He also has ranches in Walden and Kiowa, Colorado. It turns out that Malone is just as good at running ranches as he was his media business that made him worth nearly ten billion dollars. I’d like to see the two vegan billionaires I was able
continued on page 3