Transition strategies for sustainable community systems design and systems perspectives amar kjr nay

Page 1


Transition Strategies for Sustainable Community Systems Design and Systems Perspectives Amar Kjr Nayak

Visit to download the full and correct content document: https://textbookfull.com/product/transition-strategies-for-sustainable-community-syste ms-design-and-systems-perspectives-amar-kjr-nayak/

More products digital (pdf, epub, mobi) instant download maybe you interests ...

Advanced Biopolymeric Systems for Drug Delivery Amit

Kumar Nayak (Editor)

https://textbookfull.com/product/advanced-biopolymeric-systemsfor-drug-delivery-amit-kumar-nayak-editor/

Advanced Intelligent Systems for Sustainable Development AI2SD 2019 Volume 6 Advanced Intelligent Systems for Networks and Systems Mostafa Ezziyyani

https://textbookfull.com/product/advanced-intelligent-systemsfor-sustainable-development-ai2sd-2019-volume-6-advancedintelligent-systems-for-networks-and-systems-mostafa-ezziyyani/

Frontend Architecture for Design Systems A Modern Blueprint for Scalable and Sustainable Websites 1st Edition Micah Godbolt

https://textbookfull.com/product/frontend-architecture-fordesign-systems-a-modern-blueprint-for-scalable-and-sustainablewebsites-1st-edition-micah-godbolt/

Observer Design for Nonlinear Systems Pauline Bernard

https://textbookfull.com/product/observer-design-for-nonlinearsystems-pauline-bernard/

Advanced Intelligent Systems for Sustainable Development

AI2SD 2019 Volume 2 Advanced Intelligent Systems for Sustainable Development Applied to Agriculture and Health Mostafa Ezziyyani

https://textbookfull.com/product/advanced-intelligent-systemsfor-sustainable-development-ai2sd-2019-volume-2-advancedintelligent-systems-for-sustainable-development-applied-toagriculture-and-health-mostafa-ezziyyani/

Advanced Intelligent Systems for Sustainable Development

AI2SD 2018 Volume 5 Advanced Intelligent Systems for Computing Sciences Mostafa Ezziyyani

https://textbookfull.com/product/advanced-intelligent-systemsfor-sustainable-development-ai2sd-2018-volume-5-advancedintelligent-systems-for-computing-sciences-mostafa-ezziyyani/

Computational Intelligence and Sustainable Systems Intelligence and Sustainable Computing H. Anandakumar

https://textbookfull.com/product/computational-intelligence-andsustainable-systems-intelligence-and-sustainable-computing-hanandakumar/

Control Strategies for Advanced Driver Assistance Systems and Autonomous Driving Functions Harald Waschl

https://textbookfull.com/product/control-strategies-for-advanceddriver-assistance-systems-and-autonomous-driving-functionsharald-waschl/

Proceedings of IDEAS 2019: The Interdisciplinary Conference on Innovation, Design, Entrepreneurship, And Sustainable Systems

Luciana Pereira

https://textbookfull.com/product/proceedings-of-ideas-2019-theinterdisciplinary-conference-on-innovation-designentrepreneurship-and-sustainable-systems-luciana-pereira/

Transition Strategies for Sustainable Community Systems

Design and Systems Perspectives

TheAnthropocene:Politik—Economics

Society—Science

Volume26

Serieseditor

HansGünterBrauch,Mosbach,Germany

Moreinformationaboutthisseriesat http://www.springer.com/series/15232 http://www.afes-press-books.de/html/APESS.htm http://www.afes-press-books.de/html/APESS_26.htm

AmarK.J.R.Nayak Editor

TransitionStrategies forSustainableCommunity Systems

DesignandSystemsPerspectives

Editor AmarK.J.R.Nayak

ProfessorofStrategicManagement

XavierInstituteofManagement

XavierUniversityBhubaneswar Bhubaneswar,India

Moreonthisbookisat: http://www.afes-press-books.de/html/APESS_26.htm

ISSN2367-4024ISSN2367-4032(electronic)

TheAnthropocene:Politik Economics Society Science ISBN978-3-030-00355-5ISBN978-3-030-00356-2(eBook) https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-00356-2

LibraryofCongressControlNumber:2018963843

© SpringerNatureSwitzerlandAG2019

Thisworkissubjecttocopyright.AllrightsarereservedbythePublisher,whetherthewholeorpart ofthematerialisconcerned,specificallytherightsoftranslation,reprinting,reuseofillustrations, recitation,broadcasting,reproductiononmicrofilmsorinanyotherphysicalway,andtransmission orinformationstorageandretrieval,electronicadaptation,computersoftware,orbysimilarordissimilar methodologynowknownorhereafterdeveloped.

Theuseofgeneraldescriptivenames,registerednames,trademarks,servicemarks,etc.inthis publicationdoesnotimply,evenintheabsenceofaspecificstatement,thatsuchnamesareexemptfrom therelevantprotectivelawsandregulationsandthereforefreeforgeneraluse.

Thepublisher,theauthors,andtheeditorsaresafetoassumethattheadviceandinformationinthis bookarebelievedtobetrueandaccurateatthedateofpublication.Neitherthepublishernorthe authorsortheeditorsgiveawarranty,expressorimplied,withrespecttothematerialcontainedhereinor foranyerrorsoromissionsthatmayhavebeenmade.Thepublisherremainsneutralwithregardto jurisdictionalclaimsinpublishedmapsandinstitutionalaffiliations.

SeriesEditor:PDDr.HansGünterBrauch,AFES-PRESSe.V.,Mosbach,Germany

EnglishLanguageEditor:Dr.VanessaGreatorex,Chester,UK

TheimageinthecoverpageisbasedontheTSSCSFramework,Bhubaneswar,India.Theimagehas beendevelopedbytheEditorandpermissionhasbeenreceivedforittobeusedhere

ThisSpringerimprintispublishedbytheregisteredcompanySpringerNatureSwitzerlandAG Theregisteredcompanyaddressis:Gewerbestrasse11,6330Cham,Switzerland

Foreword

Thisbook,onTransitionStrategiesforSustainableCommunitySystems(TSSCS) andtheTSSCSSymposiumitamplifiestoalargeraudience,representsapowerful androbustspinningtogether,byhundredsofpeople,of fivevibrantstrands(called heredimensionsorthemes)ofthinkingandaction,thebettertoexploreandachieve SustainableCommunitySystemsinruralIndia.Wehaveallbeensogreatlyenrichedbyparticipatinginthisspinning,publicly,forthepastfouryears,thatIam humbledandhonouredtoofferabriefForewordattheinvitationoftheNational ApexBankforAgriculturalandRuralDevelopment(NABARD)ChairUnitat XavierUniversityBhubaneswar,Odisha,India,andgratefultoitsacademicand organisingpartnersconvenedbyProf.AmarK.J.R.Nayakandhisteammates.

Athirty-three-yearcareerintheUNFoodandAgricultureOrganisation(FAO), duringeachyearofwhichIworkedinagricultural fieldsandcommunities(mostly ricepaddiesandtheirvillages)inIndia,emboldenmetoofferspotlightsonavery fewcomparativeinternationalexamplesthatcouldbenefitfromthethreadspun togetherinthiscollectivework.Duringthesefouryears,mostofTSSCS ’ collaborativeworkdrewoutstrandsfromsustainableagriculturalsystems,organisations, governanceandinstitutions,eachofwhichcouldreflectmoreorlessautonomous unitsinFAO,includingmyearlierhomeDivision:PlantProductionandProtection. IthasbeenrefreshingthattheTSSCS’ workstyleandvalueshavevigorouslyand relentlesslypuncturedtheintellectualandmanagerial/bureaucraticwallsisolating thesestrandsordimensions,enablingallofustolistenbettertoeachother.For thesefourstrands,andthesectionsofthebooktheycomprise,thisactivedemolitionofconventionalprofessionalsilosorstrongholdshasstrengthenedand deepenedthediscussionsandreflectiveanalysesthereaderswilljoin.

Afterhearing,readingandreflectingonnearlyallthepapers,however,Ichoose tofocusthisForewordonthe fifthdimensionorstrand,foundatthecoreofthe “mandala”.TheTSSCS’ initiativeuniquelysetsandkeepsatthecentrethisstrand: Relationships.Theexemplaryattractivevariableinthisdimensionis trust.Four decadesofinternationalexperienceofvillage-levelorganisations,institutionsand governanceconvincemethattrustisalwaysnecessaryforasuccessfultransitionto sustainedcommunitysystems.Onlytrust within thecommunitywillprotectnew

institutionsandorganisations.Trustiscertainlyatruismoftheliteraturefrom management “gurus” to(notso) “new” institutionaleconomics.Butitisevenmore essentialinthelifeordeathoflocalcommunitysystems.Itisoneoftheveryfew necessaryvariablestoconfrontanddisassembleinequality,whichotherwisegrows withoutlimitinthepresenttime.Trustisnecessaryforruralhouseholdstokeep togetherthevitalrelationshipsamongfamilies,acrosscastes,classes,gendersand ages,evenwhenunderpressurefrom “natural” disasters,warsorcivilunrest,and “boomandbust” pricecyclesandenvironmentalovershootsdrivenbymarket forces.Ihumblysubmitthatamajormethodologicalkeytothegrowingsuccess oftheTSSCS’ approachcanbestbeseeninhowthecollaboratorskeeptrust and itsfellowrelationshipneighbourslikefaith,morals,ethics,belief,interdependence andidentifyingoneselfwithothers aliveandpresentinsomanyformaldiscussionsandinformalconversationsostensiblystartedaboutfarmerproducerorganisations,PanchayatiRajinstitutions,women’sself-helpgroups,orsoilsand moisture.

MoralRice,DharmaGardenTempleandBuddhistEco-spiritualityinYasothon Province,North-EastThailand.

Thisexplorationdemonstrateshowstrongerandhealthierrelationshipscanincrease benefitsamongruralAsianvillagersgrowingthesamecropsforthesamerangeof localtonationaltoglobalconsumersinthesameproductionecosystems.Yasothon ProvinceispartoftheIsanregioninnorth-eastThailandontheLao–Thai–Cambodianborder.Thecriticalcomparativestudy(KaufmanandMock2014) demonstratedthataBuddhisttemple-basedgroupoforganicricefarmersheld deeperBuddhisteco-spiritualvaluesthananon-profi t,butnon-temple-basedgroup oforganicfarmersinthesamevillageswhoretainedamorecommercialworld view.Bothgroupshadaccesstogovernment-sponsoredsubsidiesthatencouraged themtoplantorganicricecrops,includingorganicallycerti fiablefertiliser.

Whileyieldsandincomesdidnotdiffersignifi cantly,theBuddhisttemplegroup hadastatisticallysignificantlyhigherpercentageofmembers,however,who eliminatedtheirdebts afterbecomingmorespiritualaswellasadoptingmore organicmethodsoffarming.Asigni ficantlyhigherproportionoftheBuddhist templegroupalsoperceivedthattheirphysicalhealthimprovedastheycontinued topractiseorganicagriculture;themoredebtfarmershadtocarry,thelesshealthy theyfelt.TheBuddhisttemplegroupmemberseliminatedtheuseofagrochemicals, usedorganicfertilisers,atemostlyorexclusivelyorganicfoodandfoundincreased biodiversityontheirfarms.Whentheglobalpriceof(non-organic)ricespikedin 2009,alargerproportionofnon-temple-basedorganicricefarmersabandonedtheir organiccropsandsimplygrewasecondconventionalcropofricetotakeadvantage ofthatpriceincrease.

ThecontextforthiscomparisongrewoutofThailand’sreligioustraditions, startingwithlocalanimistrelationshipswithsacredgrovesortrees,andwildanimalssuchaspropitiatingtheRiceSoul,theRiceMother,theEarthMotherandthe RiverMother,allreinforcingtheroleofriceasalive-givingforce.Theravada BuddhismspreadfromSriLankaandhasbeenpractisedinThailandsincethesixth

toninthcenturiesCE,i.e.overfor1,200–1,500years.Thecoreprinciples emphasisedinTheravadaare(I)the fivepreceptsofthePalicanon:1 nottokill; 2 nottosteal;3 nottoengageinsexualmisconduct;4 nottolie;and5 notto consumeintoxicants;(II)theEightfoldPath;(III)DependentOrigination (Paticcasamuppada)and(IV)theLawofKarma(connectedwithIII)(Kaufman 2012).

TheGreenRevolutionarrivedinthe1970s;mostCentralThailandricefarmers adoptedseeds,inorganicfertiliserandagrochemicals.Privatecorporatediscounts andbonusestogetherwithgovernmentsubsidiesincreasedtheratesofadoption oftheGreenRevolutionalongwithabandoningtraditionalpracticesbasedonlocal ecologicalandtechnicalknowledge.Smallenclavesoffarmers,includingthose affectedbyamplifi edpriceswings,drewuponthelocalBuddhistandsyncretic animisttraditionsandexploredmarketopportunitiesfororganicriceandother products.WhenThailandwasseverelyhitbytheexchange-ratecrisisof1998,the government,whichhaduntilthensupportedGreenRevolutionpractices,beganto encourageorganicproduction.

ManyfarmersintheIsanregion,alreadyatlowerincomelevelsthanCentral Thairicebowlfarmers,exploredorganicproductiontoreduceprice fluctuation-drivenrisks.TheKing,HMKBhumibolorHMKRamaIX,encouraged anationalsufficiencyeconomytoreducethecostsofproduction,andreinforced traditionalvenerationofricespiritsandlocalanimisttraditions.Monksintempleor monasterycommunitiesemphasisedtheecologicaldimensionsofTheravada Buddhistspirituality.Charismaticindividualmonksandpriestsbuiltfollowingsthat includedlaypersons.Asinmanyeconomicallypoorerruralvillages,mentendedto seekemploymentinlargercities.Women,youngpeopleandoldermenbecamethe largestproportionoffarmoperators.Thesefarmersjoinedandbecamemoreactive invillage-levelorganisations,suchastheDharmaGardenTemple’s “MoralRice” network.FarmerswhodidnotshareasdeepacommitmenttoBuddhist eco-spiritualityoftenjoinedmarketingcollectivesthatprovidedcheaperinputsbut withoutthehighlevelofsolidarityofthetemple-basedgroup.Bothtypesofgroup memberhadaccesstolocal,nationalandinternationalmarkets,asThailandis traditionallyamongthehighestrice-exportingcountries,andpeoplearoundthe worldarefamiliarwithThairice.ThisishowthecomparisonbetweendemographicallysimilargroupswhoshowedhigherandlowerdegreesofBuddhist devotionemerged.Thecomparisonrevealedoneoftheclearestexamplesofhow twenty- first-centuryfamilyfarmersinaglobaleconomybecomemoreresilientin economicandhealthtermsthroughstrongerrelationshipsprovidedbyareligious organisation.

MysecondexplorationstartsfromChap. 8 intheRelationshipssection,by Prof.PraveenKumar,on Paticcasamuppada,orDependentOrigination,already mentionedasacorebeliefofBuddhism.Thestrongconnectionsbetweenmorethan twoactionsorthoughts,oreconomicinstitutions,meanthatpeoplehavethepower tochangetheirsituations,theirposition,toanewanddifferentoutcome,arising fromtheiractions,becausetheyacteddifferently,indeeperunderstandingofthe multipleforcesactingoneachother.ProfessorP.Kumargivesanespeciallyvivid

metaphoroftheoriginationofgreed asapassionforeatingtheearththatgrows outofcontroluntilitdestroysrelationshipsand,ultimately,theenvironment.

Thismetaphorechoesafamousparagraphwrittenover60yearsagobythe economichistorianProf.KarlPolanyi.Itisfoundin TheGreatTransformation, Polanyi’smasterpieceonthe “politicalandeconomicoriginsofourtime”.This subtitleclearlyechoeshisexplorationinadirectionparalleling Paticcasamuppada, tounderstandmultipleinterdependentoriginations.Theparagraphexaminesthe impactoftheexplodingscopeandpowerofmarketsonnaturalresources(inthis case,soil)andpeople.

… leavingthefateofsoilandpeopletothemarketwouldbetantamounttoannihilating them.Accordingly,thecountermoveconsistedincheckingtheactionofthemarketin respecttothefactorsofproduction,labor,andland.Thiswasthemainfunctionofintervention(Polanyi1957,p.131).

TwomorerecentscholarsofBuddhism,whoeachwentontohavelongacademiccareersandpublishedanumberofbooksandhundredsofarticles,choseto writetheirPh.D.dissertations(eachofwhichthenbecameabook)onphilosophical interpretationsofcausalityinBuddhism,concentratingon Paticcasamuppada. ProfessorDavidKalupahanawasfromSriLanka,studiedthereandatthe UniversityofLondon,thenbecametheChairofthePhilosophyDepartmentand SeniorProfessorofBuddhismattheUniversityofHawaii.Hefocused,including withgrammaticalanalysis,ontheearliestBuddhisttexts,mostlyinPali,andsought todemystifytheconceptofincarnationscarryingthesinsofearlierlives,replacing itwithinterdependentoriginationduringthecurrentlife.Inlaterpublications,he pointedoutnumerousparallelsbetween Paticcasamuppada inBuddhistcausality withthepositionofAmericanpragmatism,especiallyofWilliamJames, C.S.PeirceandlaterJohnDewey.Thepositionofthatgroupofphilosopherswas thatpeoplearefullypartoftheenvironmentaroundthem,sothattheperceptions andresponsesbyapersontotheworldarecreatedtogetherwithallotherpeople whointeractwiththatperson.

ProfessorJoannaMacy,whoisstillpublishingasemeritaprofessor,alsolooked intoearlyPaliwritings,butthenfocusedherdissertation,whichwasalsoabout Buddhistcausality,onparallelswiththeGeneralSystemsTheoryshehadstudied withProfessorErvinLaszlo.GeneralSystemsTheoryevolvedincloseassociation withbiology,bothphysiologyandecology.ProfessorMacywentontopublish extensivelyonsystemsapproachestomindfulactioninthemodern,including twenty- firstcentury,worldfromBuddhistanddeepecologyperspectives. Boththesescholarsprovidedpathsforustoexploreapplicationsof Paticcasamuppada.

A finalexplorationandinspirationcomesfromtheworkofDr.B.R.Ambedkar. Dr.Ambedkarapplied Paticcasamuppada tounderpinhisargumentagainstthe existenceofanomnipotentGodaspartoftheBuddha’sDharma(Book3,PartIV, Section2,paragraphs50–58,of TheBuddhaandHisDharma). Paticcasamuppada providesacoherentlogicandapplicabletoolstoanalysecausesinordertoleadtoa pathofaction.Amongmanyotherinstances,Dr.Ambedkarappliedand

acknowledgedtheAmericanpragmatistphilosopher,Prof.JohnDeweyof ColumbiaUniversity,inhisclassic(andundelivered)lectureon Annihilationof Caste (1936,reprinted2016;Chap.25,Sect.25.4,p.313):

Secondly,theHindusmustconsiderwhethertheyshouldconservethewholeoftheirsocial heritage,orselectwhatishelpfulandtransmittofuturegenerationsonlythatmuchandno more.ProfJohnDewey,whowasmyteacherandtowhomIowesomuch,hassaid:

‘Everysocietygetsencumberedwithwhatistrivial,withdeadwoodfromthepast,and withwhatispositivelyperverse Asasocietybecomesmoreenlightened,itrealizesthatit isresponsiblenottoconserveandtransmitthewholeofitsexistingachievements,butonly suchasmakeforabetterfuturesociety.’

IhopetheseexplorationsindicatethepotentialrangeandpowerthattheTSSCS approach,centredaroundrelationshipsbutinterrogatingandapplyingtheotherfour strands,contributedeeplytoinvestigatingpracticalquestionsontransitionsto sustainablecommunitysystems.

PeterKenmore FAO-UN,California,USA

References

Ambedkar,B.R.(BhimraoRamji).2016. TheAnnihilationofCaste:Theannotatedcritical edition/editedandannotatedbyS.Anand.LondonandNewYork:Verso. Ambedkar,B.R.(BhimraoRamji).2006. TheBuddhaandHisDharma.Delhi:SiddarthBooks. Falvey,JohnL.2000. ThaiAgriculture:GoldenCradleofMillennia.Bangkhen:Thailand. KaesesartUniversityPress. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/236694126_Thai_ Agriculture_Golden_Cradle_of_Millennia .(30November2016).

Kalupahana,DavidJ.1989.Towardamiddlepathofsurvival,inCallicott,J.Bairdand RogerT.Ames,eds.1989. NatureinAsianTraditionsofThought:EssaysinEnvironmental Philosophy.Albany:StateUniversityofNewYorkPresspp.247–256. Kalupahana,DavidJ.1975. Causality:TheCentralPhilosophyofBuddhism.Honolulu: UniversityPressofHawaii. Kaufman,AlexanderH.2012.Organicfarmers’ connectednesswithnature:ExploringThailand’s alternativeagriculturenetwork. Worldviews:GlobalReligions,Culture,andEcology,Volume 16,Issue2,pp.154–178.

Kaufman,AlexanderH.;JeremiahMock2014.Cultivatinggreaterwell-being:ThebenefitsThai organicfarmersexperiencefromadoptingBuddhisteco-spirituality. JournalofAgricultural andEnvironmentalEthics.December2014,Volume27,Issue6,pp.871–893.

Kaufman,Alexander;NikomPetpha.2016.Moralricenetwork,DharmaGardentemple,Yasothon province,NortheastThailand,inLoconto,inA.,Poisot,A.S.&Santacoloma,P.(eds.), InnovativeMarketsforSustainableAgriculture HowInnovationsinMarketInstitutions EncourageSustainableAgricultureinDevelopingCountries.Rome:FAO/INRA.pp.181–199 (Chapter10).

Kumar,Praveen.Inpress. Paticcasamuppada(TheTheoryofDependentOrigination):AScientific MeansofChangingPerson.Thepresentvolume,Chapter8.

Macy,Joanna.1991. MutualCausalityinBuddhismandGeneralSystemsTheory:TheDharmaof NaturalSystems.Albany:StateUniversityofNewYorkPress.

Nayak,AmarK.J.R.2019. TransitionChallengesandPathwaystoSustainableCommunity Systems:DesignandSystemsPerspectives.Thepresentvolume,Chapter1. Polanyi,Karl.1957. TheGreatTransformation.Boston:BeaconPress.

Preface

Therehasbeenincreasingrealisationthatthemainstreamlogicofeconomicgrowth anddevelopmentisinjeopardyandnotsustainable.Thekeypillarsoftheeconomy, environmentandsocietyhavegraduallydriftedawayfromtheirnaturalprinciples andvaluesandhaveweakened,makingcommunitiesandsocietiesunstable,vulnerableandunsustainable.

Whiletheintentionofmanyofourinitiativestowardseconomicgrowthand sustainability whetherinproductionsystems,producerorganisations,community governanceorinstitutions mayhavebeennoble,inconsistenciesbetweenthe intentionandapproaches,methods,tools,techniquesandactionsoftenmakethese initiativesunsustainableovertime.Theinherenttechnicalinconsistenciesand tensionsinthedesigns,andlackofsynergyacrossdifferentsub-systems,perpetuate lock-ineffectsandgreaterexternalcontrolthanfreedom.

Inthelightoftheaboveimpending/socio-economic–environmentalcrisis,this bookisanefforttodiscussthepossibletransitionstrategiesandpathwaystowards facilitatingSustainableCommunitySystems.Itpresentstheoretical,practicaland policyperspectivesandempiricalevidencesofthekeydimensionsofanycommunity systems:relationships,institutions,production,organisationandgovernance.

Thejourneytowardsthisexplorationbeganaround2005,whenIhad finished mydoctoralstudiesonforeigndirectinvestmentstrategiesofsomeofthemost successfulmultinationalcorporationsandhadbegunanextensivestudyonthe explosivegrowthstrategiesoflargeIndianmultinationalenterprises.Subsequently, threeinternationaleditionsofmybookson ForeignMultinationalsinIndia, Indian Multinationals and IndiaintheEmergingGlobalOrder werepublished.My coursesonInternationalBusinessandStrategicManagementofIndian MultinationalsweredoingverywellwiththestudentsofamajorbusinessmanagementschoolinIndia.

However,mypasttwentyyearsofengineeringandmanagementstudies, experienceofworkingwithlargecorporationsandscholarshiponglobalisationand foreigndirectinvestmentinIndiaandJapan,priorto2005,hadraisedseveral queriesanddoubtsinmymindastowhetherthemainstreamtheory,policyand practicewouldstandthetestoftimefromasustainabilitypointofview.

Iwonderedwhethertheverydesignoflargecorporationsthathelpedthese fi rms togrowwasattherootcauseofunsustainabilityofcommunitiesandsocietyat large.ThisinnervoiceofdissentregardingwhatIwastaughtandwasteaching successfullyledmetoformulateanactionresearchprojectondevelopingorganisationaldesignforsustainablecommunityenterprisesystems.

Thissmallactionresearchprojectwasinitiatedinaremoteandneglectedtribal communityinOdisha,India,in2007,usingmyownlimitedpersonalsavings.It subsequentlyreceivedtheattentionofdevelopmentagencieslikeNABARDand RabobankFoundationthatsupportedtheactionresearch.Thisstudywasgradually complementedwithotherrelatedstudiesbyseveralotherorganisations.The interestingandsurprisingoutputsofthesestudiesledtoaseriesofseminars, workshopsandround-tablediscussionsfrom2012onwards,andaverylarge symposiuminJanuary2017.Thescholarlycontributionsofthe2017symposium and “TransitionStrategiesforSustainableCommunitySystems” formthecontents ofthisvolume.

Basedontheongoingresearchanddeliberationonthe fivekeydimensionsof sustainability,thisbookhasbeenpresentedin fiveparts,focusingonrelationships, institutions,production,organisationandgovernance.Chapter 1 providesanoverall designandsystemsperspectivesoftheabove fivedimensionsandonrespective factorsassociatedwitheachofthedimensions.Thelastchapterisasynthesisofthe valuablecontributionofallthechaptersunderdifferentdimensionsandthepossible wayforward.

Bhubaneswar,IndiaAmarK.J.R.Nayak

Acknowledgements

Thisbookhasbeenanoutcomeofanengagingsymposiumofsenioracademics, practitioners,policy-makersandyoungresearchersinsustainability.Over500 membersparticipatedindifferentforumsoveraperiodofabouttwoyears,and nearly150membersparticipatedinthethree-daysymposiuminJanuary2017. Iwishtorecordthecontributionsofallthesemembersinmakingthisbook.Its chaptersemergedfrompaperspresentedduringthethree-daysymposiumin2017. Iwouldliketoexpressmydeepgratitudetoalltheauthorsfortheirscholarly contributions.

IwouldliketoexpressmysinceregratitudetoHisExcellency,Dr.S.C.Jamir, GovernorofOdisha,Prof.V.S.Vyas,Prof.Y.K.Alagh,Prof.A.Vaidyanathan, thelateDr.PushpaM.Bhargava,Dr.PeterKenmore,Prof.K.V.Raju, Prof.G.Krishnamurthi,Mr.SubhashMehtaandProf.AnupDashfortheir scholarlyguidanceandsupport.

Severalinstitutionshavesupportedthiscause,andIwouldliketothankand recordthecontributionsoftheXavierInstituteofManagement,XavierUniversity Bhubaneswar,theNationalBankforAgricultureandRuralDevelopment,the TATATrusts,theDevelopmentManagementInstitution,Patna,theNational InstituteofAgriculturalMarketing,Jaipur,theIndianCouncilofAgricultural Research,theGovernmentofIndia,IMAGE,theGovernmentofOdisha, NISWASSBhubaneswar,andtheSustainabilityTrust,Bhubaneswar.

IrecorddeepappreciationforDr.H.K.Bhanwala,Dr.U.S.Saha, Mr.ShobhanaK.Pattanayak,Mr.R.Venkataramanan,Dr.(Mrs.)IrinaGarg, Dr.TrilochanMohapatra,ShriM.V.Ashok,Dr.K.C.Panigrahi,Mr.ManojAhuja, Dr.BimalKumarDas,Mr.JitendraNayakandMr.PradyutKumarBagfortheir financialsupportandco-operation.Igreatlyappreciate(Dr.)PaulFernandes,SJ, E.A.Augustine,SJ,(Dr.)DonaldD’Silva,SJ,(Dr.)LourdurajIgnacimuthu,SJand (Dr.)V.ArockiaDas,SJforalltheiradministrativesupportandencouragement.

IwouldliketothankmyresearchsupportteamofMr.BibhutiSahoo,Mrs. RadhaRaniRayandMrs.SunitaMishra,andmydoctoralcolleagues,Mr.Asish Panda,Mr.AmarPatnaikandMrs.UshaPadhee,fortheirvaluableandtimely

contributions.IalsothankDr.JohannaSchwarzofSpringerNatureandDr.Hans GünterBrauchofAFES-PRESS,theeditorofthisbookseries,fortheirsupportand co-operationingettingthisbookpublished.Withouttheirmeticulousandanonymousreviewprocess,thisbookcouldnothavereachedthisstandardbefore publication.

IwouldliketothankDr.HansGünterBrauch,whowasthe firsttoshowinterest inthisconferencecompilation.Heshowedgreatpatienceandcommitmenttogetit peerreviewedbeforepublication.WithouttheconsentfromDr.JohannaSchwarz ofSpringer,thisbookwouldnothavegonethroughtheprocess.Iexpressmydeep gratitudetoEnglishLanguageEditorDr.VanessaGreatorexforhelpingtomake thisbookreader-friendly.IalsothankMr.ArulmuruganVenkatapalam,theProject CoordinatorofSpringer,andhisdevotedandsuperbtechnicalteaminChennai, TamilNadu,forhisefficientcoordinationandsupport.

Bhubaneswar,IndiaAmarK.J.R.Nayak July2018 xivAcknowledgements

1Introduction:TransitionChallengesandPathwaystoSustainable

5Paticcasamuppada:TheTheoryofDependentOrigination:

7Re-envisioningDevelopmentforSustainableCommunity

PartIIInstitutions

9Strategy-DrivenInstitutionalConvergence:APolicyVista forIntegratedAgricultureDevelopment

HemnathRaoHanumankar

10ConvergenceandFlexibilityforLast-MileDelivery ofCitizen-CentricServices:ACaseStudyfromNabarangpur, Odisha ...............................................

UshaPadhee

PartIIIProduction:SustainableAgriculturalSystems

11In-SituWaterConservationonOne-HectareFarmland: AnActionResearch 121 AmarK.J.R.Nayak,TanmayKhuntiaandBirendraSuna

12Intensi ficationof Bodi-BasedFarmingforSustainable LivelihoodAssurance

ChandrakantaB.PrasanandJoshuaN.Daniel

13Farm-DiversityManagementforSustainableProduction Systems ..............................................

ArunK.Sharma

14UnderstandingLivelihoodDiversification:ACaseStudy ofMushroomFarminginBihar ...........................

SuryaBhushan,PiyushKumarSingh,SridharTelidevara andSantoshKumar

15ForestAccountingandSustainability

ParashramJ.Patil

16MoringaProductionandConsumption:AnAlternative PerspectiveforGovernmentPolicy-Making

GoutamSahaandMouSen

17CottonFarminginIndia:AlternativePerspectives andParadigms

LipsaMohapatraandGoutamSaha

18MDCMApproachtoSustainableAgricultureProduction forOdisha ............................................

BishnuPrasadMishra,BanashriRath,LaxmidharSwain andAamlanSaswatMishra

19SourcesofProductivityGrowthandLivelihoodsResilience inBiharintheRecentDecade:ADistrict-LevelNon-parametric Analysis

SuryaBhushan

Abbreviations

AKRSPAgaKhanRuralSupportProgramme

APEDAAgricultureProductsExportDevelopmentAuthority

ATMAAgricultureTechnologyManagementAgencies

BCIBetterCottonInitiative

BPLBelowPovertyLine

BRBio-physicalResilienceIndex

BRLPSBiharRuralLivelihoodsProjectSociety

BTBacillusThuringiensis

CABCottonAdvisoryBoard

CACPCommissionforAgriculturalCostsandPrices

CCSCreditCo-operativeSystem

CEDECCentreforDevelopmentEducationandCommunication

CICRCentralInstituteforCottonResearch

CLCuVCottonLeafCurlVirus

CSOCentralStatisticalOrganisation

DASDaysAfterShowing

DCFDiscountedCashFlow

DEADataEnvelopmentApproach

DESDirectorateofEconomicsandStatistics

DFIDDepartmentforInternationalDevelopment

DIMEDesign,Implementation,MonitoringandEvaluation

DPAPDroughtProneAreaProgramme

EFEcoFarming

ERIEconomicResilienceIndex

FAOFoodandAgricultureOrganisation

FGDFocusGroupDiscussions

FICCIFederationofIndianChambersofCommerceandIndustry

FPCFarmerProducerCompanies

FPOFarmerProducerOrganisations

FSRFarmingSystemResearch

FYMFarmYardManure

GMGeneticallyModifi ed

GOIGovernmentOfIndia

GOTSGlobalOrganicTextileStandard

GPGramPanchayat

GSDPGrossStateDomesticProduct

GWFGreyWaterFootprint

HDPHighDensityPlanting

HHHouseholds

HRIHealthResilienceIndex

IADInstitutionalAnalysisandDesign

IARCInternationalAgencyforResearchonCancer

IARIIndianAgriculturalResearchInstitute

ICACInternationalCottonAdvisoryCommittee

ICARIndianCouncilofAgricultureResearch

IITIndianInstituteofTechnology

IRDPIntegratedRuralDevelopmentProgramme

IRMAInstituteofRuralManagement

ISOTIndianStandardforOrganicTextiles

ITDAIntegratedTribalDevelopmentAuthority

IWCInsituWaterConservation

JASJapaneseAgriculturalStandard

KVICKhadiandVillageIndustriesCommission

KVKKrishiVigyanKendras

KVSKisanVikasSamiti

LDLLow-DensityLipoprotein

LPLinearProgramming

LRILivelihoodsResilienceIndex

MANAGENationalInstituteofAgricultureExtensionManagement

MCDMMultipleCriteriaDecision-Making

MDGMillenniumDevelopmentGoals

MGNREGSMahatmaGandhiNationalRuralEmploymentGuaranteeScheme

MPIMultidimensionalPovertyIndex

MPWPCLMadhyaPradeshWomenPoultryProducersCompanyLtd

MSPMinimumSupportPrice

NABARDNationalApexBankforAgriculturalandRuralDevelopment

NAIPNationalAgriculturalInnovationProject

NAISNationalAgriculturalInnovationSystem

NARSNationalAgriculturalResearchSystem

NCDCNationalCo-operativeDevelopmentCorporation

NCFNationalCommissionforFarmers

NDCNationalDevelopmentCouncil

NDDBNationalDairyDevelopmentBoard

NFDBNationalFisheriesDevelopmentBoard

NHBNationalHorticultureBoard

NISWASSNationalInstituteofSocialWorkandSocialSciences

NOPNationalOrganicProgram

NRANaturalResourceAccounting

NSSONationalSampleSurveyofOrganisation

OBCOtherBackwardClasses

OCSOrganicContentStandard

ODFOpenDefecationFree

OLSOrdinaryLeastSquares

OUATOrissaUniversityofAgricultureandTechnology

PANPesticideActionNetwork

PINProfessionalInstitutionalNetwork

POProducerOrganisations

PRAParticipatoryRuralAppraisal

PRIPanchayatiRajInstitutions

RCPRealCostofProduction

RRARapidRuralAppraisal

RWHRainWaterHarvesting

SADAStateAgriculturalDevelopmentAgency

SAUStateAgricultureUniversities

SCScheduledCaste

SDGSustainableDevelopmentGoal

SEEASystemofEnvironmentalEconomicAccounting

SFAStochasticFrontierApproach

SFACSmallFarmersAgribusinessConsortium

SFDASmallFarmerDevelopmentAuthority

SGSYSwarnajayantiGramSwarozgarYojana

SHGSelf-helpGroups

SISimpsonIndex

SLASustainableLivelihoodsApproach

SLFSustainableLivelihoodsFramework

SMARTSpeci fic,Measurable,Attainable,RealisticandTime-bound

SNASystemsofNationalAccounts

SRISystemRootIntensification

SRISocialResilienceIndex

SSESocialandSolidarityEconomy

TFPTotalFactorProductivity

TLCTotalLiteracyCampaign

TSCTotalSanitationCampaign

TUATankUsersAssociations

USDAUnitedStatesDepartmentofAgriculture

VOCVolatileOrganicCarbons

WHOWorldHealthOrganisation

WHSWaterHarvestingStructures

ListofFigures

Fig.1.1Transitionstrategiesforsustainablecommunitysystems. Source Theauthor,28October2016;www.xub.edu.in/ NABARD-Chair/activites.html 5

Fig.1.2Spectrumofdimensionsandfactorsforoptimisinginternal designsandsystemsconsistency. Source Nayak(2017) 8

Fig.9.1Sectorvaluechainforagriculture. Source Theauthor 108

Fig.9.2SuggestedstructureforSADAgoverningboard. Source Theauthor ......................................... 108

Fig.10.1Lifecyclewelfaremodelofahousehold. Source Author ’s conceptualisation ..................................... 115

Fig.10.2ConvergencestrategyinaGramPanchayat. Source Author ’s conceptualisation ..................................... 116

Fig.11.1Basictechniqueusedforin-situwaterconservation. Source Theauthors ................................... 127

Fig.12.1Appearanceofa bodi duringdifferentseasonsoftheyear: a summer; b rainyseason; c post-rainyseason; d winter. Source Photobyauthor,ChandrakantaBaradaPrasan 137

Fig.12.2Shedsconstructedforducksandpoultryin bodi-based farming. Source Photobytheauthor,Chandrakanta BaradaPrasan 138

Fig.14.1Constraintstomushroomcultivation. Source Author estimationbasedonfocusgroupdiscussionswithcultivators inthethreevillagesparticipatinginthestudy 162

Fig.14.2AverageIncomevis-à-visExtentofDiversi fi cation. Source Authorestimation 164

Fig.17.1Inputcostversusincome. Compiledby:Theauthors 199 Fig.17.2Profitsearned. Compiledby:Theauthors .................. 199

Fig.17.3Theviciouscycleoflifeanddeath – magiccottonseeds ...... 205

Fig.19.1Percapitaincomeandstructuraldecompositionofnetstate domesticproductatconstantprices2004–05(inRs.). Source CompiledfromEconomicSurvey,Bihar,2015–16:5–6 ....... 233

Fig.19.2NationalandeasternregionalTFPgrowthrateindexes, 1980–2008. Source CompiledfromRada(2013) ............ 234

Fig.19.3Averageresourceintensityvis-à-visagriculturaloutput perhectareacrossdistrictsfor2000–2010. Source Author ’s calculation.......................................... 238

Fig.19.4TemporaldecompositionofagricultureTFPinBiharduring 2001–2012. Source Author ’scalculation 241

Fig.19.5LRIanditscomponentsforthetopandbottomsixdistricts. Source Author ’sCalculation

Fig.19.6LRIandTFPindicesatthedistrictlevel. Source Author ’s Calculation

Fig.20.1Conceptualframeworkforsustainableperformance. Source Panda/Nayak(2017) 255

Fig.21.1Activitydiagram. Source Author ’sconceptualisation 266

Fig.22.1Thiscarneedsallfourwheelstorun. Source Visualised bytheAuthor .......................................

ListofTables

Table11.1Rainfalldata

Table11.2Waterextractedfromthefarmwell

Table12.1Economicsof bodi-basedfarmingsysteminthe firstyear

Table13.1Ideologicaldifferencesbetweenecofarming andconventionalfarming

Table14.1Productioneconomics

Table14.2Mushroomproductinnovation

Table14.3Leveloflivelihooddiversi ficationandpercapitaincome

Table14.4Determinantsoflivelihooddiversi fi

Table16.1AfewMoringapowderproducingorganisations

Table18.1Model1:Solutionwithwaterasthetoppriority

Table18.2Model2:Constraintsummarywithwaterasthetop

Table18.3Sensitivityanalysisofall fi

Table19.1Annualgrowthratesininputuse,output,TFPandreal costofproduction(RCP)fordifferentcropsgrown inBihar:1975–2005

Table19.2Livelihoodsresilienceindicators

Table19.3AverageTFPdecomposition,inputcontribution, for2000–2012

Table20.1Firmsizeonrateofgrowthofsales

Chapter1

Introduction:TransitionChallenges andPathwaystoSustainable CommunitySystems:Design andSystemsPerspectives

Abstract Thischapterprovidesabackgroundtothevariousdimensionsofsustainabilitythatweunderstandasthecriticalpillarsofsustainabilityforanycommunitysystem.Basedonthese fivekeydimensions,thecontributionsinthisbook havebeencategorisedinto fivebroadsections.Thischapterdiscussesthese five criticaldimensions – relationships,institutions,production,organisationandgovernance – fromdesignandsystemsperspectivesforthesustainabilityofany communitysystem.Undereachdimension,criticalfactorsarepresentedasa spectrum;wherecharacteristicsofeachfactoratoneendofthespectrumtendto createlocking-ineffects,controlbyafew,inequityandunsustainabilityinthelong run,whileattheotherendcharacteristicsofthesamefactorsfacilitateequity, freedomandsustainability.Withreferencetocharacteristicofeachfactor,the chapterinherentlyarguesthatdesignforsustainabilityneedstobeanchoredonthe naturalprinciplesofinterconnectionsandinterdependence.

Discussionsinthechapteruncoverthatalthoughsustainabilityappearstobe fuzzy,blurredandimpossible;makingourcommunitiesandsocietysustainableis withinourcollectivechoicesinthewaywechoosethedirectionofeachofthese factorsunderthe fivecriticaldimensions.Figures 1.1 and 1.2 ofthischapter summarisethecriticaldimensionsandthespectrumofeachofthetwenty- five factors.Inthe finalanalysis,thischapterimpliesthatifpeopleinsmallcommunities andvariousexternalstakeholders,includinggovernmentofficials,developmentand corporateexecutives,recognisethecurrentdesign flawsandsimultaneouslymake effortstounlockthemselvesfromthevariouslock-ineffects,ourtransitionto sustainabilitywillbeeasilyachievable.

Keywords Transitionstrategies Sustainablecommunities Relationships Institutions Production Organisation Governance Design Systemsscience AmarK.J.R.Nayak,ProfessorofStrategicManagement,XavierInstituteofManagement, XavierUniversityBhubaneswar,Odisha,India;Email: amar@ximb.ac.in

© SpringerNatureSwitzerlandAG2019

A.K.J.R.Nayak(ed.), TransitionStrategiesforSustainableCommunitySystems, TheAnthropocene:Politik Economics Society Science26, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-00356-2_1

1.1Background

Whiletheintentionsinmanyofourinitiativestowardssustainabilityhavebeen noble;inconsistenciesbetweentheintentandapproaches,methods,tools,techniquesandactionsoftenmaketheseinitiativesunsustainableovertime.The inherentinconsistenciesandtensionsinthedesigns,andlackofsynergyacross differentsub-systems – eveninsmallcommunities – perpetuatelock-ineffects,path dependenciesandgreaterexternalcontrolthanfreedom,leadingtoinequityand unsustainability.

Thechapterhas fiveparts: First,itdiscussesthebasicpostulateunderlyingthe designandsystemsperspectiveintermsofthenatureandstateofrelationshipsin society. Second,itpresentstherationalebehindthechoiceofthe fivemajor dimensionsofsustainabilityaroundwhichthischapterhasbeenstructured. Third,it discussesthefactorswithineachdimension,thespectrumofeachfactor,inherent tensionwithinthespectrumofeachfactor,dynamicsofrelationshipsandlock-in processeswithinadimensionandacrossthedimensions. Fourth,itproposesa potentialnarrowbutsimplepathtounlocksustainability. Fifth,itindicatesthe potentialareasofresearchtounderstandsustainabilitybetterfromdesignand systemsperspectives.

First,withregardtothebasicpremisesunderlyingthedesignandsystems perspectivesintermsofthenatureandstateofrelationshipsinsociety,thereare indeeddeepinterconnectionsandahighdegreeofinterdependencebetweennature andoursociety.Onecanlookattheworkingsofaclocktounderstandtheinterconnectionsandinterdependence.Theconnectionbetweenthesecond,minuteand hourhandscanindicatethenatureofinterconnections,buttherealitycouldbe muchmorecomplex.Interconnectedgearsinamachinecanillustrateitalittle better.However,theinterconnectionsthatactuallyoccurinsocietyacrosstimeand spaceappeartobemuchdeeperandmorecomplex.Deepinterconnectionsand interdependenceinnaturalsystemsandthewebofhumanlifeneedtobeaccordinglyconsideredinournewdesignsfromasystemsperspective.

Therehavebeenanumberofstudiesthatsuggesttherearegrowingeconomic inequalitiesbetweenpeopleacrosstheworld,weakeningtheir socio-economic-politicalrelationships.Piketty(2014)showsthatglobalincome inequalityhasincreasedinthelasthundredandninetyyearsorso,andthatthe Gini coefficient hasbeenincreasingduringthisperiod.Incomeinequalityinthe emergingcountrieshasbeengrowingmuchfasterinrecentdecades.Forinstance, inIndia,incomeinequalitywaslowerduringthe1950sto1980s,whenitwasa socialeconomy.Subsequenttothe1980s,whenitstartedliberalising,inequalityin termsofthe Ginicoefficient hasbeenrisingsteadily.Further,wealthinequalities acrosscountrieshavebeenmuchgreaterthanincomeinequalities.Weoftencategorisethesephenomenaasdevelopmentparadoxes.Shouldwenotdiscoverwhy thishappensandwhatcausestheseincreasesininequalities;factorsof unsustainability?

Theseinequalitiesdonotseemtobeonlyaphenomenonofthelasttwohundred years.Rousseau(1762)wroteabouttheinequalitiesoverthreehundredyearsago. Inhisbook, TheSocialContract,Rousseauwrote: “Manisbornfreeandeverywhereheisinchains.Onemanthinkshimselfthemasterofothersbutremains moreofaslavethantheyare.” Incomeandmaterialinequalityhasbeenaconstant sourceoffearandlossofcontrol.Asfarbackasfourthousandyears, ChakraVyuha and Labyrinths fromacrosstheworldshowthesymbolsoffearandlossofcontrol bythecommonman.Today’scontrolmechanismsmaynotjustbephysicalor materialcontrols,butcouldalsoentailpsychologicalandmentalcontrolofthe individualbymarketforces.

Globally,theseventeennoblegoalsspecifiedintheSustainableDevelopment Goals2030oftheUnitedNationsandratifi edbythenationstateswereformulated totransformtheworld.However,inthecurrentstateofincreasinglyunequal relationshipsinourcommunities,nationsandsocietyatlarge,canthesegoalsbe achieved?

Thesignificanceofrelationshipsforthesustainabilityofourcommunitiesis expressedintheworkingdefinitionofsustainability:

Sustainabilityisadynamicstateofdeeprelationshipsamongthepeopleandalltheconstituentsbothlivingandnon-livingwithinamicroecologicalunitthatstronglyvaluesthe actsofsacrifice,reciprocityandloveforeachother;wherethepriorityistostrengthenthe weakest,andthespiritofhighinternalcompetitionwithhighexternalco-operationnotonly drivesitsownecologicalunittopeace,joyandhappinessbutalsoinspiresothermicro ecologicalunitsforsuchdeeperinterrelationships(Nayak 2011:p.117).

Inouranalysis,relationshipsarestudiedfromthesystemsscienceperspective andspirituality(includingphilosophicalandtheological)perspective.Further, relationshipsarecoretoallotherdimensionsofstudy:institutions(bothformaland informal)atdifferentlevelsofoursociety,productionsystems(withspeci ficreferencetosustainableagriculturalsystems),organisations(includingproducer organisations),andgovernance(withspecialreferencetograss-root-levelcommunitygovernance).

Second istherationalebehindthedimensionsandfactors,theboundariesin termsofdesignthinkingandsystemsperspectives.Thesehaveevolvedduringthe lasttwodecadesthroughthevariousdeductiveandinductivestudies,engaging actionresearchwithruralagriculturalcommunitiesandinvolvementinpolicy formulation.Theystronglypresentacompellingneedtounderstandthelock-in mechanismsofourdesignsandsystemswithinandacrossthese fi vedimensions. Althoughourresearchandactionresearchhavelargelyfocusedonproductionin theprimarysector – namelytheagriculturalsectorandtheorganisationaldesignof farmerproducerorganisations (FPOs)ascommunityenterprisesystems – the issuesofinstitutionsandcommunitygovernancehavebeencriticaltothesustainabilityofthe firsttwodimensions.Further,thefactorsofsocialcapital,trustand co-operationhavebeenfundamentaltothesustainabilityatalltheselevels. Accordingly, fivedimensions – addressingRelationships(I),Institutions(II),

Production(III),Organisation(IV)andGovernance(V) – havebeenchosenfor analysisanddiscussion.

Acommunitysystemnotonlyconsistsofacertainnumberoffamiliesina clusterofvillagesbutalsoacertainextentofgeographicalspreadwithits ecosystem.Accordingly,amicro-watershed,thebasicunitofecology,formsthe technicalbaseofourcommunitysystem.Howeverforoptimisationofsizefor economicviability(especiallyunderadiverseproductionsystem),andeasier identi ficationofphysicalboundarieswhichaffectthepeople,a GramPanchayat (GP),orWardthatmayconsistoftwotofourmicro-watershedsdependingon whetheritisinahilly,plainorcoastalregion,hasbeenusedasacommunity systemfortheanalysis.

Interestingly,countriesacrosstheworldarestructuredaccordingtosimilar primaryboundariesoftheirrespectivelocalcommunities;examplesincludethe GewoginBhutan,theParishadCouncilinBangladesh,theGramaNiladariinSri Lanka,andtheUnionCouncilinPakistan.CountriesofAfricahaveasimilar political/administrativegovernancestructure.Forinstance,TanzaniahasWardat thelowestlevelandDistrict/Municipalityatthenextupperlevel.TheUnited Kingdomdoesnothavesuchstructuresbuthasthetraditional,informalinstitutional structureofParishatthelowestlevelofcommunityorganisations.Advanced industrialeconomiesusuallyhaveWardatthelowestlevelandDistrictatthehigher level.Inotherwords,assmallcommunitysystemsexistincountriesaroundthe world,itwouldbeprudenttofacilitateholisticsustainabilityinitiativesinsuch smallcommunitiesintherespectivenationstoattainthegradualbutoverallsustainabilityofanation.

Third relatestothefactorswithineachdimension,thespectrumoffactorsin eachdimension,tensionswithinthespectrum,dynamicsofrelationshipsamong factorswithinadimensionandlock-inprocesses.Figure 1.1 showsalistofthe factorswithindifferentdimensions.Interestingly,italsoshowstheorderoflayering,fromcoretoperipheryandhighinterdependenceamongthese fi vedifferent dimensions.

Eachofthe fivecriticaldimensionsofasustainablecommunitysystemisbeing studiedfromafewspecificfactors.Thekeyfactorsineachofthe fivedimensions arediscussedbrieflyinthissection.

1.1.1Relationships

Thenatureandstateofrelationshipsoftenshapethesustainabilityofourendeavoursininstitutions,productionsystems,organisationsandcommunitygovernance. Indeed,relationshipsseemtohavebeenatthecoreofhumanengagementsandour endeavourstowardssustainability.Weexploresuchrelationshipsfromthesystems scienceandspiritualityperspectives.

Fromasystemsscienceperspective,wedeliberateonthenotionsof interdependence andidentifyingselfwithothersaroundus,andonthenotionsof capital

Ownership Managemen

Frequency of Interactions

Decision-making Method

Problem Solving Approach

Resource Dependency

Governance Architecture & Responsibilities

Norms & Conventions

Rules & Regulations

Principles of Justice Interaction Intensity Institutional Loading

Fig.1.1 Transitionstrategiesforsustainablecommunitysystems. Source Theauthor,28October 2016; www.xub.edu.in/NABARD-Chair/activites.html

andwealth.Thespiritualityperspectivehasbeendiscussedthroughphilosophical andtheologicallenses.Thebroadfactorshavebeeninterpretedintermsofthe moralsandvalues anddeep-rooted faithandbeliefs thatprobablyshapeour behaviour,andactionsthatareeitherinsyncwithorcontrarytotheprinciplesof sustainability.Thefactor mentalconstruct hasbeenstudiedfrombothasystems scienceperspectiveandaspiritualityperspective.

1.1.2Institutions

Thenatureandtypeofinstitutionsatthedistrict,state,nationalandgloballevels caneitherfacilitateordestroysustainableprinciplesadoptedintheotherfourinner layers,namely,communitygovernance,productionorganisation,productionsystems,andcultureofrelationshipsatthecore.Evenifthereareinconsistenciesinthe institutionsatthehigherlevelsfromdistricttogloballevel,coherenceofinstitutionswithinadistrictthatisatdistrict,blockorGP-Wardlevelcangreatlyfacilitate sustainabilityattheotherfourinnerlayers – GramPanchayat(GP),FPOs, ProductionSystemsandRelationships.Accordingly,analysisinthisdimension

Another random document with no related content on Scribd:

A. Convex, protuberant, tumular.

Conceal. Hide, suppress, secrete, disguise.

A. Reveal, expose, make manifest, lay bare, confess, publish, divulge.

Concede. Surrender, admit, resign, yield, allow.

A. Refuse, claim, contend, contradict, deny, contest.

Conceit. Notion, whim, vagary, idea, abstraction, affectation, imagination.

A. Reality, fact, substance; simplicity, humility.

Conceited. Egoistical, opinionated, vain.

A. Simple, unassuming, unaffected.

Conceive. Imagine, apprehend, believe, design, think, understand.

A. Express, produce, execute.

Concentrate. Convene, assemble, congregate, muster, centralize.

A. Scatter, disperse, dispense, dismiss.

Concern. Interest, anxiety, solicitude; affair, matter, institution.

A. Indifference, carelessness, disregard.

Concerning. About, regarding, in relation to, respecting, in respect to, relative to, of.

A. Disregarding, omitting.

Concert. Agreement, harmony, concord, concordance, combination, union, association.

A. Opposition, disagreement, discord.

Concession. Surrender, grant, boon, acknowledgment, admission.

A. Refusal, denial, withdrawal.

Conciliate. Win, gain, pacify, reconcile, propitiate.

A. Alienate, irritate, estrange, lose, antagonize.

Concise. Succinct, condensed, terse, pregnant, pointed, brief, short, laconic.

A. Prolix, verbose, diffuse, discursive, rambling, pointless.

Conclave. Assembly, synod, cabinet, council, bureau.

A. Throng, mob, populace, concourse, crowd.

Conclude. Close, end, terminate, finish; decide, determine.

A. Begin, commence, undertake, initiate; prolong, protract.

Conclusion. End, termination, finale, finis.

A. Commencement, beginning, initiation.

Conclusive. Final, decisive, positive, definitive, indisputable.

A. Dubious, vague, uncertain, problematical, theoretical, indeterminate.

Concoct. Brew, prepare, compound, mix.

A. Spoil, upset, overbrew.

Concoction. Compound, brew, mixture; scheme, fiction.

A. Rawness, crudity; simplicity.

Concomitant. Attending, coincident, attendant, synchronous.

A. Antecedent; diverse, unconnected; subsequent.

Concord. Harmony, agreement, friendship, unanimity, accord.

A. Variance, animosity, discord.

Concourse. Assembly, throng, crowd, mob, assemblage, gathering, multitude.

A. Conclave, cabal, cabinet; desert, solitude.

Concrete. Solid, firm, compact; complex, conglomerate; individualized, specific, particular.

A. Loose, shifting, yielding, unresisting; abstract, general.

Concur. Approve, harmonize, agree; help, combine, conspire.

A. Disagree, dissent, part, differ, disapprove, separate.

Concussion. Collision, encounter, crash, impact, percussion.

A. Inter-divergence; escape; tangency; failure, missing.

Condemn. Blame, censure, denounce, convict, sentence, reprove, doom.

A. Acquit, exonerate, absolve, pardon, justify, praise, approve.

Condense. Concentrate, abridge, shorten.

A. Expand, amplify, enlarge.

Condescend. Deign, vouchsafe, stoop.

A. Scorn, spurn, disdain.

Condescension. Graciousness, favor.

A. Arrogance, haughtiness, pride.

Condign. Adequate, deserved, merited, suitable, meet, just.

A. Unmerited, inadequate; excessive or scant.

Condiment. Sauce, seasoning, preserve, pickle, relish, appetizer.

Condition. Situation, case, circumstances, plight; rank, estate, grade; proviso, consideration, stipulation.

A. Concession, adaptation; relation, dependence.

Conditionally. Provided, provisionally, hypothetically, contingently.

A. Absolutely, positively, categorically.

Condole. Console, commiserate, sympathize.

A. Congratulate, rally, exhilarate.

Condone. Pardon, overlook, forgive.

A. Atone, expiate, satisfy.

Conduce. Subserve, promote, forward, advance, contribute to, aid.

A. Defeat; counteract, neutralize.

Conduct. Lead, direct, guide, convoy, escort; command, govern; manage, regulate; rule, superintend.

A. Mislead; mismanage; follow.

Confection. Candy, cake, condiment, concoction, sweetmeat.

Confederacy, Confederation. Alliance, league, treaty, union, coalition, federation, compact.

A. Secession, disruption, disunion.

Conference. Discourse, conversation, talk; interview, colloquy, parley, consultation; convention, convocation, meeting.

A. Silence; monologue; dispersion.

Confess. Acknowledge, admit, disclose, own, allow, grant, concede, avow.

A. Deny, conceal, repudiate, disavow, hide, dissemble.

Confession. Admission, avowal, acknowledgment; creed, doctrines, tenets, catechism, subscription.

A. Heresy, apostasy, protest, refutation, renunciation, abjuration.

Confide. Trust, rely, lean, hope, depend, believe, put confidence in.

A. Doubt, mistrust, disbelieve, disprove, despair of.

Confident. Assured, sure, positive, certain; bold, presumptuous, impudent, sanguine.

A. Dubious, doubtful, undecided, vacillating.

Confidential. Intimate, secret, private; trusty, faithful.

A. Public, patent, open; treacherous, insidious, traitorous.

Configuration. Outline, shape, form, contour.

A. Shapelessness, indeterminateness; distortion, deformity.

Confine, v. Limit, bound, imprison, restrict, circumscribe, enclose.

A. Widen, expand, liberate, unfasten, loosen, extend, dilate.

Confirm. Sanction, uphold, assure, establish, strengthen, substantiate, settle, corroborate.

A. Shatter, weaken, upset, annul, abrogate, cancel, destroy, shake.

Confiscate. Forfeit, seize, escheat, condemn, sequestrate.

A. Release, restore, refund.

Conflagration. Fire, arson, ignition, incendiarism, combustion.

A. Extinction, quenching; smoldering.

Conflict. Contest, battle, struggle, encounter; clashing, interference, disagreement, discord.

A. Amity, reconciliation, pacification, arbitration.

Conform. Agree, consent, harmonize, comply, correspond, comport.

A. Dissent, disagree; antagonize, secede; vary, differ.

Confound. Confuse, perplex, bewilder, mystify; surprise, astonish, astound, startle; destroy, ruin, overwhelm; disconcert, abash, shame.

A. Clear, set right, arrange, enlighten; save, protect; calm, console, soothe, restore.

Confront. Oppose, threaten, encounter, challenge, face, intimidate.

A. Encourage, abet, countenance.

Confuse. Mingle, confound; derange, disturb, perplex, embarrass, obscure, mortify.

A. Arrange; relieve, assist, allay; calm, restore.

Congeal. Freeze, convert to ice, benumb.

A. Melt, thaw, dissolve.

Congenial. Kindred, similar, sympathetic, suited, natural, proper, agreeable.

A. Disagreeable, abhorrent, unnatural, alien, dissimilar, unsuited, unsympathetic.

Congenital. Coeval, connatural, innate, inherent, ingenerate.

A. Unnatural, assumed, extraneous, acquired, artificial, adventitious.

Congeries, Congestion. Conglomeration, aggregation, accumulation, plethora, repletion.

A. Dissipation, diffusion, clearance, dispersion. Congratulate. Felicitate, compliment, rejoice with.

A. Console, condole with, commiserate.

Congregate. Assemble, collect, meet, convene, gather, throng.

A. Disperse, disappear, separate, part, scatter.

Congregation. Assembly, meeting, audience, conference.

A. Dispersion, dismissal.

Congress. Parliament, conclave, cabinet, council, assembly, legislature, synod, convention, conference.

A. Cabal, sedition, uprising, mob; intrigue.

Congruous. Accordant, agreeing, harmonious, coherent, suitable, consistent, proper, appropriate.

A. Discordant, heterogeneous, inharmonious, improper, unsuitable.

Conjecture, n. Supposition, surmise, guess, hypothesis, theory, notion, divination.

A. Calculation, inference, deduction, proof; fact, surety, certainty, security.

Conjuncture. Combination, concurrence; emergency, crisis, exigency, juncture.

A. Provision, preparation, arrangement. Connection. Conjunction, combination, union, association, dependence.

A. Independence, disjunction, dissociation, dissolution.

Conquer. Overcome, subjugate, master, vanquish, subdue, rout, defeat, overpower, overthrow, prevail over, reduce, win, surmount, worst, checkmate, beat, crush, down, discomfit.

A. Surrender, capitulate, cede, forfeit, fly, yield, retreat, withdraw, retire, submit, succumb, fall, lose, resign, fail.

Conquest. Victory, subjugation, triumph.

A. Defeat, failure, surrender, submission.

Conscience. Moral sense, intuition, integrity, principle.

A. Irresponsibility, laxity, undutifulness, unscrupulousness.

Conscientious. Scrupulous, exact, upright, high-principled, honest, honorable, equitable, incorruptible, fair, faithful.

A. Lax, unprincipled, unscrupulous, reprobate, dishonorable, faithless.

Conscious. Sensible, cognizant, aware, intelligent, advised, apprised, assured, sure, certain, informed; thinking, reflecting, rational, intellectual.

A. Insensible, unaware, ignorant, dead, cold, deaf; irrational, thoughtless.

Conscription. Drafting, impressment.

A. Volunteering, enlistment.

Consecrate. Dedicate, ordain; sanctify, hallow.

A. Desecrate, defile.

Consecutive. Sequent, continuous, orderly, following.

A. Disordered, rambling, discursive, illogical.

Consent. Assent, approve, agree, yield, comply, acquiesce.

A. Refuse, resist, decline, dissent.

Consequence. Result, issue, sequel, effect, outgrowth, event, end, upshot; importance, dignity, moment.

A. Cause, occasion, origin; axiom, postulate, premise, antecedence; insignificance, paltriness.

Consequential. Following, resulting, coherent, cogent, connected; pompous, self-conceited, arrogant, vainglorious.

A. Incoherent, illogical; affable, accessible, humble, considerate.

Conservation. Protection, perpetuation, preservation, maintenance.

A. Neglect, exposure, destruction, abolition.

Conservative. Stationary, traditional, opposed to change.

A. Radical, progressive, changeable, transitional, modifiable, innovating.

Consider. Think, ponder, meditate, reflect, investigate, weigh, deliberate, observe, attend, regard.

A. Guess, conjecture, ignore, chance, hazard.

Considerate. Kindly, thoughtful, reflective, careful, prudent, deliberate, serious, charitable, forbearing, cautious.

A. Rash, careless, imprudent, thoughtless, rude, selfish, overbearing, injudicious.

Consignment. Custody, commission, delegation; sending, shipping.

A. Miscommitment.

Consistency. Density, solidity, compactness, coherence; agreement, congruity, correspondence, uniformity, harmony, invariableness.

A. Tenuity, subtility, volatility; incoherence, incongruity, contrariety, contradiction.

Console. Comfort, condole with, sympathize, encourage, soothe, assuage, solace.

A. Distress, grieve, disturb, annoy, sadden, trouble, wound, hurt.

Consolidate. Solidify, harden, condense, compress, compact; thicken, strengthen, solder, cement, fuse; conjoin, combine.

A. Dissolve, melt, vaporize, weaken, dissipate, sublimate, pulverize; dissect, disjoin.

Conspicuous. Visible, apparent, discernible, plain, clear, perceptible, noticeable; eminent, distinguished, prominent,

famous, noted, manifest.

A. Invisible, microscopic, hidden, imperceptible, unseen; ordinary, mediocre, commonplace.

Conspiracy. Intrigue, treason, cabal, plot, machination, combination; sedition.

A. Legislation, congress, parliament, synod.

Constant. Fixed, immutable, invariable, unchanging, permanent, perpetual; resolute, firm, steady; persevering, assiduous; incessant, unbroken, continuous; faithful, true, loyal, devoted.

A. Irregular, exceptional, casual, incidental, fickle, faithless, broken, treacherous, untrustworthy, false.

Consternation. Amazement, terror, alarm, dismay, panic, bewilderment.

A. Fearlessness, boldness, composure, presence of mind.

Constituent. Elector, patron, voter, supporter, sender; ingredient, component, element.

A. Representative, nominee; constitution, system, compound, whole.

Constitution. Organization, formation; quality, character, temperament, peculiarity, characteristic; charter, law.

A. Conspiracy, rebellion, tyranny, anarchy, despotism, destruction, disorganization; disposition, mood, frame of mind, temper.

Construct. Build, erect, invent, form, shape, combine.

A. Demolish, overthrow, destroy, derange.

Construction. Building, erection, composition, fabrication; structure, formation, form, figure; explanation, version, rendering, interpretation.

A. Dislocation, dismemberment, dissolution; misunderstanding, misconception.

Consult. Deliberate, take counsel, confer, advise with, canvass, question, consider, regard.

A. Dictate, counteract, contradict.

Consume. Eat up, devour; destroy, lavish, dissipate, waste, spend.

A. Discard, reject, throw aside; preserve, replenish, supply, provide.

Consummate, a. Perfect, excellent, supreme, finished, complete.

A. Common, faulty, defective, ordinary, mediocre.

Consummation. Achievement, attainment, completion, termination, accomplishment, fulfilment, realization, close, finish, finale.

A. Beginning, attempt, inception, initiation, source, origin.

Consumption. Expenditure, use, waste, extinction, destruction.

A. Development, increase, growth, enlargement, augmentation.

Contact. Touch, junction, contiguity, closeness, union.

A. Adjacence, proximity; separation, distance, isolation.

Contagion. Infection; contamination, taint, pestilence, corruption.

A. Prevention; antisepsis, disinfection.

Contain. Include, embody, comprehend, comprise, embrace; restrain, hold.

A. Omit, exclude, drop, discharge; yield, give way.

Contaminate. Taint, defile, corrupt, sully.

A. Cleanse, purify.

Contemn. Despise, scorn, disdain, slight.

A. Venerate, respect.

Contemplate. Meditate, study, ponder, survey, reflect; intend, design.

A. Overlook, waive, abandon; execute, complete, do.

Contemptible. Despicable, abject, base, worthless, mean, low.

A. Respectable, venerable; worthy, estimable, important, grave.

Contend. Strive, fight, struggle, combat; debate, argue, dispute; affirm, assert, maintain, claim.

A. Concede, allow, surrender.

Content. Satisfied, pleased, easy, willing, resigned, gratified.

A. Reluctant, unwilling, unsatisfied, rebellious, discontent.

Contention. Strife, dissension, quarrel, rupture, dispute, debate, controversy, altercation.

A. Peace, amity, harmony, concord, reconciliation.

Contingent, a. Casual, happening, fortuitous, dependent, incidental, provisional, uncertain.

A. Independent, absolute, positive, uncontrolled, uninfluenced, unaffected.

Continual. Incessant, ceaseless, invariable, perpetual, constant, uninterrupted, unbroken, unremitting, continuous.

A. Exceptional, irregular, casual, contingent, intermittent, interrupted, suspended.

Continually. Constantly, perpetually, ever, always, repeatedly, frequently, continuously.

A. Occasionally, rarely, sometimes.

Continue. Remain, endure, persist; abide, stay, tarry; persevere, be constant or steadfast.

A. Stop, cease, fail, pause.

Contract, n. Compact, stipulation, agreement, arrangement, bargain, covenant, pact, obligation, pledge, engagement, bond.

A. Promise, parole, assurance, understanding, assumption.

Contract, v. Narrow, abbreviate, abridge, lessen, reduce, compress; shrivel, shrink; agree, stipulate, bargain.

A. Expand, amplify, dilate; reverse, cancel, abandon. Contradict. Deny, gainsay, dispute, impugn, controvert; oppose, counteract, annul, thwart, abrogate.

A. Maintain, argue, confirm, state, affirm, endorse.

Contrary. Opposite, opposed, adverse, counter; conflicting, contradictory, antagonistic, repugnant; perverse, obstinate, stubborn, headstrong.

A. Compatible, agreeing, kindred, compliant, submissive; consistent.

Contrast, v. Differentiate, discriminate, oppose, compare.

A. Resemble, be like or similar, liken, harmonize. Contribute. Add, give, coöperate, assist, subscribe, supply.

A. Refuse, withhold, deny.

Contribution. Donation, offering, gift, subscription, subsidy, aid, assistance.

A. Withholding, retention, reservation.

Contrive. Plan, design, devise, invent, project, form, frame, scheme, plot, consider; manage, make out; concert, adjust.

A. Hit, chance, venture, bungle, hazard; mismanage, miscontrive.

Control, v. Direct, manage, rule, command, sway, superintend; hinder, repress, restrain, curb, check.

A. License, free; neglect, abandon; mismanage, misconduct.

Controversy. Dispute, altercation, contention, disagreement.

A. Agreement, unanimity, coincidence.

Contumacy. Obstinacy, stubbornness, perverseness, pertinacity, obduracy; disobedience, insolence.

A. Docility, tractableness, flattering, fawning, servility.

Contumely. Obloquy, reproach, opprobrium, insolence, abuse, contempt, scorn, disdain, arrogance.

A. Regard, consideration, adulation, obsequiousness.

Convene. Assemble, meet, congregate, summon, master, collect.

A. Dismiss, disperse, disband, dissipate.

Convenient. Suitable, fit, appropriate, proper, adapted; advantageous, commodious, comfortable, useful, serviceable.

A. Inconvenient, useless, awkward, superfluous; inopportune.

Convention. Assemblage, conference, meeting, concourse, session, synod, congress, convocation; treaty, compact.

A. Recess, dissolution, prorogation; dispersion, scattering; promise, understanding, parole.

Conventional. Usual, customary, ordinary, habitual, regular, wonted, prevalent, social, everyday; stipulated.

A. Unusual, erratic, extraordinary; legal, compulsory.

Conversant. Familiar, skilled, acquainted, proficient, versed.

A. Strange, ignorant, unversed, unlearned.

Conversation. Converse, communion, intercourse, parley, talk, chat, conference, communication, discourse, colloquy, dialogue.

A. Speech, oration, harangue, soliloquy, apostrophe, monologue, silence, taciturnity.

Converse, a. Opposite, reverse, contrary, counter, contradictory.

A. Identical, one, same, indistinguishable; direct, primary.

Conversion. Alteration, transmutation, change, transformation.

A. Permanence, identity, persistence, conservation.

Convertible. Equivalent, interchangeable, identical; reversible.

A. Variant, contrary, incommensurate.

Convey. Take, transfer, move, change, carry, shift, transmit, transport, remove, consign, relegate.

A. Retain, preserve, hold, cling to, possess.

Conviction. Belief, assurance, persuasion; confutation, refutation; proof, detection.

A. Doubt, disbelief, misgiving; vindication, justification.

Convince. Persuade, satisfy, enlighten, indoctrinate, inoculate.

A. Mislead, mystify, perplex, puzzle, unsettle, upset; turn, convert.

Convivial. Social, festive, hospitable, jovial, jolly, companionable, gay.

A. Inhospitable, unsocial, unneighborly, churlish; abstemious, ascetic, austere.

Convocation. Convention, congress, assemblage, council, synod.

A. Dispersion, disruption, dismission, dismissal.

Convolution. Coil, involution, spiral, twist, contortion.

A. Unfolding, evolution, unraveling, explication.

Convoy. Escort, guard, attendance, protection.

A. Capture, betrayal, onset, onslaught, hold up.

Convulse. Disturb, shake, agitate.

A. Calm, compose, soothe, assuage.

Cool. Somewhat cold, chilling, frigid, freezing; unimpassioned, composed, collected, unruffled, self-possessed, sedate, placid,

quiet; indifferent, unconcerned, apathetic.

A. Hot, warm, burning, heated, excitable, ardent, eager.

Coöperate. Assist, abet, help, conspire, concur, co-labor.

A. Oppose, thwart, rival, counteract, conflict, hinder, defeat, frustrate.

Coördinate. Equal, equivalent, proportionate, commensurate, tantamount, equipollent.

A. Subordinate; disparate, extraneous; inferior, superior.

Copy. Portraiture, facsimile, duplicate, imitation, likeness, image, transcript, counterfeit.

A. Model, original, pattern, example, prototype, archetype, exemplar.

Cordial. Earnest, warm, hearty, ardent, affectionate, sincere, invigorating, refreshing, pleasing, grateful.

A. Cool, formal, ceremonious, distant, reserved, disinclined.

Corner. Angle, bend, crotch, knee; nook, recess, niche, retreat.

A. Abutment, protrusion, prominence, convexity, projection.

Corollary. Inference, conclusion, deduction, consequence.

A. Problem, proposition.

Corporal, Corporeal. Fleshly, bodily, material, physical.

A. Spiritual, mental, intellectual, moral, ethereal, immaterial.

Corps. Body of troops, division of army, squadron, band, company.

A. Aggregate, army, host, mass, force, organization.

Corpse. Remains, dead body, cadaver, carcass, dust.

A. Soul, spirit, individual, personality, mentality.

Corpulent. Fat, fleshy, plump, obese, portly, round, stout.

A. Lean, thin, attenuated, emaciated, slight, slender, frail.

Correct. True, exact, accurate, proper, faultless, right.

A. False, untrue, wrong, inexact, inaccurate, fallacious, defective.

Corrective. Regulative, preventive, alterative, preservative, rectifying, modifying, improving, reformatory.

A. Confirmative, stimulative, intensitive, provocative, conducive.

Correlation. Interrelation, correspondence, apposition, interdependence, mutuality, reciprocation, interchange, reciprocity.

A. Contradiction, independence, opposition, inconsistency, incongruity.

Correspond. Agree, suit, match, fit, tally, harmonize, answer, correlate, stand counter; communicate, write.

A. Vary, disagree, clash, jar; ignore, disregard, neglect.

Correspondence. Adaptation, agreement, congruity; writing, letter, despatches, communication.

A. Conversation; withdrawal, non-intercourse; incongruity, discord, disagreement.

Corroborate. Strengthen, establish, sustain, support, confirm.

A. Weaken, confute, rebut, invalidate, shake, enfeeble, overthrow.

Corrode. Consume, eat away, waste, impair, rust, canker, wear, crumble.

A. Renew, restore.

Corrupt, v. Defile, pollute, infect, taint, vitiate, demoralize, contaminate, debase, spoil, deteriorate.

A. Cleanse, purify, better, correct, ameliorate.

Corruption. Decay, decomposition, pollution, defilement, infection, contamination, adulteration; depravity, immorality, laxity, wickedness; dishonesty, bribery.

Cost. Price, worth, expenditure, expense, charge, disbursement, outlay; preciousness, richness, splendor; loss, damage, pain.

Costume. Dress, livery, robes, uniform.

A. Disguise, incognito; nudity, nakedness.

Council. Cabinet, bureau, chamber, conclave, synod, convocation, meeting, conference, parliament, consultation, convention.

A. Cabal, league, conspiracy; multitude, mob.

Counsel. Advice, consultation, opinion, suggestion, recommendation, instruction, caution, admonition; deliberation, forethought; plan, design, scheme; purpose; lawyer, barrister, attorney.

Count. Compute, reckon, add, tell, estimate, number, enumerate, sum, calculate.

A. Guess, conjecture, surmise, think, fancy.

Countenance, v. Approve, support, sanction, help, aid, abet, encourage, patronize, befriend, assist, favor.

A. Oppose, confront, discourage, browbeat, face, compare, disparage.

Counter. Contrary, opposed, opposite, against.

A. Accordant with, coincident, consonant.

Counteract. Oppose, foil, baffle, thwart, hinder, rival, resist, defeat, cross, frustrate, neutralize.

A. Aid, coöperate, subserve, promote, advance, assist.

Counterfeit, n. Forgery, fraudulent copy, cheat, artifice, pretense, sham, fabrication.

A. Exposure, detection; verity, fact, truth, reality.

Countermand. Abrogate, annul, revoke, rescind, recall, make void.

A. Order, command, bid, charge, enjoin, direct, instruct.

Counterpart. Duplicate, copy; correlative, complement, supplement, obverse; match, mate, tally, twin.

A. Antithesis, contradiction, contrast.

Countervail. Balance, compensate, make up, counterbalance, offset.

A. Overthrow, unbalance, weigh down.

Countryman. Rustic, agriculturist, farmer, swain, yeoman, laborer, peasant, husbandman; clown, boor.

A. Citizen, townsman; alien.

Couple, v. Link, unite, connect, join, clasp, tie, yoke, buckle, pair, splice, button; marry, wed.

A. Loose, part, separate, detach, isolate, unclasp; divorce.

Courage. Bravery, valor, fearlessness, spirit, heroism, fortitude, hardihood, boldness, daring, mettle, pluck, resolution, intrepidity.

A. Cowardice, timidity, fear, dread, terror, dismay, consternation.

Course. Route, way, road, track, race; direction, bearing, progress, process; career; succession, order, regularity; deportment, conduct; series, system.

A. Deviation; disorder, discursion; hindrance, error.

Court, v. Woo, flatter, seek, invite, solicit.

A. Avoid, shun, repudiate, repel, antagonize.

Courtesy. Politeness, affability, urbanity, civility, complaisance.

A. Rudeness, incivility, churlishness, ungraciousness.

Courtly. Polished, elegant, polite, ceremonious, formal, respectful.

A. Undignified, unrefined, coarse, awkward, boorish, plebeian.

Covenant. Agreement, stipulation, bond, compact, contract, bargain, arrangement, concordant, pact, treaty.

A. Promise, understanding, assurance, parole.

Cover, v. Hide, conceal, overspread, overlay, secrete, cloak, veil, screen, mask, shroud, disguise; invest, clothe, wrap; protect, shelter, shield, guard, defend; comprehend, comprise, embrace; balance, compensate, countervail.

A. Expose, reveal, produce, exhibit; betray, divulge; omit, exclude.

Covet. Desire, long for, wish for, aim after, aspire to.

A. Dislike, despise; undervalue.

Covetous. Eager, avaricious, desirous, greedy, grasping, acquisitive, rapacious.

A. Liberal, unselfish, generous, bountiful.

Coward. Craven, recreant, dastard.

A. Hero, champion; daredevil, desperado.

Coy. Bashful, shy, modest, reserved, retreating, shrinking.

A. Bold, forward, impertinent, pert, brazen, flippant. Crack. Split, break, chop, rend, cleave, snap; craze, madden.

A. Mend, unite, repair; restore, heal.

Craft. Skill, ability, power, talent, dexterity, aptitude, tact; artifice, shrewdness, guile, deception, cunning, deceit; art, trade, employment, vocation, calling; vessel.

A. Inaptitude, tactlessness; fairness, openness, candor, sincerity, frankness, ingenuousness, straightforwardness.

Cramp. Restrain, hinder, check, confine, hamper, clog, fetter, cripple.

A. Free, liberate, loose, expand, ease, relieve, extricate.

Crash. Jar, uproar, clash, rending, noise, clang, resonance.

A. Murmur, whisper; silence.

Crassitude. Grossness, thickness, density, corpulence, obesity.

A. Tenuity, agility, activity; spareness, slightness.

Crave. Intreat, beg, beseech, implore, supplicate, desire, long for, hunger for, yearn.

A. Demand, insist, require.

Crazy. Shattered, broken, tottering; distracted, mad, lunatic, insane, delirious, cracked, demented, deranged.

A. Sound, robust, vigorous, sane, whole.

Create. Form, produce, make, originate, cause, occasion, appoint, constitute; beget, engender, generate; imagine, compose, fashion, design.

A. Destroy, demolish, annihilate.

Creature. Created being, being, animal, man, person; dependent, vassal, parasite; wretch, miscreant.

A. Chimera, ghost, hallucination, fantasy, phantom, conceit, crotchet.

Credence. Belief, trust, faith, acceptance, confidence, reliance.

A. Denial, distrust, disbelief, doubt, skepticism. Credentials. Diploma, missive, title, warrant, vouchers, certificates, testimonials.

Credible. Probable, possible, reliable, trustworthy, likely.

A. Improbable, unlikely, incredible, unreliable, untrustworthy.

Credit. Trust, belief, faith, confidence, credence, reliance; reputation, influence, power; esteem, regard; loan, securities.

A. Insecurity; distrust; shame, disgrace, censure.

Credulity. Gullibility, credulousness, simplicity.

A. Skepticism, suspiciousness, incredulity, shrewdness.

Creed. Belief, catechism, confession, articles of faith, tenets, dogmas, doctrines.

A. Protest, abjuration, disbelief, recantation, retraction.

Crestfallen. Downcast, dispirited, dejected, disheartened, depressed, desponding, low-spirited, down-hearted.

A. Exuberant, elated, confident, inspirited.

Crew. Gang, set, band, horde, crowd, mob, throng.

A. Supercargo; bevy, galaxy, cream, élite.

Crime. Offense, misdeed, wrong, felony, sin, iniquity, misdemeanor, enormity, transgression, wickedness, delinquency.

A. Good deed, well-doing, exploit, achievement, duty, service, benefit, benefaction, heroism.

Criminal, a. Immoral, iniquitous, sinful, unlawful, wicked, wrong, vile, nefarious, culpable, abominable, illegal, vicious.

A. Virtuous, moral, innocent, just, honorable, praiseworthy, lawful, legal, right, meritorious.

Criminate. Charge, accuse, arraign, impeach.

A. Acquit, absolve, extricate.

Cripple, v. Weaken, disable, impair, break down, cramp, curtail.

A. Renovate, strengthen, augment, liberate, ease, expedite.

Criterion. Standard, test, rule, touchstone, measure, canon, proof.

A. Eye, glance; intention, conjecture.

Critic. Judge, censor, reviewer, connoisseur; caviller, carper; arbiter, savant.

A. Artist, author, writer, performer, maker, poet, composer.

Critical. Accurate, nice, exact; decisive, crucial, determining, important; dangerous, hazardous, imminent, momentous, dubious, precarious.

A. Inexact, loose, undiscriminating; unimportant, inconclusive; safe, sure, settled, decided, retrieved, redressed.

Criticism. Censure, stricture, animadversion, review, critique.

A. Approbation, praise, approval.

Criticize. Examine, estimate, judge, discuss, analyze, anatomize, scan, animadvert.

A. Survey, overlook, slur, skim, slight, neglect.

Crooked. Bent, curved, bowed; distorted, twisted, wry, askew, deformed, disfigured; perverse, contumacious, capricious; dishonest, unfair, unscrupulous, knavish, deceitful, tricky.

A. Straight, linear, upright, direct, honest, straightforward.

Cross. Fretful, petulant, peevish, snappish, touchy, morose, illnatured, sullen, snarling, cynical, sour, out of humor, captious, crabbed, sulky.

A. Amiable, genial, good-tempered, good-natured, blithesome, charming, winsome, attractive, benign.

Crowd. Throng, multitude, concourse, press, horde, herd, host, rabble, mob, populace.

A. Cream, élite, bevy, constellation, galaxy; solitude, solitariness.

Crown, n. Diadem, coronet, garland, chaplet, wreath, laurel, bays; reward, honor, distinction, dignity; summit, crest, top, head, brow, apex.

A. Base, bottom, floor, foot, pedestal, foundation, sole; infamy, shame.

Crown, v. Complete, consummate, conclude, seal, achieve, accomplish.

A. Mar, spoil, frustrate, fail.

Crucial. Severe, trying, searching, decisive, critical, momentous, strategic.

A. Superficial, indifferent, mild, lenient, lax, unimportant.

Crude. Raw, immature, unripe; coarse, unrefined; undigested, unconsidered, unpolished, uncouth, awkward.

A. Mature; refined, sensitive; well-considered, finished, classical, highly wrought, elaborate.

Cruel. Inhuman, merciless, unfeeling, dire, ruthless, pitiless, relentless, savage, brutal, ferocious, blood-thirsty, sanguinary; severe, sharp, bitter, hard.

A. Gentle, mild, merciful, humane, forbearing, generous.

Crush. Pound, crumble, demolish, overpower, squeeze, compress, bruise, shatter, raze, pulverize.

A. Consolidate, compact, amalgamate, solidify, stabilitate.

Culmination. Zenith, success, consummation, acme, completion, apex.

A. Failure, downfall, defeat, descent, decline.

Culpable. Blameworthy, blamable, censurable, reprehensible, faulty, wrong.

A. Innocent, blameless, laudable, praiseworthy.

Culprit. Criminal, delinquent, felon, malefactor, offender.

A. Hero, example, pattern, model, saint, upright man. Cultivate. Till; fertilize; improve, refine, train, discipline, develop; study, pursue, investigate; nourish, foster, cherish, promote.

A. Neglect, blight, blast; uproot, eradicate, extirpate; stifle, abandon, prevent, discourage.

Cunning. Craft, artifice, deceit, intrigue, subtlety, chicane.

A. Candor, guilelessness, sincerity.

Cupidity. Longing, greed, lust; covetousness, avarice, acquisitiveness, stinginess.

A. Prodigality, liberality, generosity, extravagance. Curb. Restrain, check, control, repress, bridle.

A. Indulge, emancipate, loose, release, free, liberate.

Cure, n. Remedy, antidote, restorative, corrective, help, specific; healing, restoration, convalescence, alleviation, renovation.

A. Complaint, contagion, disease, ailment; aggravation, confirmation; inoculation.

Curiosity. Inquisitiveness, wonder, marvel, rarity, celebrity; inquiry, investigation, scrutiny, research.

A. Indifference, heedlessness, disregard, abstraction; apathy.

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.