Nickel Belt News
Volume 56 Number 9
Friday, March 4, 2016
Thompson, Manitoba
Serving the Norman Region since 1961
Providing you with expert advice & friendly service. Book online at speedyglass.ca or try our free app on your iPhone
We look forward to serving you. Ϳͷ-A Kelsey Bay Thompson, MB R;N ͷS Ph: Ͷͺ-ͽͽ;-ͽͶͺ; Fax: Ͷͺ-ͽͽ;-ͽͷͺ
Lynn Lake Winter Carnival
Nickel Belt News photo courtesy of James Lindsay Myran Cook competes in the Lynn Lake Winter Carnival fire building competition. See related story and photos on Page 6.
Police shooting death inquest that made no recommendation condones ‘killing an Indian,’ says God’s Lake chief BY IAN GRAHAM EDITOR@THOMPSONCITIZEN.NET
The judge presiding over a Fatality Inquiries Act inquest into the death of Paul Duck of God’s Lake Narrows, who was shot by RCMP in March 2011, made no recommendations to help prevent such deaths in the future, a decision that doesn’t sit well with Duck’s family or the chief and council of the remote Northern Manitoba First Nation. God’s Lake First Nation Chief Gilbert Andrews said March 1 that the judge’s decision condoned the killing of “Indians.” Duck was shot in the arm and the leg by RCMP Const. Shawn Steele on March 15, 2011. Steele and fellow RCMP Const. Adam Harmes were guarding the scene of a house fire that had killed 73-yearold Demus James, three-year-old Kayleigh Okemow and two-year-old Throne Kirkness the previous day.
The shot that hit Duck’s arm – one of three fired by Steele after Duck did not obey a command to drop the shotgun he was carrying – severed his brachial artery, which is the main blood vessel supplying blood to the arm and is similar in size to the carotid artery on the neck. Although the nurse on duty at the God’s Lake Narrows nursing station had experience dealing with gunshot wounds as a nurse in Los Angeles, the doctor who conducted the autopsy concluded that, given the distance from a hospital with surgeons and resuscitative equipment, it was extremely unlikely that Duck could have survived his injury. Duck was not impaired by alcohol or drugs at the time of the shooting, but had been chasing a group of youth who had been vandalizing his sister’s home and had fired three shots from his shotgun in the air prior to approaching police. His gun was not loaded when he was shot.
An independent investigation was conducted by a Saskatoon police officer, whose report was reviewed by an Ontario Crown prosecutor, who recommended that no charges be laid against Steele. “There is nothing, in my view, that can be recommended to prevent similar deaths from occurring in the future,” wrote Judge Murray Thompson in his inquest report, which was released Feb. 23. “Our members still question if this tragedy was motivated by racism; not valuing the life of an Indian or is it that officers who come to our communities are genuinely scared of our people and are too quick to use excessive force?” said Andrews in a press release. “When the judiciary said, ‘there is nothing, in my view, that can be recommended to prevent similar deaths from occurring in the future,’ it leaves us with apprehension that this kind of behaviour [to kill an Indian] is condoned
by the justice system and for us to fear the actions of the RCMP in the future.” Tom Duck, the brother of the man killed by police, said in the same press release that the inquest and the way information was released make it difficult for Paul Duck’s family to move on. “The family is not pleased the inquiry report was released without any notice to the family,” said Tom Duck. “We found out through media the judge had no recommendations. Our family is still looking for closure, we still have a lot of unanswered questions and we can’t stress enough that this travesty could have been avoided if the officer had not been so fearful during the line of duty and too quick to use his revolver. To believe my brother died needlessly because the value of life did not take precedence by the officers involved is beyond my understanding. His wife and children are still grieving.”
CALL TO BOOK YOUR DENTIST APPOINTMENT! We offer:
Professional Whitening System
Dr. Dina welcomes new patients!
OPEN 8 am - 7 pm Monday - Saturday
204-778-7000
LOCATED IN THOMPSON ACROSS THE STREET FROM BOSTON PIZZA WALK-INS WELCOME! GUARANTEED TO BE SEEN SAME DAY! AFTER HOUR EMERGENCY CARE AVAILABLE!