Page 1


We Do Not Torture


"We do not torture" George.W. Bush Panama City 2005


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

” Th e Un i ted S ta tes is committed to th e wor ld wide eli mi n a ti on of tor tur e a n d we a r e lea din g this figh t by ex a mple.” G e o rg e W. B ush 20 0 3

2


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

… h e r emember ed n oticin g th a t an odd fluid wa s lea kin g out of th e 1B sh ower in to h is office… h e sa w a sea led body ba g lea ki n g fluid a cr oss th e floor . " We open ed it up a n d looked a t i t." Sg t G ra ne r i n h is Ap ri l 20 0 5 t e s ti m o ny .

4


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

" Th i s guy doesn 't wa n t to cooper a te."

Diaz r epor ted th a t

a t th i s poi n t, th e deta in ee's fa ce wa s swollen a n d defor med, a n d h e wa s bleedin g fr om th e mouth . Dia z said h e a lso r ea li z ed tha t a l -Ja ma di (th e deta in ee) n o lon ger h a d a pulse.

6


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

" th e i n terr oga tor seemed sh aken up an d ha d sa id someth i n g li ke, 'Th e gu y j ust died on us.'" At th a t poin t, a ccor di ng to B r in son , a l -Ja ma di (th e deta in ee) wa s lyin g on th e gr oun d fa ce up. O n e of his eyes wa s b loody, a n d th er e wa s a smudge of blood on th e floor a bout th e size of a ma n 's pa lm.

8


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

M i li ta r y poli ce told in vestig a tor s th a t th ey believed CIA per son n el followed th eir own r ule book. " You kn ow th ese guys ca n ki ll people," Gr a n er said in a n April 2005 sta temen t to th e Ar my Cr imin a l In vestiga tion Comma n d (CID). " Th e O GA guys do wh a tever th ey wa n t. Th ey don 't ex i st."

10


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

Th ey wer e told to h a n g h im fr om his a r ms in a tor tur e posi ti on kn own a s ” Pa lestin e h an ging” … After th ey left th e r oom on e M P r edca lled ” we h ea r d a lot of scr ea min g” . Less th a n a n h our la ter Ma n a del a l -Ja ma di wa s dea d… Wh en th e M Ps took th e dea d man down ” blood ca me gush i n g out of h i s nose a n d mouth , a s if a fa ucet h a d been tur n ed on ” Dia z r epor ted. Th e n ex t da y a medic ha d him ca rr ied out of th e pr ison on a str etch er a s i f h e wer e a live a n d mer ely ill… a n d th er e wa s n o pa per tr a ils beca use a l -Ja ma di h a d n ever been offi ci a lly r egistr ed. Philip Zim bardo

12


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

Cpl Gr a n er , you a r e doin g a fin e j ob in Tier 1 of th e B FC… You h a ve r eci eved ma n y a ccola des fr om th e M 1 unitsh er e a n d speci fi ca lly fr om LTC. Con tin ue to per for m a t th is level a n d i t wi l l h elp us succed a t our over a ll mission . Captain B ri nson to Cp l Grane r o n Nov 16t h 2 00 3

14


Cpl Gra ne r


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

" Amer i ca sta n ds for liber ty, for th e pur suit of h a ppin ess, a n d for th e un a li en a lien a ble r igh t of life. George W. Bush Nov. 3, 2003

16


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

" We h a d a good Ca bin et meetin g, ta lked a bout a lot of i ssues. S ecr eta r y of S ta te a n d Defen se br ough t us up to da te a bout our desir es to spr ea d fr eedom a n d pea ce a r oun d th e wor ld." Ge orge W. B ush, Was hing ton, D.C., Aug. 1, 200 3

18


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

" A ta ll b la ck soldi er ca me a n d put electr ica l wir es on my fi n ger s an d toes a n d on my pen is, a n d I h a d a ba g over my h ea d," Sa a d sa id in h is sta temen t. " Th en h e wa s sa yi n g 'wh i ch swi tch is for electr icity.' An d h e ca me with a loudspea ker a n d h e wa s sh outin g n ea r my ear . An d th en h e br ough t th e ca mer a an d h e took some pictur es of me, wh i ch I kn ew beca use of th e fla sh of th e ca mer a ." De taine e

20


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

" I wa s j oki ng wi th him, a n d told him if h e fell off, h e would get e lectr ocuted," Ha r ma n sa id. O n e year la ter , Gr a n er spoke to i n vestiga tor s a bout for cin g deta in ees to sta n d on box es, a ta ctic h e cla ims to h a ve employed with th e a ppr ova l of milita r y in telligen ce. " You fell a sleep, you fell down . Wow, you j ust woke your se lf up," Gr a n er ex pla i n ed.

22


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

No ph ysi ca l or men ta l tor tur e, n or a n y oth er for m of coer ci on , ma y be i nflicted on pr ison er s of wa r to secur e fr om th em i nfor ma tion of an y kin d wh a tever . Pr ison er s of wa r wh o r efuse to a n swer ma y n ot be th r ea ten ed, i n sulted, or ex posed to a n y un plea sa n t or di sa dva n ta geous tr ea tmen t of a n y kin d. G e ne v a C o nve nt i o n Ar t i cle 17

24



� We Do Not Tor tur e�

" It wa s li ke n oth in g. O ver h er e, killin g people is like squa sh i n g a n a n t. I mea n , you kill somebod y, a n d it's li ke, 'All r i gh t, let's go get som e pizza ,' " Army Pvt. Gre e n de scribe d s hooti ng a man who re fuse d to s top at a n Iraqi c he ck poin t

26


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

M r Sh a a th , for mer Pa lestin ia n for eign minister , sa id th a t i n a 2003 meeti n g with M r B ush , th e US pr esiden t sa id h e wa s " dr i ven wi th a mission fr om God" .

"G od wou ld te ll m e, G eorge, go and fight those terrori sts i n Af ghanistan. And I did, and t h en G od wou ld te ll m e, G eor ge, go and end the ty ranny in Ira q... And I di d. "And no w, again, I feel G od's words c om i ng to m e, G o get the Palestinians their sta te a nd get t he Israelis their sec urity , and get pea c e i n the Mi ddle East. And by G od I'm g onna do i t." Palestinian transcript of the meeting is containing a version of Mr Bush's remarks. But the Palestinian delegation was reluctant publicly to acknowledge its authenticity.

28


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

" I h a d br ough t him over to th e wa ll wh er e we wer e pr ocessi n g people a n d h e h a d been r esisitin g me th e wh ole ti me," Gr a n er said. " Wh en I put him up n ea r th e wa ll, h e h a d come ba ck on me. I push ed h im for wa r d a ga i n st th e wa ll, blood s ta r ted comin g fr om un der n ea th hi s sa n dba g.

30


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

I wa s told ea r ly th i s mor n in g th a t, perh a ps, our tr oops wer e ca ptur ed, a n d, if th er e is somebody ca ptur ed ... I ex pect (th em) to be tr ea ted h uma n ely j ust like we'r e tr ea ti n g th e pri son er s tha t we h a ve ca ptur ed h uman ely. If n ot, th e people wh o mistr ea t th e pr ison er s will be tr ea ted a s wa r cr i mi na ls G.W. B ush M arc h 2 003

32


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

You kn ow, th ese people a r e bein g fir ed a t ever y da y. I'm ta lki n g a bout people h a vin g a good time, th ese people, you ever h ea r d of emotion a l r elea se? You [ever ] h ea r d of n eed to blow some st ea m off?" Raido host R us h Limbaug h

34


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

" Th ey str i pped me of a ll my cloth es, ev en my un der wea r ," H. told CID i n vestiga tor s. " Th ey ga ve me woma n 's un der wea r th a t wa s r ose color with flower s in it, a n d th ey put th e ba g over my fa ce. O n e of th em whisper ed in my ea r , 'Toda y I a m going to fuck you,' a n d h e sa id this in Ar a bi c."

36


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

" He cuffed my h a n ds with ir on s beh in d my ba ck to th e meta l of th e wi n dow, to th e poin t my feet wer e off th e gr oun d an d I wa s h an ging th er e for a bout 5 h our s j ust beca use I a sked a bout th e time, beca use I wa n ted t o pr a y. An d th en th ey took a ll my cloth es a n d h e took th e fema le un der wea r an d h e put it over my h ea d. After h e r elea sed me fr om th e wi n dow, h e tied me to my bed un til befor e da wn ."

38


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

“ Th e Ch ri sti a n in me sa ys it’s wr on g, but th e cor r ection s offi cer i n me sa ys, I love to ma ke a gr own ma n piss h i mself” C h a rles G ra ne r

40


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

Th e use of dogs h a d been r ecommen ded two mon th s ea r li er by M a j . Gen. Geoffr ey Miller , th e for mer comma n der of th e U.S . prison fa cility a t Gua n tá n a mo B a y, a s pa r t of h i s pla n to impr ov e in ter r oga tion in Ir a q.

42


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

… Romer o h a d specifica lly given or der s to mistr ea t th e deta i n ee. " You kn ow h is wor ds wer e, 'M a ke h is life a living h ell for th e n ex t th r ee da ys,'" sa id Gr a n er ...

44


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

" We n eed common -sen se j udges wh o un der sta n d our r i gh ts wer e der i ved fr om God," G . W. B u sh as qu o te d i n th e d o o cu m e nta ry “Th e J es us fa ct o r”

46


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

Th er e wer e even mor e sh ockin g ph otogra ph s tha t th e U.S . gover n men t chose n ot to r elea se to public beca use of th e gr ea ter da ma ge th ey would sur ely h a ve don e to th e cr edi bi li ty a n d mor a l ima ge of th e U.S . milita r y an d Pr esi den t B ush ’s a dmin istr a tive comma n d. P h i li p Zi m ba rd o

48


” We Do Not Tor tur e”

S er gean t Joseph M . Dar by i s best kn own a s th e wh istle blo wer in th e Abu Gh r aib tor tur e a n d pr i son er a buse sca n da l. At th e time, Da r by w a s a U.S . Ar my Reser vist wh o ser ved a s a n M .P. a t th e Abu Gh ra i b pr i son , in Abu Gh ra ib, Ir a q. After lea r n in g of th e a buse, Da r by wa s th e fi r st per son to ta ke steps to a ler t th e U.S . milita r y comma n d. In Ja n uar y 2004 , Da r by pr ovi ded a compa ct disc of ph oto gr a ph s a n d an a n on ymous n ote to S peci a l Agen t Tyler Pi er on of th e US Ar my Cr imin a l In vestiga tion Comma n d, wh o wa s sta ti on ed a t Abu Gh r a i b Pr i son , tr igger in g a n in vestiga tion wh ich led to th e implica tion of sever a l soldi er s vi ola ti n g th e Gen eva Con ven tion . Dar by in itia lly wa n ted to r ema in a n on ymous — h e a n d th ose i mpli ca ted a ll ser ved in th e 37 2n d M ilita r y Police Compa n y, but beca me kn own a fter Dona ld Rumsfeld pu blicl y n a med h im dur in g a S en a te h ea rin g. Da r by h a d a gon i z ed for a mon th befor eh an d, but fin a lly decided to blo w th e wh istle on h i s for mer fri en ds ex pla in i n g " It viola ted ever yth in g I person a lly be lieved in a n d a ll I'd been ta ugh t a bout th e r ules of wa r ." He h a d kn own Lyn n die E n gla n d, on e of th e most well -kn own suspect s, si n ce ba si c tr a in in g. He testi fied th at h e h a d r eceived th e photos fr om Ch ar les Gr a n er , a n oth er soldier in th e ph otogr aph s.

49


� We Do Not Tor tur e�

Th e di sclosur e wa s n ot r ecei ved wel l b y th e commun ity fr om wh ich Dar by a n d his wife, B er n a dette, wer e li vi n g i n M a r yla n d. Th ey h a ve been sh unn ed by fr ien ds a n d n eigh bor s, th ei r pr oper ty h a s been va n da li z ed, a n d th ey n ow r eside in pr otective milita r y custody a t a n un di sclosed loca ti on . B ern a dette sa id, " We did n ot r eceive th e r espon se I th ough t we would. People wer e, th ey wer e mea n , sa yin g h e wa s a wa lkin g dea d ma n , h e wa s wa lkin g a r oun d wi th a bull's -eye on h i s h ea d. It wa s sca r y." O n th e oth er h a n d, CBS r epor ts th a t for mer n eigh bor s fr om on e of his ch ildh ood homes i n Pen n sylva n i a wer e proud of h i m. Dar by h a s a lso sa id tha t soldier s in h is unit sh ook h is h a n d a fte r wa r d. O n M a y 7 , 2004 , Da r by wa s pr ofi led a s th e " Per son of th e Week" by a n ch or Peter Jen n i n gs on AB C's Wor ld New s Ton igh t, a n d in December 2004 , h e wa s sele cted a s on e of th r ee AB C News " People of th e Yea r " . He wa s pr ofiled a n d in ter viewed by An der son Cooper on th e December 10, 2006 br oa dca st of 60 M in utes (th e segmen t wa s a ir ed a ga in on Jun e 24 , 2007 ). Da r by r ecei ved a Joh n F. Kenn edy Pr ofile in Coura ge Awa r d on M a y 16, 2005, in r ecogn i ti on of h i s coura ge i n ex posin g th e a buses a t Abu Gh r aib. S ource : Wikipe dia

50


Lennart Grebelius 2007 and 2010


Sources: www.wikipedia.org www.cnn.com www.guardian.co.uk www.ap.org www.usatoday.com http://judicial-inc.biz/ http://www.thememoryhole.org/ http://www.conspiracyplanet.com/ Philip Zimbardo, The Lucifer Effect


“We Do Not Torture” 2010 Lennart Grebelius Published by Sätila Förvaltning AB, Västra Hamngatan 9, 411 17 Göteborg, Sweden ISBN 978-91-86495-20-6

Cop yl e ft, n o ri ght s re serv e d.


We Do Not Torture  

” The United States is committed to the worldwide elimination of torture and we are leading this fight by example.” George W. Bush 2003

Read more
Read more
Similar to
Popular now
Just for you